Professional Documents
Culture Documents
1
It was taught in the name of Rabbi Eliezer: G-d swore by His
throne of glory, "If converts come from any nation they will
be accepted, but from the progeny of Amalek and his
household they will not be accepted" (Mechilta, end of
B'shalach. Also see Midrash Tanchuma Ki Tezta 11, P'sikta
D'rav Kahana 3)
The option of conversion is open for all nations and peoples, with
the exception of Amalek, who can never join the Jewish people. On
the other hand, the Gemara in a number of places relates that
descendants of Haman, who was a prominent member of the
Amalek family, did in fact join the Jewish people.
All non Jews when they convert and accept all the
commandments…are like Jews for all matters,… except the
four nations exclusively[bilvad] (who can not convert) and
they are Amon, Moav, Egypt, and Edom. These nations, when
they convert, are Jews for all matters with the exception of
joining the community (in marriage) (Mishna Torah Issuri
Biah 12:17).
The Rambam (Laws of Kings 6:4) describes the etiquette of war, and
says that prior to battle the opposing side should be offered the
possibility to accept the commandments and subjugation. This offer
is also extended to Amalek. Apparently, when Amalek accepts the
seven Noachide laws, they lose the status of Amalek and must no
longer be obliterated. In other words, there are three possibilities for
2
an individual born of Amalekian blood: maintaining his initial status
of Amalekite and thus being slated for obliteration; accepting the
seven Noachide laws, at which point his status becomes that of a
righteous gentile; and full-fledged conversion.
Said Rabban Gamaliel to him: "Is it not already laid down, 'An
Ammonite or a Moavite shall not enter into the assembly of
the Lord'? R. Joshua replied to him: Do Ammon and Moav still
reside in their original homes? Sancherev King of Assyria
long ago went up and mixed up all the nations, as it says, 'I
have removed the bounds of the peoples and have robbed
their treasures and have brought down as one mighty their
inhabitants'; and whatever strays [from a group] is assumed
to belong to the larger section of the group (Brachot 28a)
On the other hand in the very next law, the Rambam writes of the
obligation to destroy Amalek. Here the Rambam leaves out this
important caveat. For some reason the Rambam believes that the
identities of the seven nations have disappeared due to the policy of
massive population transfers employed by Sancherev, yet Amalek
lives as a distinct, identifiable entity! Rav Chaim explained that
Amalek is therefore a conceptual category and not merely an
historical reality: One who behaves as an Amalekite can achieve the
status of Amalek. Rav Chaim's grandson, Rav Yosef Dov
Soloveitchik, applied this teaching to the Nazis who adopted an
Amalakian worldview, unfortunately with more success than the
historical Amalekites.
3
The tradition that former Amalekites studied Torah in B'nai Brak has
a fascinating post- script. Who is referred to in this passage? The Ein
Ya'akov cites a tradition that the person referred to was Rav Shumel
bar Shilat. Other sources identify the descendant with B'nai Brak's
most famous citizen, none other than Rabbi Akiva! We know that
Rabbi Akiva lived in B'nai Brak from a celebrated passage in the
Haggada of Pesach. The Talmud also tells us that B'nei Brak was the
home of Rabbi Akiva:
4
Timna was an aristocratic woman who wished to join the Jewish
People. Avraham, Yitzchak and Ya'akov rejected her. She chose what
seemed to her the next best thing, and joined Esav, reasoning that
Esav was from the same family. Timna's union with Esav is thus
reminiscent of the midrashic accounts of Hagar's relationship with
Avraham: She, too, was a descendent of royalty. Evidently, the "Beit
Din" of our forefathers felt that Timna should not be accepted into
the fold; perhaps they sensed that Amalek would emerge from her.
The Talmud, though, concludes that had they accepted her, Amalek
would never have emerged.
Our observations began with the stipulation that the Torah portion
regarding Amalek is one of the most important of the yearly cycle,
and that we are enjoined from generation to generation to wipe out
the nefarious memory of our arch-enemy. At this point, we have
come to appreciate another option the Torah offers for "wiping out
the memory of Amalek": Teach them Torah and correct the mistake
and injustice perpetrated against Timna long ago.