lawyers line

novemBER - 2012

lawyers line

novemBER - 2012

Editor & Publisher :

V.gunasekaran, B.Sc, B.L
Executive Editor :
B. Sarkarai Pandian
Sub Editors :
s.Sathyamurthy, M.K.Anand
Editor-in-Charge
Coimbatore : Na. Thangavelan
Puducherry : S. Rajasekar
Advisory Board :
E.EzhilCarolinM.A,B.L. ,
J. Suresh B.A, B.L.

R.Rajaram B.A, B.L.,

C.Murugan B.A,B.L.,
K.Ethiraj M.A., M.Phill.,B.L.,
G.Nithiyakumar B.A, B.L. ,
T.Gnanabanu B.A,B.L.
Investigation Team :
C. Manimaran,
G.Prabu,
J. Jenilaya,
R. Srinivasan,
Ravikumar,
P. Kalpana.
M. Sakthivel,
G. Hariharan,
Karu.Marimuthu,
R. Sivaram,
Advt & Marketing :
V.Baskar - 9176312470
Design & Layout
G.Kumaraguru
ONLINE SUPPORT :
www.lawyersline.net
Vetrichelvan,
Govindarajan,
Babu,
Vadivel
Shakthi Online Services
Copyright & Publication Info :

10

J M C
, FM
C
F
.
L
A. H
q CL
PM
. GF CJ
I K
N K.
GF H M.
.
g J
, C
.
FK
C,
A. P
MF FCJJ

I . J
Q K
e
K
F .
,

.
CK

18

Copyright Lawyers line. All Rights reserved. Reproduction in any manner is prohibited. Published
and owned by V. Sekar and published from No.
15, Velu Natchiyar Street, M.G.R. Nagar, Chennai
600 078, and printed by M.S. Ashok at Kadalosai
Achagam, No. 1/1, Bay Arcot Road, Kodambakkam, Chennai - 600 024. Editor : V.SEKAR

vK

Q K
?
?

All Communications / Queries /

Feedbacks to be contacted at
Lawyers Line (Monthly)
72/3, Anand Appartments, Ground Floor,
100 Feet Road, Vadapalani, Chennai -26.
Tel : 044- 23650044, 9841607006
email : info@lawyersline.net
web: www.lawyersline.net

27

All disputes are subject to exclusive

jurisdiction of competent courts and forums in
Chennai only

lawyers line

novemBER - 2012

 c F b

f
.I F , 13&2010
I
GF .
F: 13.04.2010
Q:
FHK F vv
v.I
C.R.P. (NPD) :2009& 4173
M.P. & 2009& 1.
I A G,
x A
,
STS v, , . 194.,
H , H,
. 600001 .......... .
F,
1..I
2. /. ..C.. (v) G
lawyers line

GO F W F
G. , F A,
L v, cAK ... 643243...
J F G ....
HFF.
, cFF
O e 2007& O.S.&4& 2008&
E.P. 15& 2009& E.P. 28& 12.11.2009
M F
F CM .

F H.v., P
F.M.F.
HFF: F.v..
HFF 1&,
:
, cFF
O 2007& O.S. .4& 2008&
novemBER - 2012

E.P. 15& 2009 E.A 28& 12.11.2009

M F F C F
HK 227& W, CM
.
2. 2009& E.A. 28& ,
/K JC CM
O 175& HK 151 CPC
58, XXI & F
F , , K
F 2007& O.S.
4& 2008& E.P. 15& W cFF
H FF
K J MM
. F ,
HFF/,
HFF/bH
A F .
3. cF bO O,
J 12.11.2009 ,
2009& E.A . 28& bH,
WG cF
M .
W: M F F
, AJ
,
A A.
I & .
4. /K
P F.H.v. ,
cF 12.11.2009
M E.A 2009& 28& W F
M
KJ H
KM. f J,
, HFFJ, bH K
. .55,43,870/& . ,
bH KM
HFFJ,
A e
. 12.03.2009& .16,29,57,436/&
KM.
5. W cF, J
A
O, HFF/
b
,
M H
HH P
. K ,
F .

K P,
HFF/b
lawyers line

M KM. F
W A
MM H
H J,
bH J HFF
K .
MM
, e
, , bH FF
J, HFF
. P GF
O
H L , 2002&
HK13(4) 34& (F SARFAESI PH)
cFF F .
6. SARFAESI F HK 13&
HK 4(a) M,
F e K
, P W
O, F
M MM O
K,
KA ,
AJ A
. , HK(1)& P
H , b
PH F
P
O, F
W O
H.
7. /K
A
A HFF
O HC
K.
, M

novemBER - 2012

 , HFFJ
K .
K
8. HFF/bH H. J, SAR P F.S.K. FAESI F HK 34& W CM
, HFF/bH F , HF
. bH , FJ K , Q
M F F M
M M
H. HFF G.
P, HFFJ
12. 21 58(2) CPC &J,
J e MK H
AJ HFGF J
KMM.
F W
Q P,
M,
HFFJ
F e K,
bH
F
FK
M
SARFAESI
P.
H
9.
K
P, CM
,
cFF
K
F
cFF
SARFAESI F HK
.
O.S.
34& cFF
Q A
F
.
. SARFAESI F
F K,
34& HKM

CM cFF
M
F b
bQ, H
f
Q F
bF P
J

OA.
M P
13. A
F
HFF b
F W
, G
L 23.01.2009 HFF /bH
e F
A GF G H C M .
A ,
A F , 1993& W HFFJ 17.09.2004, 05.11.2004
FF 13.06.2005 A FO F
F A .

10. P K.
SARFAESI , 34& HKM, F J 4 9 5 2
F W AP PH O
, C M c F F O, 29.10.2008 31.10.2008
FF eP A O
.
SARFAESI F W
11. F, HF F/ P . ,
bH cF, 12.03.2009 FJ
P F.S.K. , b F , FK
HFF, . F
F F , cFF O
bH MM 2007 OS .4& 2008& E.P.R. 15&

F
W

J 2008-
4-
A
HFF/
b
A
G
HCK.

lawyers line

novemBER - 2012

 M,
F ,
23.01.2009
F

,
KM .
c
, 2008& EPR
.
15&
bH, cF,
M
, A
H
F
F
F F W
H
HK 13(2) W P
CM.
,
,
1961, K F
M
156& HKM W

P
, 29.10.2008
FA.
31.10.2008 A FO,
,

SARFAESI F W
HFF SAR H, C
FAESI F W
, F


.

14. SARFAESI F W
A. SARFAESI

F FI HK
J 2008&
(13(2), (3)
O.S. 4& A
(3&A)&M, HK 13(2) & W
HFF/b
P

F P
A G
,
HCK. 2007
P
P.S. Raman - Senior Advocate
O.S 4& HF
SARFAESI F W
FJ KM
. HFFJ A A. HK 13(13)
HFFJ O HK 13(2)& W PM
MM K . F PM
, HFFJ A. HK 13(2)
b, SARFAESI F 34& HKM W PM. J
W b, ,
. Q, F N M
J e 30.01.2009 A F H K
J, cFF O, HK(13(2)&
J e W PM J
K . Q, b
K AJ F M
HFF/bH M A O
, HFF/b A.
H
16. , FHK cF
, J e F b ,
K F HK13(2)&
A, A MM J b
F K , A
A.
HFF F
15. P 2008(1) MM A.
SCC 125& PM F
17. , 2004(4)
F F Q A M SCC 311& PM Iv
lawyers line

novemBER - 2012

GF F F Q A
SARFAESI , b,
, FHK cFF
P , F HK
13 17& W F,
, HK 13& W
F
/M ,
FI
A. F 34& FJ
W CM cF P
O KMA.
F 34& HK ,
F
f
M ,
F CM cFF FF
. F W
LA. , 1993, A
GF GO
F F
W F W
O FF,

cFF
O OA.
18&2008& E.P. 15& ,
MO ,
W cF O ,
A, , F
O W, 17.09.2004,
05.11.2004 13.06.2005 A FO,

.
, HFF,
MM P,
SARFAESI F W
29.10.2008 31.10.2008 A FO
.
GO 2008(1), SCC 125&
lawyers line

10

FHP cFF bH
( PH), HK 13(2)&
W P, F
SARFAESI F W A
J
. , HF
F, b , b
H O HFF

. A
F
A
F W M
.
19. HFF P,
58CPC 21& W
, f . ,
K
HK 227& W
c . cF
, GF F
, GA F,
F C F HK 227& W,
cFF b
F F. A,
W cF, 58 CPC 27&
F
HH. 21 58 CPC W
f ,
cF M M
AJ
A . Q,
Q Q,
W cF, K ,
HFFO F
M
P
M M. ,
P F ,

novemBER - 2012

K HFF/b
J e K
eP
.
21. A
G F
PH FHK
cFF bH
F , W cFF
SARFAESI
21 58, CM O
MF F G,
O A.
22. , CM
F,
cFF O 2008& E.P.
.15& 2009& E.A. 28& 12.11.2009
W cFF
O A.

A. Q
F I.

N,
.
A,
f ,
SARFAESI F MF
F . F W
M CM cF
F A. ,
HFF/b Q
HFF/bH
O F F
. b
, ,
MM, b G,
M .
AJ SARFAESI F W J e M

SARFAESI F MF
A. SARFAESI F
W AJ
KA.
, HFF/bH
E.P.MO J e
F, K
K M
.
20. 21 58(2) CPC &J ,
cF, ,
J e ,
K , SARFAESI W
J e K K
F

. 12.03.2000&
A , e
.16,29,57,436/& .
MM M F,
HFF/bH
MM M
. Q,
J e K/
E.P.J
M ,
K K
e AM .
29.10.2008 HK (13(2)& W
PM,
b , HFF
, J
GF
. ,
J e
lawyers line

Legal Quotes
Rightful liberty is unobstructed action according to our
will within limits drawn around us by the equal rights of
others. I do not add within the limits of the law because
law is often but the tyrants will, and always so when it
violates the rights of the individual.
- Thomas Jefferson
Music is a moral law. It gives soul to the universe,
wings to the mind, flight to the imagination, and charm
and gaiety to life and to everything.
- Plato
Law and order exist for the purpose of establishing
justice and when they fail in this purpose they become
the dangerously structured dams that block the flow of
social progress.
- Martin Luther King, Jr.
The fundamental law of the militia is, that it be created,
directed and commanded by the laws, and ever for the
support of the laws.
- John Adams
Freedom prospers when religion is vibrant and the
rule of law under God is acknowledged.
- Ronald Reagan

11

novemBER - 2012

lawyers line

12

novemBER - 2012

, J
, c
O
.
C M.
F HC
Q H JKO
. .
MF,
O 20
.
GJ, M
Q, eP

. O, F M
MI,

MF MTP
J F W A.
10, , 1972
e 1975& FF.
FM J
O,
C N G,
F
A
A. F MTP F ,
G
M .
1. F
. (a)
H , ,
,

. J,
J K C
A.
O, E A

MF
. FA
F
L A. F
A F
L
A.
F MFO, I
GO, F
, , WK
O E e
. F

(1) c
E J
F
F (2)
H, I K
I
F
F , . Q
12 , 20
, F
OF
.
2. F .
3. FJ A
.
F P,
?

lawyers line

13

novemBER - 2012

F J G
?
M P
M
A.
, bH, F
cF, L J
, 19 P
CI PJ
A. cF,
MH F
,
eP H K
J b M.
cFF
Q, J K H
. .
bO.
A b F O
PA.
F, F
J,
I K M KY
.
I H GA A,
M Q,
H
F O

lawyers line

14

? M
M .
H J
K F K.
GA
K, M K
K Q K
O A M GA.
H F ,
A.
1. P p
. , C K
J.
2. H H P
H F
A.
3. Q .

. K
F .
.
J
P F .
L
A K .
MF F

. , ,
M
H
MM. J J
I AM.
GJ .
, F H
F
.
Q , M
N.
YN . K
H K F P.
, A P.
F I C.
J C
J J .
A
, L N.
J K
F .
F ,
F M
, H H J
.

novemBER - 2012

News @ Glance
Siblings Murder -

The LandMark Judgement

minds of the criminals and confidence
in the minds of the society, the judge
said.

money laundering
cases against Bharti

Judge of the Mahila Court M.P.

Subramanian on Thursday awarded
double death sentence, three life
terms and three years rigorous imprisonment to R. Manoharan, the
second and lone surviving convict in
the abduction, rape and murder of
two siblings.
Commencing the pronouncement
of verdict in a packed court hall at
around 2.15 p.m., the judge said the
accused during the cross examination under the provisions of 313 of
Criminal Procedure Code (CrPC)
had accepted all that he had stated
in his confessions before the Judicial
Magistrate under the provision of 164
of CrPC.
Judge listed the number of prosecution witnesses who had deposed

in the court for having seen the second accused with the first accused
and the victim children. He said the
prosecution had sought the highest
punishment so as to serve as a deterrent, while the defence counsel had
cited that the age of the accused, his
family back ground and aged parents
as mitigating circumstances for reducing the quantum of punishment.
Though the court was agreeable to
the circumstances cited by the defence, Judge said that considering
the nature and gravity of the offence
committed, said that it would not be
fair on the part of the court to show
any mercy on the convict.
He awarded life term and Rs
1,000 fine for the offences of conspiracy, abduction and rape besides
three years RI for the offence of
concealment of evidence while the
highest punishment of double death
came for the murder of the siblings.
However, the sentences would run
concurrently, the judge said. He
added that the period detention/trial
period shall be set off against the
conviction under section 428 Criminal
Procedure Code.
Sentence should instil fear in the
lawyers line

15

novemBER - 2012

The Enforcement Directorate is

conducting investigations on money
laundering cases against Indias largest telecom service provider, Bharti
Airtel, according to Minister of State
for Finance SS Palanimanickam.
Directorate of Enforcement
is investigating cases under the
provisions of Prevention of Money
Laundering Act, 2002, and Foreign
Exchange Management Act, 1999,
involving M/s Bharti Airtel Ltd, he
wrote in a reply to a question in the
parliament.
As a result, the shares of the
company fell as much as 5 per cent
to touch an intraday low of Rs 291.90
on Tuesday on news of investigations. The
shares of
the company were
trading at
Rs 300.40,
down 2.29
per cent on
the domestic stock exchange. The total trading
volumes increased 126 per cent to
3,45,096 shares.
Bharti said that it was corporate
investigations and said that it has
already provided all the information
asked for by the relevant authorities
in the investigations. The company
also said in a statement that it will
continue to cooperate further in the
inetigations.
The company has a pan India
presence in telecom services and
sells its series under the band `Airtel.
The company also offers services in
several other countries, including
those in Africa.

, C
F 32 226& W,
, K
F Y M, C
cF LF
PH MA. 32&
J, H..
P. C F
PH I
A K L
...........
C I M.
M
PH ... C F
,
, C F
32& P M
H.. P
P M G.
,
C
CJ I A
EP H..
M C K
GA.
32& (2), cFF

cF

cFF,

FK

L
.
F H,
F W
L
L K

cF
& MK

lawyers line

16

novemBER - 2012

,
F
A. , , ,
F M

. F CH III F
O K
P K F
. 226&
(1),
K ,
32& (2) cF F
A cFF
A. Q 226& M HK
Q, P,
F
cF
F A.
v
PA. cF
, cFF
cFF, FK,
G
M
. F
M A C
F 553& F, ..,
cF ,
F, WcFF
F, ,
,
PH C K
G P
F. HQ GF F
CQ A, 2005(6) SCALE-435,
cF, cF
I , GE
Q G
F . ,
L
P.
..v, FM G
O e F
L 364& F,
cF ,
F, ( Q
)
C O
cF
F
PHA. O,
MA.
K, K
K G
lawyers line

F FF,
M K
. , K
G F
GJ K K
P,
M cF
M K
F K
PWS&S F T CA
A (2007) 2 SCC 491) cF.
cF ,
FKJ e,
K,
K
P. FH
GF F K L (AIR
2004 SC 3800) T.H. F .C..
GF (AIR, 2003 SC 1764) , d
.T. GF F M.CU
CA (AIR 1977 SC 2149) .v.
Q F
K (AIR 1966 SC 334)
F H GF F
M (AIR 1954 SC 493) A
O cF
b A.
cF
cFF,
FK
L . F
K GF F
NO F (AIR 1952
SC 179) .M.. F
GF , (AIR 1967 SC 993)
AP, b bO
MF P,
M M
KYL
cF P F
Q F v.H.M A,
( AIR 2004 SC 1402) c F
M G
.
G
G
O
cF P. vF
vK C GF F
F QQ A, (AIR 1975 SC 46)
G
F, A
cF
cG A. ,
17

novemBER - 2012

 G L
M H
. F Q F
Aw J A, AIR 2004 SC 1194 ,
cF M
, F K
L
WG b FK
F
cF
MA. F d
GF A, AIR 1973 SC 964
.v.. Q F
C M FKJ A, AIR
1966 SC 334 cF
H .
L
, F H,
F W
L L K
H . bO
J, cF ,
FKJ e
L ,
G FK
, b
cF A.
cF ,

C
K E
M G
O
PH .
v G M
F C.. K
A, AIR 2004 SC 561,
cF
FKO
,

cF J
. MK
, ,
G M

226& W F
, N
J ,
FIP HH

C MF F
cFJ

lawyers line

18

HH
. K
F F RTA I A
AIR 1978 SC 209 bF

FK J
cF
cF bO.
cF
,
O cF

. , C C F
CA A, AIR 1976 SC 2216
d .C. GF F
CU C A, AIR 1977 SC 2149
F
L
cF PM. H
v F F L
A AIR 1969 SC 1306
H Q G
cF
c P
,
FK F

novemBER - 2012


,
PH MA. Q
G F F CA
AIR 1980 SC 1306 G
F KAw K ,
AIR 1966 SC 1081 F
v GF , AIR 1961 SC 1731
AP MK , F
IP ,
AM. F H G
F M A AIR 1954
SC 493 cF ,
F A
F A .
M,
C O W cF
. H
F G A, AIR
1970 SC 769 , Q
, M
A
. M F
K A, AIR 1962 SC
1796 cF
i

M
.

,
. cF M
cF P. H v
F L A,
AIR 1969 SC 1306 , cF ,
F O
M
GF F
cF P.
F F x F LT
, GA, Q H, U
HF A AIR 1971 SC 2399
PH
.
F H F .H
O A, AIR 2008 SC 3176
NOJ
, cF
cF
cF P, Q
C F FA.
G F
MJ A, 2006 AIR SCW
1991, F FC
MF e
GF


cF P.
, F eP
F
F wHF
F,
cF
K MH.
I F
GF A, AIR 1954 SC 592
cF P
PH MA.
, K
e F,
G
FK,
K.
C, ,
K e
K A
F G
M.

lawyers line

19

novemBER - 2012

 c F b

2008 CRILJ 1484 w
J F F H
GF
F H cF
(L )
Q :
2 U
N.K. J.J.
(M )
Crl., A. . 4 2 , 2 0 0 0 ,
D/14.12.2007.
bF
& F

& GJ
,

KM P
M
&
F J
PMM
cF
FJ F
M & FH ..
,
H
.
F M
FK K
P G
A.
, ,
M
, M
GO C
M.
,

F J
A.
.

OK F
, Q GO
Q M
GJ
M F F .

lawyers line

20

novemBER - 2012

A.K.J &
M.P.S.K P.P.HF
F
b:
U :
HFF 374&
HK Cr. P.C.& W, H..
302 HKM W
.1000/&

MF ,
F H
F
23.12.1999
v M
5/92& b
F f
.
2. F, A

Q,
M
F
.
J
. F
,
M
. 28.8.1991
4 E
M
M i
.
, W O,
e P,
, H A
M. H M
GF
6.10 EM

lawyers line

21

... F .
H
,
K ,
5.15 E
M ..v
L (P.N.3)
F
. H
4.9.1991 M
. H K
, M.v.
K (P.W.6)
. F
, P M
, FK
. M
J ,

,
M
Q, ,
A .

J F
,
bJ F
P. M
cF,

.H.. 302& HKM W,
O
P
O.
F
f F .
3. f
H PO
, FM
, Q
.
P, A, K
C I,
..vL
( P.W.3) F
F
J b
P.
,
F F
,
A .
F
FK.

novemBER - 2012

Q, L 5.15 E F
H, P
5.30 E
H.
... 6.10 E F
. F ...
KA.
,
, KA. , M cF
, cA
M. Q, F C
C ,
,
. J F
,

H.
K
A.
K
G P KMM.
, GJ
KMM.
K P
F,
A. M C
F d GF (AIR 2001 SC
2124) : (2001 Cri LJ 2556) I v
APv F GF
(AIR 2002 SC 2996): (2002 Cri LJ 3917)
A O b
. ..vL
(P.W.3) C MC, b
C F d GF
(AIR 2002 SC 526) : (2002 Cri LJ 973)
F GF
(AIR 2003 SC 265): (2003 Cri LJ 441) A
O b .
, , ,
J F,
cFF
F
C M P,
F w GF
(AIR 1971 SC953): (1971 Cri LJ 798)
, C
O CJ
P. L
W

K L HM
. F

. 10
lawyers line

22

C
M M. F
, IP O b
. , M
F .
4. F J, HFF
F P M cFF
b K, b
P CO J
P. b
F J
. M cFF,
F H
MKF I
P. F P, q
M F F H GF
(2006) 10 SCS 178) : (2006 Cri LJ3301)
M F I GF
(2006) 9 SCS 240 : (2006 Cri LJ 1625)
C F K
GF (2004) 13 SCC 204: (2006 Cri LJ
1409) A A b
f GI

H.
5. , A
C
FH C F
KM. K
(P.W.1.) N
F C. ,
F PJ,
,
H K. H
J M M OP
M. M.
M cF, ..v
L (P.W.3) F
F C K
P,
KF
cFFJ F M
I MC. ,
M cF, F ,
S.32 & W,
cFFJ F
MF
J, J
M GK. (P.W.2)
C.
, K .
F OJ i
vFK . ,
FH K, M.
novemBER - 2012

 (P.W.4) v
H C (Ex. P/6)
v H e

,
F K
F
K
PM. ,
FH K
M. (P.W.5.)
i.
FH K
M. A (P.W.6)
K
F
H KM.
xK (P.W.10)
K K.
FH K
M.
6. A
K C
GJ,

.
cFFJ F
, F
.
F M Q,

F

,
?
J
b? .
7. bO cF
M
L,
GO



,
cF F

O A.
M C F d
GF A (AIR 2001
SC 2124: ( 2001 Cri LJ 2556),
cF W
.
cF

F A (
HF F F
H GF ,
AIR 1953 SC 420 : (1953 Cri LJ
1772)
cFF b

F w G
F A (AIR
1962 SC 130 : (1962 (1) Cri LJ
196) ,
F
J, F K

. Q
O
M M
.
AIR 1976 SC 2199 : (1976
Cri LJ 1718) & KM
A ( M
F F H G)
. F cF
P:&
,
MK
, I K
Q
b
K ,
, IP

M MF
, F MF

A. , cF
F

FC G
M,

F.
16. , .F
F F
PK A , AIR
1976 SC 1994 : (1976 Cri LJ
1548) cF Q
K.

I, HK 32& W
F. ,
MJ gC
, F H
F W
lawyers line

23

novemBER - 2012

 , cF
I , b
, H F e
.
Q O F
. Q, J
I
L L
F
, cF F A
C. Q,
, ,

J
O . cF,
FO

P, H, GJ
OFA F
. ,
M , MIP,
OFA F
.
Q O P
H, cF IP
b.
cFFJ,
J, M & F J,
, OK
F
, Q GO
Q M GJ

M F F
. F
KF cF
G F
lawyers line

24

. , J
QQ , ,
M ,
O , O
J, K
, Q GJ
eP O G
F. FM M,
O
AF, F
FK
, A F
,
H L
(AIR 1958 SC 22 : (1958) Cri LJ 106)
Q .
8. F w GF
A (AIR 1971 SC 953: (1971 Cri LJ 798)
cF W .
, , cF
F F . ,
M. Q
GJ ,
, cFF
.
2 E P
H . cFF
. P
GJ, G
, cFF
C H
.
9.M F I
GF A (2006) 9 SCC 240: (2006
Cri LJ 1625) C ,
F J b
, Q
F . L,
L

cF A.
GJ , O

, cF H
H .
H,
K MA H, K
F H, cFF
WK F ,
.
C F K
GF A (2004) 13 SCC 264: (2004
Cri LJ HK 32(1) M MF
O M .
novemBER - 2012


MJ .
F,

. , F
FJ M MF
A cF P.
q M F F H
GF A (2006) 10SCC 718: (2006
Cri LJ 3301) P
H ,
J F b cF
P. G,
. ,
M ,
.
q M F F H
GF A (2006)10 SCC 718: (2006
Cri LJ 3301), P
H ,
J F b cF
P. G,
.
M ,
.
10. bH, F
F F
J F M
MF , FK
e H I
K .
Q, O M
. C Q
G K,
F, H
,
.
cF, L ,
F, F,

F . G
, GJ, O
F cF
O . ,
A, MF
F M F C
.
11. F
..v
5.15 E F F
. M G
. ML
. F
F Ex P/5. , ,
lawyers line

G ,
F P. ,
F
G PHM.
GJ,
O , P
. MJ ,
F
J KMM
. G I

F
cFF
KMM .
12. A,
A

F (Ex P/5) J
.
FM.
Q G
M. H
M. J K
M
F
cFF M.
F
G, GJ
, P F
FJ M. FK P
F, , Q
G, Q,
OA FJ
.
13. M.v. (P.N.6)
H K F, 70-&80%
b P P.
25

novemBER - 2012

b AK
, , b
HM .
F ,
. b H,
GJ, ? ? F
KM M.
, 80% b
H J
KM.
, M
M.
KM
M.
, b H
G
O, J 7
, GJ
KM
M. FK O,
G
GJ

. F
, K
I FC.
14. P (Ex D/4)
GH v x C
(P.W.3) MK.
H CgM GF
.
b KM.
FF v.. (D.W.1) LK
J GA
, 6.1.1989,
,
KF, CA O.
K Ex D/2 .
, 5&6
F ,
K GJ
M KM.
I
A.

P MA. K K
M M.
K E. M
. ,

GJ MCF .
,
P F
. , J
lawyers line

26

F, MCF
F F O.
.H., HF F
CA EP
, F
, G
M P, LK
K
P. , O
I ,
M
.

P. M cF P
O ,
CA HM
10 F
K
F, M M
. , FK ,
GO M .
KA.
F,
FA.
, C FK
. F
C KM. Q
F C (P.W.2,
P.W.1., P.W.8 P.W.10,
MJ
F . ,
, F
K P
, M. P
. , P C
J ,

F.
15. ..H.v. (P.W.9) .
F
cFFJ M M
. K
F
M P.
K 161 Cr P.C HKM W
F , ,
K F, ,
O M J
K P
M P. ,
F
G
O
KA. A.
novemBER - 2012

 cFF
F C
M.
F F .
, FC Q,
K FF .
M . (Ex P/5 &
FF KMM.
J K
C. I.O F
F ,
K O
GJ K
P F
M. I.O , K K
KM
KM. , K
, , ,
K M
. ,
F, F

lawyers line

M. F GH
PM. ... L
F
K
P M I.O
L ... F
H, K
P. , F
F
P K M
M.
, v...(H)
J W
M ,
A M P.
16. P J,
O C: FF
v.. (D.W.1)
.H. (D.W.2) A,
K F
H J
I A.
F
.
O
M, MCF F, H
F
M
G .
O KMM.
F, F
. , L
M. ..
FH
,
F M
FK K J
P G
H. J
, O
CA L
G P F ,
H C CA O
H F .
, A, F F
L 5.15& F
, H G P F
5.30& H ...
6.10 E F .
, F F
. , F A,
I A FM
27

novemBER - 2012

F F
.
17. G
,
A
GO
J,
.
G
FM
KA.
, H M.

c
I. ,

.

A.
18. P MO
J, M cF
F F

O
J
. , F
, ,
F
GH PM
A.
F,
, F
H G
. F
H
M.

O GJ
,

GH
FM
. , F

.
19.P MO
J,
O , f
A.
f M
MA.
F
M M
.

News @ Glance
No mercy for students of
unrecognised institutions

The Supreme Court told Students

who are getting admission in educational
institutions without verifying whether they
are recognised or not are to be blamed
themselves, by refusing sympathy with
them.
A bench of justices K S Radhakrishnan and Dipak Misra refused to
grant recognition to a Madhya Pradeshbased institute and turned down its plea to sympathise with students as they
would suffer if recognition is not granted.
The students who take admission are not young in age.

Man to pay Rs 1.5 lakh as Monthly

Maintenance to wife and minor son

The Delhi High Court rejected the

claim of a husband that he is a poor
son of wealthy parents and directed
him to pay an interim allowance of Rs
1.5 lakh per month to his wife and son
as maintenance.
Justice PK Bhasin awarded Rs
1.5 monthly interim maintenance to
the wife and rejected the plea of the
husband.
Considering two letters written by
the husband during the pre-litigation
period that he has been paying Rs
1.5 lakh as pocket money to his wife
and son, Justice Bhasin trashed his
plea that it was a typing error as the
amount was infact Rs 15,000 per
month.
The court considered the fact that
the husband himself is claiming that
he had been paying a sum of Rs 1.5
lakh to the wife and upheld that the

lawyers line

28

novemBER - 2012

same amount be paid till the final

hearing of the matter.
The court agreed to the womens
plea who said that the man belongs
to a wealthy family but does not want
to pay maintenance to her.
The women, who married the man
in 2004 said the family had a lavish
life style as the couple had gone to
Australia, New Zealand and Thailand
for honeymoon.
The court rejected the mans plea
that he is the only son of a wealthy
parents but himself is a poor man
earning Rs 2 lakhs per annum.
The court also rejected the husbands plea that he has been disowned by parents saying that his
parents have not come forward to
say that because the bickering of their
son and daughter-in-law they have
disowned him.

Q K

? ?
F
G C
J
FKJ

F K
.
O,
G

Q K , 1993&
HK 2& Q K
Q K , F, K
FH K.
O
H W FO
FM cF L
.
, C K
e 1966,
16 A O J
,
K e
.
F W F
M?
W O
,
a) W P ,
lawyers line

29

novemBER - 2012

Q F
H
K K M
.
(i) Q K e b
.
(ii) e ,
C .
(b) cFF , ,
Q K e
MO,
cFF F J.
(c) G O H,
G C
C
G , F CA, Y
F A

F, OO
G ,
K .
(d) H
W L , Q K
H, , P
FI
K.
(e) bM , Q K
M
, K GF
K.
(f) Q KO e
, P
FI K.
(g) Q KO J
.
(h) F FO
Q K M H H,
, A
N , KO H
P MN
.
(i) G
G Q K J
M.
(j) Q KO F
C
.
M
F F ?
F W
MKJ, 1908,
F W MK KJ
cFF F
.
lawyers line

30

W I A, .
(a) CO
LF, J W
MK.
(b) H,
H.
(c) FO e
.
(d) cF F
F
P .
(e) C O
, F .
(f) K MF
.

A? , Q K e
O MK, J

N
. F W, F
G C J
FKJ
F K .
O, G
.
, Q
, AJ,
H GI ,
O M GJ,
, F,

novemBER - 2012

M F NK
&
F GI.
F GFJ Q F
32& HKM .
F H
, H FK ,
., , M
FCJ , xM
FC x M
A H
M KJ J,
FFJ GI.
MK ?
Q KO eO M
K , PH
F, W F
G H
GF,
P , ,
P PH F
M Q,
MK . ,
P ,
M
J
F
M FF ,
,
OK P
KMM.

lawyers line

M , W
O .
1) MJ , Q K
e , Q
K e F
Q C
F K,
F,
F M

K
A K.
2) cF cF
, ,
cF
GA
.
3) F
H, FC
L G
K
FK K.
F
W K ...
O, Q K
e, O
J Q
, F C
P . P
H, MK,
, K
KM. F, F
F, KO K
P
F
F KM.
MF F
K J

P HK. PJ
O.
UF, A H
FF K
NJ . O
FA. O
e MFF.
,
A,
F
. MK K,
v
IL
. F CJ
E .
31

novemBER - 2012

, W
F.
(a)
G
.
(b) F W M P.
(c) O, , .
(d) .
(e) K P.
F
P/K F/G/
F O ?
F/F /G ,
/, F,
P/KO e,
F
O
K KM.
KO K
?
,
.
O A :&

lawyers line

32

* J G P
* P
* G
*
* H
* M
* J K
* C
*
* C F ,
CJ G.
* J
H e .
* , NO
* F.
* F .
*
, .
* , N
.
* L
,
HC.
* HK
.
F A

F O
MK I A.
O Q ,
K eF HKMK
K ,
FK FI K
.
Q , Q
, ,
G
A
A A
Q K K F
A. Q K
O MK L, F
F, P, i
O
.
F , KJ
C, ,
K HK
. bM
, C , N
, YF C
, C ,
A O
C A.
novemBER - 2012

, F, J c,
F
L
G ,
M, F ,
, FK K
G , F

N, LF A.
FO K,
N, Y
C H F
,
, Q, K,
O K,
L F
CJ K,
O F
.
A
* KJ F
* bM
F, MF
bM , 2000& (
) .
* bM FO
Q K .
* JK F
wH
MF.
* G/ J
O Q KO .
* CJ ,
N
N.
* F
, Q N

* F
F e M.
* , C
H O FI Y
F.
* C,
H G F.
* Q K e ,

.
* ,
K.
* K
N c.
* J
HH C
.
lawyers line

* ..M./v F
Q K.
* Q KO
M .
* F O K.
* , C
J,
O K.
* H F
.
* IK K O
A A F
.
* cF FJ W, C,
L P

P E.
* F
.
* LO K F
.
* PH, J
K K.
* M .
* Q F c.
* Q K M MN
M F
F .
* ,
FK KJ
Q K JC.
* H M G
.T..O Q K
K .
* F P, F F
, F FK
P HK.
* Q K HC e
.T. G/C
.

P F,
, A.
I F K,
A.

72/3, v,
, Q, & 26
C : 044 & 2365 0044
33

novemBER - 2012

FK F
FF M P F
M .
CJ . FK F P. K,
K P. F C FK
F.

A
cF, ,
F, P
, A
. C PA. C
A. FF
C F, F,
F F

F . F QQ
HK. F AO
,
AO M O
.
QQ G. O
Y, ALJ

. F . M
, Q F
P . H 499
v F
H P v. P
F .
P c
lawyers line

34

& E

CF, .
, Q A.
c L P C
. v O
A .
M
J.
F
F K F
F CJ
. FF
F. F ?
F K F F
. Q A
. C
M eP H
. .
FM .
. MF.
K A
FJ F
.
FO
. K
novemBER - 2012

K F
CH. O
K K
CF K
CF YA ,
,
K
I F .
,
F
, P
C K.

. F
A.
. 1950
K 26& F F
A. .
300 A C
A. F
A A,

F. F
F C
N O A. F
P. K P
K
P.
O
.
C F, FM H
L J
. M F F
M
MH. A
K , ,
, K .
A FJ ,
F.
C M

A.
Y .
F F
A
.
C F .
FF
H .
1976 cFF
K P
bH M
P
F
M
lawyers line

.
CJ
. FK F
P. K,
K P.
F C
FK
F. F
M .
E FK
F .
A M C
F
K
, K P
.
. e M
. AK
U F C G
G H vC
H . F
F AM
C H U.
MF. C ,
K.
F F O
FK F.
E . P F
H W.
FK C
MF I A.
F,
M,
FK
. F L
C C ,
FKO M A
. F
T M
CJ
O. .
IF Av
F K N
F 6
C . K
F
6 C
C Av
C.
FM GF
..
L M
F
F
35

novemBER - 2012

C FK. M FK
I
F. E c
. KTv HC
KTv 1967& 7 C
E . E L
M M FK 7
C e K
, F C L
P
M F H
A . 67&
C H.
O Av C
FK e .
1954
..M O H

Av
1969& M. K
J .
J F C
H M .
J
F . i
M. J
Fd ,
K M.
GF , FK
. FC
YM M L A,
c Al G
G
M
YM 20 A
F .
, C C H
. FK
.

. F
F,
F
C C H
Q ?

C ? eF ...
CJ 4 H I
F FK
MF M A.
F M
K ... , FK
A.
A ? .F... CJ
lawyers line

36

, LM
Q M A.
M I FC
. F H
c M
? m?
F ,
E M,
C E
, E
KM, EJL MA
KM. CQM
, AM
? K
F ? Q

E G ?
J .
.T.. I
.T... .T. A.
. .T..
FJ F
. C
.

A .T.
.
.T.. .
K C
I G
A.
C F FM.
FK G
. ,
F QQ K
. K, K, M
. ,
CJ .

novemBER - 2012

lawyers line

37

novemBER - 2012

lawyers line

38

novemBER - 2012