You are on page 1of 19

9th annual Spring value investing congress

April 3, 2014 Las Vegas, NV Investing by the C.O.D.E


Chris Mayer, Agora Financial

www.ValueInvestingCongress.com

Investing by the C.O.D.E.

Chris Mayer Editor & Founder, Capital & Crisis, Mayers Special Situations coffeecan@agorafinancial.com

#1 Mortgage Servicing Rights (MSRs)


The big picture: Banks are getting out of the mortgage

servicing business Specialty servicers taking the slack (Ocwen, Walter, etc.) Im not recommending a servicer

Page 2

4/4/2014

First, How MSRs Work


Servicer earns a fee based on the unpaid principal

balance (UPB)
Basic servicing fee Excess servicing fee

Contractual flows with interesting properties


Page 3 4/4/2014

Cherry Hill Mortgage Inv Corp. (CHMI)


Unique mortgage REIT that co-invests in MSRs with

partner Freedom Mortgage Corp.


Freedom started in 1990 by Stanley Middleman; $13 billion in originations in 2012: $10 billion in first half of 2013 Paid most of CHMIs listing fees (went public in October) Stock is $19 7.5 mil shares outstanding Quarterly dividend is 50 cents for 10.5% yield Book is $21.50 (up 8.6% since IPO)

Page 4

4/4/2014

Page 5

4/4/2014

After IPO
Agency MBS (65% of assets); Excess MSRs (25% of

assets), but majority of equity (68%) in Excess MSRs. Bought 2 pools of Excess MSRs

Excess MSRs also helps protect book value against

interest rate increases. (Hence, that 8.6% gain)


Page 6 4/4/2014

Cherry Hill
Comps?
HLSS (not a REIT, focuses on subprime) co-invests with Ocwen, trades ~1.3x book NRZ co-invests in excess MSRs with Nationstar (but lots of other assets too), trades for ~1.3 times book

Upside for Cherry Hill


Stock is $19, book value is $21.5, plus you get that 11% yield.

Page 7

4/4/2014

Comparisons

Page 8

4/4/2014

Second idea

Page 9

4/4/2014

#2 Investing in NPLs in the EU


EU banks sit on $1 trillion + in NPLs

Pressure to get rid of them:


Basel III Retrenchment Improved liquidity

The pace will quicken

Page 10

4/4/2014

Best places to be

Page 11

4/4/2014

Investing in NPLs in the EU


The big 3:
UK Spain Ireland $226 billion $230 billion $186 billion

Large discounts

Page 12

4/4/2014

Kennedy Wilson Europe (KWE)


February IPO raised $1.7 billion
Kennedy Wilson, invested $200 million, is the manager

Seed portfolio:

NAV per share is 9.77 pounds (shares go for 1,050)


Page 13 4/4/2014

The Kennedy Wilson Complex


Kennedy Wilson is the manager Basic criteria:
KW can immediately boost the return on the property (such as in the Alliance) Good prospects for rental growth and price appreciation Where the property should benefit from on-going foreign investment in Europe

Page 14

4/4/2014

A word about KW

Page 15

4/4/2014

Outperformance since IPO


KW total return of 135% since listing in November 2009

Tells only part of the story

Page 16

4/4/2014

McMorrow The O in CODE


From the 2011 annual report:

2009 book value per share $4.36: 2013 was $9.91


Page 17 4/4/2014

Summary
#1 Cherry Hill (CHMI) #2 Kennedy Wilson Europe (KWE)
Also Kennedy Wilson (KW)

Review of Last Years Picks


First Citizens (FCNCA) up 27% since Atlas Financial (AFH) up 86% since

Contact e-mail: coffeecan@agorafinancial.com My letters:


Capital & Crisis +17.6% annualized return since inception in January 2004 Mayers Special Situations +13.1% annualized since inception in July, 2006
Page 18 4/4/2014

You might also like