Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Consultancy Report
On
Rehabilitation of Bank
On The
Sabour
And
Consultancy On Rehabilitation of Bank On Approach of Bridge No. 144 - Malda Division : Eastern Railway
INDEX
Contents
Page 2 2 3 3 3 3 4 5 5 6 6 8 8
Observations by RDSO team Track Structure Details Of Soil Samples Site Inspection And Collection Of Field Data Analysis & Discussion Of Test Results Slope Stability Analysis Recommendations Annexures -
I II
10-12 13-16
1. 2. 3-4 5-6
17 18 19-20 21-22
Page 1 Of 22
Consultancy On Rehabilitation of Bank On Approach of Bridge No. 144 - Malda Division : Eastern Railway
PREFACE
This report is based on soil exploration, field investigation, soil testing and literature survey. The views expressed are subject to modifications from time to time in the light of future developments on the subject. The views do not represent the views of Ministry of Railways (Railway Board), Government of India. This report is the property of RDSO and is meant essentially for official use. It may not be loaned, reproduced in part or in full or quoted as an authority without the permission of Director General, RDSO.
(S.K.SHARMA)
Joint Director/G.E.
(ALOK KUMAR)
Executive Director/Geo-technical Engineering
SYNOPSIS
The single line section between Sahibganj and Bhagalpur stations on Malda Division of Eastern Railway is posing problem of settlement at Sahibganj end approach bank at km 291/11-12 of Bridge No. 144 near Lailakh Mamalkha station. It is a Group B route having maximum permissible sectional speed of 100 kmph. On the request of Eastern Railway, detailed field investigations of bridge approach between Sabour & Lailakh Mamalkha stations were carried out and disturbed as well as undisturbed soil samples were tested at GE Directorate of RDSO. This Report includes remedial measures to be adopted for rehabilitation of bank on the approach of bridge no. 144. Recommendations include flattening of slopes, construction of retaining wall, provision of blanket material on top of formation and extra earthwork for unstable slopes
Page 2 Of 22
Consultancy On Rehabilitation of Bank On Approach of Bridge No. 144 - Malda Division : Eastern Railway
1.0
INTRODUCTION
Settlement of approach (Sahibganj end) of bridge no. 144 (Span 5x18.3 m Plate Girder) at km 291/11-12 between Sabour & Lailakh Mamalkha stations in Bhagalpur-Sahibganj section falls in the jurisdiction of Malda Division of Eastern Railway. This is single line section, which was constructed long back. The entire formation is constructed on highly clayey soil having poor bearing capacity, as a result of which longitudinal and transverse cracks got developed in slope, cess and near toe of bank. Chief Bridge Engineer, Eastern Railway vide letter no. W(7)436/15/Pt.VI/A, dated 22.12.2006 referred the problem to RDSO for investigation & suggesting remedial measures. Accordingly, RDSO team visited site on 24th & 25th December 2006 for investigation and suggesting remedial measures. SL 1 Referred Location Approach of Bridge No. 144 at Km 291/11-12 Locations Selected Approach of Bridge No. 144 at Km 291/11-12 Between Stations Sabour & Lailakh Mamalkha
Accordingly, the site observations were made & soil samples were collected from this location.
2.0
REFERENCE
Chief Bridge Engineer/Eastern Railway/Kolkata, vide his letter no. W(7)436/ 15/Pt.VI/A, dated 22.12.2006 requested RDSO for investigating and advising remedial measures.
3.0
SCOPE OF WORK
Site inspection, soil exploration, testing and recommendations for stabilization of settlement of bank on approaches of bridge no.144 (Span 5x18.3 m Plate Girder) at km 291/11-12.
4.0
4.1
HISTORY OF PROBLEM
Bhagalpur - Sahibganj is a single line B.G. section in Malda Division of Eastern Railway, constructed over highly compressible soil (CH). Bank height is 6.55 m to 7.70 m at bridge approach. As per special report of CBE/ER, initial settlement occurred on 21.11.06. At the Sahibganj end approach of the bridge no.144 (Span 5x18.3 m Plate Girder), there was a misalignment of 50 mm. It was noticed that there were wide cracks at the cess, slope and beyond the toe of bank upto a distance of 50 m away from the track near abutment A1 as shown in Fig. 2. Later on, these cracks developed right under the track also. These cracks were 50 mm to 100 mm wide & 140 mm deep and there was a differential settlement on either side of the track on slope as well as in the ground in the vicinity of the track.
4.2
Page 3 Of 22
Consultancy On Rehabilitation of Bank On Approach of Bridge No. 144 - Malda Division : Eastern Railway
4.3
Same night, the static patrollers observed cracking of pier no. P4, which is near abutment A2 at Bhagalpur end. The crack was at a depth of about 3 metres from pier top. The width of the cracks was about 25 mm and there was lateral shift of 20 mm between the bottom and top of the pier at Sahibganj end side.
5.0
5.1
5.2
5.3
The base soil of the bridge approach was sunk and in track formation, there were cracks in slope, cess and on the toe of bank and also the track geometry was disturbed due to sinking. Due to these reasons, base soil at the toe has suddenly settled and formation of track developed cracks. It was observed, there was no wing wall constructed at bridge abutments. As remedial measures, railway is providing 11 m rail piling at the toe of bank, stone dust and ballast were unloaded to this spot to maintain the track geometry. Presently, cracks on the pier were filled with cement mortar.
5.4
Page 4 Of 22
Consultancy On Rehabilitation of Bank On Approach of Bridge No. 144 - Malda Division : Eastern Railway
5.5
As a preliminary measure, RDSO team gave following suggestions to the railway officials at the site : i) ii) To prevent scouring of river, river training measures should be adopted. Stone boulders crates alongwith two layers (zig-zag) of rail piling at 1.0 m centre to centre at toe of bank should be provided in the affected length of the bank. Cracks should be filled up with gravel or sand.
iii) Retaining wall should be provided upto suitable length of affected bridge approach in downstream side. iv) Flattening of slope should be carried out and side slope of 2.5:1 should be maintained in the first stage. Turfing shall be provided on slope of bank and sub-bank. v) Proper boulder pitching on slope should be provided upto the HFL. vi) Earthwork shall be done as per RDSOs Guidelines for Earthwork in Railway Project, GE: G-1, July2003. Three undisturbed and three disturbed soil samples & one stone dust sample were collected and received in RDSO on 02.01.2007.
6.0
TRACK STRUCTURE
Rail Sleeper Sleeper Density Deep screening GMT/annum Ballast cushion Speed restriction imposed : : : : : : : 52 Kg SWR laid in 1991-1992 PSC laid in 1991 - 1992 M+ 7 Done in year 1991-1992 8.5 107 mm 10 kmph
7.0
Page 5 Of 22
Consultancy On Rehabilitation of Bank On Approach of Bridge No. 144 - Malda Division : Eastern Railway
These soil samples were tested in Geo-technical Engineering Laboratory at RDSO for the following tests : (a) (b) (c) (d) (e) (f) Natural Moisture Content (NMC) Natural Dry Density Grain Size Analysis OMC & MDD Residual shear test Triaxial shear test in Consolidated measurement of pore pressure. Undrained condition (CU) with (NDD)
8.0
8.1
(iii) It was observed that there was no wing wall constructed at bridge abutments. (iv) River training measures have not been adopted. (v) At this bridge approach, sudden variation of cross-level and alignment with uneven settlement has been occurring since 21st November 2006, as reported by railway officials.
(vi) 11.0 m rails piling in zig-zag form at the toe is in progress. (vii) Stone dust and ballast have been unloaded at site and track is being attended continuously. (viii) Index plan, Site plan and Cross section profile are shown in Figures 14.
9.0
9.1
Page 6 Of 22
Consultancy On Rehabilitation of Bank On Approach of Bridge No. 144 - Malda Division : Eastern Railway
SL 1 2
Soil Parameters Classification : Grain Size distribution : Gravel (%) Sand (%) Silt (%) Clay (%) Fines passing sieve (%) 75
51 24 27
53 28 25
4.
1.79 21.79 1.525 0.210 25.16 24.69 1.614 7.7 1.1 0.117 20.01 0.02 24.0 17.75 1.560 12.1 0.67 0.095 26.46 -
5. 6.
7.
9.2 9.3
Soil at Km 292/11-12 under consideration is CH type, i.e. inorganic clay with high plasticity as per IS classification. Soil contains about 80% to 94% fines and Liquid Limit varies from 53% to 58%. There will be significant loss of shear strength of embankment soil on its saturation. This also explains the behavior of soil, which exhibits subsidence alongwith appearance of large cracks. Moisture content in the soil is found upto 24.69%, which is near the plastic limit. Therefore, the soil is in plastic state. Hence, it is having very low bearing capacity. Natural dry density of soil varies from 1.525 to 1.614gm/cc. These values are very low and therefore, adversely affect the strength of the formation. Shear strength parameters of embankment soil and sub soils are low; therefore, bank slope is not strong enough to withstand even present conditions; as such toe failure of bank has occurred. So, flatter slope should be required.
9.4
9.5 9.6
Page 7 Of 22
Consultancy On Rehabilitation of Bank On Approach of Bridge No. 144 - Malda Division : Eastern Railway
With these parameters, slope stability analysis has been carried out as detailed at AnnexuresII & II/2. Thus, re-profiling of formation has to be carried out at 2.5H : 1V slope for the cross-section of A-A and 2.75H : 1V slope for the crosssection of B-B (Annexure-II/1& II/3).
11.0 RECOMMENDATIONS
Following recommendations are made : i) To prevent scouring of problematic abutment, suitable river training measures (one or combination of two as per site condition) as given in Para 808 of Indian Railway Bridge Manual-1998 should be adopted, especially near abutment slopes. Flattening of slope should be carried out. As per recommended profile, side slope of 2.5 H :1 V to be maintained at the cross section A-A and of 2.75 H : 1 V slope for the cross section B-B. Turfing shall be provided on slope of bank.
ii)
iii) Flattening of slope at cross section B-B upto 2.75 H : 1 V will result in situation where the toe of flattened slope would fall into the river portion. To avoid this situation, retaining wall would be required. The retaining wall to contain the flattened slope be provided close to abutment A1 as shown in Fig. 2. iv) Retaining wall/boulder filled gabions should be provided upto suitable length of affected bridge approach at downstream side as well as on upstream side. Design of retaining wall should be ensured as per site condition. v) Under above circumstances, for CH type of soil, minimum 100 cm thick compacted blanket layer is required at top of formation as per Para-4.3.2 and 4.3.4 of Guidelines For Earthwork In Railway Projects GE : G-1, July - 2003, which shall be ensured at site.
Page 8 Of 22
Consultancy On Rehabilitation of Bank On Approach of Bridge No. 144 - Malda Division : Eastern Railway
The report has been prepared by Shri S.K. Sharma, Joint Director/Geo-technical Engineering under guidance of Shri Alok Kumar, Executive Director/ Geotechnical Engineering/RDSO. This report has been prepared on the basis of field inspection, soil exploration and testing done by the following staff of Geo-technical Engineering Directorate : 1. Shri S.K. Awasthi, ARE 2. Shri Samay Singh, SRE 3. Shri R. Horo, JRE-I 4. Shri Shiv Bahadur, SRE 5. Shri D.K. Srivastava, SRE Following officials were associated in preparation of the Consultancy Report : 1. 2. Shri B.S. Rajpal, Dy. Director Shri Y. R. Tirpude SSE (Design)
Page 9 Of 22
Consultancy On Rehabilitation of Bank On Approach of Bridge No. 144 - Malda Division : Eastern Railway
ANNEXURE I
LL
PL
PI
SL
DF S OMC%
Gravel %
NMC%
Sand %
3 CH CH CH SP-SM
4 -
5 -
6 00 00 01 06
7 06 12 19 86
8 69 70 67 08
Clay % 9 25 18 13 00
Silt %
10 94 88 80 08
13 58 51 53 NP
14 26 24 28 NP
15 32 27 25 NP
16 -
17 -
18 14
19 1.79
21
10
2.185
Page 10 Of 22
Consultancy On Rehabilitation of Bank On Approach of Bridge No. 144 - Malda Division : Eastern Railway
Passing 75 micron %
LL
PL
PI
SL
DFS OMC%
Sand %
3 -
6 -
7 -
8 -
Clay %
Silt %
9 -
10 -
11 -
12 -
13 -
14 -
15 -
16 -
17 -
18 -
19 -
Page 11 Of 22
Consultancy On Rehabilitation of Bank On Approach of Bridge No. 144 - Malda Division : Eastern Railway
Annexure I/2
Passing 75 micron %
Mechanical Analysis
Cu
Cc
Consistency limit
Residual Shear test Peak value Residual Value (Cr) Kg/Cm (r) Degree
LL
PL
PI
SL
DFS
Gravel %
Sand %
1 0002
3 -
4 -
5 -
6 -
7 -
8 -
Clay %
Silt %
(C) Kg/C m
() Degree
9 -
10 -
11 -
12 -
13 -
14 -
15 -
16 -
17 -
18 0.14
19 27
20 0.02
21 24
Page 12 Of 22
Consultancy On Rehabilitation of Bank On Approach of Bridge No. 144 - Malda Division : Eastern Railway
Annexure II
SAHIBGANJ - BHAGALPUR, MALDA DIV. E.Rly. PROFILE AT CH/KM: 291/11-12 HEIGHT OF BANK: 06.55 m FACTOR OF SAFETY: 1.291
EXISTING
Soil 1 EMBANKMENT SOIL Soil Model Mohr-Coulomb Unit Weight 15.9 Cohesion 21 Phi 25.16 Unsaturated Phi B 0 Piezometric Line # 0 Ru (added) 0.25 Pore-Air Pressure 0 Soil 2 SUB SOIL Soil Model Mohr-Coulomb Unit Weight 16.23 Cohesion 2 Phi 24 Unsaturated Phi B 0 Piezometric Line # 0 Ru (added) 0.5 Pore-Air Pressure 0 Soil 3 Bedrock Soil Model Bedrock Unit Weight -1 Piezometric Line # 0 Ru (added) 0 Pore-Air Pressure 0
45
40
35
30 1.291
25
Elevation (m)
6.55m
EMBANKMENT SOIL
SLOPE 2:1
20
3.25m
SUB SOIL
15
10
5 -2
13
18
23
28
33
38
43
48
53
58
Page 13 Of 22
Consultancy On Rehabilitation of Bank On Approach of Bridge No. 144 - Malda Division : Eastern Railway
AnnexureII/1
SAHIBGANJ - BHAGALPUR, MALDA DIV. E.Rly. PROFILE AT CH/KM: 291/11-12 HEIGHT OF BANK: 06.55 m FACTOR OF SAFETY: 1.425
DESIGNED Soil
45
1 EMBANKMENT SOIL Soil Model Mohr-Coulomb Unit Weight 15.9 Cohesion 21 Phi 25.16 Unsaturated Phi B 0 Piezometric Line # 0 Ru (added) 0.25 Pore-Air Pressure 0 Soil 2 SUB SOIL Soil Model Mohr-Coulomb Unit Weight 16.23 Cohesion 2 Phi 24 Unsaturated Phi B 0 Piezometric Line # 0 Ru (added) 0.5 Pore-Air Pressure 0 Soil 3 Bedrock Soil Model Bedrock Unit Weight -1 Piezometric Line # 0 Ru (added) 0 Pore-Air Pressure 0
40
35
1.425
30
25
Elevation (m)
6.55m
EMBANKMENT SOIL
SLOPE 2.5:1
20
3.25m
SUB SOIL
15
10
5 -2
13
18
23
28
33
38
43
48
53
58
Page 14 Of 22
Consultancy On Rehabilitation of Bank On Approach of Bridge No. 144 - Malda Division : Eastern Railway
Annexure II/2
SAHIBGANJ - BHAGALPUR, MALDA DIV. E.Rly. PROFILE AT CH/KM: 291/11-12 HEIGHT OF BANK: 07.7m FACTOR OF SAFETY: 1.197
EXISTING
45
Soil 1 EMBANKMENT SOIL Soil Model Mohr-Coulomb Unit Weight 15.9 Cohesion 21 Phi 25.16 Unsaturated Phi B 0 Piezometric Line # 0 Ru (added) 0.25 Pore-Air Pressure 0 Soil 2 SUB SOIL Soil Model Mohr-Coulomb Unit Weight 16.23 Cohesion 2 Phi 24 Unsaturated Phi B 0 Piezometric Line # 0 Ru (added) 0.5 Pore-Air Pressure 0
40
35
30
1.197
25
Elevation (m)
7.7m
EMBANKMENT SOIL
20
4.25m
SUB SOIL
15
10
Soil 3 Bedrock Soil Model Bedrock Unit Weight -1 Piezometric Line # 0 Ru (added) 0 Pore-Air Pressure 0
18 23 28 33 38 43 48 53 58
5 -2
13
Page 15 Of 22
Consultancy On Rehabilitation of Bank On Approach of Bridge No. 144 - Malda Division : Eastern Railway
Annexure II/3
SAHIBGANJ - BHAGALPUR, MALDA DIV. E.Rly. PROFILE AT CH/KM: 291/11-12 HEIGHT OF BANK: 07.7m FACTOR OF SAFETY: 1.410
DESIGNED
45
Soil 1 EMBANKMENT SOIL Soil Model Mohr-Coulomb Unit Weight 15.9 Cohesion 21 Phi 25.16 Unsaturated Phi B 0 Piezometric Line # 0 Ru (added) 0.25 Pore-Air Pressure 0 Soil 2 SUB SOIL Soil Model Mohr-Coulomb Unit Weight 16.23 Cohesion 2 Phi 24 Unsaturated Phi B 0 Piezometric Line # 0 Ru (added) 0.5 Pore-Air Pressure 0 Soil 3 Bedrock Soil Model Bedrock Unit Weight -1 Piezometric Line # 0 Ru (added) 0 Pore-Air Pressure 0
40
1.410 35
30
25
Elevation (m)
7.7m
EMBANKMENT SOIL
SLOPE 2.75:1
20
4.25m
SUB SOIL
15
10
5 -2
13
18
23
28
33
38
43
48
53
58
Page 16 Of 22
Consultancy On Rehabilitation of Bank On Approach of Bridge No. 144 - Malda Division : Eastern Railway
Figure 1
K iu l km 403.47
M on ghyr
M andar V idyapith
T inpahar
B allalpur Pordanga
Bonidanga
M alda T ow n km . 0.00
Page 17 Of 22
Consultancy On Rehabilitation of Bank On Approach of Bridge No. 144 - Malda Division : Eastern Railway
F igure 2
A
C racks
Sah ibganj A1
N O TE S: 1. A1 & A 2 Are B ridge Abutm ent 2. P1,P2,P3 & P4 Are Piers O f B ridge N O T TO SCALE
U /S R iver
B hagalpur R A IL P1 P2 P3 P4 A2
C racks
D /S R iver
B '
A'
Site Plan
L ocation : K m 2 9 1/1 1 -1 2 (Facing B hagalpur)
R esearch D esign s & Stan dards O rgan isation
SETTLEM ENT OF BANK ON THE A PPR O A C H E S O F B R ID G E N O .1 44 A T K M 2 91 /1 1 - 12 B E TW EEN L AILAK H M A M ALK H A & SA B O U R S TA T IO N S O N M A LD A TO W N D IV IS IO N , E A S T E R N R A ILW A Y
D R G . N O . G E /S K /E R /512/R ev.0/2007
Page 18 Of 22
Consultancy On Rehabilitation of Bank On Approach of Bridge No. 144 - Malda Division : Eastern Railway
Figure 3
C L of Track Crack
DS-3
:1V 2H
UDS-3
1.9 5H
DS-1
:1V
6.55m
UDS-1 5.0m DS-2 UDS-2 Cross Section AA' Location: Km 291/11-12 (Facing Bhagalpur) Sadonia River Cracks 4.50m Water Level
SETTLEMENT OF BANK ON THE APPROACHES OF BRIDGE NO.144 AT KM 291/11 - 12 BETWEEN LAILAKH MAMALKHA & SABOUR STATIONS ON MALDA TOWN DIVISION, EASTERN RAILWAY
DRG. NO. GE/SK/ER/503/Rev.0/2007
Page 19 Of 22
Consultancy On Rehabilitation of Bank On Approach of Bridge No. 144 - Malda Division : Eastern Railway
Figure 4
C L of Track
3 H:
1V
1.7
5H
2H
:1V
:1V
7.70m
Rail Piling Boulder Pitching Cross Section BB' Location: Km 291/11-12 (Facing Bhagalpur) Sadonia River 2.0m Water Level Cracks 4.50m
SETTLEMENT OF BANK ON THE APPROACHES OF BRIDGE NO.144 AT KM 291/ 11 - 12 BETWEEN LAILAKH MAMALKHA & SABOUR STATIONS ON MALDA TOWN DIVISION, EASTERN RAILWAY
DRG. NO. GE/SK/ER/513/Rev.0/2007
Page 20 Of 22
Consultancy On Rehabilitation of Bank On Approach of Bridge No. 144 - Malda Division : Eastern Railway
Figure 5
6.55m
4.50m Recommended Profile at Section AA' Location: Km 291/11-12 (Facing Bhagalpur) Sadonia River
SETTLEMENT OF BANK ON THE APPROACHES OF BRIDGE NO.144 AT KM 291/11 - 12 BETWEEN LAILAKH MAMALKHA & SABOUR STATIONS ON MALDA TOWN DIVISION, EASTERN RAILWAY
DRG. NO. GE/SK/ER/514/Rev.0/2007
Page 21 Of 22
Consultancy On Rehabilitation of Bank On Approach of Bridge No. 144 - Malda Division : Eastern Railway
Figure 6
3H
:1V
5H
75
:1 V
1V
2H
:1 V
H:
Rail Piling 2.0m Water Level Cross Section BB' Location: Km 291/11-12 (Facing Bhagalpur) Retaining wall Sadonia River 4.50m
SETTLEMENT OF BANK ON THE APPROACHES OF BRIDGE NO.144 AT KM 291/ 11 - 12 BETWEEN LAILAKH MAMALKHA & SABOUR STATIONS ON MALDA TOWN DIVISION, EASTERN RAILWAY
DRG. NO. GE/SK/ER/515/Rev.0/2007
Page 22 Of 22