Page 1 of 20

Shopping | Obituaries | Horoscopes | Lotteries

Search Search vancouversun.com... Search

YellowPages Find a business or person

Weather Centre

0 Overcast Vancouver More

Subscriber Services Start Home Delivery Digital Edition Mobile Products

canada.com network

Newspapers

National Post Victoria Times Colonist The Province (Vancouver) Vancouver Sun Edmonton Journal Calgary Herald Regina Leader-Post Saskatoon StarPhoenix

http://www.vancouversun.com/news/been+down+this+path+before/5798026/story.html

12/5/2011

Page 2 of 20

Windsor Star Ottawa Citizen The Gazette (Montreal) DOSE Postmedia Community Publishing Nanaimo Daily News

Log in Register

In Mondays newspaper

Whistler Film Festival wraps

Read Mondays Vancouver Sun to find out what happened during the weekend at the Whistler Film Festival. more

The Vancouver Sun

Top Picks

Timeless beauties: Hottest actresses...

These stunning actresses prove that beauty can get better with age. Take a look at some of Hollywoods hottest starlets who are over 40 -- but youd never know it. more

http://www.vancouversun.com/news/been+down+this+path+before/5798026/story.html

12/5/2011

Page 3 of 20

Weather Centre

0C Overcast Vancouver Detailed Forecast

News

Opinion

Business

Sports

http://www.vancouversun.com/news/been+down+this+path+before/5798026/story.html

12/5/2011

Page 4 of 20

Entertainment

Life

Technology

Travel

Topics

http://www.vancouversun.com/news/been+down+this+path+before/5798026/story.html

12/5/2011

Page 5 of 20

Jobs

Cars

Homes

Classifieds

Don't miss: Holiday guide 2011 Sun Run Adopt-a-school Student videos Vancouver 125 NFL pool eStore Today's Paper Video

RSS

http://www.vancouversun.com/news/been+down+this+path+before/5798026/story.html

12/5/2011

Page 6 of 20

Weve been down this path before

As civilizations mature, they tend to make the same mistakes. We are in the middle of one of those mistakes right now
By Frank Giustra, Special to The Vancouver SunDecember 1, 2011
Recommend

49
2

Comment 8 Story Photos ( 1 )

http://www.vancouversun.com/news/been+down+this+path+before/5798026/story.html

12/5/2011

Page 7 of 20

The type of economic restructuring both America and Europe need is so difficult and painful that, even if the current political systems were functioning, it would still take many years and the kind of courage and sacrifice that does not seem to exist.
Photograph by: Nease, MCT
What has been will be again, what has been done will be done again; there is nothing new under the sun. Ecclesiastes 1:9 If, as an investor, you are looking at the U.S. and Europe, and are confused by the barrage of sombre news relating to economic issues such as stubbornly high unemployment, collapsing housing prices, soaring government-debt levels, waning consumer confidence and a precarious banking system I dont blame you. As far as I can tell, so are the legions of experts, media and politicians, those we have traditionally trusted to explain such complex economic and financial matters to us. And why have all the herculean efforts to save us from these maladies failed so miserably, despite the fact that we seem to be drowning in remedies? It seems as though America and Europe are going down for the count. As Canadians, we have a solid financial system and a stable government that functions as it was designed to do. And yes, we Canadians can take comfort that we are somewhat shielded from the profligate and irresponsible policies of our American and European friends, but given their sheer size and our inter-connectedness, we cant completely escape the collateral damage when the stuff eventually hits the fan. As the above Ecclesiastes quote (generally attributed to King Solomon) suggests, history is replete with examples of repetitive behaviour. Observing the behaviour of todays policy-makers, I suspect this quote is as valid today as it was more than two millennia ago. We are in an unholy mess and however loudly the sane few may plead, the chances it will get turned around without disaster striking are slim indeed. The type of restructuring both America and Europe need is so difficult and painful that, even if the current political systems were functioning, it would still take many years and the kind of courage and sacrifice that does not seem to exist. One of these days, some unforeseen event, akin to the child in Hans Christian Andersens The Emperors New Clothes declaring But he isnt wearing anything at all! may serve as the tipping point that brings the entire financial system to its knees. To get a proper understanding of the current situation, we should start by ignoring all the noise propagated by the experts, media and elected officials. Our global financial system is based on the very simple and fragile concept of confidence. So you cant really blame the policy-makers and politicians for not telling the public the entire truth; feeding us constant reassurances, peppered with a little mendacity. And to make things worse, its just human nature for us, the recipients of this information, to reject the idea that the worst can happen, hence our willingness to find reassurance in the misinformation we are fed. But folks, the worst CAN happen. I doubt the citizens of Imperial Rome ever considered that their empire, which stretched from the Atlantic Ocean to the Caspian Sea, would eventually collapse on itself from the sheer weight of effort and resources needed to maintain it, or that 16th-century Spaniards ever thought their high standard of living, sustained by the plundered riches of the New World, would disintegrate once the supply of gold dwindled. Or that the upper-class 19th-century Brits leading up to 1918 ever fathomed that the sun could cease to set on lands ruled by the British Empire. History has shown that when great nations mature and over-extend themselves, they revert to the paths of least resistance: borrow and/or print money. They all did it and they all failed; this time will be no different.

http://www.vancouversun.com/news/been+down+this+path+before/5798026/story.html

12/5/2011

Page 8 of 20

If Einsteins definition of insanity doing the same thing over and over again and expecting different results holds true, we should move to have all of Americas and European policy-makers locked up in padded cells. This hubris holding on to time-worn ideas about what made a nation great in the first place, but ignoring the hard sacrifice that went with it has prevailed throughout history and is as relevant today as it was for every great nation that came before America and the European Union. Still, the experts continue to reassure us that America was built on a foundation of entrepreneurial spirit; we can get ourselves out of any mess. (At least the Europeans know better than to preach such fantasy.) I sense that some of those ideas dont hold up as well as they once did, especially as the world outside of America has become highly competitive. At some point in the evolution of a great nation must come a time when the simple math of mounting debt, lack of productivity and printed money plays havoc with ingrained beliefs. This is one of those times in history. Therefore, as much as I would love to provide solutions to this mess-in-waiting, I would rather give some thoughts as to how to protect yourself. Consider the following precaution as a condom for your portfolio or savings: protection against STDs (savings total destruction). The bottom line is that the money needed to bail out Europe and to fund Americas spiralling debt and future unfunded obligations is in the tens of trillions. IT DOES NOT EXIST. It has to be created by printing money in massive quantities, and despite all the rhetoric you will hear against such policies, in the end its the path of least resistance. Printing money is an invisible tax on savings, much easier to initiate, than, say, raising taxes or cutting back on services and entitlements. However, there is a lag on its negative effects, a perfect policy tool for elected officials who inevitably kick the can down the road to future governments. Policy-makers in most democracies live in a 24/7 campaign mode, which prevents them from making difficult, long-term and most certainly unpopular decisions. Simply said, we operate in a system not conducive to decisive action. Witness last weeks dismal failure by the U.S. Congressional Super Committee to reach agreement after months of bitter negotiating on what was essentially a ridiculously minuscule reduction of the deficit over the next decade and you get the picture. There will be a quantitative easing three (QE3) in the U.S. and the European Central Bank (ECB) will eventually follow suit in printing money in American-style amounts, despite Germanys resistance to date. If the world continues to print money, currencies will be debased against tangible things such as gold, farmland, exclusive real estate, rare art and collectibles, select equities to list a few. Therefore, having your savings invested in cash, bonds, money and markets, could mean a complete destruction of those savings by runaway monetary inflation. Having said that, timing is an issue you must weigh carefully. There is a chance that another financial crisis such as we experienced in 2008 would cause the value of real assets to go down and, by definition, make cash holdings more valuable for a short period of time, until further printing reverses the trend once more. I would recommend owning plenty of gold and, depending on your available resources, select real estate and collectible art, which works well for wealth preservation, and having an adequate pool of cash, which would only be used to acquire additional real assets in the event of another crisis. Its your wealth, your life savings; you are the only person who can protect it. No one else really cares. Wake up and smell your future. Frank Giustra is a Vancouver business executive with interests in the mining and filmmaking industries, and a noted philanthropist. Copyright (c) The Vancouver Sun

http://www.vancouversun.com/news/been+down+this+path+before/5798026/story.html

12/5/2011

Page 9 of 20

E-mail this Article Print this Article Share this Article

Location refreshed

More on This Story

Submit a letter to the Vancouver Sun Full Vancouver Sun op-ed coverage

Story Tools

E-mail this Article Print this Article Font: * * * * *

Image: * * * * Sponsored By:

http://www.vancouversun.com/news/been+down+this+path+before/5798026/story.html

12/5/2011

Page 10 of 20

The type of economic restructuring both America and Europe need is so difficult and painful that, even if the current political systems were functioning, it would still take many years and the kind of courage and sacrifice that does not seem to exist.
Photograph by: Nease, MCT

E-mail this Gallery Print this Gallery Share this Gallery

Photo Galleries

More Photo Galleries

http://www.vancouversun.com/news/been+down+this+path+before/5798026/story.html

12/5/2011

Page 11 of 20

Photos: Flames drop in on Canucks...

Calgary Flames and Vancouver Canucks renew rivalry... more

Photos: Rogers Santa Claus Parade...

Rogers Santa Claus Parade 2011 more

Timeless beauties: Hottest actresses...

These stunning actresses prove that beauty can get... more

More Photo Galleries

What Do You Think? Already a member? To comment, please Login.

Login or Register New to the site? To leave a comment, you need to Register. Questions? - Visit our FAQ

8 comments

Sort by:
Score: 0

Newest to Oldest

Diamond Lou 11:26 PM on 12/3/2011 Demographic trends will reinforce Giustra's forecast. You'd be wise to heed his predictions IMO.

Report Abuse

http://www.vancouversun.com/news/been+down+this+path+before/5798026/story.html

12/5/2011

Page 12 of 20

Score:0 anon958032305 12:38PMon12/3/2011 collectibleandrareart???????Thereissuchanoverabundanceof"art"onthemarket todaythatwhenthecrunchcomes80%ofitwillbecomeworthless. humanvaluesproject??whichofcourse,youwillbetheirleaderanddemanda6figure salarytellingushawtolive.Not!!Whatisneededisahighinterestrateonallloans,a taxonspeculation,andamajorreductioninspecialinterestgroupinfluence.

ReportAbuse

BrianStrader 7:56PMon12/2/2011 Apologies.Thelastlineofmylastpostwascutoff. TheglobalOccupymovementisthevisiblesignandheraldofthisnecessary organization.

Score:0

ReportAbuse

TheHumanValuesProjectwillofferalternativestrategiestothecurrentglobalfinancial system,onewhichcouldtranscendmoneyasamediumofexchangeandpotentially evenTheMarketitself,likeaninternationallycoordinatedbarter/creditssystem.The Projectwillhaveasocialfunctionaswell,analyzingthebeliefsandattitudesthatcreate andreinforcedysfunctionlikehomophobia,sexism,xenophobia,racism.Itsagendawill betocreateastrategyofbetterhumanliving.Itsmemberswillbecomprisedof internationalhumanrightsactivistsandprofessionalsinpsychology,history, criminology,etc.whosecredentialswillguaranteethemoralsuasionnecessarytoshame governmentsintovitalchange.Shameistheonlywaytogetchangefromgovernments now.
Score:0 BrianStrader 7:43PMon12/2/2011 FrankGiustra:"ThetypeofrestructuringbothAmericaandEuropeneedissodifficult andpainfulthat,evenifthecurrentpoliticalsystemswerefunctioning,itwouldstilltake manyyearsandthekindofcourageandsacrificethatdoesnotseemtoexist....Simply said,weoperateinasystemnotconducivetodecisiveaction."

ReportAbuse

Agreed.Alltrue. FrankGiustra:"Therefore,asmuchasIwouldlovetoprovidesolutionstothismessin waiting,Iwouldrather...." SinceMr.Giustrahasnone,Iwouldlovetoprovideasolution.ItiscalledTheHuman ValuesProject.Itisanorganizationthatneedstobecreated.Iseriouslydoubtany individualgovernmentwillcreateit,sinceitsscopewouldbeinternational.TheUnited Nationswouldhavetocreateitoraprivatefoundation.TheHumanValuesProject wouldexaminethebeliefsofthehumanspecies,includingthosewhichcreateThe Market.TheglobalOccupymovementisthevisiblesignandheraldofthisnecessary organiz
Score:1 BrianStrader 7:26PMon12/2/2011 FrankGiustra:"Iwouldrecommendowningplentyofgoldand,dependingonyour availableresources,selectrealestateandcollectibleart,whichworkswellforwealth preservation,andhavinganadequatepoolofcash,whichwouldonlybeusedtoacquire additional"realassets"intheeventofanothercrisis."

ReportAbuse

Thisisworsethanaconservativestrategy.Thisisthefinancialequivalentofahippy "dropoutandgetbacktotheland"strategy.TheMarketiscyclical:boomandbust. We'reinabusttimenow,butwhatisrequiredisTheNextBigThing,likeapersonal computerineveryhome.Thatwillgetusoutofthisrecession.That,andspending. Spending,nothoardingyourmoney,willgetusoutofthecurrentrecession.

Score:0 BrianStrader 7:18PMon12/2/2011 FrankGiustra:"Oneofthesedays,someunforeseenevent,akintothechildinHans ChristianAndersen'sTheEmperor'sNewClothesdeclaring'Butheisn'twearinganything atall!'mayserveasthetippingpointthatbringstheentirefinancialsystemtoitsknees."

ReportAbuse

Agreed.Anexcellentpoint.Itwillbetheunexpectedthatwilldestroyus,anditmaybe assimpleasaEurozonegovernmentrefusingtobowtoimposedfinancial"solutions"of France,Germany,andtheIMF.

http://www.vancouversun.com/news/been+down+this+path+before/5798026/story.html

12/5/2011

Page 13 of 20

FrankGiustra:"Ourglobalfinancialsystemisbasedontheverysimpleandfragile conceptofconfidence." That'swhyitisfailingnow.Thefinancialsystemneedstoberebuiltonafarstrongerand sanerfoundation. FrankGiustra:"Butfolks,theworstCANhappen." Itcananditwilliffundamentalchangesarenotmade,andnotjusttotheglobal financialsystem.

Score:1 BrianStrader 7:05PMon12/2/2011 FrankGiustra:"Andyes,weCanadianscantakecomfortthatwearesomewhatshielded fromtheprofligateandirresponsiblepoliciesofourAmericanandEuropeanfriends...."

ReportAbuse

IchallengeMr.Giustratodefine"profligateandirresponsible".Noexamplesweregiven. Therefore,thestatementisrhetoricalandirrelevant.Canadaisbynomeansholierthan thou.Ourgovernmentdoestheexactsamethingasalltheothers. FrankGiustra:"Weareinanunholymess...." No,wearenot.Weareinaglobalaccountingcrisisofnationaldebtfinancing.Nothing more.ThisideaofaEurozoneCrisis(notecapitals)isentirelymediagenerated,andthe criticalthinkerhastoquestionwhoseagendaisatworkandwhoprofitsfromthe hysteria.

Score:0 TommyH 11:50AMon12/2/2011 DoesMr.GiustrathinkthatVancouverandLowerMainlandresidentialproperty,with themarketwhereitisnow(highcomparedtoothercities),qualifiesas"selectreal estate"?

ReportAbuse

Related Topics

Europe United States Opinion

http://www.vancouversun.com/news/been+down+this+path+before/5798026/story.html

12/5/2011

Page 14 of 20

Hot photos and videos

News Sports Entertainment Business

Hockey

Photos: Flames drop in on Canucks

Calgary Flames... more

Rogers Santa Claus Parade 2011

Photos: Rogers Santa Claus Parade 2011

Rogers Santa... more

Top Picks

Timeless beauties: Hottest actresses over 40

http://www.vancouversun.com/news/been+down+this+path+before/5798026/story.html

12/5/2011

Page 15 of 20

These stunning... more

Football

Junior football takes over BC Place

Football fever... more

Christmas

Cute kids and pets with Santa

Send us your... more

Entertainment

Wild, weird celebrity Twitter pics

Sexy, scary ... more

http://www.vancouversun.com/news/been+down+this+path+before/5798026/story.html

12/5/2011

Page 16 of 20

More photos >>

Most Popular News

Most Read E-mailed Commented

Uproar in Gitxsan First Nation after support for Enbridge's Northern Gateway pipeline announced Bands, dancers accompany Santa during his annual parade through Vancouver UFC Ultimate Fighter finale results: Bisping dominates Miller Canucks Gameday: Luongo to make first start in three weeks against Flames Rams achieve epic victory against Hawks Vancouver to Toronto WestJet flight diverted after alleged bomb threat

more RSS "The Amazing Race Australia" has landed at YVR Uproar in Gitxsan First Nation after support for Enbridge's Northern Gateway pipeline announced Vancouver to Toronto WestJet flight diverted after alleged bomb threat Small plane flips over at Kelowna International Airport Rogers Santa Claus Parade 2011 draws large crowds to downtown Vancouver Sex sells in any income bracket

more RSS Canada's anti-Kyoto stance sours climate-change discussions in Durban 55 days of teacher bargaining but still nothing B.C. woman arrested for 18-year-old Ontario child abduction case Gitxsan First Nation take ownership stake in Northern Gateway pipeline project Untitled Article Labour board sides with teachers over report cards, pay

Sponsored By

Breaking News Alerts

Sign up to receive e-mail alerts on breaking news from The Vancouver Sun.
you@canada.com

Submit Our Privacy Statement

More News Headlines

http://www.vancouversun.com/news/been+down+this+path+before/5798026/story.html

12/5/2011

Page 17 of 20

Latest updates

Julian Assange can pursue extradition fight in Britain: court

WikiLeaks founder Julian Assange is granted permission to apply to England's highest court in a final attempt to block his extradition to Sweden over ... more 20 minutes ago Comments (0) Photos: Timeline of the Julian Assange saga The whistleblower: Assanges life overshadows his work Internet has become 'surveillance machine': Julian Assange WikiLeaks "spy files" show global surveillance industry

Local updates

Italy pushes deep austerity to avoid Greek-style 'collapse'

4 minutes ago

Former negotiator says Canada blocking Durban talks

Two Mounties injured in Alberta standoff

Ads by Google

http://www.vancouversun.com/news/been+down+this+path+before/5798026/story.html

12/5/2011

Page 18 of 20

Aftershock is Eye-Opening Susan R. from Montgomery, Ala. is raving about her free copy. Get it. www.newsmax.com o katrina discover what's next in music by watching the band black lips. vitaminwater.com/music How bad is the U.S. Debt? Five Simple Ways to End Americas Spiraling National Debt. Free RPT MoneyMorning.com/US_Debt_Report Inside The Vancouver Sun

Photos:

Heating

Advent:

Photos:

Weekend

Home News Opinion Business Sports Entertainment Life Health Technology Travel Jobs Cars Homes Classifieds

http://www.vancouversun.com/news/been+down+this+path+before/5798026/story.html

12/5/2011

Page 19 of 20

Don't Miss Holiday guide 2011 Sun Run Adopt-a-school Student videos Vancouver 125 NFL pool eStore Today's Paper Video

RSS Most Popular Uproar in Gitxsan First Nation after support for Enbridge's Northern Gateway pipeline announced Bands, dancers accompany Santa during his annual parade through Vancouver UFC Ultimate Fighter finale results: Bisping dominates Miller RSS Formats Sitemap / RSS Contests Blogs Columnists Photo Galleries Videos Mobile iPad App

Vancouver Sun About Us Contact Us Work for Us Advertise with Us Subscribe to the Print Edition Rate Our Delivery Service and WIN Newspaper in Education

Tools Search vancouversun.com... Search

Search for a Job Buy/Sell a Car Real Estate Listings SwarmJam Sweet Deals

Place a Classified Ad

http://www.vancouversun.com/news/been+down+this+path+before/5798026/story.html

12/5/2011

Page 20 of 20

E-mail Alerts

canada.com Logo About canada.com Privacy Statement Terms Copyright & Permissions 2008 - 2011 Postmedia Network Inc. All rights reserved. Unauthorized distribution, transmission or republication strictly prohibited.

http://www.vancouversun.com/news/been+down+this+path+before/5798026/story.html

12/5/2011