1,2 1 3 1 1 1

1.,,
2300092.,,
230601
3.(),,
215024
:,
,
, ,
,
,
:;;;;

:
TK422DOI:
10.
3969/
i
s
sn.
1004-132X.
2012.
16.
022
j.
F
i
n
i
t
eEl
eme
n
tAna
l
s
i
sonBo
l
t
e
dJ
o
i
n
t
sBa
s
e
donThr
e
e-d
imen
s
i
ona
lAc
cu
r
a
t
eMode
l
i
ng Me
t
hod
y
,
HeP
i
ng1 2 L
i
uGuang
f
u1 GuYe
shu
i3 ZhouDan1 Huang Ha
i
hong1 Wang Yan1
1.
He
f
e
iUn
i
ve
r
s
i
t
fTe
chno
l
ogy,
He
f
e
i,
230009
yo
,
2.
Anhu
iUn
i
ve
r
s
i
t
fAr
ch
i
t
e
c
t
u
r
e He
f
e
i,
230601
yo
(
)
,
,
3.
Gi
fRe
s
e
a
r
chCen
t
e
r Ch
i
na Co. Lt
d. Suzhou,
J
i
angsu,
215024
Ab
s
t
r
a
c
t:Ac
c
o
rd
i
ngt
ot
he mode
l
i
ngd
i
f
f
i
cu
l
t
i
e
sandimp
r
e
c
i
s
i
onc
aus
edbyi
ncomp
l
e
t
et
hr
e
adi
n
,
t
hepr
o
c
e
s
so
ff
i
n
i
t
ee
l
emen
tana
l
s
i
sf
o
rb
o
l
t
as
i
r
a
lm
o
d
e
l
i
n
m
e
t
h
o
da
n
das
i
m
l
i
f
i
e
dt
h
r
e
e
-d
i
y
p
g
p

mens
i
ona
lax
i
symme
t
r
i
cmode
l
i
ng me
t
hodwe
r
eadop
t
eds
epa
r
a
t
e
l
r
i
ngt
her
e
su
l
t
so
fs
t
r
e
s
s
y.Bycompa
d
i
s
t
r
i
bu
t
i
onone
a
chc
i
r
c
l
eo
ft
hes
c
r
ewsandt
he max
imum o
fequ
i
va
l
en
ts
t
r
e
s
sa
tt
her
oo
t
so
ft
he
t
hr
e
adsc
a
l
cu
l
a
t
edf
r
omtwod
i
f
f
e
r
en
tnume
r
i
c
a
lmode
l
s,t
her
e
a
s
onsf
o
rt
hed
i
f
f
e
r
enc
ebe
twe
ent
he
twod
i
f
f
e
r
en
tmode
l
i
ng me
t
hodswe
r
eob
t
a
i
ned.Ther
e
su
l
t
sshowt
ha
tbo
t
ho
ft
hetwo me
t
hodshave
e
f
e
r
ab
l
epr
e
c
i
s
i
on,wh
i
chensu
r
ea
c
cu
r
a
t
eana
l
i
so
ft
hes
t
r
e
s
sd
i
s
t
r
i
bu
t
i
onone
a
chnodeo
fbo
l
t
pr
ys
t
hr
e
ads,wh
i
l
et
hemode
l
i
ngo
ft
hesp
i
r
a
lmode
l
i
ng me
t
hodi
smo
r
ed
i
f
f
i
cu
l
t.I
nc
ompa
r
i
s
on,t
her
e

su
l
t
so
ft
het
hr
e
e-d
imens
i
ona
lax
i
s
t
r
i
cmode
l
i
ng me
t
hodc
anr
e
f
l
e
c
tt
heme
chan
i
c
a
lp
r
ope
r
t
i
e
s
ymme
,
o
ft
heax
i
a
lbo
l
tp
r
e
f
e
r
ab
l
r
ov
i
det
het
heo
r
e
t
i
c
a
lba
s
i
sf
o
rop
t
ima
lde
s
i
fs
t
ruc
t
ur
e
s.
y andp
gno
Ke
r
d
s:
bo
l
t;f
i
n
i
t
ee
l
emen
tme
t
hod;t
hr
e
e-d
imens
i
ona
lax
i
symme
t
r
i
cmode
l;t
hr
e
e-d
imen
ywo

s
i
ona
lsp
i
r
a
lmode
l;s
t
r
e
s
s

;,

,;

; , ,

[
8

10]
,

, ,

20 ,

ABAQUS

[
1

3]

,
[
6

7]

[
5]

[
4]

[
8

10]

:
20110701

:(
50775061);
(
KJ
2011B050)

1991

 23 16 2012 8

1
,

Tf =

/(
t
an(
+)= (
t
an
+t
an
1-t
an
t
an

,
, 2a;

, 2b;

(
1)

t
an
= s/cos
=1.
15s

:289190
300797,
C3D8
IC3D6,

1
Fpre(
dpt
an(
+)+dww )

t
an
d2 )
= P/(

dw =

(
1)
Tf =

3
3
2 B - Di
2
2
3 B - Di

3
3
dp(
1.
15sd2 +P) 2 B - Di ]
1
Fpre[
+ w 2
2
2
d2 -1.
15sP
3 B - Di

(
2)

, 2c

,
Tf ;
Fpre ;
P ;
dp

, I
SO

;
;
s ;
w
;
dw ;
B

,
M101
25, I
SO

,dp =d2 ;
;

;
Di

,
[13]
Fpre Kt + Kc
=360 P ( K K )
t c

(
3)

,
Kt ;
Kc
;

2.
2

,
;,

,
,
,
(
a)

(
b)

(
c)

,,
,
,
,

2.
1

,
;,

1992

, 1 ,

, A B
(,
,,
,, 3

, c =0
0382mm);
,,
(
Fpre=8
0kN)

3.
1
3.
1.
1

30CrNiMo8(
1),

130CrNiMo
8(
1)

(
kg/m3)
E20

7830

0.
3

(
GPa)

(
10-6/K)
G20
(MPa)

206

11.
5
79230

(HBW)
Rm
(MPa)
R
(MPa)
D
(mm)

(MPa)

266
1250
1050
16
750

( 3)
( 4) ,

,
[3]

6 , ,
,

,
,

, (
k1) (
k2) ,

,
5

[1113]

,
,

3.
1.
2
7
,

, ; A
C
0
5%
,
,
,

( 4),

A
C B , 8 8 ,
,
,

,,
1993

 23 16 2012 8

,
,

,(
), ,
7

;
f
g ,
;
g , ;
gh
,
,,
,

3.
1.
3

10

11 ,

M
S E
(
t
1)

,;

,
( ),,
;

(
M ); ,
S(
t
2~t
6),
;

,;

(
t
7) ,
,(
t
6)

,,

,[
2]

,[
3]

,
( ),
( );

, S E

( ),[
5]
10
a
c ,
,
b
;
c
e ,
;
d
e
, c
e ;
e
f
,
e
1994

11

3.
2
,

,
;

, 1
3% ,
6 16 ,
,,
0
5% ,

0
56% ,

,,
,

,
,
12( 13),
,
,

14

15
12

16

,
,,
,

13

[
9

10] , 4
,
,

14~ 16 9 14
,,

3.
3

2
4% 11 15 ,

17,

1995

 23 16 2012 8

,,

18 A ,
B

,
,
,

:
[
1]Venka
t
e
s
anS,Ki
n
z
e
lGL.
Reduc
t
i
ono
fS
t
r
e
s
sCon

c
en
t
r
a
t
i
oni
nBo
l
t- Nu
tConne
c
t
o
r
s[
J].
J
ou
r
na
lo
f
Me
chan
i
c
a
lDe
s
i
11):
1337

1342.
gn,2006,128(

[
2] . [M]. :
,
1995.

[
3] .[M]., .
:,
1984.

[
4]Bu
t
t
e
rwo
r
t
hJ.
F
i
n
i
t
eEl
emen
tAna
l
s
i
so
fS
t
r
uc
t
u
r
a
l
y

S
t
e
e
lwo
r
kBe
amt
oCo
l
umnBo
l
t
edConne
c
t
i
ons[
J].
CS502,1997,
1:
1

14.

[
5] ,, .
17

[
J]. ,1990,21

(
4):
100

105.

[
6] ,, .

[
J]. ,2006,17(
8):

845

848.

[
7]Snyde
rM D.Te
chn
i
sf
o
rEva
l
ua
t
i
ono
fPr
e
l
oad
que

edBo
l
t
edJ
o
i
n
t
si
naPWRf
o
rFau
l
t
edEven
t
s[
J].
Tr
ans
a
c
t
i
ons,2001,8:
1

6.

[
8]Re
i
dJD,Hi
s
e
rN R.De
t
a
i
l
ed Mode
l
i
ngo
fBo
l
t
ed
18

(
1)
,
(
2),

(
3),
, ,
,

(
4),

J
o
i
n
t
edwi
t
hS
l
i
J].
F
i
n
i
t
eEl
emen
ti
nAna
l
s
i
s
ppage[
y
andDe
s
i
9):
547

562.
gn,2005,17(

[
9]Zhao Hua.Ana
l
s
i
so
ft
heLoad Di
s
t
r
i
bu
t
i
oni
na
y

Bo
l
t- nu
t Conne
c
t
o
r[
J].Compu
t
e
r
s & Amp;

S
t
r
uc
t
u
r
e
s,1994,53(
6):
1465

1472.

[
10] , .

[
J].,2006,28

(
4):
524

531.

[
11]Bo
r
e
s
lA P,
Schmi
d
tRJ.Advanc
ed Me
chan
i
c
so
f

Ma
t
e
r
i
a
l
s[M ].New Yo
r
k:
J
ohn Wi
l
ey & Sons,

I
nc.,2002.

[
12]Br
ownT H.Ma
r
ksCa
l
cu
l
a
t
i
onsf
o
r Ma
ch
i
neDe

s
i
r
k:McGr
aw-Hi
l
l,2005.
gn[M].New Yo

[
13] ,, , .

[
J].(),2009,45(
4):
224

227.

( )

,
,
,

: ,,
1980

,,

10 ,,
1945

(
5)
,,
,
, ,
1996

,,
1980
( ) ,,

1980
,,
1980
,,
1976