Professional Documents
Culture Documents
of
April 15, 2013 M;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;; Course Instructor: Business Analysis University, of Dhaka
Subject: Submission of the termpaper on Bangladeshs Mobile Telecom Industry & Grameenphone Limited
Dear Sir, Here is the termpaper on Bangladeshs Mobile Telecom Industry & Grameenphone
Limited: Business Analysis as you asked me to prepare for the partial fulfillment of the
Business Analysis .With great pleasure I am submitting this termpaper as an integral part of the course. Working for this termpaper has definitely enriched our theoretical and practical knowledge about the External and Internal Environment of a business, &FAROUT model of an organization, and proper implementation of the formulated strategies- which ultimately strengthened our overall understanding of the Strategic Management. This task also enhanced our skills in writing research report. As per your direction, we tried our level best to highlight our findings by applying strategic management concepts and models. We tried to gather a collection of information to make our report specific and coherent, and make the report as reflective as possible. We are really thankful to you for giving us such a splendid opportunity to present you the report, which is authentically based on our team effort and we appreciate this kind of work. We also appreciate to provide any information or clarification if necessary. Thank you for your consideration.
Table of Contents
Executive Summary .......................................................................................... .. 6 Chapter One: Introduction .................................................................................. . 7 1.1 Mobile Telecom Industry in Bangladesh .......................................................... 8 1.2 Grameenphone Limited (GP) ......................................................................... 9 1.3 Objectives .................................................................................................... 11 1.4 Outline of the Report .................................................................................... 11 Chapter Two: External Environment Analysis ......................................................12 2.1 Macro Environment Analysis ........................................................................12 2.1.1 Demographic ............................................................................................ 13 2.1.2 Socio-cultural ............................................................................................ 13 2.1.3 Political/Legal: ........................................................................................... 14 2.1.4 Technological ............................................................................................ 15 2.1.5 Economic .................................................................................................. 16 2.1.6 Global ....................................................................................................... 17 2.2 Porters Five Forces Analysis .........................................................................18 2.2.1 Bargaining power of Buyers: .....................................................................18 2.2.2 Bargaining power of Suppliers: ..................................................................18 2.2.3 Industry Substitutes: ................................................................................. 19 2.2.4 Threat of New Entrants: ............................................................................19 2.2.5 Rivalry among competitors: ......................................................................20 Chapter Three: Internal Environment Analysis of Grameenphone .......................21 3.1 Core Competencies ......................................................................................21 3.1.1 Excellence in Network: ..............................................................................22 3.1.2 Branding and Market Position: ...................................................................22 3.1.3 Innovative Products and Services: .............................................................22 3.1.4 Better Customer Services: .........................................................................23 3.1.5 Top Management: ..................................................................................... 23 3.2 SWOT Analysis ............................................................................................. 23 3.2.1 Strengths: ................................................................................................. 24 3.2.2 Weaknesses: ............................................................................................. 24 3.2.3 Opportunities: ........................................................................................... 24 3.2.4 Threats: .................................................................................................... 24
Chapter Four: Grameenphones Competitive Strategies and Implementation ... ... 26 4.1 Corporate-Level Strategies: ......................................................................... 26 4.1.1 Entry Strategy: ........................................................................................ .. 26 4.1.2 Diversification Strategy: ............................................................................ 27 4.2 Strategy Implementation in Grameenphone ................................................. 28 4.2.1 Strategic Control: ..................................................................................... . 29 4.2.2 Organizational Design: .............................................................................. 29 4.2.3 Corporate Governance: ............................................................................. 29 4.3 CSR Policy of Grameenphone ....................................................................... 30 4.3.1 GPs CSR Practices: ................................................................................. .. 30 Chapter Five: Conclusion & Recommendations .................................................. 33 Chapter Six: References ..................................................................................... 34 Appendix ......................................................................................................... . 38
Executive Summary
From the dawn of human civilization people use many ways to communicate with each other and those ways of communication were changed or updated time to time because of new innovation and demand. The power of telephony is forging a new enterprise culture, from banking to agriculture to healthcare. The opportunities that lie in the telecom industry seem endless and lucrative due to the continuous innovation and growing demand for mobiletelephony. Nowadays mobile phones have become an indispensable part of Bangladeshi's everyday-life and we never want to leave this device at home while we head for our work. Hence we have preferred the mobile telecom industry of Bangladesh for our current study and chosen Grameenphone Limited (GP) as the case. There are six mobile phone operators in Bangladesh. These are Grameenphone (GP), Banglalink, Robi, Airtel, Citycell and Teletalk. Citycell was the first mobile phone operator, while Grameenphone Limited is the largest mobile operator in Bangladesh in terms of revenue, coverage and subscriber base. There are many unexploited opportunities in mobile telecom industry, like around 40% of the population yet to be connected, buying habits as well as talking habits of the people, availability of cheap skilled workers, trust & dependence on foreign companies & products, relatively flexible regulations, advancement in ICTs & government patronization for foreign investment, development of Hi-Tech park, opportunities for Value Added Services and diversified products, there is a vast demand for high speed internet, and last but not the least the country is eagerly waiting for 3G technology- new and existing companies can be benefited from these opportunities. Moreover, the mobile telecom industry in Bangladesh is moderately attractive with huge growth potential. GP has positioned itself in the best way to explore these opportunities with its core competencies and competitive strategies. It also has resilience in its diversified business model. GPs strategy implementation is best in the industry and its corporate governance is up to the international standard. It also has excellence in CSR activities which is clearly evident form its ubiquitous presence in social development in Bangladesh. Thus GP has achieved excellence in all of its business activities and proudly earned the leadership position in Bangladesh telecom industry.
increased productivity in businesses as a result of mobile phone usage and (3) increasing the involvement and engagement of its population with news and current affairs (BTRC, 2012a). The government has identified the Information and Communication Technology (ICT) as one of the thrust sectors for rapid economic development, unemployment, & poverty alleviation (Ashaduzzaman & Ahmed, 2012). Internet penetration in Bangladesh is the lowest in the region. Among the 6 million internet users, around 90% uses Mobile internet which means more mobile penetration will create more internet access for the people of Bangladesh (BTRC, 2012a). Increased mobile penetration will help in upward access to Voice & Data, Ehealth service for 24 hours in remote areas. It will open the door for Medical advice, Eeducation, E-Governance, E-payment, E-banking and Agri-service. Thus this sector has opportunities for growth & diversification and the participants can survive profitably in the long run if adopt appropriate strategies in the competitive market.
Prof. Yunuss suggestion the company is named as GrameenPhone , a simple name that carried a nationally recognized brand name and would not confuse rural people with complex words like telecommunications. (Isenberg, et al., 2007) GP has 38.412 million mobile subscriptions (BTRC, 2013) and 4,696 employees (Telenor Group, 2013). It is also the largest taxpayer of the country, paid BDT 1,121 crores to the national exchequer during the first quarter of 2013 in the form of taxes, VAT and duties. This sum up GPs accumulated contribution to the national exchequer to BDT 25,638 crores since its inception (GP, 2013b). GP offers core voice services and a number of value-added services on both a contract and prepaid basis (Telenor Group, 2013). GP operates a digital mobile telecommunications network based on the GSM standard in the 900 MHz and1800 MHz frequency bands, under a license granted by the Bangladesh Telecom Regulatory Commission (BTRC) (GP, 2013a). GP serves both rural and urban customers across Bangladesh, where mobile telephony is a major driver of socioeconomic development. It built its network on a nationwide basis. As of December 2012, GPs network covered 99% of Bangladeshs population and 90% of the total land area, and the network infrastructure included more than 13,000 base stations located in about 7,200 sites in operation around the country (GP, 2013a). The company is one of the first mobile phone operators to launch GSM service in the country. GP was also one of the first operators in Bangladesh to offer the subscribers mobile to mobile service, EDGE, prepaid service, voice SMS and over-the-air topups. 2008, In Grameenphone became the first January mobile operator in Bangladesh to offer
BlackBerryTM services (GP, 2013a). It has been also a pioneer in bringing innovative mobile-based solutions to Bangladesh (Telenor Group, 2013). Notable among these is the Healthline, a 24 hour medical call centre manned by licensed physicians. Other innovations (Appendix: Fig. 3) include Studyline, a call centre-based service providing education related information, Mobicash, for electronic purchase of train tickets, Billpay, for paying bills through mobile phones and over 500 community information centers across Bangladesh. These centers bring affordable Internet access and other information based services to people in rural areas. GPs financial performance is among the best in the country and it consistently paying high dividend to its investors. On its 15th Annual General Meeting the shareholders approved the 205% cash dividend (including 140% interim cash dividend) for the year 2012 among other
10
agenda. GP reported BDT 2,322 crore revenues for the first quarter of 2013 with 12.3% increase from same period of 2012. Net profit after taxes for the first quarter of 2013 was BDT 520 crores with 22.4% margin compared to BDT 287 crores with 13.9% margin of the first quarter of 2012. Higher profit for this period was mainly due to revenue growth, efficient cost management and reduced depreciation expenses. EBITDA margin for the first quarter of 2013 was 55.1%, which also has increased by 7.3 percentage points compared to 47.8% of the same period last year. As a result, Earnings per share (EPS) for the first quarter of 2013 stood at BDT 3.85 compared to BDT 2.12 of the first quarter of 2012. (GP, 2012, 2013a, 2013b)
1.3 Objectives
The objectives of this termpaper are to analyze the external and internal environment of mobile telecom industry of Bangladesh taking Grameenphone Limited (GP) as the case by using Porters Five Forces . Then review the corporate level strategies, strategy implementation process and CSR policy of GP.
11
12
2.1.1 Demographic
Demographics are the most easily understood and quantifiable elements of the general environment. They are the root of many changes in society. Demographics include elements such as the aging population, rising or declining affluence, changes in ethnic composition, geographic distribution of the population, and disparities in income level (Colvin, 1997; G. G. Dess & Lumpkin, 2003). According to the Population and Housing Census 2012, total population of Bangladesh is 149,772,364 with an annual growth rate of 1.37% (Morol, 2013). The projection shows that the population is likely to grow up to 222 million around 2051, and stabilize at 250 million by 2081, even if replacement level fertility is achieved by the year 2015 (Nabi, 2013; Ruiz & Michalski, 2009). The fertility rate fell from 6.6 births per woman in 1975 to 2.4 in 2009, a huge drop attributed to the introduction of a major policy initiative in 1976 that emphasized population and family planning as integral to national development (UNDP, 2012). Bangladesh is largely ethnically homogeneous and its name derives from the Bengali ethnolinguistic group, which comprises 98% of the population (Wikipedia, 2013c). About 90% of Bangladeshis are Muslims and the remainders are mostly Hindus. Average life expectancy is 67.2 years and 61.4% of the population belongs to 15-64 years range and thus are the potential target for the mobile operators (Wikipedia, 2013c). The mobile telecom sector is the fastest growing sector of the country and still there are around 60 million people who are yet to use cell phone. This implies that there are a lot unmet needs that could be a great potential for the industry. The literacy rate of the country is 67% which implies that major portion of the population have the academic depth to adopt new products and services, but they are highly price sensitive and prefer low prices for their poor economic condition (Salam, 2013). These statistics show that demographic trends are continuously diversifying, indicating why it is becoming ever so important to target specific customer groups, determine their needs, and then satisfy them (Murray, 1998).
2.1.2 Socio-cultural
Socio-cultural forces influence the values, beliefs, and lifestyles of a society. Examples include a higher percentage of women in the workforce, dual-income families, increases in the number of temporary workers, greater concern for healthy diets and physical fitness, greater interest in the environment, and postponement of having children (G. G. Dess & Lumpkin, 2003).
13
In Bangladesh people have more leisure than work, and they love to gossip & talk whenever have time. The phenomenal growth of the telecom industry over the last two decades has considerably changed the way people interact. Mobile telecom has played a significant role in appealing consumers' emotions and stressing the importance of social conversations and staying connected to family & friends using aggressive advertising and promotional activities and thus strengthened our social relationships (Wikipedia, 2013e). Here people love city dwelling rather then quiet village stay. The proportion of urban population in Bangladesh has increased from 5.2% in 1961 to 25.1% in 2008, and most of the urban growth is taking place in the major cities of the country e.g. Dhaka, Chittagong, Rajshahi and Khulna (Nabi, 2013). According to the article (Nabi, 2013), 57% of people will be living in cities in Bangladesh by 2050 and Dhaka may become one of the densest cities of the world. The national population growth rate is 1.34%, while the national internal migration rate is 4.5% per annum (Nabi, 2013). Gender discrimination in Bangladesh begins at birth as most parents want to have male children (Shahidullah, Islam, Majid, & Shams, 2004). There are glass-ceilings for woman at work though they are the half (50%) of our total population. Despite many barriers, more and more women are taking higher education today and doing jobs. Womens work participation rates have doubled in Bangladesh since 1995 but they are still extremely low at 26 percent (World Bank, 2008). The last decade has witnessed an impressive rise of women in the workforce in Bangladesh, especially in a variety of male-driven corporate sectors (Hassan, 2013).
2.1.3 Political/Legal:
Political processes and legislation influence the environmental regulations with which industries must comply (G. G. Dess & Lumpkin, 2003). Some important elements of the political/legal arena of Bangladesh include The Corporate Governance Guidelines of 2006, SEC Act of 1993, The Company Act of 1994, The Labour Act of 2006, The Consumer Rights Protection Act of 2009, etc. In order to ensure development of telecommunication services in Bangladesh and to regulate them, Bangladesh Telecommunication Regulatory Commission (BTRC) was formed as an independent statutory body under the Telecommunication Act 2001 (MOF, 2012; Wikipedia, 2013f). All relevant powers, responsibilities and pertinent matters related to telecommunication regulation have been vested with the Commission. Tariff regulation is one
14
of the most important responsibilities of the BTRC to provide the telecommunication facilities to the general people at an affordable price (BTRC, 2012d). High taxation regime for the telecom sector has compelled the mobile operators to subsidize Tk 605 on every single SIM in Bangladesh (FE Report, 2013b). According to Robi Axiata official, all mobile operators except the Grameenphone are incurring loss due to this taxation on SIM (FE Report, 2013b). There is some problem with the 2G licensing also. License tenure of four mobile operators has expired on November 10, 2012 (FE Report, 2013d). The renewal decision has not been finalized as some issues around the license renewal are pending before the court and thus the final conditions for renewal are still unclear (Johnsen & Rusten, 2013; Telenor, 2012).
2.1.4 Technological
Developments in technology lead to new products and services and improve how they are produced and delivered to the end user. Innovations can create entirely new industries and alter the boundaries of existing industries (G. G. Dess & Lumpkin, 2003). Internet technology provides better opportunities for companies to establish distinctive strategic positionings than did previous generations of information technology (Porter, 2001). ICTs can reduce communication costs, break down geographical borders and make an important development impact by overcoming barriers of social, economic, and geographical isolation, increasing access to information and education, and enabling poor people to take part in more of the decisions that affect their lives (M. A. Rahman, 2007) and thus technology can empower the Poorest (Kelly, 2008). There is digital divide between developed and developing countries. But the mobile phone sector has made possible the availability of data enabling services across Bangladesh and mobile internet has helped, and will likely continue, to bridge the digital divide between people with access to information and services (BTRC, 2012a; CIPE, 2010). With the support from the Government and increasing private investment, Bangladesh has stepped into a new digital era, replacing analogue technology. Six mobile operators and nine PSTN operators have been allowed to operate to facilitate the customers with voice services (MOF, 2012, pp. 238-239). For narrowing the gap and for the liberalization of innovative VoIP technologies, a number of IP Telephony licenses have been issued. A good number of internet service providers, new entrant WiMAX operators and also the mobile as well as PSTN operators are playing the same role for data service (MOF, 2012, pp. 238-239). Infrastructure operators and
15
the gateway operators (IGW, IIG, & ICX) are the important parts of the telecom-skeleton of Bangladesh. Rural telecommunication has been given the topmost priority and BTRC is striving to ensure access for each of the citizens. IP telephony license (IPTSP) has been opened for ISP operators as an overlay service and already 40 licenses have been issued (MOF, 2012, pp. 238-239). Bangladesh is connected to SEA-ME-WE 4 or South-East Asia Middle East - Western Europe 4 through submarine cable and also a member of the proposed SEA-ME-WE-5 (Wikipedia, 2013f). The country is planning to send her first ever satellite Bangabandhu-1 into space in 2015 (Wikipedia, 2013f). Third Generation (3G) cellphone technology is knocking at our door. The government is seeking opinions from the public on the guideline for 3G cellphone service as it moves to issue five licenses for the advanced technology (FE Report, 2013d). IT industries are also flourishing in Bangladesh. Currently, more than 50 software and IT service companies in Bangladesh are exporting software and providing their services to 30 different countries which include among others USA, UK, Australia, Canada, Denmark, KSA, Japan, Sweden, UAE, Germany, Italy, Netherlands, Norway, Switzerland, France and Nepal, and earned US$ 45.31 million in FY 2010-11 (MOF, 2012, p. 238). Some important users of Bangladeshi software are Nokia, Japan Airlines, World Bank, HP, US Postal Department and US Department of Agriculture (MOF, 2012, p. 238).
2.1.5 Economic
The economy has an impact on all industries, from suppliers of raw materials to manufacturers of finished goods and services, as well as all organizations in the service, wholesale, retail, government, and nonprofit sectors (G. G. Dess, Lumpkin, & Eisner, 2007). Key economic indicators include interest rates, unemployment rates, the Consumer Price Index, the gross domestic product, and net disposable income (G. G. Dess, et al., 2007; Pearce-II & Robinson-Jr., 2003). Telecommunication has a significant social, cultural and economic impact on modern society. In 2008, estimates placed the telecommunication industry's revenue at $3.85 trillion or just under 3% of the gross world product (Wikipedia, 2013e). Because communication technologies deliver tangible economic empowerment to individuals, low initial purchasing power does not create a barrier. According to Iqbal Z. Quadir, Connectivity is productivity; productivity translates as the ability to pay (CIPE, 2010).
16
The overall economic performance of Bangladesh in FY 2010-11 provided grounds for optimism with 6.66% growth in GDP, compared to 6.07% in FY 2009-10 and 5.74% in FY 2008-09 (MOF, 2012, pp. 1-2). In FY2010-11, per capita GNI and per capita GDP stood at US$ 818 and US$ 755 respectively, up from US$ 751 and US$ 687 respectively a year earlier (MOF, 2012, pp. 1-2). The year-on-year inflation reached 10.17 percent in June 2012 from 8.70 percent in June 2010, food inflation rose to 12.51 percent in June 2012 from 10.88 percent in June 2010, while non-food inflation increased moderately to 5.73 percent from 5.24 percent in June 2010 (MOF, 2012, pp. 3, 28). The weighted average rate of interest on commercial lending increased to 12.39 percent in June 2012, from 12.37 percent in June 2010 and the deposit rate increased to 8.85 percent from 7.40 percent over the same period (MOF, 2012, p. 5). The BD taka has depreciated by more than 15% against the US dollar during the year 2012(Ahmed, 2013; S. Rahman, 2013). Though the exchange rate was steady at Tk. 68Tk. 69 between 2004 and 2010, even in the beginning of 2012 the dollar was sold at Tk. 71 for import payments (S. Rahman, 2013). According to the Bangladesh Economic Review2012, the number of economically active population (above 15 years) is 5.37 crore, out of which, a labour force of 5.10 crore (male 3.85 crore and female 1.25crore) is engaged in a number of professions, i.e. unemployment rate is 5% (MOF, 2012, p. 27).
2.1.6 Global
There is an increasing trend for firms to expand their operations and market reach beyond the borders of their home country. Globalization provides both opportunities to access larger potential markets and a broad base of factors of production such as raw materials, labor, skilled managers, and technical professionals. The world has come out of the recession of 2007-2009 stronger than anticipated (MOF, 2012, pp. 1-2). The economy of Bangladesh has successfully tackled the contagion effect of global economic crisis and managed to maintain a sustained growth. The foreign exchange reserve remained steady at above US$ 10 billion during this period (MOF, 2012, pp. 1-2). There are incentives from both government and public sectors which helped the telecom sector to grow and it is now one of the biggest sectors of Bangladesh. As a populous country, its huge ICT market has attracted many foreign investors to invest in this sector (Wikipedia, 2013f). BTRC is committed to ensure effective control on telecommunication and to introduce new services and to create a favorable atmosphere for the local and foreign investors who intend to invest in the telecommunication sector in Bangladesh (MOF, 2012, pp. 162-167). In order to attract
17
big transnational companies or world-class investors with a view to facilitating hi-tech and knowledge-based industries, construction of infrastructure facilities for Hi-Tech Park on 231.685 acre of land at Kaliakoir, Gazipur is going on (MOF, 2012, pp. 162-167).
2.2.1 Bargaining power of Buyers: There are six mobile telecom operators in
Bangladesh and they offer almost homogenous services which have low switching costs between operators and thus has provided buyers with extremely high bargaining power. The bargaining power of buyers in this industry is very high, with the exception of remotearea customers who have no alternative network available in their vicinity.
2.2.2 Bargaining power of Suppliers: All the mobile operators other than Teletalk
have international identity and have experience to work in the global platform. The companies have the opportunity to acquire necessary equipments from different international chains across the globe. The bargaining power of suppliers in the mobile industry varies depending on the brand name and strategic importance of the supplies as well as the size of
18
the Company, such as Ericsson and Nokia Siemens in the mobile telecom machinery industry is that type of suppliers who enjoy strong power in the industry. On the other hand there are many potential suppliers and vendors in telecom industry e.g. Cisco, Siemens Enterprise Communications, Alcatel-Lucent, Huawey and Motorola, Nortel, Oracle, Nokia, Samsung, Juniper, Converse, HP, Sun etc. According to Salam (2013) in 2010, Huawei, the Chinese telecom equipment manufacturer, was one of the major suppliers of telecom equipment in Bangladesh and its major clients include Grameenphone, Banglalink, Robi, Citycell, Teletalk and BTCL; while VimpelCom (a.k.a 'BeeLine') provided voice and data services to Djuice of Grameenphone and Banglalink, and ACME Tele Power Ltd. (India) provided solar power support to Grameenphone. Recently, Huawei Technology played an important role in modernizing GPs network infrastructure on the new 3G platform (GP, 2012). All of these available resources ensure competitive price and abundant supply support to the country's telecom industry. Therefore, the bargaining power of suppliers in the industry is moderate to weak.
2.2.4 Threat of New Entrants: Mobile Telecom is capital and resource intensive
business which poses a significant entry barrier for potential players in Bangladesh. Existing companies have created significant brand positioning and economies of scale in network coverage- which also act as entry barrier. Government rules and regulations- like imposition of huge tax on SIM card, strong tariff control by the authority, can also create difficulties to entrants; in addition the price battle between the competitors brought the tariffs to its lowest in this region. But the major barrier to entry in Bangladesh mobile telecom market is to obtain a radio spectrum license from BTRC. So potential direct entry to the industry is relatively restricted at the moment, due to control over licenses. However, companies are
19
finding other ways to enter the industry, i.e. through merging with existing operators. For example, Bharti Airtel acquired 70% stake of Warid Telecom and rebranded as Airtel in order to enter the Bangladesh market (Salam, 2013). Hence it seems that the threats of new entrants in mobile industry are moderate to weak.
2.2.5 Rivalry among competitors: There is an intense battle in price ground between
the six mobile operators. Grameenphone is leading the industry and standing in an advantageous position than others. Each company is trying to increase the market share by lowering call rate, superior network coverage and better Value Added Services. The competition has driven the industry's average revenue per share to a very low level. Considering the intensity of the competition - the rivalry among existing competitors is very high. Form the five forces analysis we can say the mobile telecom industry in Bangladesh is moderately attractive with great growth potential. Summary: Form the general environment we can identify many unexploited opportunities. New and existing companies can be benefited from the huge population of the countryaround 40% of the population yet to be connected through mobile phone services, buying habits as well as talking habits of the people, availability of cheap skilled workers, trust & dependence on foreign companies & products, relatively flexible regulations, advancement in ICTs & government patronization for foreign investment in ICTs, development of Hi-Tech park, opportunities for Value Added Services and diversified products, Internet penetration is one of the lowest and there is a vast demand for high speed internet, and last but not the least the country is eagerly waiting for 3G technology. Form the five forces analysis we can say the mobile telecom industry in Bangladesh is moderately attractive and still has huge potential for growth. There are already six giant companies trying to find their position. It has been clearly noticed that as the market is growing, proportionately all the operators are getting new subscribers depending on their nationwide coverage. And due to the high growth rate of the industry each company is being benefited, despite strong bargaining power of the customers and intense rivalry between the competitors.
20
21
competitors. Core competencies of a firm can sometimes become core rigidity for it (G. Dess & Picken, 1999; Ingram & Baum, 1997). In this view, if the firm continues its strategic focus on the core competence when it is no longer relevant in the external environment, this then disadvantages the firm by restricting the development of new core competencies, and thus the development of a new competitive advantage (Hanson, et al., 2008). According to Porter (1996), a company can outperform rivals only if it can establish a difference that it can preserve. From GPs case, we can clearly identify the following important core competencies- which make the firm a leader in its chosen industry.
3.1.1 Excellence in Network: Network has always been a strong point for GP and seen
as the best network by the mobile phone users in Bangladesh. To retain this position, GP has upgraded its entire network with future proof technology (GP, 2012). The modernized network is ready for facilitating 3G technology and broadband services. As of December 2012, GPs network covered 99% of Bangladeshs population and 90% of the total land area, and the network infrastructure included more than 13,000 base stations located in about 7,200 sites in operation around the country (GP, 2013a). It invested BDT 373 crores during first quarter of 2013 for network capacity and quality enhancement. With this, GPs cumulative investment since inception now stands at BDT 17,465 crores (GP, 2013b).
3.1.3 Innovative Products and Services: Innovation in products and services is one
of the core competencies of GP. In the products and services side, the Company introduced My Zone, first of its kind in Bangladesh, which offers discount on call tariff depending on customers location (GP, 2012). A number of products, diversified promotional tariff offerings and innovative Value-added Services (VAS) were launched during the year 2012, e.g. dynamic pricing, allocation based discount offer in tariff, Bangla contents in low cost handsets Grameenphone C200, modified Prepaid price plans for Apon & Bondhu, GP
22
Business segment, 1-sec-pulse prepaid package Spondon, mobile Facebook for valued customers, Micro SIM card for iPhone and iPad users, and organized Internet Festival jointly with Prothom Alo (GP, 2012). Other innovations include Healthline, Studyline, Mobicash, Billpay, Cellbazaar etc. (Appendix: Fig. 3).
3.1.4 Better Customer Services: GP always strives to provide quality services to its
valued subscribers. Grameenphone established a Customer Experience Lab, which is helping the Company to gain valuable customer insight about its products and services (GP, 2012). The corporate website of the Company has been revamped with many new tools and applications to make life easy for its customers (GP, 2012). Bangla versions of the website along with WAP version were also lunched. One of the major features of the website has been the eCare system, which enabled the customers to avail many services online (GP, 2012). In addition, GP is in touch with the subscribers round the year through various customer touch points such as 93 Grameenphone Centers (GPC) - a flagship sales and service point under one roof- especially designed to cater customers need 365 days a year. GP has expanded its distribution footprint and is serving the customers with around 342,000 retail points with increased focus in the rural markets.
3.1.5 Top Management: GP has a strong professional management team which is the
best in the in the industry and highly valued by all the stakeholders. The top management is well experienced from international mobile telecom industry as well as from multinational corporations (MNCs) and, is a core competency of the company.
23
3.2.1 Strengths: Grameenphone has always been committed to providing quality services
and it has been one of the main strengths for GP from the beginning. Other strengths includeGPs clear strategic direction, its a multinational company, its the market leader with a 42% market share, skilled & dedicated workforce (4,970 employees in GP & GPIT), best indoor coverage, 99% population coverage, 90% geographic coverage, network infrastructure included more than 13,000 base stations located in about 7,200 sites in operation around the country, strong financial position (credit rating: AAA for long term loan and ST-1 for short term loan), multiple financing alternatives, wide range of product and product innovation skills, strong brand image and reputation in the industry, strong company culture, superior customer care (BTRC, 2013; GP, 2012, 2013a).
3.2.2 Weaknesses: The weaknesses of GP are relatively high tariff rate for users,
multicultural management, poor leadership development from local talents for top level position, poor negotiation & conflict management skills for solving regulatory problems, unfair labor practice with no specific guideline for recruitment (Azad, 2013; FE Report, 2013c; Staff Correspondent, 2013), and huge capital expenditure for modernization of network (Telenor, 2012).
3.2.3 Opportunities: There are potential in the industry for increasing the customer base
and market shares. There is also a vast demand for high speed internet and BSCCL has a plan to lease out a portion of its spare capacity (only 30% percent of bandwidth is being utilized) (MOF, 2012). BTRC is planning to approve mobile banking (BTRC, 2012d), which could serve as a solution for 76% of the population in Bangladesh that are unbanked (Telenor Group, 2013). The government is going to issue five licenses for 3G cellphone technologyfour licenses will be given to four local mobile phone operators, including state-owned operator Teletalk, and one to the foreign operator through auction process (FE Report, 2013d).
3.2.4 Threats: There are few threats from political/legal side, e.g. unstable political
condition, increasing regulatory surveillance and government legislation, imposition of additional taxes and charges on talk time and SIM cards. M&A between Bharti Airtel and Warid Telecom and introduction of 3G mobile technology by Teletalk also poses threat to GP. Rapid changes and advancement in existing cellular technology, changes in customers needs, proliferation of substitutes in the market etc also pose threats to the company. IP
24
telephony, by VoIP service providers, is the new threat in telecom industry (FE Report, 2013a). It has the potential to buoy a raft of new household brand. Summary: GPs core competencies make it the leader in the market. GP has a valuable inventory of strengths that will help it succeed. Its strengths will also help it capitalize on emerging opportunities. GP has many threats and opportunities from the external environment, and also have some weaknesses that it should overcome in shortest possible time.
Accuracy
Resourceefficiency
Objectivity
Usefulness
Timeliness
High
High
Medium to High high High High Medium to high High Medium to high Medium to high
25
In this section we will discuss the corporate-level strategies, implementation of strategies and CSR policy of Grameenphone.
4.1.1 Entry Strategy: The global marketplace provides many opportunities for firms to
increase their revenue base and their profitability.Moreover intodays knowledge-intensive economy, there is the potential to create advantages by leveraging firm knowledge when crossing national boundaries to do business. A firm has many options available to it when it decides to expand into international markets e.g. Exporting, Licensing, Franchising, Strategic Alliance, Joint Venture, and Wholly Owned Subsidiary. Telenors corporate strategy has been characterized since the 1990s by almost prescient acquisitions in underserved wireless markets ready to blossom . The first wave of acquisitions took place in early nineties, when Telenor decided to expand their operations into the Eastern European market. In the mid-nineties their focus swiveled towards the underserved markets of South East Asia, starting with Bangladesh in 1996 and moving later into Thailand, Malaysia, and Pakistan. Telenor entered into Bangladesh in a joint venture agreement with Grameen Telecom- Telenor (62%) and Grameen Telecom (38%). Joint venture involves the formation of a third-party legal entity where two or more firms contribute their assets.
26
27
provide
Infrastructure products and services to other telecom operators as well as other businesses like WiMAX operators, ISPs, etc (GP, 2012). A number of new innovative wholesale products and services were introduced into the market in 2012, which catered to the immediate demand of the market. GP has signed agreements on different infrastructure sharing products with Telecom operators (e.g. Robi, Banglalink, Airtel Bangladesh etc), ISP operators (e.g. Bangladesh Internet Exchange, Agni Systems, Drik ICT Ltd. etc.) and WiMAX operators (e.g. Bangladesh Internet Exchange etc) in 2012. (iii) Financial Services: GP continued to see greater acceptance and growth of mobile financial services for executing basic transactional services via mobile phone infrastructure. In addition to its existing services (i.e. bill payment, railway & sports ticketing etc.), GP has launched the initial phase of an inward foreign remittance disbursement service on behalf of two leading banks in the country focusing on cash-to-cash disbursement of remittance payments in the last mile of distribution (GP, 2012). GPs BillPay service processed and settled several million utility bills for nine major utility companies in the country and continued to build significant market share in its areas of operation. According to a study conducted by the Boston Consulting Group for Telenor in 2012 the introduction of mobile financial services to Bangladesh could serve as a solution for 76% of the population in Bangladesh that are unbanked (Telenor Group, 2013). The economical and societal contributions of the new business activity include adding a 2% increase to the total GDP by 2020, creating 500,000 new jobs and improving health care access. All these corporate-level strategies gave GP a competitive edge over its rivals. GPs diversification strategies ensures above average return from its investment by reducing its exposure in single business, and optimizing business portfolio.
28
Companies typically realize only about 60% of their strategies potential value because of defects and breakdowns in planning and execution . Research shows that enterprises fail at execution because they go straight to structural reorganization and neglect the most powerful drivers of effectiveness decision rights and information flow . The ability of frontline employees to execute a companys strategy without close central oversight is vital as the pace of technological change accelerates and as companies grow rapidly and become increasingly decentralized .
4.2.1 Strategic Control: Organization must have effective strategic controls if they are to
successfully implement their strategies. This includes systems that exercise both informational control and behavioral control. An organizational control system is also required. This control system equips managers with motivational incentives for employees as well as feedback on employees and organizational performance. GP has strong informational and behavioral control- attributed by its good corporate governance.
2
4.3 CSR Policy of Grameenphone
Corporate social responsibility (CSR) is a form of corporate self-regulation integrated into a business model, while CSR policy functions as a built-in, self-regulating mechanism whereby a business monitors and ensures its active compliance with the spirit of the law, ethical standards, and international norms (Wikipedia, 2013b). When attempting to gain market power over competitors, CSR practices can add value to a business strategy . There are very few literatures about CSR practices in developing countries like Bangladesh, and therefore the global models cannot be replicated there as the macro environmental conditions are very much different from that of developed countries (Majumdar, 2010). However, there are five recognized domains in the existing CSR models, e.g. economical, legal, ethical, philanthropic, and environmental (Majumdar, 2010). CSR practices in Bangladesh are still in its infancy and most of the businesses in Bangladesh are family owned, first-generation businesses (Alam, Hoque, & Hosen, 2010). Here philanthropy gets the main attention from the corporate bodies (Majumdar, 2010), without having any definite policy about the expenses or any solid motive regarding financial gains in many instances (Alam, et al., 2010).
Summary: GPs corporate-level strategies gave it a competitive edge over its rivals. Its diversification strategies ensures above average return from its investment by reducing its exposure in single business, and optimizing business portfolio. Strategy implementation is very much efficient in GP which is attributed by its strategic control system, unique organizational structure and good corporate governance practices. From GPs case we can say, CSR is no longer exclusively practiced in developed countries- companies in Bangladesh are showing interest and commitment in CSR. GP has concern about all the five domains of CSR, and it helped GP to earn its leading market position in Bangladesh mobile telecom industry.
32
From this study, we have the following recommendations for GP: It should revise its tariff plan according to the market trend It should develop a recruitment policy based on the rules and regulation of Bangladesh It should focus on leadership development from local tenants It should hire professionals for negotiation and conflict management It should develop more resilience in its business model to absorb the uncertainty stems from the macro environment Should focus on efficient diversification by grabbing all the feasible opportunities in the industry, e.g. mobile banking and financial services, 3G services, IP TV services, VoIP services, high speed broadband Internet etc.
33
34
Appendix
Table 1: Brief History of Telecom Sector in Bangladesh (BTCL, 2012; Salam, 2013)
Year 1853 1971 1975 1979 1981 1983 1985 1989 1989 1989 1989 1995 1995 1995 1996 1996 1998 2000 2001 2002 2004 2005 2006 2008 2010 2010 Events Telegraph branch under Posts and Telegraph Department, British India. Reconstructed as Bangladesh Telegraph and Telephone Department under Ministry of Posts and Telecommunications. Reconstructed as Telegraph and Telephone Board. Reconstructed as Bangladesh Telegraph and Telephone Board (BTTB) with right to issue license for telecom and wireless services. Digital Telex Exchange in Bangladesh. Automatic Digital ITX started in Dhaka. Coinbox Telephone service introduced in Bangladesh by BTTB. GENTEX Telegraph messaging service introduced in Bangladesh. Bangladesh Rural Telecom Authority got license to operate exchanges in 200 upazilla. Sheba Telecom got license to operate exchange is 199 upazilla. Cellular mobile phone company Pacific Bangladesh Telephone Limited and Bangladesh Telecom got license. Card Telephone service introduced in Bangladesh by BTTB and TSS (TSS - Telephone Shilpa Sangstha is the premier manufacturer of Telephone sets of Bangladesh). Regulatory power of BTTB (Bangladesh Telegraph and Telephone Board) transferred to Ministry of Posts and Telecommunications. 2nd and 3rd ITX installed in Dhaka. Grameenphone got cellular mobile Telephone license. Telecom Malaysia International Bangladesh got cellular mobile license. Telecom Policy. Global Telecom Service (GTS) Telex Exchange venture with British Telecom. Telecommunication Commission (BTRC). Act, to establish Bangladesh Telecommunication Regulatory
Information & Communications Technology (ICT) Policy. Teletalk cellular mobile launched. Egypt based Orascom acquired Sheba Telecom and established the brand name of 'Banglalink' Next Generation Network (NGN) introduced in BTTB (Bangladesh Telegraph and Telephone Board). BTTB (Bangladesh Telegraph and Telephone Board) converted into Bangladesh Telecommunications Company Limited (BTCL) with 100% shares owned by Government. NTT DoCoMo bought 30 percent stake in Aktel and rebranded as 'Robi' Bharti Airtel acquired 70 percent stake in Warid Telecom and emergence of the brand 'Airtel'.
38
Strengths
Clear strategic direction Multinational Corporation Strong Company Culture Superior customer care Market leader with a 42% market share Skilled & dedicated workforce (4,970 employees in GP + GPIT) Brand image & reputation for best network and quality services 99% population coverage,90% geographic coverage 3,000 base stations located in about 7,200 sites Wide range of product and product innovation skills Strong financial position (credit rating: AAA for long term loan and ST-1 for short term loan) Multiple financing alternatives
Weaknesses
Comparatively high tariff rate Huge capital expenditure for network upgradation Multicultural management Poor local leadership development for top level position Poor negotiation & skills guideline conflict for for management No specific
Opportunities
Threats
The potential to increase the customer base The potential to increase market share Growth Mobile Banking 3G cellphone technology opportunities in broadband Internet Political instability The proliferation of substitutes Technological advancement Changes needs Increasing regulatory monitoring and government legislation IP telephony by VoIP service providers (VSP) M&A between Bharti Airtel and in customers
Warid Telecom
Introduction of 3G by Teletalk
39
40
Figure 1: Percentage of Active Mobile Phone Subscribers by Mobile Operators at the end of May 2013. The total number of subscribers was 92.120 million- among these GP has 38.412 million, Banglalink has 25.252 million, Robi has 18.733 million, Airtel has 6.667 million, Citycell has 1.713 million and Teletalk has 1.342 million subscribers (BTRC, 2013).
Banglalink 27%
Airtel 7%
Figure 2: The total number of Mobile Phone subscribers in different time periods (BTRC, 2012b, 2013; Wikipedia, 2013f)
100 90 80 70 60 50 40 30 20 10 0 Time 45 Feb-09 Jun-11 Dec-11 May-12 76.43 85.455 92.12
41
42
* Not a member of the Management Team **Deputy CEO has a special role on Stakeholder Relations of the Company
43