You are on page 1of 12

FIRSTPOSTYOUSPEAKFAKING NEWS Firstpost Read More

Mumbai 27

Lokpal live: Anna takes on AAP, asks if they have read bill 161 Comments Between Delhi polls and Lokpal, Kejriwal is politically vulnerable 459 Comments
FRONT PAGE Politics Sports India World Business Economy Investing Life Bollywood Tech Blogs PLUSFirstvote Half Stories United States United Kingdom Photos Videos Archive Mobile Apps Firstpost World

Sign in see more

Fukushima disaster: Japan incapable of decommissioning plant


by Ayeshea Perera Dec 15, 2013 #Dai-Ichi plant #Fukushima disaster #Japan #NewsTracker #Nuclear disaster #Nuclear Regulation Authority #Tsunami #World Tw eet 10 Share Like 1 0 Share 3 CommentsEmailPrint Japan is incapable of safely decommissioning the devastated Fukushima nuclear plant alone and must stitch together an international team for the massive undertaking, experts say, but has made only halting progress in that direction. Unlike the US and some European countries, Japan has never decommissioned a full-fledged reactor. Now it must do so at the Fukushima Dai-Ichi plant. Three of its six reactors melted down after the 2011 earthquake and tsunami, making what is ordinarily a technically challenging operation even more complex. The cloud over Japan's capacity to get the decades-long job done has further undermined the image of the nuclear industry with the public. Opinion surveys show a majority of Japanese are opposed to restarting 50 reactors that were put offline for safety and other checks in the aftermath of the disaster. Japan has been forced to import oil and gas to meet its power needs, burdening its already feeble economy.

The Fukushima nuclear plant: AP "Even for the US nuclear industry, such a cleanup and decommissioning would be a great challenge," said Akira Tokuhiro, a University of Idaho professor of mechanical and nuclear engineering who is among those calling for a larger international role at Fukushima. Decommissioning a nuclear power plant normally involves first bringing the reactor cores to stable shutdown, and then eventually removing them for long-term storage. It is a process that takes years. Throughout, radiation levels and worker exposure must be monitored.

At Fukushima, there is the daunting challenge of taking out cores that suffered meltdown, which is the most dangerous type of nuclear power accident. Their exact location within the reactor units isn't known and needs to be ascertained so their condition can be analyzed. That will require development of nimble robots capable of withstanding high radiation. The lack of experts is worse at the regulatory level. The tally is zero. Japan's Nuclear Regulation Authority has no one devoted to decommissioning, said spokesman Juntaro Yamada, though it has experts dealing with the ongoing removal of fuel rods from one of the Fukushima reactor units. Its predecessor organization was criticized after the Fukushima disaster for being too close to the nuclear industry, so the members chosen for the new agency launched last year don't have direct ties to the industry to ensure their objectivity. The government-funded Nuclear Energy Safety Organization, which is to be folded into the regulatory authority to beef up its expertise, has one expert on decommissioning, a person who studies overseas regulations on the process. The group mainly helps with routine nuclear plant inspections, but since the 2011 catastrophe has been involved with bringing the Fukushima plant under control. In contrast, the US Nuclear Regulatory Commission has 10 people devoted to decommissioning including four project managers, four health physicists, and a hydro-geologist. It says it has the equivalent of more than 200 years of experience in decommissioning and has overseen the termination of 11 power reactors and 13 research reactors. France has decommissioned nine reactors, and its regulatory agency has seven decommissioning experts at the national level, and 10 more at the local level. Lake Barrett, a retired nuclear engineer who took part in decommissioning Pennsylvania's Three Mile Island after the meltdown of its reactor core in 1979, was hired as a consultant by Fukushima operator Tokyo Electric Power Co. He visits about once a year or so to give advice, and is not assigned daily to the job. The cleanup at Fukushima would be more difficult than Three Mile Island because the damage is more numerous, involving three reactors instead of one, and more serious because of the greater damage from the bigger explosions. Barrett said one reason he wanted to help Fukushima was that Japanese engineers had helped out at Three Mile Island. He had asked about their whereabouts but got no answers. He fears they are all retired or working in other industries. "The most challenging area is skilled nuclear engineers and managers that can plan, integrate and communicate effectively in Japanese," he said. Japan's nuclear program started later than the U.S. and it has scrapped only a small test reactor. Five reactors are in various stages of decommissioning, including two experimental reactors and three commercial ones. The furthest along is Tokai Power Station's No. 1 reactor, which is 15 years into a planned 22-year process. About 70 experts are working on the decommissioning, but the experience gained with Japan's oldest reactor is not directly transferable to Fukushima. The decommissioning of two reactors similar to Fukushima's began in 2009 at Hamaoka nuclear power plant west of Tokyo, but it is in the early stages and is expected to take nearly 30 more years. It took until August this year, nearly two and half years after the tsunami, for Japan to set up the International Research Institute for Nuclear Decommissioning, to bring together ideas, both inside and outside Japan, on Fukushima decommissioning and encourage communication. Tokuhiro, who has more than 20 years in the nuclear design and safety fields, calls it a step in the right direction but too small, given the huge task at hand. The organization acknowledges much remains to be done, including responding to unprecedented challenges that will require the development of robotics and other new technology. Tokuhiro is advocating the creation of an international team to help Japan, including those with experience at Three Mile Island and Chernobyl in the Ukraine. "It is clear that this very large undertaking requires an international effort," he said. "It is in the spirit of a global nuclear energy partnership." Associated Press ALSO SEE

Fukushima plant: Workers start removing radioactive fuel rods

Fukushima decommissioning: Unprecedented challenge ahead, say scientists

Repair of Fukushimas wrecked plant begins RELATED VIDEOS

Chinese plane over disputed islands prompts Japan to send jets

India more confident than Aussies going into Super 8

Scandal widens: Rebekah Brooks held, police chief quits


More from the web
Amazing New Time-Lapse Video Shows You the America You've Never Seen National Geographic Meet the Car that Can Go 3,000km on One Litre of Gasoline

More from Firstpost


Live: BJP, Congress, Anna and AAP locked in Lokpal feud

Politics
Finland welcomes Delhi HC order to defreeze Nokia assets

Wired
In South Korea, Delays Drag a Project to Build Homegrown Fighter Jets The New York Times 7 of Nelson Mandela's Most Inspiring Quotes Goodnet Dont Send Shoes or Breast Milk or Teddy Bears to the Philippines. Send Slate

Business
In refusing Congress alliance, did Kejriwal overplay his hand?

Politics
Diplomats arrest: Incident smacked of racial bias, says father

World
I wont keep quiet any more, says French first lady World
Recommended by

CLOSE X Firstpost encourages open discussion and debate, but please adhere to the rules below, before posting. Comments that are found to be in violation of any one or more of the guidelines will be automatically deleted: Personal attacks/name calling will not be tolerated. This applies to comments directed at the author, other commenters and other politicians/public figures Please do not post comments that target a specific community, caste, nationality or religion. While you do not have to use your real name, any commenters using any Firstpost writer's name will be deleted, and the commenter banned from participating in any future discussions. Comments will be moderated for abusive and offensive language. Please read our comments and moderation policy before posting

3 comments Join the discussion


Newest Community P avit hra
19 hours ago

Share

Login

Kudankulam comes to my mind!!


Reply Share

S phinx 1 S phinx 2

Pavithra 18 hours ago


Reply Share

Some risk is always there with any development. You can take preventive actions, but you can't eliminate all risks.

21 hours ago
Reply Share

End of the world is near.

ALSO ON FIRSTPOST

WHA T ' S T HI S ?

Study says universe on verge of collapsing


13 comments 19 hours ago

What the AAP can learn from the Congress about arrogance
173 comments 3 hours ago

P avit hra So basically you guys do not know!! Then I do

not consider this as a news!!

iTrollNot It has always been BJP vs Rest of the parties

(Corrupt congress and clan) and will always be like that.

Worst over for job market? HR experts expect doubledigit hikes


2 comments 2 hours ago

Congress is not serious about Lokpal, says BJP


2 comments 19 hours ago

pic alas only AAP is serious. BJP filled 46% of criminal in

Coolguy LOL. Keep dreaming!

Delhi, what you can expect from them??

Su b s cri b e

Ad d D i s q u s to yo u r s i te

Search Firstpost..

Submit

LIVE Australia V England


AUS vs ENG | Dec 13th, 2013
Full Scorecard

ENG 2 4
RUNS

1 6.4
WKTS OVERS

Future of India's hydrocarbon sector

MOST RECENT

India's untapped potential in oil and gas sector

Creating tomorrow's energy solutions

MORE FROM Ayeshea Perera

Is Kejriwal destined to be undone by his Lokpal movement? Dec 15, 2013 Lokpal live: SP unfazed by Rahul's plea to pass Lokpal Dec 15, 2013 Live:Karat welcomes AAP decision to fight Cong, BJP in Delhi Dec 14, 2013 Live: Lok Sabha, Rajya Sabha pay tributes to Nelson Mandela Dec 06, 2013 Conclusions from exit polls: AAP, Sheila set for Delhi disappointment Dec 04, 2013 VIEW MORE

Pakistan planning last suicide attack in honor of retiring Kayani


Dec 3, 2013

India, China sign pact to declare Chinese incursion up to 20 km as friendly v isit


Oct. 23

x Newsletters Please check the newsletters you wish to subscribe to Today's Headlines While you were sleeping Big Story

Politics Daily Tech Weekly Business Wrap Sports Daily


Your email id...

Editor's picks
Fri 12.13 Mon 12.09 Sat 12.07 Fri 12.06 Wed 12.04 Tue 12.03

Bellwether Lok Sabha poll survey shows Modi effect in UP, Bihar A deep-dive survey in one bellwether constituency each in Bihar and UP shows BJP and Modi well ahead of the pack for 2014

Contrary to what Imran Khan thinks, Tendulkar was tested the most Sachin Tendulkar was severely tested by a plethora of great fast bowlers from his own era.

Diplomat's arrest: 'Shocked' India summons US consul Nancy Powell Meanwhile the US Ambassador in India was also summoned regarding this issue.

Hrithik Roshan announces separation from wife Sussanne Hrithik Roshan announced that he and his wife Sussanne Roshan are separating. The actor issued a statement today informing the media that Sussanne had decided to separate from him and end their seventeen year old relationship.

Verdict 2013: The rise and fall of Sonia's Dole-onomics Politicians implicitly believe that voter doles are vital to re-election. The results from Rajasthan and Delhi show that voters are making the connect between what they get free and what they lose as a result.

Elections result 2013: Why the idealistic AAP is better off in the opposition Now that the elections are over, the real problems of governance begin. And governance often becomes a millstone around the necks of those who were once seen as saviours.

BJP win lifts markets, but road to economic recovery may be long The function of the markets is to believe what it wants to believe. A bear market factors in only the worst even if there are some signs of turning around. A bull market factors in the best, even if the signals are unsustainable.

It is time for Indian sports to have its own AAP movement Just like a good player doesnt automatically become a good coach, there is no guarantee that sports administration will improve by putting a sportsperson at the helm.

Poll eve: Will Madhya Pradesh turn out to be a very close race? The BJP leaders exude confidence but refrain to talk about the surveys projecting a comprehensive win for the party.

Why we shouldn't be happy with India's gain at WTO For public consumption, the country has gained in getting rid of the threat of the old Peace Clause through the interim mechanism that will work till a permanent solution. But on all other aspects, India has given in to pressure.

Why Ahmedabad is the safest place for women today Effective policing and the visible curb on drunkenness in public places has made Gujarats capital city safer for women

Delhi assembly polls: Here are the possible outcomes The rise of the Aam Aadmi Party has decimated the Congress, and in a three-way vote split, the BJP could well score.

Power to forgive: Mandela's death and the Babri demolition anniversary In India by the time we woke up to news of Nelson Mandelas death it was already 6 December. For us that day marks a different anniversary. 6 December 1992 was the day the Babri Masjid came down and brought in its wake a communal horror which still haunts us. No truth. No reconciliation. Just bitterness.

Digital journalism: How the internet will save the Indian press The Indian media are at a tipping point, hobbled by suspect financing, a history of servility, and a massive loss of public trust. The internet is no silver bullet, but it most certainly represents a lifeline.

Foot in mouth: Farooq Abdullah apologises for sexist remark Farooq Abdullah managed to offend with a statement regarding women, claimed to apologise and then made another one.

R...Rajkumar review: Shahid, Sonakshi in a r...regressive film Prabhu Deva is making films that will make feminists want to throttle him to death and regular, sane, not-part-of-the-Khap people wonder why his films are so appallingly retro.

Delhi elections 2013: How AAP has changed the polling game Whether or not AAP succeeds, the party has shown it is possible to fight elections on low budget, without musclemen, without experienced politicians, by adopting innovative methods, and largely eschewing the temptation to appeal for votes on the basis of caste and religion.

Truth behind Tehelka: Tejpal's non-journalism and society's colluders It is this brand of politics, which prefers fiction to truth, that suits Indias current rulers the best. It is this brand of journalism that Tejpal served up to the gullible both in India and abroad.

Delhi polls: Will urban voter apathy be the undoing of AAP? However, the worst enemy the AAP can find is people like us who vent ire and grief but do not walk to the polling booths

Why selfish BCCI needs to see the bigger picture What the BCCIs claims amount to is a board that already has more money than it knows what to do with simply more cash to stash because, well, because it does.

Article 370: Why BJP fear to say Modi, party are not on same page Modis call for a debate on Article 370 had put the party on a spot.

Delhi polls: Why Congress, BJP may have little to fear from AAP A hung assembly would set the political clock back by about a decade in Delhi, which has always given a decisive mandate for assembly or parliamentary elections.

Why Jerry Pinto's Facebook post about the Tehelka case made us angry Why would not one but several level-headed women writers explode over a Facebook status post, and revisit a case of sexual harassment that was reported two years ago?

A culture of distrust: How India's ruling class feeds on paranoia Pratap Bhanu Mehta argues that a changing India has left the ruling class uncertain of its position, and is therefore resorting to intellectual closure and emotional crudity to preserve itself.

Submit
About Firstpost Verticals: Front page Plus: New Delhi Tools: Sitemap RSS Feed Mumbai Photos FP Exclusives Cartoons Video room eBooks Election Weather India Politics World Business Economy Investing Life Bollywood Sports Tech Blogs Newsletter RSS Twitter Facebook

Online Study Material

Business Technology News

MTV India

Online Shopping in India

Think India

[+] Hot Topics: Copyright 2013 Firstpost All rights reserved Terms of use Privacy Advertise moneycontrol.com ibnlive.com in.com tech2.com cricketnext.com

You might also like