Professional Documents
Culture Documents
NASSCOM
TM
Published by:
Recruitment Practices
The Who, What
and How of
Sourcing the Best ?
In conversation with
Deepak Dhawan,
EXL and
Bhaskar Das,
Cognizant
Inside
Let’s start with an exercise. Think of the top 3 business challenges
that your organization is facing today or is likely to face in the near
future. Lack of the right talent is sure to figure in your list. Logically,
the process of recruitment emerges as one of the most critical and
strategic processes in your organization.
Published by Accor Services, Camera House, Majiwade Village Road, Thane (West), Mumbai 400 601 www.accorindia.com.
Supported by NASSCOM, www.nasscom.org.
Knowledge Partner : Hewitt Associates, www.hewitt.com. For private circulation only.
2
HR CONNECT
BPO service providers in India, to discuss current and future trends of recruitment practices in India. Here is our tete-a-tete with Mr.
Deepak Dhawan, Vice President Human Resources, EXL Services and Mr. Bhaskar Das, Vice President Human Resources,
Cognizant.
Progress in recruitment practices from ahead of us in the scale of online testing and certification systems
2000 to 2006…. that are available
The recruitment function itself has emerged as
a very significant function. Till 2000, Innovative recruitment at EXL
recruitment was hidden behind the HR EXL has been a path breaker in this area.
function. Today, it is no longer a department § We have dedicated recruitment offices across the country
attached to HR. Hiring has become highly manned by our own people.
customized and processes, hiring screens, § We have run many new campaigns like the Voice of Pune
testing methods have evolved differently for campaign, tie ups with FM channels for BPOs across many
Mr Deepak Dhawan,
VP HR, EXL Services different sub-functions. Hence, it is highly cities.
responsive to business needs. In 2000, we did not understand the § We have tie ups with service providers to use their offices for
fact that the quality of people we hire has the most significant hiring across the country. Our aim is to make recruitment retail
impact on our business. Today, we have understood that much by reaching out to people rather than sitting in our office and
better. waiting for people to walk- in to hire them.
§ We ensure that not more than 50% are hired from outside, in
Evolution of testing mechanisms…
order not to deny opportunities to people within the company.
The testing method in our sphere is basically 3 tiered
§ Blanket skills across the entire BPO domain like basic
Key future trends in recruitment
computer navigation skills
§ Functional and domain specific skills § Investment in e–recruitment and technology application
§ Psychometric testing in some cases because of the support for recruitment.
requirement, of differences in profiles for collections (which § Vendor support for hiring will also increase with Recruitment
would require good negotiation skills) versus accounts (where Process Outsourcing and Training Process Outsourcing
one might need a high boredom tolerance index) being the next big things.
“
Recruitment in India v/s global practices…
This has arisen from the sheer quantum of people that IT firms in
India hire and hence the amount of investment to develop and
build capability in this area has been huge. Rest of the world is
“
Recruitment has become a sales function. Today you need skills
like strong vendor management, high target orientation, the ability
to manage networks across the country and a very sharp
business focus in people who handle recruitment.
A perfect prototype employee or diversity that they can make a more knowledgeable choice when they
in your workforce… decide to join an organization.
In terms of values and cultural constructs,
§ Evolution from the single summer pass-out system to a system
there is a Cognizant prototype. However,
of two pass-out seasons in a calendar year. Between April and
what would vary are the areas of skill, years of
July, the entire academia churns out thousands of graduates,
experience, and so on. We don’t want 32,000
but the industry cannot absorb them in just these three months
clones, instead people with a certain kind of
Mr Bhaskar Das, time-frame; they need talent all year round. The ratio of students
VP HR, Cognizant anchoring and of a certain mould.
Passing out in two different seasons should change to at least
Screening mechanisms… 60:40 if not 50:50. This change in the campus pass-out and
We have a fairly good system for screening. We rely on three there-fore placement system would have a huge impact on the
things: dynamics of the talent market. This is something that the
§ A seasoned interviewer, by virtue of his/her experience and industry can at least encourage the academic world to move
knowledge, can tell a fake CV easily. towards.
“
“
§ Strong networks with companies and educational institutes Campuses need to evolve their placement system
which we deploy to conduct checks. from a summer pass out system to a system of two
§ A 3rd party background check. pass out seasons in a calendar year
Industry measures towards building better talent… Psychometric tools for recruitment….
One of the prime interventions that the industry can bring about is We use psychometric profiling for developmental purposes but
to strengthen its academic interface. not for recruitment. As a recruitment tool, the factors measured by
§ Co-development of curriculum psychometric tools are not useful. It’s almost like saying if a person
§ Ensuring that the faculty teaching that curriculum has adequate likes the colour orange, then he/she is comfortable with power,
exposure to the industry. and would be good for a CEO position. Good story, not a very
§ Devise ways to increase exposure of students to the industry, so robust method to make a recruitment decision.
3
HR CONNECT
Point of View
Hewitt’s Recruitment Framework
Planning for the talent Attracting the right talent Selecting the right talent Induction and orientation
§ Forecasting talent § Identifying candidate sources § Establishing clear selection § Building a smooth induction
§ Identifying gaps between § Focusing on internal channels criteria process
desired and current demand of recruitment (internal job § Establishing robust selection § Ensuring business, role and
§ Determining priority to fill the posting/ employee referral/ processes to ensure selection culture orientation
talent demand website) of quality talent § Improving business
§ Establishing and § Improving lead time and leadership and senior
communicating a strong reducing recruitment cost management involvement
employer brand § Ensuring regular follow up
Are You Planning Your Talent Force? Are You Selecting The Right Talent?
[ Forecast talent needs based on current and future business [ Develop competency models for hiring - focus on behaviors in
needs addition to skills and credentials
[ Develop partnerships between Human Resources and [ Use selection tests and role play exercises
business units to improve accuracy of projections [ Use “realistic job previews” before hire
[ Consider forecasting of talent demand and identification of [ Develop coaching tools to assist managers to understand their
talent supply separately role in the hiring process
[ Use technology as a key to successful workforce planning [ Improve reference checking to include performance testimony
[ Describe positions and requirements precisely
[ Of the positions needed to be filled, prioritize and identify the What are others doing right?
critical ones requiring immediate focus
Allstate Insurance Company
What are others doing right? § Candidates complete an on-line application form and watch
3M a video-based realistic job preview for Claims Department
§ Uses demand forecasting techniques such as the use of project jobs.
estimates to plan for future requirements. § Candidates take various selection tests including a
§ During business planning, each unit forecasts the number of “computerized in-basket” exercise which has employees
make decisions as they would on the job and also helps
recruits needed.
evaluate computer familiarity.
Are You Attracting The Right Talent?
Texas Instruments
Effectiveness Of Sourcing Methods
§ Uses an electronic self-selection tool for candidate
Source of recruitment Volume Quality ROI
assessment. Candidates perform a “fit check” by answering
Online 37% 25% 36% a series of questions to find out the degree of compatibility
between the company and themselves.
Newspaper 46% 16% 24%
Referrals 8% 28% 23%
4
HR CONNECT
Perspective
How Do Best Employers Recruit?
The Hewitt Best Employers in India study is the largest employee Employer Brand:
research project and market practice audit in India. The study A majority of organizations have a formal and clearly articulated
identifies those organizations whose people practices distinguish Employer Brand that is used to attract the best talent. While most
them as outstanding places to work and enable them to deliver organizations had an employer brand, following were the most
value through people. and least descriptive characteristics used by organizations to
describe themselves.
We present to you, highlights of the recruitment practices of
Least Descriptive Characteristics
premier organizations within the IT and ITes industry in India that
constitutes approximately 28% of the 272 organizations that § Diversity in workforce
participated in the last Best Employers in India 2004 study. § Flexible work hours
§ Great place for first job experience
Planning for the Talent Force § Alignment of employee skill set with the work
Staffing Strategy:
§ 87% of organizations have reported having a staffing strategy in
place that helps them recruit the best talent and appropriately Most Descriptive Characteristics
staff them on work. § Advancement opportunities
§ There is a clear trend in the staffing strategy of Best Employers – § Provide a career
75% of IT organizations emphasize on developing employees § Interesting & challenging work
from within the organization, while only 25% emphasize on hiring
experienced employees from outside the organization.This Selecting the Right Talent
trend in the recruitment philosophy is depicted in the graph Other 34%
below. Informal lunch/dinner 50%
Internship program/formal 77%
probationary period
35%
32% 32% Assesment centers/skills assesment 43%
30%
Behavioral environment interviewing 40%
25%
Psychological assesment test/interview 40%
20% Group interviews (with several candidates) 7%
15% 14% Interview with potential subordinates 23%
11%
10% Interview with potential peers 60%
7%
Hire experienced employees Hire experienced employees Interviews with HR and potential supervisors are the most
from outside the organisation. from within the organisation. commonly used practices in these organizations, while group
interviews are the least used.
§ Another increasingly common channel is through internships
Attracting the Right Talent
§ New practices like informal meals, BEI and psychological
Identifying Candidate Sources:
assessments are also seen to be increasing.
While there is still heavy reliance on external consultants for senior
positions, employee referrals and internet are also being
Induction and Orientation
extensively used across all positions. 80% of the organizations in
§ 100% of organizations had meetings with the CEO/senior
the IT segment alter the referral amounts based on the position
executives and presentation of the organization’s values and
being hired.
business objectives as a part of the orientation program.
§ Computer based orientation through CDs and internet was
No.1 channel No.2 channel No.3 channel seen as a commonly used method with 80% of organizations
having using this.
Senior External Employee Internal
§ Team activities were the least common orientation method.
Management Consultant Referral Recruitment
Team
Middle Employee Internet External BEST EMPLOYERS IN INDIA 2007
Management Referral Consultant
Junior Employee Internet Internal Job Hewitt has launched the Best Employers in India
2007 study in partnership with The Economic Times.
Management Referral Posting
For more information on the study and to register your
participation log onto www.bestemployersasia.com
5
HR CONNECT
6
HR CONNECT
Case Studies
Building Talent The Infosys BPO Way
With a fast growing employee base from 610 employees in 02-03, to 7021 employees in 05-06, Infosys BPO believes that the focus
of Talent Sourcing should be on talent acquisition as well as increasing the overall supply of talent in the Labor market. Hence, their
following innovative initiatives are geared towards this.
Campus Ambassador Program: The Campus Ambassador Professor Internships Program : This program aims to bridge
Program (CAP) aims at building relationships with top colleges the divide between management theory and the dynamics of real-
and creating an understanding of the BPO industry, available job world business. The program invites faculty members from B-
prospects and growth opportunities in the student and academi c schools and premier graduate schools for various functional
community. The program is a 4 month Internship (Sept ember – projects at Infosys BPO. Each project experience becomes an
Jan uary) and starts with the chosen Campus Ambassadors from enriching corporate medium to study live subject matter and gain
colleges across the country participating in a week long real-world insights for advanced academic research.
orientation program at the Bangalore office, during which they
Project Genesis: This program creates awareness amongst the
meet with top management and get a perspective about the
industry. In its 3rd year, this program has grown to include 125 teaching fraternity in B and C towns, to equip teachers to create a
colleges under its reach and has attained an aspiration status for positive reflection of the BPO industry among students, help them
students to be selected as the Infosys BPO Campus Ambassador acquire the necessary skill sets through training programs and
of the year. handle any queries about BPO careers. Over 6000 students have
been trained under “Project Genesis” since its kick off in April
The Infosys BPO Elective : Through a 2nd year elective i n BPO in 2004. Based on the success of the initiative in Karnataka, Infosys
the B-school curriculum of selected Management institutes, was invited by the Rajasthan government to launch a similar
Infosys senior management members teach students about the initiative.
industry and various aspects like Operations, Sales, Human
Resources etc. This enables Infosys help students make an
informed decision about this industry.
Recruitment @ Nipuna: From plans to practices duration. The activity was conducted at Hyderabad from 27th-
Focusing on quality recruitment: Nipuna’s throughput rate of 31st July 2006. The philosophy behind this innovative
3% reflects focus on quality. At Nipuna, all recruitment processes, approach was to facilitate the prospective candidate to walk
such as FAST (Forecast Analyze Staff and Train) methodology, into our office any time during the 100 hour window as per
have been audited for adherence to eSCM* (eSourcing Capability his/her convenience.
Model) level 4 standards. § Job Fair Sponsorship & Participation: Nipuna participates
in job fairs across cities, increasing hiring while reaching out to
Manager-level recruitment: For the all-important managerial
a larger target audience through word-of-mouth publicity and
openings, a rigorous 5-step process involving HR interviews,
peer recommendation.
psychometric tests, background checks, reference checks and
leadership interaction is used. It is one of the very few
organizations to use peer-level interviewing to get a second Recruitment process at Nipuna leverages
opinion on a prospective candidate. Industry Best Practices
Internal Job Postings: Internal Job postings are used to best § Technical test and Voice & Accent test for accent
leverage talents within the organization and add to the knowledge neutralization
pool of associates
§ Case studies (scenario-based)
Exploring innovative recruitment methods § Role plays, psychometrics, cross-functional interviews
Nipuna aggressively looks out for opportunities to tap the best (Managers & above)
talent available. Some examples in recent times: § Mandatory leadership interaction (Leaders & above)
§ 100-hours non-stop recruitment marathon: A unique
recruitment drive aimed at attracting the best talent in a short
7
HR CONNECT
Case Studies
Branding Recruitment: Symantec India
Symantec was founded in 1982 and now employs more than 15,500 people. Forbes magazine has called it “The Best Managed
Companies in America”. We spoke with Mr. Abhay Valsangkar, Director HR Symantec India about recruitment practices at
Symantec.
Employee Referrals
At GCI, around 30% of our recruitments are through the referral
route. The incentive amount varies with position and they
recognize and encourage employees to refer more than one
candidate. The internal referral program has a tremendous return
on investment and it is also an indicator of the employees pride in
GCI.
8
HR CONNECT
International Trends
Talent Market Research And Trends From
Around The World
Most worldwide research on talent attraction and retention sets a Getting it right
foreboding warning for all organizations - highly skilled, talented, According to a recent Deloitte research study titled “Its 2008: Do
dedicated people, the kind that drive successful organizations are you know where your talent is?”, organizations need to evolve from
scarce and will continue to become scarcer over the next few the conventional metric focused ‘acquisition’ and ‘retention’
years. Amidst this, what can organizations do to ensure they hire strategies, to methods that concentrate on the things that
top performers who already have jobs and many an offer lined up. employees care about most: developing in ways that stretch their
And if getting them on board was not enough, retaining them and capabilities, deploying work that engages their heads and hearts,
ensuring they grow along with the organization poses another and connecting to the people who will help them achieve their
tough challenge objectives. By focusing on these three things, attraction, and
retention largely take care of themselves.
Where to find them
A Booz Allen survey of leading U.S. companies, done in 2005 for
Develop: providing the real-life learning employees need to
the Direct Employers Association, found that 51 percent of new
master a job – the “trial by fire” experiences that stretch their
hires in 2005 were sourced on the Internet and only 5 percent were
capabilities and the lessons they learn from peers, mentors,
found through classified ads in newspapers.
and others.
51 % of new hires were sourced on the Internet:
Deploy: working with key individuals to (a) identify their deep-
§ 21 % were produced by the companies’ own websites rooted skills, interests, and knowledge, (b) find their best fit in
§ 15 % came through general job boards such as Monster and the organization, and (c) craft the job design and conditions
CareerBuilder. that help them to perform.
§ 6 % through “niche” sites meant for specific occupations or
industries. Connect: providing critical employees with the tools and
§ 5 % through social-network websites guidance they need to (a) build networks that enhance
individual and organizational performance, and (b) improve
§ 4 % through commercial résumé databases
the quality of their interactions with others.
HR departments need to design their own websites to appeal to
the best performers. Most corporate sites are not “talent-centric,” The study also says that few organizations like Microsoft, SAS and
or centered around what top performers want. They are designed Southwest Airlines, have been able to devise and use methods
for someone looking for work, not people who might be looking for that have been able to attract and retain the right people.
a change. The company web site should instead answer the
questions about what its targeted talent pool looks for in a career
and hence offer the right value proposition that might draw in a
visitor’s interest.
The SAS way
Giving them what they want SAS is the world’s largest privately held software company,
A 2006 Conference Board study highlights that the key to hiring top boasts 3.5 million users, 90 % market penetration of the
performers and retaining them is to comprehend what the best Fortune 500, and 26 years of consistent revenue growth. SAS
want from their work and tailor the company’s value proposition attributes its success to finding the right people at the right
accordingly. A growing number of companies have been time and taking care of them. Finding the right people is driven
successful in marrying employee expectations and experience to
by a key tool for project managers - a highly detailed skills
the company’s evolving strategic needs. But before organizations
database. The software helps SAS’s managers analyze the
can put a unique value proposition out in the market, they need to
know what the best really want. The best and the brightest also gap between the skills they currently have in their departments
eagerly look for ‘job stretch’ - the degree to which a job being for a business unit or project and the skills they will need in
offered to a candidate will exceed the challenges, influence and future. Dynamic models allow them to test different scenarios.
status in his or her current job. By predicting their needs, they can set out to find and develop
the best people to help them shift strategies. How do they find
A Conference Board study asked employees what they
the best people? Not through software, but through
expected from their employers.
connections. SAS employs dedicated “networkers” whose
The top three responses were:
full-time job is to connect people and ideas. They are key
1. Interesting, challenging work
players in the process, matching managers to the people and
2. Open, two-way communication
skills that they need, no matter where they reside in the firm.
3. Opportunities for growth and development
Compensation finished a distant eighth. Decades of research
suggest that money becomes most important when it is
inadequate.
9
MEAL VOUCHERS &
MEAL SMART CARDS
www.accorindia.com
Bangalore: 93425 10043 - Baroda: 93770 85866 - Chennai: 93810 62571 - Delhi: 931250 9455 - Hyderabad: 93953 16110
Kolkatta: 9339242278 - Mumbai: 93210 26565 - Pune: 93255 03115
E-mail: ticketrestaurant@accorservices.com