Professional Documents
Culture Documents
TECHNOLOGY HANDBOOK
by
Charles M. Davis
Edward F. Carome
Martin H. Weik
Shaoul Ezekiel
Robert E. Einzig
Publisher and Distributor
Optical Technologies (OPTECH)
A Division of Dynamic Systems, Inc.
360 Herndon Parkway, Suite 1200
Herndon, VA 22070-5225
Tel: (703) 478-0844 Fax: (703) 478-0649
Copyright Optical Technologies, Inc., 1982; 1986
Registration Number TX 1-094-758
All rights reserved.
No part of this publication may be
reproduced, copied or transmitted, in any
form or by any means - graphic, electronic,
or mechanical, including photocopying,
taping or information storage and retrieval
systems - without the prior written
permission of Optical Technologies (OpTECH).
FOREWORD
THE FIBEROPTIC SENSOR TECHNOLOGY HANDBOOK
The FIBEROPTIC SENSOR TECHNOLOGY HANDBOOK reflects
the latest technology concerning the field of
fiberoptic in general and fiberoptic sensors in
particular. The fiberoptic sensor technology principles
and practices laid down in this HANDBOOK will give the
reader a solid basis for mastering a relatively new
technology. Only a nominal general technical background
is needed to fully comprehend its contents. The
contributing authors have been as explicit and rigorous
in their presentation as time and space constraints in
this HANDBOOK would permit. All the material has been
edited to ensure coherency and consistency.
OPTICAL TECHNOLOGIES, INC.
Optical Technologies, Inc. (OPTECH) is a young and
rapidly growing corporation devoted to the research and
development of useful fiberoptic sensor applications and
to the advancement of fiberoptic sensor technology.
OPTECH is recognized as a leader in this field. The co-
founders of OPTECH, Dr. Charles M. Davis and Mr. Robert
E. Einzig, who are also authors of this HANDBOOK, are
pioneers in the field of fiberoptic sensor technology.
Dr. Davis headed the branch at the Naval Research
Laboratory that designed and produced the first
fiberoptic hydrophore. He has since collaborated in the
design of numerous other fiberoptic sensor systems. Mr.
Einzig has also designed fiberoptic sensor systems for
private research laboratories, industry and government.
Finally, both men were the key contributors to the
development of the Navys Fiber Optic Sensor System
(FOSS) Program in 1977. Presently, their experience and
talents are being applied at OPTECH where, together with
other physicists and engineers specializing in
fiberoptic sensing, advances in the field are continuing
to be made. To date, OPTECHS experience with
fiberoptic sensors includes development of sensors for
the measurement of temperature, pressure, acoustic
signals, acceleration, magnetic fields, and seismic
disturbances.
AUTHORS
Charles M. Davis, PhD. Currently Dr. Davis is Vice
President of Optical Technologies, Inc. He has over 30
years of experience in acoustooptics and physical
acoustics. As head of the Physical Acoustics Branch at
the Naval Research Laboratory, he was instrumental in
the development of the fiberoptic hydrophore and the
establishment of the FOSS Program.
Edward F. Carome, PhD. Currently Dr. Carome is a
Professor of Physics at John Carroll University. He
participated in the initial research at the Naval
Research Laboratory that led to the development of the
fiberoptic hydrophore.
Martin H. Weik, D.SC. Currently Dr. Weik is a
senior systems analyst at Dynamic Systems, Inc. Dr.
Weik has written several comprehensive dictionaries in
the fields of computers, information processing systems,
fiberoptic, lightwave propagation, and general
communications.
Shaoul Ezekiel, D.SC. Currently Dr. Ezekiel is a
Professor at MIT. He has conducted research concerned
with ultraprecision measurements using optical
techniques. More recently, he has investigated the use
of passive resonators and fiberoptic interferometers for
rotation measurements.
Robert E. EinziR, MSEE. Currently Mr. Einzig
serves as President of Optical Technologies, Inc. He
has extensive applications experience in fiberoptic
sensors and data transmission systems, which adds to his
broad underwater acoustic sensor background.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
Appreciation is extended to Dynamic Systems,Inc.
and specifically to Mickey Hedrick, Sandee M. Boyer, and
Sue M. Gift, and their supporting staff for their
secretarial, word-processing, and graphics support in
the preparation of this Handbook.
Robert E. Einzig
President
Optical Technologies, Inc.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
FOREWORD
CHAPTER
1.0
1.1
1.2
1.3
2.0
2.1
2.2
2.3
2.4
3.0
3.1
3.2
3.3
4.0
4.1
INTRODUCTION
Background .
Purpose . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .1-1
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .1-1
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .1-1
Contents by Chapter . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .1-1
FIBEROPTIC SENSOR COMPONENTS . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .2-1
Optical Fiber Properties . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .2-1
2.1.1 Design Objectives . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .2-1
2.1.2 Lightwave Propagation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .2-4
2.1.3 Propagation Modes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .2-5
Optical Fiber Fabrication . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .2-12
2:2.1
2.2.2
2.2.3
Refractive Index Profile Control . . . . . . . . . . . . . .2-12
Fiber Fabrication Processes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .2-13
2.2.2.1 The Double-Crucible Process. . . . . . . . . . . . .2-13
2.2.2.2 The Inside Vapor-Phase Oxidation (IVPD) Process . .2-14
2.2.2.3 The Outside Vapor-Phase Oxidation (OVPD) Process . .2-15
2.2.2.4 The Vapor Axial Deposition (VAD) Process . . . . . .2-15
Fiber Strength . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .2-16
Solid State Fiberoptic Light Sources . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
2.3.1 Energy Levels in Semiconductors . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
2.3.2 Light Emitting Diodes (LEDs) and Diode Laaers . . . . . . .
Photodetector . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
FIBEROPTIC COMPONENT INTERCONNECTION . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Fiberoptic Connectors and Splices . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
3.1.1 References. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Fiberoptic Couplers . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
3.2.1 References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Fiberoptic Cables . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
3.3.1 General . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
3.3.2 Commercial Fiberoptic Cables. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
3.3.3 Summary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
LICRTWAVES IN FIBEROPTIC SENSORS . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Interferometric Fiberoptic Sensors . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
4.1.1 Intensity Interferometry . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
4.1.1.1 Basic Principles . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
4.1.1.2 The Michelsen Interferometer . . . . . . . . . . .
4.1.1.3 The Mach-Zehnder Interferometer . . . . . . . . .
4.1.1.4 The Sagnac Interferometer . . . . . . . . . . . .
4.1.1.5 The Fabry-Perot Interferometer . . . . . . . . . .
4.1.1.6 Interferometer Sensitivity . . . . . . . . . . . .
4.1.2 Fiberoptic Intensity Interferometers . . . . . . . . . . .
4.1.3 Polarization in Fiberoptic Sensors . . . . . . . . . . . .
.2-17
.2-17
.2-19
.2-22
.3-1
.3-1
.3-5
.3-5
.3-7
.3-7
.3-7
.3-8
.3-8
.4-1
.4-1
.4-1
.4-1
.4-1
.4-1
.4-2
.4-2
.4-2
.4-3
.4-3
4.2 Phase
4.2.1
4.2.2
4.2.3
4.2.4
4.2.5
4.2.6
4.2.7
4.2.8
and Intensity Detection . . . . . . . .
Phase Detection . . . . . . . . . . . .
Homodyne Detection Applications . . . .
Phase Noise . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Amplitude Noise . . . . . . . . . . . .
Satellite Modes and Multimode Operation
Phase-Locked-Loop Operation . . . . . .
Heterodyne Detection . . . . . . . . .
References . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
.4-5
.4-5
.4-8
.4-8
.4-9
.4-9
.4-1o
.4-1o
.4-11
4.3 Integrated Optical Circuits (IOCS) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .4-12
5.0 FIBEROPTIC SENSORS AND COMPONENTS . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .5-1
5.1 Phase Modulated Fiberoptic Sensors . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .5-1
5.1.1 General . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .5-1
5.1.2 Fiberoptic Acoustic Sensors . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .5-2
5.1.2.1 Acoustic Pressure Sensors . . . . . . . . . . . . .5-2
5.1.2.2 Pressure Gradient Sensors . . . . . . . . . . . . .5-3
5.1.3 Fiberoptic Magnetic Sensors . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .5-5
5.1.4 Fiberoptic Electric Current Senaors . . . . . . . . . . . . .5-6
5.1.5 Fiberoptic Spectrophones . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .5-6
5.1.6 Summary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .5-7
5.1.7 Reference . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .5-7
5.2 Intensity Modulated Fiberoptic Sensors . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .5-7
5.2.1 General . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .5-7
5.2.2 Evanescent-Field Fiberoptic Sensor . . . . . . . . . . . . .5-8
5.2.3 Reflection Coefficient Fiberoptic Sensor . . . . . . . . . .5-8
5.2.4 Moving Grating Fiberoptic Sensor . . . . . . . . . . . . . .5-8
5.2.5 Microbend Fiberoptic Sensor . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .5-9
5.2.6 References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .5-12
5.3 Fiberoptic Linear Accelerometers . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .5-12
5.3.1 References. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .5-14
5.4 Fiberoptic Rotation-Rate Sensors . . . . . . . . . . . .
5.4.1 Introduction. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
5.4.2 Methods of Rotation Sensing . . . . . . . . . . .
5.4.3 Interest in Optical Rotation Sensors. . . . . . .
5.4.4 Sagnac Effect in a Vacuum . . . . . . . . . . . .
5.4.5 Sagnac Effect in a Medium . . . . . . . . . . . .
5.4.6 The Magnitude of the Sagnac Effect. . . . . . . .
5.4.7 Methods of Optical Rotation Sensing . . . . . . .
5.4.8 Fundamental Limits in Optical Rotation Sensors. .
5.4.9 Fiberoptic Rotation-Rate Sensors. . . . . . . . .
5.4.10 Photon Shot-Noise Limit . . . . . . . . . . . . .
5.4.11 Ideal Performance . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
5.4.12 Measurement of Nonreciprocal Phase Shift. . . . .
5.4.13 Methods of Nonreciprocal Phase Modulation . . . .
5.4.14 Open Loop and Closed Loop Operation . . . . . . .
5.4.15 Problems in Fiberoptic Rotation Sensors . . . . .
5.4.16 Integrated Fiber Gyros. . . . . . . . . . . . .
5.4.17 Fiber Gyro Performance. . . . . . . . . . . . . .
5.4.18 Summary of Rotation-Rate Sensors. . . . . . . . .
5.4.19 General Conclusions Regarding Fiberoptic Sensors.
5.4.20References. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . .5-14
. . . . . .5-14
. . . . . .5-14
. . . . . .5-15
. . . . . .5-15
. . . . . .5-16
. . . . . .5-16
. . . . . .5-16
. . . . . .5-17
. . . . . .5-18
. . . . . .5-18
. . . . . .5-19
. . . . . .5-19
. . . . . .5-20
. . . . . .5-21
. . . . . .5-21
. . . . . .5-22
. . . . . .5-23
. . . . . .5-23
. . . . . .5-23
. . . . . .5-23
6.0 FIBEROPTIC SENSOR ARRAYS AND TELEMETRY SYSTBMS . . . . . . . . . . .6-1
6.1 Fiberoptic Sensor ArraYs . . . . . . . . . G . . . . . . . . . . . .6-1
6.1.1 Fiberoptic Senaor Array Design Considerations . . . . . . . .6-1
6.1.1.1 General Design Considerations . . . . . . . . . . .6-1
6.1.1.2 Specific Design Considerations . . . . . . . . . . .6-1
6.1.2 Fiberoptic Sensor Array Basic Configurations . . . . . . . .6-1
6.1.3 Fiberoptic Sensor Array Budgets . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .6-5
6.2 Fiberoptic Telemetry Systems . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
6.2.1 Fiberoptic Telemetry System Design Options . . . .
6.2.2 Fiberoptic Telemetry System Basic Configurations .
6.2.3 Telemetry System Budgets . . . . . . . . . . . . .
6.2.3.1 Risetime Budget Analysis . . . . . . . . .
6.2.3.2 Optical Power Budget Analysis . . . . . .
6.2.3.3 Cost Budget Analysis . . . . . . . . . . .
6.2.4 Fiberoptic Telemetry System Specific Configurations
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
.6-5
.6-6
.6-6
.6-7
.6-7
.6-9
.6-9
.6-9
6.3 Fiberoptic Sensor Array Telemetry Transmission Line Parameters . . .6-11
6.3.1 Transmission Line General Parameters . . . . . . . . . . . .6-11
6.3.2 Transmission Line Specific Parameters . . . . . . . . . . . .6-11
6.3.3 Multiplexing with Optical Fibers . . . . . . . . . . . . . .6-12
6.3.4 Connector Parameters . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .6-13
6.4 End-Terminal (Receiver) Consideration . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .6-13
6.5 Summary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .6-13
APPENDIX - Fiberoptic Sensors Glossary. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .A-l
CHAPTER 1
INTRODUCTION
1.1 BACKGROUND
The ever-present need for increased communi-
cation aystem capacity and reduced cost per message
unit has spurred the development and installation of
hundreds of operating lightwave communication ayatems
around the world. Compared to wire aystems, optical
fiber transmission syatems operate with less energy per
message unit-mile, lower signal attenuation per unit
distance, higher bandwidth for increased channel capa-
city, lower electromagnetic interference, lower cross-
talk, higher resistance to clandestine tapping, lower
shock hazard, amaller size, less weight, reduced con-
sumption of critical metals, and many others. These
advantages have encouraged improvements in light
sources; optical fibers, cables, and connectors; and
photodetectors. Optical fiber data links are off-the-
shelf ready-to-install items. Hundreds of millions of
dollars are being spent annually for improving optical
communication system component.
Capitalizing on the availability of optical
components, there haa been significant progress during
the past few years toward the development of a new
claaa of sensors employing fiberoptic. These sensors
are capable of detecting acoustic fields, linear and
rotational acceleration, electric and magnetic fielda,
and many other physical parameters. In effect, the
senaor modulates some feature of the lightwave in an
optical fiber such as the intenaity OT the phase.
Usually phase modulation must be converted to an inten-
sity modulation prior to detection. This may be accom-
plished by means of an optical interferometer. The re-
sulting signals (intensity or phase) can be telemetered
to places other than the location of the sensor (trans-
ducer, modulator) by means of a fiberoptic signal trans-
mission (telemetry) system. The optical signal may be
in analog or discrete form and the system may operate
with or without optical-to-electrical or electrical-to-
optical signal conversion. The fiberoptic aensors de-
scribed in this manual may use fiberoptic transmission
systems as well as electrical or electromagnetic trans-
mission systems. Even for the simplest case, one in
which a visual field or image is to be transmitted in
a coherent-fiber cable, the fiber bundle itself must
serve as the sensor and all the aspects of achieving
lightwave acceptance by optical fibers must be consid-
ered.
1.2 PURPOSE
This manual on fiberoptic sensors is designed
to be a stand-alone document intended to serve many pur-
poses. It provides a basic background for understand-
ing the concepts that make up the field of fiberoptic,
particularly as they apply to fiberoptic sensors. It
describea the propertied of optical fibers, then fab-
rication, and the properties of light sources and de-
tectors associated with fiberoptic sensora. Specific
emphasis is placed on design considerations for these
major components and for associated connector,
splices, couplers, and cables.
Different schemes may be used for controlling
lightwaves in order to sense a physical parameter. Many
of these control schemes are discussed in this manual,
including interferometry, polarization, and modulation.
Intensity and phase modulation are discussed in terms
of homodyne and heterodyne detection. Integrated opti-
cal circuits are introduced with emphasis on their fab-
rication and operating principles.
Many different types of fiberoptic sensors
are described in terms of their design and operation.
Some of these include intensity and phase modulation
sensora, rotation sensors, and accelerometers. Devices
discussed include the fiberoptic sensora (transducers,
modulators) used in hydrophores, magnetometera and geo-
phones.
In most fiberoptic sensor and sensor array
applications there will be a requirement to telemeter
sensed data over the full range of distances. Various
fiberoptic aensor arrays and telemetry schemes are dis-
cussed. Information is given concerning risetime and
power budgeting. Overall design considerations for tele-
metry systems are also briefly discussed.
1.3 CONTENTS BY CHAPTER
Following thia brief Introduction, (Chapter
1), Chapter 2 is devoted to the properties of the baaic
component of the fiberoptic sensor: the optical fiber
itself. Electromagnetic wave (lightwave) propagation
in optical fibera in terms of the wave equation; the
coupling of lightwaves in and out of fibers; power loss
by absorption, leakage, and scattering; are all discuss-
ed in some detail. Various properties of fibers, their
basic construction and limitations are discussed, in-
cluding basic concepts of total internal reflection,
critical entrance angles, and numerical aperture. The
concepts of mode propagation, refractive index profiles,
and polarization are introduced. Various methods of
fiber fabrication are covered, including several meth-
ods of drawing fibers. Obtaining deaired refractive
indices and the size, strength, and level of purity of
fibers are also described. Finally, in Chapter 2, the
characteristics of various types of light sources are
discusaed in sufficient detail to understand their use
in connection with fiberoptic sensors. The chapter
closes with a discussion of the characteristics and
limitations of photodetectors with apecial emphasis on
their importance and use in connection with the output
signal from a fiberoptic sensor.
Chapter 3 follows with a diacuasion of the
various means for connecting fiberoptic aenaor inputs
to electrical or optical sources and outputs to photo-
1-1
detectors or display devices. The sensor may be con-
nected to optical fibers and cables by various types
of connectors, splices, couplers, mixers, and cables,
the connector and splice being used primarily to join
fibers and cables, the couplers being used to connect
one source to many fibers (divergence), the mixer being
used to couple many fibers to one photodetector (con-
vergence).
The operation of fiberoptic sensors cannot be
well understood without an understanding of the varioua
actions and interactions that can take place by and
among lightwaves. Many of these interactions are the
basis for sensing physical parameters. The lightwave
characteristics discussed in Chapter 4 include inter-
ferometrics, polarization, and intensity and phase mod-
ulation in relation to homodyne and heterodyne detec-
tion. Chapter 4 ends with lightwave control technique
used in integrated optical circuits.
Chapter 5 turns primary attention from gen-
eral principles and techniques used in the operation of
fiberoptic aensora to a description of the sensors
themselves and their components. Intensity modulation
sensors; phase modulation devices, such aa those used
in hydrophores and magnetometera; rotation sensors, ac-
celerometers, and geophones are discuased as examplea
of fiberoptic sensor applications.
The grouping of fiberoptic aensors into sen-
aor arrays and the telemetering of their outputs to
other locations are covered in Chapter 6. Design op-
tions; basic configuration; riaetime, power, and coat
budgeta; and specific configurations of fiberoptic
arrays and telemetry aystema are diacuased in depth,
along with light sourcea, transmission lines and end-
terminals as they relate to fiberoptic senaors.
Bibliographies pertinent to the subject are
included at the end of each chapter. The appendix con-
tains an authoritative glossary of terms and definitiona
in the field of fiberoptic with emphasia on the terms
used to describe the design, fabrication, and operation
of fiberoptic aenaors. Particular attention in the
gloasary is devoted to the terms used in this manual.
Many topics and concepta related to fiberoptic senaors,
their operating principles, and supporting theory are
included in the glosaary ao aa not to overburden the
reader with too many detaila while the main topics are
being discussed. For example, concepta concerning dia-
peraion, Msxwella equations , modulation, polarization,
reflection and transmission coefficient, and various
tvpes of fiberoptic sensors and interferometers are
described in the glosaary.
1-2
CHAPTER 2
FIBEROPTIC SENSOR COMPONENTS
2.1 OPTICAL FIBER PROPERTIES
In this section the basic properties of opti-
cal fibers are discussed in some detail with emphasis
placed on concepts that are important in optical fiber
sensor technology. The structure of optical fibers is
quite simple, as shown in Fig. 2.1. Basically they
consist of layered cylinders of glass or plastic with
small diameters. There is a central cylinder called
the core, which is made up of one type of glass or
plastic. Surrounding the core is a cylindrical shell
called the cladding that is made of a slightly differ-
ent type of glass or plastic. The difference between
the core and cladding materials will be discussed later.
Finally, this layered cylinder is usually surrounded by
a Protective jacket.
The light-guiding capability of
the fiber is dependent upon the properties of the core
and cladding while the mechanical strength of the fiber
is maintained by the jacket that is usually made of
plastic.
A! A
MODULATING SIGNAL
LIGHT PULSES
OPTICAL
DET&CT-
.
INPUT OUTPUT
Fig. 2.2 A basic optical fiber link.
Four major optical fiber design objectives
will be discussed. The first major objective is the
desirability of maximizing the amount of available light
that is transferred (coupled) into the core of the
fiber. It is only the light in the core that is propa-
gated along the length of the fiber with relatively low
optical power loss. In order to maximize the amount of
light transferred (coupled) into the core, it is neces-
sary to maximize the numerical aperture (NA) of the
fiber. This is one of four important fiber parameters
that strongly affect the behavior of the simple system
shown in Fig. 2.2. After introducing the other three
important parameters, each will be discussed in some
detail.
The second fiber design objective is the de-
1/ L
sizability of minimizing the light lost from a beam as
CL
CORE
Fig. 2.1 The basic structure of an optical fiber.
2.1.1 Design Objectives
Some of the design objectives considered in
the development of a good optical fiber are illustrated
by the simple system shown in Fig. 2.2. The system con-
sists of a pulse-modulated optical source. The input
signal at the left represents the intelligence (infor-
mation) that is impressed on (modulates) the light beam
that, after emerging from the source, is focused with
a lens into one end of an optical fiber. The light
travels through the fiber and emerges from the opposite
end, where it is directed into an optical detector
(photodetector), possibly focused again with a second
lens.
it travels through the core from the input end to the
output end of the fiber. This light loss is described
as the attenuation (power leas) rate, usually express-
ed in dB (decibel) per kilometer of fiber.
The third optical fiber design objective is
the desirability of maximizing the information carrying
capacity of the fiber. The input to the fiber may be
a light beam of continuously-varying intensity or a
group of well defined pulses of light as shown in Fig.
2.2. As the light pulses propagate through the fiber,
their amplitude will decrease due to attenuation. In
addition, due to a number of other effects to be dis-
cussed, the individual pulses also may broaden (spread).
If they become too broad they will overlap or coincide
with one another in both time and space. If this OC-
curs, the intelligence (information) originally impres-
sed on the light beam would be lost. Pulse broadening
that occurs in the fiber is called dispersion. This
parameter places a limit on a fibers information carry-
ing capacity (signaling rate).
The fourth design objective is the desirabil-
ity of maximizing the strength of fibers when they are
Initially drawn and maintaining this strength when the
fibers are formed into cables or are used in sensors
and other applications.
Before considering these and other fiber de-
sign objectives in some detail, the basic theory of
light propagation in optical fibers will be discussed,
beginning with light-ray propagation in layered media.
2-1
The light-ray concept is a convenient approximate ap-
proach that may be used to introduce other important
concepts such as total internal reflection and ray trap-
ping. To extend the theory of light propagation far-
ther, however, it is necesaary to take into account the
notions that light is an electromagnetic wave pheno-
menon and that optical fibers are cylindrical dielec-
tric waveguides. With these in mind it is possible to
develop concepts regarding the allowed electromagnetic
propagation modes of a cylindrical waveguide and to
introduce the frequently encountered optical fiber wave-
guide V-Parameter (V-value) that must be considered
when selecting a suitable fiber for a particular appli-
cation.
In accordance with the ray theory of light
propagation, a light beam incident from below on the
interface surface between two transparent media, at an
angle e 1 with the interface surface behaves as shown in
Fig. 2.3. When fll ia large, part of the incident beam
MEDIUM2 ! .-
n1>n2
1
X6;
n2
k
Fig. 2.3 Reflection and refraction at the interface
when a lightwave travels from a higher to
a lower refractive index medium.
is transmitted into the upper medium and vart is re-
flected. Their relative intensities depend upon the
refractive indices of the two media. The refractive
index of a medium is defined as the ratio of the velo-
city of light in a vacuum to the velocity of light in
the medium. The higher the refractive index of a med-
ium the slower light will travel in it. The refrac-
tive index of medium 1 is designated as nl and that
for medium 2 as n2 as shown in Fig. 2.3.
These indices alao determine the direction
of the beam transmitted into medium 2, i.e., @2 in
Fig. 2.3 is determined by the indexes of both media.
Snells law of refraction of light at an interface pre-
dicts that the ratio of the cosine of the angle 131 to
the cosine of the angle of t12 is equal to the ratio
n2/nl which is equal to the velocity ratio v1/v2. Thus,
as shown in Fig. 2.3, if light propagates in medium 1
at a lower velocity than in medium 2, the angle 01 will
be greater than the angle 02 and the ray will be bent
toward the interface when entering medium 2. The angle
of the reflected beam is equal to the angle of the inci-
dent beam. These are an application of the well known
laws (Snells laws) of refraction and reflection that
aPPIY in ray treatments of wave phenomena.
When the angle 81 is progressively decreased,
the results shown in Fig. 2.4 are obtained.
Beginning
at the left, a ray is shown incident at a relatively
large angle 01 with the interface between the two media,
with nl > n2. There is both a refracted and a reflected
beam and, from the conservation of energy, the sum of
their energies must equal the energy in the incident
beam.
nl > n2
v,< V2
+*NG)
I
\ MEOIUMI(CORE)
CASEI 01>0, CASE2 e)=ec CASE3: 01<8.
Fig. 2.4 Internal reflection of light rays striking
an interface surface at angles greater than,
less than, and at, the critical angle.
As the angle f31 is decreased the refracted
beam entering medium 2 bends further toward the inter-
face until finally the angle E12 reaches zero as shown
in the center of Fig. 2.4. At the same time the inten-
aity of the light entering the medium 2 steadily de-
creases and approaches zero as the angle 92 approaches
zero; thus the intensity of the reflected beam ap-
proaches that of the incident beam. The value of fJl
corresponding to the limiting value of e2 = O is defin-
ed as the critical angle Oc. At that condition cosine
02 is equal to unity and the critical angle ec is given
by:
Oc = cos-1n2/nl (2.1)
For all values of angle 01 equal to or less
than the critical angle ec as shown at the right in
Fig. 2.4, the incident ray will be totally refected and
energy will not be transmitted into medium 2. It should
be emphasized that this phenomenon of total internal
reflection at an interface occurs only when the velo-
city of light in the medium of incidence (medium 1) is
less than the velocity of light in medium 2, i.e., when
the refractive index nl is greater than the refractive
index n2. As an example, suppose that light is incident
from water on the surface between the water and air.
The velocity of light in water is approximately 2.25 x
108 m/see as compared to 3.00 x 108 mfsec in a vacumm.
Thus, the refractive index of water is 1.33 and the
critical angle at the water to air interface is approx-
imately 41. Total internal reflection will occur for
all rays that make an angle of 41 or less with the
water-air interface surface.
It is this phenomenon of total internal re-
flection that is the basis of operation of optical
fibers. The refractive index of the material making up
the core of a fiber must be slightly larger than the
refractive index of the surrounding cladding. A ray
traveling in the core at an angle equal to the critical
angle is shown in Fig. 2.5. Such a ray is totally re-
CLADDING -n2,
Fig. 2.5 A step-index optical fiber showing the
critical angle, 6C for total internal re-
flection.
2-2
fleeted each time it is incident on the core-cladding
interface so that it remains trapped in the core.
This, and any other ray with f31<f3c, will remain in the
core until it reaches the end of the fiber. Ideally
it will propagate without attenuation through the core
of the fiber.
The refractive index of the cladding is held
slightly less than that of the core and thus it is con-
venient to introduce a quantity A, the fractional dif-
ference between the two refractive indices, defined by
the equation:
A = (nl - n2)/nl (2.2)
From Eqs. (2.1) and (2.2), and for a meridion-
al ray (a ray that travels in a plane containing the
central axis of the core) the cosine of the critical
angle is given by:
cosOc=n2/nl = 1 -A (2.3)
Cos%lc = 1 -2A+A2 (2.4)
Using the Pythagorean theorem,
sin2f3c = 1 -cos2ec=2A-A2 (2.5)
sinoc=
(2A - A2)1/2
(2.6)
When A2 << 2A, which is usually the case for
optical fibers, then:
sindc . (2A)1f2 (2.7)
Typically the refractive Index nl of the core
might be 1.46 while that of the cladding n2 might be
1.44, in which case A = 0.14. In this case, 2A = 0.28
and A2 = 0.0002, or 1.4% of 2A, and to this extent the
approximation is valid. Critical angles are usually
only a few degrees. Therefore, it is sufficiently ac-
curate to compute them using the value for the sine as
given in Eq. (2.7).
As previously atated, rays propagating in the
core at angles equal to or less than Oc will be trapped
in the core while rays that propagate at angles 01
greater than ec will be partially transmitted into the
cladding each time they encounter the core-cladding
interface. These latter rays rapidly decrease in inten-
sity as they travel through the core and thus do not
contribute to propagation over long-distances in fibers.
Fibers with two different types of refractive
index profiles are widely used. One of these is the
step-index fiber. The left portion of Fig. 2.6 shows
STEP-INDEX FIBER GRADED-INDEX FIBER
INDEX
PROFILE
Fig. 2.6 Refractive index profiles for cylindrical
waveguides (optical fibers).
the variation of the refractive index as a function of
the distance from the center of the core to the outside
of the cladding for a step-index fiber. Within the
core, the refractive index does not vary with the rad-
ius, i.e., it has a constant value nl. At the core
cladding interface there is a step decreaae in the index
from nl to n2. It remains constant throughout the clad-
ding. The refractive index profiles of another type of
fiber, the graded-index fiber, is shown at the right in
Fig. 2.6. In this type of fiber the refractive index
nl decreases as a function of the radial distance from
the center of the core. Beyond the core-cladding inter-
face the index n2 remains constant with respect to the
radius all the way to the outer surface of the cladding.
Typical rays that may propagate with minimal
optical power loss within the core of a step index fiber
are shown in the lower left of Fig. 2.7. Within the
CENTRAL RAY MERIDIONAL RAY THROUGH CENTER
MERIDIONAL RAY THROUGH CENTER HELICAL RAY AVOIOING CENTER
Fig. 2.7 Differentlydirected rays in the core of an
optical fiber.
core a central ray is shown that propagates parallel to
the axis of the fiber. There also are meridional rays
that propagate in planes containing the central axis of
the fiber. They travel in the core, reflecting back
and forth each time they strike the core-cladding inter-
face.
The meridional ray for the graded index fiber
is shown on the upper right in Fig. 2.7. Because the
index varies continuously from the center of the core
out to the core-cladding interface, such rays, rather
than traveling along straight lines, propagate along
curved lines, continuously being bent back and forth;
however they travel in planes containing the central
axis of the fiber. There are other rays that travel
along helical paths that do not intersect the central
axis of the fiber as shown at lower right of Fig. 2.7.
There other similar rays, called skew rays, in step-
index fibers. There are many more helical and skew
rays than there are meridional rays and they have con-
siderable importance in light ray propagation in opti-
cal fibers. They contribute substantially to the trans-
fer of energy and information from the input end to the
output end of a fiber. However, the geometric descrip-
tion of the propagation of helical and skew rays is
more difficult than that of merdional rays, as shown at
the lower left of Fig. 2.7. Therefore, for the sake
of simplicity in developing the ray theory of light pro-
pagation in fiber, this treatment is confined to the
consideration of meridional rays. This approach provid-
es an adequate background for defining and understand-
ing the basic parameters of light propagation into,
within, and out of, optical fibers.
The numerical aperture (NA) of an optical
fiber is defined aa the sine of the half-angle of the
cone of light that is incident from air on the input
end of an optical fiber, such that all the rays having
a direction that lies within the cone will be trapped
within the core once they enter the fiber as shown in
Fig. 2.8. Thus, at the core-air transverse interface
,..
2-3
[--::= -
.! (
----
\
ACCEPTANCE
J-
&
CONE
Fig. 2.8 The acceptance cone for a ~tep~i~~$x opti-
cal fiber. (N. A.=sinec=(nl n2 )
end surface, where the refractive index of air,
no7 IS
equal to unity, there is another critical angle,3c ,
such that all ,the light contained within the cone of
half angle Clc , will be trapped within the fiber. Ap-
plying Snells Law, this time in the sine form because
ec is the angle between the cone edge (elements) and
the normal to the surface of incidence (end face of fi-
ber), the ratip of the sine of ec within the core to
the sine of ec in air is equal to the refractive index
n. of air divided by the refractive index nl of the
core. Thus, since n. = 1:
(sinoc)/no = sinec = (sin9c)/nl
(2.8)
At the core-cladding interface within the fiber it was
shown that Cosoc = n2/nl Eq. (2.3). Combining Eqs.
(2.3) and (2.8) and using the Pythagorean theorem:
sin28c + c0s20c=l=(sin20c )/n12 + n22/n12 (2.9)
Transposing:
(5in2ec )/n12=l-n22/n12=(n12-n22)n12 (2.10)
Thus, from the defini~ion that the numerical aperture
i s
As
equal to the sin ec :
2 1/2
N.A. = sinoc = (n12 - n2 ) (2.11)
defined in Eq. (2.2) above:
A = (nl - n2)/nl (2.12)
Solving for n2:
n2 =
nl (1 - A) (2.13)
Substituting Eq. (2.13) in Eq. (2.11) and simplifying:
N.A. = nl(2A - A2)1/2 (2.14)
If A2 << 2A, which iS usually the case for optical
fibers, then:
N.A. = nl(2A)
112
z [2nl(nl - n2)112 (2.15)
Eq. (2.15) statea that the amount of light that will re-
main trapped and propagate in the core is directly pro-
portional to the square root of the product of the core
refractive index and the core-cladding refractive index
difference.
Examples of these various concepts about ray
propagation in optical fibers are shown in Fig. 2.9 and
in the following table:
A $ ra
ec ( 3C ec
deg rad deg
0.010 0.142 8.13 0.214 12.24
0.001 0.045 2.56 0.067 3.85
CLADDING -.2
A
CORE -.,
8>!9
~
Fig. 2.9 Light rays in a step-index fiber core.
Two rays are ,showo in Fig. 2.9. One enters
from air at an angle, 0 , such that on intersecting the
core-cladding interface, it makes an angle less than
the critical angle, 13c, with the interface. This ray
will be totally internally reflected and will be trap-
ped in the core, so that it propagates with minimal
loss through the fiber core. A second ray, incident
from air at a larger angle, intersects the core-clad-
ding interface at an angle greater than tic. At each
reflection part is reflected back into the core and
part is transmitted into the cladding. Such a ray is
strongly attenuated, rapidly decreasing in intensity
as it propagates along the core of the fiber.
The Eqs. (2.8), (2.11) and (2.15) show that
the critical angle at the core-cladding interface for
total internal reflection in radian measure for the
trappin of light in the core is approximately equal
f
to (ti) 12 when A2 << 2A, while the $orreaponding en-
:n::;f72:ritica1 angle rem air c s qwl 0
As indicated in the above table for A = 0.01,
e: = 0.14 radians or about 8 for the core-cladding
interface. The maximum angle f3c that the trapped rays
my make with the axis of the fiber as they enter from
air is 0.21 radians, or 12, assuming that the nl of
the core is equal to 1.5. Thus a cone of light with a
24 full apex angle could enter the fiber from air and
be totally trapped in the core. ForA = 0.001, Oc is
0.045 radian or about 2.6. Light rays entering from
air,would have to lie within a cone full apex angle of
2ec , or only about 8, in order that they be trapped.
2.1.2 Lightwave Propagation
The ray theory is an approximate representa-
tion of light propagation in confined media. It ap-
plies only at wavelengths that are small in comparison
to the dimensions of the cross section of the waveguide.
For cylindrical fibers small is in comparison to the
radius of the core. For helium-neon light the wave-
length is 0.63 pm and the ray theory applies well to
fibers with a core radius greater than 25pm. For
guides with a core radius of 2 pm, the ray theory is a
poor approximation since in this case the wavelength
is only about one third of the core radius. Therefore,
electromagnetic wave theory is used to obtain a good
representation or description of light propagation.
Maxwells equations correctly describe both
the space and time interdependence of the electric and
magnetic fields in linear, homogeneous, isotropic, and
source-free media. From these equations, the general
form of the electromagnetic wave equation can be deriv-
ed. The wave equation deacribes the propagation of an
electromagnetic wave in spatial and time coordinates.
If the source-free medium is a nonconductor (dielec-
tric) the wave equation can be simplified for describ-
ing propagation in optical fibers.
Optical fibers are cylindrical dielectric
waveguides. In order to describe light propagation in
them it is convenient to use the conventional system of
cylindrical coordinates ahown in Fig. 2.10.
2-4
,> = (J
REFERENCE
6=0
REFERENCE PLANE
LI
z
Fig. 2.10 The cylindrical coordinate system for ex-
pressing lightwave propagation in an opti-
cal fiber. The point P is designated as p,
0, z.
The Z-axis of this coordinate system is taken
to be the central axis of symmetry of the waveguide.
The z-coordinate is the distance from a reference plane
designated as Z. (zEO). A spatial point in a fiber is
located by defining a radius coordinate, p, as the dis-
tance radially from the Z-axis; an azimuthal (angular)
coordinate, $, measured from an arbitrary reference
plane ($=0); and a value of z. This coordinate system
is commonly known as the cylindrical coordinate system.
In the simple case where the refractive index
depends only on the radial coordinate, the solution to
the wave equation, derived from Maxwells equations for
the electric fields, can be expressed as the product
of two functions as follows:
E(p, $,z,t) = E(p, $)e-j(~t-W) (2.16)
= E(p, $)sin(ut-&) (2.17)
The variable t is the time measured from a time refer-
ence of to. The first is an amplitude factor E(P ,$)
that depends on the radius vector P and the azimuthal
(angular) coordinate $. The second, which can be ex-
pressed as complex exponential or sinusoidal function,
indicates that the electric fields are sinusoidal waves
in time and in space. The angular frequency is u= 2nf
where f is the optical frequency. The B is the propa-
gation constant, defined as the refractive index, n,
times the z component of the wave vector k, where kn=
2h/io, and i. is the optical wavelength in a vacuum at
frequency f. Thus, optical energy transfer in dielec-
tric media takes place in the form of wave propagation
along the axis of the guide. The absolute value of k
is also called the wave number.
2.1.3 Propagation Modes
When the geometric boundary conditions at the
core-cladding interface are introduced only particular
(discrete) solutions of the wave equations are permitt-
ed. Only these values can exist, each designated by a
value for i, for the amplitude factor Ei(P,$) and cor
-
responding discrete values for the propagation constant
~. The velocity of propagation of each allowed wave,
i.e. mode, along the axis of the waveguide is given
by the ratio of the angular frequency divided by the
propagation constant Bi, of a particular wave designat-
ed by the subscript. Thus, the various allowed solu-
tions represent discrete waves with discrete amplitudes
that propagate along the axis of the guide each with a
discrete velocity.
In order to characterize light propagation in
a step-index optical fiber it is convenient to use a
parameter, usually referred to as the waveguide V-para-
meter (V-value). It is defined by the equation:
V = 2ma(nl
2 - 2 112/i
n2 )
o
(2.18)
and therefore from Eq. (2.11):
V = 2~a(N.A.)/& (2.19)
where a is the core radius; N.A. is the fiber numerical
aperture, a function of the refractive indices of the
core and cladding; and i. is the wavelength of the in-
cident light in a vacuum. (The wavelength of a light-
wave in a vacuum is nearly equal to its wavelength in
air.) These are the main parameters needed to describe
light propagation in a step-index optical fiber. The
V-parameter may be designated as the light propagation
characteristic of an optical fiber. The larger the V-
value the larger the number of modes (different discrete
waves) the fiber can support, i.e., allow to propagate.
The predictions or conclusions that may be
drawn from the wave theory of light propagation in
fibers may be summarized in graphical form. As already
mentioned, only particular (discrete) solutions of the
wave equation exist. These correspond to discrete waves
propagating along the axis of the guide with particular
velocities. Some of the characteristics of these par-
ticular (allowed) modes are shown in Fig. 2.11. The
kn,
kn2
V=? G
wAVEGUIDE PARAMETER
Fig. 2.11 The propagation constant, i3, and the velo-
city of various modes as a function of the
V-parameter of an optical fiber.
curves show the allowed values of the propagation con-
stant & as a function of the V-parameter (V-value).
Each curve corresponds to a particular allowed solution
of the wave equation. This graph indicates that the
allowed values of %for the various solutions are in
between knl and kn2, corresponding to the wave numbers
in the core and in the cladding, respectively. Since
the wave (phase) velocity in the Z-direction is given
by the quantity m/6 the curves in Fig. 2.11 also show
the phase velocity versus the waveguide V-parameter (V-
value). Thus, the velocity of the allowed waves (modes)
represented by the different curves is seen to range
from the higher velocity in the cladding (lower ordi-
nate, higher value) to the lower velocity in the core
(upper ordinate, lower value) as the waveguide V-para-
meter increases. Thus each curve in Fig. 2.11 corres-
ponds to an allowed solution of the wave equation ap-
plied to dielectric waveguides. The waveguide V-para-
2-5
meter varies directly with the core radius and numeri-
cal aperture and inversely with the wavelength of light.
As the V-parameter increases, the number of allowed
modea increasea. For V less than 2.40, only one wave
or mode, designated in Fig. 2.12 as the HE1l mode,
ia permitted. For V in the range of 2.4 to 3.8, four
modes are allowed, these being the HE1l, TEOl, TMol,
and HE21 modes. These particular alphanumeric designa-
tions are standard for electromagnetic waveguides.
They have been chosen because of the specific forms
of the spatial variations for the electric and magnetic
fields associated with the particular solutions for the
wave equation. As V increases, more and more modes are
permitted (supported).
Consider the specific case in which V is less
than 2.40 as shown in Fig. 2.12. This is especially
k,
WAVEGUIDE PAR&METER
J!kiii
@
CORE
CLADDING
V<2.40 SINGLE MODE FIBER
~1 r
Fig. 2.12 The electric field of a lightwave for the
case in which only the first mode, HE1l is
supported by an optical fiber.
important since it defines the condition required for
a single-mode fiber. A vertical line is shown corres-
ponding to a V-value of 2.15. It intersect only the
HEll curve indicating that there is only one effective
velocity value. Under this condition the wave equation
reduces to an especially simpl$ form. The magnitude
of the electric field vector, E, varies approximately
as a Gaussian function of the distance from the core
center, p, decreasing monotonically from the center of
the core to the core-cladding interface as shown in the
lower right of Fig. 2.12. The electric field does not
go to zero at the core-cladding interface. It extends
into the cladding some distance. In the cladding, how-
ever, it decays rapidly (exponentially) with distance
from the center. The dominant direction of the elec-
tric field within the core is shown in the middle dia-
gram of Fig. 2.12. In this case it has been assumed
that light polarized in the direction shown has been
introduced into the circular core of the fiber and the
arrows represent the magnitude and direction of the
dominant electric field component of the electromagne-
tic wave. The electric field is always vertical in
this figure, but decreases in magnitude aa the cladding
interface is approached. The dominant magnetic field
component will also be tranverse to the core axis and
perpendicular to the electric field. The direction of
propagation is perpendicular to both the electric and
magnetic fields. The cross section of the output beam
emitted from the fiber is shown in the upper right of
Fig. 2.12. The beam is conical and in this case the
pattern is circularly symmetric and shows no fine struc-
ture. Horizontally polarized light could also have
been introduced into the same fiber at the same time.
Such light would remain horizontally polarized in an
ideal fiber. In fact this same type of behavior ap-
plies to any direction of polarization and gives rise
to one scheme for multiplexing.
In an ideal singlemode fiber with perfect cy-
lindrical symmetry the direction of light polarization
once introduced remains constant and there is no energy
transfer among the waves with different polarization
directions. However, in real fibers, due to slight
ellipticities in the core cross section, imperfections
in the core cladding interface, variations in the re-
fractive indices throughout the core, effects due to
bending, and other causes, there is usually some coupl-
ing between the different directions of polarization
and some variations in the velocity of each of the
waves with different polarizations. These effects must
be considered in certain applications. They will be
diacussed later when lightwave polarization effects in
ainglemode fiberoptic sensor applications are consid-
ered.
Returning again to a consideration of the spa-
tial modes of lightwaves in optical fibers, consider
the case of a fiber that can support four separate elec-
tromagnetic modes. This occurs when the V-value is in
the range 2.4 < V < 3.8, as shown in Fig. 2.13. The
k.,
1
//EEE1
*:. :;:( ~Eol
HE)) I .
T,o>
1 ,..
!+.3,
&@
CLADDING
.---
,~,,
HE,,
,.21 <$2?$ CORE
J< ,.02
T,o,
,22
123456
v-~ G
WAVEGUIDE PAFIAMETEI?
A
E
/
CORE
/
CLADDING
2.4 <V ~ 3.8
&
Fig. 2.13 The propagation constant, B, and the velo-
city of various modes as a function of the
V-parameter (V-value) of an optical fiber,
showing in particular a four-mode fiber.
vertical line in the figure, corresponding to the spec-
ific case of V = 3.6, intersects the B versus V curves
of the HEll, TEOl, TMol, and HE21 modes. Energy inject-
ed into them may propagate with very low 10SS. These
modes have different velocities, though as indicated,
the TMO1 and the HE21 velocities are nearly equal.
Their spatial field distributions differ, however, so
that a number of different patterns can be produced
when the output beam from the fiber is allowed to ex-
pand and illuminate a screen. For example, by careful-
ly adjusting the incident beam at the input end of the
fiber, it is possible to excite the TEOl mode to produce
the output pattern shown in the upper right in Fig.
2.13. This consists of a doughnut shaped pattern with
a dark spot in the center. From a detailed examination
of the appropriate aolution of the electromagnetic wave
equation, one would find that the electric field vec-
tors in the core are mainly circumferential, as shown
2-6
in the right center of Fig. 2.13. They increase in
magnitude from zero along the axis of the core to a
maximum and then decay as the core-cladding interface
is approached, as shown in the lower right. As already
pointed out for the HE1l mode in this case, the fields
again extend beyond the core into the cladding.
Returning to the graph at the left in Fig.
2.13, as V is increased further, for example by de-
creasing the wavelength, ,10, of the light injected into
the fiber, additional relatively lossless modes are per-
mitted and, very rapidly, propagation phenomena change
from the single or few mode types to multimode behavior.
In fact, for V > 10 the number of allowed modes is ap-
proximately equal to V2/2 for a step-index fiber. As
already pointed out above in the discussion of the rad-
ial electric field distribution for the HE1l and TEOl
modes, shown in the lower right in Fig. 2.12 and 2.13,
respectively, the ~-fields may extend well beyond the
core cladding interface. In fact when each mode is
first allowed much of its energy is associated with
fields that penetrate the cladding. This phenomena is
shown in Fig. 2.14 where the ratios of the power in the
Fig. 2.14 The variation of the ratio of optical power
in the cladding to the total optical power
in a fiber as a function of the V-parameter
(V-value).
cladding, pclad, to the total power, F, in a particular
mode are plotted as functions of the V-parameter. At
low values of V, for example V less than 1.0, most of
the energy transmitted by the HE1l mode is associated
with the field in the cladding. The spatial character
of each new allowed mode becomes more complex within
the V-values, for example, most of the energy transmit-
ted by the HE1l mode is associated with the fiel~s in
$he cladding. As the V-value is increased, the E and
H fields of the HE1l mode extend a smaller distance
into the cladding and a larger portion of its transmit-
ted energy is confined to the core, reading approxi-
mately 80% of the total when V = 2.4, as shown in Fig.
2.14. At this value of V, the TEOl, TMOl, and HE21
modes first come into existence and initially, again,
pcladtpz 1. As the V-value increases further the energy
associated with these three modes also become more con-
fined to the core. At V = 3.8, three additional modes,
the HE12, EH1l, and H31, are allowed. In this case, due
to the radial and azimuthal structure of their ~ and P
fields they initially propagate with approximately half
of their energy in the core and half in the cladding,
so that the power ratio Pclad/P starts off at 0.5 and
and then decreases rapidly as V increases.
This characteristic of mode propagation in
optical fibers is employed to advantage in a number of
fiber sensor applications. It is the basis of opera-
tion of evanescent wave couplers, or beam splitters,
wherein a portion of the light propagating in one fiber
is transferred to a second fiber by bringing their
cores close together by etching or lapping away a por-
tion of the cladding. Another application of this same
phenomenon is as the transduction mechanism in a number
of different intenaity-type aensors, where, through
carefully controlled micro-displacements induced by
bending, light can be ejected from the loosely-bound
high-order core modes. These and other useful applica-
tions of this core-into-cladding energy transfer of the
electromagnetic wave fields are discussed in detail in
later sections.
After the above brief discussion of the ray
and the waveguide theories of light propagation in op-
tical fibers, it is appropriate to return to a more
general consideration of the macroscopic propertied of
fibers. The conceut of attenuation will be discussed
next. Assume that-a pulse of light, of
(optical power) 1., is injected at the
core of a fiber, as shown in Fig. 2.15.
peak intensity
left into the
In general, as
OUTPUT INTENSITY DECREASES WIH INCREASING
IIZ)=Ioeaz
ATTENUATION EXPRESSED IN DECIBELS PER KILOMETER (dB/km)
I(z)
F OR Z . 1 km, dB/km=lOloglo~
Fig. 2.15 Light intensity (optical power) relative
attenuation as a function of distance in an
optical fiber.
it propagates through the fiber its intensity, I, will
decrease exponentially so that the intensity of any
point (transverse plane) z in the fiber is given by:
I(z) = Ioe-az (2.20)
where 10 is the intial intensity of the point of entry
into the core (z = O), z is the longitudinal distance
along the fiber, and = is the intensity attenuation co-
efficient. Thus, as indicated in the graph in Fig.
2.15, if in traveling a particular distance, z1, the
intensity decreases to 0.51., then at z = 2z1, it will
be 0.251., i.e., at the end of each Z1 incremental in-
2-7
crease in distsnce the intensity is reduced to l/2 of
the intensity at the beginning of the incremental in-
crease. For example, for this case, at the end of 521
the intensity will be 2-5 = 1/32 of the initial value.
For optical fibera, the attenuation rate is uaually
specified in terms of the decibels loss per kilometer,
i.e., (dB/km). In the case of z = 1 km, the attenua-
tion rate may be defined by the equation:
Attenuation Rate = -10 loglO(I1/Io) dB/km
(2.21)
In a fiber with an attenuation rate of 10 dB/km the in-
tensity (optical power) will fall to one tenth of the
incident intensity after traveling one kilometer. A 3
dB/km attenuation rate corresponds to a reduction to
one half the incident intensity after one kilometer,
since loglo 0.5 is equal to 0.3. In this latter caae,
after 5 km the intensity would be down 15 dB from the
initial value, i.e., the attenuation will be 15 dB.
A historical picture of the change in attenu-
ation rates of available fibers, from about 1968 to the
present, is shown in Fig. 2.16. The graph indicates
o
0
%a
,
0
0
0011
I , , , , ,
1968 1970 7972 1974 1976 1978 19s0 1982 1984 +
YEAR
absorption, ia due to absorption of optical energy into
the electronic energy levels of transition metal impuri-
ties, such as iron, copper, chromium and nickel, and
into the vibrational levela of hydroxyl ions (OH-) in
the core and innermost sections of the cladding. In
this case, energy is absorbed from the optical beam and
reradiated into the molecular lattice in the form of
heat. The second type of attenuation is due to bendin~
losses of which there are two typea. One is due to
:regular bending of the entire fiber at nominal radii.
For example, bending loss may be due to winding the fi-
her on a small-diameter mandrel. The second, referred
1:0 as mlcrobend loss, arise because of random variations
in the direction of the axia of the core. These may
even be microscopic, due to external forcea, imperfec-
tions in the coating or cladding, ripples in the core-
(:ladding interface, ticrocracks, and other causes. In
either caae, light will be injected from the core into
the cladding, and thus cause a decreaae in the light
intensity transmitted through the core to the output
end of the fiber. Finally, there are three types of
scattering losaes. The first, called Rayleigh scatter-
ing la cauaed by microscopic density fluctuation that
are frozen into the random molecular structure of the
glass making up the fiber core when it cools to its
relatively high solidification temperature. These den-
sity fluctuations may be resolved into spatial frequen-
cies that have wavelengths much shorter than the optical
wavelength. Rayleigh scattering losses vary inversly
as the fourth power of the optical wavelength. In addi-
tion to the static denaity fluctuations, there are also
dynamic density fluctuation due to thermal sound waves.
These waves originate and propagate becauae the temper-
ature of the glass is above absolute zero. These pro-
pagating density fluctuations (thermal phonons) lead to
Brillouin scattering. Finally, there is scattered
light caused by absorption and reradiation from atomic
vibrational and rotational energy levels, i.e., Raman
scattering. These latter two scattering processes,
i.e., Brillouin and Raman, are non-linear processes
and are significant only at high optical intensities.
The strength and wavelength-dependence of
some of these loss mechanisms is shown in Fig. 2.17.
Fig. 2.16 The reduction of fiberoptic attenuation
rates over the years. The + is a projected
value.
351
I I I I I I
why fiberoptic communication links were impractical in
the late 1960a, since attenuation rates in the range
1000 to 100 dB/km correspond to a decrease to one tenth
of the input intensity after traveling only 10 to 100
metera, respectively. A very evident atep decreaae in
attenuation rate occurred around 1970, with the intro-
duction of a new fiber fabrication technique, the vapor
phaae deposition proceas. This led to the availability
of the first high-priority silica fibers, and the de-
velopment of a group of related techniques for produc-
ing extremely high purity, low leas fibers. Today fi-
bers are available with minimum lossea, at selected
wavelengtha, in the range 0.2 to 1.0 dB/km so that the
repeaterless optical communication links of longer than
50 kilometer are an achievable reality.
A clear understanding of the factors that ef-
fect attenuation in optical fibers is of importance not
only to the fiber designer but also to the fiber user.
The causea of attenuation may be divided into
three aeparate categories: The first, called material
30
25
c
2
20
~.
15
x
0
J
10
5
0
05 06 07 08 09 10 11
WAVELENGTH (MICRONS)
G TRANSITION METAL IMPURITIES (Fe, Cu, Cr,Ni)
G HYDROXLION (OH)-1 PPM~ldB/km@.95#m
G RAYLEIGH SCATTERING w l/A4
G LEAKAGE LOSSES (MICROBEND, REGULAR BEND, ETC.)
Fig. 2.17 Sources (causes) of optical power attenua-
tion rate as a function of wavelength in a
typical optical fiber.
2-8
The vertical height of the various cross-hatched re-
gions represent the loss as a function nf the wave-
length arising from the various sources. Note that the
minimum total attenuation at approximately 0.8 micron
wavelength is approximately 10 dB/km. This is a some-
what mediocre fiber by todays standards. The lowest
four regions in Fig. 2.17 correspond to the loss due
to 1 part per million by weight, in silicon oxide (Si02)
glass, of the metallic impurities Cu, Ni, Fe, and Cr,
from bottom to top, respectively. The peak in the
vicinity of the 0.95-micron wavelength is due to the
third harmonic of the hydroxyl (OH-) vibrational mode,
and corresponds to roughly a 20-part-per-million impur-
ity content. The black dots are predicted values of
losses based on calorimetry-type optical absorption
measurements made on the glass sample from which the
fiber was drawn. The upper cross-hatched region repre-
sents the attenuation due to Rayleigh scattering while
the white region is the remaining difference between
the total loss versus wavelength (the uppermost curve)
and the sum of the previously mentioned losses. The
latter is attributed to regular bending and microbend-
ing losses.
The attenuation versus wavelength curve shown
in Fig. 2.18 is for a currently available very-low-
5.0 .
.
3.0
.>
.
2.0
\
1.0
0.5 -
\
bend radius, all of the solutions
represent waves that decay with
along the centerline of the core.
of the wave equation
increasing distance
/
\
6
/
/
6< 9.
e 70,
Fig. 2.19 Leakage of optical power froman optical
fiber at a constant-radius bend.
0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1.0 1.1 1.2 1.3 1.4 1.5 1.6
WAVELENGTH (pm)
Fig. 2.18 Attenuation rate of optical power in a low-
10SS optical fiber as a function of wave-
length. The arrows along the abscissa in-
dicate the wavelengths of commercially
available lasers.
loss, single mode fiber. The arrows along the lower
abscissa correspond to the wavelengths of currently
available lasers. The peak in the loss curve at the
1.4-micron wavelength is due to the OH- radical, which
has been reduced to a relatively low concentration
level. The minimum at approximately the 1.3 micron
wavelength is of special interest, not only because the
attenuation rate is down to 0.5 dB/km, but also because
this wavelength is very close to the zero-dispersion
wavelength of Si02 which is of special interest in some
applications, as will be discussed shortly.
Fig. 2.18
shows that extremely low attenuation rates attainable
with current fiber fabrication techniques at wave
-
lengths where high intensity long-life, solid state
laser sources are becoming commercially available. It
is now up to the fiber user to devise techniques and
configurations that can maintain this low loss by not
introducing significant regular
(macro) bending and
microbending losses.
tion. In the bent region, the ray intersects the core-
cladding interface at an angle 13 that is greater than
dC and thus it will be partially transmitted out of the
core and into the cladding. This will occur at each
successive reflection from the outer interface and large
losses may occur. Another qualitative explanation of
this type of loss is as follows. In the beam propagat-
ing in the fiber, assuming plane wavefronts, if the
velocity at the center of the core in the bent section
were equal to the c/nl, the proper velocity in the
core, then the velocity at the outer edge of the front
would have to be higher than c/nl, which cannot occur.
Radiation in the form of core-to-cladding scattering
results. Finally, from the electromagnetic wave theory
it may be shown that in a waveguide with a constant
Using the latter approach it is possible to
compute the expected loss due to a constant bend radius.
The results of such calculations are shown in Fig. 2.20,
where loss curves versus bend radius are shown for
singlemode fibers at the 0.83-micron wavelength having
different numerical aperture (N.A.). Note the strong
dependence on bend radius and N.A. Referring to Fig.
2.20, consider a fiber with a numerical aperture of
0.1. When a 10-meter length is wound on a l.2-cm-
radius mandrel, the attenuation due to bending is ap-
proximately 6 dB, i.e., 75 percent of the light energy
injected into the core at the input end is scattered
out of the core while propagating in the ten meters
to the output end. Nhen 10 meters of identical fiber
are wound on a 1.0 cm radius mandrel, the attenuation
due to bending will increase by a factor of about
250,000 to 60 dB, so that only about one millionth of
the original light remains at the end of the fiber.
Just about all of the input light is scattered out of
the core. On the other hand, using the 1.2 cm radius
mandrel and increasing the numerical aperture (N.A.)
to 0.12 reduces these attenuations to 0.16 dB and 1.6
dB, respectively. Therefore, care must be taken in
designing fiberoptic sensors that require bending and
winding of fibers and in specifying fibers for such
applications.
A ray picture of the regular (constant) bend
radius loss mechanfsm is shown in Fig. 2.19.
Assume a
ray is traveling to the right at an angle of o less
than the critical angle ec in the straight fiber sec
-
2-9
-2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12
BEND RADIUS (mm)
Fig. 2.20 The variation of optical power attenuation
rate as a function of bend radius for con-
stant radius bends in typical optical fibers
for various values of constant numerical
apertures (N.A.) using 0.83-micron wave-
length light.
C.H. Bulmer, private communication.
The effect of a microbend on ray propagation
in an optical fiber is shown in Fig. 2.21. A ray pro-
+==2si-
Fig. 2.21 The angle between an incident ray and the
core-cladding interface surface exceeds the
critical angle and therefore total internal
reflection does not occur at the microbend,
allowing part of the ray to leave the core
and enter the cladding.
pagating in the core at less than the critical angle
is totally reflected before it reaches a section of
fiber distorted by a small imperfection. On successive
reflections from the core-cladding interface it is in-
cident at an angle with the interface surface larger
than the critical angle so that some light is transmit-
ted into the cladding. Random distortions such as this,
due to imperfections in the core-cladding interface or
due to bending or tensile forces exerted at scattered
points along the interface surface of the fiber can in-
duce microbends in the core surface that lead to sub-
stantial cumulative losses. Such distortion losses are
usually undesirable and detrimental, for example, when
they arise in fiber cabling operations. on the other
hand, microbending is employed in fiberoptic sensors
as a transduction mechanism, as will be discussed later.
The optical fiber property to be considered
last is velocity dispersion, i.e. , differences in velo-
city among various portions of the light that may be
propagated in the core of a particular fiber. It will
be shown later how dispersion directly affects the be-
havior of specific fiberoptic sensors. For now, the
significance of dispersion will be illustrated in terms
of how it affects pulse broadening and thus limits
bandwidth in fiberoptic data links and other communica-
tion applications.
In the introduction to this chapter, it was
pointed out that one of the aims of the optical-fiber
designer is to design a fiber that will preserve the
information impressed on a beam of light as it propa-
gates through its core. A measure of success in this
regard, as pointed out in the discussion of Fig. 2.2,
Subsection 2.1.1, is how well the width of an indivi-
dual narrow pulse is maintained without broadening.
When a light pulse is injected into a step-index multi-
mode fiber, its energy is divided among several differ-
ent modes. Each mode travels at a particular velocity,
or range of velocities, and thua they may arrive at the
output end of the fiber at different times depending on
their velocity and the length of the path they take.
Obviously this contributes to pulse broadening and, in
fact, this modal dispersion is the major source of pulse
broadening in step-index multimode fibers. This type
of dispersion is reduced substantially in graded-index
multimode fibers in which the various modal propa-
gation times are nearly equal to one another and thus
the various portions of an injected pulse arrive at the
end of the fiber at the same time though their propaga-
tion velocities and paths will differ. In this case,
however, the next lower level of pulse broadening ef-
fects becomes evident. This is the so-called material
or chromatic dispersion that occurs because the velo-
city of an electromagnetic (light) wave is usually a
function of the wavelength in dielectric material. If
an optical source emits a pulse of other than purely
monochromatic (single-wavelength) radiation, the vari-
ous wavelengths preaent will propagate at different
velocities and thus lead to pulse broadening.
The effects of modal and material dispersion
are shown in Fig. 2.22 where the theoretically-predict-
ed dipersion or pulse broadening, expressed in nano-
seconds increase of pulse width for each kilometer of
travel in a fiber, is plotted as a function of numeri-
cal aperture (N.A.) for various operating conditions.
Two types of 0.85 micron nominal wavelength optical
sources are considered. One is an injection laser emit-
ting light with a apectral width (linewidth or varia-
tion of wavelength) of 20 Angstroms. The other is a
light emitting diode (LED) emitting light with a spec-
tral width (linewidth) of 350 Angstroms. When narrow
pulses of light are injected into either graded-index
or step-index fibers, Fig. 2.22 shows that for laser
sources and for numerical apertures less than 0.15, the
predicted broadening is only 0.2 nsec/km for the grad-
ed-index fiber, however, the dispersion is more than 10
nsecfkm for the step-index fiber. This increase is due
to modal diaperaion, because increasing N.A. corres-
ponds to increasing the waveguide V-parameter so that
additional optical modes are allowed. Initially at low
N.A. values with the light emitting diode, material dis-
persion leads to a broadening of approximately 5 nsec
per km in commercially available step-index and grad-
ed-index fibers,
further increases
values.
and then modal dispersion leads to
in step-index fibers at higher N.A.
2-1o
60
40
20
10.C
~8
x
z
6
n
u 4
%
c
62
m
u
u
$
1.0
00.8
06
04
02
0.1
AO = 0.85 pm
LED S1 FIBER
PRACTICAL LED
/
PRACTICAL LASER
GI FIBER
\
I
1 I I I I I I I II I I I I 1 I I I I I I I I I I I
o 0.05 0.10 0.15 0.20 0.25 0.28
NUMERICAL APERTURE
Fig. 2.22 The variation of dispersion in nanoseconds
per kilometer as a function of numerical
aperture (N. A. ) for step-index (S1) and
graded-index (GI) optical fibers driven by
laser or LED optical sources.
After C. Keo and J. Goell, Electronics, 113, Sept.
16, 1976.
The above results also can be expressed in
terms of the bandwidth of the modulation signals that
may be transmitted by fibers. The bandwidth capacities
(bandwidth-length product) currently attainable with
various types of available fibers are summarized as
follows:
Modal-dispersion-limited behavior:
Step-index fibers: 30 MHz-km
Graded-index fibers
Research grade 1000 MHz-km
Production grade 400 MHz-km
Material-dispersion-limited behavior:
Graded-index fibers (0.85 Urn):
LED (350 ~ spectral ~idth) 150 MHz-km
Injection laser (20 A) 2500 MHz-km
The capacities are expressed as the product
of the highest modulating frequency in megahertz that
can be applied (without excess decay) multiplied by the
fiber length in kilometers. Thua, using high quality
graded-index multimode fibers, it is now possible to
send signals with frequency components in excesa of 1
GHz over fiber lengths approaching 1 km, or in excess
of 5 GHz over fiber lengths approximately 200 m, and
so on.
In singlemode fibera, material or chromatic
dispersion IS a significant factor. In silicon oxide
(si02), the main constituent of the core and cladding
of most high-grade glass fibers, the curve of the re-
fractive index as a function of the optical wavelength
has a minimum point at approximately 1.3 microns as
shown in Fig. 2.18. There are two other types of dis-
persion effects that usually occur when singlemode fi-
bers are employed. The first of these is called wave-
guide dispersion which results from the variation in
the propagation constant, B, or wave velocity (phase
velocity), clneff, with changes in the V-parameters,
and thus the wavelength, 1. This was considered earl-
ier in the discussion of Fig. 2.11, but for the present
discussion, it is useful to present the same informa-
tion in another form as follows.
In Fig. 2.23, typical curves of the optical
angular frequency, w, are plotted as functions of the
propagation constant, 6, for a few of the lower-order
allowed modes in a fiber waveguide. This graph shows
cln~
RADIATION
MODE
REGION
- - - -
~
MODE ~
PROPAGATION CONSTANT B
Fig. 2.23 The optical angular frequency, u, as a
tion of the propagation constant, B, for a
few low-order modes for lightwaves propa-
gating in typical optical fiber, showing
the phase and group velocities.
the difference between the phase velocity of a single-
frequency continuous optical beam and the group velo-
city of an optical pulse. The wave velocity (phase
velocity) is defined by the values of the ratio u/fi for
any point on the curves for the allowed modes. These
curves terminate on the straight lines that define the
plane wave phase velocity in the core and cladding
i.e., cfnl and c/n2, respectively.
A narrow impulse of light, by its very nature,
consists of a band of modulating frequencies and the
narrower the pulse, the broader is its modulating fre-
quency spectrum. Light at a wavelength of 1 micron in
a vacuum has a frequency of 3 x 1014 Hz. If it is pulse-
modulated to produce impulaes 0.1 nsec wide, their
bandwidth would exceed 10 GHz (Actually 20 GHz if the
Nyquist criterion is applied). The velocity of propa-
gation of such a pulse would be defined as the velocity
of the maximum of its envelope, referred to as the
group velocity, Vg, which can be shown to be equal to
the slope d~ld~ of the modal curves in Fig. 2.23.
Since the individual frequencies, or wavelengths, mak-
ing up the pulse propagate at different velocities the
pulse tends to broaden and this is the source of the
waveguide dispersion.
Another type of dispersion or velocity varia-
tion that may affect propagation in singlemode fibers
is referred to as polarization dispersion. It has not
been emphasized up to this point, but in fact optical
fibers operating in a so-called singlemode are in fact
at least bimodal. This is due to birefringence, or
2-11
azimuthal dependence of the refractive index, i.e.,
variations of the optical wave velocity, with changes
in the direction of the radial component of the elec-
tric field vector. 7!his will be discussed in more de-
tail later. The concepts are mentioned at this point
because birefringence can be a source of pulse broaden-
ing and related effects in singlemode fiber due to
randomly-induced transitions between different polari-
zation atates.
In cloaing this section on the various pro-
perties of optical fibers, it is appropriate to compare
some of the propagation characteristics of optical fi-
bers with thoae of more conventional waveguide communi-
cation links. This is done in graphical form in Fig.
2.24. Three curves are shown that represent the atten-
uation of radio frequency (RF) signals with bandwidths
in the frequency range from 1 MHz to 1 GHz for various
widely-uaed coaxial cablea. Also shown ia the range of
attenuation rates currently obtained for lightwaves,
propagating in high quality fibers, that are modulated
by signala over the same frequency range. For modula-
tion frequencies above a few megahertz, optical fibera
are far auperior to even the largeat diameter (> 2 cm)
RG/u219 coaxial cable. Signals with a bandwidth up to
1 GHz may be propagated up to fifty kilometers in high-
quality fibera without using repeaters (signal proces-
sors).
2.2 OPTICAL FIBER FABRICATION
It was indicated in Section 2.1, and shown in
Fig. 2.1, that many fibera consist of a core of refrac-
tive index nl; a cylindrical cladding layer of alightly
lower refractive index n2 surrounding the core, and an
outer layer that serves as a protective jacket. It was
1000
500
5
3
2
1
12 5 10 20 50 100200 5001000
MODULATION BANDWIDTH (MHz)+
Fig. 2.24 The variation of attenuation rate as a
function of modulation bandwidth for sever-
al coaxial cables and a fiberoptic cable.
T. Giallorenzi, Proc. IEEE ~, 744 (1978).
alao shown that important parameters of optical fibe~a
~:~)f~~, ~;~rical aperture (N.A.), equal tO (nl -
is, the sine of one-half of the apex
angle of the cone of light that can be injected and
trapped in the core of the fiber; the radius of the
core, which together with the numerical aperture, deter-
mine the modal atructure of the electromagnetic waves
that may propagate in the core; the attenuation coeffi-
cient that determines the rate of the exponential
decay of the core light intensity with increasing dis-
tance of travel within the core; the dispersion (pulse
broadening) that depends on the differences between
the propagation velocities of the various allowed modes
and the variation of the modal velocities with optical
wavelength; and finally the strength of the fiber that
depends on how free from scratches and other imper-
fections the outer surface of the cladding is immedi-
ately after drawing, and on how well the cladding sur-
face is protected during spooling, cabling, and use.
This brief listing of some of the important
parameters of optical fibera emphasizes the need for
precise control of the refractive indices of the core
and cladding.
2.2.1 Refractive Index Profile Control
There are several techniques being uaed by
optical fiber manufacturer for maintaining preciae con-
trol of refractive index profiles and refractive index
differences.
A step-index fiber with a cladding of pure
silica (ailicon oxide, Si02) that has a refractive index
of 1.458 for a lightwave of wavelength of 0.83 ~m and
that has a core of refractive index 1.461, has a numer-
ical aperture of 0.10 as ahown in the following table:
DEPENDENCE OF NUNERICAL APERTURE ON CORE INDEX
SILICA CLADDING n2 = 1.458 (0.83pm)
N.A. = (n12 - n22)1/2
N.A.
1 .:*1 0.10
1.464 0.14
1.469 0.18
1.472 0.20
When the refractive index of the core is increased to
1.472, and the cladding index remains at 1.458, the
numerical aperture increasea from 0.10 to 0.20 and thus
changes the critical acceptance cone apex angle from
11.5 to 23.0. From the above table it may be seen
that the refractive index of the core must be control-
led to about one part in a thousand to obtain a desired
N.A. and hence an appropriate acceptance angle to wfth-
in a few degrees.
The desired refractive index of the core is
usually obtained by adding varioua typea of other
glasaea or dopants, to the pure silica. For example,
suppose that germanium oxide (Ge02) iS added to the
silicon oxide (Si02). The addition of Ge02 to Si02
increases the refractive index of the mixture as ahown
in Fig. 2.25a. The addition of 10 percent, by molec-
ular content, of Ge02 to pure Si02, increases the re-
fractive index from 1.468 to approximately 1.471.
Si02 and Ge02 form glaasy (vitreoua) mater-
ials. They have microscopic molecular structures in
which the moleculea are somewhat randomly distributed
and disoriented rather than arranged in highly-ordered
crystalline-type lattices. They have indefinite solid-
ification temperaturea and behave aa liquida that have
extremely high viscosities. Thus, under ordinary con-
ditions, glaas fiber may be considered as consisting of
super-cooled liquida. The core glaas, as diacussed
above, may be considered as a mixture of two supercool-
ed liquids, Si02 and Ge02. Their molecular density and
thermal expansion coefficient are so closely matched
that in the mixed state their combined structure is re-
2-12
: 1.5
v
GeOz
z
o 0
=1.49
~
u w
~1.48
>
1-
0 v
:1.47
a
L E
:1.46
u
u
,4, ~
10
(a) DoPANT CONCENTRATION
(MOLE PERCENT)
x
P*05
1.49 r
1.48
1.47
1.46
K
1.45 ~
10 20 30
(b) DOPANT CONCENTRATION
(MOLE PERCENT)
<
f
u
5 10 15
K
(c) DOPANT CONCENTRATION
(MOLE PERCENT)
Fig. 2.25 The variation of the refractive index of
silica glass (Si02) as a function of the
concentration of various dopants.
latively strong and free of localized stresses. The
addition of phosphorus pentoxide (P205) to pure silica
glass (Si02) also brings about an increase in refrac-
tive index as shown in Fig. 2.25b. Thus, P205 is fre-
quently employed as a core dopant. On the other hand,
the addition of boron trioxide (B203) to pure silica
(S102) produces a decrease in the refractive index as
shown in Fig. 2.25c. Thus, B203 is employed as a dopant
for cladding glass. The addition of dopants to pure
silica, and to other glasses that are used to make op-
tical fibers, yields the refractive indices required
for the core and cladding, to produce fibers with par-
ticular numerical apertures.
Large numerical apertures allow light from
wide entrance angles (large acceptance angles) to be
accepted into the fiber cores and still maintain total
internal reflection. It was indicated in Section 2.1
that bending losses are lower in fibers of higher N.A. ,
so that when it is necessary to wrap fibers on small
mandrels, in order to make fiberoptic sensors, it again
appears to be desirable to employ fibers with as high
an N.A. as is possible. Unfortunately, the addition
of dopants to either the core or the cladding causes an
increase in the oDtical attenuation, as shown in Fig.
The attenuation versus
.3 EKRADIUS (mm,
EFFECT OFFENDING
bend radius curves that
(b)
NIJ$.4ERICAL WE RTRE
EFFECT OF COMPOSITION
.26 The variation of attenuation in silica Fig. 2.
glass (Si02) optical fibers as a function
of ordinary bend radius, numerical aperture
(N.A.), and type of dopant at a wavelength
of 0.83 pm.
C. H. Bulmer. private communication.
were shown as Fig. 2.12 in Section 2.1 are shown again
in Fig 2.26 together with data that shows the increase
in attenuation observed in fibers with various N.A.lS,
obtained by adding dopants to the Si02 in the core or
cladding. Dopant concentration high enough to produce
numerical apertures of 0.2 or greater cause scattering
and absorption leases in exceas of 10 dB/km, which is
the theoretically predicted bending loss for an 0.2 N.A.
fiber wound on a 3 mm radius mandrel. Thus in this re-
spect, it may be necessary for the fiber designer and
user to optimize the dopant concentration of fibers
specified for a particular application.
2.2.2 Fiber Fabrication Processes
Several different methods are being used to
produce fibers with particular dopant conce~trationa,
gradients, and refractive-index profiles throughout the
core and cladding.
2.2.2.1 The Double-Crucible Process
The most direct method is the double-crucible
proceas. The construction of the furnace portion of a
double-crucible system ia shown in Fig 2.27. The core
cOREF=:G-n l-cMDDNG FEED ROD
R
CLADDING GLASS
INNER CRUCIBLE IBLE
L~
TO FiBER DRAWING
MACHINE WINDING DRUM
Fig. 2.27 The double-crucible process for optical
fiber fabrication.
glass is contained in the inner crucible, usually made
of platinum, while the cladding glass is in the outer
crucible , which is actually a cylindrical shell that
surrounds the inner crucible. The two glasses are
heated in such a way that they begin to flow out of the
orifices at the bottom of the two crucibles as very
highly ViSCOUS liquids. They then are cooled rapidly
to below the solidification temperature almost immedi-
ately after they are combined in the region below the
orifices. The resulting fiber is drawn under control-
led tension so that its outer diameter is held nearly
constant. As the fiber is drawn, the glass in the two
crucibles may be maintained at a conatant level by
slowly feeding rods of core and cladding-type glasses
continuously into the two crucibles.
A simplified overall view of a double-crucible
fiber drawing system is shown in Fig. 2.28. As the
fiber is drawn from the bottom of the furnace it passes
through a non-contacting thickness gage and a feedback
system that controla the rate of rotation of the take-
UP drum to maintain a constant outer diameter of the
cladding. The fiber then passes through a pool of the
jacketing material (or materials) that coats the out-
side of the cladding. The fiber is then dried, cured,
and wound continuously on to the take-up drum.
2-13
n
+
FURNACE
PREFORM
THICKNESS GAGE
- - -
JACKETING UNIT z
P
II
DRYING FURNACE
-----r!l I I
+
6)
TAKEUP DRUM -
~>
Fig. 2.28 The double-crucible optical fiber drawing
system.
In principle, the double-crucible process has
the advantage that it may be used to draw continuous
fibers of any desired length. Unfortunately, because
the core and cladding glasses must be contained and
heated within the crucibles, it is difficult to main-
tain the very high purity levels required to yield the
very low-loss fibers.
A much different procedure for producing ex-
tremely low-losa fibers was developed during the early
and middle 1970a. Though several variations of the
same approach are being used by manufacturer, they
all are based on the production of glass fiber using a
vapor-phase oxidation (VPO) process.
2.2.2.2 The Inside Vapor-Phase Oxidation (IVPO)
Process
The inside vapor-phase oxidation process
(IVPO) is shown in Fig. 2.29. Vapors of various metal
SILICA BAIT TUBE
GeC14
Q
Fig. 2.29
SiCl
4
J.
+== BURNER
H2+02TORCH
MIXING MANIFOLD
AND FLOW
r
CONTROLLER
1
i)
He
The vapor-phase oxidation (VPO) process for
producing optical fiber preforms.
halides are mixed with oxygen and helium to desired
highly-controlled concentration levels and fed into a
hollow silica cylinder (bait tube). The chlorides of
silicon and germanium exist as liquids at atmospheric
pressure and room temperature, while those of phospho-
rus and boron must be stored under high pressure, as
shown in Fig. 2.29. In each case, the halides are in-
troduced into the mixing manifold by means of a vapor
distillation process. For example, high purity oxygen
may be bubbled through the liquid silicon tetrachloride
(SiC14)and germanium tetrachloride (GeC14). This pro-
cess reduces the level of impurities in the halide
vapors that are fed into the reaction tube. Heat is
applied to the outside of the tube using a movable
hydrogen-oxygen torch. This leads to oxidation of the
metal halides, yielding a precipitate of very fine
glass particles (soot) that builds up on the walls of
the bait tube.
The tube is mounted in a glass-working lathe
and continuously rotated during the oxidation process
so that the precipitate deposits uniformly around the
inner circumference of the tube, as shown in Fig. 2.30.
/
BAIT TUBE
REACTANTS
_ SOOT FORMATION_
(METAL HALIDES+ 02)
:)
EXHAUST
u
SINTERED GLASS SOOT DEPOSIT
TRAVERSINiG BURNER
Fig. 2.30 The inside vapor-phase oxidation (IVPO)
process for producing optical fibers.
After P. Schultz, Appl. Opt. Q, 3684 (1979)
The traversing burner not only provides the heat re-
quired to oxidize the various metal halide vapors but
also transforms the porous soot deposit into thin
sintered glass layers that are built up as the burner
slowly traverses back and forth along the length of the
bait tube. By controlling the concentration of the
various reactants fed into the bait tube it ia possible
to build up layers of Si02 glass with any desired level
of doping. These will eventually form the cladding and
the core of fibers that may be drawn from the resulting
glass boule (preform) that is produced in this process.
Several other steps are carried out before
the tube is ready for fiber drawing. These are show
in Fig. 2.31. After the cladding and core glasses are
depoaited, the tube is heated so that under surface
SUSSTRATE
TUBE
CLADDING
DEPOSITED
CORE
DEPOSITED
COLLAPSED
PREFORM
Fig. 2.31
c1
Q+
,- d
FIBER DRAWING
I
@
/
1 ~
/;
SUBSTRATE REMOVED
gjjj/p
FIBER DRAWING
1// THIN LAYER DEPOSITED
, //
o
c?
(3
u
FIBER ORAWING
Stages in the processing of preforms in
production of optical fibers.
the
2-14
tension it collapses to eliminate the remaining center
hole. In order to obtain various desired physical pro-
perties, fibers can be drawn either without removing
the substrate tube, after removing the substrate tube,
or after a final layer of glass haa been deposited on
the outside of the collapsed preform, as shown in Fig.
2.31.
In the drawing process, the boule is placed
in an induction furnace and fibers are drawn and coated
in almost exactly the same manner as in the double-cru-
cible technique that was shown in Fig. 2.28.
2.2.2.3 The Outside Vapor-Phase Oxidation (OVPO)
Process
Preforms also are made by precipitating soot
on the outside of a rod that is turned in a glaas-work-
ing lathe, as shown in Fig. 2.32a. In the outside vapor
(a) SOOT DEPOSITION
g+ww
4....
o:,::.#.:~C:DING
>0
INDEX n
(b) PREFORM SISTERING (c) FISER DRAWING
Fig. 2.32 The outside vapor-phase oxidation (OVPO)
process for producing optical fibers.
After P. Schultz, Appl. Opt. l&, 3684 (1979).
phase oxidation (OVPO) process, the core material is
deposited first and then the cladding is deposited on
the outside, just in the IVPO process described earlier.
The amount of doping may be continuously varied during
the core material deposition process. It is thus poa-
sible to produce preforms for graded-index fibers, as
well as for step-index fibers, as shown in the example
of refractive index versus radial displacement curve at
the extreme upper right in Fig. 2.32. The refractive
index of the porous material deposited on the center
bait rod decreases monotonically out to what will cor-
respond to the core-cladding interface, and then it
remains constant to the outer surface of the porous
cylindrical shell.
Thus, preform fabrication by the OVPO process
is a multistage procedure, including center bait rod
removal, followed by porous preform sintering and the
collapsing of the central hole, either prior to or dur-
ing the fiber drawing process. Aa in the IVPO process,
the deposition process is carried out on a glass-work-
ing lathe. Thus, the preforms produced by both proces-
ses have a limited size so that usually fiber lengths
from 10 to 20 kilometers may be drawn from a single
preform.
2.2.2.4 The Vapor Axial Deposition (VAD) Process
Length limitations are overcome in the vapor
axial deposition (VAD) process that is ahown in Fig.
2.33. Core and cladding glass particles ejected from
oxygen-hydrogen burners are deposited longitudinally
and radially on to the end of a silica rod. By care-
fully controlling the concentration of the metal halides
fed to the burners, a porous preform with the desired
radial variation of refractive index is built up, be-
ginning at the end of the silica rod. The rod is slowly
pulled vertically upward as deposition continues at a
constant rate at the lower end of the porous preform.
The porous section then passes through a concentric
heater ring that collapses and sinters the porous sec-
tion to form a clear glass rod with the desired radial
refractive index profile. The entire process is car-
ried out inaide a reaction chamber with a carefully con-
trolled inert atmosphere to reduce the level of impuri-
ties. The VAD process permits the production of large
preforms capable of yielding single pieces of fiber
over 100 km long. The optical quality of current VAD
fibers is very high. Data on attenuation rates versus
wavelength for VAD and IVPO fibers is shown in Fig.
2.34. The IVPO process produces a fiber with a rela-
tively large attenuation rates peak at 1.4 pm and small-
er peaks in the vicinity of 1.23 pm and 0.94 Um. These
are due to the vibrational mode absorption lines of the
OH- radical. In the VAD process, the OH- radical con-
tamination is reduced substantially by careful drying
during the preform fabrication process thus eliminating
these attenuation peaks.
-..
}!
( ;=> STARTING SILICA ROD
T
f--l
I I
TRANSPARENT PREFORM
$!!$
. - -.
--
CARBONHEATER
.,.. .,,,,,,.,,,
..-=-, =..
1 I
l..
t POROIJS PREFORM
I :
+ I
,..
I
& ~~
% ~%-.+
\
FINE GLASS PARTICLES
QOxy-HyDROGEN BURNERS
SiC14+BBr3
SiC14+GeC14+PC13
Fig. 2.33 The vapor axial deposition (VAD) process
for producing optical fibers.
After P. Schultz, Appl. Opt. l&, 3684 (19791
0.8 1.0 12 1,4 1.6 1.8
WAVELENGTH (pm)
Fig. 2.34 The variation of attenuation as a function
of wavelength in optical fibers produced by
the vapor axial deposition (VAD) and the
inside vapor-phase oxidation (IVPO) proces-
ses.
2-15
2.2.3 Fiber Strength
The operational and shelf-life of fiberoptic
sensors will depend to a large extent on the mechanical
strength of the glass fibers used in them. In a cer-
tain way, glass fiber is much atronger than steel.
Short, pristine silica fibers, immediately after draw-
ing, have elastic limits, and ultimate and breaking
tensile strengths, greatly exceeding that of steel
wires. Stress-strain curves for priatine silica fiber
and steel wire are shown in Fig. 2.35. The elaatic
100
- 109
E
~
$ 108
w
u
G
107
106
FIBER
WIRE
104 103 102 10 10
STRAIN
Fig. 2.35 Stresa versus strain curves for steel wire
and pristine silica (Si02) fiber under ideal
conditions.
limit of steel typically uaed in wire is about 0.2 x
10-9 Newtons/m2 at a atress of about 0.1 percent. Steel
wires tend to break at strains of the order 0.5 percent
and a stress of about 1.5x109 N/m2. On the other hand,
unscratched fibers remain elastic to strains in excess
of 10 percent, corresponding to stresses of about 5 x
109 Newtona
per square meter. However, unlike steel,
which may be made malleable and capable of flow-healing
small surface cracks, glass is brittle. Thus, very fine
cracks in glass fibers tend to become stress concentra-
tion centers that propagate transversely across the fi-
ber. They lead to exceasive strain and ultimately to
complete rupture.
A length of fiber is only as strong as its
weakest section. Under constant tension a length of
fiber will tend to break at its weakest point.
The
break will most likely occur where there is a scratch
on the outer surface of the fiber. A long length of
fiber ia more likely to have a weakest point that is
weaker than the weakest point of a short length of
fiber. Thus, fiber strength determination is a procesa
of collecting statistics of failure. This is illus-
trated by the reaults of a seriea of tests performed on
a group of test samples, each 60 cm long, cut from sec-
tions distributed uniformly along a 1 km length of fi-
ber. Each sample was streased to rupture in a tension
test machine. The percentages of the total number of
specimens that failed below a given stress level are
shown as a function of the breaking stress in Fig. 2.36.
Fig.
1 I I 1 ! , ( ! , , ,
99 - *# .:
./
80 -
./
60 -
~ 40 -
/
u
m
3
~ 20
GAGE LENGTH= 60cm
if
8 -
4
1 , I I , [
0.5 0.8 10 2.0 3.0 4.0
TENSILE STRENGTH (GN/m2)
2.36 The percentage of optical fiber specimena
that failed as a function of breaking ten-
aile strength.
From the graph it may be seen that the first apecimen
broke at approximately 0.5 x 109 N/m2, approximate 10
J
percent of the specimens broke at 0.8 x 109 N/m or
leas another 10% broke at atresses between 0.8 and 1.0
4
x 10 N/m2, and so forth. A few of the s eclmens, how-
ever,
%
withstood stresses of 4.0 x 109 N/m before break-
ing.
From a practical, application-oriented view-
point, it is the weakest point in a length of fiber
that determines ita overall strength. Thus, in spec-
ifying fibers for a given application,
the maximum
streas or strain to be encountered ahould be determined
and the entire length of fiber to be employed should
be pre-tested at some acceptable safety margin above
this level. Such testing is usually done by reeling
the fiber from one spool to another at a fixed rate,
while maintaining the interreel section under the fixed
specified stress (tension).
There is evidence that preform preparation
and treatment, as well aa the manner in which fibers
are handled after they are drawn, contribute substan-
tially to their overall atrength. Data on the breaking
or tensile strength of a particular type of fiber drawn
from identically produced preforms is shown in the bar-
graph in Fig. 2.37. In the upper portion of Fig. 2.37,
the number of specimens versus breaking strength ia
plotted for 40 specimens taken from a length of fiber
drawn from an ordinarily prepared preform that was
heated as usual in an RF induction furnace. As indi-
cated, the breaking strengths ranged from approximately
0.50 x 109 N/m2 to 5.5 N/m2 with a maximumof 12 speci-
4
mena that broke at 3.0 x 10 N/m2. Results are presented
in the center aection of Fig. 2.37 on 46 specimens from
a length of fiber drawn, using the RF induction fur-
nace, from a preform that had been fire-polished prior
to drawing in an effort to eliminate any fine cracks
(microcracks) and other imperfections that might have
existed in its outer surface. In this caae, the first
specimen to break withstood stresses up to 1.8 x 109
N/m2 and 36 of the specimens broke at a stress exceed-
ing 3.8 x 102 N/m2. In the third case, as ahown in the
lower portion of Fig. 2.37, 42 specimens were tested
from a fiber that waa drawn using an infrared laser to
heat the preform, that also had been fire polished
prior to drawing. All of the specimens withstood ten-
sile atresses up to 4.0 x 109 N/m2 before breaking.
However, instead of being distributed over a very wide
range of breaking tensile strengths, the breaking points
were all in the range from 4.0 to 5.25 x 109 N/m2.
2-16
NO FIRE POLISH
N = 40
:
FURNACE FIRE POLISH ~
N = 46 ;
b
m
LASER FIRE POLISH :
N = 42 ~
z
MAXI MUM TENSI LE STRENGTH (GN/m2 = lo
g
N/m2)
10
5
:L_.dJu
o 200 400 600 800 1,000
MAXIMUM TENSILE STRESS (KPSI)
Fig. 2.37 The variation of maximum tension stress of
a number of optical fibers for unpolished,
furnace polished, and laser polished fibers
showing the number of fibers that failed at
the various stress levels in total tested
for each polishing condition.
These results clearly indicate how important it ia to
carefully prepare the preforms and to accurately control
the drawing process in order to maintain the strength
of the final drawn fibers and thus get as cloae as pos-
sible to the ideal strength of silica glass.
2.3 SOLID STATE FIBEROPTIC LIGHT SOURCES
Solid state optical sources and detectors
utilized in compact fiberoptic sensors will be discus-
sed in this section. This information will serve as a
background for understanding later discusaiona of sen-
sor noise and packaging. In order to understand the
trade-offs required, a knowledge of light production
mechanisms and fabrication processes is helpful.
Finally, such information is important for estimating
what is likely to be available in the future.
2.3.1 Energy Levels In Semiconductors
Electrons in free atoms are normally tightly
bound in discrete energy levels. When the atoms are
located in a crystalline structure these discrete
energy levels are replaced by energy bands. Some of
the electrons remain tightly bound to the atom while
other, more energetic electrons, have energies corres-
ponding to the valence or conduction bands. Those in
the valence band are atill localized at individual atoms
but have the highest energy of such bound electrons,
while electrons in the conduction band are free to move
throughout the crystal. Materials can be divided into
a number of classes depending on the energy gap (separ-
ation between the top energy level of the valence and
the bottom energy level of the conduction band) and
upon the number of electrons, if any, in the conduction
band and lack of electrons in the valence band as shown
in Fig. 2.38. Electrons cannot possess energies that
lie in the gap.
In an insulator the valence and conduction
energy bands are separated by a wide energy gap. If
the gaps in Fig. 2.38 were drawn to scale, the gap
between the valence and conduction bands of the insu-
lator would be much wider than that of the other mater-
ials. The conduction band in insulators is normally
devoid of electrons while the valence band is filled.
Therefore, when an electric field is applied across
INSULATOR CONDUCTOR
1~
; ~zNDucToNNE~
K
Lu BAND-GAP EG
6
VALENCE BAND
P-TYPE SEMICONDUCTOR N-TYPE SEMICONDUCTOR
I 1 I 1
I 1
DONOR LEVEL
I a. a. * a.
I
ACCEPTOR LEVEL
Fig . 2.38 Energy band diagrams in which the cross-
hatching symbolizes that there are many
electrons in the various energy bands for
various types of materials.
the insulator, no current flows. If sufficiently high
temperatures are applied (thousands of degrees) it is
possible to excite some of the electrons with valence
band energies up to the energy level of the conduction
band. At such an elevated temperature, insulators be-
come conductors with conduct ivities that increase with
temperature. Electrical conductors, such as metals,
consist of materials in which electrons fill the val-
ence band and about half the conduction band. In this
case when an electric field is applied the electrona
move through the crystal easily and the material is
referred to as a conductor. In metals an increaae in
temperature increases lattice vibrations and electron
scattering, therefore the conductivity decreases with
increasing temperature. Materials with properties be-
tween insulators and conductors are known as semicon-
ductors. Semiconductors are similar to insulators in
that the valence band is filled and the conduction band
is empty. However, the energy gap separating the con-
duction and valence bands is much smaller than that of
insulators. For such semiconductors, thermal energy
can excite a few electrons from the valence to the con-
duction band. Such materials are known as intrinaic
semiconductors. Their conductivity increases with in-
creasing temperature. By doping these materials with
certain impurities, it is possible to greatly increase
the number of carriers and increase the conductivity.
If the dopant has carriers with an energy level that
lies in the band gap just slightly below the conduction
band, then thermal motions can readily excite electrona
from these impurities (or dopants) into the conduction
band where they are free to move through the crystal
causing the material to become more conductive. Such
dopants are known as donors and the resultant materials
are known as negative or n-type semiconductors due to
the fact that the carriers are electrons. Galium arse-
nide (GaAs) crystalline materials are important as room-
temperature light-emitting diodes (LEDs) and diode (or
injection) lasers. In these materials, tin and tellur-
ium serve as dopants that contribute (or donate) elec-
trons to the conduction band while germanium (an accep-
tor impurity) introduces trapping sites with energy
levels slightly above the valence band in the band gap
itself. In the case of an acceptor, thermal motions
will provide sufficient energy to permit electrons from
the valence band to be trapped by an acceptor impurity
atom. The holes left behind in the valence band act
as positive conductors. These materials are known as
p-type semiconductors.
An important semiconductor energy state is
2-17
shown in Fig. 2.39. This state is known as the popula-
tion inversion state. It corresponds to the condition
in which holes exist in the valence band and electrons
exist in the conduction band simultaneously. This
leads to the production of photons. The energy gap is
indicated by E in Fig. 2.39. When electrons from the
conduction ban~ lose some of their energy and drop down
T
CONDUCTION
BAND
+
BAND-GAP,EG
Q
Fc
hv
Fc= CONDUCTION SANO
ENERGY LEVEL
SPONTANEOUS: h.=EG
STIMULATED: tWCEFc
PHOTONS AMPLIFY
THEMSELVES
FERMI
EFV
Fig. 2.39 Electrons (cross-hatch) from the valence
band are stimulated to the energy level of
the conduction band in a population inver-
sion situation. Their return to the valence
band causes the emission of photons.
into the valence band they recombine with holes and
photons are produced. This process is known as recom-
bination. In the desired case, the energy is given up
entirely in the form of photons. If this process oc-
curs spontaneously, the energy of the emitted photon
iS approximately equal to the band gap energy, Eg. The
photons produced travel in random directions. On the
other hand, if sufficient density of photons exist in
the recombination region both spontaneous emission (or
recombination) and stimulated recombination occur. The
stimulated photons that are produced travel in the same
direction as the primary photons. In the latter case
the photon energy is less than the difference between
the Fermi energy level in the conduction band, EFc, and
the Fermi level in the valence band, EFV. These condi-
tions, spontaneous and stimulated emission, are neces-
sary for the proper operation of light emitting diodes
(LEDS) and diode lasers, respectively. In order to
understand how LEDs or diode lasers can be produced
and operate in practice, consider the condition at a
p-n junction as shown in Fig. 2.40. In this case, GaAs
}
&
1%
z
w
-
CONDUCTION BAND
I
1
,
,
I
is doped with an acceptor material on one side of the
junction, resulting in a p-type semiconductor region,
and with a donor material on the other side, resulting
in an n-type semiconductor region. The spatial separa-
tion between the p- and n-type regions is known as the
p-n junction. The electron energy levels in the con-
duction and valence bands are as shown in the upper
part of Fig. 2.40. Notice that when a bias voltage is
not applied, as on the left, a population inversion
does not occur. Electrons from the valence band of the
p-type region flow into the conduction band of the n-
type region until the electron energy levels on each
side of the p-n junction are equal, then essentially no
more electrons flow across the junction. The energy
level difference across the junction constitutes a bar-
rier to further current flow. If a forward bias volt-
age is applied, as shown on the right of Fig. 2.40,
electrons are forced or injected into the n-type region
and holes are formed in the p-type region. When the
energy level of a sufficient number of electrons are
raised to the energy level of the conduction band, their
electron energy level exceeds the barrier energy and
electrons flow across the junction into the p-region.
More detail is shown in Fig. 2.41. In the population
RECOMBINATION
l-REGlON*HOMOJuNcTlON
!
4, hv
r
Fv
L
cc
1,1
I
.1 I I ~
VG= EG/e
FORWARD BIAS
Fig. 2.41 The various regions and energy levels at a
forward-biased p-n junction of a semicon-
ductor diode.
inversion region, just on the left of the p-n junction,
electrons can spontaneously recombine with holes pro-
ducing photons. Since in this region there is a finite
lifetime for the electrons depending upon the average
time it takes for such recombination to occur (typical-
ly 3 to 5 ns), the inversion region is restricted in
spatial extent as shown in Fig. 2.41. In this case the
I
junction is known as a homojunction and under proper
conditions may be used to fabricate a homojunction LED
or diode laser.
, 1 I
m
P N
4
P-N JUNCTION
Fig. 2.40 The
1:~~
energy levels in a p-n junction.
Current density is directly proportional to
the thickness of the recombination layer. Therefore,
in order to reduce the current it is important to re-
duce the thickness of the recombination layer. This can
be accomplished in a gallium arsenide (GaAs) crystal by
the use of layers alloyed with varying amounts of alum-
inum (Al). The substitution of aluminum (Al. ) for gal-
lium (Ga) occurs with little or no distortion of the
crystal lattice. The energy gap plotted against the
fraction of aluminum that replaces an equal fraction
of gallium ( Ga) , forming gallium aluminum arsenide
(GaAIAs) is shown in Fig. 2.42. For up to 37% Al sub-
stituted for Ga, the energy gap increaaes from 1.43
electron-volts to 1.92 electron-volts. This is approxi-
2-18
mately a 0.5 electron-volt increase. For fractional
parts of Al greater than 0.37, i.e., x > 0.37, mechan-
isms in addition to simple photon production occur dur-
ing recombination with the result that not all of the
energy goes into producing photons, part of it goes in-
to thermal energy with the possibility of crystal dam-
age and a reduced tendency for lasing. The wavelength
can be obtained from the photon energy relation E
t
= hf
and from the wavelength-frequency-velocity relation ~f=
= c/n, from which the relation 1 = hc/nEt is obtained,
where h is Plancks constant, c is the velocity of light
in a vacuum, n is the refractive index taken as unity,
and E
t
is the energy lost by a particle. For a parti-
cle with a charge of one electron that loses energy
equal to the gap energy, A = 1.24/Eg, where h is the
wavelength in microns and Eg is the gap energy in elec-
tron-volts. Thus for GaAs, 1 = 0.90 micron and for 37%
Al, 1 = 0.64 micron. Longer wavelength lasers (1.1
micron to 1.6 micron) can be produced by using the
quarternary alloy iridium-gallium-arsenic-phosphorous
(InGaAsP).
~ :;v:;:N:;GAp<2ev
b:
G FOR X>0.37COMPETING
9 /.
~
,-
PROCESSES OCCUR MAKING
/-
m2.O
u
...
ONSET OF LASING LESS
..0 PROBABLE
n-
a
>
0
AIXGal.XAs
G FOR X INCREASING FROM
%
OT00.37 THE REFRACTIVE
z
300K
INDEX DECREASES BY 5%
u.1 15
[ 1111111111
o 0.5 1.0
GaAs x AIAs
Fig. 2.42 The band-gap energy level versus aluminum
galium arsenide composition (AIXGA(l-X)AS).
Another important effect is that as the frac-
tional part of Al, x, increases from zero to 0.37 the
refractive index decreases by 5%. Thus, as x in-
creases, the energy gap increases and the refractive
index decreases. The energy gap increases by almost
30% and the refractive index by about 5%.
The energy band structure for a crystal in
which a higher concentration of aluminum in two regions
sandwich a third region of lower aluminum content be-
tween them is shown in Fig. 2.43. The corresponding
crystal structure can be formed by a number of proces-
ses one of which is the liquid-phase epitaxial growth
process. Epitaxial growth is the growth of a crystal
from the surface. For the case of interest the follow-
ing is a highly simplified description. The process
begins with a crystal of gallium arsenide (GaAs), one
surface of which is put in contact with a high tempera-
ture solution of gallium aluminum arsenide (GaAIAs).
The crystal is maintained at a slightly lower tempera-
ture than the liquid and crystal growth occurs from the
surface. Once the proper thickness of this particular
composition has been achieved, the crystal is removed
from the bath and put in contact with another liquid
having the composition corresponding to that of the
next layer. A crystal results with a p-type and an n-
type layer, each of which have a higher aluminum con-
tent, larger energy gap, and lower refractive index,
1 P,
A
P
~
qi -N
I
I
I
I
I
1 1
1
++++++++++++++++++++++++++
1
Gal.xA~As:Ge ,~Ga
l-y AyAs ~
Gal_xAlxAs:Sn/Te
I
Ge
S;;Te
Fig. 2.43 The energy levels of a semiconductor for-
ward-biased double heterostructure laser in
a junction of lower concentration alumlnum
surrounded by higher concentration alumi-
num.
and between which is a recombination layer with lower
aluminum content, smaller energy gap, and higher re-
fractive index. The amount of aluminum in the recom-
bination layer determines the wavelength of the light
emitted. In this manner the structure corresponding to
the energy diagram shown in Fig. 2.43 can be formed. By
this process the recombination layer can be made thin,
often as small as a few tenths of a micron. The long-
er-wavelength quarternary InGaAsP alloys are produced
by liquid-phase epitaxial growth on an iridium phospho-
rus (InP) substrate.
The recombination layer has lower aluminum
content and therefore, a smaller energy gap, while the
layers on each side have greater aluminum content and
a resulting larger energy gap. In this case, when an
electrical bias is applied, electrons are introduced
from the n-type layer into the recombination layer.
Recombination occur overwhelmingly more often in the
layer with the lowest energy gap.
2.3.2 Light Emitting Diodes (LEDs) and Diode
Lasers
The use of crystal structures to fabricate
either an LED or a diode laser is shown in Fig. 2.44.
Electrons are introduced into the bottom of the crystal
and holes are introduced into the top. In the recom-
bination layer, holes and electrons recombine to form
photons that tend to move outward in all directions as
shown on the left of Fig. 2.44. In this case, the device
behaves as an LED. The light, emitted in all direc-
tions, results from spontaneous emission.
In order to produce a laser it is necessary
to confine and guide the emitted light. This increases
the light intensity to the level where stimulated emis-
sion occurs. This is accomplished in the following
way. The recombination layer has less aluminum there-
fore it has the lower energy gap and recombination oc-
curs here. The use of some aluminum in the recombina-
tion layer allows the wavelength to be adjusted but in
addition it reduces the probability of crystal damage.
Furthermore, the layer with the smallest energy gap
also has the highest refractive index. Thus, a higher
refractive index layer is sandwiched between two layers
of lower refractive index. This is exactly the situa-
tion that leads to lightwave trapping in optical fibers.
Similarly for the structure shown on the right in Fig.
2.44, photons tend to be reflected from the lower re-
fractive index surface back into the higher-refractive-
index recombination layer. Photons are retained in the
2-19
LED
SPONTANEOUS RADIATON
\
WOTO
hu=Eg
LASER
STIMULATEDRADIATION
m
Fig. 2.44 The structure of a light emitting diode
(LED) and a diode laser showing radiation
of photons from recombination.
recombination region for a longer period of time by the
partially reflecting mirrors that are in effect formed
at the cleaved ends by the difference in refractive in-
dex between the crystal and air, as shown on the right
in Fig. 2.44. Thus, photons formed in the recombina-
tion layer tend to reflect back and forth a number of
times. In this process, the light intensity is increas-
ed in the recombination region. When the light inten-
sity becomes sufficiently high, stimulated emission be-
gins. This is the condition for lasing. When the num-
ber of energy gains matches the number of energy losses,
for every photon that escapes one or more is formed
within the recombination layer, thus resulting in an
everincreasing recombination rate and photon produc-
tion. Ultimately, equilibrium is reached and the number
of photons being emitted (radiated) from the ends equals
the number of photons being produced. The requirement
for this to occur is that both carriers (electrons and
holes) and radiation (photons) tend to be confined to
the recombination layer. The carrier confinement re-
sults in the required population inversion. This in-
sures that electron-hole recombination and the result-
ing photona will occur in the recombination layer. The
higher refractive index in the recombination layer and
the effectively partially-mirrored ends reflect or
guide the photons back into the layer thus increasing
the light intensity by several orders of magnitude
above that of spontaneous emission.
The emitted optical power versus applied di-
rect current is shown in Fig. 2.45. The emitted opti-
cal power initially increases linearly with current.
This is the region where spontaneous emission dominates.
Once a sufficiently high photon intensity level is
reached, stimulated emission begins to dominate and the
emitted optical power increases sharply as shown in Fig.
2.45. The spontaneous emission portion of the curve is
relatively temperature independent compared to the
stimulated emission portion. The electrical current
level corresponding to the onset of stimulated emission
increases with increasing temperature, however the slope
of the stimulated emission curve remains approximately
constant, as shown by the T1 and T2 curves in Fig. 2.45.
Thus, diode lasers are mounted on heat sinks and may
require temperature control devices and feedback cir-
cuitry to control the light intensity. LEDa operate
by spontaneous emission and do not require such tempera-
ture compensation. If one extrapolates backward the
steeply riaing stimulated emisaion region of the curve,
the intersection with the current axis, known as the
threshold current, is temperature dependent. In the case
shown in Fig. 2.45, the threshold current is approxi-
mately 360 ma at temperature T1. Currently, diode lasers
exhibit threshold currents in the range of 20 to 200 ma.
The solid curve shows the optical power emitted versus
current and the superimposed dots indicate repeated
measurements taken after 8000 hours. As can be seen,
no essential change in laser characteristics occurred.
The operational lifetimes of currently manufactured
diode lasers are as long as 106 hours.
4 -
2 -
SPONTANEOUS
0
T2>T1
0 100 200 300 400 500
DIRECT CURRENT (mA)
Fig. 2.45 The optical power emitted by a diode laser
as a function of applied electrical current.
Diode lasers produced in the manner described
above are known as double heterojunction lasers. The
characteristics of such a laser are shown in Fig. 2.46.
The refractive index is plotted on the left and the
band gap energy is plotted on the right, both relative
to the layera of the laser. The refractive index and
energy gap both undergo step-function changes at the
edges of the recombination layer. Other fabrication
characteristics of the diode laser include the partial-
ly-mirrored ends and the electrical contacts parallel
to the recombination layer. Holes and electrons are
injected into the recombination region. Optical energy
is distributed across the recombination
approximate Gaussian distribution shown
)
INDEX
n
Fig.
laver the
2.46 A double-heterojunction
The smaller the volume of the
lower the reauired threshold
layer in the
in Fig. 2.46.
<
Eg=O.3eV
S~GAP
ENERGY
laser.
recombination
current. As
previously stated. recombination layers in double
~eterojun~tion diode lasers are as thin as several
tenths of a micron. However, the layer shown in Fig.
2.46 extends across the entire crystal. With a recom-
bination layer this wide, the onset of lasing does not
occur uniformly throughout the layer. Lasing can start
2-20
in one portion of the recombination layer but not in
another. Lhis is known as filamentary lasing. Such
lasing behavior tends to produce noise. If the width
of the layer is less than 10 microns, it is too narrow
for such filamentary behavior to occur and when lasing
does begin it occura uniformly throughout the layer.
Furthermore, when the width is less than 15 microns
singlemode propagation usually occurs. Finally, the
less the width of the recombination layer the less the
required threshold current. Double-heterojunction diode
lasers with threshold currents as low as 20 ma have
been produced. However, trade-offs may be required.
For example, reducing the recombination layer width
also reduces the maximum safe photon intensity. A safe
cw optical power output that can be maintained without
danger of facet damage is approximately 1 mW for each
micron of recombination layer width. Thus, a laser with
a recombination layer 10 microns wide can produce 10 mW
of optical power safely.
A striped-geometry injection laser diode,
such as that shown in Fig. 2.47, has the desired thin
and narrow recombination region. With this geometry,
the emitted light spreads out in the vertical direction
by as much 50 and in the horizontal by 8 or more.
The dimensions of the recombination layer are of the
order of 0.3 microns thick, 10 microns wide, and Up to
500 microns long. These dimensions and light spreading
angles must be taken into account when the laser is
coupled to an optical fiber or substrate.
-4 l-+=
Fig. 2.47 A GsAs-GcAIAs geometry CW injection laser
diode.
The distribution of optical energy across the
lasing region is shown in Fig. 2.48. The fundamental
and second harmonic of the longitudinal modes are shown.
In the longitudinal fundamental mode, the energy tends
to be concentrated more heavily towards the center, and
tapers off towards the edges in a Gaussian distribution
curve. If this lasing region is sufficiently wide, the
second harmonic mode can occur and the emitted optical
energy is concentrated in two regions.
Several techniques have been employed to fab-
ricate such stripe geometry. Some of these are shown
in Fig. 2.49. The upper left (a), an oxide protective
stripe is shown between the metal contact and the cry-
stal. The stripe is formed where the oxide layer is
omitted in the center. Electrons tend to be injected
into this region only. In this case, the current can
spread out underneath the oxide layer where it is not
confined. Another technique, shown at the lower left
(b), reduces such current spreading by increasing the
resistivity in the regions on each side of the stripe.
This can be accomplished by photon bombardment that
UDINAL (q)
FUNDAMENTAL MODE
{ (!:;)
~
,-I 2ndMODE
,
,,, (m::)
DISTANCE
I
u 1
TRANSVERSE
Y
(m)
E LATERAL(s)
Fig. 2.48 The light intensity as a function of dis-
tance across the face of a laser for the
fundamental and second lightwave modes gen-
erated by a laser.
METAL CONTACT
-
P
(a) STRIPE CONTACT
METAL CONTACT
II(Zn-DIFFUSED)
)
/[n
P
N
P
euBsTRATE
(c) DOPING-PROFILE
METAL ~ONTACT
PROTON
METAL CONTACT
SOMSARDED
(SEMI t+SULATING)
P
(b) PROTON-BOMBARDMENT (d) STRIPE MESA
Fig. 2.49 End views of various stripe geometry diode
lasers.
produces a semi-insulating layer on each side of the
stripe. A third technique, shown at the upper right
(c), uses the diffusion of a dopant, such as zinc, into
the stripe region to significantly lower the resisti-
Vity. Finally, almost complete electric current con-
f inement occurs in the structure shown at the lower
right, (d). A stripe mesa (plateau or table) such as
this is formed during the process of growing the cry-
stal. Often such a mesa is buried by depositing addi-
tional material over it.
For diode laser operation one major concern
has been the reduction of the spontaneous emission re-
gion that was shown in Fig. 2.49. However, spontaneous
emission is the mechanism responsible for light emis-
sion in LEDs. These devices are cheaper. Simpler
construction techniques may be used. The light they
produce is not coherent and is emitted over a much
wider angle (approximately 180 ) with the result that
less optical power may be coupled into a fiber. On
the other hand, the spontaneous emission portion of
the optical output power versus input direct current
curve is far less temperature dependent than the stimu-
lated emission region. Thus , because LEDs are less
temperature dependent than diode lasers, temperature
control and optical feedback problems are reduced.
2-21
LEDs are fabricated both as edge and surface
emitters. An example of surface emission is shown in
Fig. 2.50. A well is etched in the substrate to within
FIBER
EPOXY=
d
GE~
SUBSTRATE
ELECTRICAL
N
CONTACT
N RECOMBINATION
LAYER (N OR P)
INSULATING
/
LAYER
Fig. 2.50 A surface-emitting LED with an etched well.
approximately 1 micron of the recombination layer. This
puts the surface close to the recombination layer and
reduces the tendency for the light generated in the re-
combination layer to be reabsorbed before it can escape
from the crystal. The optical fiber into which the
light is being coupled is epoxied to the LED is also
shown. This arrangement is satisfactory for a multi-
mode optical fiber but, for coupling into singlemode
fiber, edge emitters mounted in the same manner as
diode lasers are more desirable. The waveguide char-
acter of the heterojunction structure leads to improved
coupling efficiency and greater directionality, that
is, it confines the emitted light to a narrower beam.
In this case, the ends are cleaved at an angle several
degrees from the normal to the surface of the recombin-
ation region in order to breakup optical standing waves
and thus extend the region of spontaneous emission.
In the discussion so far, the production of
photons by electron-hole recombination has been consid-
ered. The reverse can also occur. A photon can be ab-
sorbed and thus produce an electron-hole pair. This
phenomenon occurs in photodetectors and will be consid-
ered next.
2.4 PHOTODETECTORS
The simpleat type of photodiode is the homo-
junction or p-n diode as shown in Fig. 2.51. The most
1
>DEpLET10t4 REGloN
L-
1-
ABSORPTION
REGION -1
Fig. 2.51 The electric field and regions of a p-n
(homojunction) photodiode with bias supply.
successful photodetectors employ silicon ( Si ) although
galium arsenide (GaAs) is sometimes used. When the
device is reverse (back) biased as shown, the electric
field is not uniform. It peaks around the p-n junction
as shown the bottom of Fig. 2.51. Thus , electron-hole
pairs formed by the absorption of photons in this re-
gion are swept away (depleted) , electrons going to the
n side and holes to the p side. This region of in-
creased electric field is known as the depletion re-
gion. AS shown, the depletion and absorption regions
do not necessarily coincide, the absorption region
tending to be larger. Electron-hole pairs, formed by
the absorption of photons from the depletion region,
randomly diffuse, often recombining to produce photons.
A depletion region may exist even without a reverse
(back) bias, but then it is narrow. However, there
are circumstances where unbiased operation is impor-
tant, such as for low electrical power operation. Also
with a bias, a dark field current (dark photocurrent)
flows due to thermally generated electron-hole pairs
even in the absence of light. Removing the reverse
(back) bias eliminates the dark field current. Opera-
tion with zero bias that is, without a bias supply, is
known as photovoltaic operation.
In order to make the depletion region as
large, or larger than, the absorption region, the ar-
rangement shown in Fig. 2.52 is used. Here a wide re-
P-REGION
FDEPLETIONREGIONfi
N-REGION
3~
LIGHT INTRINSIC REGION
b G
lABSORPTION~
OUTPUT
REGION
R
1-,1~1
BIAS SUPPLY
Fig . 2.52 A pos i t i v e - i nt r i ns i c - ne ga t i v e (PIN) photo-
diode with bias supply.
gion with little or no dopant is placed between heavily
doped n-type and p-type regions on opposite ends. An
undoped semiconductor is referred to as an intrinsic
semiconductor, therefore the broad lightly-doped region
is called the intrinsic or i-type region, or simply the
i-region. Such photodiodes are known as poaitive-in-
trinsic-negative or PIN diodes. The corresponding elec-
tric potential curve is also shown in Fig. 2.52. The
highly doped n- and p-type regions at each end have low
resistivity and therefore make good electrical contact.
The resistivity of the i-region is often so high that
even without a reverse (back) bias the depletion region
extends half way through the i-region. The voltage re-
quired to extend the depletion region completely through
the i-region ia called the punchthrough voltage.
When considering fiberoptic microbend sen-
sors, reference will be made to dark field operation.
A current exists in a reverse-biased photodiode even
with no incident light. This current is called the
dark field current and results from the thermally gen-
crated electron-hole paira that are driven by the bias
voltage. Thus, the amount of dark current depends on
the temperature of the photodiode, the energy gap, and
the geometry of construction. Silicon photodiodes have
been manufactured with very low dark currents.
In order to insure that nearly all of the
photons are absorbed (high quantum efficiency) the width
of the i-region should exceed that of the absorption
region by a factor of 2 or 3. However, the photodiode
should be as thin as possible for fast response. Thus,
high quantum efficiency and fast response represent de-
sign tradeoffs. Photodiodes such as those shown in Fig.
2.53 are known as avalanche photodiodes (APD). Here a
highly-doped layer of p-type material is sandwiched
between the i- and n-regions. This results in a region
of high electric field just before the positive contact.
In this arrangement, an electron freed in the i-region
drifts toward the positive electrode. When it enters
the high field region it speeds up achieving sufficient
kinetic energy to produce another electron-hole pair if
it collides with the lattice. The new carriers generated
in this manner can likewiae produce additional carriers.
Thus, a primary electron freed in the i-region can
free numerous secondary electrons in the high field
region. The resultant devices exhibit high quantum ef-
ficiency. An example of one type of APD construction
is shown in Fig. 2.54. The temperature dependence of
APDs is greater than that of either p-n or PIN photo-
diodes.
hi~
w
kDEpLETION REGION+SECONDARY ELECTRON
PRODUCTION REGION
34
LIGHT P I P N
OUTPUT
-111~+
BIAS SUPPLY
Fig. 2.53 Field regions in an avalanche photodiode
(APD) with bias supply.
L!IGH!
k;:;;:;LL v A
b OUTPUT
,,, ,;;; ::,, ,,, ,,,,,:< ,,
/,;;;; ,,//:: 4, *;,
P-.~
R
INTRINSIC
BIAS
P
. SUPPLY
+
r
*
I
N
[
,,, , ,, ,~,,,,
T
ELECTRICAL
CONTACT
Fig. 2.54 The physical construction of an avalanche
photodiode (APD).
2-23
CHAPTER 3
FIBEROPTIC COMPONENT INTERCONNECTION
Optical power loss (attenuation) has been
drastically reduced in optical fibers since 1970. A
power loss of 0.2 dB per kilometer has been achieved
and the prospect is good for another order of magnitude
improvement to 0.02 dB per kilometer. If this occurs,
approximately 50 kilometers of fiber would exhibit only
a 1 dB leas. One consequenceof this progress inreduc-
ing attenuation in fiber is the increased importance of
the attenuation associated with component-to-fiber,
fiber-to-fiber, and fiber-to-component interconnect-
ions. Little is accomplished if 0.02 dB per kilometer
attenuation is achieved in optical fibers and at the
same time a number of Interconnections are required,
each resulting in an appreciable fraction of a dB loss.
In the case of fiberoptic sensora, where much shorter
lengths of optical fiber are utilized than in communi-
cation systems, such as several hundred meters of fiber
or less per sensor, and where the fiber used in most
cases is not chosen for low 10SS, problems with inter-
connections may be less important although connection
insertion losses can still be a large portion of the
total loss in a fiberoptic sensor. Interconnections,
especially singlemode fiber interconnections, are still
required and therefore of importance. The current
state of their development and manufacture will be con-
sidered in the following discussions.
3.1 FIBEROPTIC CONNECTORS AND SPLICES
Some of the uses of interconnections in the
fabrication of fiberoptic sensors include joining
sources and detectors to fiber , splitting the output of
a source (especially laser diodes) among a number of
sensors, beam splitting and combining of light in inter-
ferometers, and providing fiber-to-fiber interconnec-
tions. All interconnections must be designed taking
reflection and consequent insertion losses into ac-
count, with the aim of minimizing the insertion losses.
Interconnections can be grouped into three
classes, namely (1) connectors (remountable intercon-
nections between fibers or between a fiber and some
component, suchas a source, a detector, or an inte-
grated chip), (2) splices, (fusion joints or permanent
joints between two fibers or a fiber and some optical
component, and (3) couplers (connections that redistri-
bute energy between two or more fibers). In the case
of singlemode fibers, splices are relatively easy to
form. Splices and connectors with less than one tenth
dB insertion loss per splice can be achieved. Also,
in the case of singlemode couplers, especially simple
four-port couplers having two input ports and two out-
put ports, losses of less than a dB have been achieved.
Multimode connectors and couplers are now commerically
available and their singlemode counterparts are just
beginning to become available also. In the case of
multimode connectors, the average loss is about 1 or 2
dB. Goals are set for less than 0.5 dB. For purposes
of discussion, the fiber from which light is emerging
will be designated the source fiber while the fiber
into which light is being introduced will be desig-
nated the sink fiber.
In connectors and splices, power losses fall
into two general classes: intrinsic and extrinsic.
Intrinsic losses are due to variations or imperfections
in the fiber that occur during the manufacturing pro-
cess and are not mechanically or externally correctable.
Extrinsic losses are those that occur after the manu-
facturing process and are mechanically or externally
correctable, such as incorrect finishing of the fiber
end-surfaces or incorrect mechanical mating of fibers.
Some of these effects are shown in Fig. 3.1. Only the
INTRINSIC
x
(I:C
CORE AREA MISMATCH
NUMERICAL APERTURE MISMATCH
PROFILE MISMATCH
Fig. 3.1 Some causes of
EXTRINSIC
~ ~d
-c
END SEPARATION
+
p-
ANGULAR MISALIGNMENT
-L
/
t
LATERAL OFFSET
intrinsic and extrinsic
power losses in optical fiber interconnec-
tions.
fiber cores are shown in these sketches. Intrinsic
effects are shown on the left of Fig. 3.1. If the
core areas of the source and sink fibers are not the
same, the mismatch can result in a power loss. Differ-
ences in numerical aperture (NA) between the two fibers
can also result in losses. For the case of graded
index fibers, discussed earlier, a refractive index
profile mismatch can lead to intrinsic losses. Losses
occur only when directing light from a fiber of larger
core or NA into a fiber of smaller core or NA. In
these cases some of the light from the core of the
source fiber will not be trapped in the core of the
sink fiber. For the reverse, small-to-large core or
NA, losses due to the mismatch do not occur.
Examples of causes of extrinsic losses are
shown in the right column of Fig. 3.1. If the light
input to a sink fiber or output from a source fiber
diverges, such as at cone angles of 15 to 20, a core
separation will allow some of the light emanating from
the core of the source fiber to miss the core of the
3-1
sink fiber. Likewise angular misalignment can lead to
a portion of the light from the source fiber entering
the aink fiber at angles that will not allow trapping
in the core. Finally, losses can occur due to lateral
offset between two fibers because they are not properly
aligned or their cores are not concentric with respect
to the outer diameter of the fiber even when the outer
surfaces of the cladding are properly aligned. In gen-
eral, fibers are lined up by their outer surfaces.
There are a number of other extrinsic effects that are
not indicated here. The fiber end might not be smooth.
rhis can lead to scattering loaaea. The fiber ends
may not be flat cauaing lensing effects to occur. Thus,
it is esaential that care be taken in the manufacture
or acquisition of optical fibers, connectors, and
splicea in order to inaure that the intrinaic and ex-
trinsic leases are or can be minimized. h effect that
can be corrected easily ia reflection from the ends of
both fibers due to refractive index difference between
glass and air. For silicon dioxide (Si02) this reaulta
in a 0.4 dB loaa. In order to correct thia it is only
nesaary to employ an index-matching liquid or potting
material between the ends of the two fibera being butt-
joined.
The effect of the mismatch between either the
core areas or the fiber numerical apertures is shown in
Fig. 3.2. A problem exista when a source fiber with a
1.0
0.8
0.6
~ 0.2
rn
S 01
~ 0.08
0.06
0.04
0.02
0.001
A
I 1 1 I 1 1
2 4 6 8 10 12 14
PERCENT OF DIFFERENCE IN CORE DIAMETERS
OR FIBERNA
Fig. 3.2 Approximate losa in dB due to larger-to-
smaller core diameter difference or fiber
numerical aperture difference for two butt-
joined optical fibers.
larger core or larger numerical aperture ia joined to
a aink fiber with a smaller core or a smaller numerical
aperture. Furthermore, as their difference in numeri-
cal aperturea or core diameters is increased, the loss
will increase. The curves in Fig. 3.2 ahow the optical
power loaa in dB as a function of either the percentage
difference in core diameters of larger source cores
butt-joined to amaller aink corea, or source fibers
with larger numerical apertures butt-joined to aink
fibers with amaller numerical aperturea. These specific
curves actually apply to step-index fibers but the gen-
eral trenda shown are also true for graded-index fibers.
A 10% mismatch in either the core diameters (larger to
amaller) or the numerical aperturea (larger-to-amdler)
would cauae approximately a 0.5 dB loss. For the larger
multimode fibers it is not a difficult problem to main-
tain diameters to within 10% of each other or within
the same fiber. For a fiber with a 50-micron core it
would be necessary to hold the dimensions to + 5
microns, but when dealing with singlemode fibers w~th
a 5 micron core or less it is necessary to hold the dia-
metera to within a half a micron. Differences in numer-
ical aperature also need to be controlled accurately,
however in general, refractive indices are being con-
trolled within and among fibers to within a variation
of only a few percent. Thua, the primary problem is
the variation in the core diameter among fibera and
within the aame fiber.
The extrinsic leas due to end separation for
atep-index fibers is shown in Fig. 3.3. The core dia-
b 01 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5
END SEPARATION (S/D)
Fig. 3.3 Variation of connector power loss with end-
separation-distance-to-diameter ratio bet-
ween two atep-index air-gap optical fiber
ends for several valuea of numerical aper-
ture (N.A.).
meter ia indicated by D and the separation by S. The
coupling leas in dB is plotted as a function of S/D.
This effect is alao a function of numerical aperture.
The greater the numerical aperture (NA) the greater the
spreading of light from the source fiber and therefore
the larger the percentage of light that will miss the
core of the aink fiber. In thia figure, results are
plotted for NA ranging from 0.15 to 0.50. For the
fibera used in fiberoptic sensora the NA of Intereat
is below 0.20 and in fact more nearly 0.15. In thia
case, as can be seen in Fig. 3.3, a difference of 10%
in the core diameters will produce only a couple of
tentha of a dB loaa. Indeed, for NA = 0.15, an end
separation of half the core diameter will produce about
0.7 dB coupling loaa. In the caae of aplicea there is
no end separation therefore this losa does not occur.
The effect of axial transverse (lateral) dis-
placement of equal-diameter cores is ahown in Fig. 3.4.
The fiber core diametera, D, and the transverse dis-
placement, d, la shown. As can be seen, a 10% trans-
verse displacement, which for ainglemode fibera can be
0.5 urn (micron) can reault in a 0.5 dB losa. When pur-
chasing fiber, carefully apecified fiber dimensions are
important, e.g., fiber outaide diameter should be main-
tained uniform to ~ 1% of some nominal value and corea
should be concentric to within 0.5%. For an 80 urn
fiber, a 1% variation in the diameter is 0.8 pm. It
could lead to a 0.4 ~m transverse displacement, which
for 5 ~m core could lead to d/D = 0.08 corresponding to
a leas of approximately 0.4 dB.
Another extrinsic effect, an axial angular
3-2
o 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0:5
TRANSVERSE DISPLACEMENT (d/D)
Fig. 3.4 Connector power loss due to transverse
(lateral) displacement of the cores of two
step-index optical fiber butt-joined enda.
misalignment is shown in Fig. 3.5. It can occur when
the fibers are not lined up axially or are not cleaved
exactly at right angles to the core axes. This effect
is also a function of NA, increasing as NA increases.
As little as a 5 angular misalignment produces appro-
ximately a 0.4 dB loss in the connection between two
fibers each with NA = 0.15.
o 1 4
~(DEGR&
Fig. 3.5 Connector power loss due to axial angular
misalignment of the cores of two step-index
optical fiber butt-joined ends.
As indicated above, an important criterion
for the success of either a connector or a splice is
the proper end-preparation of the fibers themselves.
Optical fibers used in sensors usually consist of a
glass core surrounded by glass cladding that is in turn
jacketed by a buffer material used to protect the sur-
face. One type of jacket is made of acrylic material
that can be removed with acetone and a swab. Another
type of jacketing material consists of a IOO-micron-
thick layer of silicone rubber surrounded by another
100- or 200-micron-thick layer of a harder plastic,
such as Hytrelc. This may be removed with a razor
blade. In order to prevent scratching of the fiber,
the blade must be held at a very shallow angle with re-
spect to the axis of the fiber. Furthermore, a blade
should be used only once. After the jacket has been
removed the fiber can be cleaved in any of several ways.
One of these is shown in Fig. 3.6. Another technique
consists of laying the fiber on a curved surface with
approximately a 5 cm radius and applying a tension of
about 1/4 pound (120 grams). The fiber is then scribed
with a file causing a smooth cleave to occur. Another
technique is also shown in Fig. 3.6. The fiber is
lightly scored and then pulled. Care must be taken so
as not to bend the fiber. If the fiber bends a lip
tends to form when it breaks and a smooth endface does
A)STRIPJACKET
t
FIBER
C) RESULTS OFFENDING
P
v
h
&d
B)SCORE
~FILE
6 ?
D) RESULTS OF PULLING
~.
Fig. 3.6 A method of cleaning an optical fiber and
the results obtained.
not necessarily result. An alternative approach to
amooth cleaving consists of polishing the ends to pro-
vide a flat surface. This can be rather costly and
take a great deal of time. Once a smooth end has been
formed, the fiber can be inserted into a connector or
spliced to another fiber that alao haa a smooth end.
A simple snug-fit connector is shown in Flz.
3.7. A hole in- the c&nector is provided so that tie
Fig. 3.7 A simple snug-fit connector with hole for
index-matching fluid.
index-matching fluid can squeeze out as the fiber ends
are inserted. This is not an easily remountable type
of connector. A fairly good splice can be formed in
such a manner by using an index-matching epoxy in place
of the index-matching liquid.
If the splice is snug
enough to hold the fiber fixed, an index-matching liquid
can be used. The difficulty with such remountable con-
nectors is that in order to be mounted and demounted
many times it is necessary to maintain a radial clear-
ance of at least several microns. This technique is
not practical for singlemode fibers because no more
than an 0.5 urn lateral displacement is allowed In order
to avoid excesaive power losa.
A connector, recently marketed by TRW Incor-
porated is shown in Fig. 3.8 (see Ref. 1 in Subsection
3.1.1). Four relatively large diameter glass rods are
fused together. The ends are bent at an angle of ap-
proximately 6 and the hole formed along the axis is
enlarged at both ends. The fiber is factory filled
with an index-matching liquid or a fluid curable with
ultraviolet (UV) light. The fibers to be connected
are inserted into opposite ends. The curvature causes
the fibers to be pressed into the V-groove formed be-
tween two of the larger fibera thus aligning the fibers
being connected as they are brought together. The re-
sultant arrangement ia inserted into a spring loaded
holding device. The resulting splices cause losses of
0.02 to 0.34 dB. These may be mounted and demounted
many times. If LJV-curable fluid is used they may be
permanently fused.
LENGTHWISE SECTION
/ \
Fig. 3.8 A single-mode remountable optical fiber
connector recently marketed by TRW Incorp-
orated.
Accurately etched V-grooves in a silicone sub-
atrate may be used for aligning fibers. A small pres-
sure is applied to keep them firmly seated. The use
of such V-grooves to align fibers is shown in Fig. 3.9.
The fibers are then welded with an electric arc. A
number of fairly simple techniques may be used in the
laboratory. These techniques prove to be quite effec-
tive in forming splices and remountable connectors but
they are not very useful in a more permanent environ-
ment. The use of a sheet of thermoplastic material
(Plexiglasc) into which a section of fiber is pressed
to form a groove is shown in Fig. 3.10. An elevated
temperature may be used to facilitate the process. The
groove so formed is then utilized to align two aimilar
fibers. An index matching liquid or potting material
OPTICAL FIBER
ELECTRODE
Fig. 3.9 Splicing two optical fibers with an elec-
tric arc.
is applied and a second piece of plaatic-glass (Plexi-
glass) or some other flat material is placed on top to
hold the fibers in position. A connector formed in
this way is shown in Fig. 3.11.
Fig. 3.10 Joining two optical fibers using grooved
plastic-glaas (Plexiglass) to form a sub-
strate splice.
FI . 3.11 h optical fiber splice formed with two
pieces of Plexiglasc.
A fusion splice is shown in Fig. 3.12 at the
CLAD
/ ~ORE
//
(a) BEFORE HEATING
(b) tititiING HEATI NG
\ 4
(c) AFTER HEATING
x = AXIS OFFSET
z
o
1=
v
Lu
z
z
o
v
THEORETICAL CURVE
6.0
/
5.0
1/
+ BEFORE HEATING
~ AFTER HEATING
4.0
3.0
L
/
2.0
i
4
,/ ,1
1.0
0
--&.-4--+-
0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5 3.0
(x/a)
Fig. 3.12 Fusion splicing of two singlemode optical
fibers.
Adapted from Tsuchiya and Hatakeyana, Proc. Conf.
Opt. Fiber Transmission, Williamsburg, VA Feb. 1977.
3-4
left. The ends of the two fibers are brought together
wittmut necessarily eliminating lateral displacement.
Upon heating, the fiber melts and surface tensions tend
to align the fibers as shown. The graph on the right
side of Fig. 3.12 shows connector loss as a function
of lateral displacement both before and after heating.
The results prior to fusing is a theoretical curve with
experimental reaults superimposed. As can be seen a
significant reduction in loss is realized as a reault
of fusion splicing.
One method of connecting an optical fiber to
an encased laser diode is shown in Fig. 3.13. The laser
OPTICAL SPOT
EMITTING SOURCE
/1 I n
/
SOURCE PACKAGE
Fig. 3.13 A laser-to-optical-fiber connection.
surface is displaced from the fiber end because of the
covering that protects the laser face. The resulting
displacement between the fiber and laser source causes
a great deal of the light to miss the fiber due to
spreading. A lens can be used to collect the light and
focus it into the core. The problem is illustrated in
Fig. 3.14. At the top, the spreading (divergent) angle
from the laser and the acceptance angle into the fiber
are ahown. The laser emission is such that light
apreads out in a 20 to 40 cone, while the acceptance
angle (cone) for the fiber is 10 to 14. Thus, even
if the fiber is brought into actual contact (butt
coupled) with the laser face aa shown at the bottom of
Fig. 3.14, a large portion of the light being emitted
will mlaa the core or go into the core at such an angle
that it will be
interface, into
trans~tted through the core-cladding
the cladding, and lost. In order to
LASER
@ ,oo--
EMISSION PROFILEOF ACCEPTANCE CONE FORA
ALASERIN THE PLANE
TYPICAL STEP-INDEX FIBER
PERPENDICULAR TOTHE
JUNCTION
Fig. 3.14
LASER PELLET
E:
FIBER
+
a.
LIGHT LAUNCHED ATAN ANGLE GREATER
THANaWILLBE LOST
Loas of optical power in a pigtail connec-
tion between a laser and an optical fiber.
The angle = is equal to or less than the
critical angle.
prevent damage to the mirrored faces of the laser, a
alight separation must be maintained. For butt coupl-
ing, utilizing an index-matching liquid and no addi-
tional optical elementa, it is us~i to couple less
than 5% of the emitted light into the fiber. From 10
to 20% coupling of the light would be considered excel-
lent. If lenaes are used to focus the light into the
fiber it is possible for 70% or more of the light to
be coupled into the fiber and trapped. The manner in
which such a lens can be formed from the core of the
fiber is shown in Fig. 3.15. In this case the core
Fig. 3.15 Fabrication of an integral elliptical lens
at the end of an optical fiber.
glass haa a lower glass transition (softening) tempera-
ture than the cladding. Thus, the end of the fiber can
be heated and preasure applied to force a portion of
the core to bulge out aa shown, forming a lens. A
variety of other techniques for connecting lasers to
fibers have been developed and described in technical
literature. These should be reviewed In the event
such an Interconnection is required.
A mechanical device used to align and hold a
fiber and laser is ahown in Fig 3.16. The fiber is
positioned on one anvil in a V-groove and epoxied in
place. The laser sets on a second anvil that also aer-
ves as a heat aink. The two structures are brought to-
gether and the smooth faces are butted, aligned, and
epoxied. A sleeve is placed over the connector. In
this way a rather small fiber pigtailed laser can be
formed.
ELECTRICAL LEAD
ER
CUTAWAYA
Fig. 3.16 A pigtailed anvil for laser-to-optical
ber connection.
fi-
3.1.1 References
1. Fiberoptic Technology, p. 115, Dec. 1981.
3.2 FIBEROPTIC COUPLERS
It is often necessary to divide the beam emit-
ted from a laser and insert it into two or more fibera.
2-5
A laboratory beam splitter set-up used to accomplish A great deal of effort is being devoted to
this is shown in Fig. 3.17. It consists of a helium-
neon (HeNe) laser, a prism 3-dB divider, an objective
lens to collect and focus the light into a fiber, and
the associated micropositioners. The prism coupler is
shown in Fig. 3.18. In order to accomplish the same
purpose with a solid state device, the cores of two or
more fibers must be brought sufficiently close and
parallel to each other such that the energy distributed
in and around one core overlaps that in the other. As
shown earlier, the energy is not guided entirely in the
core but tends to be guided evanescently by the clad-
ding material itself. The cores are surrounded by a
relatively thick cladding that must be removed in order
to achieve coupling. After the claddings have been re-
moved and the cores are brought close together, the
degree of overlap is adjusted in order to achieve the
desired coupling ratios. It is then necessary to cement
or fuse the fibers together in order to fix their rela-
tive position (ruggedize) and thus to maintain the
coupling ratios. The coupling ratios ahould remain con-
the development of singlemode fiber couplers, particu-
larly 3-dB couplers that couple light from an input
fiber equally into two output fibers.
Such couplers
are under development at Stanford University; the ITT
Electrooptic Product Division; the Gould Research Lab-
oratories; the U.S. Naval Research Laboratory; and the
U. S. Naval Underwater Sound Center.
The use of pigtailed laaers and bulk couplers
can reduce volume by several orders of magnitude. Two
such devices are considered next. The method developed
at Stanford University is shown in Fig. 3.19. A fiber
stant with temperature.
(a) EMBED (b) POLISH
(c) OVERLAp
Fig. 3.17 A helium-neon laser with 3-dB coupler
(beamsplitter) and lens in a laboratory
set-up for coupling light into optical fi-
bers.
Fig. 3.19 Steps in fabricating a polished fiberoptic
coupler.
After Digonnet and Shaw, J. Quant. Electron, QE-18,
746 (1982).
is cemented into a grooved slab and the combination is
then ground or polished until nearly half of the fiber
is polished away virtually exposing the core. Ideally
it is desirable for some cladding to remain so that the
core-cladding interface is not disturbed. A coupler is
formed by joining two such slabs with their faces to-
gether and adjusting the amount of overlap or alignment
to achieve the desired coupling ratio. A satisfactory
method of accomplishing temperature-independent fusing
has not been developed.
The technique developed by Sheem, et al, (see
Ref. 1 in Subsection-3.2.1) is-sho~ in Fig. 3.20~ The
Fig. 3.18 A 3-dB priam coupler in a laboratory.
Fig. 3.20 Steps in
coupler.
INDEX
MATCHING
POTTING
(b) ETCH (C) RUGGEDIZE
fabricating an etched fiberoptic
fibers are cleaned carefully after removing the jacket.
Then they are twisted together and while remaining
twisted they are etched to remove most of the cladding,
leaving approximately one or two microns of cladding
around the core. The diameters of the fibers after
etching are less than 10% of their initial diameters,
therefore the resulting sections of fibers are quite
fragile. The joint IS held fixed (ruggedized) by either
potting in an indexmatching material or by fusing under
an axial tension that prevents the fiber from sagging
due to gravity and at the same time stretches the fiber
slightly, thus forming a biconical taper. This is shown
in Fig. 3.20 on the right. Index matching silicone
liquids have been proven to be highly temperature depen-
dent. Better results are obtained with index-matching
silicone rubber. However, there is still a temperature-
dependence problem. A great deal of success has been
achieved recently using a gel glass material (see Ref.
2 in Subsection 3.2.1) that is initially in liquid form.
This material consists of metal oxides dissolved in an
organic material. When heated the organic material is
driven off and the metal oxides form a glass. The re-
fractive index of the resulting glasa, and therefore
the degree of coupling, can be controlled by adjusting
the temperature and the length of time utilized to cure
or form the gel glass.
Temperature dependence can be minimized if
the fibers are actually fused. The biconical taper
arrangement mentioned above is shown in Fig. 3.21. To
END VIEW
OF FIBER
aturized bulk optical components similar to the labora-
tory devices shown in Figs 3.16, 3.17, and 3.18. These
bulk components and fibers may be connected by various
means, such as GRIN rods.
Using similar techniques star couplers have
been fabricated that allow the light from one fiber to
be coupled equally into as many as 32 other fibers.
Such devices would be useful for permitting a single
optical source to simultaneously furnish optical power
to a number of sensors.
In summary, satisfactory techniques now exist
for forming low-loss singlemode splices and remountable
connectors and for fabricating low insertion loss
singlemode couplers. Recently, commercially available
remountable connectors have appeared on the market.
Singlemode biconical tapered couplera are also becoming
available. Several other types of couplers are under
development by a number of groups and thus can be ex-
pected to appear on the market in the near future.
3.2.1 References
1.
2.
3.
S. Sheem, Appl. Phys. Lett ~, 869 (1980).
D. Tran, K. Koo, and S. Sheem, J. Quant. Electron.
QE-17, 988 (1981).
R. Ulrich, S. Rashleigh, Beam-to-Fiber Coupling
with Low Standing-Wave Rtutio, Appl. Opt. ~, 2453
(1980).
4.
5.
6.
7.
CROSS SECTION
VIEW
OF FUSED COUPLER
8.
Fig. 3.21 A biconical (tapered)
make this coupler a portion of the
fiberoptic coupler.
cladding is removed
from each of the fibers. These are then twisted to-
gether and etched until the thickness of the remaining
cladding is about half the core diameter. The twisted
pair is then fused under some axial tension causing a
decrease in diameter, especially in the region of con-
tact, i.e., the interaction region. The original core
dimensions indicated in the upper right of Fig. 3.21
are reduced as shown in the lower center of Fig. 3.21.
The result is that optical energy that initially was
confined close to the core tends to spread into the
cladding in the region where the core diameter has
been decreased. This results in a stronger overlap and
therefore a higher coupling ratio. The Electrooptics
Product Division of ITT has recently developed a spe-
cialized optical fiber that allows them to produce
fused copulers by this method without the necesaity of
etching. These couplers are available for sale. An
alternate to these fiber couplers is the use of mini-
G.B. Hocker, Unidirectional Star Coupler for Sin-
gle-Fiber Distribution System, Opt. Lett. ~, 124
(1977).
S. K. Sheem, T. G. Giallorenzi, Single-Mode Fiber
Optical Power Divider: Encapsulated Etching, Opt.
Lett. ~, 29 (1979).
J. G. Ackerhusen, Microlenses to Improve LED-to-
Fiber Optical Coupling, Appl. Opt. ~, 3694
(1979).
M. Saruwatari, K. Nawata, Semiconductor Laaer to
Single-Mode Fiber Coupler, APP1. Opt. ~, 1847
(1979).
H. Kuwahara, N. Tokoyo, M. Sasaki, Efficient
Coupling from Semiconductor Lasers into Single-
Mode Fibers with Tapered Heimspherical Ends,
Appl. Opt. g, 2578 (1980).
3.3 FIBEROPTIC CABLES
3.3.1 General
Just as with conventional wire interconnec-
tions and communication links, there is a need for fi-
beroptic cables to accomplish a number of different
purposea. In many ways, the individual fibers in an
optical cable are treated very much like varnished or
plastic insulated copper wires. The individual fibera
consist of 100- to 200-micron-OD core-cladding wave-
guide elements having an outer coating that may be as
thin as several microns of lacquer or as thick as 200
to 400 microns of plastic, such as nylon, teflon, or
polypropylene. Cabling serves the purpose of space-
division multiplexing, combining anywhere from a few to
many individual fibers into a single conveniently-pack-
3-7
aged multichannel unit. High-strength reinforcing mem-
bers are usually added to the structure and additional
inter-fiber separators (apacers) and outer protective
jacketing are provided within a cable with a relatively
small outer diameter. The jacket reducea the effecta
of cabling and protects the individual fibers from the
externl environment. Unlike copper wire and coaxial
cables, crosatalk between individual fiber waveguides
is virtually nonexistent. The equivalent of low resis-
tance shorts between two wirea and ground loopa do not
exist for fiber interconnection. Breaks can occur in
fibers just as in wirea. However, increases in optical
power loaaes in fibers due to microbend effects must be
considered. These may be introduced during cable con-
struction or installation. They also may be produced
by environmental disturbance that cause differential
stress or thermally induced bends. Care must be taken,
in cable design to prevent such effecta, particularly
when low-leas fiberoptic links are required.
3.3.2 Commercial Fiberoptic Cables
An example of how conventional cabling proce-
dures, developed for the communication industry for
wire tranamiasion media may be employed for optical fi-
ber cables is shown in Fig. 3.22. The figure ahows the
OUTER JACKET
COND
CENT
HEAVY DUTY CASLE WHICH CAN SE INSTALLEDBY REGULAR CREWS.
EXTERNAL CONSTRUCTION FOLLOWS TRADITIONAL TELEPHONE CASLE PRINCIPLES
Fig. 3.22 A fiberoptic cable produced by General
Cable.
structure of a heavy duty, combined wire and optical
fiber cable manufactured by General Cable deaigned for
use by the telecommunication industry.
As indicated,
it conaiats of two almoat identical multiwire and multi-
fiber sandwich-like stripa that are parallel to each
other on opposite sidea of a channeled plastic rod that
aeparates them. The atripa are held in place with tape
wrapping. l%is is surrounded by a welded aluminum tube
that forms the main strengthening element of the cable,
which in turn is aheathed by inner and outer plastic
jacketa that encaae a corrugated steel reinforcing wrap.
A aecond type of cable developed for uae in
standard telephone applications is shown in Fig. 3.23.
Produced by Bell Telephone Laboratories, it contains
144 separate multimode fibers. Twelve fibers are fuaed
in each of twelve plastic ribbona that form a 12 x 12
matrix that runs through the center of the cable. This
is wrapped with paper tape and surrounded by inner and
outer plastic jackets aeparated by flexible fiber and
steel wire strengthening elements.
optic communication purpoae are shown in Fig. 3.24 and
3.25. The first is an International Telephone and
Telegraph cable that has a group of plastic-jacketed
multimode fibers relatively looaely packed within a
central polyurethane jacket surrounded by a layer of
high-atrength Kevlarc fibers and an outer plastic jack-
et. The second is a SIECOR cable in which a group of
Corning lacquer-jacketed multimode fibers are threaded
loosely through individual loose fitting protective
tubes that are distributed around a central steel re-
inforcing wire. Theae tubea are surrounded by two suc-
cessive layera of Kevlarc fibers separated by inner and
outer plastic jackets. In each of these two cablea,
special care haa been taken to allow some flexibility
and freedom of motion for the individual optical fibers
to minimize the introduction of cabling-induced micro-
benda.
POLYETHYLENE OUTER JACKE1
POL
FIBERS I
12x12 FISER ARRAY
Fig. 3.23 A fiberoptic cable produced
phone Laboratories.
by Bell Tele-
KEVLAR STRENGTH MEMSERS UTER <K>
//
;HicK P L A S T I C JAcKETING
Fig. 3.24 A fiberoptic cable produced by International
Telephone and Telegraph.
KEVLAR STRENGTH
MEMBERS
/
/
LOOSE FITTING
PTFE TUSES
k
..$.,:
STEEL WIRE
STRENGTH MEMBER
y
OUTER
/*w
.7 JACKET
PLASTIC INNER
JACKET
LACOUER COATED
FISERS
Fig. 3.25 A fiberoptic cable produced by SIECOR.
TWO other aimilar cables produced for fiber-
3-8
Two cables manufactured in Japan by SUMITOMO
for underground and indoor telecommunication applica-
tions are shown in Figs. 3.26a and 3.26b, respectively.
In the cable designed for underground installations a
set of four multimode fibers, separated by plastic
strings are spaced uniformly around a cushioned central
strength member and surrounded first by a cushioning
sheath and then a second high-strength outer polyethy-
lene jacket. This cable has an outer diameter of only
18 millimeters. The multifiber cable designed for in-
door test is even smaller. As shown in Fig. 3.25b, it
has an outer polyvinylchloride (PVC) jacket only 8 mm
in outer diameter, and an inner cushioning sheath that
surrounds a set of plastic-jacketed graded-index opti-
cal fibers.
PLASTIC TAPE
ISmmOD ~ PESHEATH
mO.D
PLASTI C STR
STRENGTHM
A. underground CABLE B. INDOOR CABLE
Fig. 3.26 Two fiberoptic cables produced by SUMITOMO
of Japan.
A somewhat different cable design is employed
by HITACHI to reduce losses induced by cabling and in-
stallation. As shown in Fig. 3.27, channels are formed
in the outer periphery of a plastic spacer that is re-
inforced with a central high-strength metal or plastic
tension member. The individual plastic-jacketed opti-
cal fibers, and copper wires if some are required, fit
loosely in the channels and are held in by a thin outer
sheath. Thus, each fiber is well isolated from both
external and internal stress.
CU WIRE
SPACER \
16mm O.D
NONMETALLIC CABLE coMPOUNDCASLE
Fig. 3.27 A fiberoptic cable produced by HITACHI of
Japan.
3.3.3 Summary
used, especially for relatively short-run applications
where microbend losses introduced by cabling are not
excessive. For low-loss long-run applications, unique
designs aimed at eliminating random bending and the
effects of cabling and environmental disturbances have
been developed that are capable of preventing the addi-
tion of more than 1 or 2 dB/km to the original optical
power losses in the uncabled optical fibers.
Discussions of fiberoptic cable risetime bud-
gets, power budgets, bussing schemes, design parameters,
environmental factors, and their use in connection with
fiberoptic sensor arrays and telemetry systems is given
in Chapter 6.
From the above brief discussion of current
fiberoptic cabling procedures, it should be clear that
in some cases conventional cabling techniques are being
3-9
CHAPTER 4
LIGHTWAVES IN FIBEROPTIC SENSORS
4.1 INTERFEROMRTRIC FIBEROPTIC
4.1.1 Intensity Interferometry
4.1.1.1 Basic Principles
SENSORS
The basic transduction mechanism employed in
many fiberoptic sensors now being developed is the phase
modulation of coherent light propagating through a sec-
tion of singlemode fiber by the action of the energy
field that is to be detected. The techniques of opti-
cal interferometry may be used to detect these phase
shifts in lightwaves. These techniques allow for the
extremely high sensitivity that is achievable with the
various types of interferometric fiberoptic sensors.
Until recently, optical interferometry has been a re-
search tool used in laboratories rather than an applied
or operational technique. With the development of low-
10SS singlemode optical fibers, subminiature aolid-
state laser light sources, photodetectors, and other
related purely optical and electrooptical devices,
it is now possible to construct practical interferomet-
ric-type devices for use in operational systems. Fiber-
optic sensors have the potential to revolutionize sen-
sor technology.
Four different interferometric configurations
currently are being employed in fiberoptic aensors.
These are the Michelson, the Mach-Zehnder, the Sagnac,
and the Fabry-Perot configurations. It is convenient
to review their operation in terms of a nonconventional
schematic arrangement using airpaths and bulk optical
components before considering how they may be construct-
ed with optical fiber elements.
There is one important aspect that these in-
terferometric sensors have in common.
In each one, the
output beam from an optical source is split into two or
more portions. After traveling along different paths,
these separate beams are recombined and allowed to ac-
tuate a photosensitive detector.
4.1.1.2 The Michelson Interferometer
The basic principle is illustrated first in
Fig. 4.1 for the case of an air path Michelson inter-
ferometer. The beam splitter is shown as a partially-
reflective, partially-transmissive mirror. It sends one
portion of the output beam from the laser upward to the
fixed mirror where it is reflected back to the beam
splitter, where it is then partially transmitted to the
optical detector and partially reflected back toward
the laaer. The other portion of the laser output beam
passes through the beam aplitter, 1S reflected from
the movable mirror to be partially reflected to the
optical detector and partially transmitted back toward
the laser. If the difference in the the path lengths
back and forth to the fixed mirror and to the movable
mirror is less than the coherence length of the laser,
the two beams transmitted to the detector can be made
to interfere with one another. The detector output
will go from a maximum to a minimum and back to a maxi-
mum each time the movable mirror is displaced by one
half the optical wavelength. With this technique, it
is ossible to detect
?
10- urn, e.g. 0.63 x
light.
mirror displacements as small as
10-13 m, for a He-Ne laser red
LASER TRANSDUCER
SPLITTER
w
Fig. 4.1 The principle of the Michelson interfer-
ometer.
4.1.1.3 The Mach-Zehnder Interferometer
The Mach-Zehnder interferometer configuration
is shown in Fig. 4.2. The laser output beam is split
BEAM
R-
1 , ,
MOVABLE
LASER
I
1
BEAM
SPLITTER
Fig. 4.2 The principle of the Mack-Zehnder interfer-
ometer.
by the lower beam splitter. After traveling the upper
and lower optical paths the two beams are recombined
so that they may interfere with each other at the opti-
cal detector. This arrangement may also be employed to
4-1
detect displacements of the movable mirror as small as
10-13 m. l%is configuration has the advantage that
little or no light is fed directly back into the laser.
This is in contrast to the Michelson configuration. A
more detailed description of how such feedback can lead
to laser instability and noise is contained in Section
4.2. It should be noted that there are two other beams
not shown explicitly in Fig. 4.2, that travel upward
from the second beam splitter, i.e. a reflected portion
of the upper horizontal beam and a transmitted portion
of the righthand vertical beam. These could be fed to
another optical detector to yield a second output sig-
nal , which may be employed to advantage in certain ap-
plications.
4.1.1.4 The
The
shown in Fig.
Sagnac Interferometer
Sagnac interferometric configuration is
4.3. With this arrangement, the two por-
II II
TRANSDUCER
1 t
FIXED MOVABLE
MIRROR MIRROR
Fig. 4.4 The principle of the Fabry-Perot interfero-
meter.
sive mirrors. The reflectivity of these mirrors usual-
ly is quite high, e.g. 95% or even higher. Assuming
that the reflectivity (reflection coefficient) is 95%,
at any instant 95% of the output light from the laser
source will be reflected back toward the laser and 5%
will be transmitted into the Interferometer cavity.
When this portion of the incident light reaches the
right-hand mirror, 95% of it will be reflected back
toward the left-hand mirror and 5% will be transmitted
through to the detector. This will combine with light
that has been reflected back and forth successively an
increasing number of times between the two mirrors.
Neglecting losses other than the 5% transmission (at
each interface), each successive output beam intensity
will be reduced from the previous one by the factor
(0.95)2 = 0.9025. Assuming that the laser has a coher-
) 1 11/ I A ence lenzth manv times the distance between the two
I
LASER
Fig. 4.3 The principle of the Sagnac interferometer.
tions of the lasers output beam are sent in opposite
directions around the closed path formed by the beam
splitter and the two mirrors. They are then recombined
to be sent on to the photodetector and also back toward
the laser. If any of the mirrors is displaced perpen-
dicular to its reflecting surface, both path lengths
would be changed by the same amount and there should
be no detectable change in the interference process
at the photodetector. On the other hand, if the table
on which the interferometer is mounted were set into,
say clockwise,
rotation about an axis perpendicular
to the plane of the beams, the beam traveling clock-
wiae, i.e. In the direction of rotation, would be
delayed with respect to the counterclockwise traveling
beam. The clockwise beam has to catch up to the end
moving in the same direction. The counterclockwise beam
runs into the end moving in the opposite direction.
Thus, the Sagnac interferometer may be employed as a
sensitive rotation detector and, in principal, it is the
basis for the design of the ring laser gyroscope cur-
rently in use in a number of inertial guidance systems.
4.1.
tion
4.4.
.5 The Fabry-Perot Interferometer
The fourth type of inter ferometric conf igura-
the Fabry-Perot interferometer, is shown In Fig.
It consists of two parallel, partially transmis-
mirrors, the optical signal intensity incident on the
detector may be found by forming the vector sum of the
electric fields of the various transmitted beams.
4.1.1.6 Interferometer Sensitivity
The sensitivity of various interferometers is
shown graphically in Fig. 4.5. Consider first, what
occurs in the first three type of interferometers that
were considered earlier. For the Michelson, Mach-Zehn-
der, and Sagnac configurations, two separate optical
beams are combined at the sensitive interface of the
photodetector. As indicated in the upper left, the
~1 and 22 which are assumed to be of equal magnitude
wo electrical fields are represented by the vectors
and linearly polarized in the same direction. The op-
tical intensit
z
is proportional to the square of their
vector sum, E ( 8 ), which is at its maximum when the
temporal and spatial relative phase angle between the
two vectors is zero. If the length of one of the in-
terferometer paths changes the phase angle varies, and
E2( e ) and the intensity vary as indicated in the graph
in the upper right in Fig. 4.5. , i.e. , the intensity
drops to zero as 13 increases from O to n radians, vary-
ing as cos e. For further increases in e, E2( e) oscil-
lates from zero to its maximum and back to zero again
each time 13 varies by 2T radians.
The corresponding diagrams for the Fabry-
Perot interferometer are shown in the lower portion of
Fig. 4.5. As pointed out earlier in this case, there
is a set of electrical field vectors, in principle in-
finite in number, each successive one down from the
previous by a factor R2, where R is the amplitude re-
flection coefficient. When the mirror separation is
some integral number of half wavelengths, all of these
vectors are in phase and the output intensity is at a
maximum. When the separation is increased slightly,
each successive vector is shifted with respect to the
previous one by the same angle. By continuing the vec
-
4-2
tor addition indefinitely, as indicated in the lower
left, one can easily show that E2(13) in this case is a
sharply peaked function with maxims at = O, Zm, 411,...
and s. forth; E2(e) rapidly decreases and remains CIOSe
to zero for values of f3 only slightly different from O,
2n, 41r,... etc., as indicated in the vector diagram at
the lower center in Fig. 4.5c. Thus, in the vicinity
of its maxima, the Fabry-Perot interferometer is an ex-
tremely sensitive position and length measuring device.
It is in fact, one of the most sensitive displacement
measuring devices available to modern science.
A) MICHELSON, MACH-ZEHNDER AND SAGNAC
RELATIVE PHASE SHIFT (RADIANS)
B) FA6Ry-pEROT
that are currently available, it is already possible to
construct relatively small-sized, highly-stable, and
quite rugged interferometric fiberoptic sensors that
are capable of withstanding the rigors of many field-
type applications.
Sketches outlining all fiber configurations
of the four different types of interferometers are
shown in Fig. 4.6. In the Mach-Zehnder fiberoptic in-
A) MICHELSON
3dB COUPLER
=;::;s
RTRANSDUCER
A
B) MACH-ZEHNDER
El > ~
E[@),
r f \
DISPLACEMENT- O.25 05 0.75 I MICRON
5=i!4._-!=-!=-
Fig. 4.5
4.1.2
have been
The sensitivity of various typea of inter-
ferometers as a function of relative phase
difference between two interfering light-
wavea.
Fiberoptic Intenaity Interferometer
Up to this point, the various interferometers
depicted aa they exist in the typical optics
laboratory, with air paths and lumped optical devices
such as beam splitters and mirrora. Their extremely
high displacement sensitivity has been used to measure
atrain and streas. In addition, they also have a very
high dynamic range. This will be brought out in more
detail in later discussion. If the many advantages
of the use of fiberoptic, electrooptics, and integrat
-
ed-optics are added, one can conceive of configurations
and systems that are capable of revolutionizing sensor
technology.
By employing single-mode optical fibers for
the interferometer paths, the rather stringent limita-
tion on their length is immediately removed. Path
lengths of the order of a kilometer are easy to achieve
and are being used in practice. Extremely small, long-
life, solid-state laaers and detectors that are capable
of being used in hostile environments are becoming
available. Elements such as etched or lapped fiber-to-
fiber couplers and their integrated-optic counterpart
are being developed and tested. By incorporating items
C) SAGNAC
El
LASER
DETECTOR
D) FABRY-PEROT
LASER - 1
a
!- DETECTOR
\: /
PARTIAL TRANSMITTING MIRRORS
Fig. 4.6 The configuration of various types of fi-
beroptic interferometera.
terferometer shown in Fig. 4.6b, the two beam splitters
are replaced with two etched or lapped 3-db couplers
that divide the laser output beam into two equal por-
tions and they also recombine the light that haa tra-
versed the two optical paths. It is possible to butt-
couple the laser output beam directly into the fiber
and to similarly couple the output fibers directly into
the two photodetectors. Thus, between aource and de-
tectors, the interferometera consiats only of fiber
elementa. By combining integrated circuit techniques
with current electrooptic capabilities, all of the other
elements, including the laser, detectors, and signal
processor, could be packaged in a single miniature chip
to which the fibers will be butt-coupled. Though the
device is not an off-the-shelf item today, there is
little doubt that they will be readily available in the
not too distant future.
4.1.3 Polarization in Fiberoptic Sensors
Earlier in this discussion of interferometers
it was mentioned, but not especially emphasized, that
4-3
the fiber interferometer should employ singlemode
fibers. In this case, the lightwaves injected into each
arm of the interferometer would propagate at a unique
velocity. In fact, the so-called singlemode fibers are
really at least two-mode fibers in the sense that there
are two different states of optical polarization that
can be propagated, i.e. the electric field vector can
be resolved into two mutually perpendicular component
that are perpendicular to the axis of the fiber. In
an ideal, straight, imperfection-free fiber with circu-
lar symmetry, the propagation velocity is independent
of the direction of polarization. Polarized light in-
jected into such a fiber would maintain ita direction
of polarization. Thus, in an interferometer applica-
tion, one could have available two similarly polarized
optical beams that can produce the optimum interference
effects. That ia, if their intensities are equal, their
electric field vectora can interfere destructively and
thereby completely cancel. This can occur only for
beams of the same polarization.
In reality, however, ideal fibers with per-
fect symmetry do not exist. The complications that
this introduces can be illustrated by considering a
fiber with an elliptical core, as ahown in Fig. 4.7.
In this case, there will be two preferred direction
of polarization, those along the major and along the
minor axes of the elliptical croas section aa ahown by
a and b along the x and y axes in Fig. 4.7.
t Y
----------
z
\
I
x\
Fig. 4.7 b optical fiber with an elliptical cross
section.
Linearly polarized light injected into the
fiber with its direction of polarization at some angle
other than along the x or y axes will propagate in two
aeparate.modea, the ao-called HE 11 and HE 11 modea,
~ Such a that travel at alightly different velocitie .
fiber is aaid to have a modal birefringence, B, defined
by:
B= (~-~)x/211 (4.1)
where the two 6s are the propagation constanta of the
two polarization modes and i is the wavelength in a
vacuum. Under this condition, the direction of polar-
ization will continuously change along the length of
the fiber. Even when light that is polarized along
one of the two major axes is injected into a fiber
there will be some coupling into the other mode due to
imperfections in the core-cladding interface, index of
refraction fluctuations, and other mechanisms. Thua,
both static and dynamic changes in polarization along
the length of the fiber may occur.
The occurrence of such changes of polariza-
tion may be observed in the laboratory in the following
situation. Referring to Fig. 4.8, imagine a beam of
linearly polarized light injected into an elliptically-
cored two-mode fiber in such a way that the input
energy is aplit equally between
the HEIIX and HEIIY
modes. The modal velocities are different therefore
the polarization state will change continuously along
the length of the fiber, aa shown at the left in Fig.
4.8. The HEIIX and HE1lY modes are linearly polarized
along the X and Y axea, respectively, and at each posi-
tion, z, along the axis of the fiber the state of polar-
iza~ion is *determined by the time varying vector sum
of Ex and
Y
Beginning at some point (a) where the
two modes are in phase, the polarization state will
change from linear polarization at (a) to circular
polarization at (b); back to linear at (c), rotated,
however, by 90 from its direction at (a); to circular
at (d), but in the opposite direction from that at (b);
back to linear at (e), just as at (a); and ao forth
down the length of the f~ber.
BEAT LENGTH L=;
(a)
(b)
(c)
(d)
(e)
Fig. 4.8
OBSERVER
@(z) =(pxpy)z=o
4-11
4.3 INTEGRATED OPTICAL CIRCUITS (IOCS)
The optical counterpart of the field of inte-
grated electronics is the field of integrated optics.
However, though integrated optical circuita have been
made, they are for the moat part not commercially
available. They are the subject of extensive research
and development efforta at a large number of laborator-
ies. The goal of these efforts is to commercially fab-
ricate in large quantities these miniaturized devices
with interconnected waveguides all on a single sub-
strate. The generation, detection, propagation, modu-
lation, switching, and coupling of light on such sub-
strates have been accomplished. Techniques for the
fabrication of substrates and the production of the
high resolution material distribution patterns required
for these integrated optical circuits exist. Most
integrated optical circuits and associated devicea
operate in a singlemode, therefore they are compatible
with singlemode optical fibers. In essence most LEDs,
diode lasers, and photodiodea are integrated optic
devices. Integrated optical circuits are considered
here because they are a part of second generation fiber-
optic sensor technology.
The waveguides used in integrated optical
circuits are usually of two types namely planar films,
that confine the light wavea in the vertical direction,
and planar strips, (channels) that confine lightwaves
in two dimensions. In both caaea, the waveguides are
made of a higher refractive index than the surrounding
material. Light is trapped in the layer or channel in
much the same way that it is trapped in the core of an
optical fiber. These planar waveguides can be formed
by sputtering glass on a substrate of lower refractive
index. A very uaeful type of channel waveguide can be
formed by evaporating titanium (Ti) onto lithium ni-
obate (LiNb03) or lithium tantalate in the desired
waveguide patterns, and diffusing the Ti into the aub-
strate thus forming a channel of higher refractive in-
dex. This is shown in Fig. 4.23. The attenuation in
-r
LiNb03
&
SUBSTRATE
OPTICAL
1
n2
CHANNEL
nl>nz
Si02_
n1>n2>n3
ELECTRODES
(A) TITANIUM STRIP
ON LiNb03
SUBSTRATE
(B) TITANIUM DIFFUSEDAT
HIGH T INTO SUBSTRATE
FORMING CHANNEL
WAVEGUIDE
(C) PROTECTIVE LAYEROF
Si02 SPUTTERED
ON SURFACE
(D) ELECTRODES APPLIED
Fig. 4.23 Steps in the fabrication of a channel wave-
guide.
auch channels is typically 1 dB/cm. A protective layer
of silicon dioxide (Si02) ia often sputtered on top in
order to protect the surface. Electrodes may be deposit-
ed on the Si02.
Coupling a fiber to an integrated optic chan-
nel has been accomplished as shown in Fig. 4.24. The
1 v SILICON
SINGLE-MODE FIBEti
IN ALIGNMENT
V-GROOVES IN SILICON
Fig. 4.24 An optical fiber pigtailed to a lithium
niobate (LiNb03) fiberoptic chip.
fiber is aligned and epoxied in an etched silicon (Si)
V-groove. The fiber end and the Si edge are polished
and butted against the polished edge of LiNb03. Index-
matching liquid is used between the fiber and substrate
ends. Similar techniques are uaed to couple diode
lasers and photodetectors to the substrate. The dimen-
sions of channel waveguides are close to those of both
ainglemode fiber corea and the radiating areas of stripe
geometry diode lasers. For stripe geometry, the long
dimension of the channel should be oriented perpendicu-
lar to the long dimension of the radiating area of the
diode. Insertion leases as low as a few dB can be
achieved.
Channel-to-channel couplers can be formed on
the integrated optical circuit aubstrate by paralleling
two channels in cloae proximity to each other for a
sufficient distance to achieve the desired coupling
ratio. The coupling length is defined as the distance
required for complete power transfer to occur. The
length required to achieve a apecified coupling ratio
depends on the separation between channels and the re-
fractive indices of the channels and subatrate. The
refractive index of LiNb03 ia a linear function of the
applied electric field.
This is known aa the Pockels
effect. Thus, if electrodes are applied as shown in
Fig. 4.25, the refractive index can be varied and the
light can be awitched to the other of the two output
ports of the coupler. The direction of the electric
field is oriented oppositely in the two channels result-
ing in equal and opposite refractive index changes.
When the proper value of voltage is applied, the coupl-
ing length is made ahorter and the light will exit from
the same fiber it entered. When the voltage is not ap-
plied, the coupling length is longer and the light will
emerge from both ports. The exit channels from this
switch may be combined to form the Mach-Zehnder inter-
ferometer shown in Fig. 4.26. The result is an electro-
optic intensity modulator. When the light wavea recom-
bine they excite the fundamental mode of the exit chan-
nel. When they arrive out of phase they tend to excite
the aecond mode but the second mode cant propagate in
the singlemode channel, therefore it radiatea.
An acoustooptic modulator (Bragg Cell) is
ahown in Fig. 4.27. The interdigited ultrasonic trans-
ducer is shown at the bottom. The surface acoustic wave
4-12
sets up periodic spatial fluctuations in the refractive
index of the waveguide. These act as phase gratings
deflecting a portion of the lightwave incident perpen-
dicular to the resulting grating. The lightwave that
passes straight through the grating exits with its fre-
quency unchanged, while the diffracted ray has its fre-
quency shifted by an amount equal to the acoustic fre-
quency, e.g., 500 MHz. Such Bragg cells can be used
for optical heterodyning.
nlAn n, +dn
+ l-l+
ELECTRODES ( n.
>
LiNb03
+h
- , , /s.BsTRATE
WAVEGUIDE
INCIDENT BEAMJ
Fig. 4.25 A Pockels effect electrooptic binary switch
mounted on a lithium miobate substrate.
MODULATED LIGHT OUT
A
,-
OP
POLARIZ
Fig. 4.26 A Mach-Zehnder interferornetric electrooptic
ACOUSTIC ABSORBER
FREQUENCY
I SHIFTED BEAM
ACOUSTIC
SURFACE WAVE =
LIGHT
-
INCIDENT
.
/
UNDIFFRACTED
/
BEAM
OPTICAL FIBER
/
/
E3--
INTERDIGITED
CHANNEL TRANSDUCER
WAVEGUIDE
ACOUSTIC ABSORBER
Fig. 4.27 A Bragg cell integrated acoustic modulator
in which an interdigital transducer is used
for frequency shifting in accordance with
an electrical input signal that develops an
ultrasonic wave in a bifurcated optical
waveguide.
Technology exists for integrating an array of
channel couplers connected to an array of photodiodes
with charge-coupled device readout all on a single sub-
strate. Using flip-chip techniques (mounting the chip
face down) multiple fiber pigtails can be attached to
a single chip. Such integrated devices promise to sig-
nificantly reduce the size and cost of arrays of opti-
cal sensors.
intensity modulator mounted on a lithium
niobate (LiNb03) substrate chip.
4-13
CHAPTER 5
FIBEROPTIC SENSORS AND COMPONENTS
5.1 PHASE MODULATED FIBEROPTIC SENSORS
5.1.1 General
A large variety of phase-modulated fiberoptic
sensors have been demonstrated, including acoustic,
electric, magnetic, rate of rotation, acceleration,
electric current, trace vapor, pressure, and tempera-
ture sensors. They are being applied to hydrophores,
magnetometers, gyroscopes, accelerometers, and other
devices. These devices exhibit numerous advantages,
the most important of which are geometric flexibility,
immunity to electromagnetic interference (EMI) and
electromagnetic pulses (EMP), large bandwidth, and
great sensitivity i.e., ability to detect extremely low
signal levels and small signal level changes. Phase
shifts as small as 10-7 radians have been detected (See
Ref. 1 in Subsection 5.1.7 at the end of this section).
For a wavelength of 0.83 microns, this is equivalent to
a length of approximately 10-14 meters, corresponding
to the size of an atomic nucleus. Transduction, i.e.
phase shifting, occurs as a lightwave travels through-
out the sensing length of the optical fiber. Coherent
light sources, singlemode fiber, and relatively complex
optical and electronic circuitry are required.
Consider
shown in Fig. 5.1.
the Mach-Zehnder interferometer
Phase-locked loop homodyne
LASER
detec-
m:oDEs
Fig. 5.1 A phase-locked loop Mach-Zehnder-type homo-
dyne-detection interferometer that cnnverts
phase modulation
modulation.
tion, which is especially
between 10 Hz and 20kHz, is
mode fiber-ui~tailed diode
to intensity (amplitude)
suitable for frequencies
shown. Light from a single-
laser is divided eaually
between the ~ms of the interferometer using a solid
state 3-dB fiber coupler. The sensing portion of the
sensor arm is designed to respond to the field to be
measured while the remainder of the sensing and refer-
ence arms are insensitive. The two beams of light
that have traveled independently through the two arms
are recombined by a second 3-dB coupler that converts
the phase-modulation to an intensity-modulation. The
amplifiers and summing circuits combine the electrical
signals from the photodiodes, one for each of the two
output optical ports from the 3-dB coupler, in such a
manner as to reject common mode noise, e.g., laser
amplitude fluctuations. An integrator completes the
phase-locked loop. The output signal is filtered to
eliminate low frequency noise. In an alternate ar-
rangement, both arms of the interferometer have a por-
tion that is sensitive to the field being measured.
These portions are spatially separated and therefore
the combination is sensitive to the gradient of the
field being measured. Using a homodyne detection
scheme in a phase-locked loop configuration, phase
shifts as small as 10-7 radians have been measured at
frequencies above 1 kHz. The phase shifter in the refer-
ence arm is used as part of the phase-locked loop. The
phase shifter can be fabricated by winding the fiber
around a PZT stretcher or by applying a piezopolymer
jacket on part of the fiber. In either case, the output
of the amplifier/integrator circuit is applied to the
phase shifter causing a phase modulation in the refer-
ence arm of the interferometer equal to that in the
sensing arm. With this arrangement, the phase relation
between the two arms of the interferometer is locked
at the point of maximum sensitivity. This is known as
quadrature operation.
Various fiberoptic sensnr configurations are
shown in Fig. 5.2. A planar arrangement is shown in
SPATIAL SHADING
a
GRADlENT
Fig. 5.2 Optical fiber configurations used in fiber-
optic sensors.
the upper left. The linear array of spiral wound sen-
sors in the lower left is suitable for beam forming.
A spatially shaded element, such as in the upper right,
where the spacings between windings vary according to
a Gaussian distribution, possess a beam pattern exhi-
biting greatly reduced side lobes. Finally, the grad-
5-1
ient configuration in the lower right is produced by
utilizing both arms of the interferometer aa spatially
separated sensors.
5.1.2 Fiberoptic Acoustic Sensors
5.1.2.1 Acoustic Pressure Sensors
Extending the discussion for an acoustic sen-
sor in Subsection 4.2.1 and considering Eqa. (4.7) and
(4.8), the pressure variations associated with a sound
wave produce phase fluctuations given by:
A$ = kA(nL) = k(nAL + LAn) (5.1)
A$ = kL(nAL/L + An) (5.2)
where AL/L is the axial strain, S11; k is the wave num
-
ber; n is the refractive index of the core; and An is
given by:
An = -(n3/2)[(Pll + P12)S12 + P12S11] (5.3)
where Pll and P12 are the Pockels coefficients and S12
is the radial strain. A constant volume assumption
yields the relation S12 = -S11/2. This assumption is
valid only for a material whose Poissons ratio is close
to 0.5. It is also quite good for the polyester jacket
material Hytrelc, but not as good for fused silica.
These materials exhibit values of Poissons ratio equal
to 0.483 and 0.17 respectively. More exact treatments
sre given in Refs. 2, 3, and 4 in Subsection 5.1.7.
Substituting these relations into Eq. (5.3) yields:
A$ = kLn[l+(n2/4)(Pll - p12)]Sll (5.4)
In fused silica Pll = 0.12, P12 = 0.27 and n = 1.46.
Substituting into Eq. (5.4) results in:
A$ = 0.92kLnSll (5.5)
For an isotropic material:
AL/L = Av/3v :(1/3V)(~V/aP)AP (5.6)
where AL/L = S11 is the axial strain, V iS the volume,
P is the applied pressure and (1/V)(aV/ap) iS the com
-
pressibility, K. Thus:
S1l = (1/3)KAP (5.7)
With Kaa the wave number, Eq. (4.7) in Subjection 4.2.1
reduces to $ = kLn. Using this and combining Eqs. (5.5)
and (5.7) results in:
A@/@AP = 0.307K (5.8)
The compressibilities of silica and the pol~~
ester Hytrelc are 2.7 x 10-11 and 2.67 x 10-10 pascals
respectively, leading to:
A$/$AP = 8.3 x 10-12 pascal-l
for bare optical fiber and:
A$/$AP = 8.2 x 10-11 pascal-l
for Hytrelc jacketed optical fiber. Experimental values
of A$/$AP, shown in Fig. 5.3, (See Ref. 5 in Subsection
5.1.7) are 4.5 x 10-12 and 1.0 x 10-10 pascal-l respec-
tively. The calculated and measured values agree to
within 18% for Hytrelc and a factor of two for fused
silica. These are quite reasonable agreements espec-
ially for Hytrelc where the constant volume assumption
is more nearly valid. Thus, the phase of a lightwave
in Hytrelc-jacketed optical fiber, where the croas sec-
tional area of the Hytrelc is much greater than that
of the fused silica, responds to pressure according to
the Hytrelc compressibility. While the results shown
in Fig. 5.3 are for jacketed optical fibers, similar
results are obtained when bare optical fiber is wound
tightly on a Hytrelc or similar mandrel. In either
case, the more compressible plastic (either jacket
or mandrel), when subjected to fluctuating pressure,
carries (atretches or compresses) the optical fiber
along with it.
J
PIJSTICCOAT(lmm)
K DD
K ODDDU K
PLASTIC COAT (O.4 mm)
00
Ooooo(looooooooo(x o 0 0
1
~lo -
In
Q
$
SARE
$
ALUMINUM COAT
<
AAAAAAAAAAA A A 6 A A
1
1 , 1 1 1 1
0.2 0.4 O.b 0.8 10 12 1.4 16
FREQUENCY (kHz)
Fig. 5.3 Acoustic sensitivity vs frequency for vari-
ous typea of optical fiber jacketing.
Adapted from Lagakos et al., Opt. Soc. Am. ~, 460
(1982).
The discussion above is valid for the mandrel-
wound or thick-jacketed fibers. For thinner jackets,
the phase sensitivity is a more complicated function
of the elastic moduli. A low Poissons ratio will re-
sult in the thick-jacketed limit being approached with
thinner jackets. Baaed on the criteria of large com-
pressibility and low Poissons ratio, Teflon
c
appeara
to be an optimum material. In order to demonstrate the
effect of increasing jacket thickness. Ea. (5.2) is re-
written as:
A$ = kLn(AL/L + An/n)
= kLN[(l/L)aL/aP +
and therefore, since $ = kLn as
A$/$AP = (1/L)aL/aP +
(1/n)an/aP]AP
indicated above:
(1/n)an/aP)
(5.9)
CL,Z + Cn,z+cn,r
where CL z corresponds to the first term in the brackets
and the 2n,z and cn,r correspond to the fiber axial and
transverse components of the second term in the brack-
ets. The last two terma are both associated with the
pressure-dependence of the refractive index, n. The
various values of the three components of A$/$AP are
shown in Fig. 5.4 (see Ref. 4 in Subsection 5.1.7). As
can be seen, the thick-jacketed fiber results were ob-
tained for a jacket thickness of approximately 600Pm.
5-2
--
~
I
I T I I I I
I
1! 20
~
c
n.z
9
10
0
= ~ n,r
%
0.0 ~ - --- - - - -
*
g 10
z 20
>
~ W
%
40
$
~ -50 -
< so
I I I I I I
100 2(Y2 300 400 500 600
HYTREL THICKNESS (pm)
Fig. 5.4 The components of the per-unit phase change
of a lightwave in a Hytrelc-jacketed fiber
per pascal as a function of jacket thick-
ness.
After Lagakos and Bucaro, Appl. Opt. ~, 2717 (1981).
In order to calculate the pressure sensitivity
of one meter of Hytrelc-jacketed fiber, consider the
experimental results that were given in Fig. 5.3. The
is 10-~0 pascal-l.
measured value of A /@jAP, corresponding to a l-mm plas-
tic jacket Solving fOr A$/~ and
taking L = 100 cm, n = 1.5, k = 7.4 x 104/cm (for A =
0.85 microns) yields aA$/$of 10-6 radians for 10Q3
pascals. Thus,
103 micropascals produces a one micro-
radian phase shift. The pressure sensitivity per meter
for this case is 60 dB re 1 micropascal. Increasing
the length of optical fiber to 10 and 100 meters in-
creases the pressure sensitivity to 40 dB re 1 micro-
pascal and 20 dB re 1 micropascal respectively. These
results are only 5 dB greater than the quantum limited
theoretical results shown in Fig. 5.5. Included for
~
\ \
t \ H56EOUIV \
d
~ 30 cOATEDFIBER 115fiW20ml
Y\Y
+
I
3 5 10 2 5 100 2 5 1,000 2 5 Io,orm
FREQUENCY (H,]
Fig. 5.5 Variation of acoustic energy spectrum level
as a function of frequency for two coated
fibers along with other noise levels in a
sea subsurface environment.
comparison in Fig. 5.5, are various ambient noises,
such as shipping, weather and seismic noiaes. Also
shown is the equivalent noise pressure of the U.S.
Navys H56 hydrophore.
The effect of jacketing optical fiber with
aluminum (measured experimentally) is to reduce the
value of A~$AP below that of fused silica, as was shown
in Fig. 5.3. Theoretical results are shown in Fig. 5.6
--
1
-a
I T I r I I I I
%
0.5
:
y
0.0 -
:
30.5
~
:
10 -
5
~
15
CALCIUM ALUMINATE GuSS
G
z
# 2.0
g
: ~,5 -
$
<
0 20 40 60 SO 100 120 140
COATING THICKNESS (pm)
Fig. 5.6 Acoustic response (phase shift of a light-
wave) in an optical fiber as a function of
coating thickness.
After Lagakos et al., Opt. Lett. ~, 460 (1982).
(See Ref. 6 in Subsection 5.1.7) for jackets of nickel,
calcium aluminate glass, and aluminum. A nickel jacket
as thin as 10 microns should reduce the acoustic sensi-
tivity of silica fiber to zero; however, the thickness
is critical. On the other hand, a 90-micron jacket of
aluminum is required for zero acoustic sensitivity but
the thickness is much less critical. The variation of
L,z~ n,z~ cn,r,
and A$/@P versus the thickness of
the the aluminum jacket are shown in Fig. 5.7 (See Ref.
5 in Subsection 5.1.7).
4,
--
I
2 -
z
:
c1 E n,z
y
0 -------
0
---
g
%
* 2 -
~
o 20 40 60 80 100 120 140
ALUMINUM THICKNESS (pm)
Fig. 5.7 Pressure components per unit sensitivity
per unit pressure as a function of aluminum
jacket thickness on an optical fiber.
After Lagakoa and Bucaro, Appl. Opt. 20, 2719 (1981).
5.1.2.2
mined by
Pressure Gradient Sensors
The direction of a sound source can be deter-
using either an array of omnidirectional sen-
5-3
sors or a pressure gradient sensor. Sensor arrays will
be considered in Chapter 6. Pressure gradient hydro-
phores sense the pressure at two closely spaced points.
The distance between sensors, S, iS typically much less
than the wavelength of sound, k, in the propagation
medium, namely water in the calculations that follow.
A pressure gradient measurement can be accomplished by
means of either two distinct sensors, one at each point,
or by a single senaor apanning the distance between the
two points. Both types of sensora will be considered
here.
Since the output signal from a pressure-grad-
ient hydrophore is proportional to the preasure grad-
ient, ita reaponse ia proportional to the particle velo-
city. Such sensors are therefore often called particle
velocity hydrophores. This is an advantage when operat-
ing near a pressure releaae aurface where the particle
velocity almost doublea and the pressure itself goes to
zero. The tendency to reapond to particle velocity
renders them more aensitive to flow noiae than omni-
directional hydrophores. Thia follows because particle
velocity fluctuations associated with flow are often
much greater than the particle velocity oscillations
associated with the acoustic signal being measured.
Consider the sine wave shown in Fig. 5.8 where the
PA- -
I
P
Fig. 5.8 The pressure distribution aa a function of
distance from the zero-preasure point of a
single pressure wave.
instantaneous acoustic preasure, P, is given by:
p = pAsiIi (2~/ka)x (5.10)
where pA is the acoustic amplitude, as is the sound
wavelength, and x is distance in the same units as ~.
The pressure amplitude at x = O and x = S (S <<~) are
O and 21rPAS respectively (for small y, siny=y). If one
aensor (or sensing end) iS at x = O and the other at x
= S, then the pressure difference to be measured is:
P~n = (2TpA/~s)S (5.11)
At 100 Hz, a gradient aenaor element 10 cm long will
detect a preasure P~n = -27.5 dB re pA. The value of
Pdn referred to PA variea 20 dB per decade thua, at
10 Hz the value of Pmin which must be detected is -47.5
dB re PA. The large acoustic senaltivlty achievable
with fiberoptic acouatic aensors make them especially
desirable for this application. The variation of P~n
with frequency is shown in Fig. 5.9 for 118 meters and
373 meters of optical fiber in each case wound on two
2.5 cm diameter Teflon
c
mandrels spaced 8 cm apart.
Fig. 5.9
100
90
80
HEAVY RAI N
70
60
50
40
SS2 WI ND
30
SPEED
10 KTS
20
\
1
3 5 ID 2 5 100 2 5 1,000 2 5 10,000
FREOUENCY (Hz)
V a r i a t i o n of the acouatic energy spectrum
level aa a function of frequency for a fi-
beroptic presaure-gradient hydrophore with
other noise levels in a sea subsurface en-
vironment.
The calculated reaults shown in Fig. 5.9 is
for the case of the aound wave propagating parallel to
the line joining the two sensors. The sensitivity of
a Preasure gradient sensor to a sound wave propagating
perpendicular to this direction ia zero because both
sensors are then aubjected to the aame pressure. The
directivity is dipole-like aa shown in Fig. 5.10(a).
The cardioid directional responae shown in Fig. 5.10(b)
can be obtained by combining the dipole output with
that of an omnidirectional hydrophore with sensitivity
equal to that exhibited by the dipole at e = OO. The
(a) (b)
DIPOLE CARDIOID
PRESSURE GRADIENT PRESSURE GRADIENT
Fig. 5.10 Sensitivity directivity patterna for prea-
sure gradient aensors.
cardioid directivity pattern is not drawn to the same
scale as the dipole pattern.
For the extended element pressure gradient
sensor, consider a neutrally bouyant cylinder of length,
s, spanning the distance between the two sensing points.
If this cylinder is oriented with ita axis parallel to
the direction of sound propagation, it will experience
a force, F = A(P2 - PI) where A ia the area of the end
face, and P1 and P2 are the presaures at the two ends.
Pmin in Eq. (5.11) is equal to P2 - Pl, thus:
F=AP~n=mamin (5.12)
and combining with Eq. (5.11) yields:
5-4
(5.13)
Since neutral bouyancy is required, m/AS = maaa per unit
volume = 1 and Eq. (5.13) becomes:
tin = (2T/k~)pA (5.14)
Thus, once the sound frequency (wavelength, 1s) and
pressure level are chosen, the acceleration can be
determined. For f = 100 Hz (As = 1460 cm) and PA = 50
dB re 1 micropascal, corresponding to the 118-met r
-3
curve that waa shown in Fig.
(1.6 gal).
= 1.67 X 10 g
This requires an5;1;r~%Ny sensitive ac-
celerometer. The two-fiber accelerometer described
below exhibits the required sensitivity.
5.1.3 Fiberoptic Magnetic Sensors
Yariv and Winsor (See Ref. 7) suggested that
an optical fiber could be used to measure the change
in length of a magnetostrictive material subjected to
a magnetic field. The resulting optical phase change
is linearly related to the magnetic field. Jarzynski,
et.al. (See Ref. 8 in Subsection 5.1.7) developed ex-
pressions for the strain induced in a magnetostrictive-
ly-jacketed fiber subjected to a weak axial magnetic
field. These expressions were obtained as a function
of jacket thickness for a variety of magnetostrictive
materials as shown in Fig. 5.11. The magnetooptic
70
-1
*j
aXO
t 4.5% CO.95.5% Ni
10.0
8.0 -
2V-PERMENDUR
6.0 -
4.0 -
2.0 -
I
, , # 1 # 1 , 1
0 5 IO 15 20 25 30 35 40
METAL JACKET THICKNESS (pm)
Fig. 5.11 Magnetic sensitivity of magnetostrictive
metal-jacketed optical fiber as a function
of jacket thickness for various magneto-
strictive metals.
Adapted from J. Jarzynski et al., Appl. Opt. ~, 3746
(1980).
coupling coefficient as shown in Fig. 5.12 was measured
for nickel by Cole, et.al. (See Ref. 9 in Subsection
5.1.7) using a nickel cylinder around which the optical
fiber in one arm of the interferometer was wound as
shown in Fig. 5.13). The relevant theory has been com-
pared with magnetooptical experimental data taken at
low frequency (< 1 kHz) and msgnetomechanical data
taken at frequencies greater than several tens of kilo-
hertz. Thia study demonstrated that the piezomagnetic
atrain coefficient remains constant from low frequency
up to the frequency at which eddy currents become im-
portant. Therefore, the low frequency measurement re-
aults may be uaed to design magnetic sensors that will
operate at high frequencies, i.e., to the eddy current
limit.
J
10 100 1,000 10,000
FREQUENCY (HZ)
Fig. 5.12 The magnetooptic coupling coefficient ver-
sus frequency for an optical fiberwound
nickel toroid with walls 0.038 cm thick.
After J. Cole et al., Opt. Lett. ~, 216 (1981).
\ /-WINDING
.
-TOROIDAL
WINDING
HOUSING
Fig. 5.13 Optical fiber wound on a magnetostrictive
nickel toroid (wall thickneas 0.038 cm) for
use in meaauring the magnetooptic coupling
coefficient.
After J. Cole et al., Opt. Lett. ~, 216 (1981).
Magnetoatrictive materials have been used ex-
tensively as acoustic transducers for the production or
detection of sound. In the preaent application these
materiala are used to detect magnetic fields by measur-
ing the reaulting atrain produced. The most atraight
forward and sensitive technique for such measurements
involvea uaing an optical fiber in one arm of a Mach-
Zehnder interferometer. The fiber is either jacketed
with the magnetostrictive material or wound around a
magnetostrictive mandrel. The resulting change in op-
tical path is due to changes in both the refractive
index and the length of the optical fiber core. This
leads to a phase ahift A+ given by Eq. (5.5) in Subsec-
tion 5.1.2.1. An expression for S11 can be obtained
from the effective piezomagnetic strain constant dT de-
fined by the expression:
dT = 4n(3S11/aH)T (5.15)
where T is the streaa. Integrating this expression
yields:
Sl l = (1/41r) a b dTdH (5.16)
where the limits a and b are Ho-Hi/2 and Ho+H1/2, re-
spectively, H. is the dc bias field choaen to ~ximize
dT, and HI is a small excursion about that point. For
5-5
nickel H. = 3.6 oersteds and for a small excursi n
-8
about the maximum, dT r~~ains constant at 8 x 10 .
Therefore, S1l = 6.4 x 10 HI and:
@/kLHl = 8.6 X 10
-7
oersteda
-1
(5.17)
is the magnetooptic coupling coefficient. This agreea
quite well with the value of coupling coefficient be-
tween 7 and 8 x 10-7 measured by Cole et.al. (See Fig.
5.12 and Ref. 9 in Subsection 5.1.7). The value of dT
used in Eq. (5.16) was measured at approximately 30 kHz
and has been shown to be valid up to the frequency at
which eddy current limitations occur.
Using the measured magnetooptic coupling co-
efficient shown in Fig. 5.12, the minimum detectable
magnetic field (oersteds) per meter of nickel-jacketed
optical fiber can be calculated. From Fig. 5.12, for
A$ = 7.5 x 10I7 kLH, and using k = 7.4 x 10-4 (for 0.85
micron optical radiation), L = 102 cm, and 10-6 radians
minimum detectable phase shift, the minimum detectable
magnetic field for 1 meter of nickel-jacketed optical
fiber is 1.8 x 10-7 oersteds (1.8 x 10-2 gamma). Re-
cently a minimum detectable magnetic field of 5 x 10-9
oersted per meter of fiber waa measured using optical
fiber jacketed with an amorphous magnetostrlctlve mater-
ial (See Ref. 10). Extrapolating to 1 km of such me-
tallic glass-jacketed fiber leads to the prediction
that magnetic fields as amall as 5 x 10-12 oersteds may
be detected by this means. On the other hand a one cm
length of such jacketed fiber should permit the meas-
urement of a magnetic field as small as 5 x 10-7 oersted
(0.05 gamma).
The sensitivities of pressure, magnetic, and
temperature fiberoptic sensors is summarized in Fig.
5.14. The cross section configuration of the various
jacketed optical fiber is shown in the middle column.
The predicted sensitivities corresponding to one mlcro-
radian phase shift for one meter of jacketed fiber is
shown in the last column.
SENSOR TYPES
PRESSURE
MAGNETIC
TEMPERATURE
CONFIGURATIONS
op,Geo~
Si02
LASTOMER
a
SiO*,0e02
SiO*
MAGNETO
STRICTIVE
SiO~
e
Si02, GeO~
METAL
FI?EDICTED PERFORMANCES
A~-W-6RAD, lMETER FISER)
P~NX 60dS re #Pa
HMNZ 5xlo90ERsTED
(METALLIC GLASS)
ATMNZ FTSC
Fig. 5.14 Fiberoptic sensor performance parameters
(coefficients) for several fiber
5.1.4 Fiberoptic Electric Current Sensors
jackets.
Two techniques for measuring electric cur-
rents are shown in Fig. 5.15 (See Ref. 11 in Subjection
5.1.7). In the first, a section of nickel-jacketed
fiber is located in the center of a solenoid energized
by the current being meaaured. By measuring the magne
-
tic field intensity, the electric current is determined.
Using this technique a
1o-8 A/m waa measured
to 5000 Hz.
minimum electric current
over the frequency range
of 3 x
100 Hz
FIBER
a
\
I
ALUMINUM
FIBER TUBING
Fig. 5.15 Fiberoptic senaors for measuring electrical
currents.
After A. Dandridge et al., Electron. Lett. ~, 524
(1981).
The second technique, also shown in Fig. 5.15,
depends on the resistive heating that occurs in a sec-
tion of aluminum jacketed optical fiber as a result of
passing the electric current to be measured through the
jacket. Using this technique aminimum detectable elec-
tric current of 1.3 x 10-5 A/m was measured at 1 Hz.
5.1.5 Fiberoptic Spectrophones
Spectrophones are used to determine the pre-
aence of trace vapors by means of the acoustic signal
produced by the temperature increase associated with
the absorption by the vapor of a pulsed laser output.
Conventional microphones are used to detect the acous-
tic signal. The schematic of a fiberoptic spectrophone
(See Ref. 12 in Subsection 5.1.7) is shown in Fig. 5.16.
339uItleNe
LASER
06328 . H?Ne
LAsER@
Fig. 5.16 A fiberoptic spectrophone for detecting the
pressence of trace vapors.
After D. Leslie et al., Electron. Lett. ~, 581 (1981).
The frequency of the excitation laser is equal to an
excitation frequency in the absorption spectrum of the
trace vapor being detected. The absorption cell con-
sists of a thin walled cylinder around which is wound
a fiberoptic coil to form one arm of a Mach-Zehnder
interferometer. The fiber coil serves as the micro-
phone. It has the advantage of not requiring electri-
5-6
cal leads in the vicinity of the vapor. The chopper
is operated at a frequency at which the acoustic aenai-
tivity of the absorportion cell is high.
The light from the excitation laser excites
a characteristic absorption line in the molecular spec-
trum of the vapor being detected. When the excited
molecules return to equilibrium the temperature of the
vapor Is increased resulting in a preaaure increase.
By chopping (interrupting) the light at a given rate
(frequency), the resultant fluctuation in preasure Is
detected as aound of the same frequency. Even more
desirable 1S to make use of a variable frequency laaer
aa the excitation source. The absorption coefficients
vs. frequency of ambient atmosphere and of methane
whose concentration 1S five times ambient are shown in
Figs. 5.17 and 5.18.
lo~
WAVELENGTH
Fig. 5.17 The absorption coefficient of ambient at-
mosphere aa a function of wavelength.
Provide by D. Leslie, U.S. Naval Reaearch Laboratory.
ABSORBERS
TYPE (TORR)
H20 14.260
C02 0,251
03
2.3x lC5
N20 2.1 X1 O-4
co 5.7 x10-5
II I
I
CH4
121 0-31 1
1~
II
~i
02
159627
22.9C
760 TORR
JJ
WAVELENGTH
Fig. 5.18 The absorption coefficient of methane gas
as a function of wavelength for a concen-
tration of 7.6 x 10-3 torr (5 x ambient).
Provide by D. Leslie, U.S. Naval Research Laboratory.
5.1.6 Summary
The acoustic and magnetic field sensors des-
cribed above represent primary measurement devices.
Other primary measurement devices include sensors to
measure strains, electric fields, temperature, accel-
eration, and rate of rotation. They differ from the
acoustic and magnetic senaors discussed above that rely
on specialized jacketa and utilize a Mach-Zehnder inter-
ferometer. The electric current and trace vapor sen-
sors are secondary devices relying on the measurement
of the magnetic field or the temperature in the former
case and the aound associated with the absorption of
light in the latter case.
5.1.7 References
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
5.2
D. Jackson, A. Dandridge, and S. Sheem, Opt. Lett.
~, 139 (1980).
B. Budiansky, D. Drucker, G. Rino, and J. Rice,
APP1. Opt. ~, 4085 (1979).
G. Hocker, Opt. Soc. Am. ~, 320 (1979).
N. Lagakos and J. Bucaro, Appl. Opt. 20, 2716
(1981).
.-
.- 100 200 300 400
;
FREQUENCY, tiz
Fig. 5.39 The minimum detectable acceleration (g =
9.8m/s2) as a function of frequency for a
simple single-fiber fiberoptic accelero-
meter.
5.3.1 References
1. A. Tveten, A. Dandridge, C. Davis, and T. Giallor-
enzi, Electron. Lett. ~, 854 (1980).
5.4 FIBEROPTIC ROTATION-Fb+TE SENSORS
5.4.1 Introduction
The measurement of rotation is of consider-
able interest in a number of areaa. For example, iner-
tial navigation systems as used in aircraft and space-
craft depend critically on accurate inertial rotation
sensors. The allowable errors in rotation sensor per-
formance depend on the particular application. Typical
requirements for aircraft navigation lie between 0.01
and 0.001 degreeslhour. In terms of earth rotatio
rate, flE = 15 degrees/hour, this becomes 10-3 to 10
-2
!lE. Fig. 5.40 lists several other applications of rota-
tion sensors, such as surveying, where the accurate
determination of azimuth and geodetic latitude is impor-
tant (see Ref. 1, Subsection 5.4.20). In this case
-6 ~ or less iS needed.
performance of 10
2
Geophysics
applications include t e determination of astronondcal
latitude, and the monitoring of polar motion caused by
wobble, rotation, precession and wandering effects (see
Ref. 1, Subsection 5.4.20). A highly precise rotation
sensor may be used to measure any changes in the length
of the day and to detect torsional oscillation in the
earth caused by earthquakes. Finally, ultraprecise
sensors may find applications in relativity-related
experiments such as the determination of the preferred
frame and dragging of inertial frames (see Ref. 2,
Subsection 5.4.20).
G
G
G
G
NAVIGATION WQESIO
3
SURVEYING
AZIMUTH, GEODETIC LATITUDE N <106
flE
GEOPHYSICS
ASTRONOMICAL LATITUDE S106
POIAR MOTION (WOBBLE, NUTATION, PRECESSION,
WANDERING)
LENGTH OF DAY
EARTHQUAKES <1011
RELATIVllV
GLOBAL INERTIAL FRAME
DRAGGING OF INERTIAL FRAMES <1010
Fig. 5.40 Various application areas
aensors.
of rotation-rate
5.4.2 Methods of Rotation Sensing
The popular rotation sensor used over the
past few decades (Fig. 5.41) has been the mechanical
gyroscope which dependa for its operation on the high
angular momentum generated by a spinning wheel or a
spinning ball. The angular momentum of spinning nuclei
has also been investigated for use as a rotation sensor
(see Ref. 3, Subsection 5.4.20). The advent of the
laser in 1960 rekindled the interest in the use of the
Sagnac (see Refs. 4 and 5, Subsection 5.4.20) effect
for the sensing of inertial rotation by purely optical
means. The so-called ring laser gyroscope (see Ref.
6, Subsection 5.4.20) which has been under active de-
velopment for almost two decades has succeeded in ac-
hieving inertial-grade performance and has recently
been selected for use in the new Boeing 757 and 767
aeroplanes and also in other navigation systems. More
recently the availability of low-loss single-mode fi-
bers opened up a very active and very promising area
of research in fiberoptic rotation sensors also based
on the Sagnac effect (see Ref. 7, Subsection 5.4.20).
5-14
G ANGULAR MOMENTUM CRYOSCOPES
MECHANI CAL - ROTATING WHEELIBALL
NUCLEAR - SPINNING NUCLEI
G SAGNAC EFFECT GYROSCOPES
E.M. WAVES
MAITER WAVES
G DISTANT-STARS TRACKERS
SIMPLE STAR TRACKERS
LONG-BASELINE STELL4R INTERFEROMETRY
Fig. 5.41 Various rotation-rate sensor devices.
5.4.3 Interest in Optical Rotation Sensors
The main advantages of optical gyroscopes
over mechanical ones are briefly outlined in Fig. 5.42.
However, it is the promise of the projected low cost of
the optical devices that is driving their development.
G NO MOVING PARTS
G No wARM-UPTIME
G NO G-SENSITIVITY
. LARGE DYNAMIC RANGE
G DIGITAL READOUT
G LOW COST
G SMALL SIZE
G USES LIGHT
Fig- 5.42 Potential advantages of optical rotation-
rate sensors (gyroscopes).
In this section we will give a brief and
ple derivation of the Sagnac effect in vacuum and
in a medium; discuss techniques of implementing
sim-
also
the
Sagnac effect for the measurement of rotation together
with the fundamental limits on sensitivity in each case.
The basic principle of fiberoptic rotation aensors will
then be considered with emphasis on techniques, problem
areas, and recently achieved performance.
5.4.4 Sagnac Effect in a Vacuum
AH the optical rotation sensors under de-
velopment are based on the Sagnac effect (ace Ref. 5,
Subsection 5.4.20) which generatea an optical path dif-
ference AL that is proportional to a rotation rate fl.
For example, if we have a diac of radius R that is
rotating with angular velocity Q, as shown in Fig. 5.43,
the optical path difference AL experienced by light
propagating along opposite directions along the peri-
meter is given by:
AL = (4A/c)$l (5.30)
where A is the area enclosed by the path, i.e., A = ~R2
and c ia the velocity of light in a vacuum.
The rigorous derivation of this formula is
based on the propagation of light in a rotating frame
(see Ref. 5, Subsection 5.4.20) i.e., an accelerating
frame of reference, where the general theory of rela-
tivity must be used to perform the calculation. How-
ever, a simple way of explaining the formula in Eq.
(5.30) iS given in Fig. 5.43. Again, consider the disc
% 1
D
-----------
,
.
iR,,@j 2
1 ,,,
,
.,
,/
.
,,
..-
--
------
{
Lcw=2mR+R~tcw= Ccwtcw
Lccw=27rR-R~tccw= Cc,-wtccw
>tcw= ~c::RRQ
2*R
: tccw = Cccw + RQ
~At=tcwtccw= wR
[2R~ - (Ccw - Cccw) ]
Ccw ccc.
IN A VACUUM CCW=CCCW=C
~ A t = TR ~ O = %() ; ~ AL= LCW LCCW. ~C)
Fig. 5.43 A demonstration of the Sagnac relationships
for the vacuum case.
of radius R rotating with an angular velocity !l about
an axis perpendicular to the plane of the disc. At a
given point on the perimeter, designated by 1 in Fig.
5.43, identical photons are sent in clockwise and coun-
terclockwise directions along the perimeter. If Q = o,
the photons, which travel at the speed of light in a
vacuum, will arrive at the starting point 1 after cover-
ing an identical distance 2?TR in a time t = 2nR/c. Now
in the presence of a disc rotation $2, the ccw photon
will arrive at the starting point on the disc, which is
now located at position 2, after covering a distance
Lccw which iS shorter than the perimeter 2TR given by:
L
Ccw
= 2TR - l?iltccw = cccwtccw (5.31)
where Ri2 is the tangential velocity of the disc and
tccw is the time taken to cover the distance Lccw. I
n
addition, Lccw is also given by the product of the
velocity of light Cccw in the ccw direction and tccw.
For propagation in a vacuum Cccw = C. Similarly, the
photons propagating in the cw direction experience a
larger perimeter Lcw given by:
L
Cw
= 2TR + R!ltcw = ccwtcw (5.32)
Using Eqs. (5.31)
tccw as given In
between clockwise
comes:
At = tcw - tccw
4TR2nlc2 =
and (5.32) we can solve for tcw and
Fig. 5.43 so that the difference At
and counterclockwise propagation be-
.
(21TR)(2Rf0/C2 =
(5.33)
(4A/c2)sl
5-15
The path length AL traveled by light in a time At is
therefore given by:
AL = cAt = (4A/c)fl (5.34)
5.4.5 Sagnac Effect in a Medium
In the case of light propagation in a medium
(see Ref. 5, Subsection 5.4.20) of refractive index n,
(Fig. 5.44) the velocity of propagation must take into
consideration the relativistic addition of the velocity
of light in the medium, i.e., c/n and the tangential
velocity of the medium, i.e., Rfl so that Ccw becomes:
to first
Ccw = (c/n + R.Q)/(l + RQ/nc) =
c/n+RQ(l- l/n2 + ...)
order in VIC. Similarly Cccw,
CCCW = (c/n - IW)/(1 - RQ/nc) =
c/n-RQ(l - l/n2 + ...)
IN A MEDIUM. REFRACTIVE INDEX n
c
~ +RO
c
Cw =
.
~ +RQ (l ~)+..
1+%
2
c
Ti-
R()
C&w = =
,~
nc
c
7i-
Rfl (1-~)+
~Ccw-Cccw=2RQ (1-;)
r
(5.35)
is given by:
(5.36)
This
given
where
corresponds to a nonreciprocal phase shift A$,
by:
A$ = 2~Atc/Ao = 2rAt/(A/V)
(5.40)
= (8.AN/aoC)c?
A = A./n and v = c/n are the wavelength and sc.eed
.
of light in the medium (n is the refractive index of
the fiber core), respectively. In terms of path length
difference:
AL = A4A012T = (4AN/c)!l (5.41)
For a fiber of length L wound in a coil of diameter D:
A = TD2/4 and N = L/nD so that:
AL = (4~/c)n = (LD/c)n (5.42)
or:
AI$ = (2TTLD/aoC)Q (5.43)
5.4.6 The Magnitude of the Sagnac Effect
In order to get a feel for the magnitude of
AL, (Fig. 5.45) assume an area A = 100 au2 and a rota-
~~:~orate of 10-3 ~ (i.e., 0.015/hr or 7 x 10-8 radl
For a single-turn fiber loop enclosing such an
area we get AL . 10-15 cm. This is not a very large
effect considering the diameter of a hydrogen atom is
about IO-8 cm. Clearly, a large number of turns N is
necessary to increase the magnitude of AL.
~A, ~2wR[2R &(Ccw-Cccw)l ~ 2rR12R0-2R62(l-p)j
Ccwcccw
C2
2
EE1
THESAME ASIN AVACUUM
Fig. 5.44 A demonstration of the Sagnac relationships
for the rotating single-loop optical fiber.
Therefore, At in a medium becomes:
At = tcw - tccw
(5.37)
= 21rR[2Ro - (Ccw - cccw)l/[cc#ccwl
UPon substitution for Ccw - Cccw from above, there is
obtained:
At = 21TR[2RQ - 2RQ(I - l/n2]/[c2/n2]
(5.38)
.
21TR(2RQ/C2) = (4A/c2)Q
which is idential to that in a vacuum. If the medium
is an optical fiber wound in a coil of N turns, then At
becomes:
At = (4AN/c2)fl (5.39)
A=100cm2; Q .CiE * 10-4 rad/sec
~ AL*10-12cm
W. DIAMETER- OF HYDROGEN ATOM- lo-8cm
FoR n = 10-3nE = 10-7 radlsec
Fig. 5.45 Computation of the change in effective opti-
cal length (Sagnac effect) in a rotating
single-loop of optical fiber.
5.4.7 Methods of Optical Rotation Sensin&
For the sake of completeness, Fig. 5.46 shows
the various schemes for the measurement of AL. On the
extreme right is the multiturn fiber interferometer
method (see Ref. 7, Subsection 5.4.20) mentioned above.
On the extreme left is the ring laser approach (see
Ref. 6, Subsection 5.4.20) and in the middle is the
passive resonator approach (see Ref. 8, Subsection
5.4.20). In both the active and the passive reaonator
approach, a nonreciprocal path length difference AL due
to the Sagnac effect becomes a nonreciprocal change in
the resonance frequency, Af, of the cavity for CW and
ccw propagation where:
Af = (4A/ioP)$l (5.44)
5-16
where P is the optical perimater of tha path. In the
active resonator (i.e., ring laser) approach the cw and
ccw outputs of the laser have a frequency difference
Af which IS auto~tically generated when the laser is
subjected to a rotation. In the case of the passive
resonator, Af has to be measured by means of lasers
external to the cavity (see Refs. 8 and 9, Subsection
5.4.20).
JIL
SAGNAC EFFECT
I
1
I I
ACTIVE APPROACH PASSIVE APPROACH
[ r {
RING LASER RESONAT OR
II
I NTERFEROMETER
~
c ~0/2
P H O T O N S H O T N O I S E
jf]MFG= LD ~
Fig. 5.48 Photon shot-noise computation for a multi-
turn fiberoptic gyroscope utilizing the
Sagnac effect.
I-7 d
( AL=!$N,,
where r. is the linewidth of the ring laser cavity with
no gain; nph Is the number of photons/see in the laser
beam and T is the averaging time. For the passive res-
onator (PR) case the limit is determined by photon shot
noise and is given by:
H
&@=bA N,,
fcw fccw
A. & -
AL
6nPR
= (kop/4A)(rc/(nphTl~T )12) (5.46)
where q D is the quantum efficiency of the photodetector.
As can be seen, the passive and active resonator ap-
proaches give approximately the same limit. For the
multiturn fiberoptic (FO) interferometer ( see Ref. 11,
Subsection 5.4. 20) the photon shot noise limit is given
by:
Fig. 5.46 Methods of measuring the change in effective
optical length ( Sagnac ef feet).
5.4.8 Fundamental Limits in Optical Rotation
Sensors
M-lFo = (c/LD) (ko/2(nph~JjT )1/2)
(5.47)
Figs. 5.47 and 5.48 show a comparison with-
out derivation of the quantum noise limit for all three
cases. For the ring laser (RL) , the quantum limit comes
from spontaneous emission in the gain (see Ref. 10, Sub-
section 5.4. 20) medium and gives an uncertainty 6!l in
the measurement of Sl given by:
where nph is a number of photons/see leaving the inter-
f erometer. Al these limits are compare
i
-# in Fig. 5.49
for A = 100 cm ; P = 60 cm; 10 = 6 x 10 =3X
1015 photons/see corresponding to 1 mW; L =c~bOn~h(i. e. ,
N = L/P = 1000); rc = 300 kHz; IID = O. 3; and T = 1 sec.
We notice tha the uncertainty d~ in this
-t ,E
example is
about 5 x 10 or O. 008/hr for all three cases.
6%
x oioP/4A)(rc/(nphT) l2) (5.45)
RING LASER PASSIVE RESONATOR FIBER
c
AOI 2
LD j=
G RING LASER GYRO
J-------+
+- + ~+
4 4
1
I
1
1
! SPONTANEOUS
I I
fccw fcw
, EMISSION
,
~2
EXAMPLE: A = 77
P = To
L = NP
= 100 cm
2
; Ao= 6x1O cm
= 40 cm ; n ~h = 3x1015Isec = lmW
= 400 m ; T * 1 sec
,\cJ P I ~
,)!! x
RLG 4A ~
1
\-~:;.+.w- fccw
i
fcw
G PASSIVE RESONATOR GYRO
t+
El
PHOTON
SHOT NOISE
-t
rc x 300 kHz
70
= 0.3
&f)= 4.104QE 7XI0
QE
5X1O4 f)E
0.006 /hr 0.01 Ihr 0.008 O/hr
Fig. 5.49 Computation and comparison of the shot-noise
limits for various types of rotation-rate
sensors utilizing the Sagnac ef feet.
I I
Fig. 5.47 Computation of quantum noise limits in fi-
beroptic rotation-rate sensors.
5-17
5.4.9 Fiberoptic Rotation-Rate Sensors
A simple configuration of a multiturn fiber-
optic rotation-rate aensor (see Ref. 7, Subsection
5.4.20) is shown in Fig. 5.50. Light from a laser or
some other suitable light source ia divided into two
beams by a 50-50 (3 dB) beamsplitter and then coupled
into the two ends of a multiturn (multlloop) single-
mode fiber coil. The light emerging from the two fiber
ends is combined by the beamsplitter and detected in a
photodetector. In the abaence of rotation, the two
emerging beams interfere either destructively or con-
structively depending on the type of beamsplitter used.
For a 50-50 (3 dB) lossless beamsplitter the emerging
beams, as shown in Fig. 5.50, interfere destructively.
NTURNS
d
DETECTOR
L L~cw=~NQ
Cw
c
n
e,g. N=1000:A=100cm2: Q=f)E
=AL~16gcm
-5A
=2X1O
A$=8mANQs10-4 RAD
Aoc
Fig. 5.50 Computation of the phaae change for a multi-
turn fiberoptic interferometric rotation-
rate sensor.
However, the emerging beams that return back to the
light source interfere constructively, i.e., at the peak
of a fringe. In the presence of a rotation rate $2, a
AL will be generated given by:
AL = Lcw - Lccw = (4Atf/c)n = (LDIc)Q (5.48)
where A, N, L, D have been defined earlier. This AL
will therefore cause a fringe shift Az given by:
AZ = (LD/ioC)n (5.49)
or a phase shift of:
A$ = (21TWaoC) (5.50)
For A = ~D2/4 = 100 cm2 and N = L/rD = 1000 (i.e., D
11.3 cm and Lx 355 meters) and if i. = 0.63 ~m and
n= 1.5, we get a phase shift of 3.0 rad for a rotation
rate of 1 rad/sec. Therefore, to detect the full earth
rotation, we must measure a phase shift of 9.1 x 10-5
radians and for typical navigation applicat ons (10-3
~) the phase ahift reduces to about 10
-{
radians.
For a given size sensor, i.e., a fixed coil
diameter D, the sensitivity may be enhanced by increas-
ing the length of the fiber L by adding more turns. Un-
fortunately L cannot be increased indefinitely because
of the finite attenuation of optical power in the fiber.
Typically, for a fiber attenuation rate of 1 dB/km, the
optimum length is several km.
5.4.10 Photon Shot-Noise Limit
Earlier a proof was given of a comparison of
the basic limits to the rotation measurement using the
three techniques outlined in Fig. 5.46. In this section
we will derive an approximate formula for the limit in
a fiberoptic rotation-rate sensor.
Fig. 5.51 shows a plot of intensity I or de-
tector output current iD versus nonreciprocal phase
shift A+ . In this case, the peak intensity, due to con-
structive interference, is shown centered on A$ = O for
a zero rotation rate. In the presence of a rotation,
A+ shifts from zero and therefore a change in detection
current iD occurs. The greatest change in iD for a
given small change in A$ clearly occurs at the point on
the fringe with the maximum slope, i.e., where A$ = +
~12. Therefore, by applying a fixed nonreciprocal bia~
of T/2, the operating point can be maintained where the
sensitivity to rotation is a maximum. In this way, an
applied rotation causes a A$ which in turn generates a
change in the light intensity at the detector that is
proportional to the rotation. A problem arises when the
1
&
I D
,)
INTENSITY NOISE
;1 i
, 1
, 1
, 1
- w OY?$7
)
A+
8(A+)
- PHOTON
/
N O I S E - -
8( AIP)s-=
iD/~ - iD/IT
T
*LS
7r
.
SIN iDm
m
*OC ~=87AN
BUT A@=* Q
AOC
SHOT NOISE
Fig. 5.51 The optical intensity (power) or photode-
tector output current as a function of
phase change and photon shot-noise computa-
tion in a fiberoptic rotation-rate sensor.
intensity of the light source varies since this cannot
be distinguished from a change in intensity due to a
rotation. Therefore, the uncertainty in the measure-
ment of a given rotation rate, i.e., a given A$, must
be influenced by the intensity noise in the light. M-
though there are many ways of compensating for intensity
variations of the light source, it is not, however,
possible to reduce the effect of photon shot noise (see
Ref. 12, Subsection 5.4.20) because it is a random pro-
ceas. Therefore under ideal conditions the uncertainty
in the measurement of A$ ia limited only by the photon
ahot noise (see Ref. 12, Subsection 5.4.20). This un-
certainty 6(A$) is therefore given by:
6(A$) = (photon shot noise)/(fringe alope) (5.51)
5-18
This is a minimum where the fringe slope is a maximum.
In other words:
15(A$) z n(2eiDB)
qiD .
iT(nph~DT )12/nph~DT
(5.52)
where e iS the electron charge; B is the bandwidth of
the detection system; nph is the number of photonsfsec
falling on the detector; ~ is the quantum efficiency of
the detector; and T is the averaging time = l/2B. Since
Eq. (5.50) iS:
A+ = 2nLD/loc
the uncertainty in the measurement of ~, i.e., 6$2, be-
comes:
which :
5.4.11
may be
drift :
not be
62 = Aoc&(A41)/21rLD
= (C/LD)(lo/2)/(nphtlT)l2 = (5.53)
cio/2LD(iD/2eB)112
s the same expression given earlier.
Ideal Performance
The ideal performance of a fiberoptic gyro
summarized as shown in Fig. 5.52. The random
s limited by photon shot noise and there should
any aource of bias or drift in the absence of
rotation. For a given rotation, the stability of the
scale factor, i.e., 2nLD/aoc, which related !2 to Ah
must be limited by the stability of L, D and ~o.
G
G
G
RANDOM DRIFT IS LIMITED BY PHOTON SHOT NOISE
NO BIAS OR DRIFT WHEN!! =0
SCALE FACTOR STABILITY IS LIMITED BY STABILITY OFL,D
ANDAO
Fig. 5.52
5.4.12
cussed in
Ideal performance features of a fiberoptic
rotation-rate sensor (L = coil length, D =
diameter, and i. = source wavelength).
Measurement of Nonreciprocal Phase Shift
In order to reach the ideal performance dis-
the previous section, a number of problems
must be overcome. The measurement of nonreciprocal
phase shift A@ with an uncertainty that is limited only
by the photon shot noise will now be described.
A simple way of measuring A$ is illustrated
in Fig. 5.53, where a T/2 bias is applied so as to oper-
ate at the point of maximum slope. In thia way an in-
crease in intensity correaponda to a negative A$ and
vice veraa. Among the disadvantages of this method is
the stability of the bias and the need to compensate for
laser intensity fluctuations. A better method might be
to employ a differential scheme in which two detectors
are placed astride a fringe as ahown in the lower dia-
gram of Fig. 5.53. l%is scheme has twice the sensitiv-
ity of the first, and better discrimination againat
intensity variations. However, it still suffers from
the instability of the operating points and requires
high common mode rejection.
Fig. 5.53
JtL
o $7 A#J
iii-
I/
-7r 0 r 4#J
Two DC methods for measurement of phase
change, LO, in a fiberoptic rotation-rate
sensor.
A much better method is to use an a.c. modu-
lation scheme employing nonreciprocal phase dither (see
Ref. 11, Subsection 5.4.20) as shown in Fig. 5.54. The
requirements for optimum operation are that the ampli-
tude of the phase modulation should be + r/2 and the
rate of the modulation should be high enou~h so that the
detector noise is dominated by photon shot noise. Fig.
5.55 is a sketch of a typical noise spectrum of a laser
showing the large l/f noise component at low frequen-
cies. The start of the ahot-noise-limited region de-
pends on the particular light source and can be any
where from a few kHz to a few hundred kHz. Using such
.MODULATION METHODS
I
I
D
\,& .+
-w ; o : w
e
~NONRECIPROCAL
PHASE MODULATION
REQUIREMENTS:
G AMPLITuDE*r/2
cRATE HIGH ENOUGH TO GIVE SHOT-NOISE LIMIT
Fig. 5.54 AC measurement of phase change, A$, in a
fiberoptic rotation-rate sensor.
It
INTENSITY
NOISE
PHOTON
1--
SHOT
NOISE
o f
Fig. 5.55 Atypical intensity-noise spectrum of a
laser showing inverae frequency (l/f) and
phase noise.
5-19
a modulation scheme, the output of the photodetector is
demodulated in a phase-sensitive demodulator followed
by a low-pass filter. In this way a zero output is ob-
tained at A$ . 0, a positive voltage for A+< O and a
negative voltag
e
for A$ > 0. The main advantages of the
modulation method are that the peak of the interference
pattern is used as the reference point (i.e., no need
for external offset) and that the null point is inde-
pendent of intensity fluctuations as long as the modula-
tion rate 1S high enough as mentioned above.
5.4.13 Methods of Nonreciprocal Phase Modulation
The various possibilities for achieving non-
reciprocal phase modulation at high rates will now be
described. The phase shift $ that light experiences in
propagating along a single-mode fiber of length L and
refractive index n (Fig. 5.56) given by:
~ = 2~fnL/c (5.54)
where f 1S the frequency of the light in Hz and c is
the velocity of light in a vacuum. It should be noted
that the magnitude of $ does not depend on the direc-
tion of propagation so that $Cw = $Ccw = $. This implies
that if L, n, or f is varied, a nonreciprocal phase
shift cannot be generated.
Therefore, in order to generate a nonrecipro-
cal phase shift, either Lcw ~ Lccw or ncw $ nccw or fcw
+f
Ccw
c
@~w - 4CCW =
~ fn (Lcw Lccw)
but suffers from the fact that orthogonally polarized
beams propagating in the fiber do not experience the
aame index thus generating a temperature dependent bias.
Another method of making ncw # nccw makes use
of the Faraday effect either in the main fiber coil or
In a separate length of fiber. By applying a longitud-
inal magnetic field to the fiber it is possible to cause
the index for right circularly polarized light to be
different from that for left circularly polarized light.
Even though the Verdet constant, i.e., the constant of
proportionality between magnetic field strength and in-
dex difference, is small, it can be enhanced consider-
ably by using a longer length of fiber. Again, this
scheme has been demonstrated recently (see Ref. 14, Sub-
section 5.4.20).
Yet another nonreciprocal index scheme that
has enjoyed much popularity is the time delay modula-
tion method (see Ref. 15, 16, 17, and 18, Subsection
5.4.20), illustrated in Fig. 5.57. In this case advan-
tage is taken of the comparatively long time the pho-
tons spend in the fiber. A typical scheme would be to
A /
* /
OUTPUT
D
2T fL (ncw Ccw)
G 4CW - @ccw ~
14
Cw
$Ccw ~ 2$0 SIN (2T fm ~)
I
4CW - 4CCW = gn Ufcw - fccw)
Fig. 5.56 Various possibilities
phase modulation.
for nonreciprocal
One possibility of making Lcw ~ Lccw whether
In a medium or in a vacuum is to mechanically dither the
interferometer at a high angular rate so that the Sagnac
ef feet itself resulting from this motion can provide the
necessary nonreciprocal phase ahift. This method has in
fact been used in early fiber gyros (see Ref. 13, Sub-
section 5.4. 20) but is clearly not very desirable in
general.
In order to generate a nonreciprocal refrac-
tive index, i.e. , ncw # n
ccw there me a number of meth-
ods that could be used. A simple scheme would be to
make the polarization of, say, the cw beam orthogonal
to the polarization of ccw beam and then use an electro-
optic (E/0) phase modulator to generate a polarization-
dependent refractive index. Such a scheme has been dis-
cussed and demonstrated ( see Ref. 11, Subsection 5.4. 20)
AMPLITUDE OF
PHASE MODULATION
f FOR fm = &
Fig. 5.57 The time-delay modulation method for a non-
reciprocal fiberoptic rotation-rate sensor.
pla~e a phase modulator near the beamsplitter as shown
in Fig. 5.57. The phase modulator can be constructed
in many ways, such as an electrooptic crystal, or a fi-
ber wound around a PZT. Now if the phase modulator is
driven at a frequency fm it is then possible to gener-
ate a nonreciprocal phase shift given by ( see Ref. 18,
Subjection 5.4.20):
r$cw - $Ccw . 2@05in(2nfmTD/2) (5.55)
where $0 is the magnitude of the reciprocal phase shift
generated by the phaae modulation and T ~ is the delay
time in the fiber which is given by nL/c. To maximize
the nonreciprocal phase shift it is necessary to make
the argument of the sin function = n/2 i.e. , by choos-
ing fm = 112 ~. If fm is less than l/2TD, $0 has to be
increased to achieve the appropriate amplitude of the
nonreciprocal phase shift. For a 1 km fiber the opti-
mum f m is about 100 kHz.
5-20
The generation of nonreciprocal phase modula-
tion by the frequency method will now be described (see
Refs. 11 and 18, Subsection 5.4.20). In this scheme
fcw is made different from fccw so that:
@
Cw
-0
Ccw
= (2nnL/c)(fcw - fccw) (5.56)
A simple way of implementing this method is by employ-
ing two acoustooptic (A/0) frequency shifters placed
symmetrically on either side of the beamsplitter within
the interferometer. By driving the A/O with independent
oscillators it is possible to generate both nonrecipro-
cal phaae modulation as well as fixed nonreciprocal
phase shifts. For example, In a 1 km fiber a frequency
difference fcw - f
ccw of 50 kHz generates a nonrecipro-
cal phase shift of T/2.
Related frequency methods have also been in-
vestigated (see Refs. 19 and 20, Subsection 5.4.20).
5.4.14 Open Loop and Closed Loop Operation
The open loop sensor system is shown in Fig.
5.58 where a nonreciprocal phase modulator (NRPM) is
placed near one fiber end and driven at fm. The out-
put of the photodetector is then demodulated at fm in
a phase senaitive demodulator. After low pass filter-
ing the demodulator output is a sinusoidal function of
At as illustrated in Fig. 5.58. For any given A$, a
d.c. voltage output is obtained which is proportional
to A$. The disadvantages of the open loop system in-
clude (a) the calibration of the demodulator output
since this depends on the gains of the various ampli-
fiers that precede it as well as on the intensity of
the light source and (b) the nonlinear behavior of the
demodu~ator output with A$.
LIGHT
SOURCE
DETECTOR
1,
OUTPUT I
w
AIP
Fig. 5.58 Open-loop nonreciprocal phase modulation in
a fiberoptic rotation-rate sensor.
In the closed loop system (see Refs. 11 and
18, Subsection 5.4.20), shown in Fig. 5.59, the output
of the demodulator is passed through a servo amplifier
which then drives a nonreciprocal phase transducer
(NRPT) placed within the fiber interferometer. In this
way, the sensor is always operated at null, i.e., at
A+ = O by generating a suitable nonreciprocal phase
shift in the NRPT that is equal to but opposite in sign
to that generated by a rotation 0. The output of the
system ia then the output of the NRFT. Therefore, the
NRFT becomes a critical element.
II
T
NRPT
LIGHT
NRPM I
1. A II
I l--cl
w fm
~ETEcToRL A I
-u
Smo
*
DEMOD
OUTPUT
A+
/
NULL
Fig. 5.59 Closed-loop nonreciprocal phase modulation
in a fiberoptic rotation-rate sensor.
She advantages of the closed loop system over
the open loop system include (a) the output is indepen-
dent of light source intensity variations since the sys-
tem ia always operated at null (the modulation frequency
must be high enough to reach the photon shot noise);
(b) the output is independent of the gains of individual
components in the measurement system as long as a very
high open-loop gain is maintained; and (c) the output
linearity and stability depends only on the NRPT.
The NRPT could, for example, be a Faraday ef-
fect device or an acoustooptic frequency shifter. If a
Faraday device is used, then the stability depends on
the stability of the length of the fiber and the atabil-
ity of the magnetic-field/phase-shift transfer func-
tion. However, if the NRPT is an acoustooptic crystal,
then a frequency difference Af = fcw - fccw is generated
to offset a A$ = (21TLD/loC)n caused by a rotation.
Therefore:
A+ = 2rAfnL/c = (21TLD/aoC)il (5.57)
which implies that:
Af = (D/nAo)!2 (5.58)
Eq. (5.58) indicates that the scale factor stability
depends on the coil diameter D, n, and ~. If the nu-
merator and denominator of Eq. (5.58) is multiplied by
nD/4, then:
Af = [(nD2/4)/(nlomD/4)]~ = (4A/XoP)fl (5.59)
where P is the optical perimeter = nTD of the fiber
coil. It should be noted that Eq. (5.59) is identical
with Eq. (5.44) for either the ring laser or the passive
reaonator approach.
5.4.15 Problems in Fiberoptic Rotation Sensors
So far the basic principles of fiber rotation-
rate sensors with emphasis on the measurement of small
nonreciprocal phase shift in a multiturn fiber inter-
ferometer have been described. A number of error aources
that can influence the performance of the fiber gyro
will now be described briefly.
5-21
Fig. 5.60 lists several sources of error that
must be dealt with in order to achieve the predicted
performance. Perhapa the major source of noise is back-
scattering within the fiber (see Ref. 21, Subsection
5.4.20) and at interfaces, particularly in a setup that
employs discrete components. To overcome this problem,
researchers have used broadband lasers (see Ref. 17 and
22, Subjection 5.4.20), frequency jittered lasers (see
Ref. 18, Subsection 5.4.20), phase modulators, (see Ref.
23, Subsection 5.4.20), and even light-emitting diodes
(LED) (see Ref. 24, Subsection 5.4.20). By destroying
the temporal coherence of the light source the detection
system becomes sensitive only to the interference be-
RAYLEIGH SCAITERING IN FIBER
SCAITERING FROM INTERFACES
POLARIZATION EFFECTS
PRESENCE OF HIGHER ORDER MODES
TEMPERATURE GRADIENTS
NONIDEAL MODULATORS
NONIDEAL POLARIZERS
INTENSITY DEPENDENT NONRECIPROCITY
LIGHT SOURCE PROBLEMS
MEASUREMENT SYSTEM PROBLEMS
STRESS INDUCED EFFECTS
MAGNETIC FIELD EFFECT
Fig. 5.60 Sources of noise and errors that must be
considered in the design of a fiberoptic
rotation-rate sensor.
tween waves that followed identical counter-propagating
paths. Thus, interference due to backacattering will,
in principle, average to zero.
The problem that has received much attention
both theoretically (see Refs. 25 and 26, Subsection
5.4.20) and experimentally (see Ref. 17, Subsection
5.4.20) is the error due to the polarization behavior
of the optical fiber. By uaing polarizers to establish
the axis of polarization (see Ref. 26, Subsection
5.4.20) in the long-fiber interferometer, it has been
possible to reduce polarization-dependent errors. The
use of the now available single-mode polarization-pre-
serving fibers (see Ref. 27, Subsection 5.4.20) may
turn out to be a convenient solution.
All the fiber gyros under study so far have
used single mode fibers. Care has to be taken to insure
that higher order transverse modes are highly attenuat-
ed.
A number of error sources are related to tem-
perature gradients, (see Ref. 28, Subsection 5.4.20)
non-ideal polarizers, (see Ref. 29, Subsection 5.4.20)
non-ideal modulators, stress induced effects, external
magnetic field effects (see Ref. 30, Subsection 5.4.20)
and electronics problems in the measurement system.
A very basic source of nonreciprocal phase
shift has been uncovered, namely that due to unequal
intensities propagating along opposite directions in
the fiber (see Ref. 31, Subsection 5.4.20). This is a
nonlinear optical effect based on four-wave mixing that
takes place in a fiber having a third order nonlinear
susceptibility. Such an intensity-induced nonrecipro-
city may be reduced by maintaining equal intensities
in the counterpropagating beam.
5.4.16 Integrated Fiber Gyros
Although the early investigation of fiberop-
tic gyros employed (see Refs. 19, 30, 32 and 33, Sub-
section 5.4.20) discrete optical components for conven-
ience, it is clear that if fiber gyros are to make a
large impact an integrated (see Ref. 34, Subsection
5.4.20) optical system (Fig. 5.61) with a semiconductor
laser/LED as a light source must be uaed. Beamsplitters
can be replaced by either waveguide or fiber 3-dB coup-
lers (see Ref. 17, Subsection 5.4.20). Nonreciprocal
4
I NR MODULATOR
I
Q=POuTpuT
f~
Fig. 5.61 An open-loop integrated fiberoptic rota-
tion-rate sensor employing a phase trans-
ducer.
phase modulators may employ a short length of fiber
wound around a PZT, the Faraday ef feet, an integrated
Bragg cell, or other features.
Integrated polarizers (see Ref. 17, Subsec-
tion 5.4. 20) and polarization controllers (see Ref. 17,
Subsection 5.4. 20) are also feasible.
In the closed
loop approach shown in Fig. 5.62 the nonreciprocal
phaae transducer could be a Bragg cell, a Faraday ef-
fect device, or other device. In other words various
possibilities exist for constructing a solid-state fi-
ber gyro. An all-optical-fiber open-loop system has
already been demonstrated with a very promising perfor-
mance (see Ref. 17, Subsection 5.4.20).
I
SERVO
DETECTOR
f~
Fig. 5.62 A closed-loop integrated
tion-rate sensor employing
ducer.
fiberoptic rota-
a phase trans-
5-22
5.4.17 ~
Once the various noise mechanisms in fiber
gyros were uncovered and understood, published perform-
ance data began to improve rapidly. Fiber gyros employ-
ing several hundred meters of fiber wound around a coil
of 15 to 20 cm in diameter have demonstrated short term
drifts in the range of 0.1 - O.01/hr for averaging
times of about 10 seconds (see Refs. 17 and 18, Subsec-
tion 5.4.20). Long term drift of O.lO/hr for more than
one hour has also been demonstrated (see Refs. 17 and
18, Subsection 5.4.20).
5.4.18 Summary of Rotation-Rate Sensors
In summary, fiberoptic rotation sensors have
demonstrated promising preliminary performance. However
most of the causes of short term noise are understood,
the causes of long term drift need further study. Clear-
ly, the emphasis must now be placed on integrated de-
vice development.
5.4.19 General Conclusions Regarding Fiberoptic
Sensors
It may be concluded for this entire chapter
that fiberoptic sensors demonstrate tremendous poten-
tial for application in any area that requires the sens-
ing of physical parameters, including electric fields,
magnetic fields, forces, temperature, pressure, linear
and rotation displacements, velocities, and accelera-
tions. Application areas include navigation, medical
engineering, surveying, transportation, telemetry (com-
munication), in fact, any area in which measurements
are to be made.
5.4.20 References
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
D.H. Eckhardt, Proc. Soc. Photo-Opt. Instru. Eng.
~, 172 (1978).
M.O. Scully, in Proc. of the Fifth International
Conf. on Laser Spectroscopy, H. Walther and K.
Rothe, eds. (Springer-Verlag, Berlin, 1979); M.P.
Haugan, M.O. Scully, and K. Just, Phys. Lett. ~,
88 (1980).
J.H. Simpson, Astron. & Aeron. ~, #10, 42 (1964).
G. Sagnac, Compt. Rend=, 708 (1913).
E.J. Post, Rev. Mod. Phys. 39, 475 (1967).
5-23
CHAPTER 6
FIBEROPTIC SENSOR ARRAYS
AND TELEMETRY SYSTEMS
Ease of multiplexing and modulation and the
fundamental properties of lightwaves and optical fibers
make them suitable for use in multisensory uniform and
random arrays for many different applications. This
chapter will cover the important characteristics of sen-
sor arrays, their connection into telemetry systems for
transmission of baseband data within the array, and the
characteristics of fiberoptic transmission lines for
telecommunication systems.
6.1 FIBEROPTIC SENSOR ARRAYS
6.1.1 Fiberoptic Sensor Array Design
Considerations
6.1.1.1 General Design Considerations
The sensor system selected for a particular
application will depend on many considerations.
For
example, the individual sensors that are selected de-
pend on the parameter to be sensed, the sensitivity re
-
quired, the dynamic range of the parameter to be sen-
sed, the baseband frequencies, and the noise and Power
levels. The geographic distribution of the sensors in
an array will be governed by the distribution of loca-
tiona at which parameters are to be aenaed. Other
variables to be selected are the modulation scheme and
whether an analog or a digital form will be used for a
particular application. These and other considerations
may be summarized as follows:
FIBEROPTIC SENSOR ARRAY DESIGN CONSIDERATIONS
SENSOR TYPE
Intensity Modulation
Phase Modulation
Frequency Modulation
Polarization Modulation
Wavelength Modulation
DISTANCE BETWEEN SENSOR ELEMENTS
ANALOG VS DIGITAL TRANSMISSION
SIMPLEX, DUPLEX, MULTIPLEX, OR COMBINATION
SIGNAL PROCESSING REQUIREMENTS
SENSOR/LINR CALIBRATION REQUIREMENTS
POWER LEVELS
SYSTEM NOISE
NUMEER OF SENSOR CHANNELS
MAXIMUM FREQUENCY OF SIGNAL INFORMATION
OPERATIONAL NOISE ENVIRONMENT
SIGNAL DYNAMIC RANGE
SENSOR LEAD LENGTHS
DESIRED TRANSMISSION SCHEME
DESIRED MULTIPLEXING
6.1.1.2 Specific Design Considerations
Detailed design considerations for a fiber-
optic sensor array and associated telemetry depend on
the method of energizing the array, the type of sensor
used, and the telemetry methods that are used. Design
aspects differ from one basic configuration to another,
therefore detailed design aspects will be discussed in
the next subsection, Fiberoptic Sensor Array Basic Con-
figurations.
6.1.2 ~
The method of energizing an array and the
type of fiberoptic sensors used in the array are often
interrelated. For example, suppose an array of base-
band-modulated darkfield microbend sensors are each
sequentially mounted on a single fiber and each is pre-
ceded by a mode-stripper in such a manner that each
microbend sensor of the baseband signal causes an amount
of light proportional to the baseband signal amplitude
to enter the cladding. Following each microbender is
a tap designed to remove this baseband signal from the
cladding and send it via the tap (coupler) to a common
return bus.
photodetected
PULSED
LIGHT
SOURCE
(LASER) 1
The return bus output signals may be
as shown in Fig. 6.1. If the array is
MODE STRIPPER MODE STRIPPER
TAP TAP TAP
DETECTOR
BUS COUPLERS
Fig. 6.1 A fiberoptic darkfield microbend sensor ar-
ray telemetry system with single return bus.
a linear array of equally spaced sensors and the opti-
cal feed bus is pulsed, the pulses on the return bus
will be automatically time-division multiplexed for
the return telemetry. If the sensors are not equally
spaced and the amount of fiber required to create
equal spacing is excessive, the arrangement shown in
Fig. 6.2 can be used. The source output is continuous
in this case. Each microbend cladding mode stripper
output is fed to a separate photodetector via an inde-
pendent optical fiber as shown in Fig. 6.2. Return
telemetry for both of these arrangements is discussed
below in greater detail. Both of these arrangements
make use of darkfield sensing.
6-1
CONTINUOUS
LIGHT
MICROBEND SENSOR ARRAY
MODE STRIPPER
MODE STRIPPER
STRIPPER
,
. .
: :
. .
Fig. 6.2 A fiberoptic darkfield microbend sensor ar-
ray telemetry system with multiple cable
return.
Brightfield sensing can also be accomplished
in a fiberoptic sensor array as shown in Fig. 6.3. A
STAR COUPLER
I
.
.
.
.
CONTINUOUS
\ .)
)
: MICROBEND BRIGHTFIELD
SENSOR ARRAY
DETECTOR
ARRAY
Fig. 6.3 A fiberoptic microbend brightfield star-
coupler-fed sensor array telemetry system.
star coupler is fed by a continuous light source, e.g.,
a laser or an LED. Each output of the star-coupler is
fed to a baseband-modulated microbend fiberoptic bright-
field sensor. The output signal of each fiberoptic
sensor in the array is separately fed to an array of
photodetectors for further processing and transmission.
~so, an electrical power bus to a light source (LED)
at each sensor can be used to energize the baseband-
modulated microbend fiberoptic brightfield sensor as
shown in Fig. 6.4. The electrical bus is continuously
LIGHT SOURCE
ELECTRICAL POWER BUS
)
I
F
....
(LED) (LED) (LED)
.
G MICROBEND SENSOR
.
.
ARRAY
.
.
.
Fig.
.
/
DETECTOR ARRAY
6.4 A fiberoptic microbend brightfield electri-
cal-bus-fed sensor array telemetry system.
energized and either the return optical cables are each
returned to a photodetector in an array, or the return
bus may be a single optical cable with time-division
multiplexed signals from equally-spaced sensors fed to
a single photodetector as discussed earlier.
The sensor array can also consist of an array
of optical grating sensors that modulate the output of
individually-coupled light sources (LEDs) powered by
light pulses on a common electrical bus as shown in
Fig. 6.5. The grating outputs are individually coupl-
ELECTRICAL POWER BUS
>
I
:
fl
))
PHOTODETECTOR
ARRAY
Fig. 6.5 A fiberoptic optical grating electrical-
bua-fed senaor array telemetry system.
ed to photodetectors in an array via fiberoptic cables.
Some of the performance features of these and other
fiberoptic sensor array configurations will now be
discussed in some detail.
An array of sensors may be used to beam-form
or to signal average. In the former case it is neces-
aary to distinguish, i.e. maintain separation of, the
output signals from the individual sensors. In the
latter case the signals from a number of sensors are
summed (OR-gated). For example, beam forming is used
in echo ranging, while averaging can be used to dis-
criminate between signals that arrive normal (perpen-
dicular, transverse) to a linear array and those that
arrive parallel (longitudinal) to the array. Thus,
very often the spatial distribution of an array of
fiberoptic sensors can be used to accomplish the multi-
plexing, mixing, or summing, of signals from the array.
Although the principle of operation of only a linear
array of sensors will be discussed, the same principles
can be applied to multidimensional arrays.
A linear array of fiberoptic sensors may be
energized by means of a common bus. The bus may be an
electrical conductor, fed by a direct-current power
source or an alternating-current power source, or the
bus may be an optical fiber fed by a relatively high-
powered optical continuous-output source, such as a
laser. Alternatively, in each of these situations, the
power source output can be pulsed rather than be con-
tinuous, giving rise to four posaible arrangements,
namely continuous electrical, continuous optical,
pulsed electrical, and pulsed optical power. In any
caae, the fiberoptic sensors (transducer, modulators)
in the linear array may be either directly connected
to the optical bus by means of a fiberoptic coupler,
or a light source at each sensor may be connected to
the electrical bus. The selection of the appropriate
6-2
method of sensor energization will depend on the power
budget, risetime budget, distances to and within the
array, and other matters related to the specific appli-
cation.
The physical parameter variation (baseband)
to be sensed, such as a sound wave, a magnetic field
variation, a pressure wave, or a force variation, will
modulate the optical input to the fiberoptic sensor,
thus producing an optical baseband-modulated signal out-
put. This sensor output signal can be telemetered to a
distant location (for detection and processing) in any
of a number of different ways depending on spatial,
timing, compositional, and other factors.
For the pulsed-bus method of energization of
an equally-spaced linear array of sensors, spatial dis-
tribution of the sensors will cause the baaeband-modu-
lated output signal pulse from each sensor of the array
to occur at a different time according to the time it
takes for a pulse to propagate from one sensor to an
-
other. If these signals are all fed into a single
common return bus, they will be automatically time-
division multiplexed on that bus. This arrangement is
shown in Fig. 6.6. Assume a pulse of light is dis-
PHOTO PULSED
OETECTOR SOURCE
I r
PULSED SOURCE OPTI CAL FEEO BUSwlTH M.l
LENGTHL~
)J
LINEAR ARRAY
SPACEDINTENSITY-
. . .
MODULATION
{r
)J
EQUALLY-SPACEO PULSES IN AN OPTICAL RETURN SUS
Fig. 6.6 A fiberoptic darkfield optical-bus-fed sen-
sor array telemetry system with single op-
tical return bus.
patched along the feed bus. A coupler at each sensor
location taps a fraction of the light from the bus.
The pulse of light enters each sensor in turn where it
is modulated by the baseband signal imposed by the sen-
sor. The modulated pulse travels via the return bus
bsck to the photodetector for further processing. The
minimum time that can be allowed for the spacing be-
tween the leading edges of pulses in the return bus is
the propagation time between a given sensor location
and the next sensor in the array and return to the given
sensor location. The distance between sensors is
L/(m - 1), where L is the length of the linear array
and m is the number of sensors. The wave has to travel
the distance between aensors in the feed bus and in the
return bus, therefore the travel distance is 2L/(m - 1).
The speed of propagation of a lightwave in the bus is
c/n, where c is the speed of light in a vacuum and n
is the refractive index of the core. It iS assumed the
refractive index is the same for both busses. The time
of propagation is the distance divided by the speed,
thus, the time between leading edges of output pulses
is:
to=2[L/(m-1)] /(c/n)=2nL/c(m-1) (6.1)
The pulse repetition rate (PRR) of the pulses emanating
from the linear senaor array is given by:
Warray
= l/t = c(m - 1)/2nL (6.2)
For 50 sensors in a linear array, an optical
fiber bus core refractive index of 1.5, a linear array
500 meters long, Eq. (6.1) indicates that the time be-
tween the leading edges of array output pulses is:
to=(2)( l.5)(500)/3(108) (49)=102 ns (6.3)
The corresponding pulse repetition rate, PRR, is:
PRR = l/t. = 1/102(10-9) = 9.8 kfPPS. (6.4)
Thus, the input feed bus pulses cannot be
wider than to. This is the rate at which the baseband-
signal modulated pulses will emerge from the input-out-
put end of the array. Also, some time should be allowed
between pulses for random variations of sensor spacing,
delays through sensor leads from and to the busses, and
pulse risetimes. Therefore, the pulse length should
not exceed 0.9to or about 90 ns for the above example.
If they are wider, they are liable to overlap in the
return bus. They can be narrower. The pulses will ar
-
rive as a train of pulses at the photodetector. The
pulses in the train will come from and be in the same
sequence as the sensors are positioned in the linear
array. These events occur each time the feed bus is
pulsed and as many pulses will be in each array output
pulse train as there are sensors in the array. The
photodetector must be capable of responding to about
10 Mpps for the above example. If any analog-to-digi-
tal (A-D) conversion is to take place in a single A-D
converter fed by the return bus, the length of the
pulses must be long enough to allow for analog to digi-
tal conversion. The repetition rate of the pulses in
the train can be reduced by placing additional fiber
between the sensors or by using a fiber with a higher
refractive index, as indicated by Eq. (6.2).
Various methods can be used to telemeter the
sensor-modulated signals from the sensor array to a
photodetector. For example, the detector could be an
optical repeater if long distance optical transmission
is required, or the output of the photodetector could
be transmitted electrically, via a wire line, coaxial
cable, or radio-link. The radio frequency carrier
could be modulated by the detected analog pulses or by
an analog-to-digital converter output. The above dis-
cussion applies each time a single light pulse is sent
along the fiber bus. The maximum safe pulse duration
was shown to be, from Eq. (6.1) and allowing a 10%
safety margin:
msx
= 1.8nL/c(m - 1) (6.5)
The maximum rate at which the pulses can be
dispatched down the optical fiber feed bus is limited
by the overall length of the array. Each pulse must
travel twice the full length of the array and clear the
first sensor before the next pulse can be applied to
the array. This maximum pulse rate is the maximum rate
at which the baseband signal inputs to the fiberoptic
aensors can be sampled. The minimum time between lead-
ing edges of feed bus pulses is twice the time length
of the array, plus the pulse length (maximum possible
pulse width is assumed) plus a safety margin for rise-
time and settling time. Therefore, these considera-
tions will yield a minimum sampling period ts of:
t+ = 2nL/c + 1.8nL/c(m - 1) + tr
(6.6)
ts
= [2 + 1.8/(m - l)]nL/c + tr
where m is the number of aenaors in the linear array, n
is the refractive index of the fiber busses, L is the
length of the array, c is the velocity of light in a
6-3
vacuum, and t= is the overall risetime to be calculat-
ed later in this chapter. This value of ta can be re-
duced to the extent that the pulse width can be reduc-
ed. If there are only a few sensors in the array the
second term in bracketa in Eq. (6.6) is significant.
As the number of sensors is increased, the second term
in Eq. (6.6) becomes less significant. Eq. (6.6) does
not apply to one senaor because then L = O, the second
term in brackets becomes indeterminate, and in fact
there is no array. In this case, only the risetime
requirement will place a limit on the sampling period.
The maximum permissible sampling rate PR~s is:
Pluqs.= l/ts (6.7)
where ts is defined in Eq. (6.6). The sampling rate
can be arbitrarily reduced, but should not be less than
twice the highest significant frequency component in
the baseband signal in order to obtain reproduction of
the baseband signal without significant distortion
(Nyquist criterion).
Another method for energizing an array of sen-
sors is to connect the array to a pulsed electrical bus
as shown in Fig. 6.7, rather than the pulsed optical
7I 1 w ,
LENGTH L-~
WLSSDELECTRICALF
L-RARRAY
OFMEWY
SPACEDSENZORS
WITNLSOAND
INTSN.91v-M~L4T10N
EWAUY-SPACEDPJSES NANOFTCAL REluRssus SENSORS
Fig. 6.7 A fiberoptic lightfield pulsed
bus-fed sensor array telemetry
single optical return bus.
electrical-
system with
bus just described. A light source, such as an LED, is
optically connected to each sensor. Thia is the bright-
field form of senaor energization. The return bus can
be the same, as was shown in Fig. 6.6, and the analysis
above still applies except that the propagation time
in the electrical bus will be different. In this case,
the electrical sampling pulae period will be:
telec=l/2 [ts+[2+l.8/(m-l)]L/v+trc] (6.8)
where the variables are as in Equation (6.6), v is the
velocity of propagation in the electrical bus, and trc
is the combined electrical and optical risetimes that
will be discussed later in this chapter.
Another configuration for energizing a ran-
domly-distributed (non-linear) array of fiberoptic aen-
sors is shown in Fig. 6.8. A continuous source of
light (laser) energizes a star coupler that may be
placed at the center of the array to reduce fiber re-
quirements. The output of the coupler is fed to each
fiberoptic sensor where it is modulated by the baseband
signal. The senaor outputs are individually fed to an
arrayof photodetector (PDs). In the arrangement
shown in Fig. 6.8, the inputs to the photodetector (PD)
array (one PD for each sensor) are time-division multi-
plexed, sampled, digitized, and telemetered as a digi-
tal data bit stream via a fiberoptic cable to another
location for exploitation. In this case, there ia no
requirement for any specific spatial relationship among
the sensors. The minimum sampling period for each sen-
sor tssen in the array will be:
asen
= mtad (6.9)
where m is the number of sensors in the array and tad
is the analog-to-digital conversion time. This pre-
sumes a photodetector for each sensor output, a multi-
plexer (for polling each photodetector output), and a
aingle A-D converter with its sample-and-hold and other
associated circuitry aa shown in Fig. 6.8.
>#
I
l--+-l
EEk5?ltlzl
Fig. 6.8 A fiberoptic star-coupler-fed sensor random
array telemetry system with multiple and
single cable returns.
The random array of fiberoptic sensors may be
energized instead by a direct-current electrical bus
as shown in Fig. 6.9. In this case, there is a contin-
CONTFWOUS (DC) ELECTRICAL FEED BUS
J
Fig. 6.9 A fiberoptic electrical direct-current bus-
fed sensor array telemetry aystem
multiple and single cable return.
with
The
is
uous-output light source (LED) for each sensor.
baseband-modulated optical output of each sensor
separately cabled to a photodetector array and proces-
sed there in a manner similar to the preceding arrange-
ment that had the continuous optical feed as was shown
in Fig. 6.8.
6-4
The preceding discussion applied primarily to
intensity-modulated lightfield and darkfield sensors.
The outputs of arrays of other tYPes of sensors can
also be telemetered to locations distant from the sen-
sors. An interferometer sensor array configuration is
shown in Fig. 6.10. The optical outputs of all fiber-
. . .
(REPEAT OF
R,GT S,DE,
OPTICAL BuS
m
L...-.!
\
I
COUPLERS
ELECTROOPTIC
PHOTODETECTORS
INTEGRATED CHIP
DETECTIONIFEEDBACK
DIGITIZATION(MULTIPLEXER
LED
CLOCK
L
Fig. 6.10 A fiberoptic interferometric star-coupler-
fed sensor array telemetry system with op-
tical multiple cable and single cable re-
turn and integrated optical circuit chip.
optic sensors are brought to a common point, an elec-
trooptic chip. The integrated optical chips are not
yet commercially available, however, they are under
development. A single optical fiber is used to conduct
the output of the electrooptic chip to a distant loca-
tion. Ml signal processing is done at the array loca-
tion on the chip. The output of each senaor is sent
to the single integrated fiberoptic chip for processing
via a separate fiber. If It should prove desirable to
use less fiber, use can be made of the spatial separa-
tion between sensors and the outputs can be automatic-
ally time-division multiplexed provided the signal pro-
cessing can be accomplished at each interferometric
sensor as ahown in Fig. 6.11. In this arrangement, a
single optical return bus is used to telemeter the out-
puts to a distant location.
T!+AE Owwm
0
~-
LASER 1
I
REFEREW3EARM
II
II
>
ELECTROOPTCCH!P
POWER
1
Tlt.lEDIvISlON
MULTIPLEXER
MULTI PLEXER
ELECTRCAL BUS :
L---. ...__._J
Fig. 6.11 A fiberoptic interferornetric star-coupler-
fed equally spaced sensor array telemetry
system with electrical outputs to a single
electrical return bus.
There are many other variations and combina-
tions of the basic fiberoptic sensor-array telemetry
schemes shown here. The basic options include the
selection of the type of telemetry link (to and from
the sensor array, electrical, optical, or electroopti-
cal); the type of fiber optic sensor (interferometric,
intensity, phase, darkfield, brightfield); the type of
coupling (star, tapped bus); the type of light sources
(laser-powered or LED-powered bus, LED at each sensor);
signal types (analog, discrete); multiplexing schemes;
and many others. Each of these options will incur a
different set of technical problems that require solu-
tion, a different set of costs, and a different set of
performance characteristics. For example, frequency-
division multiplexing of fiberoptic sensor outputs can
also be applied by energizing the common feed bus of
the equally-spaced-sensor arrays discussed earlier with
a constantly-changing-frequency pulse (frequency ramp).
Thus, each fiberoptic sensor in the linear equally-
spaced array will be fed a different frequency to be
modulated by the baseband signal. The outputs can be
demultiplexed with appropriate narrowband filters.
6.1.3 Fiberoptic Sensor Array Budgets
Fiberoptic aensor array budgets may be pre-
pared in much the same manner as for the telemetry bud-
geta to be described in Subsection 6.2.3. Risetime,
power, cost, and other budgets for fiberoptic sensor
arrays depend on the same set of factors as for the
entire sensor-telemetry system. tin optical power bud-
get for the sensor array shown in Fig. 6.20 is as
follows:
SENSOR ARRAY POWER BUDGET
OUTPUT POWER
Laser output power 7 mW = 38.5 dB VW
Coupling loas in fiber
pigtail (78% Coupling)
AVERAGE POWER OUTPUT
SYSTEM LOSS
Star coupler insertion loss
Star coupler splitting loss (1:60)
Coupler insertion loss (2, ldB each)
3 dB coupler aplitting loss
Fiber loss (300 m, 5 dB/km)
Splicing loss (6, 0.5 dB each)
TOTAL
TOTAL
POWER
.
6.2
optic
SYSTEM LOSS
AVAILABLE MARGIN 37.3 - 29.3 =
MARGIN AT EACH DETECTOR
Antilog of 0.80 =
FIBEROPTIC TELEMETRY SYSTEMS
- 1.2 dB
37.3 dB UW
2.0 dB
17.8
2.0
3.0
1.5
3.0
29.3 dB
8.0 dB VW
6.3 UW
The properties of optical fibers and fiber-
sensors have been discussed in detail in prior
chapters where particular attention was given to con-
struction (materials and geometry), principles of opera-
tion (light transmission properties of fibers), and
relative advantages of fiberoptic sensors over other
types of sensors. Various ways were discussed in which
fiberoptic sensors can be designed to measure absolute
magnitudes or relative changes of a physical parameter,
develop an output signal that is a function of these
absolute or relative values, and emit this signal in a
form suitable for subsequent processing and transmis-
sion. In essence, the fiberoptic aensor is a trans-
ducer; it provides the transform that enables an on-
6-5
site measurement of a physical parameter to be repre-
sented in a form (baseband signal) that can be directly
and immediately processed and transmitted to another
location, where it can be further processed and ex-
ploited for any desired use or application. Most, if
not all, applications will require that the signal from
a sensor be telemetered to a location other than the
point of its generation. There are virtually no limits
on the range of telemetering distances that may be re-
quired. llus, many fiberoptic sensors permit direct
optical data transmission without conversion to elec-
trical signals until photodetection. This section will
be devoted to the configuration and use of fiberoptic
sensor arrays, the telemetering of their outputs to
other locations, and the reconversion of these signals
to useful forms. Topics include system considerations,
sensor systems, data transmission, data link analysis,
repeater design, cable and connector design, and the
budgeting of time, power and cost in telemetry systems.
These topics may be summarized as:
FIBEROPTIC: TELEMETRY SYSTEMS
SYSTEN GENERAL CONSIDEIbiTIONS
LINR ANALYSIS: RISETINE, POWER,
AND COST BUDGETS
SENSOR SYSTEMS
REPEATER DESIGN
CABLE AND CONNECTOR DESIGN
END-TERMINAL RECEIVER CONSIDERATIONS
The basic components of a telemetry system, from the
sensors of the variations of a physical parameter to
the instruments for displaying, recording, or simply
using a representation of the variation at some desti-
nation user location are shown in Fig. 6.12.
?
P PHYSICAL
PARAMETER
0
TRANSDUCER
I s-f(p)
El
ENCODER
MOOULATOR
MULTIPLEXER
CONVERTER
TRANSMITTER
SOURCE
Y
END INSTRUMENT
DISPLAY
SOUND
RECORD
COMPUTE
E@
TRANSMI SSI ON
I
SINK
Fig. 6.12 Basic components of a fiberoptic array
telemetry system.
6.2.1
Fiberoptic Telemetry System Design OptiOnS
Mny options are open to the designer of a
fiberoptic telemetry system. These include the deter-
mination of the overall system configuration; the de-
sign and selection of fiberoptic senaors, cables, and
connectors; the design and selection of transmitters
and receivers; and the specification of system para-
meters, such as signal-to-noise ratios, distortion
limits, permissible bit error-rates, multiplexing
schemes, modulation methods, and the coding, sensing,
and detection arrangements.
6.2.2 Fiberoptic Telemetry System Basic
Configurations
Perhaps the most general telemetry system
configuration is the multisource (sensor array), multi-
user (user-array) general communication network-con-
nected system shown in Fig. 6.13. The simplest system
FIBEROPTIC, RADIO,
OR WIRE
ARRAY
FIBEROPTIC
SOURCE CABLES
1
m------
L
TRANS-
MISSION
SYSTEM
-----El
.
---b
Fig. 6.13 Generalized fiberoptic telemetry system.
is a single sensor connected to a single output device
via a single channel. Many variations are poasible,
for example the multisource, multiplexed, single user,
fiberoptic data link configuration shown in Fig. 6.14.
El-
1
FIBEROPTIC
CABLES
USER END INSTRUMENTS
0
RECORDER
DISPLAY DEVICE
LOUDSPEAKER
COMPUTER
TRANSMITTER
SIGNAL
I 1
CONDl-
4
TIONER
FOCABLE photodetector
AND DEMUX
. . .
5
B-J
.
.
.
n
Fig. 6.14 A multisource multiplexed single-uaer fi-
beroptic sensor array telemetry system.
Various arrangements for the transmission of
signals from a fiberoptic sensor array to many users
via different types of fiberoptic data links are ahown
in Fig. 6.15. The simplex, half-duplex, full-duplex,
and multiplex schemes illustrated in Fig. 6.15 describe
various system configurations with different capabili-
ties. These configurations may be connected to operate
as one-way-at-a-time, two-way alternate, or two-way
simultaneous systems. For example, two simplex chan-
nels could be associated for operating a two-way simul-
taneous data link.
6-6
SIMPLEX
FIBEROPTIC TRANSMITTER FIBEROPTIC RECEIVER
DUPLEX
%T21
cl-l
T,
m
RI
R2
m
T2
x Km7dl
Fig. 6.15 Generalized transmission schemes.
6.2.3 Telemetry System Budgets
Each telemetry system component interacts
with other components within many time and space con-
straints. This gives rise to many different ways of
aPPIYing the constraints.
Each component may provide
useful power, consume available power, occupy limited
space, contribute to overall weight, poasesa a useful
life, require maintenance, has an acquisition and con-
nection cost, or has other features that affect the
whole system. Thus, each component makes a contribu-
tion to, or imposes a liability on, the whole system
in each of these areas. If there are limits to re-
sources or characteristics that are imposed on the
whole system, there will be a requirement to budget
them. h obvious example is to place a limit on system
cost, space, and weight and then aelect a aet of com-
ponents whose total cost, space, and weight do not
exceed theae limits. Budgeting of time, power, and cost
will be discussed for fiberoptic telemetry systems.
6.2.3.1 Rise Time Budget Analysis
Distortion, length of lines, attenuation,
signaling (pulse-repetition) rates, and dispersion will
place a limit on the length of time that can be allowed
for a step or pulse input to a fiberoptic transmitter
to reach the 90% of maximum signal level at the output
terminal of the receiver. This risetime is distributed
over the electrical and optical serially-connected
(tandem connected) components of the link on the basis
of an approximated Gaussian distribution in which the
combined risetime of the components in tandem is the
square root of the sum of the squares (RMS) of all the
risetimes of the serially-connected components. Nor-
mally the total link risetime is the root-meansquare of
the transmitter, cable, and receiver risetimes. How-
ever, these components themselves may have serial
elements each with individual risetimes. For example,
the transmitter may have an electronic risetime and a
fiberoptic pigtail and coupler risetime. The cable
may have splices or repeaters. All the risetimes of
these are combined on the same RMS basis. A schematic
diagram of a simple fiberoptic link ia shown in Fig.
6.16. The elements that comprise the risetime of the
fiberoptic link are as follows:
I
FIBEROPTIC SPLICE
I
3+! -,
G m
4 E
\ \
FIBEROPTIC CONNECTOR FIBEROPTIC CABiE
Fig. 6.16 A fiberoptic data link.
TRANSMITTER RISETIME, tr(xmtr., primarily due to the
STATION DuPLEXER
LSR(A2)
H=?
HSR
OPTICAL
DU~ER
LSR
OTHER REKATERS
Fig. 6.25 h example of a fiberoptic full duplex re-
peater.
rection for user data and a low bit-rate in the other
direction for control and supervisory data in a single
fiberoptic cable. An arrangement for the optical du-
plexers that was shown in Fig. 6.25 is sho~ in Fig.
6.26.
TOHSR
RCVR
_HSR
6 Q
()
. . . ---
A,
p
_LSR
A2 Q
AZFROM
--- LSRXMTR
- - - -
~. .
- - -~%1:
DICHROIC
FILTER
Fig. 6.26 An arrangement for a fiberoptic duplexer.
tin indication of the power-loss-per-hertz
versus frequency for an optical fiber, compared to wire
pairs and coaxial cables, iS sbo~ in Fig. 6.27. Note
that in the graded-index fiber the loss-per-hertz is
almost independent of frequency for frequencies up to
almost one gigahertz.
4
24
~
01 1000
FREQUENCY (MHz)
Fig. 6.27 The optical power loss per hertz for one
kilometer lengtha of several types of cables
at various frequencies.
6.3.3 Multiplexing with Optical Fibers
Multiplexing may be accomplished with optical
fibers in the following ways:
FREQUENCY-DIVISION MULTIPLEXING (FDM)
Modulate a single optical wavelength with a dif-
ferent carrier frequency for each channel.
WAVELENGTH-DIVISION MULTIPLEXING (WDM)
Use two or more optical sources each with a differe-
nt wavelength for each channel.
TIME-DIVISION MULTIPLEXING (TDM)
Different time-slot for each channel.
sPAcE-DIvxsIoN MULTIPLEXING (fiDM)
Different fiber for each channel.
POLARIZATION
Different form of polarization for each channel.
The multiplexing scheme that is used for a
given application depends on the number of channels re-
quired and the cost factors for each scheme. A typical
multiplexing arrangement is shown in Fig. 6.28. In
m
2
$
SENSOR
ARRAY
1
TRANSMl~ER
IJULILS,GNAL / \ ( /
-45-J RECEVER
AQQ.. nlln
Fig. 6.28 An example of a fiberoptic sensor linear-
array telemetry system with single optical
repeatered cable return.
this figure, the signals from the sensor array are
multiplexed on a time-division multiplexing (TDM) basis
so that only one series of repeaters is required for a
single fiber. This basic fiberoptic link consists of
a fiberoptic transmitter (modulated light source), a
6-12
fiberoptic cable (optical cable), and a fiberoptic
receiver (photodetector). Electrical-to-optical and
optical-to-electrical conversion (transduction) is pre-
sumed at each end, though such presumption is not al-
ways true for all fiberoptic links. For example, the
receiving end may consist of a fiberscope (display de-
vice) or simply a flashing light indicator of on-off
conditions.
6.3.4 Connector Parameters
There are many performance requirements and
design considerations that enter into the choice of
suitable connectors for fiberoptic cables. In addition
to the optical insertion loss introduced by the connec-
tor, other optical features such as axial misalignment,
axial offset, and spacing between fibers must be con-
sidered, as was indicated in Chapter 3. Some of the
connector physical features and design considerations
are as follows:
CONNECTOR DESIGN CONSIDERATIONS
NUMEER OF ELECTRICAL LEADS AND SIZE
NUMBER OF OPTICAL FIBERS AND SIZE
OPERATING TEMFERiTURR AND PHESSURE
MOISTURE AND DIRT RESISTANCE
FIELD MATABILITY
STRAIN RELIEF DESIGN
An example of a ruggedized connector is shown
in Fig. 6.29.
ACHlEVED2.8dS LOSS WHEN COUPLING
50#m CORE0.2 NAGRAOEDINOEX FIBER
Fig. 6.29 A ruggedized fiberoptic cable connector.
Courtesy Standard Telecommunications Labor-
atories Limited, Harlow, Essex, England;
and ITT Cannon, Basingstoke, Hampshire,
England.
6.4 END-TEHMINa (RECEIVER) C0N51DEWT10N
After a physical parameter, such as a sound
wave or a varying magnetic field, has been sensed and
transformed by a fiberoptic sensor into modulated light
that is then transmitted to a point of use via a fiber-
optic telemetry system, the modulated light has to be
demodulated in order to recover the information-bearing
signal. One or more photodetectors may be required to
obtain an electrical signal that may be used as is or
further processed by electrical circuits. Demultiplex-
ing may be required to obtain the separate signals that
were originally generated or transmitted. For digital
data, decoding will be necessary to convert the pulse
codes to analog form or to recover alphanumeric data.
In some cases, the incoming signals need not be con-
verted to electrical signals, but ULSY be directly dis-
played as light signals, such as for signaling on-off
conditions or for telemetering images received via a
multifiber coherent optical cable connected directly
to the faceplate of a fiberscope. Thus, the type of
processing that must be performed on incoming lightwave
signals at an end terminal depends on the specific
application.
6.5 SUMMARY
The topics that were covered in this chapter
included fiberoptic telemetry system configuration;
system risetime, power and cost budgeting; sensor array
design and construction; and fiberoptic transmission
considerations, including multiplexing and fiberoptic
cable, repeater, and connector design considerations.
6-13
APPENDIX
FIBEROPTIC SENSORS GLOSSARY
This Glossary on fiberoptic aensors is intended to
provide definitions of the terms used in this Handbook
and to provide supplementary information directly re-
lated to the topics discussed. Many topics that were
introduced in the various chapters are developed in
further detail in thia Glossary. l%is approach was used
to avoid burdening the reader with details and explana-
tions of terms aa topics were covered. For example,
Maxwells equations, solid state electronics, electro-
optic effects, electromagnetic theory, multiplexing
and modulation methods, and various coefficient for
transmission, reflection and attenuation are covered
in this Gloasary.
The definitions in this Glossary are consistent
with international, national, Federal, military, and
technical society atandards. Many were taken from the
more comprehensive Fiberoptic and Lightwave Communi-
cations Standard Dictionary, Illustrated, 284 pages;
and from the Communications Standard Dictionary,
Illustrated. 1045 Dazes. by Martin H. Weik, Van
.-. .
Nostrand Reinhold Company, 135 W. 50th Street, New
York, New York, 10020.
A
absorption. The transference of some or all of the
energy contained in an electromagnetic wave to the
substance or medium in which it ia propagating or
upon which is is incident. Abaorbed energy from
incident or transmitted lightwaves is converted into
energy of other forms, usually heat, within the
transmission medium, with the resultant attenuation
of the intensity. See intrinsic absorption.
acceptance angle. The maximum angle, measured from the
longitudinal axis or centerline of an optical fiber
to an incident ray, within which the incident ray
will be accepted for transmission along the fiber,
that is, total internal reflection of the incident
ray occurs. If the acceptance angle for the fiber
is exceeded, total internal reflection will not oc-
cur and the incident ray will be lost by leakage,
scattering, diffuaion, or absorption in the clad-
ding. The acceptance angle is dependent upon the
refractive indicea of the two media that determine
the critical angle. For a cladded fiber in air,
the sine of the acceptance angle is given by the
square root of the difference of the squares of the
indices of refraction of the fiber core and ~he cla -
ding. In mathematical notation, sine= (n -n
7
where 0 ia the acceptance angle, n, is tiie r~~l~c~
tive index of the core, and n2 is the refractive
index of the cladding. Synonymous with acceptance
one-half angle.
acceptance cone. A solid angle whose included apex
angle is equal to twice the acceptance angle. Rays
of light within the acceptance cone can be coupled
into the end of an optical fiber and still maintain
total internal reflection for all the rays in the
cone. Typically, an acceptance cone is 40.
acceptance one-half angle. Synonym for acceptance
angle.
acceptor. In an intrinaic semiconducting material (such
as galium arsenide), a dopant (such as germanium
that has nearly the same electronic bonding struc-
ture as the intrinsic material, but with one less
electron among its valence electrons than that re-
quired to complete the intrinsic bonding structural
pattern. This pattern leaves a space or hole
for one electron for each dopant atom in the struc-
ture. The dopant atoms are relatively few and are
far apart and hence to not interfere with the elec-
trical conductivity of the intrinsic material. An
electron from a neighboring intrinsic material atom
can fill the hole at the dopant site, leaving a hole
from whence it came; thus, the hole can appear to
move or wander about, although with less mobility
than the electrons that are free and exceas to donor
atoms. Also see donor; electron; hole.
acoustooptic effect. The changes in diffraction grat-
ings or phase patterns produced in a transm.lssion
medium conducting a lightwave when the medium is
subjected to a sound (acoustic) wave, due to the
photoelaatic changes that occur. The acoustic waves
might be created by a force developed by an imping-
ing sound wave, the piezoelectric effect, or magne-
tostriction. The effect can be used to modulate a
light beam in a material since many properties,
such as lightconducting velocities, reflection and
transmission coefficients at interfaces, acceptance
angles, critical angles, and transmission modes,
are dependent upon the diffractive changes that
occur. The effect includea the phase transduction
mechanism used in fiberoptic sensors, i.e., t h e
change in phase that occurs due to the change in
length and refractive index caused by the acoustic
presaure. Also see electrooptic effect.
acoustooptics. The study and application of the inter-
relation of acoustics and optics. Synonymous with
optoacoustics.
amplification by stimulated emission of radiation
(laser). See light amplification by stimulated emis-
sion of radiation (laser).
amplitude modulation (AM). The modulation of the ampli-
tude of a wave serving as a carrier, by another wave
serving as the modulating signal. The amplitude ex-
cursions of the carrier are made proportional to a
parameter of the modulating signal that bears the
information to be transmitted.
A-1
angstrom. A unit of length equal to 10-10 meter, 10-1
nanometer, and 10-4 micron.
aperture. See numerical aperture (N. A. ).
array. See sensor array.
attenuation. The decrease in power of a signal, light
beam, or lightwave, either absolutely or as a frac-
tion of a reference value. The decrease usually
occurs as a result of absorption, reflection, dif-
fusion, scattering, deflection, or dispersion from
an original level and usually not as a result of
geometric spreading, i.e., the inverse sqwre of
the distance. In an optical fiber, attenuation Is
undesirable for transmission purposes but desirable
for prevention of leakage or clandestine detection.
Optical fibers have been classified as high-loss
(over 100 dB/km), medium loss (20 to 100 db/km),
and 10W1OSS (less than 20 dB/km).
B
band. See conduction band; energy band; valence band.
bandwidth. 1. A range of frequencies, usually speci-
fying the number of hertz of the band or the upper
and lower limiting frequencies. 2. The range of
. frequencies that a device is capable of generating,
handling, passing, or allowing, usually the range
of frequencies in which the response is not reduced
greater than 3 dB from the maximum response.
baseband. The band of frequencies associated with or
comprising an original signal from a modulated
source. In the process of modulation, the baseband
is occupied by the aggregate of the transmitted sig-
nals used to modulate a carrier. In demodulation,
it is the recovered aggregate of the transmitted
signals. The termis commonly applied to cases where
the ratio of the upper to the lower limit of the
frequency band is large compared to unity.
beam splitter. h optical device for dividing a light
beam into two separated beams. One simple beam
splitter consists of a plane parallel plate, with
one surface coated with a dielectric or metallic
coating that reflects a portion and transmits a por-
tion of the incident beam; i.e., part of the light
is deviated through an angle of 90, and part iS
unchanged in direction. A beam splitter may also
be made by coating the hypotenuse face of a 45-90
prism and cementing it to the hypotenuse face of
another. The thickness of the metallic beam split-
ting interface will determine the proportions of the
light reflected and transmitted. In metallic beam
splitters, an appreciable amount of light is lost by
absorption in the metal. It may also be necessary
to match the reflected and transmitted beam for
brightness and for color. In these cases, it is
necessary to use a material at the interface that
gives the same color of light by transmission and
reflection. Nhere color matching at the surface or
interface cannot be accomplished, a correcting color
filter may be placed in one of the beams. In a
fiber-to-fiber beam splitter, evanescent coupling
can be used to transfer optical energy from one
fiber to another.
birefringence. The splitting of a light beam into two
divergent components upon passage through a doubly-
refracting transmission medium, with the two com-
ponents propagating at different velocities in the
medium. In an optical fiber, birefringence is re-
lated to the strain in the fiber which causes the
fiber to be a single polarization transmission
medium.
Bragg cell. An acoustooptlc device that accepts fixed
frequency monochromatic light and that has a base-
band vibrating element capable of modulating the in-
put lightwaves producing an output lightwave with a
frequency equal to the frequency of the input light-
wave plus the frequency of the baseband input signal.
The Bragg cell has application as part of an inter-
ferometer in which heterodyne detection is used.
Brewster angle. The angle, measured with respect to
the normal, at which an electromagnetic wave inci-
dent upon an interface surface between two dielec-
tric media of different refractive indices is totally
transmitted into the second medium. The magnetic
component of the incident wave must be parallel to
the interface surfa~~l The Brewster angle is given
by: tan B = (~2/E1) , where B is the Brewster an-
gle, c1 is the electric permittivity of the incident
medium, and e2 is the electric permittivity of the
transmitted medium. The Brewster angle is a conven-
ient angle to transmit all the energy in an optical
fiber to an outside detector. There is no Brewster
angle, for which there is total transmission and
therefore zero reflection, when the electric field
component is parallel to the interface, except when
the permittivities are equal, in which case there
is no interface. Mso, for entry into a more dense
medium, such as from air into an optical fiber: tan
B = (n2/nl), and from a more dense medium into a
less dense medium, such as fiber to air: tan B =
(nl/n2), where nl and n2 are the refractive indices
of the air and fiber, respectively.
brightfield sensor. In fiberoptic, a sensor in which
the optical power modulated by the sensor is all or
a large fraction of the total optical power fed to
or available to the sensor. Synonymous with light-
field sensor. Contrast with darkfield sensor.
budget. See optical power budget; power budget; rise-
time budget.
bulk coupler. In fiberoptic, a coupler that has one
input and many outputs.
bundle jacket. The outer protective covering applied
over a bundle of optical fibers.
bus. 1. One or more conductors that serve as a common
connection for a related group of devices. 2. One
or more conductors used for transmitting optical or
electrical power or signals.
bend. See ordinary bend.
bend loss. See microbend loss.
A-2
c
cable. 1. A jacketed bundle or jacketed fiber in a
form that can be terminated. 2. A group of con-
ductors that are bound together, usually with a pro-
tective sheath, a strength member, and insulation
between individual conductors and for the entire
group. See fiberoptic cable.
cable jacket. The outer protective covering applied
over the internal cable elements.
carrier. 1. In communications, a wave, pulse train,
or other signal suitable for modulation by an infor-
mation-bearing signal to be transmitted over a com-
munication system. 2. h unmodulated emission. A
carrier is usually a sinusoidal wave, a recurring
series of pulses, or a direct-current (DC) signal.
See charge carrier.
cavity. See resonant cavity.
charge carrier. tin atomic or molecular particle that
possesses an electric charge and is capable of mov-
ing under the influence of an electric or magnetic
field. For example, an electron, a hole, or an ion.
cladding. An optical transparent material, with a re-
fractive index lower than that of the core, placed
over or outside the core material of an optical
waveguide that serves to reflect or refract light-
waves in order to confine them to the core. The
cladding also serves to protect the core.
cladding mode stripper. 1. A material applied to op-
tical fiber cladding to allow light energy being
transmitted in the cladding to leave the cladding of
the fiber. 2. A piece of optical material or an
optical component that can support only certain elec-
tromagnetic wave propagation modes. In particular,
it does not support the propagation modes in the
cladding of a cladded optical fiber, slab dielectric
waveguide, or integrated optical circuit. The strip-
per effectively removes the cladding modes without
disturbing the core-supported propagation modes.
close-confinement junction. A synonym for single heter-
ojunction.
CMos. See combined metal oxide semiconductor.
coating. See optical fiber coating.
coherence length. The coherence time of a light beam
multiplied by the velocity of the light, namely
(1/cAv)c = l/Av. AI.SO see coherence time.
coherence time. In beam of light propagating in a vac-
uum, the time obtained from the expression l/cAv,
where c is the velocity of light in a vacuum, v is
the reciprocal of the wavelength, and Avis the vari-
ation or spread of v over time for the beam. In
material media, the c is replaced by c/n, where n is
the refractive index. Also see coherence length.
coherent bundle. A bundle of optical fibers in which
the spatial coordinates of each fiber are the same
or bear the same spatial relationship to each other
at the two ends of the bundle. Synonymous with
coherent light. Light of which all parameters are pre-
dictable and correlated at any point in time or
space, particularly over an area in a plane perpen-
dicular to the direction of propagation or over time
at a particular point in space. Contrast with
incoherent light.
collection angle. Synonym for acceptance angle.
combined metal oxide semiconductor. A metal oxide semi-
conductor that consists of both positively-doped and
negatively-doped material.
common-mode. 1. Pertaining to any uncompensated com-
bination of generator or receiver ground potential
difference (voltage), generator common return offset
voltage, and longitudinally-coupled peak random
noise voltage measured between the receiver circuit
ground and receiver cable with the generator ends
of the cable short-circuited to ground. 2. The
algebraic mean of the two voltages appearing at the
receiver input terminals with respect to the receiv-
er circuit ground. 3. Pertaining to the relative
optical intensity fluctuations between two coherent
electromagnetic (light) waves.
common-mode rejection ratio (CMRR). The ratio of the
common-mode interference voltage or optical inten-
sity at the input of a circuit to the interference
voltage or optical intensity at the output of the
circuit.
conduction band. In a semiconductor, the range of elec-
tron energy, higher than that of the valence band,
possessed by electrons sufficient to make them free
to move from atom to atom. When they leave the
valence band, they are free to move under the influ-
ence of an applied electric field and thus they
constitute an electric current.
conductor. 1. In fiberoptic, a transparent medium
that is capable of transmitting or conveying light-
waves a useful distance. 2. In electric circuits,
a material that readily permits a flow of electrons
through itself upon application of an electric field.
Electrical conductors include copper, aluminum,
lead, gold, silver, and platinum. The conductivity
is specified by: J = aE, where J is the current
density in amperes/square meter for S1 units, E is
the applied electric field in volts/meter, and o is
the conductivity in reciprocal ohms/meter. Also see
dielectric. Contrast with insulator.
connector. In fiberoptic, a device that permits the
coupling of signals from one optical fiber or cable
to another.
connector insertion loss. The power loss sustained by
a transmission medium, such as a wire, coaxial cable,
optical fiber cable, or integrated optical circuit
component, due to the Insertion of a connector be-
tween two elements, which would not occur if the
media were continuous without the connector i.e.,
if there were no reflected, absorbed, dispersed,
or scattered power.
controllable coupler. See electronically controllable
coupler. aligned bundle.
A-3
core. The central primary light-conducting region of a
material medium, such as an optical fiber, the re-
fractive index of which must be higher than that of
its cladding in order for the lightwaves to be
totally reflected or refracted. Most of the optical
power is in the core.
coupler. In optical transmission aystems, a component
used to interconnect two or more optical fibera.
Also see connector; bulk coupler; electronic&lly-
controllable coupler; reflective star-coupler; 3-dB
coupler.
coupling. The connection, attachment, or binding of
optical elements, electric circuit elementa, elec-
tric and magnetic fields, propagation modes, or elec-
tromagnetic wave component, such as surface waves
and evanescent waves, to internal waves in wave-
guides, dielectric slabs, or other interdependent
associations and interactions of events and materials
in a system. For example, two optical fibers or cer-
tain elements in an integrated optical circuit may
be coupled together in some manner to preserve signal
continuity. See evanescent field coupling.
coupling coefficient. Synonym for coupling ratio.
coupling efficiency. In fiberoptic transmission, the
ratio of the optical power on one side of an inter-
face to the optical power on the other side. For
example, the ratio of the power developed by a light
aource to the power accepted by a bundle of fibers,
or the power received at the end of a bundle of
fibers to the power that impinges on a photodetector.
For light sources with emitting areas larger than
fiber core diameters, the product of fiber numerical
aperture (N.A.) and core diameter is a good indica-
tor of maximum coupling efficiency. For other
sources, such as small laser diodes with emitting
areas small than the fiber core diameter, the N.A.
alone is a relevant indicator of coupling efficiency,
usually expresaed as a percentage.
coupling loss. In a fiberoptic coupling, the optical
power loss caused by the coupling itself, a loss
that would not occur if the optical fiber were con-
tinuous without the coupling.
coupling ratio. The ratio of power on the output side
of a coupling to the power on the input side. The
coupling ratio is always less than unity. Synonymous
with coupling coefficient. Also see 3-dB coupler.
critical angle. The angle, with the normal, at which
an electromagnetic wave incident upon an interface
surface between two dielectric media, at which total
reflection of the incident ray first occurs as the
incident angle with the normal to the incident aur-
face is increased from zero, and beyond which total
internal reflection continues to occur although with
increased attenuation at a rate determined not only
by the electromagnetic parameters of the transmis-
sion medium, but also by the frequency and the inci-
dence angle. The wave is guided along the reflect-
ing surface with no average transport of energy into
the second medium, and the intensity of the reflect-
ed wave is exactly equal to the intensity of the
incident wave. The wave in an optical fiber will
be confined to the fiber for all incidence angles
greater than the critical angle. The critical angle
is given by sin ec = (~2/~1) 1/2 where 9C is the
critical angle and Cz and c1 are the permittivities
of the transmitted (outside) and incident medium
(inside), respectively, and where El is always great-
er than =2; e.g. , the case for an optical fiber (con-
ducting a wave), and air. In terms of refractive
indices, the critical angle is the incidence angle
from a denser medium, at an interface between the
denser and less dense medium, at which all of the
light is refracted along the interface, i.e., the
angle of refraction is 90. When the critical
angle is exceeded, the light is totally reflected
back into the denaer medium. The critical angle
varies with the refractive indices of the two media
with the relationship, sin Oc = n2/nl, where n2 is
the index of refraction of the less dense medium, nl
is the refractive index of the denser medium, and 9C
is the critical angle, as above. In terms of total
internal reflection in an optical fiber, the criti-
cal angle is the smallest angle made by a meridional
ray in an optical fiber that can be totally reflect-
ed from the innermost interface and thus determines
the maximum acceptance angle at which a meridional
ray can be accepted for transmission along a fiber.
Also see total internal reflection.
critical radius. The largest radius of curvature of an
optical fiber, containing an axially propagated
electromagnetic wave, at which the field outside the
fiber still detaches itself from the fiber and rad-
iates into space because the phase-front velocity
must increase to maintain a proper relationship with
the guided wave inside the fiber. Thia velocity can-
not exceed the velocity of light, aa the wavefront
sweeps around the outside of the curved fiber. This
causes attenuation due to a radiation loss. The
field outside the fiber decays exponentially in a
direction transverse to the direction of propaga-
tion. It is the radius of curvature of an optical
fiber at which there is an appreciable propagation
mode conversion loss, due to the abruptness of the
transition from straight to curved. For a radius
of curvature greater than the critical value, the
fields behave essentially as in a straight guide.
For radii smaller than the critical value, consider-
able mode conversion takea place.
D
dark current. ~e current that flows in a photodetec-
tor when there is no radiant energy or luminous flux
incident upon its aensitive surface, i.e., when there
is total darkness. Dark current generally increaaea
with increaaed temperature for most photodetectors.
For example, in a photoemissive photodetector, the
dark current is given by:
Id = AT2eq $l kT
where A is the surface area constant, T is the ab-
solute temperature, q is the electron charge, $ ia
the work function of the photoemisaive surface mater-
ial, and k is Boltzmanns constant.
darkfield sensor. In fiberoptic, a sensor in which
the optical power tapped and modulated by the sensor
is a small fraction of the total optical power fed
to or available to the sensor. Contrast with bright-
field sensor.
data. Representation of facts, concepts, or instruc-
tions in a manner suitable for communication, inter-
pretation, or processing by human, manual, semiauto-
matic, or fully-automatic means. The characters
used as data may assume any form or pattern to which
meaning may be assigned in order to represent infor-
A-4
mat ion. Data may be transferred or transported from
place to place, auch as from city to city; from posi-
tion to position, such as from coordinate poaition
to coordinate position in the display space on the
diaplay surface of a display device as display ele-
ments, display groups, or display images; or from
location to location, such as in computer or buffer
storage as characters or words. Data may be holes
in tapes or cards; magnetized spots on discs, drums,
tapes, cards, or chips; electrical current or volt-
age pulses in a wire; or modulated electromagnetic
waves in free space or in optical fibers. Data may
be presented on a CRT screen, a LED or gas panel, a
fiberscope faceplate at the end of a coherent bundle
of optical fibers, or other surface suitable for data
display.
data link. 1. A communication link suitable for trans-
mission of data. The data link does not include the
data source and the data sink. 2. TWO data sta-
tions and their connecting network, operating in
such a manner that information can
tween the stations. See fiberoptic
dB. See decibel.