2012年醫師工作環境問卷調查 (結果完整報告)

2012
internr@googlegroups.com
http://www.facebook.com/MEDLabor

90
32
2011 8
2007

1.
(n=214)
(n=214)
157
73.36%
35
16.36%
57
26.64%
32
14.95%
27
12.62%
13
6.07%
19
8.88%
91
42.52%
14
6.54%
34
15.89%
87
40.65%
28
13.08%
25
11.68%
91
42.52%
4.21%
64
29.91%
1.87%
4.21%
10
4.67%
20
9.35%
30
14.02%
214 157 57 13
91 34 28 25 23 91
42.52% 64 29.91% 9 4.21% 20 9.35% 30 14.02%

1.
(n=214)
(n=104)
(n=110)
2011
9.86
5.85
7.46
5.36
12.14
5.38
114
10
87
40.65%
21
20.19%
66
60.00%
15
29
13.55%
6.73%
22
20.00%
94.36
22.28
88.06
22.88
100.32
20.03
80
152
71.03%
62
59.62%
90
81.82%
88
140
65.42%
55
52.88%
85
77.27%
5.99
0.62
5.91
0.59
6.05
0.63
39
18.22%
14
13.46%
25
22.73%
35.84
10.55
35.10
11.66
36.55
9.38
28
197
92.06%
93
89.42%
104
94.55%
30
196
91.59%
93
89.42%
103
93.64%
32
183
85.51%
84
80.77%
99
90.00%
36
59
27.57%
21
20.19%
38
34.55%
10.18
4.72
9.89
5.03
10.45
4.40
10
78
36.45%
32
30.77%
46
41.82%
14
177
82.71%
84
80.77%
93
84.55%
22.97
11.62
23.95
12.70
22.05
10.46
108
50.47%
45
43.27%
63
57.27%
8.52
4.44
6.01
4.80
8.59
4.08
115
53.74%
57
54.81%
58
52.73%
24
24
10
33
ACGME
15/10
81
80
88
42
28
36/32/30
14
10
24
24
10
10

09
10
15
1115
09
10
1115
15
13%
68%
40%
32%
26%
74%
14%
7%
12%
20%
9.86 53% 9 20% 10 15
94.36
2011ACGME
80
8088
88
100.32
88.06
80
88
65%
29%
71%
42
6%
94.36 71% 2011 ACGME 80 65% 88
2011ACGME
5.99
6.05
5.91
06
06
6
18%
82%
5.99 18% 2011 ACGME 6
35.84
35.1
2011ACGME
36.55
28
2830
3032
3236
36
36
28
58%
8%
92%
6%
0%
28%
35.84 92% 2011 ACGME 28 92%86%28% 30

3236
24
2011ACGME
24
14
1410
10
14
10.18
9.89
10.45
10
46%
17%
83%
37%
24
24 10.18 83% 2011 ACGME 14
2011ACGME
24
23.95
24
24
24
22.97
50%
22.05
22.97 50% 2011 ACGME 24
50%
2011ACGME
10
10
10
10
8.59
8.52
6.01
46%
54%
8.52 54% 2011 ACGME 10

50% 2011 ACGME 24
70% 20 %
10 15 24
2011
ACGME 36 2011 ACGME 28
28% 36
2.
(1)
(n=214)
(n=104)
(n=110)
5.97
0.93
6.01
0.95
5.94
0.91
3.96
1.43
4.14
1.42
3.79
1.42
4.32
3.50
3.57
3.01
5.04
3.79
209
97.66%
100
96.15%
109
99.09%
209
97.66%
100
96.15%
109
99.09%
5.97 3.96 4.32 98%
(2)
(n=214)
(n=104)
()
83
38.79%
()
93
43.46%
168
()
( 10%)
(n=110)
29
27.88%
54
49.09%
38
36.54%
55
50.00%
78.50%
87
83.65%
81
73.64%
16
7.48%
5.77%
10
9.09%
1.88
1.18
2.00
1.17
1.76
1.19
0.861
39% 43% 1.88

79% 7% 10%
(3)
(n=214)
(n=104)
(n=110)
()
137
64.02%
61
58.65%
76
69.09%
()
60
28.04%
27
25.96%
33
30.00%
()
12
5.61%
5.77%
5.45%
()
17
7.94%
4.81%
12
10.91%
()
11
5.14%
2.88%
7.27%
64% 28% 6%8% 5%
3.
(n=214)
(n=104)
()
45
()
54
(n=110)
(n=17042)
21.03%
19
18.27%
26
23.64%
2245
13.2%
25.23%
25
24.04%
29
26.36%
976
5.7%
0.939
61.71
21.64
0.913
56.35
19.87
66.77
22.11
32.8
20.2
60.56
20.67
0.887
56.30
20.47
64.59
20.13
28.2
19.3
63.20
21.31
0.849
58.35
20.36
67.78
21.27
35.6
20.6
49.71
18.66
0.887
45.63
17.42
53.56
19.05
30.1
19.3
78.28%
15.56%
0.828
74.42%
16.19%
81.93%
14.06%
52.6%
12.1%
25.23%
23.64%
81.93
78.28
74.42
26.36%
24.04%
66.77
61.71
56.35
21.03%
18.27%
64.59
60.56
56.3
13.20%
32.8
67.78
63.2
58.35
35.6
28.2
53.56
49.71
45.63
52.6
30.1
5.70%
21% 25%
61.7160.5663.2049.71 78.28
2007
4.
(n=214)
(n=104)
(n=110)
0.936
41.23
20.93
0.907
38.83
21.44
43.49
20.27
46.10
26.90
0.960
44.47
26.11
47.64
27.67
45.09
27.92
46.88
27.80
43.41
28.06
40.54
26.78
42.07
26.13
39.09
27.41
()
15
7.01%
6.73%
7.27%
()
1.40%
0.96%
1.82%
7.01%
7.27%
6.73%
41.23
1.40%
46.1 45.09
44.47
40.54
47.64
46.88
38.83
42.07
43.49
43.41
39.09
1.82%
0.96%
7% 1%
41.2346.1045.0940.54
5.
(n=214)
(n=104)
(n=110)
()
102
47.66%
49
47.12%
53
48.18%
()
50
23.36%
16
15.38%
34
30.91%
()
105
49.07%
49
47.12%
56
50.91%
4.95
3.83
5.26
3.84
4.66
3.81
1.06
0.88
1.25
0.88
0.88
0.85
0.898
57.57
18.34
0.837
54.17
18.90
60.79
17.27
71.55
17.06
0.840
70.57
17.97
72.48
16.18
64.09
18.46
0.867
61.68
18.89
66.36
17.83
48%
49%
52%
51%
48% 49%
4.95
5.26
4.66
23%
1.06
77%
1.25
0.88
23% 4.95 1.06

57.5771.55 64.09
50%
23%

1.
(1)
T
T (>0.05)
(<0.4)
(>0.930)
C3-1
0.000
0.703
0.926
C3-2
0.000
0.748
0.924
C3-3
0.000
0.770
0.924
C3-4
0.000
0.816
0.922
C3-5
0.000
0.713
0.925
C4-1
0.000
0.811
0.923
C4-2
0.000
0.683
0.925
C4-3
0.000
0.708
0.925
C4-4
0.000
0.645
0.926
C4-5
0.000
0.661
0.926
C5-1
0.000
0.485
0.929
C5-2
0.000
0.521
0.928
C5-3
0.000
0.525
0.928
C5-4
0.000
0.576
0.927
C5-5
0.294
-0.145
0.939
C6-1
0.000
0.664
0.926
C6-2
0.000
0.521
0.929
C6-3
0.000
0.638
0.926
C6-4
0.000
0.496
0.929
C6-5
0.000
0.570
0.927
C6-6
0.000
0.530
0.928
T 0.05 0.4(0.930)
C5-5 T
C5-5
(2)
A. (construct validity)(exploratory factor analysis)
KMO (sampling adequacy)
Bartlett
C3-C6
Kaiser-Meyer-Olkin (>0.8)
0.923
Bartlett (<0.05)
0.000
KMO Barlett (principal component

method)(parallel analysis)
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
9.544
2.144
1.731
0.867
0.703
0.699
0.576
0.479
0.477
0.433
0.375
0.354
0.296
0.265
0.249
0.201
0.176
0.162
1.582
1.460
1.365
1.284
1.209
1.138
1.073
1.007
0.947
0.888
0.844
0.787
0.730
0.681
0.631
0.583
0.534
0.485
(Eigenvalue)
(promax rotation method)
F1
F2
0.827
0.870
0.826
0.814
0.770
0.803
0.679
0.905
0.776
0.787
F3
0.813
0.953
0.877
0.522
0.846
0.835
0.881
0.637
0.788
0.670
(%)
47.72%
10.72%
8.66%
0.40
10
6 4 47.72%10.72% 8.66%
61.95%
20
B. (concurrent criterion validity)
(BSRS-5)
C4
C5 *
C6
C7 *
C1
C2
C3
0.861
0.526
0.574
0.644
0.531
0.479
0.000
0.000
0.000
0.000
0.000
0.000
C4
0.482
0.573
0.653
0.569
0.503
0.000
0.000
0.000
0.000
0.000
C5
0.351
0.412
0.372
0.212
0.000
0.000
0.000
0.002
C6
0.456
0.362
0.332
0.000
0.000
0.000
(=0.861)
(=0.351)

(=0.644/0.653/0.412/0.456=0.531/0.569/0.372/0.362)
(=0.479/0.503/0.212/0.332)
A1
A2
B2
B3
B7
B8
C3
0.348
0.320
-0.318
0.353
0.690
0.650
0.000
0.000
0.000
0.000
0.000
0.000
C4
0.281
0.363
-0.322
0.365
0.601
0.625
0.000
0.000
0.000
0.000
0.000
0.000
C5
0.226
0.299
-0.144
0.266
0.399
0.383
0.001
0.000
0.036
0.000
0.000
0.000
C6
0.172
0.138
-0.171
0.322
0.356
0.502
0.012
0.044
0.012
0.000
0.000
0.000
(=0.348/0.281/0.226/0.172=0.320/0.363/0.299/0.138)
(
=-0.318/-0.322/-0.144/-0.171=0.353/0.365/0.266/0.322)
(=-0.144/0.266)
(=0.690/0.601/0.399/0.356=0.650/0.625/0.383/0.502)
(3)
Cronbachs 95%
Cronbachs
95%
C3-1C3-2C3-3C3-4C3-5
0.913
0.893
0.930
C4-1C4-2C4-3C4-4C4-5
0.887
0.861
0.909
C5-1C5-2C5-3C5-4
0.849
0.813
0.879
C6-1C6-2C6-3C6-4C6-5C6-6
0.887
0.849
0.901
C3C4C5C6
0.939
0.950
0.926
20
Cronbachs 95% 0.8
(4)
T
T (>0.05)
(<0.4)
(>0.810)
C7-1
0.000
0.318
0.828
C7-2
0.000
0.705
0.758
C7-3
0.000
0.638
0.767
C7-4
0.000
0.555
0.784
C7-5
0.000
0.484
0.795
C7-6
0.000
0.684
0.762
C7-7
0.000
0.494
0.793
T 0.05 0.4(0.810)
C7-1 C71
(5)
A.
KMO Bartlett
C7
0.824
Bartlett (<0.05)
0.000
KMO Barlett
3.258
0.858
0.673
0.534
1.244
1.123
1.030
0.965
F1
0.811
0.801
0.731
0.621
0.792
0.641
(%)
54.30%
0.40
6 54.30%
B.
C1
C2
A1
A2
B2
B3
B7
B8
C7
0.508
0.402
0.414
0.379
-0.356
0.399
0.572
0.453
0.000
0.000
0.000
0.000
0.000
0.000
0.000
0.000
(=0.508=0.402=0.414=0.379
=0.399)(=-0.356)
(=0.572
=0.453)
(6)
Cronbachs 95%
Cronbachs
95%
C7-2C7-3C7-4C7-5C7-6C7-7
0.828
0.790
0.861
Cronbachs 0.8 95% 0.8 0.790

Cronbachs 0.8 0.7
2.
(1)
T
T (>0.05)
(<0.4)
(>0.938)
C8-1
0.000
0.291
0.940
C8-2
0.000
0.353
0.939
C8-3
0.000
0.667
0.935
C8-4
0.000
0.605
0.936
C8-5
0.000
0.683
0.934
C8-6
0.000
0.704
0.934
C8-7
0.000
0.689
0.934
C8-8
0.000
0.627
0.935
C9-1
0.000
0.706
0.934
C9-2
0.000
0.653
0.935
C9-3
0.000
0.538
0.937
C9-4
0.000
0.467
0.939
C9-5
0.000
0.556
0.937
C12-1
0.000
0.752
0.933
C12-2
0.000
0.764
0.933
C12-3
0.000
0.771
0.933
C12-4
0.000
0.796
0.932
C12-5
0.000
0.776
0.933
T 0.05 0.4(0.938)
C8-1 C8-2
C8-1 C8-2 C9-4 (0.939)(0.938)
(2)
A.
KMO Bartlett
C8C9C12
0.930
Bartlett (<0.05)
0.000
KMO Barlett
10
11
12
13
14
8.338
1.904
1.027
0.702
0.659
0.594
0.533
0.426
0.373
0.318
0.300
0.231
0.199
0.155
1.507
1.385
1.290
1.209
1.135
1.064
0.998
0.931
0.874
0.816
0.770
0.714
0.659
0.616
F1
F2
0.568
0.840
0.846
0.805
0.831
0.748
0.669
0.661
0.671
0.596
0.441
0.927
0.960
0.915
0.923
0.920
(%)
52.11%
11.90%
0.40
11
5 52.11% 11.90% 64.01%
16
B.
C12
C12-6
C12-7
C8C9
0.622
0.500
0.514
0.000
0.000
0.000
(=0.622
=0.500=0.514)
C10
C11
C8C9
0.494
0.498
0.000
0.000
C12
0.507
0.485
0.000
0.000
C12-6
0.473
0.401
0.000
0.000
C12-7
0.408
0.328
0.000
0.000
(
=0.494/0.498=0.507/0.4850.473/0.401
=0.408/0.328)
C3
C4
C5*
C6
C8C9
0.385
0.333
0.190
0.380
0.000
0.000
0.005
0.000
C12
0.448
0.408
0.271
0.377
0.000
0.000
0.000
0.000
C12-6
0.279
0.233
0.164
0.130
0.000
0.000
0.017
0.057
C12-7
0.284
0.244
0.219
0.164
0.000
0.000
0.001
0.016
(=0.385/0.448/0.279/0.284=0.333/0.408/0.233/0.244)
(=0.190/0.271/0.164/0.219)
(
=0.80/0.377//0.164)
C7*
A1
A2
B2
B3
C8C9
0.281
0.221
0.212
-0.201
0.227
0.001
0.001
0.002
0.003
0.001
C12
0.388
0.178
0.199
-0.198
0.209
0.000
0.009
0.009
0.004
0.002
C12-6
0.130
-0.28
0.019
-0.034
0.079
0.057
0.686
0.784
0.622
0.249
C12-7
0.164
0.032
0.127
-0.102
0.142
0.018
0.647
0.065
0.138
0.039
=0.281/0.388)
(=0.221/0.178
=0.212/0.199=0.227/0.209)(=-0.201/-0.198)
(2)
Cronbachs 95%
Cronbachs
95%
C8-3C8-4C8-5C8-6C8-7C8-8
0.907
0.888
0.925
11
C9-1C9-2C9-3C9-4C9-5
C12-1C12-2C12-3C12-4C12-5
0.960
0.951
0.968
C8C9C12
0.936
0.922
0.948
16
Cronbachs 95% 95%

0.9 0.888 0.9
3.
(1)
T
T (>0.05)
(<0.4)
(>0.911)
C18-1
0.000
0.507
0.908
C18-2
0.000
0.449
0.910
C18-3
0.000
0.384
0.911
C18-4
0.000
0.410
0.910
C18-5
0.000
0.353
0.912
C18-6
0.000
0.257
0.913
C18-7
0.000
0.404
0.910
C19-1
0.000
0.566
0.907
C19-2
0.000
0.478
0.909
C19-3
0.000
0.569
0.907
C19-4
0.000
0.580
0.907
C20-1
0.000
0.639
0.906
C20-2
0.000
0.665
0.905
C20-3
0.000
0.639
0.906
C20-4
0.000
0.530
0.908
C20-5
0.000
0.550
0.907
C21-1
0.000
0.661
0.905
C21-2
0.000
0.711
0.904
C21-3
0.000
0.621
0.906
C21-4
0.000
0.664
0.905
C21-5
0.000
0.468
0.909
C21-6
0.000
0.497
0.909
C21-7
0.000
0.658
0.905
T 0.05 0.4(0.911)
C18-5 C18-6
C18-5 C186 C18-3 (0.384)(0.4)
(2)
A.
KMO Bartlett
C18C19C20C21
0.880
Bartlett (<0.05)
0.000
KMO Barlett
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
7.985
2.525
1.437
1.209
0.932
0.856
0.698
0.679
0.603
0.558
0.495
0.441
0.435
0.389
0.373
0.355
0.269
0.254
0.201
1.599
1.477
1.383
1.301
1.227
1.156
1.091
1.025
0.965
0.906
0.863
0.805
0.749
0.699
0.648
0.600
0.551
0.501
0.463
F1
F2
F3
0.633
0.843
0.921
0.887
0.602
0.784
0.956
0.616
0.428
0.694
0.797
0.475
0.643
0.517
0.563
0.998
0.928
0.840
0.533
0.619
(%)
38.02%
12.02%
3.84%
0.40
C19-4 C20-2
C20-5
F1
F2
F3
0.633
0.845
0.913
0.880
0.606
0.797
0.940
0.631
0.515
0.712
0.774
0.511
0.557
0.978
0.894
0.832
0.520
0.594
(%)
37.64%
13.78%
7.9%
0.40
7
6 5 37.64%13.78% 7.9%
59.32%

C19-4 C20-2 C20-5 18
B.
C19C20
C21
C18
0.312
0.375
0.000
0.000
C19C20
0.638
0.000
(=0.638)
(=0.312=0.375)
C13
C14
C15
C16
C17
C18
0.412
0.452
0.570
-0.218
-0.165
0.000
0.000
0.000
0.001
0.016
C19C20
0.393
0.319
0.477
-0.133
-0.135
0.000
0.000
0.000
0.053
0.048
C21
0.389
0.288
0.454
-0.152
-0.226
0.000
0.000
0.000
0.027
0.001
(
=0.412/0.393/0.389=0.452/0.319/0.288=0.570/0.477/0.454)

(=-0.218)
C3
C4
A1
A2
B2
B3
C18
0.369
0.385
0.319
0.327
-0.095
0.210
0.000
0.000
0.000
0.000
0.166
0.002
C19C20
0.501
0.536
0.156
0.310
-0.264
0.297
0.000
0.000
0.022
0.000
0.000
0.000
C21
0.423
0.437
0.128
0.261
-0.163
0.207
0.000
0.000
0.062
0.000
0.017
0.002
(=0.369/0.501/0.423
=0.385/0.536/0.437)
(=0.319/0.156/=0.327/0.310/0.261)
(=/-0.264/-0.163
=0.210/0.297/0.207)
(3)
Cronbachs 95%
Cronbachs
95%
C18-1C18-2C18-3C18-4C18-7
0.837
0.800
0.869
C19-1C19-2C19-3C20-1C20-3C20-4
0.840
0.805
0.871
C21-1C21-2C21-3C21-4C21-5C21-6C21-7
0.867
0.837
0.892
C19C19C20C21
0.898
0.877
0.917
18
Cronbachs 95% 0.8
214
9 ACGME 80
3.5 3
2007
28.4 40 40 40
8.33 10.21 81.46 97.24 30.69 36.99 4.67
3.80 2.31 4.77 p 0.05 0.07
0.059 40
ACGME
C4 40
C4 >40
(n=39)
(n=175)
A1
A2
95%
(2)
8.33
5.47
10.21
5.89
-1.818
0.070
-3.90
0.16
81.46
23.30
97.24
21.05
-4.150
0.000
-23.27
-8.28
0.199
A4
30.69
9.23
36.99
10.51
-3.458
0.001
-9.89
-2.71
0.102
A7
9.86
4.12
8.22
4.46
2.103
0.037
0.10
3.18
0.112
B2
4.67
1.27
3.80
1.42
3.513
0.001
0.38
1.35
0.169
B3
2.31
1.45
4.77
3.67
-6.805
0.000
-3.18
-1.75
0.190
1. 9
>9
3.58
>9
3.37
3.1
2.98
2.46
2.16
2.05
2.01
1.72
1.62
1.50
1.64
1.02
2.19
1.1
1.33
1.26 1.33
1.21 1.19
0.138
>9
>9
83.58
72.39
67.46
55.15
65.35
55.1
73.78
66.23
59.75
49.87
52.63
44.5
46.37
69
37.5
41.8
45.2544.96
66.12
61.76
41.5 39.69
0.059
A1 9
A1 >9
(n=100)
(n=114)
95%
(2)
B6
2.05
1.13
1.72
1.21
2.028
0.044
0.01
0.64
0.146
B7
2.98
0.75
3.58
0.91
-5.267
0.000
-0.82
-0.37
0.165
B8
2.16
0.88
2.46
1.05
-2.307
0.022
-0.57
-0.04
0.138
B9
1.02
1.20
1.62
1.24
-3.599
0.000
-0.93
-0.27
0.104
B10
1.50
0.61
1.64
0.64
-1.635
0.104
-0.31
0.03
B11-1
3.10
1.65
3.37
1.66
-1.183
0.238
-0.72
0.18
B11-2
2.01
0.90
2.19
0.99
-1.408
0.161
-0.44
0.07
B11-3
1.10
0.36
1.33
0.94
-2.456
0.015
-0.42
-0.05
B11-4
1.26
0.76
1.33
0.89
-.644
0.520
-0.30
0.15
B11-5
1.21
0.71
1.19
0.79
.165
0.869
-0.19
0.22
C3
55.15
18.75
67.46
22.43
-4.319
0.000
-17.92
-6.69
0.181
C4
55.10
17.75
65.35
21.90
-3.779
0.000
-15.60
-4.90
0.174
C5*
59.75
20.30
66.23
21.81
-2.239
0.026
-12.18
-0.77
0.155
C6
46.37
16.46
52.63
20.02
-2.476
0.014
-11.24
-1.28
0.087
C7*
72.39%
15.94%
83.58%
13.41%
-5.575
0.000
-0.15
-0.07
0.264
C8C9
37.50
19.92
44.50
21.33
-2.469
0.014
-5.54
-0.62
0.117
C12
41.80
25.16
49.87
27.91
-2.209
0.028
-3.05
-0.17
0.113
C12-6
45.25
27.22
44.96
28.65
.077
0.939
-0.29
0.31
C12-7
41.50
24.67
39.69
28.57
.492
0.623
-0.22
0.36
C19C20
69.00
17.68
73.78
16.25
-2.061
0.041
-1.68
-0.04
C21
61.76
18.50
66.12
18.26
-1.733
0.085
-1.96
0.13
0.260
0.116
2. 80
80
>80
80
3.47
>80
3.36
2.95
2.89
2.46
2.04
2.06 2.13
1.98
1.81
1.51
1.47
1.62
1.13
0.94
1.29
1.26
1.3
1.10
1.24
0.138
80
>80
80
>80
74.12
81.73
65.56
52.26
64.47
50.97
65.23
70.07
67.06
56.53
53.73
50.16
52.11
44.51
43.82
33.17
67.17
36.13
46.88
40.73
44.08
31.85
0.138
80
A2 80
A2 >80
(n=62)
(n=152)
95%
(2)
B6
2.04
1.08
1.81
1.22
1.298
0.196
-0.12
0.58
B7
2.89
0.75
3.47
0.89
-4.856
0.000
-0.82
-0.34
0.428
B8
1.98
0.95
2.46
0.97
-3.283
0.001
-0.76
-0.19
0.372
B9
0.94
1.17
1.51
1.26
-3.076
0.002
-0.94
-0.21
0.441
B10
1.47
0.56
1.62
0.65
-1.595
0.112
-0.34
0.04
B11-1
2.95
1.67
3.36
1.64
-1.649
0.101
-0.90
0.08
B11-2
2.06
0.83
2.13
1.00
-.421
0.674
-0.34
0.22
B11-3
1.13
0.42
1.26
0.83
-1.558
0.121
-0.30
0.04
B11-4
1.29
0.76
1.30
0.86
-.098
0.922
-0.26
0.23
B11-5
1.10
0.47
1.24
0.84
-1.623
0.106
-0.32
0.03
C3
52.26
20.74
65.56
20.86
-4.238
0.000
-19.49
-7.11
0.388
C4
50.97
18.55
64.47
20.26
-4.531
0.000
-19.38
-7.63
0.404
C5*
53.73
19.49
67.06
20.87
-4.320
0.000
-19.42
-7.25
0.384
C6
43.82
16.78
52.11
18.91
-3.004
0.003
-13.74
-2.85
0.391
C7*
70.07%
15.37%
81.73%
14.50%
-5.240
0.000
-0.16
-0.07
0.450
C8C9
33.17
18.40
44.51
21.06
-3.701
0.000
-7.65
-2.33
0.402
C12
36.13
20.93
50.16
28.05
-4.012
0.000
-4.19
-1.42
0.338
C12-6
40.73
27.99
46.88
27.79
-1.465
0.144
-0.58
0.08
C12-7
31.85
24.03
44.08
27.10
-3.090
0.002
-0.80
-0.18
0.392
C19C20
65.23
17.71
74.12
16.15
-3.551
0.000
-2.49
-0.71
0.367
C21
56.53
18.76
67.17
17.48
-3.954
0.000
-3.35
-1.12
0.382
3. 3.5
3.5
>3.5
3.5
>3.5
3.69
3.43
3.14
3.08
2.77
2.34
2.07
2.01
1.98
1.74
1.68
1.63
1.48
1.35
1.15
1.39
1.15
1.25
1.21 1.20
0.059
3.5
>3.5
3.5
>3.5
77.99
86.15
71.43
70.71
56.24
73.97
68.02
54.85
60.49
66.98
62.46
53.83
55.36
47.31
46.53
67.92
37.81
41.75
46.7544.16
44.16
38.5
0.059

3.5
B2 3.5
B3 >3.5
(n=77)
(n=137)
95%
(2)
B6
1.63
1.10
2.01
1.21
-2.306
0.022
-0.71
-0.06
0.065
B7
3.69
0.86
3.08
0.83
5.064
0.000
0.37
0.84
0.146
B8
2.77
1.00
2.07
0.89
5.238
0.000
0.43
0.95
0.151
B9
1.68
1.21
1.15
1.25
2.971
0.003
0.18
0.87
0.061
B10
1.74
0.70
1.48
0.57
2.936
0.004
0.08
0.43
0.070
B11-1
3.43
1.58
3.14
1.69
1.229
0.220
-0.17
0.75
B11-2
2.34
1.11
1.98
0.83
2.486
0.014
0.07
0.65
B11-3
1.35
0.93
1.15
0.59
1.682
0.095
-0.04
0.43
B11-4
1.39
0.96
1.25
0.75
1.116
0.267
-0.11
0.39
B11-5
1.21
0.77
1.20
0.75
.100
0.921
-0.20
0.22
C3
71.43
20.32
56.24
20.47
5.222
0.000
9.46
20.92
0.141
C4
70.71
18.69
54.85
19.56
5.784
0.000
10.45
21.27
0.147
C5*
68.02
22.65
60.49
20.11
2.510
0.013
1.62
13.44
0.083
C6
55.36
19.13
46.53
17.69
3.401
0.001
3.71
13.94
0.105
C7*
86.15%
12.73%
73.97%
15.46%
6.207
0.000
0.08
0.16
0.164
C8C9
47.31
23.08
37.81
18.85
3.082
0.002
1.50
6.87
0.080
C12
53.83
28.92
41.75
24.77
3.084
0.002
0.87
3.96
0.061
C12-6
46.75
27.91
44.16
27.99
.651
0.516
-0.21
0.42
C12-7
44.16
28.93
38.50
25.37
1.486
0.139
-0.07
0.53
C19C20
77.99
16.16
67.92
16.53
4.312
0.000
0.98
2.64
C21
66.98
18.83
62.46
18.11
1.725
0.086
-0.14
2.03
0.078
0.119
4. 3
>3
3.67
>3
3.54
2.96
2.97
2.63
2.08
2.32
2.04
1.65
1.64
1.46
1.91
1.70
1.39
1.07
1.07
1.18
1.43
1.11
1.30
0.059
>3
>3
77.34
85.89
69.75
54.38
68.38
53.44
58.87
54.53
36.81
68.67
59.91
46.08
45.31
66.27
71.48
67.95
51.37
41.29
44.6445.59
44.12
37.28
0.059
(Night Float) 2011 ACGME

3
B3 3
B3 >3
(n=112)
(n=102)
95%
(2)
B6
2.08
1.19
1.65
1.13
2.745
0.007
0.12
0.75
0.137
B7
2.96
0.84
3.67
0.80
-6.259
0.000
-0.92
-0.48
0.220
B8
2.04
0.89
2.63
0.99
-4.492
0.000
-0.84
-0.33
0.191
B9
1.07
1.26
1.64
1.18
-3.370
0.001
-0.90
-0.23
0.201
B10
1.46
0.57
1.70
0.67
-2.733
0.007
-0.40
-0.06
0.121
B11-1
2.97
1.72
3.54
1.54
-2.539
0.012
-1.01
-0.13
0.099
B11-2
1.91
0.80
2.32
1.05
-3.202
0.002
-0.67
-0.16
0.097
B11-3
1.07
0.29
1.39
1.00
-3.131
0.002
-0.51
-0.13
0.085
B11-4
1.18
0.59
1.43
1.02
-2.193
0.030
-0.48
-0.03
0.129
B11-5
1.11
0.43
1.30
0.98
-1.865
0.064
-0.41
0.11
C3
54.38
21.49
69.75
18.85
-5.543
0.000
-20.85
-9.91
0.186
C4
53.44
20.73
68.38
17.62
-5.654
0.000
-20.15
-9.73
0.206
C5*
58.87
20.15
67.95
21.64
-3.179
0.002
-14.71
-3.45
0.131
C6
45.31
17.55
54.53
18.75
-3.717
0.000
-14.11
-4.33
0.158
C7*
71.48%
15.78%
85.89%
11.53%
-7.676
0.000
-0.14
-0.11
0.264
C8C9
36.81
19.52
46.08
21.44
-3.310
0.001
-6.51
-1.65
0.127
C12
41.29
25.17
51.37
27.86
-2.780
0.006
-3.44
-0.59
0.156
C12-6
44.64
28.36
45.59
27.66
-0.247
0.805
-0.34
0.26
C12-7
37.28
24.66
44.12
28.62
-1.878
0.062
-0.56
0.01
C19C20
66.27
16.98
77.34
15.23
-5.002
0.000
-2.78
-1.21
0.183
C21
59.91
18.28
68.67
17.63
-3.564
0.000
-2.86
-0.82
0.139
5. 40
40
>40
40
>40
3.32
3.45
2.9
2.62
2.51
2.36
2.08 2.11
1.77
1.46
1.46
1.44
1.61
1.35
1.27
1.05
1.03
0.82
1.25
1.00
0.059
40
>40
40
>40
74.51
82.25
66.45
67.66
66.29
60.83
53.36
49.36
35
49.57
43.26
33.33
58.26
47.86
32.11
30.51
32.69
0.138
53.48
43.14
28.85
40
C4 40
C4 >40
(n=39)
(n=175)
95%
(2)
B6
2.36
1.28
1.77
1.14
2.865
0.005
0.18
1.00
.078
B7
2.62
0.78
3.45
0.84
-5.678
0.000
-1.13
-0.55
.444
B8
1.46
0.72
2.51
0.93
-7.789
0.000
-1.32
-0.78
.443
B9
0.82
1.21
1.46
1.24
-2.912
0.004
-1.07
-0.21
.133
B10
1.44
0.60
1.61
0.63
-1.529
0.128
-0.39
0.05
B11-1
2.90
1.73
3.32
1.64
-1.443
0.150
-1.00
0.15
B11-2
2.08
0.93
2.11
0.96
-.221
0.825
-0.37
0.30
B11-3
1.03
0.16
1.27
0.80
-3.684
0.000
-0.37
-0.11
.325
B11-4
1.05
0.32
1.35
0.90
-3.564
0.000
-0.47
-0.14
.118
B11-5
1.00
0.00
1.25
0.83
-3.940
0.000
-0.37
-0.12
.068
C3
35.00
17.24
67.66
17.69
-10.473
0.000
-38.80
-26.51
.751
C5*
49.36
16.46
66.29
21.08
-5.495
0.000
-23.07
-10.78
.288
C6
33.33
17.29
53.36
16.96
-6.644
0.000
-25.96
-14.08
.381
C7*
60.83%
14.97%
82.25%
12.91%
-9.097
0.000
-0.26
-0.17
.476
C8C9
32.11
20.99
43.26
20.43
-3.068
0.002
-8.06
-1.75
.170
C12
30.51
19.96
49.57
27.06
-5.022
0.000
-5.32
-2.30
.239
C12-6
32.69
22.33
47.86
28.35
-3.638
0.001
-0.94
-0.27
.151
C12-7
28.85
23.32
43.14
26.86
-3.363
0.001
-0.91
-0.23
.148
C19C20
58.26
19.49
74.51
15.00
-5.771
0.000
-3.92
-1.93
.355
C21
53.48
22.64
66.45
16.57
-4.113
0.000
-4.03
-1.42
.294
3.56
3.02
2.94
3.14
3.14
3.57
3.39
3.05
38%
1.85
62%
1.38
62% 43%

50% 2011 ACGME 24
70%
20 % 10 15
2011 ACGME 36
2011 ACGME 28 28% 36
2007
9 80 3.5 3
40
3.5
(Night Float) 2011 ACGME
B1
B9
B9-1
B9-2
1 2 3-4 3 1-2 4 1-3 5
B10
1-10% 2-10 to -5% 3-5 to +5% 4+5 to +10% 5+10%
1-5 to +5% 2-10 to -5%+5 to +10% 3-10%+10%
B11
B11-1
B2
B3
B4
1 2
B5
1 2
B6
B7
1 2 3 4 5
1 2<1 3 1-2 4 3-4 5>5

B11-2
1 2 3 4 5
B11-3
B11-4
B11-5
1 2<1 3 1-2 4 3-4 5>5
C1
B8
B8-1
B8-2
B8-3
1 2 3 4 5
C2
1 2 3 4 5
A1
A2
A3
A4
A5
A6
A7
B8-4
B8-5
0 1 2 3 4 5
<6 6-9 10-14 >15
C3
C3-1
C7
C7-1
C3-2
C3-3
C3-4
C3-5
0 1 2 3 4
C4
C4-1
C4-2
C4-3
C7-2
C7-3
C7-4
C7-5
C7-6
C7-7
1 2 3 4
C8 ()
C8-1
C4-4
C4-5
0 1 2 3 4
C5
C5-1
C5-2
C5-3
C5-4
C5-5
C8-2
C8-3
C8-4
C8-5
C8-6
C8-7
C8-8
1 2 3 4 5
C9 ()
0 1 2 3 4
C6
C6-1
C6-2
C6-3
C6-4
C6-5
C6-6
0 1 2 3 4
C9-1
C9-2
C9-3
C9-4
C9-5
1 2 3 4 5
C10
1 2 3 4 5
C11
1 2 3 4 5
C18-3
C18-4
C12_1
C12-1
C12-2
C12-3
C12-4
C12-5
1 2 3 4 5
C12-6
C18-5
C18-6
C18-7
1 2 3 4
C19
C19-1
C19-2
C19-3
1 2 3 4 5
C12-7
1 2 3 4 5
C13
1 2 3 4 5
C14
1 2 3 4 5
C19-4
1 2 3 4
C20
C20-1
C20-2
C20-3
C20-4
C20-5
1 2 3 4
C15
C16
C17
C18
1 2 3
1 2 3 4 5
C18-1
C18-2
C21
C21-1
C21-2
C21-3
C21-4
C21-5
C21-6
C21-7
D
D1
D2
D3
D4
D5
D6
D7
D8
D9
D10
1 2 3 4 5

2012年醫師工作環境問卷調查 (結果完整報告)

Uploaded by

Document Information

Original Title

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

2012年醫師工作環境問卷調查 (結果完整報告)

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

2012

9.86 53% 9 20% 10 15

94.36 71% 2011 ACGME 80 65% 88

5.99 18% 2011 ACGME 6

35.84 92% 2011 ACGME 28 92%86%28% 30

24 10.18 83% 2011 ACGME 14

22.97 50% 2011 ACGME 24

8.52 54% 2011 ACGME 10

5.97 3.96 4.32 98%

39% 43% 1.88

64% 28% 6%8% 5%

23% 4.95 1.06

KMO Barlett (principal component

(promax rotation method)

B. (concurrent criterion validity)

Cronbachs 95% 0.8

Cronbachs 0.8 95% 0.8 0.790

Cronbachs 95% 95%

Cronbachs 95% 0.8

(Night Float) 2011 ACGME

1 2<1 3 1-2 4 3-4 5>5

You might also like