2

l awyers line

- DECemBER - 2012

Volume : 2, Issue-13, Dec: 2012

Editor & Publisher :

V.gunasekaran, B.Sc, B.L
lawyerslineguna@gmail.com

Executive Editor :
B. Sarkarai Pandian
Sub Editors :
s.Sathyamurthy, M.K.Anand
Editor-in-Charge
Coimbatore : Na. Thangavelan
Puducherry : S. Rajasekar
Advisory Committee :
E.EzhilCarolinM.A,B.L. ,
J. Suresh B.A, B.L.
R.Rajaram B.A, B.L.,
C.Murugan B.A,B.L.,
K.Ethiraj M.A., M.Phill.,B.L.,
G.Nithiyakumar B.A, B.L. ,
T.Gnanabanu B.A,B.L.
Investigation Team :
C. Manimaran,
G.Prabu,
A.Ramesh
V.Prabu
J. Jenilaya,
R. Srinivasan,
A.Ravikumar,
P. Kalpana.
M. Sakthivel,
G. Hariharan,
Karu.Marimuthu,
R. Sivaram,

OO
cF?
&

CJ
C

12

Advt & Marketing :

V.Baskar - 91763 12470
G.Himalaya - 99654 40349

Design & Layout

G.Kumaraguru
ONLINE SUPPORT :
www.lawyersline.net
Vetrichelvan,
Govindarajan,
Babu,
Vadivel
Shakthi Online Services
Copyright & Publication Info :

Copyright Lawyers line. All Rights reserved. Reproduction in any manner is prohibited. Published
and owned by V. Sekar and published from No.
15, Velu Natchiyar Street, M.G.R. Nagar, Chennai
600 078, and printed by M.S. Ashok at Kadalosai
Achagam, No. 1/1, Bay Arcot Road, Kodambakkam, Chennai - 600 024. Editor : V.SEKAR

All Communications / Queries /

Feedbacks to be contacted at
Lawyers Line (Monthly)
72/3, Anand Appartments, Ground Floor,
100 Feet Road, Vadapalani, Chennai -26.
Tel : 044- 23650044, 9841607006
Email : info@lawyersline.net
Web: www.lawyersline.net
All disputes are subject to exclusive
jurisdiction of competent courts and forums in
Chennai only

F
P
, G


C .
A,
O,

C P.

F W,
F
. F
. F
Q Q
.
Q e

A K
.
cF
C F
A e F

O
G . G
.
, .

CK

24

& F HEJ

08 -& Q
10 & K ?
14 & M
23 & M cF
30 & C
F..
.
. G W A A
C .
A : 149202000000797
AJ
: F Yv (IOB)
A
: v
C 9841607006 F
. M Lawyersline.net F K .

l awyers line

- DECemBER - 2012

eF OJ PJ,
I A , C
Y, F HC A O
N F F P.
CM F A FF,
. , F M
Q, M , F
G v ON OJ. ,
O M F
A. P v
O MKA, P,
E P
P M
P MA. cF
, K bM MK
A.
GJ v O,
A , CM F
F O, P M
A KM. 2011& A
A 33 IL
N. MJ 99
IL N. G
F M .
A I K C M
FC. Q,
GF MJ 29%&
A GA. O, 10,524
. CM 2,230 , HCL
534 , YM 384 .
I CP G
F F P ,
F K . T A.
E C, Y HCL A.
FK HJ E
F. 2011&, AO
3

, PH
i FK
. 26 O
O A
P
E . F
H HC
JCJJ
G P
J. FK
M.
Q A
O . 2005&
K , C,

P, GF h
O, C
A, F
F F
K
A
P.

v G
F P
M
AM.
, PO K
e GF M
FK A
MK.
,
.

FKJ
PM . ,
FK L
?

GF
FKJ P
H. FBI&J
FK M
J MJ
F. ,
G Y,
FM ,
FM G
h MF eP
MK E
J
F
OA.

l awyers line

- DECemBER - 2012

C cF F
& O F !

O M, M FM
. Q F G
F FM. F A NJP
M O K.
M. ,
P P
c A.
C cF F F
C A
F P, A
K C P C
J HFLA .
C cF F
J A , cFJ
C
. C
F F J
C cFJ K
G
A
.
Q CP

QF
A,
M O
P P
.
I .
F .
F
A E
.
O O J
A N F
K J
A.
I GJ .
G P
P. C
O
l awyers line

- DECemBER - 2012

 Q
. ,
F ,
A A H
G S..
K C I
. C
, O F
I C .
Q K K
C M .
cF F C M
A K
F . cF
F M
. M
M, M F
M . Q
F G
F FM. F
A NJP
M O
K.
G b
cF J F
. H
HA. ,
, G
A. C, K
FI
F.
C K
F
G.
K F.
C Q
A..1970& H F
. F C

.
FM A.H. 1843& YF O
LR . F
M
C , C

, F .
FF H C C
K. v,
A HF
1920,1922 1924 A O
C .
H, YF
H, C
MS J

. K C
, 14
CJ M
, FK K
O F
J O
, .
C cF , 2006& FF
GJ,
, J O
KH C ,
F F K C
.
, M, H
M P
e O F
F, O
J.
,
F P , J
M.
O
O J
,
A. ,
C A. P 2011&
L F O
H .
, F L
N, F
e P FKO
M, K
O A.
J M
N
G,
A.
M K
F I.

l awyers line

- DECemBER - 2012

 O
cF
F
O

A ,

P
,
FJ,
P
FI

K.

OO
cF?
A J

P M P P
F..
F.
cF F
F ,
K M
KM A H
J, P
F FK,
cFF C FKO
J
M.
O cF F
O A
, P
, F, P
FI
K. G, K
FJA

L F cF
, A 3
& J F
A cFF
...

PO v
G ...
A cF
K, F

A , O
cF F
J ,

A AM.
PO H
KM.
l awyers line

- DECemBER - 2012


cF F
.
G J
K E
, K
, O
cFF cFF, P
IP
. FK O

M
M cF
E FI
PM MM O
P P
KM M.
H
cF I.
L, O, G
cF,
cFF F ,
P FK
K J .
F.IJ
P . P
.
J MM K F
O M.

K.
cFF
O PO

O H
F A
.
cF O F CCTV
E E .
L .
K ,
GJ FK
O, O cF
F P A.
C A
O, M

K H
O J A.
, O cF F
M M

. cF F G
Out Post P.S. G .

cFF F
, O
K H F .
M

.I

P, O
J F H
K
F O v

cF cFFJ
A.
MM M H
J, cF
....

l awyers line

- DECemBER - 2012

Q
M..Aw
& E

M..
F P

M F
cFF

vL

b
C

l awyers line

- DECemBER - 2012

G
K 1915& H.
F Aw
.
.
O.
. C
70
F. C C
F. Q L
. C
GA. M ..v.
FK J
, I
C
,
C G
. cF cF
F 1973&
A C b
O. K
C H
7
M.
MJ
O,
, F Q
F .
Q ,
98 . H GC
C
A.
.
GF
c .
F
H
H C
8

J vQ
L , ,
F, KM C F
vQ

. M
.. HL
KM
I C
cF C
IF M
C .
K FM Q
..
F
H M..Aw
. F
H M..Aw
F ,
L ,
vL
O
.
M.. F P
P
M F
cFF vL

b C

. K b
vL

. CJ
O
M A.
M..
Aw. vL
G

CF
. vL O
Q
vL O
K M
. G
H F
F
.
P F
F.M...
1952& L M
FA P
A. H 1957& Q J
Q C
. 1959& K
C A. 1968&
cF cFF .
H 1973& cF
cFF E.
M PA. 1999&
M M.
F,
M G YF
.
O K M
F. G

e H e
eH F
M .

F Al
, ,
H e,

F A .
cFF
GI
cFF GI. Q,

cFF GIA. cFF
M H e L
F.
Fm,
F .
H cFF e H
M Q .
M
A F
, E
M A F.M..
Aw . 20&
Q , ,
Y, C
H .

P, ,
F
, , M
O
K F
A.
F K:
. GF C
. K
M . O
F . M
. M .
. M P
.
F e AF F e
O M b e
cFF GI . O
. F

.
M Q

Lawyers Line (Monthly)

72/3, Anand Appartments, Ground Floor,

100 Feet Road, Vadapalani, Chennai - 600 026.
Telephone : 044- 23650044, 9841607006
Email : info@lawyersline.net, lawyerslineguna@gmail.com
Web: www.lawyersline.net

M :
v:
v : 9176312470 & T. : 99654 40349
MF

.
.
G W A A

C .
A : 149202000000797
AJ
: F Yv (IOB)
A
: LAWYERSLINE

l awyers line

- DECemBER - 2012

K ?
FO ...
F ,

,
, ,
, C,
F, , H,
v
F J
G
A
. F

A. ,
J F
A? ,

. Q

Q
P. , F
F
F. Q,
Q
F. I
K M.
Q, b, F
, F,
,
C

F

PH Q
G
.



,
,
F
F. H
A M
l awyers line

- DECemBER - 2012

C F
F,
J O
E
I
A.
C M
P
A
A. C
,
KO


. Q
F O L
,
,

A.
OO,
10

KO, F,
CL F
O
A.
M,
H,
F
F
vF F

.
FM

HK
MK K, H
P
, F

F.
E M G,

G, C
C,
M O
L F

F.

F
A.
J
SC/St
N

M
F
I M
A
GF
O F.
Q,
H

 F
O e
? ,
FK M.
F H
FJ
,

F
, Q,
MO

K
F
M. H
H
, F

F.
Q,
F, L
A K
, ,
F, , F


.
i,
F , ,
, F
,
F

O
F.
M K M
, C F
F,
J O
E I
A. I
K

Q
A.
, I M,
W
,
NJP
, HH
O
A. , ,
F v
L
JP
O
A, GA,
KJ P
A.
F F,
Q I i

A F .
,

11

. L

,
J
O P
K
.

F
vF
. PH
,
MF
. N
JP H , M
O
A. L
M G
O
J
. ,
F M

.

K
O ,
F
F I.

l awyers line

- DECemBER - 2012

i.,

M.Sc., M.L.,

P, cF

CJ

I F CO C
A B J CC
A. G A Av
C E
E. ,
cF
cF
.
I C & II,
MF 225 CCO P
PHA.
CC A B HK
, v, M F F

J A CC
F cF J
PH.
O Italitual Offenders
J
J
PH.
cF, cF, ,
M cF, M,
M cF,
M cF A
cF I C &
II MF 226& W CC
PP J
K C
E A
CC

C
M
CC MF
815&
A H
F.
P C
gF HC
/ /
P P

A CC

.
l awyers line

- DECemBER - 2012

12

C F
F.
3. CC
M O
E . (B
CC A).
, M CC
E.
4. A CC
F
.
5. F
L , O,
A ,

F F
.
6. F
MFO K.
7. , , L A
F.
,
A F.
IF 9 F C
3 Q CO
A F FA.
CO A. Q
2007& CO
(Fan), J c, N
C CC O
A.

K HH.
K F
L A CC
.
M CC MF 815&
A H F.
P C gF HC
, , P P
A CC
. C
O CC CJ
E N A
K , ,
CCJ M
F A O M.
A C
F K .
1. CC
. A C
C Q H O
.
2. MF 387& PH
.

N C .
( CC J
A 115 A
N M N
). IP F
, Hv,
A, M A
. , OJ
13

l awyers line

- DECemBER - 2012

F O G

.
P, cF

M
&

, F GJ ,
MF H F M O G .
Q, p I AA.

MF E
P FM
O ,
A
FJK F
, EM
FA
I. ,

M E
FKM
. Q,
F F,
K O
M F.
M
M, FM J
F
FF
A.
F F P
FJ
F F
l awyers line

- DECemBER - 2012

18

.

F K
O e
M K
M F.
O
M M
F.
, K
FF, 4 10 %
,
M
p
A. , cF
F, K
P M M
H .
J p
GJ. ,
F,
3 MF
K
A.
14

A, C F O
F, ,
iO F,
F
H
H , MF
, P. Q,
F F O I K
A. M
, p
F M
H i . ,
M O 18 %
GG. e 82% Q
M.
F
M H
A. CP
J KH
A.
M
GO NJP,

A. , A
O F ,
N
H
.

F
P KF.
A.
FFJ
F F A. F I
A Q, cF
M A b c
A. ,
c M
H . E
cFF , &
J HC
N A. , F
GJ ,
MF H F M
O G . Q, p
I AA.
, ,
K A .
Q, E K
.

iO
MF
OA. F P
A.
FM Q & M

K
15

l awyers line

- DECemBER - 2012

News @ Glance
documents are required, be able to pay visa application fees,
schedule an appointment for biometrics collection, and will be
able to schedule an interview at a U.S. Embassy or consulate.
This new processing system allows applicants to schedule
their appointments either online or by phone. They wouldnt
need to pay the call center for any fee at all. In addition to that,
they are given the option to use whatever language theyre most
comfortable with, like: English, Hindi, Punjabi, Gujarati, Tamil, and
Telugu. Whats also very nice in this new system is that they will
be able to chat directly (www.ustraveldocs.com/in) to have their
questions answered through the new website during call center
hours: 8am- 8pm Monday- Friday, and 9am- 6pm on Sunday. The
numbers to call are: (91-120) 660-2222 or (91-22) 6720-9400 in
India or 1-310-616-5424 in the United States. They may also send
emails in English or Hindi at supposrt-india@ustraveldocs.com.
More convenient payment options (in paying their U.S. Visa
application fees):
a by Electronic Funds Transfer (ETF)
a with a mobile phone
a pay in cash at over 1,800 Axis bank branches

Court asks police official

to tender apology

court asked a Delhi police official to tender

an apology to a magistrate
with an undertaking to be
careful in discharging his
duties in future.
Additional Sessions
Judge Ramesh Kumar
gave the order, waiving
a fine of Rs 10,000 imposed on Sub-Inspector
Bal Kishan in June this
year by the magisterial
court, which had ordered
deduction of the sum from
his salary for his failure to
execute a non-bailable
warrant in a case lodged
Mukherjee Nagar police
station in 2002 under the
Arms Act.
On the SIs appeal,
the sessions court modified the order considering that the SI
had misplaced the NBW and his failure to execute it was not
deliberate.
The concerned revisionist (Kishan) is directed to be careful
in future regarding the processes issued by courts.
According to ASJ, Since NBW was misplaced by him, the
revisionist is directed to furnish an apology before the trial court
with an undertaking that he shall be careful in future regarding
the processes received by him for the purpose of execution.
During the hearing on revision petition, Kishans counsel
had told the sessions court that his client was the IO of the
case and had conducted the probe and had filed a charge
sheet before the magisterial court.
The counsel said the NBW issued against the accused
was given to Kishan but the same could not be executed as
it was misplaced. He added the magistrate passed the order
against the SI without hearing him.
The state, however, had sought dismissal of Kishans plea
before the sessions court saying the magistrate had rightly
passed both the orders against him on not returning the NBW
issued against the accused.

Companies and travel agents may obtain multiple fee receipts

for group travel under this new system.
Comes with this new processing is a requirement for applicants to make two appointments: for fingerprint collection and
for a consular interview.
Applicants are also advised to visit an Offsite Facilitation
Center (OFC) to submit their fingerprints and a photo prior to
their visa interviews. Currently, applicants waiting period for visa
interview appointment is less than ten days and less than one
hour at U.S. Consular facilities in India.

P F,
, A.
I F K,
A.

Indias New Visa Processing

ood news to all visa applicants in India! A new visa

processing system took effect on September 26, 2012 which
made it more convenient for all Indian applicants in making
payments and scheduling appointments. This standardize procedures was announced by the United States Embassy in India.
Starting September 26, 2012, all applicants will be able to
access a new website to fill out application forms, check what

l awyers line

- DECemBER - 2012

72/3, v,
, Q, & 26
C : 044 & 2365 0044
16

Death of woman
T

denied an abortion
causes uproar in Ireland

he death of an ailing woman

who was refused an abortion in an Irish
hospital has inflamed longstanding concern about Irelands tight restrictions on
when women can terminate a pregnancy.
Praveen Halappanavar told that his
wife, Savita, was suffering intense pain
and had been told her baby would not
survive. Upset but resigned to losing her
child, she was denied an abortion despite
repeated pleas with their Galway hospital as she suffered shakes and vomiting.
The consultant said it was the law,
that this is a Catholic country. Savita
said, I am neither Irish nor Catholic,
but they said there was nothing they
could do, Halappanavar told the newspaper from India.
As long as the fetus still had a heartbeat, the husband said they were told,
an abortion was illegal. Days later, the
heartbeat stopped and the remains were
removed, but Halappanavar grew sicker,
eventually dying of blood poisoning, her
husband told the Irish Times.
The Galway Roscommon University Hospitals Group said it could
not discuss the details of her case
with reporters, but was reviewing the
unexpected death in line with its usual
procedures to establish what had happened. It extended its sympathy to her
husband, family and friends. The Health
Service Executive, a national body that
oversees Irish healthcare, is also carrying out a review and will recommend
any changes needed to prevent similar
incidents, it said.
While abortion is banned under the
Irish constitution, its highest court ruled
decades ago it is allowed when the life
of the woman is in peril. But with no
detailed regulations or guidelines for
doctors, the question of when a fetus
can be aborted remains murky.
Even doctors who think abortion is
needed may fear arrest or losing their
careers, abortion activists say. Critics
argue the legal limbo makes doctors so
uneasy that they refuse to perform the
procedure even when mothers are at
risk or a baby is already expected to die.
James Burke said he and his wife
learned that their child wouldnt survive
outside the womb because of a rare
syndrome, but were told they had leave
the country to get a medical termination.
They went to England.
Its just so saddening that it has to
come to a woman and her child dying

for people to start talking about it,

said Burke, who went public with his
own story last year. He is now part of
an activist campaign called Termination
for Medical Reasons Ireland.
Nearly two years ago, the European Court of Human Rights ruled that
Ireland had violated European Union
law by failing to adequately protect the
lives of women. The Irish government
called upon a group of experts for advice
on how to clear up its abortion rules;
that expert group gave its report to the
Irish health department Tuesday night
for review, just before the Irish Times
published its story.
While Sinn Fein and other political
parties pressed the government to pass
long overdue legislation ensuring
that abortions to save women would be
allowed, Prime Minister Enda Kenny
argued that the government should not
take action before the death is fully investigated. His Fine Gael political party
said any changes should also await the
expert report on abortion law.
The matter will come before
government in due course, it said
Wednesday.
Sen. Kathryn Reilly of Sinn Fein
argued that the tragedy exposed the
damage done by inaction. Were no
longer dealing with what-ifs. Were no
longer dealing with a hypothetical situation, she said, pressing the government
to say when the report would be made
public and laws would be passed.
It just cant go on anymore,
Reilly said. Protests and vigils were
planned Wednesday night across the
country as the news spread in Irish and
international media.
The Irish law is unusually restrictive for a country in Europe, but the
resulting barriers to abortion access
are much like those in poorer countries
that get less media attention, said Patty
Skuster, senior policy advisor for Ipas,
which advocates for safe abortion.
17

10,000 in Ireland protest

death of dentist denied abortion

Never again! demonstrators chant in Dublin,

where they held a vigil for a woman who died during a
miscarriage after doctors refused to remove the fetus.
About 10,000 people marched through Dublin and
observed a minutes silence Saturday in memory of the
Indian dentist who died of blood poisoning in an Irish
hospital after being denied an abortion.
Marchers, many of them mothers and daughters
walking side by side, chanted Never again! and held
pictures of Savita Halappanavar as they paraded across
the city to stage a nighttime candlelight vigil outside the
office of Prime Minister Enda Kenny.
The 31-year-old Halappanavar, who was 17 weeks
pregnant with her first child, died Oct. 28, one week
after being hospitalized with severe pain at the start of
a miscarriage. Her death, made public by her husband
last week, has highlighted Irelands long struggle to
come to grips with abortion.
Doctors refused her requests to remove the fetus
until its heartbeat stopped four days after her hospitalization. Hours later she became critically ill and her
organs began to fail. She died three days later of blood
poisoning. Her widower and activists say she could have
survived, and the spread of infection been stopped, had
the fetus been removed sooner.
The case illustrates 20 years of confusion in abortion law in Ireland, where the practice is outlawed in the

constitution. A 1992 Supreme Court ruling decreed that

abortions should be legal to save the life of the woman,
including a woman who makes credible threats to commit suicide if denied one. But successive governments
have refused to pass legislation spelling out the rules
governing that general principle, leaving the decision
up to individual doctors in an environment of secrecy.
Many doctors say they fear being targeted by lawsuits or protests or even charged with murder if
they perform an abortion to safeguard a womans life.
Speakers from socialist parties, womens groups
and abortion rights organizations addressed the crowd
Saturday. They decried the fact that two decades had
passed without any political decision to define when
hospitals could, and could not, perform abortions.
About 1,000 people staged a more prayer-oriented
rally in the western city of Galway, where the Halappavanars settled in 2008. Some placed candles spelling
Savita on the pavement in Galways central Eyre
Square.
Halappanavars husband, Praveen, took her body
back to India for a Hindu funeral service and cremation Nov. 3 but intends to return to his job as a medical
devices engineer at Boston Scientific in Galway.
The Irish governments inaction on abortion means
that the only law on the books dates to 1861, during
British rule, declaring that the procurement of a miscarriage amounts to murder and could be punishable
by up to life in prison.
l awyers line

- DECemBER - 2012

 c F b

HKM
M
HFF G , F
P
G , GHM.

F .106/1996& ,
cFF cFF F &
KJ b
M, F. Q
F 1995&
HK 13& W . ,
F. f .
f & ,
F 1955& HK 13& W, 1996&
.166& F
F . F , M
HH, HFF
F K.
, HFF
F 18.5.1989 AF,
H.v. M,

F F. M
KJ , HK 20, 2009.
b, 1998& 147 &
E f F ,
1998& 166& cFF,
cFF F. KJ,
24.1.1998 b
F
H ..... b HF ,
v Q, ,
J .6, H.v. ,
Q :
FHK L cFF
FHK cFF M .
& f, 24.1.1998
l awyers line

- DECemBER - 2012

18

HFF M, e
F
F .
F, & f
I A
, F , 1990& 90
F .
M H
. ,
c, F
M
A. HFF M, F
,
i M
O
FM A.
,
i H
K i M
P. H, MJ
M F
& f F
J.
NJP HFFJ p
171 (M) 1990, F
. HFFJ
f
HFF MM.
H F
M cF W
K .
1.
?
2. , G
?
3. HFF
F?
4. H ,

HFF M HK ?
5. J ,
M F ?
6. HFF G p
F?
7.
K A?
O ,
H O
J F . ,
F M .
& f
C MK. P.W.4 H
. PW1 F H
K . F :2

vF H F .
, F
H, HFF
F
i F P,
J i FH M.
f & P,
1989& M i
. , HFF

f

. HFF 171 (M)

1990&J p A
f e .
25.6.1995 , .500/& p
M
b F
cFFJ
. H f
, M
F 90& 1990/18/1992 F
. Q , 17.6.1992
, cF, M,
cFF F.. C.
bH .
K Q, HFF
M, , F K J
A
FKJ ,
M P
.
& f ,
GF .
H, QM
M. ,
H, HFFJ
F. ,
v . ,
F .
19

l awyers line

- DECemBER - 2012

dF . P.W.5
P.W.6 . F
H & HFF C
MK. O.P.W.2
M M HFF O.P.W.1
Fw ,
C, OPW3 Q C, OP.W.5 A
OP.W.5 S .

C O H
, M cF, K
C
M .
GJ, i
C. , ,
M
. , HFFJ
& fK
i F
I
A. ,
M cF, &
fK C O
, HFFJ H M
M M
P.
HFF
F H
I M
cF P. , F
O
J M A.
Q HFF
M. HK
I M cF,
.
f F.F
H..C P HFF
F...C P A K
.
f P, M
A
KO M cF
. Q & f

K M,
H.
, f P.W.4
MKJ, H
MK C
K.
P.W.4 : 18.5.1989
F HFF
F K
l awyers line

- DECemBER - 2012

i M. i
(Rukhsati ) C
i .
Q,
HFFJI
M .
K O
F G . Q
, HFF H
, ,
, M,
L F I
A. 2.1.1994
GF
F
P. EX1.1 FM .
HFF F J

F P. P.W.4
C C K
. F HFF
C M .
O.P.W.2 HFF, ,
F HJ M
,
Q,
P.
fK P, & f
K
, F
HJ C
K H
, HFFJ
F
P M
F K I
O KA F.
HFFJ P, F
J, fK
20

C F M

P.
fK H
i (Rukhsati)
C ,
HFF NJP p
171 (M) 1990 &, p K F
. cF
. H & f
, A O
J F 90/1990&
F . 17.6.1992
. , J
( F
90/1990&J ) P,
H
M ,

, J E
f
M L
M K
P. M, M
i
I KA.
A M
J, HFF P,
K, PH
Q P
F
cF F P.
1989 HFFJ
F
F
A. Q
F 90/1990&
M.

.
Q
M

,
F
E
M
O
F
F
GI.
, H, HF
F A F
M, Q
C
A. Q f M
FF H
i A.
HFFJ H HJ
G KA
MJ ,
M,
GH PM
A.
fK
P F.C C, 24 K 1998
M ,
, M HK ,
F Y
P M
. M A
F
K . ,

e HFF
M IP A.
, HFFJ H
Iv GH
f J P,
p , p
. HFF i
P A.

A. F
90/1990&/J
bH fK C
O J,
J, HFF G
, F

P
G , GH
M. GJ fK
Q E
i A
21

l awyers line

- DECemBER - 2012

F 13& HKM K
F F
M
.
, GO

J, cF
M A P.
K
P. W:&
HM F T
, 2003(1) B.L.J. 633; w
F w (2007) 4 SCC 511; KSw
F x 2007 (2) SCC
262; bw C F F.
2008 (5) g 198.
F HFFJ P,
f FI
A A.
Q f F
E,
Y F

M O MH, H
F HK 13 B & W HK
P M
.
cF, O,
Y F PM,
O , H
c HK ,
H
GJ, F
M MA ,
M A. P
J M ,
F Y GJ
.
1955, F F 13& HK
, Y
F K MF
. F
FC A
A K
K. F

A. F
J, F F
W Y
F P
P F
.
A f M
cFF F
C MPA.
, F
90/1990, AJ
J,
A M
J J,
M cFF b
Q. , HFFJ,
, M
P M.
cFF G
J, f M
cFF .
M i
M KM. Q
MM.
, Q, PM
F
. , f
M, A.
Q M
A.

P H A.
F 1998& .
F
i
C M. f
1998& , Y
F F
f F. HFFJ
P F, J
A.
f F
fK F
MA M . M F
M M OP
.
M
i
A. F PH
Q, H F
l awyers line

- DECemBER - 2012

22

O
?
F M
cF ...

C g F,
F M cF
FM.
J
. F

F .
,
cF
. F M cF
. HF g CJ
, KO cF
C. ,
A, F
K
K. Q, cF
, J M
, F O F
23

A. F
OA. PK
GHM ,
K F
J K GH
M MM KA.
MJ
JK
A cFFJ
M I.
K cFFJ
N G
. J MJ
M MJ
cFFJ .
GH
P .
O L F
H N OA.
e
A. , M
e A
J
H F N .
K cFFJ
F M
F A.
F , 1872, F &14& W
M , K
,
K .

, M cF K
.
PH MF O
K O
,
K F
O .
J P A
K FF.
, F P
M G A. F
M Q,
F P
O H
N
A.
J,
HK M,
O G
.

l awyers line

- DECemBER - 2012

l awyers line

- DECemBER - 2012

24


&

C
N F
,
,
M

AH
N
,
A.

, J
FJ Q
P i I
C N. H H
O H
A. , H
H
F
MKA. GF
F FO
. ,
A
F.
.
H F O
.
O PH
I H .
G
LF FK J
.
CH 44&
A.
FM
FK J
C .
O, L e

C . F,
F C OM.
, iA
J. CO ,
F J
M. 1972& O
M.
Q vh
F. 1980&O,
, vh F
M F
J H L.
, wK F
F, F
KC c C GI.
25

l awyers line

- DECemBER - 2012

O F
MF
C
,
O M.

H
CJ
, I
J H
L

.
FM

H

K P
.

K (HAMA), 1956,


N A. vh, APv,
KR F
.
, 1890& HP .

N A.
:vh, APv, KR
O Q
WKF.
F
L
,
O,

1890&
F
MF
H
.
WK,

A.
H M
. F
W, 21 ,
H , Q
. F
K, .
, JL H
F M M
. ,
MK F KM.
,
, M
P F.
O
M

,
G JK K
HK,
O
K,

MF.
O
.
HF A
F. AF.
F O ,
,
,
.
F
,
A. ,
, 21
MF
HAMA A. L
l awyers line

- DECemBER - 2012

26

FI. ,
O ,
K
L
A
. O
Q b .
K

, MF
H, i
C .
C cF (
O
K) , 2000& IV F
F .
,
L
K
A. ,

K
F
,


K .

F M P
PH
C.
Q
HAMA GAWA
O M
M. ,
J
v
H H
KM
M. ,
GJ C cF (K

, 2000
M
, C
cF (O K
) FF
, 2006&
.
L F
2& HKM M
.
,
G

JK K
HK,
O

K,


MF
.
K
A
A
PF
F 2&
HKM M.
M, , M


OA.
, M


A:&
F IV F
O
A
A.
AH
.
O E
F A A

J F

, C

K F
c GO
H .
JJ F 40 HK,
J
A
J
C MFO AJ
AM MF
A. ,
K
C N
F ,
, M

O
AH
N ,
27

A.
,MF,
& , M

O H
.
, M

O H
W , MF
, H
.
1. F
F
. MF, F
J, zI
F F Q
Q b
O (W.P. (Crl) No. 1171/1982)
L
cFF bO
J .
2. 2003& F
H e
.
3. C cF (K
)
2000 F FK
l awyers line

- DECemBER - 2012

MF F W .
JJ 2000& W H
MF & :
JJ , 2000& HK 41, F MFO
33(1) W H
KMA.
JK K
G
L
. J F
K
. , M
K
MFO M
. FK ,
G , F
P
O
MF HP, F F
PM, cFF
. cF
O e
M FF
.
MF, ,
M
, G ,
F
G G
, C GI.
G
K

G A,
M ( )
K KM
F , H F

.
(ARA &M MF, F
C, F U/S 41(3) &J
PM,
K .
,
K C.
C cF , 2000& HK 2(8) &,
, F U/S 29
& M
K C .
C cF , 2000& 29& HK,
P A.
, M ,
K H

l awyers line

- DECemBER - 2012

KM F
.
CWC , M
O
v , M
F,
N , M
H, M N
, M
MF
N
C cF FF 2006
MFO W Q.
CWC J PH
,
.

MF:
C cF (K & O
) , 2000& 41(5) HK, W
F H
.
1. M J MF,
M H

KM .
2. J MF,
C

M .
3. K KM
J MF, J
,
?
cF (O K &
) , 2000& 41(6)& HKM, 41
28

 HKM, cF, W
F
F .
I. F v
.
II. JK
, L
H .
III. J F.
JJ , 2000 FF ,
cFF F C cF
F
O. Q JJ (FF)
, 2006&, MF
cF J
FF. C cF F
W H, cFF
F U/S 41, F .
, , M
O H
F, P cF
K C. JJ
cF M
, F C
FK MF F
. F W F
MFO 33(J) & cF
M,
F C FK MF
F . F
W F MFO 33(J) &, cF
, , A
P e F KJ cF
cFFJ cF,
cF KJ
cF P.
M
N P .
C ,
24 E F,
M,
M M
H .
FF W
M
GF F K
.
, M H
A KM
A.
M FK
FKJ ,
F H P
M H .

C H , PM
H H, C FK O
G N ON K
M F
, F F
C
L PM M K
M, H
PMH
. :
M,
PM CWC H
60 .
4
F PM .

KM F
M H .
H, C
H WK
O F
J HKM
H 24 E F
M H .
F F ,
KM ,
L
A .
, M M
H
KM .
WP
.
1. F M
H.
2. F H.
3. JK O ,
Q K
M .
4. L,

M .
, AP M
P O
. P J
,
,
F .
MF:& J
A, JK
KY . H
KM.

29

l awyers line

- DECemBER - 2012

& E

M
Cw
S A
. C FF

F. ,
F
F .

M M c
, H
.
A F FF
F, L,
C, F I
C O
, O
a L .
GF C
K K 1926& H.
Qv, FK
. K F.Y
. C ,
C ,
Y F F
, KK e
. K
G,
l awyers line

- DECemBER - 2012

30

 N
Y .
I K, FM
, FM K
. C
F.

K.
J Y
F I
FM K
1950&O
,
F C
. J

.
E
. C
M
H HCF
Qv ..
L CF F
F. LC
F L A ON O
. H LCF

FK
F.
E
FKJ
M.
E
NF
O K
C
1966&
C H.
FM v
, A
Qv N C
. N
K
. 1989&
O A
. FK C
CJ K
OJ.
K Q. F
K U K C
. F PH U
K C.
M

J
A

,
IO
M
I

.

31

U K M
, FK
K .
wM I,
, vh
K .
H AM.
1995&
L F

F. P .
M
Cw S
A .
C FF
F.
, F
F
. 1999&
L
, J
MF.
F J O
P i

M.
2005&
cA.
2006&
C L .
, b C
E P
C P.

, K,
E F,
F K Q
. F
FF F
.
F 1992&
F ,
K G Av bM
FO F
AK i
E M
,
F, G FF F
G ,
M.
J A
, I
O M I
.
l awyers line

- DECemBER - 2012

J M e
1995& .
H , ,
H 1996&
MF .
C
CJ C
F A. J
J FF CJ
EJ . J
K x
2006&
x
CM HK G
K Q C H.
C H
F
F I . F
J
.
, K
.
G K F M
.
. Y
C
.
L N A,
A. ,
F A
F . IF
l awyers line

- DECemBER - 2012

K F A. F
N N
A.
K.
K.
F MF
. FK U K.
g .
YN FF F
A M
. O, F
F.
. w G
. C FK.
, E
.
C ,
N F, , O
C.
N.
F F
A. K .
G
AM. G
F
. G
. w
K
F
KM ....

32

M K
vQ Q OO
F F F Q

M
A . , M K
F Q O
. Q, , cF
, M
Q O, M
K A
F H A
O 25 i F
L M.
O Q O
bH, F
P F.
FF
K FO 19(1)(g) &
e , 30 (1)
M G G
A K
KM.
F cF &

C
F F M A. M,
FM K F
A A. FM
FF H iCJ
, M , ,
20 , NO
M J, F
F A.
F Q M,
FF K
P 14 C
M
M CO KA
.
L 86 F
M F
F. F
F
33

l awyers line

- DECemBER - 2012

cFF
A
O bH, M
K C
O MF
M

P.
P, J

GJ .
Q Q O
F M
LJ
LA.

25%
W F.
OO,
,
GJ
G
K M HC
.

CK

F.
O
H
,
G F.
b
N
cF M C
M
M GO
.
A
M Q,
J
F, H,
P
H A.
,
O
O,
A.
P
. ,
F
cF P
M.
eP
l awyers line

- DECemBER - 2012

Q O
F M
LJ

LA.

25% W
F.
OO,

GJ

G K
M HC
.
34

M C
M
.
F,

b O.
O
25%

PM.
F
P
.
, bH
A,
F
. ,
F, Q
H

GJ .
G

H K O
.
O
F
,
O,

. ,
, K
F L,
M
O
F.
IP
O , F
FA.
, gFJ
G
O

G A.
H 19
(1) (g) MF e.
N Q,
b, F L
CJ
O
. ,
c F
.

35

l awyers line

- DECemBER - 2012

36

l awyers line

- DECemBER - 2012