You are on page 1of 3

THE PROBLEM OF UNKNOWABLE PROPOSITIONS A NUMBER OF LOGICIANS BELIEVE THAT THE STATEMENTS LIKE 1] N: NO ONE DOETH KNOW THAT

N IS TRUE Is NOT a knowable statement. Since if it is true then no one doeth know it that it is true. If it is false then it is true that SOME DO KNOW THAT IT IS TRUE. IF some do know that it is true then it is true. So it is true in either case and there for it is logically true and if it is logically true then it is true. If it is true then Know one Doeth know it. BUT IT IS TRIED TO PROVE THAT THERE ARE NUMBER OF PROPOSITIONS AND STATEMENTS WHCH ARE NON ARISTOTLIAN AND THERE NEGATIONS AND THEY THEMSELVES BTH ARE FALSE. PROOF: LET THE PROPOSITION / STATEMENT N: NO ONE DOETH KNOW THAT N IS TRUE IS TRUE. THEN NO ONE DOETH KNOW IT. Let it be false then SOME DO KNOW THAT N IS TRUE. IF SOME DO KNOW THAT N IS TRUE THEN N IS TRUE IF N IS TRUE THEN NO ONE DOETH KNOW IT. AS IT IS TRUE IN EITHER CASE IT IS LOGICALLY TRUE. IF IT IS LOGICALLY TRUE THEN ITS FALSEHOOD IS IMPOSSIBLE. THIS IMPLIET THAT NO ONE DOETH KNOW IT. BUT ALL THE READERS AND THE WRITER DO KNOW THE PROPOSITION N: NO ONE DOETH KNOW THAT N IS TRUE THIS IMPLIETH A CONTRADICTION. SO IT IS NOT A LOGICALLY TRUE STATEMENT /PROPOSITION

THERE FOR TRUTH OF EITHER SIDE DOETH IMPLIETH FALSEHOOD. THIS DOETH IMPLY BOTH SIDES OF THE STATEMENT ARE FALSE. ONE MAY TERM IT IS IMPROPER PROPOSITIONS OR PREPOSISIONOID IN WHICH EITHER SIDES OF THE STATEMENT / PROPOSITION IS FALSE. NECESSORY CONDITIONS FOR A PROPER / ARISTOTLIAN STATMENT / PROPOSITION. A: NO ONE DOETH KNOW THAT N IS TRUE , A=/=N PROOF: LET it be supposed that A=/=N IS NOT A NECESSORY CONDITION THEN A: NO ONE DOETH KNOW THAT N IS TRUE , A=N Then its falsehood implieth its truth. If its falsehood implieth its truth then it is true in either case. This implieth it is a logically true statement /proposition. Hence know one knoweth it. But at least all the readers and the writer do know it. This implieth a contradiction. This implieth that IF IT IS SUPPOSED THAT A=/=N IS NOT A NECESSORY CONDITION THEN A CONTRADICTION IS IMPLIED. THERE FORE A=/N IS AT LEAST ONE OF THE CONDITIONS OF A PROPER PROPOSITION OR ARRISTOTLEALIAN STATEMENT /PROPOSIION. ITS POTH SIDES ARE FALSE THAT IS IT IS TRUE THAT N IS FALSE AND IT IS FALSE THAT N IS FALSE SINCE IT IS NOT A PROPER /ARISTOTATLEAN PROPOSITION / STATEMETNT. RATHER IT IS A SENTENCE MAY BE CALLED STATEMENT-OID OR PROPOSITION-OID.

You might also like