179

.. *


. ,
(
);
.

. , ,
, .. , .
: , , , , :
.
, :
I
1) ;
2) .
, , . 15, 330, 395 .
( ) (
), , , .5 .5
1
5 1999 . 46- , .6, 71 2
26 1995 . 208- ( );
II
1) ,
2) ,
3) ,
3
4) ,
5) ,
6) , ,
7) , ( ),
8) ,
9) ;
* .., 2006

180

. 2006. 1 (41)

III
1) ,
2) ,
3) ,
4) , ,
5) ,
6) ;
IV
1) ,
2) ,
4
3) ,
4) ,
5) - .
, , ( ).
, ,
.
,

( ,
), .. , :
I
:
1) ;
2) .
II
:
1) () ;
2) () ;
3) ;
5
4) .
-.
, -,
, ( ) ,
(,
,
, ) , - ,
. . , , ,
, , ,
, , ( )

181

, .. ..
.

:
1) ,
(.3 .10 );
2) ;
3) (.5 .9 , .5

6
18 2003 . 19 );
4)
, (.3 .10 ).
1- .. .
, , , .. (.17, 18,
21, 24, 48, 49, 56 ). (.1 .322 ).
,
(.2 .322, .2 .1047 ).
.
, , 7
.
2- () . , .1
.98 .II .2 .52 .
(.II .2 .52 ).
, .. , ; , .. , (
), (
). , , ? , , .. , , . ? , , .. 1)

; 2) ; 3)
.
3- ,
, , .. .

182

. 2006. 1 (41)

, :
1) ; 2)
. .II .1 .98 .5 .9
. . .12 8 2001
8
. 129- 9
, , .. . 10
.
.169 ,
, , .
4- 2 : .

(.50 ), (.430 ) ..


(.980 ). .II .2 .98
.986 , , , ,
. ,
, , .
.984 : ( )
,
(), . ( ).
. :
1) ,
;
2)
,
.
1- . - .
2- , 10 20
, 100 200 (.15.22 ). ,
, , , , : -

183

. ,
, , , (.1 .51
11
22 1996 . 39- ), .. - .
(,
) (, )
.

, . (.2, 3 .14.1 ) (. 1 2 .171 ), .
.1 .171 ... ,
.

, . , .3 .167 .168 (.6
.80 ).
.
, ,

:
, ..
( , ) ,
, () .., . , .

( ), ( , , .).

(.15.20 ). .
( ) .
, .. , :
1)
(.24 ...)
2) () ,
(.25 ...)

184

. 2006. 1 (41)

...
. (. 1) .
1

,


,

( ,
250 .
.)

200 .
.

18
.,



3
80 . .


6 .,

120 180 .;
,

,

,






5
80 . .


6 .,
180 240 ,
4
6 .,
2 ;
,

,
,



,

,
10 20 ;
,


,

.1 .169 ;
.2 .24
...

.2 .169 ;
.2 .24
...

.1 .14.25
;
.2 .24
...

- ( ) - - . - ,
.1069, 1071 .
(. 2).

185

,
-,

,

,
,
,
, ,

,

,

,

.3 .14.25

50

50 3

.4 .14.25

.2 .25
...

- , .
- , , , , , (.12 ).
, .
(. 3).
3

()

,


()

,

,
10 20
;
,

.2 .14.25 ;
.2 .24

...

186

. 2006. 1 (41)

()

- ,




,

,


,

( ,

250 . .)

200
. .

18
.,


3

80 . .


6 .,

120 180 .
200
. .

18
.,


3 80
. .

6
.,
120
180 .



5
80 . .


6 .,

180 240 ,
4
6 .,
2

.1 .169

.1 .169

.2 .169

( , , ..). , -12
, . , ,
. , , , .

187

, , (.15.17
)? , (.5 ) , (.2 .28 ); ,
(.3 .835 )? .185
, ,
. , : (, .52
)
(, .91 13
) . , , , , , , , ,
, , , .
,

, (.30 ).
- .
, , , ( ),
,
, - .
. ,
.
. , ( ), ,
, - .

.: . 1999. - 10. .1163 ( . . .).

.: . 1996. - 1. .1 ( . . .).
3
4 ., : ..
: -. . ., 2004. .5.
4
. , : .. -
: . . . , 2001.
5
,
(.: .. : (

,
2

188

. 2006. 1 (41)

) / . . ... .: . ., 1997. .12),

.
6
.: . - 2004. -1.
7
., : . - 1998. - 1. - .61.
8
.: . - 2001. - 33 (.1). - .3431 ( . . .).
9

. , 28
2003 . 9
,
, ,
.. ( , )
. .: . 2003. - 17.
10
.. ...
, ,
,
. .: ..
- ., 2003.
11
.: . 1996. - 17. .1918 ( . . .).
12
., : ..185, 185.1 ; .15 ; 5 1999 . 46-; .51
.
13
. 52, 90, 91 , .8, 44.1 .

V.V. Dolinskaya
THE SYSTEM OF RESPONSIBILITY RELATIONS
IN JOINT-STOCK LAW
This article provides a detailed analysis of cases and peculiarities in
internal and external joint- stock relations. The author draws a conclusion
that the condition for the responsibility in internal relations is based upon
encroachments of mixed type (on right of property and legal status of
subjects); the responsibility in external relations is of a complex type
and, according to the general rule, has compensatory-restoration
orientation.