You are on page 1of 52

2012

internr@googlegroups.com
http://www.facebook.com/MEDLabor


90
32

2011 8

2007


1.

(n=214)

(n=214)

157

73.36%

35

16.36%

57

26.64%

32

14.95%

27

12.62%

13

6.07%

19

8.88%

91

42.52%

14

6.54%

34

15.89%

87

40.65%

28

13.08%

25

11.68%

91

42.52%

4.21%

64

29.91%

1.87%

4.21%

10

4.67%

20

9.35%

30

14.02%

214 157 57 13
91 34 28 25 23 91
42.52% 64 29.91% 9 4.21% 20 9.35% 30 14.02%


1.

(n=214)

(n=104)

(n=110)

2011

9.86

5.85

7.46

5.36

12.14

5.38

114

10

87

40.65%

21

20.19%

66

60.00%

15

29

13.55%

6.73%

22

20.00%

94.36

22.28

88.06

22.88

100.32

20.03

80

152

71.03%

62

59.62%

90

81.82%

88

140

65.42%

55

52.88%

85

77.27%

5.99

0.62

5.91

0.59

6.05

0.63

39

18.22%

14

13.46%

25

22.73%

35.84

10.55

35.10

11.66

36.55

9.38

28

197

92.06%

93

89.42%

104

94.55%

30

196

91.59%

93

89.42%

103

93.64%

32

183

85.51%

84

80.77%

99

90.00%

36

59

27.57%

21

20.19%

38

34.55%

10.18

4.72

9.89

5.03

10.45

4.40

10

78

36.45%

32

30.77%

46

41.82%

14

177

82.71%

84

80.77%

93

84.55%

22.97

11.62

23.95

12.70

22.05

10.46

108

50.47%

45

43.27%

63

57.27%

8.52

4.44

6.01

4.80

8.59

4.08

115

53.74%

57

54.81%

58

52.73%

24

24

10

33

ACGME
15/10

81

80

88

42

28

36/32/30

14

10

24

24

10

10


09

10

15

1115

09

10

1115

15

13%

68%

40%

32%

26%

74%

14%

7%
12%

20%

9.86 53% 9 20% 10 15

94.36

2011ACGME

80

8088

88

100.32
88.06

80

88
65%
29%

71%

42
6%

94.36 71% 2011 ACGME 80 65% 88

2011ACGME

5.99

6.05

5.91

06

06

6
18%

82%

5.99 18% 2011 ACGME 6

35.84

35.1

2011ACGME
36.55

28

2830

3032

3236

36

36
28
58%
8%

92%

6%
0%
28%

35.84 92% 2011 ACGME 28 92%86%28% 30


3236

24

2011ACGME

24

14

1410

10

14

10.18

9.89

10.45

10

46%
17%

83%
37%

24

24 10.18 83% 2011 ACGME 14

2011ACGME
24

23.95

24

24

24

22.97
50%
22.05

22.97 50% 2011 ACGME 24

50%

2011ACGME

10

10

10

10

8.59

8.52
6.01

46%
54%

8.52 54% 2011 ACGME 10


50% 2011 ACGME 24
70% 20 %
10 15 24
2011
ACGME 36 2011 ACGME 28
28% 36

2.
(1)

(n=214)

(n=104)

(n=110)

5.97

0.93

6.01

0.95

5.94

0.91

3.96

1.43

4.14

1.42

3.79

1.42

4.32

3.50

3.57

3.01

5.04

3.79

209

97.66%

100

96.15%

109

99.09%

209

97.66%

100

96.15%

109

99.09%

5.97 3.96 4.32 98%

(2)

(n=214)

(n=104)

()

83

38.79%

()

93

43.46%

168

()
( 10%)

(n=110)

29

27.88%

54

49.09%

38

36.54%

55

50.00%

78.50%

87

83.65%

81

73.64%

16

7.48%

5.77%

10

9.09%

1.88

1.18

2.00

1.17

1.76

1.19

0.861

39% 43% 1.88


79% 7% 10%

(3)

(n=214)

(n=104)

(n=110)

()

137

64.02%

61

58.65%

76

69.09%

()

60

28.04%

27

25.96%

33

30.00%

()

12

5.61%

5.77%

5.45%

()

17

7.94%

4.81%

12

10.91%

()

11

5.14%

2.88%

7.27%

64% 28% 6%8% 5%

3.

(n=214)

(n=104)

()

45

()

54

(n=110)

(n=17042)

21.03%

19

18.27%

26

23.64%

2245

13.2%

25.23%

25

24.04%

29

26.36%

976

5.7%

0.939

61.71

21.64

0.913

56.35

19.87

66.77

22.11

32.8

20.2

60.56

20.67

0.887

56.30

20.47

64.59

20.13

28.2

19.3

63.20

21.31

0.849

58.35

20.36

67.78

21.27

35.6

20.6

49.71

18.66

0.887

45.63

17.42

53.56

19.05

30.1

19.3

78.28%

15.56%

0.828

74.42%

16.19%

81.93%

14.06%

52.6%

12.1%

25.23%

23.64%

81.93
78.28
74.42

26.36%
24.04%

66.77
61.71
56.35

21.03%
18.27%

64.59
60.56
56.3

13.20%
32.8

67.78
63.2
58.35

35.6
28.2

53.56
49.71
45.63

52.6

30.1

5.70%

21% 25%
61.7160.5663.2049.71 78.28
2007

4.

(n=214)

(n=104)

(n=110)

0.936

41.23

20.93

0.907

38.83

21.44

43.49

20.27

46.10

26.90

0.960

44.47

26.11

47.64

27.67

45.09

27.92

46.88

27.80

43.41

28.06

40.54

26.78

42.07

26.13

39.09

27.41

()

15

7.01%

6.73%

7.27%

()

1.40%

0.96%

1.82%

7.01%

7.27%
6.73%
41.23

1.40%

46.1 45.09

44.47
40.54

47.64

46.88

38.83

42.07

43.49

43.41
39.09

1.82%
0.96%

7% 1%
41.2346.1045.0940.54

5.

(n=214)

(n=104)

(n=110)

()

102

47.66%

49

47.12%

53

48.18%

()

50

23.36%

16

15.38%

34

30.91%

()

105

49.07%

49

47.12%

56

50.91%

4.95

3.83

5.26

3.84

4.66

3.81

1.06

0.88

1.25

0.88

0.88

0.85

0.898

57.57

18.34

0.837

54.17

18.90

60.79

17.27

71.55

17.06

0.840

70.57

17.97

72.48

16.18

64.09

18.46

0.867

61.68

18.89

66.36

17.83

48%

49%
52%

51%

48% 49%

4.95

5.26
4.66

23%

1.06

77%

1.25

0.88

23% 4.95 1.06


57.5771.55 64.09
50%
23%


1.

(1)
T

T (>0.05)

(<0.4)

(>0.930)

C3-1

0.000

0.703

0.926

C3-2

0.000

0.748

0.924

C3-3

0.000

0.770

0.924

C3-4

0.000

0.816

0.922

C3-5

0.000

0.713

0.925

C4-1

0.000

0.811

0.923

C4-2

0.000

0.683

0.925

C4-3

0.000

0.708

0.925

C4-4

0.000

0.645

0.926

C4-5

0.000

0.661

0.926

C5-1

0.000

0.485

0.929

C5-2

0.000

0.521

0.928

C5-3

0.000

0.525

0.928

C5-4

0.000

0.576

0.927

C5-5

0.294

-0.145

0.939

C6-1

0.000

0.664

0.926

C6-2

0.000

0.521

0.929

C6-3

0.000

0.638

0.926

C6-4

0.000

0.496

0.929

C6-5

0.000

0.570

0.927

C6-6

0.000

0.530

0.928

T 0.05 0.4(0.930)

C5-5 T
C5-5
(2)
A. (construct validity)(exploratory factor analysis)
KMO (sampling adequacy)
Bartlett
C3-C6
Kaiser-Meyer-Olkin (>0.8)

0.923

Bartlett (<0.05)

0.000

KMO Barlett (principal component


method)(parallel analysis)

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

9.544

2.144

1.731

0.867

0.703

0.699

0.576

0.479

0.477

0.433

0.375

0.354

0.296

0.265

0.249

0.201

0.176

0.162

1.582

1.460

1.365

1.284

1.209

1.138

1.073

1.007

0.947

0.888

0.844

0.787

0.730

0.681

0.631

0.583

0.534

0.485

(Eigenvalue)

(promax rotation method)

F1

F2

0.827

0.870

0.826

0.814

0.770

0.803

0.679

0.905

0.776

0.787

F3

0.813

0.953

0.877

0.522

0.846

0.835

0.881

0.637

0.788

0.670

(%)

47.72%

10.72%

8.66%

0.40

10
6 4 47.72%10.72% 8.66%
61.95%

20

B. (concurrent criterion validity)

(BSRS-5)

C4

C5 *

C6

C7 *

C1

C2

C3

0.861

0.526

0.574

0.644

0.531

0.479

0.000

0.000

0.000

0.000

0.000

0.000

C4

0.482

0.573

0.653

0.569

0.503

0.000

0.000

0.000

0.000

0.000

C5

0.351

0.412

0.372

0.212

0.000

0.000

0.000

0.002

C6

0.456

0.362

0.332

0.000

0.000

0.000

(=0.861)

(=0.351)


(=0.644/0.653/0.412/0.456=0.531/0.569/0.372/0.362)
(=0.479/0.503/0.212/0.332)

A1

A2

B2

B3

B7

B8

C3

0.348

0.320

-0.318

0.353

0.690

0.650

0.000

0.000

0.000

0.000

0.000

0.000

C4

0.281

0.363

-0.322

0.365

0.601

0.625

0.000

0.000

0.000

0.000

0.000

0.000

C5

0.226

0.299

-0.144

0.266

0.399

0.383

0.001

0.000

0.036

0.000

0.000

0.000

C6

0.172

0.138

-0.171

0.322

0.356

0.502

0.012

0.044

0.012

0.000

0.000

0.000

(=0.348/0.281/0.226/0.172=0.320/0.363/0.299/0.138)

(
=-0.318/-0.322/-0.144/-0.171=0.353/0.365/0.266/0.322)
(=-0.144/0.266)

(=0.690/0.601/0.399/0.356=0.650/0.625/0.383/0.502)

(3)

Cronbachs 95%

Cronbachs

95%

C3-1C3-2C3-3C3-4C3-5

0.913

0.893

0.930

C4-1C4-2C4-3C4-4C4-5

0.887

0.861

0.909

C5-1C5-2C5-3C5-4

0.849

0.813

0.879

C6-1C6-2C6-3C6-4C6-5C6-6

0.887

0.849

0.901

C3C4C5C6

0.939

0.950

0.926

20

Cronbachs 95% 0.8

(4)
T

T (>0.05)

(<0.4)

(>0.810)

C7-1

0.000

0.318

0.828

C7-2

0.000

0.705

0.758

C7-3

0.000

0.638

0.767

C7-4

0.000

0.555

0.784

C7-5

0.000

0.484

0.795

C7-6

0.000

0.684

0.762

C7-7

0.000

0.494

0.793

T 0.05 0.4(0.810)

C7-1 C71

(5)
A.
KMO Bartlett

C7
Kaiser-Meyer-Olkin (>0.8)

0.824

Bartlett (<0.05)

0.000

KMO Barlett

3.258

0.858

0.673

0.534

1.244

1.123

1.030

0.965

F1

0.811

0.801

0.731

0.621

0.792

0.641

(%)

54.30%

0.40

6 54.30%

B.

C1

C2

A1

A2

B2

B3

B7

B8

C7

0.508

0.402

0.414

0.379

-0.356

0.399

0.572

0.453

0.000

0.000

0.000

0.000

0.000

0.000

0.000

0.000

(=0.508=0.402=0.414=0.379
=0.399)(=-0.356)
(=0.572
=0.453)

(6)
Cronbachs 95%

Cronbachs

95%

C7-2C7-3C7-4C7-5C7-6C7-7

0.828

0.790

0.861

Cronbachs 0.8 95% 0.8 0.790


Cronbachs 0.8 0.7

2.

(1)
T

T (>0.05)

(<0.4)

(>0.938)

C8-1

0.000

0.291

0.940

C8-2

0.000

0.353

0.939

C8-3

0.000

0.667

0.935

C8-4

0.000

0.605

0.936

C8-5

0.000

0.683

0.934

C8-6

0.000

0.704

0.934

C8-7

0.000

0.689

0.934

C8-8

0.000

0.627

0.935

C9-1

0.000

0.706

0.934

C9-2

0.000

0.653

0.935

C9-3

0.000

0.538

0.937

C9-4

0.000

0.467

0.939

C9-5

0.000

0.556

0.937

C12-1

0.000

0.752

0.933

C12-2

0.000

0.764

0.933

C12-3

0.000

0.771

0.933

C12-4

0.000

0.796

0.932

C12-5

0.000

0.776

0.933

T 0.05 0.4(0.938)

C8-1 C8-2
C8-1 C8-2 C9-4 (0.939)(0.938)

(2)
A.
KMO Bartlett

C8C9C12
Kaiser-Meyer-Olkin (>0.8)

0.930

Bartlett (<0.05)

0.000

KMO Barlett

10

11

12

13

14

8.338

1.904

1.027

0.702

0.659

0.594

0.533

0.426

0.373

0.318

0.300

0.231

0.199

0.155

1.507

1.385

1.290

1.209

1.135

1.064

0.998

0.931

0.874

0.816

0.770

0.714

0.659

0.616

F1

F2

0.568

0.840

0.846

0.805

0.831

0.748

0.669

0.661

0.671

0.596

0.441

0.927

0.960

0.915

0.923

0.920

(%)

52.11%

11.90%

0.40

11
5 52.11% 11.90% 64.01%

16

B.

C12

C12-6

C12-7

C8C9

0.622

0.500

0.514

0.000

0.000

0.000

(=0.622
=0.500=0.514)
C10

C11

C8C9

0.494

0.498

0.000

0.000

C12

0.507

0.485

0.000

0.000

C12-6

0.473

0.401

0.000

0.000

C12-7

0.408

0.328

0.000

0.000

(
=0.494/0.498=0.507/0.4850.473/0.401
=0.408/0.328)
C3

C4

C5*

C6

C8C9

0.385

0.333

0.190

0.380

0.000

0.000

0.005

0.000

C12

0.448

0.408

0.271

0.377

0.000

0.000

0.000

0.000

C12-6

0.279

0.233

0.164

0.130

0.000

0.000

0.017

0.057

C12-7

0.284

0.244

0.219

0.164

0.000

0.000

0.001

0.016

(=0.385/0.448/0.279/0.284=0.333/0.408/0.233/0.244)

(=0.190/0.271/0.164/0.219)

(
=0.80/0.377//0.164)

C7*

A1

A2

B2

B3

C8C9

0.281

0.221

0.212

-0.201

0.227

0.001

0.001

0.002

0.003

0.001

C12

0.388

0.178

0.199

-0.198

0.209

0.000

0.009

0.009

0.004

0.002

C12-6

0.130

-0.28

0.019

-0.034

0.079

0.057

0.686

0.784

0.622

0.249

C12-7

0.164

0.032

0.127

-0.102

0.142

0.018

0.647

0.065

0.138

0.039

=0.281/0.388)
(=0.221/0.178
=0.212/0.199=0.227/0.209)(=-0.201/-0.198)

(2)
Cronbachs 95%

Cronbachs

95%

C8-3C8-4C8-5C8-6C8-7C8-8

0.907

0.888

0.925

11

C9-1C9-2C9-3C9-4C9-5

C12-1C12-2C12-3C12-4C12-5

0.960

0.951

0.968

C8C9C12

0.936

0.922

0.948

16

Cronbachs 95% 95%


0.9 0.888 0.9

3.

(1)
T

T (>0.05)

(<0.4)

(>0.911)

C18-1

0.000

0.507

0.908

C18-2

0.000

0.449

0.910

C18-3

0.000

0.384

0.911

C18-4

0.000

0.410

0.910

C18-5

0.000

0.353

0.912

C18-6

0.000

0.257

0.913

C18-7

0.000

0.404

0.910

C19-1

0.000

0.566

0.907

C19-2

0.000

0.478

0.909

C19-3

0.000

0.569

0.907

C19-4

0.000

0.580

0.907

C20-1

0.000

0.639

0.906

C20-2

0.000

0.665

0.905

C20-3

0.000

0.639

0.906

C20-4

0.000

0.530

0.908

C20-5

0.000

0.550

0.907

C21-1

0.000

0.661

0.905

C21-2

0.000

0.711

0.904

C21-3

0.000

0.621

0.906

C21-4

0.000

0.664

0.905

C21-5

0.000

0.468

0.909

C21-6

0.000

0.497

0.909

C21-7

0.000

0.658

0.905

T 0.05 0.4(0.911)

C18-5 C18-6
C18-5 C186 C18-3 (0.384)(0.4)

(2)
A.
KMO Bartlett

C18C19C20C21
Kaiser-Meyer-Olkin (>0.8)

0.880

Bartlett (<0.05)

0.000

KMO Barlett

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

7.985

2.525

1.437

1.209

0.932

0.856

0.698

0.679

0.603

0.558

0.495

0.441

0.435

0.389

0.373

0.355

0.269

0.254

0.201

1.599

1.477

1.383

1.301

1.227

1.156

1.091

1.025

0.965

0.906

0.863

0.805

0.749

0.699

0.648

0.600

0.551

0.501

0.463

F1

F2

F3

0.633

0.843

0.921

0.887

0.602

0.784

0.956

0.616

0.428

0.694

0.797

0.475
0.643

0.517

0.563

0.998

0.928

0.840

0.533

0.619

(%)

38.02%

12.02%

3.84%

0.40

C19-4 C20-2
C20-5

F1

F2

F3

0.633

0.845

0.913

0.880

0.606

0.797

0.940

0.631

0.515

0.712

0.774

0.511

0.557

0.978

0.894

0.832

0.520

0.594

(%)

37.64%

13.78%

7.9%

0.40

7
6 5 37.64%13.78% 7.9%
59.32%


C19-4 C20-2 C20-5 18

B.

C19C20

C21

C18

0.312

0.375

0.000

0.000

C19C20

0.638

0.000

(=0.638)
(=0.312=0.375)

C13

C14

C15

C16

C17

C18

0.412

0.452

0.570

-0.218

-0.165

0.000

0.000

0.000

0.001

0.016

C19C20

0.393

0.319

0.477

-0.133

-0.135

0.000

0.000

0.000

0.053

0.048

C21

0.389

0.288

0.454

-0.152

-0.226

0.000

0.000

0.000

0.027

0.001

(
=0.412/0.393/0.389=0.452/0.319/0.288=0.570/0.477/0.454)


(=-0.218)

C3

C4

A1

A2

B2

B3

C18

0.369

0.385

0.319

0.327

-0.095

0.210

0.000

0.000

0.000

0.000

0.166

0.002

C19C20

0.501

0.536

0.156

0.310

-0.264

0.297

0.000

0.000

0.022

0.000

0.000

0.000

C21

0.423

0.437

0.128

0.261

-0.163

0.207

0.000

0.000

0.062

0.000

0.017

0.002

(=0.369/0.501/0.423
=0.385/0.536/0.437)

(=0.319/0.156/=0.327/0.310/0.261)

(=/-0.264/-0.163
=0.210/0.297/0.207)

(3)
Cronbachs 95%

Cronbachs

95%

C18-1C18-2C18-3C18-4C18-7

0.837

0.800

0.869

C19-1C19-2C19-3C20-1C20-3C20-4

0.840

0.805

0.871

C21-1C21-2C21-3C21-4C21-5C21-6C21-7

0.867

0.837

0.892

C19C19C20C21

0.898

0.877

0.917

18

Cronbachs 95% 0.8

214
9 ACGME 80

3.5 3
2007
28.4 40 40 40
8.33 10.21 81.46 97.24 30.69 36.99 4.67
3.80 2.31 4.77 p 0.05 0.07
0.059 40
ACGME

C4 40

C4 >40

(n=39)

(n=175)

A1

A2

95%

(2)

8.33

5.47

10.21

5.89

-1.818

0.070

-3.90

0.16

81.46

23.30

97.24

21.05

-4.150

0.000

-23.27

-8.28

0.199

A4

30.69

9.23

36.99

10.51

-3.458

0.001

-9.89

-2.71

0.102

A7

9.86

4.12

8.22

4.46

2.103

0.037

0.10

3.18

0.112

B2

4.67

1.27

3.80

1.42

3.513

0.001

0.38

1.35

0.169

B3

2.31

1.45

4.77

3.67

-6.805

0.000

-3.18

-1.75

0.190

1. 9

>9

3.58

>9

3.37
3.1

2.98
2.46
2.16

2.05

2.01

1.72

1.62

1.50

1.64

1.02

2.19

1.1

1.33

1.26 1.33

1.21 1.19

0.138

>9

>9

83.58
72.39

67.46

55.15

65.35
55.1

73.78

66.23
59.75

49.87

52.63

44.5

46.37

69

37.5

41.8

45.2544.96

66.12
61.76

41.5 39.69

0.059

A1 9

A1 >9

(n=100)

(n=114)

95%

(2)

B6

2.05

1.13

1.72

1.21

2.028

0.044

0.01

0.64

0.146

B7

2.98

0.75

3.58

0.91

-5.267

0.000

-0.82

-0.37

0.165

B8

2.16

0.88

2.46

1.05

-2.307

0.022

-0.57

-0.04

0.138

B9

1.02

1.20

1.62

1.24

-3.599

0.000

-0.93

-0.27

0.104

B10

1.50

0.61

1.64

0.64

-1.635

0.104

-0.31

0.03

B11-1

3.10

1.65

3.37

1.66

-1.183

0.238

-0.72

0.18

B11-2

2.01

0.90

2.19

0.99

-1.408

0.161

-0.44

0.07

B11-3

1.10

0.36

1.33

0.94

-2.456

0.015

-0.42

-0.05

B11-4

1.26

0.76

1.33

0.89

-.644

0.520

-0.30

0.15

B11-5

1.21

0.71

1.19

0.79

.165

0.869

-0.19

0.22

C3

55.15

18.75

67.46

22.43

-4.319

0.000

-17.92

-6.69

0.181

C4

55.10

17.75

65.35

21.90

-3.779

0.000

-15.60

-4.90

0.174

C5*

59.75

20.30

66.23

21.81

-2.239

0.026

-12.18

-0.77

0.155

C6

46.37

16.46

52.63

20.02

-2.476

0.014

-11.24

-1.28

0.087

C7*

72.39%

15.94%

83.58%

13.41%

-5.575

0.000

-0.15

-0.07

0.264

C8C9

37.50

19.92

44.50

21.33

-2.469

0.014

-5.54

-0.62

0.117

C12

41.80

25.16

49.87

27.91

-2.209

0.028

-3.05

-0.17

0.113

C12-6

45.25

27.22

44.96

28.65

.077

0.939

-0.29

0.31

C12-7

41.50

24.67

39.69

28.57

.492

0.623

-0.22

0.36

C19C20

69.00

17.68

73.78

16.25

-2.061

0.041

-1.68

-0.04

C21

61.76

18.50

66.12

18.26

-1.733

0.085

-1.96

0.13

0.260

0.116

2. 80

80

>80

80

3.47

>80

3.36
2.95

2.89
2.46
2.04

2.06 2.13

1.98

1.81

1.51

1.47

1.62
1.13

0.94

1.29

1.26

1.3

1.10

1.24

0.138

80

>80

80

>80
74.12

81.73
65.56
52.26

64.47
50.97

65.23

70.07

67.06

56.53

53.73

50.16

52.11

44.51

43.82

33.17

67.17

36.13

46.88
40.73

44.08
31.85

0.138

80

A2 80

A2 >80

(n=62)

(n=152)

95%

(2)

B6

2.04

1.08

1.81

1.22

1.298

0.196

-0.12

0.58

B7

2.89

0.75

3.47

0.89

-4.856

0.000

-0.82

-0.34

0.428

B8

1.98

0.95

2.46

0.97

-3.283

0.001

-0.76

-0.19

0.372

B9

0.94

1.17

1.51

1.26

-3.076

0.002

-0.94

-0.21

0.441

B10

1.47

0.56

1.62

0.65

-1.595

0.112

-0.34

0.04

B11-1

2.95

1.67

3.36

1.64

-1.649

0.101

-0.90

0.08

B11-2

2.06

0.83

2.13

1.00

-.421

0.674

-0.34

0.22

B11-3

1.13

0.42

1.26

0.83

-1.558

0.121

-0.30

0.04

B11-4

1.29

0.76

1.30

0.86

-.098

0.922

-0.26

0.23

B11-5

1.10

0.47

1.24

0.84

-1.623

0.106

-0.32

0.03

C3

52.26

20.74

65.56

20.86

-4.238

0.000

-19.49

-7.11

0.388

C4

50.97

18.55

64.47

20.26

-4.531

0.000

-19.38

-7.63

0.404

C5*

53.73

19.49

67.06

20.87

-4.320

0.000

-19.42

-7.25

0.384

C6

43.82

16.78

52.11

18.91

-3.004

0.003

-13.74

-2.85

0.391

C7*

70.07%

15.37%

81.73%

14.50%

-5.240

0.000

-0.16

-0.07

0.450

C8C9

33.17

18.40

44.51

21.06

-3.701

0.000

-7.65

-2.33

0.402

C12

36.13

20.93

50.16

28.05

-4.012

0.000

-4.19

-1.42

0.338

C12-6

40.73

27.99

46.88

27.79

-1.465

0.144

-0.58

0.08

C12-7

31.85

24.03

44.08

27.10

-3.090

0.002

-0.80

-0.18

0.392

C19C20

65.23

17.71

74.12

16.15

-3.551

0.000

-2.49

-0.71

0.367

C21

56.53

18.76

67.17

17.48

-3.954

0.000

-3.35

-1.12

0.382

3. 3.5

3.5

>3.5

3.5

>3.5

3.69
3.43

3.14

3.08
2.77

2.34

2.07

2.01

1.98

1.74

1.68

1.63

1.48

1.35

1.15

1.39

1.15

1.25

1.21 1.20

0.059

3.5

>3.5

3.5

>3.5
77.99

86.15
71.43

70.71
56.24

73.97

68.02
54.85

60.49

66.98
62.46

53.83

55.36

47.31

46.53

67.92

37.81

41.75

46.7544.16

44.16

38.5

0.059


3.5

B2 3.5

B3 >3.5

(n=77)

(n=137)

95%

(2)

B6

1.63

1.10

2.01

1.21

-2.306

0.022

-0.71

-0.06

0.065

B7

3.69

0.86

3.08

0.83

5.064

0.000

0.37

0.84

0.146

B8

2.77

1.00

2.07

0.89

5.238

0.000

0.43

0.95

0.151

B9

1.68

1.21

1.15

1.25

2.971

0.003

0.18

0.87

0.061

B10

1.74

0.70

1.48

0.57

2.936

0.004

0.08

0.43

0.070

B11-1

3.43

1.58

3.14

1.69

1.229

0.220

-0.17

0.75

B11-2

2.34

1.11

1.98

0.83

2.486

0.014

0.07

0.65

B11-3

1.35

0.93

1.15

0.59

1.682

0.095

-0.04

0.43

B11-4

1.39

0.96

1.25

0.75

1.116

0.267

-0.11

0.39

B11-5

1.21

0.77

1.20

0.75

.100

0.921

-0.20

0.22

C3

71.43

20.32

56.24

20.47

5.222

0.000

9.46

20.92

0.141

C4

70.71

18.69

54.85

19.56

5.784

0.000

10.45

21.27

0.147

C5*

68.02

22.65

60.49

20.11

2.510

0.013

1.62

13.44

0.083

C6

55.36

19.13

46.53

17.69

3.401

0.001

3.71

13.94

0.105

C7*

86.15%

12.73%

73.97%

15.46%

6.207

0.000

0.08

0.16

0.164

C8C9

47.31

23.08

37.81

18.85

3.082

0.002

1.50

6.87

0.080

C12

53.83

28.92

41.75

24.77

3.084

0.002

0.87

3.96

0.061

C12-6

46.75

27.91

44.16

27.99

.651

0.516

-0.21

0.42

C12-7

44.16

28.93

38.50

25.37

1.486

0.139

-0.07

0.53

C19C20

77.99

16.16

67.92

16.53

4.312

0.000

0.98

2.64

C21

66.98

18.83

62.46

18.11

1.725

0.086

-0.14

2.03

0.078

0.119

4. 3

>3

3.67

>3

3.54

2.96

2.97
2.63

2.08

2.32

2.04
1.65

1.64

1.46

1.91

1.70

1.39

1.07

1.07

1.18

1.43
1.11

1.30

0.059

>3

>3
77.34

85.89
69.75
54.38

68.38
53.44

58.87

54.53

36.81

68.67
59.91

46.08

45.31

66.27

71.48

67.95

51.37
41.29

44.6445.59

44.12
37.28

0.059

(Night Float) 2011 ACGME


3

B3 3

B3 >3

(n=112)

(n=102)

95%

(2)

B6

2.08

1.19

1.65

1.13

2.745

0.007

0.12

0.75

0.137

B7

2.96

0.84

3.67

0.80

-6.259

0.000

-0.92

-0.48

0.220

B8

2.04

0.89

2.63

0.99

-4.492

0.000

-0.84

-0.33

0.191

B9

1.07

1.26

1.64

1.18

-3.370

0.001

-0.90

-0.23

0.201

B10

1.46

0.57

1.70

0.67

-2.733

0.007

-0.40

-0.06

0.121

B11-1

2.97

1.72

3.54

1.54

-2.539

0.012

-1.01

-0.13

0.099

B11-2

1.91

0.80

2.32

1.05

-3.202

0.002

-0.67

-0.16

0.097

B11-3

1.07

0.29

1.39

1.00

-3.131

0.002

-0.51

-0.13

0.085

B11-4

1.18

0.59

1.43

1.02

-2.193

0.030

-0.48

-0.03

0.129

B11-5

1.11

0.43

1.30

0.98

-1.865

0.064

-0.41

0.11

C3

54.38

21.49

69.75

18.85

-5.543

0.000

-20.85

-9.91

0.186

C4

53.44

20.73

68.38

17.62

-5.654

0.000

-20.15

-9.73

0.206

C5*

58.87

20.15

67.95

21.64

-3.179

0.002

-14.71

-3.45

0.131

C6

45.31

17.55

54.53

18.75

-3.717

0.000

-14.11

-4.33

0.158

C7*

71.48%

15.78%

85.89%

11.53%

-7.676

0.000

-0.14

-0.11

0.264

C8C9

36.81

19.52

46.08

21.44

-3.310

0.001

-6.51

-1.65

0.127

C12

41.29

25.17

51.37

27.86

-2.780

0.006

-3.44

-0.59

0.156

C12-6

44.64

28.36

45.59

27.66

-0.247

0.805

-0.34

0.26

C12-7

37.28

24.66

44.12

28.62

-1.878

0.062

-0.56

0.01

C19C20

66.27

16.98

77.34

15.23

-5.002

0.000

-2.78

-1.21

0.183

C21

59.91

18.28

68.67

17.63

-3.564

0.000

-2.86

-0.82

0.139

5. 40

40

>40

40

>40

3.32
3.45

2.9

2.62

2.51

2.36

2.08 2.11

1.77
1.46

1.46

1.44

1.61

1.35

1.27

1.05

1.03
0.82

1.25
1.00

0.059

40

>40

40

>40
74.51

82.25

66.45
67.66

66.29

60.83

53.36

49.36
35

49.57
43.26

33.33

58.26

47.86

32.11

30.51

32.69

0.138

53.48

43.14
28.85

40

C4 40

C4 >40

(n=39)

(n=175)

95%

(2)

B6

2.36

1.28

1.77

1.14

2.865

0.005

0.18

1.00

.078

B7

2.62

0.78

3.45

0.84

-5.678

0.000

-1.13

-0.55

.444

B8

1.46

0.72

2.51

0.93

-7.789

0.000

-1.32

-0.78

.443

B9

0.82

1.21

1.46

1.24

-2.912

0.004

-1.07

-0.21

.133

B10

1.44

0.60

1.61

0.63

-1.529

0.128

-0.39

0.05

B11-1

2.90

1.73

3.32

1.64

-1.443

0.150

-1.00

0.15

B11-2

2.08

0.93

2.11

0.96

-.221

0.825

-0.37

0.30

B11-3

1.03

0.16

1.27

0.80

-3.684

0.000

-0.37

-0.11

.325

B11-4

1.05

0.32

1.35

0.90

-3.564

0.000

-0.47

-0.14

.118

B11-5

1.00

0.00

1.25

0.83

-3.940

0.000

-0.37

-0.12

.068

C3

35.00

17.24

67.66

17.69

-10.473

0.000

-38.80

-26.51

.751

C5*

49.36

16.46

66.29

21.08

-5.495

0.000

-23.07

-10.78

.288

C6

33.33

17.29

53.36

16.96

-6.644

0.000

-25.96

-14.08

.381

C7*

60.83%

14.97%

82.25%

12.91%

-9.097

0.000

-0.26

-0.17

.476

C8C9

32.11

20.99

43.26

20.43

-3.068

0.002

-8.06

-1.75

.170

C12

30.51

19.96

49.57

27.06

-5.022

0.000

-5.32

-2.30

.239

C12-6

32.69

22.33

47.86

28.35

-3.638

0.001

-0.94

-0.27

.151

C12-7

28.85

23.32

43.14

26.86

-3.363

0.001

-0.91

-0.23

.148

C19C20

58.26

19.49

74.51

15.00

-5.771

0.000

-3.92

-1.93

.355

C21

53.48

22.64

66.45

16.57

-4.113

0.000

-4.03

-1.42

.294

3.56
3.02

2.94

3.14

3.14

3.57

3.39

3.05

38%

1.85

62%

1.38

62% 43%


50% 2011 ACGME 24
70%
20 % 10 15
2011 ACGME 36
2011 ACGME 28 28% 36

2007

9 80 3.5 3
40

3.5
(Night Float) 2011 ACGME

B1

B9
B9-1
B9-2
1 2 3-4 3 1-2 4 1-3 5
B10
1-10% 2-10 to -5% 3-5 to +5% 4+5 to +10% 5+10%
1-5 to +5% 2-10 to -5%+5 to +10% 3-10%+10%
B11
B11-1

B2
B3
B4
1 2
B5
1 2
B6
B7
1 2 3 4 5

1 2<1 3 1-2 4 3-4 5>5


B11-2
1 2 3 4 5
B11-3
B11-4
B11-5
1 2<1 3 1-2 4 3-4 5>5
C1

B8
B8-1
B8-2
B8-3

1 2 3 4 5
C2
1 2 3 4 5

A1
A2
A3
A4
A5
A6
A7

B8-4
B8-5
0 1 2 3 4 5
<6 6-9 10-14 >15

C3
C3-1

C7
C7-1

C3-2
C3-3
C3-4
C3-5
0 1 2 3 4
C4
C4-1
C4-2
C4-3

C7-2
C7-3
C7-4
C7-5
C7-6
C7-7
1 2 3 4
C8 ()
C8-1

C4-4
C4-5
0 1 2 3 4
C5
C5-1
C5-2
C5-3
C5-4
C5-5

C8-2
C8-3
C8-4
C8-5
C8-6
C8-7
C8-8
1 2 3 4 5
C9 ()

0 1 2 3 4
C6
C6-1
C6-2
C6-3
C6-4
C6-5
C6-6
0 1 2 3 4

C9-1
C9-2
C9-3
C9-4
C9-5
1 2 3 4 5
C10
1 2 3 4 5

C11
1 2 3 4 5

C18-3
C18-4

C12_1

C12-1
C12-2
C12-3
C12-4
C12-5
1 2 3 4 5
C12-6

C18-5
C18-6

C18-7
1 2 3 4
C19
C19-1
C19-2
C19-3

1 2 3 4 5
C12-7

1 2 3 4 5
C13
1 2 3 4 5
C14
1 2 3 4 5

C19-4
1 2 3 4
C20
C20-1
C20-2
C20-3
C20-4
C20-5
1 2 3 4

C15

C16
C17
C18

1 2 3

1 2 3 4 5

C18-1
C18-2

C21
C21-1
C21-2
C21-3
C21-4
C21-5
C21-6
C21-7

D
D1
D2
D3

D4
D5
D6
D7
D8
D9
D10
1 2 3 4 5