You are on page 1of 66

, ,

2015 , 1 (51)

2015

.


.



.

.

.

: 279
ISSN:2226-9185

. 5
.

: - 46,
, -7
: +(976)-11-315735
: 315735
: www.legalinstitute.mn
: lawjournal@legalinstitute.mn

EDITORIAL BOARD

J.Amarsanaa

Academician

B.Amarsanaa

(LL.D)

J.Batzandan

(Ph.D)

J.Bayartsetseg

State Secretary, Ministry of Justice of Mongolia

B.Boldbaatar
Secretary General, the Secretariat of the State Greate
Hural of Mongolia

/ , /

J.Byambadorj

(Ph.D)

. : ,

D.Ganbat

Chairman, the Standing Committee of Law of the State

Great Hural of Mongolia

B.Gunbileg

(Ph.D)

: , ,

16

D.Dorligjav

Minister of Justice

, ,
- , , C.

, (LL.M) .

Ts.Zorig Chief Justice, Supreme Court of Mongolia


O.Munkhsaikhan

(LL.D)

, : ,

S.Narangerel

Academician

28

Ch.Unurbayar

(Ph.D)

D.Solongo

(Ph.D)

Kh.Temuujin

Member of the State Great Hural of Mongolia

B.Temuulen

(Ph.D)

P.Tsagaan

Head, the Office of the President of Mongolia

Sh.Tsogtoo

(Ph.D)

Ch.Enkhbaatar

(Sc.D)

,
(Sc.D), .


40
- , (LL.D.),
, .

, ,

Editor-in-Chief
E.Batbayar
Acting Assistant Editor
B.Gonchigsumlaa
Designed by
E.Unurbayar

, :

, ,
.

46

:
? 56
, (LL.M) .


State Registration Number:279
ISSN: 2226-9185
The National Legal Institute
publishes this law review five
times per year.

Address: Ulaanbaatar-46, Chingeltei


District, Chinggis khaan Square -7
Phone:+(976)-11-315735
Fax: 315735
Website: www.legalinstitute.mn
E-mail: Lawjournal@legalinstitute.mn


65
- , .

-
92
, , (LL.M) .

104

120

.
(LL.M.) .

Content
BEFORE CREATING A LAW
(UNDERLINING ARTICLE, INTERVIEW)
Professor B. Chimid: His knowledge and consciousness

Budget competence of the parliament: Check and balance,


and process for adopting the state budget

16

S.Narangerel, (Sc.D), Academician, Counsel of the Institute for Philosophy,


Sociology and Law under the Mongolian Academy of Science

P.Amarjargal, (LL.M), Senior Counsel of Legal Service Department,


the Secretariat of the State Great Hural

LEGAL THOUGHTS: REFLECTION


With respect to concept of the first constitution of Mongolia

28

Theoretical foundation of the constitutional concept on compensation

40

Ch.Enkhbaatar, (Sc.D), Professor, Vice Director of Management School,


Academy of Management

D.Gangabaatar, (LL.D), Associate professor of the School of Law,


National University of Mongolia

IMPLEMENTATION OF LAW, EFFICIENCY, PROBLEMS


Limitation for amending the constitution: Theoretical issues and
constitutional law of Mongolia 46
Ts.Sarantuya, (Sc.D), Professor, Honored lawyer of Mongolia

The constitution and the decision-making in economic policy:


Does Mongolia need a basic rule of economic policy?

56

J.Sainkhishig, (LL.M), Officer, the Secretariat of the Judicial General Council


of Mongolia

RESEARCH OVERVIEW
Developing formation of the government in Mongolia

65

O.Munkhsaikhan, (LL.D), Associate Professor of the School of Law,


National University of Mongolia

On accompanying position of member of the government by member


of the parliament 92
D.Uurtsaikh, (LL.M), Researcher experienced in Constitutional Law

Parliamentary participation in the process for adopting the state budget


E.Enkhgerel, Vice Director of the Ulaanbaatar Policy Research Center

. : ,

104
.
-
.
.
,
. ,


.
.,
., . .
,

- .
.
.


10
.
. ,


.
.


.


.

. ,
,
. .

. 1974
-
. -

,

,
,
. .

Background for dismissing the parliament and


the constructive mechanism 120
O.Mashbat, (LL.M), Researcher experienced in Comparative Constitutional Law

,
, - ,
,
.

, , ,
,
.

,
. .
80


, ,


, ,

.
.
1960, 70-


. 1960
-


.
-
, .
.

2015 1 (51)



. ,
.


,
,

.

, ,
,
.
.
,


.


.

,
,
.
.





.
,
.
( )
, , ,
,
,
,

.
.
-


.
()
,



.

1970-
.

( )


.
. 1992


,
.

.


.
,


,

.
-
.
(

,
.
. ,



.
, , ,
, ,
,
,
.


,
.


.

10



.

,
, , , ,
.

, -


.



.
,
.
,

.


.

.

.

, ,


.
.


,
.

. I, II

(
, ,
.
) ,

.
.
III
1974 . .

.
500 , .


, .

. 12
. 5
.

11
. 7
.

.

. 1927-1930



(Henning Haslund)- ,
(Men and Gods Mongolia)


.
.

,
,
. . ,
,
-


, ,


.

.
.
.
., .. .-


.

.
-

11

2015 1 (51)

,

,
.-,
,
.,
,
., -


.
, ,
.
(
)
. ()
.
.


,
.



.


.
-
II
.
-




.
,

.
-

.
,
.

,

, .
,
.

,


. ,

.
1992
: ...
, ,
...
.
.
.
.

.
, ,
,

.


.

.
. 1970-
-

, .
-
, , ,
, , ...
.
, ,
, ,
.
,
.



.
.
,
(.,
. , . )
(., .,
. )
-

12

,
1978

.
,
,
,


.
.

..
( -
), .
.





.



-
( ) I

( )
.
.



. .


. .
, , ,
,

.

., ., .,
.
- ,

.
,
. .

,
.
.
-
.




.
,


, ,

.

.

.
,


.

. -

.

,
. ,
1981
.


,
.
-
,

.

.

,
.
., ., .,

13

2015 1 (51)

-


, - .
.


.


,

.
. ,
,

,


,
.
.,
.,
., ., .,
....
. .

1991



,
(
) ,

.
1992
-


.

1992
.

. .
,
( .
2004.1.13, 009 (2053), 3- )

.



.

-



. ,


. ,


,

,

(.
.., ., 2008,
27 ) .
.
.


, ,

,
,


(
20
.., ., 2012,
12 ) .
.

1999 (2000)
,
,

.

,
1990-



.
.
,

14



. .

,
,

.
2000
( .
2013.1.14. 0010 (1649), 5- )
.

-





,
,




.
,
,
.
2000
,


.

- 15

.
.



,
,
(
. 2001.1.11, 9 (895) 3-
),
.

,
.



, ,
,
,
,
.

( . 2001.4.11, 7-
)
.
.

( )
.

(19642013)
,
.
,

,
,

,
.

(. ..,
., 2008, 24 )
. .

(.
..,
., 2008, 255 )
(
.
- ..,
., 2014
), ,


.



(.
.., .,
2008, 290 ) .

15

2015 1 (51)

:
, ,


.2 XIV




.3 1341
III
,

XIV

,

,

.
, XVI

.
, VIII



.4



(LL.M) .

,


.

,
,
,
.




.


.1




,

. : .. .
(2012) 23
3
Rick Stapenhurst. The Legislature and the Budget (2004)
The World Bank
4
Rick Stapenhurst. The Legislature and the Budget (2004)
The World Bank
2

1
John Adler. General principles of constitutional and administrative law. Fourth edition (2002) 275p

16


,



.
,





,
.


, ,

.5

,
,
.6

,

,
,



.
,

,
,



.

,

,
.7
,


,



.8
,
,

. ,



.9



,
. / 1 /
.

, ,

,



.10


,




.
Carlos Santiso. Budget institutions and fiscal responsibility:
Parliaments and the political economy of the budget process
in Latin America (2005) IBRD, World Bank
8
Ian Lieneri. Who controls the budget: The legislative or executives (2005) IMF working paper
9
Carlos Santiso. Budget institutions and fiscal responsibility:
Parliaments and the political economy of the budget process
in Latin America (2005) IBRD, World Bank
10
Parliament and democracy in the twenty-first century: A
guide to good practice (2006) IPU 120
7

Blacks law dictionary. Editor in chief Bryan A. Garner.


Eighth edition (2005) 207p
6
...
(2011) 158
5

17

2015 1 (51)



.

,


11 ,

,

.12


,



.

.
, ,
,




.13
,


.





.

,


,

.14


, ,


.
,
, , ,

. ,



, rubber
stamp15


.16
,



. ,

,

.




.





14
Carlos Santiso. Budget institutions and fiscal responsibility: Parliaments and the political economy of the budget process in Latin America (2005) IBRD, World Bank
15
Rubber stamp ,

.
16
Carlos Santiso. Budget institutions and fiscal responsibility: Parliaments and the political economy of the budget process in Latin America (2005) IBRD, World Bank

Alesina ets. Budget institutions and fiscal performance in


Latin America (1999) IDB OCE Working paper 394
12
Carlos Santiso. Budget institutions and fiscal responsibility: Parliaments and the political economy of the budget process in Latin America (2005) IBRD, World Bank
13

11

18



,


.17




,

. ,

,
,

,



,
.


.


,
,


. 19


,

. ,



,

,
. 20

/,
/,
/, /
/,
, , /
. ,





.21




. ,


, -
,

,
,

.22





,



.18
, -
,




.

Ian Lieneri. Who controls the budget: The legislative or


executives (2005) IMF working paper
Rick Stapenhurst. The Legislature and the Budget (2004)
The World Bank
21
Ian Lieneri. Who controls the budget: The legislative or
executives (2005) IMF working paper
22
Carolin Forestiere. Riccardo Pelizzo. The Role of the Italian parliament in financial policy in The role of parliaments in
the budget process (2005) World Bank Institute
19

20

Rick Stapenhurst. The Legislature and the Budget (2004)


The World Bank
18
Ian Lieneri. Who controls the budget: The legislative or
executives (2005) IMF working paper
17

19

2015 1 (51)









. / 2
/


/ /


.

,


.
, 40

.23



.


.






. 25
,
,




.26 ,

,

.




.




. -


,




.27
1990

,

,
,





.24 ,

Rick Stapenhurst. The Legislature and the Budget (2004)


The World Bank
26
Hallerberg, Mark. Domestic budgets in a United Europe.
Cornell University press (2004)
27
Ian Lieneri. Who controls the budget: The legislative or
executives (2005) IMF working paper
25


Carolin Forestiere. Riccardo Pelizzo. The Role of the Italian parliament in financial policy in The role of parliaments in
the budget process (2005) World Bank Institute

23
24

20

.28

, ,

,

. 29





.30




,




. ,
47 3




.31



1958 , 1960

.

. 1970
.
,

.
,
,

.
,
- .
1974
,
.
. 32



, ,

.

,



.

,
.33

,




.

,
. ,

Von Hagen, Juergen and Ian Harden. National budget


process and fiscal performance in towards greater fiscal discipline, European economy, reports and studies 3 (1994)
29
Ajendro Saporiti and Jorge M.Streb. Separation of powers
and political budget cycles (2003)
30
Carlos Santiso. Budget institutions and fiscal responsibility: Parliaments and the political economy of the budget process in Latin America (2005) IBRD, World Bank
31
.. :
(2007) 481
28

32
Barry Anderson. The value of a nonpartisan, independent, objective analytic unit to the legislative role in budget
preparation in The role of parliaments in the budget process
(2005) World Bank Institute
33
.. :
(2007) 481

21

2015 1 (51)



.



,

.34

,

,



. . 35

.
,




1958 40

.36


.

.


, ,

,





,
. ,

3 ,
60
- .

, ,

,
,


.37




.





.38

,




.


.







.39


,40
Zdenka Mansfeldova, Petra Rakusanova. Legislative budgeting in the Czech Republic in The role of parliaments in
the budget process (2005) World Bank Institute
38
Parliament and democracy in the twenty first century
(2006) IPU 142
39
Parliament and democracy in the twenty-first century: A
guide to good practice (2006) IPU 119
40
Ian Lieneri. Who controls the budget: The legislative or
executives (2005) IMF working paper
37

S.Linn &F.Sobolewski. The German Bundestag functions


and procedures. (2010) 126
35
.. :
(2007) 480
36
40
34

22

.41




,

.


,

.


,

,

.




. :
1.

, ,
;
2.
,
;
3.



,
, ,



;
4.
;

5. ,
;
6. ,
;
7.

;
8. ,

.

.



,





,
.




. ,



.42



.



Joachim Wehner. Legislative arrangements for financial
scrutiny: Explaining cross-national variation in The role
of parliaments in the budget process (2005) World Bank
Institute

42

Rick Stapenhurst. The Legislature and the Budget (2004)


The World Bank

41

23

2015 1 (51)

.
,



.43

,




,

.44


.45
,

,
,


.






, -


. 46


,

.47






.48
,
,
,


.

.
,
,


.49


, ,
,


.
,

43
Carlos Santiso. Budget institutions and fiscal responsibility: Parliaments and the political economy of the budget process in Latin America (2005) IBRD, World Bank
44
Rick Stapenhurst. The Legislature and the Budget (2004)
The World Bank
45
Ian Lieneri. Who controls the budget: The legislative or
executives (2005) IMF working paper
46
Rick Stapenhurst. The Legislature and the Budget (2004)
The World Bank

47

Rick Stapenhurst. The Legislature and the Budget (2004)


The World Bank
Zdenka Mansfeldova, Petra Rakusanova. Legislative budgeting in the Czech Republic in The role of parliaments in
the budget process (2005) World Bank Institute
49
Joachim Wehner. Legislative arrangements for financial
scrutiny: Explaining cross-national variation in The role of
parliaments in the budget process (2005) World Bank Institute
48

24





.


,



.

,
.

, ,

.

,



,
. ,


,



.



, ,



,

.


,
,


.

,



.


.



,

,



.






,
.



,




.
,

,

,

25

2015 1 (51)



,
,



.

,

.
,



.









,

.


,
.

,

,

.
,



,

,
,



.






.


,
,

.
,


,
,


.


,
,
,



.


,

,

,

.

26


, ,

.
1

---o0o---

27

2015 1 (51)


,
(Sc.D), .


,

,


,

,


.

2014


90 .

,
,



,
.

, 1924

.
-
,

,




. ,


.


,
,
,
.

1.

2000
,
.
, ,
,
,



,


.
1911



.

1912



,

28

, : ,




.1


, , ,

.2

1913
9

.3

,

,
.
, 1914
,
4


.
,

.
2.

,




.
,

. 1921 3
13-
...



5 .
, .


,

.6

.
-
. . 2000 , 2-3.
2
.
. ., 2009 .
: ,


1914- 1919
1919

. . ..
. (,
, , ), 1/2007(15),
151 . ,
- ...
1869
,

1917 .


, ,


.
3

, ,

,
.
., .. ,
, ., 1997 , 191 .
4
..
. ( ). ., 2014 , 220-221
1

,

; ,
. 1911
, (
. 1900-1914), ( .,
.); .. ,
. ., 2002 , 226 .
5
(
), ., 1970 , 7 .
6
.. . ., 2006,
15 .

29

2015 1 (51)

,
, ,


(1921.09.12),
(1921.09.20),

(1921.11.01),

(1921.03.05)
,

.

, - ,


,

.



1922
5
19- 21



7
. .,
-

1922 9 1-
39 ...

8
.

, , , ,
,
,



,
.

.9
,



,

1922 12
29-
,

.10

,


,

.


.

,

.
. ., 1984. 341-342 .
,
, ,

.
10
. 1-1-72 (- 1922 56
).
9

.-.
(1921-1940). ., 1967 , 72 .
8
. 1-1-72 (- 1922 ).
7

30

, : ,




.

1924 2
15-
.

-
..
.,
.11


.12


.


, 50



1924 11 25-26-

, 26- 16 17
14
.

.

1924
10 24- 39

.

. ,
, - III

,

,
,

;
,

,
,



; , 1924

3.

:

.

()

,13


20
,
.
-
.
,
(1924
11 25-)
:

. ., ..
: . ., 2004 , 53 .
12

.

( , ,
). . (). XX .
, . . ., 1996 , 343-344 .
13
1924 :

,

. :
11

31

2015 1 (51)

()
,


,

,
,


.

,

.14
,

; ,


,



, ,


.

:

.

,
,
( ,
, ,
, )
. 1920-1921


,




,

.15
, ,

.
,




. 1924
5 20-

,
,
.16


-
1924 6
3-
, 6
7- , ...
...


,

... ,

18
17 .
,

., ..
: . ., 2004 , xxii .
16



,


,
.
17
1921-24
. ., 1954 , 88 .

15

- , - .
14
..: ...
.
... , 15 , 338 .

32

, : ,



1924 6 13-



. 2
:

,
,
,



,
.
-

.

,
,18


.19

,


,

.20

.

,
. :

, ,

.

,

;


,





;

,



.


.: , -,
, -, ,

,

. .

.
-
. ,




. -

. ,
:
(1924 11 25).
., ..
: . ., 2004 , 51 .
19
.:

.
. .
18

1917 4

..:
...,

...,
,

. ... . .., 5
., .31, .113-118- .

20

33

2015 1 (51)

.21


. ,


.

,

, , ,
, , ,


,

; ,

,

.




.

.
-
,


.

, ,
- ,

-
, ,

,
,

- III
,
,

,

,
,



.

,
:

,


.


.



,
,
, ,
,
,


-

.


, ,
, ,
,

.


,

, ,

.. .
. ., , 2004, . 177; ...
. ., , 2010, .122-123.

21

34

, : ,

, 3)

,
, 4)



... .

1)


,
,
2) , ,

.

-



,


,

-
.24



. - ...


, ,


.
,

,
, , ,
,

,

.
1924
: ...
,

,


...22

.
,
, ,
,

,
,
23
.

3 ,
1)
,
,
..., 2)

,
,

.. . ., 1974 ,
154-155 .


- . :
-
, , ,
, ,
,

.

,

.

( ).
:
. ., 2009 , 62-63 .

24

., ..
: . ., 2004 , 90 .
23
.
22

35

2015 1 (51)

,
25
. ,
,


.26

:

(
)
.
30



,


.


27
,

.

, ,
,

, ,
, ,

,


,






,

,
,

5

.
,
, ,


.28

,
,


-

.29
,


,
,

,

-

.
,

. ,
1 :

... , 28 , 317-318
.
26
..: ,

,
.
,

, ,


.

.
. ... , 28
, 233 .
27
.. . ., 2001 , 36 .
25

... , 5- , ., 1981.-. 33.- . 46.


29
.. .
? , 5- , ., 1981. . 34. . 289-339.
28

36

, : ,



,



; 4
: -


,


.

:

. :


,



,

.

: ...

,




,




,



,
, ...
,





//





...
//


..., ...







,





...
.30 ,



.

.





( , )-

. , -
,


. 1960
. .26, .1, ..
56. ., ..
: . ., 2004 , 64-65 -
.

30

37

2015 1 (51)

1990


.
,
:

( ),

.
,
10 , ,
, ,

.
,

.

: ,

,


, .

-

1918
,



.31 , . 1924




.32 .
,


,


.33

1918


.

34
35 1924
, ,

.


, ,
,





.
1924 1918



.

, : ,


,
,

,

.

,
,
,
,

.


,

.


1924

,
.
,
,
,
. ,
,
, ,



.

,


.

---o0o---

XX ,




. 1924

.



.
.. . ., 1974 , 149
.
34

-3191\96
.
35

(
). :
. .,
2009 , 59-74 .
33

...

. . 1925, . 7;
. . . 1941.
.. . ., 1974 , 149
.
32
..
. .
2004.11.23.274. D-2 .
31

38

39

2015 1 (51)




,

,

.





.
,


?

,
?

,
?

,
?

, ?





,
,
.



.

-
, (LL.D), ,




.
6- 6.4 , 16-
16.3


,
1 .

,

. ,
,

. ,
.

, ,2
,
,
,



.

, : ,




,

, ,

.



.
,
,
.
50 .

900

.



,


.
3





.


.
,


.


.
.


.4




.5


,
.


6



.7

,


.8
-

.
-
,
- ,
.


.


.9



. Thomas Merrill, Economics of
Public Use, Cornell Law Review 72, no. 1 (November 1,
1986): 61116.
5
., 61.
6
Guido Calabresi and A. Douglas Melamed, Property
Rules, Liability Rules, and Inalienability: One View of the
Cathedral, Harvard Law Review 85, no. 6 (April 1, 1972):
1089, 1090, doi:10.2307/1340059.
7
., 1091.
8
.
9
, 1992, 6.4.
4


. R. H. Coase, The Problem of Social Cost, Journal
of Law and Economics 3 (October 1, 1960): 144.

, 1992, 6.4, 16.3.


,
.

1
2

40

41

2015 1 (51)

10


.


.

.


.11



.12

,


.
,
,


.





.


, .

,

,
.

.

,
.



.13



.14

, ,
,
.15


.




.


,

.


.


.


.





.

,

.
Christopher Serkin, The Meaning of Value: Assessing
Just Compensation for Regulatory Takings, SSRN Scholarly
Paper (Rochester, NY: Social Science Research Network,
April 9, 2005), 679.
14
United States v. 50 Acres of Land, 469 US 24 (Supreme
Court 1984).
15
Lee Fennell, Taking Eminent Domain Apart, Michigan
State Law Review, January 1, 2004, 957.
13

- , 1787, 5 .
11
United States v. 50 Acres of Land, 469 US 24 (Supreme
Court 1984).
12
Ibid.
10

42

, : ,




.16


,
?


? ,
,
?
.

.

,
,
,
.

.
100





.

,
,
,


.

,
-17


.
,


.18






.

.




.

,



.



.


?

,
?


.




.19


.20

.




, 1992, 6.4.,
, 1992, 6.4., 16.3.
18
, ,
,
- .

19

Frank I. Michelman, Property, Utility, and Fairness:


Comments on the Ethical Foundations of Just
Compensation Law, Harvard Law Review 80, no. 6 (April
1, 1967): 1165, doi:10.2307/1339276.
20
.

16
17

43

2015 1 (51)

.21


, ,

.

,
.



.







.

23

.




.


.24

,

,

.

.25


,
. 26

.

,



.

.
,

,27

,28
,






.





.


.22
,

,
.



Ibid.
Ayn Rand, ``Government Financing in a Free Society``, in
The Virtue of Selfishness (1964), 157
25
Richard A. Epstein, Takings: Private Property and the
Power of Eminent Domain, Reprint edition (Cambridge,
Mass.: Harvard University Press, 1985).
26
., 2- .
27
Jeanne L. Schroeder, The Vestal and the Fasces: Hegel,
Lacan, Property, and the Feminine, First Edition edition
(Berkeley: University of California Press, 1998), 293.
28
Margaret Jane Radin, Reinterpreting Property
(Chicago: University Of Chicago Press, 1996).
23
24

James Krier and Michael Heller, Deterrence and


Distribution in the Law of Takings, Articles, January 1, 1999,
997.
22
Two Treatises of Government (Paperback) by John Locke:
Orion Publishing Co, United Kingdom 9780460873567
Paperback, Original Ed. - The Book Depository,
21

44

, : ,



.



.


.


.



.
,
, ,


.

,
,

.



.


,

,
.

. (,
, ,
.), (,
.),
(, ,
)
.


,
.

,

, ,

.
,



,
.

.




.

.

,
.


, , ,
.



.



, ,
.

, , ,

,


.
,
,




.

45

2015 1 (51)

,
:

,
,


,
,
.

/./

.
,


eternity clause, Ewigkeitsklausel
,

. ,
-
.
1:

IV

,

.


:
1 ,
2
,
, 3

,

.
2:
- 79
,
,

, 1
20

,
,

I. .
,


,


.
,


.
,
,
,
, ?


.

, :
. ,

. ,

46

, ,

.
1 ,

,
,


,
,

.
20
,

,

,

.

,

.
,


,
?
.
, ,
.


.



.
1.



1.1 Pouvoir constituent
pouvoir constitutes-
,

, 1
1


.
,





.
,


,
,
, ,
. ,


.
,

.

.
,




.


pouvoir constituent
pouvoir constitutes

.




.


,




.

ius positivum

47

2015 1 (51)

.


. ,


.


actus
contrarius-

.

,
.
2
.



.





.


,


.




. ,

2

,

.
,

:
,
,
-


. pouvoir
constituent,
,

pouvoir constitues
.

.
,
.

.

.




.





.
1992
430


76
-
.
Pouvoir constituent pouvoir
constitutes

,
. ,

Heteronomie

48

, ,

.

,

.



.
,

.

/,
, ,
/ ,


.


,

.

,
,

.

,

. ,
-
,




...

.

.
(
)



.
1.2
,


,
,

, :
/
,

. ,
,
,


.

,

.

.



.
/
, ,
.
,

, ,

.

...

.
Pouvoir
constituant



.


.
/
/
, / .
,
,
.
.

49

2015 1 (51)

,
... ,
...
.

,
,
.



, 3,


.

.
/

.


.
,


.



.
, -

.
.
,
, ,
,
.
/
,

,
.

.

,





.
1.3

lege artis
,

,

.
lege
artis

, .

,
-
.

,

.

,

,




.
,

,



.




.


.

2014 - - ,

- - 65
.

50

, ,

2. ,



,
. 2010

,

.
,

,

,

,


,
.
, ,
...
,



.
,



.


,


.
3. ,


,




. ,



,

.

,
,
-

.

,

.
II. 1992
,

1999
12 24-
,
. ,
2000

3
,
,
,
,

,


2,
1,
1
.

,


.

,
,


.
(formelle
Pruefung)
. ,
(materielle Pruefung)

51

2015 1 (51)

.
,


.
2006 3
5-

2005
.

2007 3
12 20-

2009 2 11-
,


.
,



.
,

.


.
,

.


.
, ,

,

,
.

,
,
,
.


.


.
,



2000
.
2000 11 29
2


. 12 12 ,
1-


,
4 .
,

. 12
14-

,


,

.

,

2005
,

.
12
19-
5/51

.
,
,
4-

.

52

, ,

/2011-2014/:
4

,
4

,

. :
-
;
-

;
-
1/3-
;
-
,

;
- - ,


.


,


,

.
:
- ,
,
,
,
;
-

;
-

,
-


,

;

, ,

.
2000 .


.
,




.


.


.

,
,



.
,


.

1-
2000 12 12-

,
4
,



.
III.
,

53

2015 1 (51)



,
,
,
,



.
,


1992

,
2010
.
, ,

,

/5.2.1/,
,
/5.2.2/,
,
/5.2.4/
,


.
,


:
- ,





/ 1,
1... ./

1-
,
-
.
,

:
/12.1.6/

- ,
;


;
-
;
--
,
, ,

.

:
- ,



. ,

/
; ,

.../ ;
-
/
- ,

.../;
- ,

, ,

, / -

,

35
/ .

,
,

/
,
, ,

.../ .
,

,
,
,

54

, ,



,




.
-
...

/17.10/


.
,







.

:
,



,



,

.
,
,
,

,



, ,

.

---o0o---

55

2015 1 (51)


:

?
., 2013
30

.2

() 40
,
70 .


.3

,
,
.
,
,
,
. ,
,
, ,
,

.
,
? ,
- ,

,

,


, (LL.M) .

:
.
2008
,
,

,
.
,
2009


() ,1
()
.
() 34
,
1.6
. ,

.
,

5 , ,
-
.
2012
1.5

. http://www.dbm.
mn/
3

XIX
, XX 10 , XXI
12 .

. ., -
/PH.D/,
,
2013-08-08.
2

- 2008 12 4- 40
, - 2009 7 16-
57 .

56

, ,



,
?

.

,


,

,
,
, ,

.


,
,
,

,

.

5

.

,



. -



6
.




,



.7


,

.



.

.

,
.8
,
,
,

. ,

,
,
,

1.
4 (- )


, ,


.
,


-

.

,

-
1986 <
,

>
. http://www.nobelprize.org/nobel_
prizes/economic-sciences/laureates/1986/

Congleton, R. (2003). The Contractarian Constitutional


Political Economy of James Buchanan, p
6
Thecollected works of James Buchanan (2001), Volume
16: Choice, Contract, and Constitutions, p. 3.
7
, p. 54.
8
. , Jurisprudence- :
, . ., 2011, 170-197.
5

57

2015 1 (51)


.9



.

,

.10
, ,

,
,


- .
-

.11 ,



,



.



.,

. ,

-


.


.

,

.

, ()

,


.




.


, ,


.




- .
2.
/ /

-

.



12

,
.
.

Constitutional Political Economy by James Buchanan,


Rowley, Charles, Schneider, Friedrich (Eds.) Readings in
Public Choice and Constitutional Political Economy, 2008,
p284.
10
Tony Prosser, (2014), The Economic Constitution, Oxford
University Press, p9.
11
Thecollected works of James Buchanan (2001),
Volume 16 : Choice, Contract, and Constitutions, p. 307.
9

12

58

1 .

, ,


,

,
.
.

.


18
13

14




.

,15


16
.

, ,


.
.
,
37.4- -

24(2)b-e-

,

,
,
, ,


.

.
,

.


.17 2008



.
, 2009
(109-
3 )
. 2016


() 0.35
.




.
216.5-
- (60 )

,
.
- 50

.

36.4-



, -


.

: United States v. Butler - 297 U.S. 1 (1936)http://


supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/297/1/
14
216.1-
.
15
Article I, Section 8, Clause 1 of the United States
Constitution,
16
- 1924 .

() ,41- , 42- . .
, . , :
, ., 2004, 94-
13

Dan Fuller and Doris Geide-Stevenson, Consensus


among Economists Revisited, Journal of Economic
Education, Fall 2003, pp. 369387.

17

59

2015 1 (51)

2009

- 0.35

2011

1997

1
2011

2010

-
50

- 60

3.

- 60

- 40

...- ,
... ,
...


-
.
,

38.2.2
.

.

,


,
,19
20

. ,

,


.

,
,
, ,
,

-
,

.

.
,



,



.

,
,

,
,




.
3.

,
3.1..

.18

25
1 7-
, , ,

.
- 16.3, 5.2, ,
16.4,
- 5, 6 , 16.3, 16.4, 16.8, 16.17, 16.8,
19.1, ,
(- 5.2, 16.3.) ,
-6.2, 6.3 .
20
5.4
19





. . ,
, ., 2006

18

60

, ,

3.1..

, .
1, 2




()
4

.21


, -

.
.
1.

:
-


,



,
.
-

.22
2.

.
-

,
. : 2012.11.08 -
2013



,
,
,
,

.


.
3. -

- .
: -
2013 ,
2014-2015
-
2013 46.0, 2014 42.1,
2015 40.5
8,4 . -
49,5 .
40

23

.
4. -
-
.
: 2014
-
- 60
2-

.24
2015 - 70
- -
.

1. ; 2.
- ; 3.

- ... ; 4....
- 40
.
22
, 34
530 , 34
1.6 3
.
21

- ,
. , 2013.11.07, http://vip76.
mn/content/20694
24
- 2013.11.14-
http://batbayar.parliament.mn/uihgishiin/
categories/693/pages/15408
23

61

2015 1 (51)

.

.

,

.

.
3.2.
.

,
,
,

. , ,
,
34



40
71.7 .25
2013
26 608.1

,
,
3

- 13
.27
- 2
.
,
,
.
.28

.


,

.
, ,
.
. ,



,
, .
...
, ,
. ...

,
,
.
1-,

,
,


.
,

.
,
29
. 2-,
, -
,
.
- ,
.
-
, ,


.
3-,
, - ,

, .
,

, -

2014.02.24, http://news.dorgio.mn/economy/other/10155
http://www.legalinfo.mn/law/details/9254?lawid=9254
27
2013.05.09, http://economy.news.mn/content/
143556.shtml
28
.: ,
2014.04.06. http://politics.news.mn/content/175195.shtml
25
26

, ,
.

29

62

, ,

.



.
.
1-,
<

>

.
2-, ,


. ,



31

. 1-,
,
,


,

,
, 2-
,

,



,
.

.
, -

.30
,


,
,

.
,
.

,
.
,



, ,
.
<
>
,
,
,

.

1.
,
, (2)
-
, (3)
, (4)
, (5)
,
.

30

,
5.2.2 - 25, 38
, .

31

63

2015 1 (51)

/ /

1.

1949

10

104a-115

2.

1949

12

3.

1949

, ,
,

264-300

83-91

4.

1948

54-59
119-127

5.

1947

35-47

6.

1978

128-136

7.

1994

(
)- .

,
.


,
,
. ,


.


.


,
-


,

45



,
.
,



-

. ,

- ,
.

A.
8.

1999

81-92

9.

1995

92-97

10.

1975

11.

1991

12

53-55

12.

1997

25
10

122-124
216-227

13.

2011

36-44

. , . ,
. , ., 2009, 24-
http://www.knesset.gov.il/laws/special/eng/basic6
_eng.htm
6
, :
. , . , 49-52
http://www.sejm.gov.pl/prawo/konst/angielski/kon1.htm
4

http://www.businessinsider.com/spain-gets-balancedbudget-2011-8
2
http://www.ccourt.go.kr/home/att_file/download/
Constitution_of_the_Republic_of_Korea.pdf
3
http://www.finlex.fi/en/laki/kaannokset/1999/en19990731.
pdf
1

---o0o---

64

1992

)-

.
,

-
.
-
,

. -



.
,




, ,



.

65

2015 1 (51)



,
-
, ,

,
.2


( 4-
).
,


2014 .
-

,

- ,


-
.3

2015
-
2015
1- 13- .
-

,



.
21

,

,
, ,

.

, ,
-


:

, -


,


;

,
,
- ,



.
21

1990-



( 4- ).

( 2000
)

4
. ,
,



. 21 11 , ,
, , , , ,
, ,

,

.., :
, (, 2010), 1920.
3
., ,
2015.01.12,
http://otgonbayar.niitlelch.mn/content/6683.
shtml.
2

Robert Elgie, Up-to-date List of Semi-presidential


Countries with Dates, The Semi-presidential One,
accessed March 21, 2015, http://www.semipresidentialism.
com/?p=1053.

66

5 10
, , , ,
, , , , ,

.6
,

.

,
(

).




.




.

:


(1- );


(2- );

,
(3- );
,

(4- );
,


(5- );

(6- );
(7-
). 21
,

,

,


,
( 1, 2, 3- ).
,



(8- ),


,
(9-
).
B. 1.

.
: (1)
( ,
)- (2)

.
, , , ,
, , , , ,



.
, , , ,
, , ,


.

,

.




: (1)
,
, (2)

Robert Elgie, List of Presidential, Parliamentary and Other


Countries, The Semi-presidential One, accessed March 21,
2015, http://www.semipresidentialism.com/?p=195.
6
Elgie, Up-to-date List of Semi-presidential Countries with
Dates.
5

67

2015 1 (51)


, .


.9


,
,

. ,




.10

( )





.


.


,
.11

(1)

,


16 . , ,
, , , , ,
, , 10



. ,
()
.
, , , ,



.





.

, ,

. ,


()-
()-

.7 ,

. , 70





4 .8
( )-

(2)

,




. , ,

()-


,

.

Winter, The Role of Parliament in Government Formation
and Resignation, 123.
10
, 126.
11
Ben Seyd, Coalition Government in Britain: Lessons from
Overseas (The Nuffield Foundation, January 2002), 43,
http://www.ucl.ac.uk/spp/publications/unit-publications/84.
pdf.
9

Lieven De Winter, The Role of Parliament in Government


Formation and Resignation, Parliaments and Majority Rule
in Western Europe, 1995, 123.
8
.,
, 2 (: , 2014),
186.
7

68

2000
- 33- 1.2-

,

:
[1]
,
; [2] ,

,
,
; [3]
,
,

,




.



. ,
2008 - 76
46- .
. 2004 36,
- 36 (34)
-

,
.
. ,
2012

2012
( ),
-
. , 2014
, (
), -
.
. -
,
,

,



.





.







( ).
,




.

1992 - 33-
1.2-
,



,



.




,

.
,

.
19981999
(76- 50 )

-

.,
.

.

69

2015 1 (51)


.
,

. 2000
.
2000 ,

:
,

.

,
.12

:

33.2



.
,


,



.13
2000




. ,

-

-

. , 2000
2015




.

,

2000
.
,


. ,
,

-
.


-

.
,



. ,


.




.

.



.
, - ,

., , ,
: (: ,
2008), 197.
13
. ,
:
(: ,
,
2014), 22.
12

70

( 1- ). , ,
, , 5

, ,
, 4


.

.



.



.


,

.1924



,
.15

,
( , ) ,



.
,

.

.
C. 2.

:







, ,
: (1)

; (2)
.14
(1)

1-


,

.



. ,


.

21 10-

2.

11


( 2, 3- ). , ,
,
,
,
,
,




,


.

Jose Antonio Cheibub, Shane Martin, and Bjorn Erik
Rasch, To Invest or Not to Invest? Modes of Government
Selection in Parliamentary Democracies and Their Origins
(The Evolution of Parliamentarism and Its Political
Consequences ECPR Joint Sessions, Salamanca, Spain,
Arile -15 2014), 3, http://www.sv.uio.no/isv/english/research/
projects/evolution-parliamentarism/events/seminars/ecprsalamanca-cheibub_martin_rasch.pdf.

15

Jose Antonio Cheibub, Shane Martin, and Bjorn Erik


Rasch, The Investiture Vote and the Formation of Minority
Parliamentary Governments (Workshop, The Importance of
Constitutions: Parliamentarism, Representation and Voting
Rights, Istanbul Turkey, October 23-25, 2-13), 1113, http://
www.sv.uio.no/isv/english/research/projects/evolutionparliamentarism/events/seminars/istanbul-cheibub-martinrasch.pdf.

14

71

2015 1 (51)


.
21 (,
, , , , ,
)-

, ,


.

( )-
( )- .


.





.16

.17





.
, , , ,
,
,

( )


.
,



. 1949
.18





.
21 18-

,

(
)- .



.




. - 25-
1 6/-


.
D. 3.


21
, ,


.


. ,
,
.19

Winter, The Role of Parliament in Government Formation


and Resignation, 126; Steffen Ganghof and Christian
Stecker, Investiture Rules and Government Formation in
Germany, November 2013, 5, http://www.researchgate.
net/publication/261915168_Investiture_Rules_and_
Government_Formation_in_Germany.
17
Ganghof and Stecker, Investiture Rules and Government
Formation in Germany, 5.
16

18
Warner Heun, The Constitution of Germnay: A Contextual
Analysis, Constitutional Systems of the World (Hart
Publishing, 2011), 129.
19
., ,

(:
, 2009), 140.

72

.


,

.20




.21




.
.
()

.

.


.
.



.

(1)

: ()


, ()


(
)
.

, ,
, ,
(
).




.
,
,



.
,




. ,

(2)

, ,


.





. ,
, , , , ,



.

. ,
, , , , ,
, , ,
10
.

Cheibub, Martin, and Rasch, To Invest or Not to


Invest? Modes of Government Selection in Parliamentary
Democracies and Their Origins, 14.
21
Torbjorn Bergman, Formation Rules and Minority
Government, European Journal of Political Research 23
(1993): 5566.
20

73

2015 1 (51)






(plurality) .

.,




. ,


,
. ,





.



.

,
- .

,



.22, ,
. , ,
,

- .



.
50

1945-1987
25


48
.23




. ,


.24



.


.
,


.25


26

.27


Bergman, Formation Rules and Minority Government,
6061; Torbjorn Bergman, Constitutional Rules and Party
Goals in Coalition Formation: An Analysis of Winning
Minority Governments in Sweden, vol. 23 (Umea, Sweden,
1995), 41.
24
-
: Csaba Nikolenyi, The Impact of Government
Formation Rules in Four Post-Communist Democracies
(World Congress of the International Political Science,
Fukuoka, Japan, July 10, 2006), 14, http://paperroom.ipsa.
org/papers/paper_5077.pdf.
25
Jose Antonio Cheibub and Fernando Limongi, Legislativeexecutive Relations, in Comparative Constitutional Law,
ed. Tom Ginsburg and Rosalind Dixon (Edward Elgar, 2011),
212.
26
David Broughton and Emil Kirchner, The FDP and
Coalitional Behaviour (Pridham, 1986), 7778.
27
Seyd, Coalition Government in Britain: Lessons from
Overseas, 49.
23

Seyd, Coalition Government in Britain: Lessons from


Overseas, 38.

22

74



(- 27- ).


,






.


- .


.
14 10-


:
()- 2 , 8 (,
, , , , ,
, )- 3 , 1
()- 4
. , (1989),
,


.



14



.



.
(1)
.,
, ,





. ,
28-
:
(3) [ ]

:
...b)

E. 4.





.
, , , ,
, ,



.

.


.



14 .
, , ,

. ,


(, , , ,
, , , , ,
)

75

2015 1 (51)

(5)

,
,


.28
(2) .

.


.
, , , , ,


.
,
89-
:
(1)
14


.
(2)

14






.
(3)


(4)


.
(5)


,
,
(2) (3)
,
,

,


.
(6)


.


14



.29
(3)

.




.

61-
:
(1)
,

.

.
(2)





.



.
(3)

.

.30
(4),


.
(1949)-



.
63-
:
(1)

.
(2)

.

.
(3)


14

.
(4)



.




.




.31

(1989), http://www.servat.unibe.
ch/icl/hu20000_.html

29

(1992), http://www.servat.unibe.ch/
icl/en00000_.html

30

(1999), http://www.servat.
unibe.ch/icl/fi00000_.html

31

28

76

(1949), http://www.servat.unibe.
ch/icl/gm00000_.html

77

2015 1 (51)




. 8



1- .

14

,
, , ,


.

.



.
,


.

14

,
,
,




.


. ,


,

.
,



,
. ,



. ,




. 14







.




.

14
12-



.


.
(

)-




.32



- 22- 2- 2000

(, 33- 1.2/ )
:
2.

Cheibub, Martin, and Rasch, To Invest or Not to


Invest? Modes of Government Selection in Parliamentary
Democracies and Their Origins, 12.

32

78








.
2000


. - 22,
33- 2000



.
,

,

- 33, 22-
.
,


45


,

. ,

- 33-
1.2/-


.




. ,-



.


-

22- 2 2000

45
.
- 22- 2000

.
,




.

45 .




. ,




.


.
,

45


. ,






. ,


-
.


.
.

79

2015 1 (51)

F. 5.
,





,
,

.
,
,
,
, , , , ,
, 10



1, 2- .

,
,

.
,




( ,
, )-
,

.33


.




.
, , , ,
, , 7

.

.

.


. ,
64-


.
,


.34

.


.35







20- III
.

.36
,


.37
,



Ganghof and Stecker, Investiture Rules and Government
Formation in Germany, 4.
35
Heun, The Constitution of Germnay: A Contextual
Analysis, 128.
36
Jorn Fischer and Andre Kaiser, Hiring and Firing Ministers
Under Informal Constraints: Germany, in The Selection of
Ministers in Europe: Hiring and Firing, ed. Keith Dowding
and Patrick Dumont, Routledge Advances in European
Politics (London and New York: Routledge, 2008), 2122.
37
Ludger Helms, Executive Leadership in Parliamentary
Democracy: The British Prime Minister and the German
Chancellor Compared, German Politics 5:1 (September 20,
2007): 105.
34

Cheibub, Martin, and Rasch, The Investiture Vote and


the Formation of Minority Parliamentary Governments, 12.

33

80



.38




. ,

-
,
.39
-



.

.
,
,
, , , , ,
, , , ,
, , , 15


.
,

( 64- )


.40


.

(
)



( 67- ).



.41


,


1946
, 1989
.
, ,
,
.


. 1919


.42
,


.43

.
, ,

.



( 4- ).

.44

41
David P. Currie, The Constitution of the Federal Republic
of Germany, 1st ed. (University of Chicago Press, 1995),
140.
42
Dail Constitution 1919-1922, General Michael
Collins,
accessed
February
16,
2015,
http://
w w w. g e n e r a l m i c h a e l c o l l i n s . c o m / l i f e - t i m e s /
constitution-1919-1922/.
43
Cheibub, Martin, and Rasch, To Invest or Not to
Invest? Modes of Government Selection in Parliamentary
Democracies and Their Origins, 26.
44
Eoin OMalley and Cavatorta, Finding a Party and
Losing Some Friends: Overcoming the Weaknesses of the
Prime Ministerial Figure in Italy, Contemporary Politics
10, no. 34 (December 2004): 277, http://dcu.ie/~omalle/
CPO103P007%5B1%5D.TP.pdf.

Fischer and Kaiser, Hiring and Firing Ministers Under


Informal Constraints: Germany, 2324.
39
.,
, 184.
40
Heun, The Constitution of Germnay: A Contextual
Analysis, 128129.
38

81

2015 1 (51)

,
,
.
,





.

, (
)

. - 39-
1.2- 2000

,


-
.

-
. ,



. ,
. , ,

.

. 2014
6 2- ,
.46

,


- .


,

(- 25-
1, 27- 6, 39-
3).
14
-
.



3
, ,



1992-2000 39- 1.2, 25-
1.6-
, ,

-

.
, ,


,

-
.




. ,
1998 4- 23- .



.45



, . .
, Sonin.mn, 2015.03.21- ,
http://sonin.mn/news/politics-economy/27497.

46

Nizam Ahmed and Philip Norton, Parliaments in Asia


(Routledge, 2013), 154.

45

82


.



,
,
.


7
.

.47



.
,
, -
.

- ,
,


.






.

:
,
, .
(1)

.,
,
, , ,



.
(2)

.,
,
, , , , ,
, , 10
.49
(3)
. ,
, , ,
.




.


: 1972

1982

.




.
, 3- (18751940) 4- (1946-1958)-


.

G. 6.
48

.
., ,
(:
, 2009), 200.
48


. ,
, ,
, , ( ,
, ) .
,



.


.
47

Winter, The Role of Parliament in Government Formation


and Resignation, 137.

49

83

2015 1 (51)




.50

-
.
21

.
9


.
10


.

,
,

( 1, 2, 4- ).




.



,



.51,


.




. ,






.
.
,

.






.




.52


- 43-


,


,




. - 27-
6-

.53 -



.


:
.
2000 -



.
52

Vote of Confidence | Government, Encyclopedia


Britannica, accessed March 21, 2015, http://www.britannica.
com/EBchecked/topic/633033/vote-of-confidence.
51
Seyd, Coalition Government in Britain: Lessons from
Overseas, 57.
50

53

84

1. .

1998.04.23

2. .

1998.07.24

3. .

1999.07.22

4. .

2006.01.13

5. .

2006.10.27

6. .

2014.11.05



39:37
.1
42:22
.2
39 .3
22:46
.4
36:30
.5


.
I
- 53, 54-



.

.
,




.54
, , ,
, , , ,
8

., , , ,
,


,
.



,

.
,
,





39
.
36 .

.
, .

.
H. 7.



.
, , , , ,
, , , , ,
, , 13


.
,
Politics.news.mn, 2015.03.21- , http://politics.news.
mn/content/127486.shtml.
2
Mongolias Government 3rd To Fall In 15 Months,
Tribunedigital-orlandosentinel,
accessed
March
21,
2015,
http://articles.orlandosentinel.com/1999-07-23/
news/9907220537_1_mongolia-government-ministers-15months.
3
,
, 2006.01.13, http://forum.mn/old/index.
php?coid=1237&cid=296.
4
,
, 2006.10.27, http://www.openforum.mn/old//
index.php?cid=179.
5

, Politics.news.mn, 2015.03.21- , http://
politics.news.mn/content/194466.shtml.
1

Currie, The Constitution of the Federal Republic of


Germany, 135.

54

85

2015 1 (51)


,

.55


,

,

. ,


. ,

.



.


.
I. 8.





.



.



. ,


. , , ,


.56




.






.57


,
,
.



.

(-

7.1.12)

25- 1 6/).

. , 2012

.
.,
., .

,

. .

.
.

,

. ,

Winter, The Role of Parliament in Government Formation


and Resignation, 117118.
57
, :
, . . (,
2007), 140.
56

John D. Huber and Cecilia Martinez-Gallardo, Replacing


Cabinet Ministers: Patterns of Ministerial Stability in
Parliamentary Democracies, American Political Science
Review 102, no. 2 (May 2008): 169.

55

86

, 1949

. 1949



.



.58




,


1992 .



,


,
-

,

.




.
. 1992
, 2000

,
,
:
-
,
; ,

,
,
;
, ,

-
,


-
.
-


;


2000

6


.
2004


-
.
2008

. 2012
(48 ,
28 )

-

,
.


-

.


,
.
J. 9.


Helms, Executive Leadership in Parliamentary
Democracy: The British Prime Minister and the German
Chancellor Compared, 109.

58

87

2015 1 (51)





- .
-


;




.-



;

-
45




-
.
.



:
-


14

-

-
.

-


;





.

-
14


;



-



.
-


.



-
.


.





.
-

.




.




. ,


-
,

88



.
,

.



-

14


-
.




.


.



.


.







,

,
.


,
,

.




.



(- )

-


. ,


,

-



.




.
-

.




. ,
,

.



.


-
-
.



89

2015 1 (51)

, ,
. -


14

-

- .
-


.

-


.



-

.


- .


. -


,


-

,


. ,
-




. ,

-


,

.
K.


,
,
.

.


21
,


,
.

,

,
.
2012
,


.


:

90

.
,
-
, -


-

.


,
, -

,
-

.
,
,

,
.


,

, ,

.



. ,


- ,

.

---o0o---

91

2015 1 (51)

-
1



2000
.
1992
,

1

.

,
.
2000
12 14-
,


.
,
,
,
.
.

1992.07.06-
- , 1993.05.06-

-



1996 , -

1998
,

. 2000

, -

,
(LL.M) .

1.

-


-


.
,

,



,


.
-

,

,

, -
, -
,
, ,



.

92


-

2 .



. -


,


2011.01.12- -
.
,



. -

-



.
2012 , - .
, ,
-- ,


19
.
2013


-

,


-

-
.

-


.


/
/
.
/1992.7.21
1996.7.19/
.
/1996.7.19
1998.4.23/
.
/1998.4.23
1998.12.9/
.
/1998.12.9
1999.7.22/
.
/1999.7.30
2000.7.26/
.
/2000.7.26
2004.8.20/
.
/2004.8.20
2006.1.13/
.
/2006.1.25
2007.11.22/
.
/2007.11.22
2008.9.11/
.
/2008.9.11
2009.10.28/
.
/2009.10.29
2012.8.9/
.
/2012.8.9
2014.11.5/
.
/2014.11.21-
/

19

10

10

10

10

13

18

13

17

15

16

15

11

15
14
/2012.1.20/

12
9
/2012.1.27/

19

17

19

10

:
.,
.,
., :
1911-2012, , 2013;
/1990-2000/, , 2000; ., . ,

: , , 2014.

93

2015 1 (51)

-

,

-
,
. -
26
26.6-
,
,





,
.
. ,
, ,
10

,
,
.
2012 3 7-


2013





.


,





.3

-

.
2.

1

...
, ,

, .
.
2006 1
26-

7.1.25- ,

;- -
. 35
35.9-




, 36
-

,
,

,

,




.
1993 5
6-
20
1 2001 6
21- ,
...



.

., . ,
:
, , 2014, 15 .

94

,


-
,



.

.
1994.01.12 03 ,
.,
., .

1994.02.23- 04
,
.
1994.06.15- 06
, 22
1
29
1
1996.07.17-
,
1996.09.07- 06
, -

, -
29
1
1998.10.23-
09 ,
1998.11.24 02
.

1999 12
24-
,

2-
, , ,
,
,
,
1-
,

1
, ,
,



2000.3.15-

1. 1999
12 24-
,

,
, ,

,

2;

1 ;
2.
,
1

.

.
2000 7 28

03
,

,
,

,

,
,


.

2000.11.29-

95

2015 1 (51)


.
1999
12 24-

,
,

.
3.





4
5



.




.
,

,

.

.2

.


,

,
10




4
.

,


-


.


,

Ameller, M., Parliaments, London, 1966, p. 69.


Marc van der Hulst, The parliamentary mandate: A global
comparative study, Inter-parliamentary Union, Geneva,
2000, p. 48
3
.,
, , 2014, 242
4
Marc van der Hulst, The parliamentary mandate:A global
comparative study, Inter-parliamentary Union, Geneva,
2000, p. 48
5
Uwe Schneider in: Landtag von Sachsen-Anhalt: Bericht der
Enquete-Kommission Rechtliche und materielle Sicherstellung
der Ausbung des Landtagsabgeordnetenmandats, (Magdeburg)
1998 (= Drucksache 2/4631 vom 18.02.1998), Anlage 2, S. 19.


5
.

.
,
,
, ,

.
, ,
, , ,
, ,

.6


.9

.7

.8

1
2

., , ,
, 1- , , 2008, 45 ,
.,
, , 2014, 250 . .
5
Walter Bagehot, The English Constitution, 1964 (First
edition 1867), p. 151; Isensee/Kirchhof, Handbuch des
Staatsrechts, Band 2, Heidelberg, 1987, S.349.
4

96

Die EU-Staaten im Vergleich. Strukturen, Prozesse,


Politikinhalte, hrsg. von Oscar W. Gabriel und Frank
Brettschneider, Bonn 1994, S. 41, 55, 348, 478.
7
Jochen Weichold, Ministeramt und Parlamentsmandat, in:
UTOPIE kreativ, Berlin, Heft 112 (Februar 2000), S. 158166.
8
Johannes Koehler: Die Inkompatibilitt in Bayern.
Untersuchungen ber die Frage der Unvereinbarkeit der
gleichzeitigen aktiven Ausbung des ffentlichen Dienstes und
eines Landtagsmandates, Mnchen 1963, S. 47.

.


,
,


,

,


.
,
,

/1995

/10,

.

9
Thomas Wrtenberger, in: Landtag von Sachsen-Anhalt:
Bericht der Enquete-Kommission Rechtliche und materielle
Sicherstellung der Ausbung des Landtagsabgeordnetenmandats,
(Magdeburg) 1998, Anlage 1, S. 13.
10
Marc van der Hulst, The parliamentary mandate: A global
comparative study, Inter-parliamentary Union, Geneva,
2000, p. 48-49

97

90-

2015 1 (51)



,

.

20

,

(


),

. ,

.


( ),
,


.6
-
,
-

.7






.8
-

4.


,
,

,
.
:
- -

, ,
, ,


,
,
-
, ,


,
,
,
-

, -
, ,

Norbert Achterberg, Parlamentsrecht, 1984, S. 232 ff.


Edzard Schmidt-Jortzig: Das rechtliche Fundament der
Ministerkompatibilitt unter dem Grundgesetz. In: Zeitschrift
fr die gesamte Staatswissenschaft, Tbingen, 1974, Nr. 1, S.
139/140.
8
Wolfgang Schreiber: Handbuch des Wahlrechts zum Deutschen
Bundestag. Kommentar zum Bundeswahlgesetz, Kln, Berlin,
Bonn, Mnchen 1994, S. 567.; Hans Herbert von Arnim:
Entschdigung und Amtsausstattung. In: Parlamentsrecht und
Parlamentspraxis in der Bundesrepublik Deutschland, hrsg. von
Hans-Peter Schneider und Wolfgang Zeh, Berlin und New York
1989, S. 545.
6
7

98

600



,

.


9,



10


.

16 13
.



11,
-

12
.
-


.

1966

1967 4 6-

.13






1 1-


(1999 )

.14

,


,
,
.



.15







.



,

(, )

.


24-
(Eduskunta) 4
200
.
27


, 16

Jrn Ipsen, Der Staat der Mitte: Verfassungsgeschichte der


Bundesrepublik Deutschland, Mnchen, 2009, S. 37.
, S. 41.
11
Hartmut Maurer, Staatsrecht I, 4. Auflage, Mnchen 2005, S.
379.
12
Epping, in: v. Mangoldt/Klein/Starck, GG II, Art. 66, Rn. 19
13
https://www.bundestag.de/blob/196246/9fb8672550d4
44bcaae6904e9019f8fe/kapitel_06_04_parlamentarische
_staatssekret__re-data.pdf,
2015.02.09-

.
9

http://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/bundesrecht/
parlstg_1974/gesamt.pdf,
2015.02.09-

.
15
https://www.bundestag.de/blob/196246/
9fb8672550d444bcaae6904e9019f8fe/kapitel_06_04_
p arlamentarische_staatssekret__re-data.pdf 2015.03.19 .
16
(valtioneuvosto)
.
14

10

99

2015 1 (51)

17,
18,

,
, -


.



.

28
.



17 14

.
48
2



.
69



,


, . /Maartje de Visser,
Constitutional Review in Europe: A Comparative Analysis,
2014, P. 20/
18
38, 109
,
,


45
.
.
17




63
.

,


. 64





.



,


.
5. -




,

-
,

.19
1991
102,
76, 55
, 233
68 102

., , ,
, 1- , , 2008, 24 ,
.,
, , 2014, 81 .

19

100

76
.20

1
, 76 .

6 2000
,



,

. ,

,

.
.
-




, .



.
,
, ,
,
,

.
-
,



/cube root
law/ .
.,
, , 2014, 242 ; - -
12 II ,
XXII , 10 . -249.

20


1/3



.21

.22

- :
3.000.0001/3 = 137
.

5

5,3
5,1


200
169

4,6

166

4,4
2,9
2,0
1,3

120+
141
100
101

/ /


- ,

2011.12.31-
661.30123,
2013.12.31- 1.746.34224
.
Taagepera, Rein, & Shugart, Matthew Soberg (1989),
Seats and Votes The Effects and Determinants of Electoral
Systems, pp. 173-183.Taagepera, Rein (1972), The Size of
National Assemblies, pp. 385-401.
22
Review into the size of the act legislative assembly: Report
by the expert reference group, Canberra, 2013, p. 19.
23
http://landesportal.bremen.de/aktuelle-zahlen-33805795,
2015.03.19- .
24
http://www.statistik-nord.de/daten/bevoelkerung-undgebiet/dokumentenansicht/bevoelkerung-in-hamburg-2013/
2015.03.19- .
21

101

2015 1 (51)

83,
121 .
17.57
25
237 .


-


,



.

,



.

6

.,
2
,
,
.
.
2006.1.26-

22
http://de.statista.com/statistik/daten/studie/71085
/umfrage/verteilung-der-einwohnerzahl-nachbundeslaendern/ 2015.03.19- .

25

10-19

.
19 3
8
.
-

.
6
2000
19
10
,
6 ,
,
6


.
3


,


.

,


.
-

57

,

102


.

, -
,


,



,

:
-

,
-
,
-


,

,
-

,
,
,
-

,
,



,
,
- ,
,

,


,


.

108
-
,

,
- -
,
-

,
-
,
-

.

---o0o---

103

2015 1 (51)



,

,
.


,

.


I. :

II. :
,
III. :

IV. :
,

,



2 .



,

,

, .

, ,



.
2
The Role of Parliament in the Budget Process, Warren
Krafchik and Joachim Wehner, Institute for Democracy in
South Africa: Budget Information Service


, ,




.

,

,

.





,
,
.

104

3 .




.

.
()

-
,
.
,
2015 ,
2016-2017


c

, -
,

4. ,

.

-
,


,

.



,
,


Budget Institutions and Fiscal Responsibility: Parliaments
and the Political Economy of the Budget Process in Latin
America, Carlos Santiso, The International Bank for
Reconstruction and Development/The World Bank, 2005
4

,
http://zaluu.com/politics/?r_205
.:
http://politics.eagle.mn/content/read/27365.htm
3

2015
.
. ,
,

.
- .
,
2015.02.25

.

,



,
,


.
,
-

,

.
.

, 2007.03.08

10
,
,


.
2014
9 30- 5.5
.
2011-2014
2.8 .
, ,

5. ,




, S&P, Moodys,
Fitch
, 2015

105

2015 1 (51)


,
.
,



.
2015




,

-
70%-
.



6. 2015
2 17-




.
,

.


-


.
2 13-


,
.


,

.

6

Ibis

,



,
,

7

.



,

. :

,







,

,
,
, ,
,
8.



,
.


,

.



.,
:
?,
, 2014
8
Role of the Legislative in the Budget Process: Recent
trends and innovations, Paul Posner and Chung-Keun Park,
OECD Journal on Budgeting, Volume 7 No. 3, 2007.
7

106

,


.

,
.


,
.,

,

9

,


.,





.
,
,
,
.

,

,


.,
,


,


.
,
,



9

Ibis


.

.
:

):



,
(Von
Hagen 1992; Alesina Perotti 1995,
1996; Hallerberg Von Hagen 1999).
(

,
):


,


.
,

.
1.

,
,


: .,
:

(2014.12.05).

107

2015 1 (51)


, ,


,


10.


.

,
(OECD)
11


X
X

Me

1789.
1905.

1921.

1974.
1978.
,
1982.

1985.
, 1990,
1997.

1990.

1990.
,
1993.

1994.

1996.

,
,
,
,

3.

X
X

X
X

X
6

17

22%

63%

15%



.,

, , ,
,
, ,
-
.

-


The Legal Framework for Budget Systems OECD
Journal on Budgeting, Special Issue, Volume 4, No. 3, 2004.

11

Should Advanced Countries Adopt a Fiscal Responsibility


Law? Ian Leinert, IMF Working Paper, 2010

108



dead on arrival

12.




.




.
-

.

,
27



6 (22%),



17 (63%),
4 (15%)
.
10

X
X

,
,

,
,


.
: Krafckik, Warren and Joachim Wehner,
Empowering the Representatives. South African
Journal of Economics, vol.66(3) 1998. pp. 512-541.

2.

www.gpoaccess.gov/uscode/browse.html;
The Senate
www.senate.gov/~budget/democratic/budgetlaws.
html; CRS, 2001.



.
2
12

Blndal, Kraan and Ruffner, 2003




.
,


,
(
)-

.

, ,


12
(Appropriations Bills)
.


.



.


.


.


.
1958



.

,

109

2015 1 (51)


.

,



2001
.

.
,

.






.,
,



. ,




13.
2

.
10

40 ,
20

.

70
.
The Legal Framework for Budget Systems OECD
Journal on Budgeting, Special Issue, Volume 4, No. 3, 2004.

13







.

, 70




.
-







1958.
2001.

1996
.
1994-95.
.

1962.
1922.
www.legifrance.gouv.fr.


,
,




.


,



.
24

.

1990-

14.
14

110

Hubert, 1996



- 3% , - 60%-
.


- 2009

.
2009
,

.

,


2016
- 0.35% , 16
2020
,
- 83%-

.15

.
4
.


.

.

.

.

,
,


.

1949.
,
1967.
1969.
1969.

1985.

.

.

www.bundesrechnungshof.de/en/
veroeffentlichung/800.html.

-




1
Reforming the Constitutional Budget Rules in Germany,
Federal Ministry of Finance Economics Department,
September 2009

15

111

.
(1958) 40


,
,


.

.
(1949) -
. 2009

:


,



.
,

2015 1 (51)

.
60%-
(1997) .



,
.

. (1965)


.
(
)

.




(1999) ,

.

,


6
.


4


6


.






.


1990-


.16


-
3%- , -
60%-
.


,
.
6-8
,

.

,

90

.
-








1948.
1948.
,
1961.

1991.
1963.
,
1961.
2002.

2002;
1950, 1949.
,
.
www.mpb.go.kr
www.assembly.go.kr/index.jsp
www.bai.go.kr.


10

30
.
The Legal Framework for Budget Systems OECD
Journal on Budgeting, Special Issue, Volume 4, No. 3, 2004.

16

112



.





. 1949

.,

,




.
- ,


.




.

,

.




,
.




.


, 1866, 1921.
, 1911, 1949.
, 1968.
, 1983.

.
, 1998.
, 2000.
www.government-accounting.gov.uk
www.hmso.gov.uk







.
I ,

1980- ,
.
,


17.


,

,
,

18.




17
The Legal Framework for Budget Systems OECD
Journal on Budgeting, Special Issue, Volume 4, No. 3, 2004.
18
Budgeting in Australia, Jn R. Blndal, Daniel Bergvall, Ian
Hawkesworth and Rex Deighton-Smith, OECD Journal on
Budgeting, Volume 8 No. 2, 2008

113

2015 1 (51)

.




19.



.,

.





1900.
,
1997
Commonwealth Authorities and Companies
Act 1997

1998

, ,

Budgeting in Australia,
Mr. Lembit Suur, Australian Department of
Finance and Deregulation


75% (
, )


25%-

20.

,



.




Parliament of Australia http://www.aph.gov.au/About_
Parliament/House_of_Representatives/Powers_practice_
and_ procedure/00_-_Infosheets/Infosheet_10_-_Budget_
and_financial_legislation
20
Ibis
19

1946.
1947.
1947.
1947.
, ,
.






.
12

- .
,



, 1
.

.



50 (50/480),
20
(20/242)
. ,

114

.



,




.





21.

,




.


.

, , ,
, , ,
,
,
, ,
-,

,

-
.

,
,
,
.




.
,
,
,

,


.


- 25
7 ,
, , ,
,
,
,
,


.
20


21
The Legal Framework for Budget Systems OECD
Journal on Budgeting, Special Issue, Volume 4, No. 3,
2004

115

1991.


2010
2015


2015 1 (51)

(, )-
.
1
01- , 12 31- .
,
, 5 1-
- 6 1-
. ,
8 15-
9 15-
.
10 1- - .
11 15-

15.1.
,
, ,


,
.

4. -
#

25 7: , , ,

, ,
, , ,
.

9 .
9.1. :
9.1.1. 9.1.1-
;

18.3.
8.1-
4-
.
18.4. ,
, ,

1 1-
.
19.3. 6.1.4-

2015
58.3 , 2016
55 , 2017 50 , 2018
40
19.7.
,
.
7.1.1.,

(
)- ;

9.1.2.
, , ,
, ,
, ;

7.1.2.

;

9.1.3. ,
;

7.1.3.

;

9.1.4. , ;
9.1.5. .
22.6.4. ,
,
, ,
, , , ,
;

9.1.1. 11.1.3

,
;
9.1.2. , ,
11.1.3-
,
;
9.1.3. 8

, , ;
9.1.4. 10.1.6- ,

116

7.1.4.
;
7.1.5. ;
7.1.6. ,
,

;
7.1.7. ,
,
;
7.1.8.
,
;
7.1.9. .

-
2
. -
,


.




, ,
,

,

117

2015 1 (51)

-
.
33
1 1 ,
18
4





.

,

,

- .



6.1.4-
.

,

-




.

-

,


.

1.

,
,


.



,




.
-



,
,

.
-,
,
,


.
2.

,





,
.

,

,
,


.

,
,

,
.

118

3. ,

,
,



,

,




,





2-4

,

22
.
,

,

( 5- ).
Should Advanced Countries Adopt a Fiscal Responsibility
Law? Ian Leinert, IMF Working Paper, 2010

22

5.

6
7
8


*
6

2-3

70

90


, 0-2

1.5

4. ,
,




,
.


,
.
( ,
, .)



(
, , 2007
).
,
,

.

119

2015 1 (51)


(LL.M) .

,

.




, ,
,
//

.

.
22 2
-

.
25 1
6-

,
.

// //
//


,


.



,

.


.
:
-

-

-
-
.

22 ,

/OECD/-
,

.

, ,
.

120

.



.
,
:
-
,
-




.

.

.
,
,

,

,

,


.




.

,

1.

: , :
.

, ,

.

,

: ,

,

.

,


.



:
-
-

-
.
\

-
,

.
,

, ,

.


.

,

.
,

.

121

2015 1 (51)

,
119


//

.
,


.

104 :


120




.
.


, ,
1990
.
/
.

.

.
,

.



.



-
.


,



.
49
:


,


.

.


.

.



.


,
.





.




.
,


.

,



.
,


.
102

122



:
/

..,



, ...
.
35

.





, -


.





. ,
- 35
:
\
,
d\ ,


1

.
1990

. ,
102
:
/

..,



Constitution of Czech Republic, http://www.oefre.unible.
ch/law/icl/cz00000.html .






...
.
85
:
1/

3



.


3
,
.
2.



,
, ,

,



.



.
, ,
, ,
, , , ,




.
,
: ,
: ,

123

2015 1 (51)


.
,


.
-


,
-


.

.
.






. : 2 28
:

,

40

3
,
- 35
:
a\





,
1949
1989
.
2011 .
2011
, 1989
1949

, .
3
Constitution of Republic of Hungary, International
Constitutional Library http://www.oefre.unible.ch/law/icl/
hu00000.html .
2

b\


4
.





.


,

.
89
:
-
,
-

.

,
o ,

,
o
,

.
o


.
-
:
o

, ,
o

.5

4
Constitution of Czech Republic, http://www.oefre.unible.
ch/law/icl/cz00000.html .
5
Constitution of Republic of Estonia http://www.oefre.
unible.ch/law/icl/es00000.html .

124


.



.


.
.



,
.



:
- ,
:
- ,

:
- ,

.
1/




,
, ,
. -
28 :




6
.



,

2/

,
.




,
.
, -
67- :


.

68
.
48 8
7
22 2
45
.
3/





.

, .
,

,


. 68 :


Constitution of Republic of Hungary http://www.oefre.


unible.ch/law/icl/hu00000.html .

Reuven Y. Hazan,Analysis: Israel`s new constructive


vote of no-confidence The Ksennet https://www.knesset.
gov.il/spokesman/eng/PR_eng.asp?PRID=11200

125

2015 1 (51)


.8
.


,

,
.



.
4.


,
-



:
- ,

-



.
/

,


:


.

,
.
,
79 :
,
/
/
.

, .


,
8

Grundgesetz fuer Bundesrepublik Deutschland, 91.


...
.
,
137 :
1.

,

/ / .
2.



.
3.

.
4.

/States General/


.

.
5.

,





.
. ,
,

,
,

,

138
.


.
/

126


.





.

105 :


.

.

.


.

.
.




, -

:

.



. :



,
:
11 :
....


.

.

,
.
.


.
48 :
//
.

.

,

.
, 50 :

.
5.




.
- 1948

,

.
, ,
, , ,
.

127

2015 1 (51)

, , ,

,
1995, 2001
9.


,

.

:




,

,

.
39-

:
1\




.



.10


:
- ,
:
- ,


9

Hazan,Analysis , URL

10

Constitution of Republic of Hungary http://www.


oefre.unible.ch/law/icl/hu00000.html .


-
,
,
:
-

,

.

,


,


.


. -
67 :
1. ,


,


.
2.


.
.

,


.
,



,
,

, -
. 1998
.

128


,


.

,
,

. 68
:



.

.
.




. -1948
, 1978
,

1991

.

,

2 /1949/
2 /1978/
1 /1989/
2 /1991/
1 /1992/

//
0,03
0,06
0,04
0,09
0,05

1
0
1
2
0

50%
0
100%
100%
0

//

11.


,
.

,


10-20%- , 50%
.
,




.12

,

//

23 /1980/ 0,6

3 /1901/
0,02

166 /1926/ 1,9

5 /1901/
0,04
26 /1976/ 0,7

0
3
0
0
1


0
100%
0
0
3,8%


,

.



.




.
25 1 ,6-

11
12

129

Hazan,Analysis , URL

2015 1 (51)

6/ ,
,


, ,
;

.
-


2012-2014
.
,
.
6.

.
:
-
:



.
-



:
.
-




.

:
-

-



-


,
//
/
/
.





.

.

1948
1972, 1976,
1979, 1983, 1987, 1994, 1996, 2008, 2013
9
.

1972, 1982, 2005


. 1990


.

,



.

,

.


.



.

: , ,


, ,

, ,
.

130