Professional Documents
Culture Documents
1. INTRODUCTION
Fiber reinforced reactive powder concrete under the brand name Ductal has not only out of range unique mechanical properties but also strong durability. Because of the ultra high compressive, bending and tensile strength, the concrete bridge made of this material can enormously reduce the dead weight and this results in that the dimension of the foundation becomes very small. Therefore the total construction cost of the bridge can be probably reduced depending on the bridge span or the soil condition though, compared with the pre-stressed concrete bridge using the ordinary concrete. Additionally, the life cycle cost of the bridge made of this material can also be reduced because of the strong durability. The actual applications of reactive powder concrete have been done by around 20 projects in the world and two of them were the bridge construction [1], [2]. In this paper, the design and construction process of Sakata-Mirai Footbridge, which is the first application in Japan, are discussed to establish the future guideline for design and construction. The span of Sakata-Mirai Footbridge is 50m and the width is 2.4m. Taking account of the efficient application of mechanical advantages of Ductal, Sakata-Mirai Footbridge was designed as a boxed type cross section with perforated webs, therefore the self-weight super-structure resulted in about 1/4 of the ordinary pre-stressed concrete bridge. In order to verify the new conceptual design method, the fundamental beam test with/without wet joint beam loading experiments as well as the prototype model loading experiments have been conducted. Furthermore, the mixing process of an ordinal mixing batch plant and the casting control methodology has been confirmed using the prototype segments.
2.2 Mechanical properties o The mean compressive strength value of Ductal is 238MPa with 90 C heat treatment for 48 hours. Figure 1 shows a typical load bending stress-deflection graph of a beam under three-point loading. The o specimen beam is 4x4x16cm in size and it is cured for 48 hours in 90 C. The flexure property exhibits
417
418
Session 1
The design flow chart for Sakata-Mirai Footbridge is illustrated in Fig. 2. The service limit states (SLS) and the ultimate limit states (ULS) are considered. The tensile members due to SLS are not allowed to generate any cracks, on the other hand the tensile members due to ULS are allowed to generate cracks but they have to sustain the ultimate limit state load by bridging steel fibers. The finite displacement and non-linear FEM Fig. 2 Design flow chart for Sakata-Mirai Footbridge analyses consi dering the materialconstitutive laws were conducted for the detailed check of ultimate limit states. In order to effectively proceed the design calculation, a preliminary design and a detailed design are separated for each step. Especially for the perforated webs and the anchorage for the pre-stressing tendons, nonlinear FEM analysis is most effective way to solve the problem.
Fig. 3
Photo 1
Fig. 4
3.3 Structural concept From a point of view of the first class river management and the prevention of boats crush accidents, old piers for bridge had better be removed and one long span bridge is chosen to design. Because of the three restrictions described above, the bridge height at both ends should be less than 55cm. Therefore the lower deck typed bridge was taken into consideration. However, as the cross section is open, then the web is weak for buckling and the torsional rigidity will be lack for pre-stressing or wind loads. Finally, the upper deck typed bridge with variable height webs and closed box type cross section has been decided to design. The general view of whole bridge is illustrated in Fig. 3 and the schematic
419
f fu b u
0.16 1.25
f c tan u
2/3
F tu b nS t
(3)
sin 2 u u 30 o
(4)
tan 2 u = 2 u / ( xu tu)
(5)
where u = maximum shear stress in the section at ULS, ffu = tensile strength characteristic value contributed by steel fibers (=-5MPa), b = safety factor (=1.3), Ftu = transversal pre-stressing, bn = width of the web, St = spacing of transversal pre-stressing, u = angle between the cracking plane and the o axis of the web and its value should be greater than 30 , xu and tu = compressive stress at ULS due to
420
Session 1
the longitudinal and transversal pre-stressing.
Fig. 5
Fig. 6
Verification of ULS
3.5 FEM analyses considering perforated web For the detailed design step, 3 dimensional FEM analyses for 1/2 modeling whole structure taking into account of the circular holes on the web have been conducted. Elastic FEM analysis is employed for SLS and non-linear finite displacement 3 dimensional FEM analysis for ULS. The results of those analyses make it clear that the circular hole effects on the stress field in the web. The results are also used for the check of wet joint stress, the deflection in the middle span of the bridge due to the live load and the effects of the deviators on the final maximum load resistant capacity. FEM analysis code is DIANA and the material constitutive laws are illustrated in Fig. 7 and Fig. 8. The longitudinal stress distributions near the middle of the bridge span with/without the circular holes are illustrated in Fig. 9 for SLS. It is our design rule that the wet joint connecting longitudinal direction; that is segment block 1L and 1R, can not sustain any tensile stresses at all. The longitudinal stress distribution without the circular holes is just linearly changing along the web height, on the other hand one with circular holes is observed as follows; i.e. 1) on the middle center of the holes, the longitudinal stress distribution increases near the hole edges, 2) however on the middle line between one hole and another, the longitudinal stress distribution reversely decreases near the middle height of web. It is verified that all stresses along the wet joint are compressive even for the case of the circular holes. The maximum deflection Fig. 7 Constitutive law in tension in the middle of span is 85mm that satisfies deflection/span ratio 1/600.
421
Fig. 8
Fig. 9
4.1 Mixing, casting and curing Various kinds of mixing and casting experiments using the molds for beams, plates and shells have been carried out considering the control of the fiber orientation. Before producing the prototype pre-cast segment blocks, the verification experiments of mixing, casting and curing have been conducted to make the prototype scale specimens for the verification loading experiments; i.e. one specimen is similar to segment block 3L or 3R, another specimen is similar to segment block 2L or 2R. The segment blocks 3L or 3R are composed of two symmetrical blocks that are Fig. 10 Load factor and deflection divided half at the center of the cross section. Therefore, two symmetrical blocks should be connected together by wet joint with 30mm width and lateral pre-stressing before connecting with segment blocks 3L and 2L. 3 The type of the mixer is a pan type with 45kW motor and its volume capacity is 1.75m . Half segment block 3L was cast into the metallic mold using hopper and tremie method. The segment specimen block 2L was also cast in the same way into the metallic mold. The mold for specimen block 2L has some circular holes in the web and its holes are made from sthylene foam. The inner mold for specimen block 2L is fixed with the outer mold by bolts through the circular holes. Photo 2 demonstrates the segment
422
Session 1
specimen block 2L for the load carrying experiment. o After preliminary curing was performed for 48 hours at 30 C, the segment specimen was released o from the metallic mold and it was continuously performed 48 hours heat treatment at 90 C. The segment specimen 3L being connected by wet joint and lateral pre-stressing, it was longitudinally prestressed by two sets of big 31S15.2 tendon, where one tendon was sustaining 3,700kN/tendon by force. 4.2 Wet join The wet joint in comparison with the dry joint does not need the match cast process in producing pre-cast segment blocks. The past records of wet joint are not so many, so it is necessary to verify the construction process and the structural performance. Photo 3 indicates just after jointing laterally two symmetrical blocks by 1S12.7 mono-strand, that supplies about 100kN/tendon pre-stressing force. The gap of wet joint is 30mm and Ductal is poured inside the gap. Both end of the connecting surface to the pre-cast blocks possess a couple of shear cotter to transform shear force each other.
Photo 2
Segment block 2L
Photo 3
Fig. 11
423
6. CONCLUDING REMARKS
Unique and exceptional design has been proposed taking into account of full advantages of material characteristics, which has never accomplished by the ordinary pre-stressed concrete. It makes it possible to reduce the dead weight to 1/4 compared with the ordinary concrete and this will extremely reduce the size of the pier foundation, hence the total cost will be 8~10% reduced. Through the various kinds of material and structural experiments, the fundamental design method has been clarified and the design result has been verified. Sakata-Mirai Footbridge is now under construction and it will be completed in September 2002. It should be noted that the design and construction management rules for Ductal should be further developed through the actual construction process in the future. From the point of view of the life cycle cost, the long term monitoring of this bridge is also necessary to accumulate the field data of durability. This project has been proceeded under the judge and the recommendation by Technical Committee of Bridge Construction Applying New Material (chairman: Prof. Ikeda, Yokohama National University) organized by Co-operative Council of university-government-company in Shounai County sponsored by Yamagata prefecture. We deeply express our gratitude to the people involved in this project.
REFERENCE
[1] Adeline, R., and Cheyrezy, M. : The Sherbrooke Footbridge : the first RPC structure, FIP 98, Amsterdam, May 1998. [2] Etienne, D., Causse, M. and Behloul, M. : Design and building of Seoul Peace Footbridge, Third International Arch Bridge Conference, Paris, pp. 865-876, Sept. 2001. [3] Cheyrezy, M. : Structural applications of RPC, Proc. of the International Conf. New Technologies in Structural Engr., Lisbon, Vol.1 pp.5-14, July 1997. [4] Behloul, M. : Design rules for DUCTAL pre-stressed beam. Technical Information from Bouygues, pp. 1-15, Feb. 2000.
424