Professional Documents
Culture Documents
20118242013827
2011
2011
NSC101-2811-H001-011
480
1420143
481
Keywords:
482
1420143
Ronald Dworkin
1
Justice for Hedgehogs
Taking Rights
3
Seriously
right as trump
70
3-291998
483
Matter of Principle
forum of principle
1986Laws
6
Empire
interpretivism
integrity
7
19861996
Hart
73-109
2001
214-62007
53082003
484
1420143
Freedoms Law8
10
Justice
2006
in Robes
sovereign importance
11
8
20085
11
485
1978
liberalism
12
13
human dignity
Lifes Dominion
bioethics
ethical individualism
14
4332012
Hercules
MARK TEBBIT, PHILOSOPHY OF LAW: AN INTRODUCTION
58, 72 (2000).
14
29195-2492009
486
1420143
80
Sovereign Virtue
good
life
Is
Democracy Possible Here?
partnership democracy
15
2011110
15
132171-2232009
487
epistemology
comprehensive liberalism or philosophy
16
intellectual topography
17
16
488
1420143
18
right
constitutionalization
19
18
19 DWORKIN, supra note 3, at 92-94.
489
liberty
the right to liberty
liberty
20
21
freedom
freedom
liberty
liberty
freedom
freedom
liberty
22
20 Id. at 273-74.
21 RONALD DWORKIN, SOVEREIGN VIRTUE: THE THEORY AND PRACTICE OF EQUALITY
125-26 (2000).
490
1420143
liberty as license
liberty as
23
independence
Immanuel KantJohn
Stuart Mill
24
25
491
26
27
freedom
liberty
28
492
1420143
29
60
493
30
31
32
33
30
31
32
33
494
1420143
34
35
34 Id. at 32.
35 Id. at 35.
495
36
36
DWORKIN,
supra note 2, at 327-44.
496
1420143
37
easy cases
hard cases
discover
invent38
v.s.
37
John
Mackie, The Third Theory of Law, in RONALD DWORKIN AND CONTEMPORARY
JURISPRUDENCE 161, 161-70 (Marshall Cohen ed., 1984).
38 DWORKIN, supra note 3, at 31-39, 81.
497
39
40
41
39 Id. at 81-84, 90.
40 DWORKIN, supra note 5, at 11.
41
Joseph Raz
Jules Coleman
Keith
Culver, Leaving the Hart-Dworkin Debate, 51 U. TORONTO L.J. 367, 367-99 (2001).
7144-1522010
498
1420143
42
constructive interpretation
law as integrity43
Hercules44
fit
justificationfitjustification
Hercules
BRIAN BIX,
LAW, LANGUAGE, AND LEGAL DETERMINACY 77-132 (1993).
43 law as integrity
Joseph Raz,
Speaking with One Voice: On Dworkinian Integrity and Coherence, in DWORKIN AND
HIS CRITICS 285-90 (Justine Burley ed., 2004).
24252008
3163-2002008
44 Hercules
312Dworkin
65342001
499
45
46
HerculesHercules
Hercules
Hercules
47
Hercules
45 DWORKIN, supra note 1, at 88, 255.
46 Id. at 176.
47 DWORKIN, supra note 3, at 105-06.
500
1420143
Hercules
48
Hercules
Hercules
49
Hercules
HerculesHercules
Hercules
Hercules
Hercules
50
501
51
52
53
53 DWORKIN, supra
note 1, at 65-66.
502
1420143
54
55
responsibility
accuracy
56
54 Id. at 52, 228-29.
55
6-8
503
57
504
1420143
58
doctrinal
sociological
taxonomic
aspirational
59
505
12
60
DNAH2O
506
1420143
507
62
62 Lloyd L. Weinreb, The Moral Point of View, in NATURAL LAW,
508
1420143
constitutional jurisprudence
63
Olympus
Hercules
64
LAW: A STUDY OF THE IDEAS OF LAW AND JUSTICE IN THE WRITINGS OF LON L. FULLER,
MICHAEL OAKESHOTT, F. A. HAYEK, RONALD DWORKIN AND JOHN FINNIS 1-279
(1992).
63
509
Jeremy Waldron
65
original
the Framers
65 Jeremy Waldron, The Rule of Law as a Theater of Debate, in DWORKIN AND HIS
originalist
510
1420143
67
511
68
69
moral reading
68 Id. at 59-60.
69 Id. at 66-67.
512
1420143
70
71
72
73
513
74
514
1420143
75
76
a living constitution
77
78
75 DWORKIN, supra note 17, at 138-39.
76 Rebecca L. Brown, How Constitutional Theory Found ITS Soul: The Contributions of
77 James E. Fleming, The Place of History and Philosophy in the Moral Reading of the
American Constitution, in EXPLORING LAWS EMPIRE: THE JURISPRUDENCE OF
RONALD DWORKIN 23, 23-40 (Scott Hershovitz ed., 2006).
78
515
79
the
rule of law
rule-book
2008772008
516
1420143
80
81
82
80 Id. at 11.
81 Id. at 11-12.
82 Id. at 8.
517
83
84
83 Id. at 16-17.
84 Id. at 17, 29-31.
518
1420143
85
86
a real value
87
85 Id. at 32.
86 Altman Andrew, Fissures in the Integrity of Laws Empire: Ronald Dworkin and the
Rule of Law, in READING DWORKIN CRITICALLY 157, 157 (Alan Hunt ed., 1992).
David
Dyzenhaus, The Rule of Law as the Rule of Liberal Principle, in RONALD DWORKIN
56, 56-81 (Arthur Ripstein ed., 2007).
87 DWORKIN, supra note 17, at 10, 168.
519
88
89
accuracy
efficiency
90
88 Id. at 169.
89 Id. at 169-72, 183.
90 Id. at 172-78.
520
1420143
substantive equality
formal equality
91
92
Hercules
91 11
11
78
45-84
92 DWORKIN, supra note 17, at 104.
521
93
civil
disobedience
94
pornography
liberty of expression
right of comment
95
522
1420143
96
hate speech
97
98
96 DWORKIN, supra note 22, at 152-53; DWORKIN, supra note 21, at 354.
97
2347-872007
523
99
100
99 Id. at 359.
100 DWORKIN, supra note 9, at 218.
161-412006
524
1420143
101
Archilochus
Isaiah Berlin
102
525
103
104
tree structure
one-system picture
law as morality
103
Steven
Lukes, An Unfashionable Fox, in THE LEGACY OF ISAIAH BERLIN 44-52 (Mark Lilla,
Ronald Dworkin & Robert Silvers eds., 2001)
104 Mark Lilla, Ronald Dworkin & Robert Silvers, Introduction, in THE LEGACY OF
ISAIAH BERLIN, at ix, xi (Mark Lilla, Ronald Dworkin & Robert Silvers eds., 2001).
526
1420143
105
holistic ideal
the ideal of the perfect whole106
107
Stephen Guest
STEPHEN GUEST, RONALD DWORKIN 159-242 (3d ed.
2012).
527
108
528
1420143
1.
200824
23-68
20107141208
2000
2001Hart
73-109
2003
5307-316
2007
211-46
2008
200845-84
2012
431-35
2007
2347-87
2001
Dworkin
651-85
2009
29195-249
2009
529
132171-223
2006
161-41
1998
2008
3163-200
2.
Andrew, Altman. 1992. Fissures in the Integrity of Laws Empire:
Ronald Dworkin and the Rule of Law. Pp. 157-186 in Reading
Dworkin Critically, edited by Alan Hunt. New York, NY: Berg.
Annino, Paolo Giuseppe. 1997. An Evaluation of Ronald Dworkins
Hermeneutical Theory of Law. New York, NY: UMI Company.
Bix, Brian. 1993. Law, Language, and Legal Determinacy. Oxford:
Oxford University Press.
Brown, Rebecca L. 2006. How Constitutional Theory Found Its Soul:
The Contributions of Ronald Dworkin. Pp. 41-68 in Exploring
Laws Empire: The Jurisprudence of Ronald Dworkin, edited by
Scott Hershovitz. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Covell, Charles. 1992. The Defence of Natural Law: A Study of the Ideas
of Law and Justice in the Writings of Lon L. Fuller, Michael
Oakeshott, F. A. Hayek, Ronald Dworkin and John Finnis. New
York, NY: St. Martins Press.
Culver, Keith. 2001. Leaving the Hart-Dworkin Debate. The University
of Toronto Law Journal 51: 367-399.
Donohue, Brian. 2002. Judicial Hegemony: Dworkins Freedoms Law
and the Spectrum of Constitutional Democracies. Ratio Juris
15:267-282.
Dworkin, Ronald. 1978. Taking Rights Seriously. Cambridge, MA:
530
1420143
531