This document summarizes a presentation on urban tourism development in Thessaloniki, Greece. It begins by defining urban tourism and noting its growth as a distinct form of tourism since the 1980s. Urban areas are now seen as important tourism destinations that can support local economic development. The document then provides background on tourism development in Greece and cities generally, noting Greece's dependence on seasonal coastal tourism. It classifies different types and scales of urban tourism destinations. The presentation goes on to analyze urban tourism expansion and its role in urban planning and revival.
Original Description:
Original Title
Tourism Development in Urban Destination Case Study of Thessaloniki
This document summarizes a presentation on urban tourism development in Thessaloniki, Greece. It begins by defining urban tourism and noting its growth as a distinct form of tourism since the 1980s. Urban areas are now seen as important tourism destinations that can support local economic development. The document then provides background on tourism development in Greece and cities generally, noting Greece's dependence on seasonal coastal tourism. It classifies different types and scales of urban tourism destinations. The presentation goes on to analyze urban tourism expansion and its role in urban planning and revival.
This document summarizes a presentation on urban tourism development in Thessaloniki, Greece. It begins by defining urban tourism and noting its growth as a distinct form of tourism since the 1980s. Urban areas are now seen as important tourism destinations that can support local economic development. The document then provides background on tourism development in Greece and cities generally, noting Greece's dependence on seasonal coastal tourism. It classifies different types and scales of urban tourism destinations. The presentation goes on to analyze urban tourism expansion and its role in urban planning and revival.
Tourism on Islands and Specific Destinations International Scientific Conference
Un i v e r s i t y of t h e Ae g e a n - School Interdepartmental Program of Post Graduate Studies in Tourism Planning, Management and Policy, Chios Island, Greece December 14 16, 2000.
INNOVATIVE PARTNERSHIPS FOR SUSTAINABLE URBAN TOURISM
TOURISM DEVELOPMENT IN URBAN DESTINATIONS: CASE STUDY OF THESSALONIKI
Maria Voultsaki, Doctoral Researcher Aristotle University of Thessaloniki - Department of Urban and Regional Planning and Development, Thessaloniki, Greece
Abstract The question of the issue is based on the following thought: as we already know, the tourism development is focused either around cities either in cities. As a result, two events take place: first of all, it uses the urban space either as an intermediary station either as a final destination and, secondly, the tourism development happens to constitute the principal component of the urban development. This leads us to the conclusion that the limits of tourist and urban development are vague and after a while, it is useless to separate them. If one would add the predictions of various studies by the European Travel Commission, ETC that the urban tourism will be grown sooner than the summer holidays, mainly due to small intervals, congresses, conferences, motives and reports and also the demand for cultural visits and holidays will be increased with more rapid rhythms than other types of holidays and particularly, the winter cultural sight-seeing will be increased sooner than the holidays for winter sports, this could constitute an interesting issue (Tourist Market ; 1997). Initially, we shall define a semantic frame for urban tourism and its evolution and then, we shall notice the growth of the tourism phenomenon and its effects, mainly in territorial level, in Thessaloniki. 2 I. Tourism development in Greece
The Tourism for Greece plays an important role in the maintenance of financial stability. In our country, the Tourism development started after the end of the Second World War, the tourism arrivals from 210.000 in 1956 were increased to 5.557.109 in 1981 and 8.351.000 in 1988. According to the predictions of the international tourism arrivals in Greece, the arrivals will present augmentative tendencies during 1997-2005 and will be increased per 36,3 times in relation to 1969 (Varvaressos S.; 1998) 1 . The 85% of the tourism movement takes place on May-October while the full months, when the 50% of the tourists visits our country, are J uly, August and September (Drettakis; 1996) 2 , which demonstrates intensively the seasonal characteristic of tourism in our country. The specific data concern mainly coast areas, islands, which either are specialized in foreign tourism and possess big hotel units, either are specialized in local tourism, mainly under the form of summer residence. The visitors in our country come mainly from Europe and especially, from countries of the European Union (Germans and British) and, in a smaller percentage, from North America. Thus, we notice the dependence on the international tourism in our country. The main tourism destinations are: Rhodes, Corfou, Creta, Calchidica, Mikonos and Santorini as well as Attiki - however lately there is a series of other smaller destinations (Coccossis H., Mexa A.; 1997) 3 - Consequently, we notice an unbalanced distribution of tourism development. The above general characteristics of tourism are identified in many cases with those of the urban tourism phenomenon in our country.
II. Tourism development in Urban Destinations: Urban Tourism
The Urban Tourism is defined as the Tourism activity developed in an urban center which has the appropriate tourism infrastructure and hyper-structure and those natural, historical and cultural elements that render it an attraction pole for tourists, by supplying the possibility for production and consumption of products and services. It is based on the consumption of entertainment, which is offered on urban centers in an organized and systematized way. The identity of the urban center, which becomes the object of the development of the tourism activity, may be a metropolitan center with more than 1 million inhabitants but also an historical center with fewer inhabitants or even small cities which are historical, cultural and financial centers 4 . The above are obvious in a theoretical and scientific level. In fact, the notion of urban tourism only exists in identification with the forms of tourism phenomenon in cities (cultural, council, religious etc)
1 Varvaressos S., 1998 TOURISM, Notions, Dimensions, Structures, The Greek Reality Propompos, Athens 2 Drettakis, 1996 How many tourists visit Greece and what amounts do they invest? Article in the newspaper EXPRESS (18/12/96) 3 Coccossis H.Mexa A.1997, Tourism and Environment: the search of the balance 4 Research work Contribution of urban tourism programs in the evolution-reformation of historical centers. The case study of Athens Ministry of Environment, Urban Planning and Public Works, - Department of Urban Planning and Land Planning, Athens 2000 3 Trying to understand the phenomenon of urban tourism, it is possible to state the following typology, which composes the urban tourism destinations of different scale (Page. S.; 1995) 5
Capitals of countries (London, Paris, New York) Metropolitan centers and historical centers with ancient walls (Kaderburi, York) and small cities-fortresses Big historical cities (Oxford, Cambridge, Venice) Coast and riverside upgraded areas (London Docklands, Sydney Darling Harbour) Industrial cities (Bradford 19 th century) Coast resorts and resorts for winter sports (Lillehammer) Integrated tourism resorts (purpose built) Buildings of tourism entertainment (Disneyland, Las Vegas) Centers of specialized tourism services (baths and shrines) Cultural cities (Florence)
I.Expansion of the Urban Tourism
Urban Tourism, in an international level, started its development gradually since the beginning of 80 and constitutes today a special distinguished form of tourism whose importance is continually approved mainly in the local level. The most recent empirical researches realized by the Danish Tourism Organization confirmed the intensified attraction of urban destinations for the European tourists as well as the variety of their motives to visit the cities. The 1/3 of the questioned are interested in sight-seeing in cities while it is estimated that the 25% executes a tourism activity in relation with the urban cultural inheritance 6 . In an international level, even though Urban Tourism, as already mentioned, obtains constantly greater approval, did not lead yet the Tourism science in a holistic consideration of procedures and standards of cities evolution as tourism destinations. It is claimed that big cities, and, in general, Urban Areas, constitute important tourism destinations since they supply facilities to tourists, possess the required tourism infrastructure which cover the special needs of the local population and of the visitors of these areas which are also their attraction object by the local developing organizations. Since the beginning of 1980, the power organizations of urban centers started to face tourism as an activity which can be incorporated in local programming of financial activity and harmoniously join the promotion of local evolution. The principal reasons which helped in the tendency for the evolution of urban centers through the promotion of special tourism forms were the limited efficiency of the already developed financial activities and the need to incorporate new financial activities that could avoid the financial stability and offer new impulse in the local developing level with direct result the formation of revenue and employment. At the extent in which the applications of urban tourism are implemented, dominates gradually the opinion that urban tourism constitutes a further possibility, within the frame of urban planning, for the evolution, the improvement of functionalism, administration and
5 Page. S., 1995, Urban Tourism, Routledge, London
6 Research Work Contribution of urban tourism programs in the evolution-reformation of historical centers. The case study of Athens Ministry of Environment, Land Planning and Public Works - Department of Urban Planning and Land Planning, Athens 2000 4 management of the urban area. The specialists of local and urban design use the urban tourism as a catalyst and factor of urban revival for the reinforcement of cities in a decline crisis. However, the existing studies paid less attention in the role of tourism in cities. This happens even in big countries, London, New York where their tourism industry is an important source of revenue formation and is responsible for the creation of thousand employment posts (Fainstain, S.S.Gordon, I. and Harloe M.; 1992) 7 . Furthermore, the academic studies for the tourism of big cities consider that the cities are sources of creation of tourism flows. Business trips and congresses (professional, council Tourism) and also trips to friends and relatives, are hardly reflected in tourism systems of various countries. Furthermore, the inconveniences regarding the separation of local inhabitants by the visitors are also noticed and, consequently, the financial importance of tourism industry cannot be estimated in a precise way. The lack of modern methodological frame that could sufficiently estimate the financial and social dimension of tourism activity in the environment of the urban centers and the general developing philosophy hinders the rational development of urban tourism. It is estimated that Tourism, as a distinguished financial and social activity of service supplies and goods offering and as a branch of the tertiary sector of economy that is referred in a complex of industrial and commercial activities that service the tourism demand, may, under certain circumstances, constitute the vehicle of developing procedure and cannot constitute as it is an activity-base for the developing procedure since it is a latent resource. Urban Areas, apart their productive role for the growth of tourism, function also as admission centers or points of tourism currents. Thus, the urban area is examined as a part of a complex system for the definition of the standard of tourism developed in it.
II. Urban Destination: Thessaloniki
The area under-study concentrates all the characteristics of a metropolitan center with port. As analyzed above, Tourism, which is developed in such an area, is of completely different form than the one in Island-coast areas, in mountainous or areas with ecological interest. The tourists who visit Thessaloniki have either specialized motives, either motives in relation with the general characteristics of the city. The main trip types and motives registered for the urban tourism are the following:
Types and motives of urban tourism trips Visit the city for cultural purposes As weve already mentioned, the urban tourism has a cultural content and is also combined with certain administrational and organizational activities on cities functionalism. This kind of tourism - cultural tourism - does not concern exclusively the touring in historical monuments, the knowledge of the cultural inheritance of the area and the contact with the modern artistic creation. The tourist-visitor feels an important experience since he has the possibility to visit and meet closely monuments and works of art whose formation was also instructed in the past. Simultaneously, the contact with the modern creation helps in the understanding and
7 Fainstain, S.S.Gordon, I. and Harloe M., 1992 Divided Cities: New York and London in the contemporary world Oxford, Blackwell
5 profound knowledge of habits, tendencies, ways of thinking of the indigenous, contributes in the spiritual uplift and in the conscience that the world is not limited to our only personal area of activity. (Comite Economique et Social, 1990). The civilization is a very concrete way in which the various human societies live and are developed, by imprinting in the area of their lives their own social characteristics. It is the way of living and the system of values produced and takes their meaning through a specific geographic area. Today, the experience suggests that in some cases the tourism activity may be used as a tool for the protection and maintenance of the cultural inheritance (e.g. in Thessaloniki, Ladadika area, Athonos Square, Ano Poli etc.). Gentle tourism uses under the form, for example, of specialized museums, cultural centers or entertainment centers give the possibility to activate historical areas by stimulating the interest of public, private organizations for politics, organization and financial help in their protection. At the same time, the particular interest of the visitors for the cultural inheritance may contribute to the sensitization of the local population for the protection of such resources. Consequently, within this frame, the evolution, the diffusion and the function of urban tourism may influence significantly the Urban Areas. Individual Professional Trip (e.g. International Fair of Thessaloniki, Philoxenia, Agrotica, Infacoma, Flower Exhibition etc.) Organized professional trip Small trip within the frame of a wider sightseeing in the country (e.g Vergina, Ancient Pella, Cave of Petralona, Lake of Kerkini etc.) Trip-intermediary station for natives who travel abroad The advantage of the geographical location of Thessaloniki is an intermediary stations apart the area of Northern Greece and for the surrounding Balkan countries and the rest Europe. Trip-intermediary station within the frame of transition to another area of the country for holidays The fact that Thessaloniki is a coast area intensifies the advantage of the fixer of many tourism destinations situated in a long distance around it (with main destinations, Chalkidiki, Sporades and by road in tourism centers of Western and Eastern Macedonia - ski centers etc.) Trip in holiday times or in weekends for holidays emphasizing on culture, relax and entertainment (E.g. Book Festival, Greek Song Festival, Cinema Festival, Festivals of Open Theater, Dimitria: musical and theatrical manifestations, Festivals of Open Theater, Wine and Gastronomy Festival etc). Trip for medical reasons (Inter-Balkan Medical Center etc.) Trip for visit of friends or relatives Trip of small or one-day duration for the settlement of administrative affairs for social reasons or shopping Trips for educational or scientific reasons The combination of tourism and culture presents a sense of dynamism. Characteristic case is the congresses that contribute significantly to the evolution of tourism sector in Greece. Between 1989-1992, we notice the increase of the total number of congresses per 15.5%. In Thessaloniki, we notice the existence of an intense business and scientific activity, without 6 observing the ratio in infrastructures and plants, apart few exceptions mainly in its central and eastern area. Consequently, according to the above, we notice that the main characteristic of Thessaloniki is that It is transformed in a transitory center of tourism trips and services addressing to native and foreign people. The motive of tourist visits, lasting not over 3 days, is the use of tourism infrastructures and services of the area and for the realization of another trip towards another area of the country or abroad The area under-study is still out of the classification for areas with problems due to the intense tourism evolution or for areas, which are not, exploited tourism ally and the above factors have contributed to this.
III. Consequences of the Tourism Phenomenon in Urban Areas
As already noticed, the phenomenon of tourism presents a particularity regarding the way of structure and operation, which is very important concerning the provoked effects. The Tourism as an important universal activity is distinguished by a diffusion of financial profits between the way of admission and the wider system: travel agencies, air and advertising companies, multinationals etc. At the same time, we notice a range of effects in the social tissue and the natural receptor, exclusively in the place of destination of visitors. Two are the coefficients that intensify the pressures in the environment - abiotic and biotic: first of all, the increased concentration of visitors in an area and secondly the seasonal concentration. This means that for a very small period of time, a great number of visitors are concentrated in a small area. This time and local over-concentration of humans and activities overpasses sometimes the resistance level of the system. (Lozato Giotart J .P.; 1990) 8
Although the visitors who choose big urban centers for tourism are characterized, in their majority, by their sensitivity in environmental issues, the phenomenon of environmental degradation in those areas is frequent. The over-concentration of visitors is a menace for the cultural resources-monuments and buildings- due to frequent use of areas and to the pollution provoked. Other important problems presented in this area, which will be analyzed below, are the following: the traffic, the noise, the parking - absence of appropriate areas, intensifies the problem of traffic, the problem of increased waste production etc.
IV. Territorial Effects of the Tourism development in Thessaloniki
Regarding the level of space organization it is noticed an intense urbanization, which is expanded in the whole territory of the area, in order to satisfy the demand in hotel rooms, entertainment areas, restaurants etc. This, in turn, will result to: insufficiency of areas for expansions of activities, increase of cost and of transportation time, mixture of non- conventional land uses and pollution problems. The effects in the local society, which has to face the increased living cost since the attraction of the area is increased significantly, are also
8 Lozato Giotart, J .P; 1990, Mediterranee et Tourisme, Masson, Paris
7 very important. The pressures to the infrastructure, the services (e.g. museums) and the services like the public transport etc) are equally important. The versions of the intensified problems may and can be researched in the lack of applied policy founded in the principles of florescence, in direct relation with a respective policy for the environmental, land planning and urban planning reformation of the area. The side effects of the resistance to the classification of plants without programming and the weaknesses to implement a more balanced environmental policy in a regional and friendly point of vu, may become particularly traumatic, by reducing in the long run the international competitiveness of tourism resources of the area. The most important side effects are imprinted in brief as follows: Gradual alteration of the physiognomy of the historical areas, like the historical center- traditional core of the city Intense swelling of the traffic problem Gradual demerit of limited infrastructures Gradual demerit of one by the main tourism resources: the sea, the sewage, lacks of plants of biological cleansing In Thessaloniki, according to the needs and the requirements of the city, we notice lately the transformation of the following situation, regarding the territorial evolution of tourism activities: Intense dipole of low and high quality of hotel rooms Lack of space for the installation of big hotel units in the center of the city. Unequal territorial distribution of tourism operations: concentration of hotels and other tourism services in specific areas resulting to surplus in some and respectively deficit to others. Gradual increase of tertiary activities - between them and the operations of the tourism sector - and in other areas except the center of the city, simultaneously to main road axles. Diffusion of tourism activities - particularly big hotel units, casino, entertainment stores that operate during summer months and change the whole scenery of the area - the periurban eastern zone with direct effects in the organization of the urban and periurban area. The organization of activities in the periurban space is not foreseen in any urban planning plan. (Voultsaki Marili; 1998) 9
As far as the territorial design is concerned, the effort to decentralize the operations of a business center in local centers-cores in the region as well as the installation of activities like trade-representations-multistoried in the periurban zone of Thessaloniki, helps in the decentralization of the center and, consequently, the best service except the permanent population and the visitors of the city but not in long turn. The fact that there are no special regulations in the existing urban planning and land planning legislation regarding especially the classification of tertiary activities but is executed within the frame of special provisions of the legislation of urban planning and land planning concerning either the definition of land uses, either the classification procedures and the issue of building licenses, may offer an
9 Voultsaki Marili, 1998 Survey of Tertiary Activities and Residential Development in the Area of Thermi Thesis. Aristotle University of Thessaloniki, Faculty of Engineering, Department of Architects, Field of Urban Planning, Land Planning and Peripherical Development 8 appearing temporary flexibility but hinders the long-term rational development of the city (Kafkalas Gr.; 1999 ) 10
Finally, another inhibitory factor for the harmonious evolution of the tourism activity, in the case of urban destinations, is the split of administration into private and public organizations, local and national governmental organizations or offices. This fact aggravates the historical cities 11 . It is a general phenomenon in Greek space: the multi-split of organizations in the extent of representation of the private initiative in combination with the coverings of responsibilities of governmental organizations, leads to the hindering of the carrying out of results and, consequently, their transfer to a business level. However, the Hotel Chamber, when legislated, was meant to be a Government Counselor. This opposition existing between the interests and the different mentality of the hotels and the other tourism branches, e.g. tourism agencies (tourism agencies believe that hotels are their extension), does not allow the appearing of a unique line in the Government and their unified representation
V. Concluding Remarks
Today, at the extent the applications of the urban tourism are implemented, dominates gradually the opinion that the urban tourism is another possibility, within the frame of the urban design, for the development, the improvement of functionalism, of administration and management of the urban area. On the other side, the general delay of development of the urban tourism in Greece, except its disadvantages, has the advantage of exploiting the concentrated international experience, particularly regarding the study of effects of the tourism in cities (Defner.A. 1999) 12 The four categories of tourism effects in cities already mentioned are inter-related. Under this point of view, the facing of problems created by those effects requires the formulation and the application of a policy which wont concern exclusively the urban planning or the culture or the tourism but will combine the urban planning policy with the policy for spare time or cultural policy. The above activities and policies would better be included in an integrated plan of tourism administration that should be based on the respect of environmental values, appreciate the foreseen effects by the tourism concentration, defines the uses and activities, in the base of an index system for the prediction of concentration risks, pressure, overstepping of any kind of capacity 13
10 Kafkalas Gr.1999 THESSALONIKI: Reduction of Monocentricity in the Building Complex and the Role of the Tertiary Sector, Un.Aristotle of Thessaloniki, Field of Urban Planning, Land Planning and Regional Development, Ministry of Environment, Land Planning and Public Works, Organization of Regulatory Plan and Protection of the Environment in Thessaloniki, Ziti, Thessaloniki 11 Research Work Contribution of urban tourism programs in the evolution-reformation of historical centers. The case study of Athens Ministry of Environment, Land Planning and Public Works - Department of Urban Planning and Land Planning, Athens 2000 12 Defner.A. 1999 Cultural tourism and spare time activities: the effect in the operations of the cities in: The Development of Greek Cities. Scientific Approaches of the Urban Analysis and Policy, sur. Ikonomou D., Petrakos G., University Editions, Thessaly, Gutenberg 13 Research Work Contribution of urban tourism programs in the evolution-reformation of historical centers. The case study of Athens Athens 2000
9 References
Coccossis H., (1996), Tourism and Sustainability: Perspectives and Implications in Sustainable Tourism, European Experiences, Edwards A., Priestley G., Coccossis H., (eds.), CAB International Coccossis H., Mexa A. (1997), Tourism and Environment: the search of the balance Defner.A. (1999) Cultural tourism and spare time activities: the effect in the operations of the cities in: The Development of Greek Cities. Scientific Approaches of the Urban Analysis and Policy, sur. Oikonomou D., Petrakos G., University Editions, Thessaly, Gutenberg De Kadt Em., (1979), Tourisme: passeport pour le development?, Paris, Banque Mondiale UNESCO Drettakis, (1996) How many tourists visit Greece and what amounts do they invest? Article in the newspaper EXPRESS (18/12/96) Fainstain, S.S., Gordon, I., and Harloe, M., (1992), Divided Cities: New York and London in the contemporary world, Oxford, Blackwell Kafkalas Gr. (1999) THESSALONIKI: Reduction of Monocentricity in the Building Complex and the Role of the Tertiary Sector, Aristotle University of Thessaloniki, Field of Urban Planning, Land Planning and Regional Development, Ministry of Environment, Land Planning and Public Works, Organization of Regulatory Plan and Protection of the Environment in Thessaloniki, Ziti, Thessaloniki Law C.M., (1993), Urban Tourism: Attracting Visitors to Large Cities, Mansell Publishing Limited, London Lozato Giotart, J .P; (1990), Mediterranee et Tourisme, Masson, Paris Pearce D., (1990)Tourist Development, Longman, London Page. S., (1995), Urban Tourism, Routledge, London Varvaressos S., (1998) TOURISM, Notions, Dimensions, Structures, The Greek Reality Propompos, Athens Voultsaki Marili, (1998), Tertiary Activities and Residential Development in the Area of Thermi Diploma Thesis, Aristotle University of Thessaloniki, Faculty of Engineering, Department of Architects, Department of Urban and Regional Development Research work Contribution of urban tourism programs in the evolution-reformation of historical centers. The case study of Athens Ministry of Environment, Urban Planning and Public Works, - I.M.P., Department of Urban Planning and Regional Development, Athens 2000