You are on page 1of 36

lawyers line 3 OCTOBER - 2012

lawyers line 4 OCTOBER - 2012


vK

Editor & Publisher :


V.gunasekaran, B.Sc, B.L
Executive Editor :
B. Sarkarai Pandian

Sub Editors :
s.Sathyamurthy, M.K.Anand
Editor-in-Charge
Coimbatore : Na. Thangavelan
Puducherry : S. Rajasekar

28

Advisory Board :

E.EzhilCarolin M.A,B.L. ,
J. Suresh B.A, B.L.
R.Rajaram B.A, B.L.,
G.Nithiyakumar B.A, B.L. ,
K.Ethiraj M.A., M.Phill.,B.L.,
C.Murugan B.A,B.L.,
T.Gnanabanu B.A,B.L.
Investigation Team :
C. Manimaran,
G.Prabu,
J. Jenilaya,
R. Srinivasan,
Ravikumar,
P. Kalpana.
M. Sakthivel,
G. Hariharan,
Karu.Marimuthu,
R. Sivaram,
Advt & Marketing :
V.Baskar - 9176312470
Design & Layout
G.Kumaraguru
ONLINE SUPPORT :
www.lawyersline.net
Vetrichelvan,
Govindarajan,
Babu,
Vadivel
Shakthi Online Services

F
?
M F
b...

10

Copyright & Publication Info :

Copyright Lawyers line. All Rights reserved. Reproduction in any manner is prohibited. Published
and owned by V. Sekar and published from No.
15, Velu Natchiyar Street, M.G.R. Nagar, Chennai
600 078, and printed by M.S. Ashok at Kadalosai
Achagam, No. 1/1, Bay Arcot Road, Kodambakkam, Chennai - 600 024. Editor : V.SEKAR

All Communications / Queries /


Feedbacks to be contacted at
Lawyers Line (Monthly)
72/3, Anand Appartments, Ground Floor,
100 Feet Road, Vadapalani, Chennai -26.
Tel : 044- 23650044, 9841607006
email : info@lawyersline.net
web: www.lawyersline.net
All disputes are subject to exclusive
jurisdiction of competent courts and forums in
Chennai only


M, b C


,
J

F
F
H
C .
,
... b
.
J
F . .
cF
b
F

H
.

.
CK

23

F
....

4 P ?
19 N
25
32 ?

lawyers line 5 OCTOBER - 2012

?
F N
A.
J
,
F A.


O I
, ,
N O I
K
M P
M K
.
K
FM
M H
A. F 1990&O
F F

F,
I K
N F
F.
O HFJ
N

.
A.
, IQ
F F
..
I .
i
PJ,
M,
PM
K.
clat P
.
F
O E,
P C
. 2011& 23,500&
F
MH
F. 12 C
O
.
2010& clat

MH O
E M 6000 F
. 30,000
F
A.
F G
F K
G
, F

A. F
A F
O .
,
J F G
HK
F A.
GF J ,
P O
F H
C G
A
O G
G
A. K MF
,
P O K
, N

QA.
J
O EJ
NLU &
C
FA. 5
A
A. Q, F
MS Q,
NLU & N,
JM
C
b P

. , F J
lawyers line 6 OCTOBER - 2012

M
P,
CK
CJ
cF bJ
F
A.

O J (LLB & LLM) G
O
Hw IwM
, J
, ,
,
G . I
K
O G

..J K
E
.
N
cFF MF

J

A. 5
, F
F, , C,
, , G
C O N
A ,
O
N
.
F N
. 9 to
5

A.
FM I
JCO
.
LJ, C

F
CK, d C
J,
M,
. P
F O
.
O

C
.
F N
A.
J
,
F
A,
A. LJ I K
O C
,
M A.
K A
Q, NF
P, NJ
J F
P .
OJ

K
A, ,
F C
P C
J
A.
F W J
75& F P
F KI. ,
L F I
v K,
M e
A. ( OH
H 3 LLB OA)
H C
J
.

K E FK
A.
C
F
15 GO . G
c, O N
I
.

lawyers line 7 OCTOBER - 2012

?
F O
M O L H
W A.
FO K
O
HFL.

FM H
A. F A ,
, ,
,
cF, , C
K , , , H,
M N F, v
O K Q K
K ,
F K .
, J
GJ,
K GJ,
, F M, , A
AMA.
Q HM PMA.
HK F w,
H HKMM
F. HK F
HA. ,
lawyers line 8 OCTOBER - 2012

F H , M
C O I K
G M N
O K GJ
O KA.
C, F
CP H
H HKM,
H
FA.
C PH H,
W
F, F
M W F ,
, M GO
F K A.

A.
I O Q,

, L Q
F.
, QF O
A.
H,
A.
, , , F,
L H P

J
MA. , ,
F
O M O
L H W
A. FO
K
O HFL.
, J
A.
F F
K O
HA.
O
C
.


F ,
MF
HF . GJ,
I. G,
O A.
I A C, gv
(F , F ) CKA.
F ,
F .
F HKO

lawyers line 9 OCTOBER - 2012

K GF
K e , K
A. ,

F
O, Q O
, FO
K
J
FM .
FM H H,
J F
.

O
KA. , F
J
HA.
N
A. ,
M F
O . Q
J A.
M
.
Q F H
HK .
, FO G
, F
H HKM I
F .
HKM L
K M O
F.
L
F.
OO, O,
F A
O A C
E O
.
K

O F.
O cF 21&
HKM W K
I
PF. ,
F PA
KMA. HKM F
H GJ A.
F I F Q
Q, F CL
HFLA.

F, F
C O
F. HKM
C
F.

A.
Q A. F
I
i A
MA.
Q
F F
H .
O KO
F F
.
M
.
M C
F O,
.

K A
H
F .

Legal Quotes
Unfortunately, corruption is widespread in government
agencies and public enterprises. Our political system promotes nepotism and wasting money. This has undermined
our legal system and confidence in the functioning of the
state. One of the consequences is that many citizens
dont pay their taxes.
- Georgios A. Papandreou
We get information in the mail, the regular postal mail,
encrypted or not, vet it like a regular news organization,
format it - which is sometimes something thats quite
hard to do, when youre talking about giant databases
of information - release it to the public and then defend
ourselves against the inevitable legal and political attacks.
- Julian Assange
I think people should have the legal right to hurt themselves without fearing that theyre going to get locked up
for doing so. But on a personal level, if someone I loved
was hurting himself or herself in front of me, I would, of
course, try to restrain them.
- Chester Brown

lawyers line 10 OCTOBER - 2012

News @ Glance
Disabled rights activists flay new mental health bill

Calling it apartheid against mentally ill people, disabled


rights activists Tuesday criticised the new mental health bill
proposed by the health ministry, saying it would make it easier
to forcibly confine a person into a mental asylum.
According to activists, the draft Mental Healthcare (MHC)
Bill 2012, which is likely to be brought to the cabinet meeting
soon, deprives liberty of disabled persons and favours medical
professionals and psychiatrists.
The members say that under the new bill, the role of the judiciary has been taken off and a psychiatrist can decide whether
a person can be put in mental asylum or not.
Under the present law, Mental Health Act (MHA) 1987, the

All India Bar Exam (AIBE) fees hiked


50% with new web portal; Application
deadline: 25 October
The Bar Council of Indias (BCI)
new contractor has
launched a standalone website for
All India Bar Exam
(AIBE) takers to register for the next exam
that is scheduled for
25 November, with
fees for the exam having been
hiked by around 50 per cent to Rs
1,950 for first time examinees.
The site, accessible at www.
allindiabarexamination.com as notified by the BCI, sets out the basic
requirements of the AIBE and claims that candidates can register
for the exam online by uploading a photograph, signature and
supporting documents, after creating an account.
The deadline for applications is 25 October 2012, according
to the site, but details for offline applications have not yet been
published.
The application fees for first time AIBE takers are set out on
the website as Rs 1,900 plus State Bank of India charges of Rs
50. Those who have registered for a previous AIBE and would
like to retake the exam, would have to pay Rs 1,400 plus Rs 50
of bank charges.

judiciary has a major role in adjudicating every admission in


mental asylums.
There exists no lab test, radiological, body scanning, or
other empirical methods for validation of mental illnesses. In
this fragile situation, where questions are being raised about
the scientific validity of psychiatry, the bill hands over power to
deprive a persons liberty to psychiatry, said Javed Abidi of the
Disabled Rights Group.
Abidi says that under the new law, it has been proposed to
do away with muscle relaxants and anaesthesia during Electroconvulsive Therapy (ECT).
This is no less than torture, like giving give electric shocks
to treat a person without giving anaesthesia. We are strictly
against it, he said.
Bhargavi Davar, co-chair of national Alliance on Access to
Justice for People with Mental Illness (NAAJMI), said: Under
the proposed bill, you can forcibly keep a person inside a private
asylum for two months, renewable after a days parole. The
business interest of private players in the metal health system
is very evident.
The bill also calls for setting up of more mental asylums.
The activists demanded more discussion on the bill before
it goes to cabinet.
It is an obnoxious piece of paper and we will burn it tomorrow outside health ministry to observe the Metal Health Day
Thursday, she said.

SC mulls choice between simple and


rigorous imprisonment for lifers

SC justices P Sathasivam and Ranjan Gogoi are currently


examining whether life-term convicts should undergo simple or
rigorous imprisonment.
A man convicted for murdering his wife, whom he suspected
of adultery, was sentenced to the life-term by a Maharashtra
sessions court and the sentence was reaffirmed by Mumbai
high court.
In his appeal through the Supreme Court Legal Services
Centre, senior counsel Parmanand Katara argued on his behalf
that since the Indian Penal Code (IPC) does not define rigorous
imprisonment, the lifer should be subjected to only simple imprisonment entailing simple instead of hard labour during his life term.
The Maharashtra government has to file its reply in the matter

lawyers line 11 OCTOBER - 2012

c F b

F F v.
F K
cF F
F
Q :
FHK F.vv
v.E
W.P. (M.D.) . 4996/2007
v.F.....
F
1 F, F , FC
2. F, , FC
3. M F, (M
, F )
FC.... HFF f
F 09.02.2007 HFFJ
1.4/04/A1& M
F
K
, c K, ,
HFF F
HFF J H
.P.174/02& MM K,
cF M
H, F C F
226& HK M W F

:
FF W
HFF:
F. I
(C P)

M
F

:
19.02.2007& F
HFF
F (FC),
O M F

F .
K
, FCJ, .2, S.No.2487&
1126 ,
T.S.No.1135, F A, F H 13,
F . 98& 840

K 1985
1995 A O
. H, 10.6.1995
FJ, M
O W


F. A
F JL P

FJA.
,
18.08.1995& K
KM. JL
, M
A K.
K K,
.50,000/& O
M, MM

lawyers line 12 OCTOBER - 2012

55A
Vs
55C

, b

F,
F
12.11.2002 M F
()
H.
Q,
H
F H
HFF,
F O
,
F HFF

FC FK
K
F F
K HK
, Q
.
, 18.02.2003& F
J MO ,
2004& 173
174& , K

F
lawyers line 13 OCTOBER - 2012

F F 55(C)
HKM W

F
F K K
HFFJ O
.

HFF, K,
18.02.2003& FJ M
O FF
M , ,
F

f

O.
K 09.03.2004
F J
, ,
f . F J
, F HFFJ
F HHM.
, f
P F
F O, HF
FJ f
K KM.
03.04.2006 MO
HFF K,
M
F F F (55 C) &HKM
W , M
F F F F 38
40&O W , F K
.87,137/& K
KMA.

,
PH J e
K M , H
55A K, K,
N A
AP A &
K K MM
P.
, .2000/& F
F O e
, M F K
.85,137 MF.
MF
KM
MF

H.
K
HFFJ, M
.
F F F 55A
HKM W K MF
M H.
H MF
FF, HFF,
F F F
55(C) HKM W FJ

, P F
M .85,137/& MF
PH 2006&
L MH A
. PH
F K MF
H
. 15
H P, MF.
, HFF
03.07.2006 M H.
M KY GJ
, HFFJ
O P. 174/2004
MM F
cFF
2007& W.P. & 1084 F
.
MJ ,
MFO C P,
F 12.02.2007&
HFF HH
H. 19.02.2007&
M K cF
,

HFF M. Q
, 19.02.007& 2007
F . ,
M, F F F
38 40& HKO W,
, F K .73,905/
F K MF
.71,905 .2155/&,
.74,060/& M F
K
K

KM. FF,
HFFJ Q,
M F G

J

PAJ F .
,
HH HFF
M
FJ,

MK , F F
F 55(C) HKM W

H, HFFO
HF J .

2007& F ,

F,

lawyers line 14 OCTOBER - 2012

O K LF,
HFF F F
F M.
F , H
J e F
KJ i K F
F F 55-A
HK H,
H P FF
S.W , M K
10.06.1995&
JL
HK F
, A .
23A HKM
HK 55 A M HKO, B.C D
.
FH .100/& .1/& F
K M
F FH
F, F .10,000/&
H.
J, cFF
F 23& HK F
F FF HK 55, A,C
D A P MA.
11.01.2002 , F J
,
F F J

H cFF
, HK 55 A M W F
MM
F, HK 58 (A) (1)
FF W H
K F K P, PH
FK PH MF

A
,
H F K
MF, F e
MF
F

F. , 01.03.1999&,
, , M
K J K .4860/
J1/98-A & 10.08.2006& M
K F J
. MS.No.85& O
, P

K
A

cFF H. ,
MM

GJ,
55-C HK
F F.

GO, F e
F K FJ
100& .1/& . M ,
F FH .13/& .
11.01.2002

45794/C5/2001
, , F
J
K
,

F
J
F
. F M, O,
b, AO, P
e K
MF,
F e
H
PH G FK
, K J K
M K
P F O ,
F , , O
O
.
K
P H,
Q K , M
O P
KO K
K, M
N K P,
KO K
J MF
H. M N KJ
F,
J JL M
K, K
H, A, K
K , HK 55-A
M F K . F
F F I FF 55C
HKM W , H.

. P174/02 MM

HFF
M
MH.
F, C
P F.I ,
P.174/2002- M MM
08.11.2002 H. ,
F K
F F F I FF 55C
HKM W GJ
H. , F
F F I FF 55 A
HKM, 05.03.2000 ,
e PH
J e O K

lawyers line 15 OCTOBER - 2012

M A
H F 3%, F
K . F
F F I FF 55B
HKM W KJ
MMH , MMH A
, F FH e F
K H.
, K ,
K. 18.12.2002

,
O
K F e

K

M

M
F.
F 55A HKM W M
, FH e 13%
FH . 16.12.2004
. F
F 55C HK 2004& F
2004& 31 F, FF
. FF

K ,
H
K
P H
. , , 16.12.2004
K
K
M F
F K FH 13%
N FH 1%
P.
, 2004& 31&
F
FFH
H 55A
HK,
MM
(23A HKM
M )
KJ MMH
, PH
F F
K e K
M
,
F K, H
FF
F K
.
H
F
LF.
G
F J,
11.10.2000 F J

O, F
F
J
, O
,
KJ MMH
J A
K , F
F F HK 55C

lawyers line 16 OCTOBER - 2012

&J W HK 55A M W
H.
J, JL N A
F F F
HK 55A M W
F K FH e
13% A. ,
F 55C HK FF
2004& 31 P
J, PH F e
K
J

K , .100/&
.13% MMH
KJ FH F

H, O A
P.
Q,
K MM
J, HK
55C F C
. , 16.12.2004
P. ,
A, 18.12.2004
H.
FH e .13/&
P O ,
M M M K
HM

H.
FO K,
HK PO
H KY .
A Q ,
F MF
I C. F F
F 23A HK, MF
, K m
O , P
H C P A.
W .
23 A MF
K m O
PH C
(1) (F F
Y
)
a) GJ F
F
A F

K m

b) e F
J F P
m
K m
, K F
F FP , I
FF (5(i) HK) W K
MF.
2)
MM O ,
W K P MF.
06.03.2000& H F
F 2000& 1 , F
F F F I F
F 55A HK . W
.
4 : 55A J (23A
HKM MM )
MMH , K
e PH F
e K M
.
I I 2000& A
:&

K MM
HKM HK B,C C &
K M

P.
, FF H W
.
4 : 55A, J
MM (F 23A &M MM
) ( F HK
B,C D J MM)
PH
F F
K M .
06.03.2000 H I
2000& HK
55C D H :&
K K
M

J e K
K ( H)
K
O K
PH F e M
)
(i)
.100& (F
) .
F F
. GJ

lawyers line 17 OCTOBER - 2012

J FIL
F C
F .
, FC
O FL .
(ii) F ,
H MMH J
FH F,
.100& (Q )
F .
(iii) MMH
F
.100& FH
F .
D K K MM
.100/&

(i) F MMH ,
O
K MM ,
O MM
.100/& (F )
. F FH
F F
H
K GJ.
, F
I FJ FJ
P .
(ii) MM
, , , FCO
FL O, H
O ,
(b)
.100&
(Q
) A
K H O
MJ F
.
55C HKM P A
& K
2004&31& F
FF,
K A
W A P, P
. 16.12.2004 H
H K
, 2000& 1
F PF 55C,
2004& 31 FF F
16.12.2004 , K
H .
K M, O, b, WO
O
F F e

H A
A .
M: J F /
J P M,
O NO
P GI, A
, a I
P K .
K K,
K ,
MFO MM
, K MM
, K MM,
K MM H MM
O A. G,
K
FJ MF A.
, 2000& J MMH
MF F KJ
, O
F J
F
F J
A.
O H :&
4 : F F F
HK 55A M W GJ F
K PH
O W :&
1899& F F F 55(C)
HK

K
J MM P A.
& K K H
O . K
M, O, b, WO
P, F
H K F
e A F
A. MM A
J K
. K
K
K M 1899&
F F F 55C HKM
W .
3. 1899& F F F 55(A)
HK, ,

K K
, MFO J
MM, K MM,
K MM,
K MM 55(B), (C)
(D) A HKO W
MM P KMA.

lawyers line 18 OCTOBER - 2012


O
F
FO

& .
, K
K 2000& F 55A
HKM, MM, H

K
K

,
, M, O, bM

WOL
H
KK F

K, N K,

A
K, N ,
H , F J
O
J. ,
, 55A MM
P ,
, F 23A M
MM M)
( F HK B,C
D MM P)
,
PH

J
e
K M
, H 55A
K, K,

A
AP A
& K K MM
P. M, b
H
J e K
A
MM K KJ
e 55C HK , 55C
HK KY
, , K F
.10,000/& M
i ,
b MM, HKM
HKM b ,
J F
, HK 55C FF
A , H
& K
,
K MM

, F
I F ,
, , FCO
FL , F
H, MM
J FH e .13/& K
GJ.
01.03.1999
4860/J1 M K (J)
K , , ,
K A
A. ,
KA MM
F
F KJ A.
H
A. K
J

HKM, b MM A F
F F 58& HKM
W F H
MA. 11.10.2000
, F
F J
,
F KM
OF , HK 55(A)
55(A)1 W MM
HA , MF
F K
F .10,000/& F
100 F
H
.
PP , HK 55A ,
, F J
A O O
J
M N

lawyers line 19 OCTOBER - 2012

J K A
P

K P O , cF,
A. P, M, b , F J
WO P A 10.10.2000
K K MA. OF
A, 1126 A. , C P
. S.No.2487 .2 F K , K K
A , F H 13 F.S. .1135, P J

F Fd .98, FCJ 840 ,


. M K K
1980 1995 A O P e MM
H K PH
J J e A
F 10.6.1995 M F K FH e .13/&
MF
O W
.

, 2004&

FF

.

.
, A
, 12.11.2002
P .
F
K 18.08.
H ,
1995 .
F F 55C
H J
HKM, K MF
O
F
K

K
.
A. K
F

K

J,
.50,000& M
F
.
A
MM

A.
HFF
F
, HFF
F F
J H
12.11.2002
.174/02
OJ
H.
M
,
A.

I. ,
M

J N
H
K
A.
F M
.
NJ
Legal Quotes
, K

FF
I mean, in some
JL
cases with libel laws,
K K
you know, they can
. N J
M 55A
write things about

people who have no


HKM W
K K
course of action, be M
cause they cant afford
M F 55C HKM
55A HKM W
to take legal action
W .
against them.
F
-Elton John
55C HKM W .
lawyers line 20 OCTOBER - 2012

N
F J F A?
20,000 40,000
K . F
FH 10 20 A.

NJ

eP , K F
C O MF
F .
K F
.H.C. CJ
F G A F
H J F HCF .
F K

.

, G
M F
G
P GC
.
GCJ, H M
A J
H J
. F ,
K , K F
E MF J
A , K
M,
A H

lawyers line 21 OCTOBER - 2012

C . ,
C M
F , ,
F ,
G .
2010& KM
H , A
FJ, K
A.
N
A M. ,
J, F,
M MF, C
AA.
N F
I F F
A.
& 20,000
40,000 K .
F FH 10 20
.
& F d
15,000 25,000 K
.
& G A
15,000 22,000 K .
& K ,
5,000 10,000 K .
G A
4,000 8,000 K
.
& ,
, 13,000
29,000 K ,
.
& P
,
, HC
F F, 1,500
5,000 K
.
P 38
d E JC
49, H
M
, ? A .
F
K ,
.
K
4 A.
2007 F
K H
AK HK
M

F, A
I
P F
J F.
C , FJ
N P C. F
KJ F H
H KH
, K
C (IVP) . F H

.
HK, C F

, C O
C ,
K
. F
P

. O
F
KO J.
O F,

F,
M. H
Q
M. Q, K

I. , , H
O .
FJ H
J K .
Q F, F
, O MM
HA GJ
O KA.
K
M . ,
C,
.
, FJP
M P
. ,
, C
HP
P.
vM, v F
v, H
F
F.
P F ,

P.

lawyers line 22 OCTOBER - 2012

H P .1
. 2 P
.
, K
J
AC
J
P H, F
cFFJ G I
P.
N C
G F L
P P 20
30 O i K
O N ,
K F
FF.
F K F

G . C

v, LQ K
CA,
P C CA O
Hv Av A.
, K
F i
A N
KM P. O
,
O , J
, K M
O MA F.
K
M gFJ
A I F.
A
F A. ,
F I F P
F.
J H Q, M
CJ
K MJ C
O
A
LQM
A A Q
GF ,
F OK N
C MK A
F CK
M I A.
, i F
F F
M. N

C K F
,
I MF OA.
M I, O
K F
A
A. O, G
IVF K
O
,
O K F
Q K A
O
, . M & I,
O

P A.
( ) Q,
, P.
H, Q
M
O
H P A.
, , , i
F i
FF ,
O K
K

lawyers line 23 OCTOBER - 2012

M A G
F. M
M 25
iv AO
3.5
H & .
, KJ
A.
FJ
F A. G
F 39 K
40 v A
FwL A. ,
O,
A C
F
E. vH
C GIF
HM.
O O
P O.
. AO
O .
H M F
M HC M
P.
FJ F
, N P
CF. ( Q
F). M
F N
P F .
FA .
FJ, L ,
O
P CP,
A.
L I K CP
. Q, K
. H
KM .
F IK
, IvKJ
J
M . , O

G CK w
.
J
H M
P. FJK
CJ
K. ,
G FM. ,
. 20
K M

IvK , A
P.
,

K K
.
F P I
O C,
FM P
O C O
. A C
CT MF ,
FJ G F LGBT
F K F
P A
.
O FJ
, P
F.
O
KM
F . O

P. , F.
MM P.
N
F,
F F
,
A.
M I
.
P F
, F MO
C c M
A.
F K,
I L K
O . YA H
, M , J ,
, O M
P G
K F F
P.
H
H
J M
A. O C
P
Q KA.
I
MA A.

lawyers line 24 OCTOBER - 2012

&

KML

Hv

,
G
P
J

cFF

,
F


A
.

FM F
,

,
F v
M
A. F
MF,

A. vA
, F
G. FO
E FK
,
F P,
MJ P
FK
A. .H.
498&A
F W
F e
M F
lawyers line 25 OCTOBER - 2012

,
MF
F
O
J F
F. M,
, F

F A F
O vF K
F.
KJ

G .
Q
.
gF w
F,
A
F .
L
gF ,

MJ
. ,
, M
AJ
,
. Q MJ
,
O
FA A.
M I
A 1935&
F 13(1) (i-a) HKM W M
. F
H M
K H .
HKM W W
H .
. O
Q FM
M F
I GH . F
MJ

. ,
F J O
. .H..M 498A HKM,
M
F
K e L gF
.
A cFF
. Q, HK HJP
, e
HK.
F ?
, G
P J
cFF ,
F
A .
Q F M
F
FA A.
FM C F
E K
P, A,
A
P M e A Q
b A.
F C
GH.
HM 498-A HK
F
AP K

MO e
M .
MJ M,
M HK ,
.
MJ F
F K
M L F.
P M
.
MF
M F
. M, Q
i M M
I.
K AN, K
F K J
Q M
L P MJ
.
M N
M F N, C
GO Q E
QJ F.
M
F
,
MF F .
H K
QJ K F
MF N
A. M e
P (FIr) F , H
GH.
F MJ
,
iM O
, Q F
, F
F K
gF .
C ,
MJ F,
i, MJ ,
M M
F J M
F . F F O
K M M
F .

K F F M
M M.

lawyers line 26 OCTOBER - 2012

c F b

20,2008 EF
F FJ
Q :
FHK F. vv
P.R. C
Crl o.p.No. 18205 of 2006
M.P.No.1 & 2 of 2006.
F....
F
1. E, HFF
M , F
F,
C M cFF
H GJ 2005&
CC.No.177 & M
K F .

FM.wI
M/s. VNS GF GF
HFF...
F.M.L
:&
H FM
.
C M cF
F H CC .177& O
.2 .
I (O
.1) e HFF, M/s wI
HK GF K
P,
F 142 & HK 138& W
K K F F
Q K K AJ

lawyers line 27 OCTOBER - 2012

M M
K. HCK
/. wIHK
K, K
I F
.
K P
, HFF
J K
O MA ,
F 141 HKM
,
O F 138 HKM W
M gF K
P GH
M
M.
GJ F
F M M
.
M
GF K ,
F F
HFF / OK A .
O 138&
HKM W G K,
G
GF F
. K P
K F, K,

F K G
G .
K P
,

K
GF K, G
F
, K
O 141&
HKM , HK 138&
W K F W MK
C FC
F,
G
A. cF, F
H, K
P H M L
F FFA. ,
cF, F HFFJ
O Q K
M M G


A.
Q A M
.
F
F M cFF
K P M
. K P,
,
cFF , F
. P
F , cF
F . F ,
c, C&9 GF
2004& MLJ (Crl) 421
A b .
bH cFF
MF W .
P
A. & :&
(1) F F ,
cF
F .
(2) cFF F F
F H cFF M F
H
J H FJ
.
(3) H
OK F O.
J
.
(4) H

(
P FF)
(5) K HFF

lawyers line 28 OCTOBER - 2012

Q,
MF F
H
. ,
A,
H
F O K.

O.
(6) H H, HFF
M HJ M
Q
HM .
(7) FK HH
,
A F .
(8) HM HH
HFF M ,

, HJ M
. P MFO,
OK
, H F
F
M cFF H
. , c, C9
G F .
K P A W
A. :&
O HK 138& W
F J,
( J
O) H .
cFF J H
FJ O cF
F F F, F
. H
J .
, CO MJ
H OK
F .
J A
. Q F
MFO
F .


H A
MH . A
K P, K,
J
P M
K
M .
K P K
, ,
H, F . H
H K
A cF
A.
,
Q M e A
M M G .
, 4& FJ PH
, HFF/ O,
K GF K
GH, F A,
O F 141&
HKM
M.
,

M
F C
M cFF H
2005& Cc 177&, F
HFF/ OK Q K
e M G
A. ,
A.

P F,
, A.
I F K,
A.

72/3, v,
, Q, & 26
C : 044 & 2365 00 44

lawyers line 29 OCTOBER - 2012

w I

& .
J,
F FA.
F P
HK
FO F
M N.

SH

,
F :& F
M I K CJ1
M ?
c
GM i.
FM cF
F H w
I .
G M

M .
, M
K.G.Aw
F
CJ1 F
PH M

A, F
J (CBI) M
. ,
MF
.
K P,
P
K I

K F F
IP .
M F
lawyers line 30 OCTOBER - 2012

Q
F

.
FM FF
H I
C F H , H
J GF
H F
.
MH .
F O
K
cFF
, J
F.
Q

,
O FM I F
Q
.
F, v ON

.
M
H,

,
cFF cFF
GI
MJ
QM.

C cF P
A. F,
F
E Fv
A .
I N ,
A cFF
F
J
.
M M M
I K. FM
H F
P KF F
I F F
F P .
J, F , cF
F J , C
J M.
cF cFF
.
C 2G O ,
O
, M O cF
, F G
F, ,
MK H
FF I,
P
cF F
.
C
E G A,
M cFF
v d H
C O QJ K
F .
O MF ,
GF ,
CJ K M .
& O
O,
O N J
O O
h PMF.
F, N
M, h, H
C .
K .
cFF O M
C K
. cFF M
P I O
CJI I K

. (
O
MF
.
F M
.) H
I
F FOM.
, F cFF
M cFF
O K.
2012, 6 , M
, Fv
F e cFF
C ,
G h
.
G h G
F G Fv J
HC b .
Q F cF
f Fv
M.
Q K
bH,
O KM. G
h F G H
F A.
, C
A A.
M ,
C
F
. M K
GF F M

A.
F
A , b K
Q A IL
A K F .
G GF
. M
. YA ,
e O FM I
A G h
HC . , HI
, FK A
Q b F
FF KI.
M.L. A P, I
A
G.
, Q v&

lawyers line 31 OCTOBER - 2012

GF, GF
C F
E K N
. K
J cF cFF
.50,000/& MF.
, G
GH
C. A
. Q M
G EK.

C cFF
O .
.
cF J K b
GM . ,
M, , M F
F L K
A b O.
, cFF cF
O PM
P A , FK
O P
O M F
.
Q b F
cFFJ J F ,
FM I F MK
cF O 3
F GJ
G
GA
K .
eF E:&
F K v LI: M
& & (2&3
PQE) K v .
H Tv : M &
(3&5 PQE) K
v IP , ,
K, .
H v &
FK & (2.5 PQE)
F : F FK &
F & L /
3&5 PQE
F C: F CL
L EJ L.
MDP & v ( & M
& , Fv, E
(2&3 PQE)
C I v & K
M G

J .
GJ P A,
P M. 2010,
F M cFF
55,018 GJ .
v 2012 16 % FK. ,
63,749 GJ .
42, 583 F
F . M
W cFO
A E FK.
F P, P
O CJI J e
G K. Q,
cFFJ b ,
P. Q J
A. MC
M M (SPL) cF
.
bQM. W
cF J

lawyers line 32 OCTOBER - 2012

cFO W A.
K
F M.
, I K
cF A. F
cFF J
? P .
J
LF. P
cFF FI
KJ P
.
M F , cF
M PH
F. PO ,
PH cFF
M C K
. .
K
P.

, KO
,
K
.
M C G F
P J, SCAORA &M
F PH F
cFF ,
cFF M K
c M
H I , Q
K KM
MA K
Q GO
F ,
GF A
A M
KMF.
PO , F cFF
O F cF
cFF M F GO
P.
F.b cFFJ ,
M M H cF
cFFO E 25 M.
F 31&M 6 . 2011&
F 4 .
871
, F
M P I c M
, FM cF
. 27 O
M A

cFF C

cFF d

.
Q, cF GO
J ,
M M cFF
d
P.C A
cF C M A
FI.

A.
P P, L cF
cF
EQA IQ
cF AJ . Q
P J,
. Q
J cFF cFF
N AF
FF F . d
K GH.
cFF cFFO A
, GF HC.
FK
b . , F
M G F
, , I
c
.
J, F
FA. F
P
HK FO
F M
N.
, FM CJI O
A G?
N I F I CJI M
..
P F P.
K F, K MJ,
K Q
C.

lawyers line 33 OCTOBER - 2012


F
30&
MM
31& b

A.
Q
,

e
Q K
.

J
GCO
M
F I C
. FM
IK i F
J, I N

M G
, ,
e
F
. F
C
O
F .
,
, F
P .
CP
A.
P HA
, 4500
, K
FM P,
M. F
J , H
HJ
M. ,
NL
M.
G
F. , F
A. F
HKO G, C
NL
J,

NL C

c
?

C MF

.
, I
MM, J

NJ.
Q

A,

, K
. HK
H
,
N
, F
I
, , H
. K
J

, WN F
M.
WF H
N
M
. F
Q

F, , F

.
Q ,
J
,
HH
A.
, c
K GHd?
M
A. M CJ
(C,
v

)
HK

, vLQ GF
. I

lawyers line 34 OCTOBER - 2012

F M E
P , C
vFF 1 FF 31&
. F H
J, FQ
HF. F H
J FF F
, J
F MFA. F 1&, 30
31& ....
, O
F ,
PH A.
JK ( F HM
) (GJ)
A.
, O NH, ,
H, K, C
A ,
, ,
O .
F
30& MM 31& b
A. Q
,
e Q K
.
O J
O H.

F F, 30&
A. F ,
Q PH
.
O
A. H
P M.
MCF
J
GA. 31&
A P
M O
J H , H
F
M.
K, HFL
HFGF. O
F
H . C
O O ,
MO
. IK
M F O

HFLA. ,
I

A.
F F .
Q
F
, HJ I

lawyers line 35 OCTOBER - 2012

.
F J ,
i A H
. Q
W .
Q, F
F FMA. L
L

,
HF O
C 15&20 F
, FJ J
W F H
K M
M F
F M F
. Q
F 65 H,
C
I. e
. W
M K
. F ,
M F
HH J M
, MF
H
F MA. ,
H FJ
F P F
A. K
. c
. Q
W F
. , H
FA. Q
H H,
A.
C .
F F J
( ), , C
F F C G
A F
A. PH
HFL, C A,
C G
C . LO
L ,
LO
HC
P
M.
F HF ,
F CJ K.

O, , FM
. F
HC
,

C F
HF A.
O G.
M H
F AA.
M. M
A L F
A.
. A
FF. , H
A A?
,

.
FJ
. . Y
M J C
.
F
OJ O F ,
G
. C K
, KF Q,
F F P F,
FA P
, F
N .
W , x
F,
. i
.
M,
G A.
W , IP
HH
C A
. L
. Q F
M , Q KO
F KAM
F.
Fw
M. Y MJ
F , G
J , W
O i
G, FL .

lawyers line 36 OCTOBER - 2012

lawyers line 37 OCTOBER - 2012

lawyers line 38 OCTOBER - 2012