This article attempts to capture a certain cultural form of imagination in Hong Kong during the transitional period leading up to the historical handover of power in 1997. The analysis focuses on the ideological and utopian impulses registered in relation to a whole emotional complex of anxiety, bewilderment and despair.
This article attempts to capture a certain cultural form of imagination in Hong Kong during the transitional period leading up to the historical handover of power in 1997. The analysis focuses on the ideological and utopian impulses registered in relation to a whole emotional complex of anxiety, bewilderment and despair.
This article attempts to capture a certain cultural form of imagination in Hong Kong during the transitional period leading up to the historical handover of power in 1997. The analysis focuses on the ideological and utopian impulses registered in relation to a whole emotional complex of anxiety, bewilderment and despair.
This article was downloaded by: [Lingnan International Library]
On: 19 July 2010 Access details: Access Details: [subscription number 918253349] Publisher Routledge Informa Ltd Registered in England and Wales Registered Number: 1072954 Registered office: Mortimer House, 37- 41 Mortimer Street, London W1T 3JH, UK Cultural Studies Publication details, including instructions for authors and subscription information: http://www.informaworld.com/smpp/title~content=t713684873 FIGURES OF HOPE AND THE FILMIC IMAGINARY OF JIANGHU IN CONTEMPORARY HONG KONG CINEMA Stephen Ching-Kiu Chan To cite this Article Chan, Stephen Ching-Kiu(2001) 'FIGURES OF HOPE AND THE FILMIC IMAGINARY OF JIANGHU IN CONTEMPORARY HONG KONG CINEMA', Cultural Studies, 15: 3, 486 514 To link to this Article: DOI: 10.1080/095023800110046678 URL: http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/095023800110046678 Full terms and conditions of use: http://www.informaworld.com/terms-and-conditions-of-access.pdf This article may be used for research, teaching and private study purposes. Any substantial or systematic reproduction, re-distribution, re-selling, loan or sub-licensing, systematic supply or distribution in any form to anyone is expressly forbidden. The publisher does not give any warranty express or implied or make any representation that the contents will be complete or accurate or up to date. The accuracy of any instructions, formulae and drug doses should be independently verified with primary sources. The publisher shall not be liable for any loss, actions, claims, proceedings, demand or costs or damages whatsoever or howsoever caused arising directly or indirectly in connection with or arising out of the use of this material. Abstract Through an extensive allegorical reading of lms, this paper attempts to capture a certain cultural form of imagination in Hong Kong during the transitional period leading up to the historical handover of power in 1997. Dwelling on the world of signication conjured up through what I call the jianghu lmic imaginary, the analysis focuses on the ideological and utopian impulses registered in relation to a whole emotional complex of anxiety, bewilderment and despair in the works of some highly creative local lm- makers of the genre: Ching Siu-Tong, Ann Hui, Tsui Hark and Wong Kar- Wai. The study draws theoretically from Castoriadiss notion of the social imaginary and Blochs aesthetics of hope, to focus on the textual and con- textual re-constructions of a number of very unconventional martial arts swordplay (wuxia) lms made in Hong Kong in the last two decades: namely, Tsuis Buttery Murders (1979), Huis Romance of Book and Sword (1987), Ching/Tsuis Swordsman II (1992), and Wongs Ashes of Time (1994). By identifying the ideological and affective moments in the lmic imagin- ary, I want to trace what has been left in a ruined culture for utopian long- ings, and point to the presence/absence of hope as the cultural imagination for an unknown and unknowable future (beyond 1997). It is my contention that an understanding of that peculiar form of popular imaginary at the unusual juncture of Hong Kongs history can begin with a critical attempt to cope with this subtle practice of hope, so as to recognize Stephen Ching-kiu Chan FIGURES OF HOPE AND THE FILMIC IMAGINARY OF JIANGHU IN CONTEMPORARY HONG KONG CINEMA CULTURAL STUDI ES 15 ( 3/ 4) 2001 , 4 865 14 Cultural Studies ISSN 0950-2386 print/ISSN 1466-4348 online 2001 Taylor & Francis Ltd http://www.tandf.co.uk/journals DOI: 10.1080/095023800110046678 D o w n l o a d e d
B y :
[ L i n g n a n
I n t e r n a t i o n a l
L i b r a r y ]
A t :
1 0 : 5 0
1 9
J u l y
2 0 1 0 (or reject) it as mediation in the process of our collective cultural crisis, anticipation and identication. Keywords affect; allegory; lmic imaginary; Hong Kong cinema; hope; 1997; jianghu; martial hero; wuxia lms T HE F ORMAT I ON of a collective world of signication has been called the social imaginary, or the imaginary institution of society (Castoriadis, 1987). For our purpose, it could be understood here as the irreducible social potentialities rooted in us, as postcolonials, for resolving real cultural problems (such as those of anxiety, memory, desire and hope) through the invocation and formation of images that connote our common destiny as a community. Such images are not necessarily organized into coherent wholes, for, as we shall see, fragmentary representations of meaningful signs, ideological as they may be in a post-colony, are equally capable of registering the root problems of any criti- cal chaos or enigma of a cultural-political dimension. Castoriadis has theorized at length the intricate relationship between what he calls institution on the one hand and the social imaginary on the other. Briey, institutions have drawn their source from the social imaginary, but the latter is tied inseparably to the symbolic, without which society could not have come together (Castoriadis, 1987: 131). By invoking the contemporary Hong Kong cultural imaginary in an attempt to understand and capture our unique collec- tive fate, I shall therefore point to the ensemble of socially created and shared images that often speak guratively of the way the people of Hong Kong have managed to perceive and live out their (transitory) existence as (real) life. In other words, I shall read the symbolic dimension of our sociocultural world through a critical-hermeneutic process of meaning reconstruction. But I shall insist that: What holds a society together is the holding together of its world of sig- nication. (Castoriadis, 1987: 359) Every society up to now has attempted to give an answer to a few funda- mental questions: Who are we as a collectivity? What are we for one another? Where and in what are we? What do we want; what do we desire; what are we lacking? Society must dene its identity, its articulation, the world, its relationships to the world and to the objects it contains, its needs and its desires. Without the answer to these questions . . . there can be F I GURE S OF HOP E 4 8 7 D o w n l o a d e d
B y :
[ L i n g n a n
I n t e r n a t i o n a l
L i b r a r y ]
A t :
1 0 : 5 0
1 9
J u l y
2 0 1 0 no human world, no society, no culture for everything would be an undif- ferentiated chaos. The role of imaginary signications is to provide an answer to these questions, an answer that, obviously, neither reality, nor rationality can provide. (Castoriadis, 1987: 14647) My aim is to trace the gures of identication in the Hong Kong imaginary specic to the lived cultural problems and sociohistorical conditions of the tran- sitional period (19841997) that preceded the establishment of the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region (HKSAR) on 1 July 1997. By analysing some of these meaning-producing forms of cultural signications, we shall be able to speak more assuredly of the shared world of postcolonial imaginary prevailing in the dominant mode of cultural production outside of which both the socio- symbolic signs and economic-functional values of our time would remain ineffec- tive, if not incomprehensible, fragments of discourse. In his 1961 lecture Can hope be disappointed? the philosopher of utopian resistance Ernst Bloch (18851977) suggested: In fact, hope never guarantees anything. It can only be daring and must point to possibilities that will in part depend on chance for their fulll- ment. Thus, hope can be frustrated, but out of that frustration and dis- appointment, it can learn to estimate the tendencies of countervailing processes. Hope can learn through damaging experiences, but it can never be driven off course. (Bloch, 1988: xxv) Hope, for Bloch, generates the concrete effect of anticipatory expectation, which not only occurs as an emotion that merely exists by itself, but is conscious and known as the utopian function (Bloch, 1988: 105). This hopeful presentiment, as an activity of expectation, keeps the alliance with everything dawning in the world (Bloch, 1988: 107). Active and forceful, hope as a strong will carries the most unpresentable historical substance in its course (Bloch, 1988: 108). In short, the content of hope represents itself most fundamentally in the imagin- ation (Bloch, 1988: 105). In view of the dramatic course of Hong Kongs historical trajectory, in which subjects of postcolonial cultural imagination have been brought to realize the contingency, even impossibility, of hope as a category of life experience, my criti- cal point of intervention is the following problem. Any attempt to account for the miracle of Hong Kong as a success story reveals the inscription of a socio- historical meta-narrative. In the process of their being driven into the post- colonial phase of history, Hong Kong people have lived to interpret the meaning of success in very ambivalent contextual terms. As we know, in the decade prior to 1997, this well-disseminated success story had meant the institution of C ULT UR AL S T UDI E S 48 8 D o w n l o a d e d
B y :
[ L i n g n a n
I n t e r n a t i o n a l
L i b r a r y ]
A t :
1 0 : 5 0
1 9
J u l y
2 0 1 0 various kinds of sociopolitical guarantees (one-country, two systems, Hong Kong people ruling Hong Kong,horse-racing as usual, etc.) for the creation of a sociopolitical reality that was as yet unknown in history. After the Sino-British Joint Declaration on Hong Kongs future was signed in 1984, the world watched to see if these guarantees could deliver, as Hong Kong would become de-colon- ized into a Special Administrative Region under the Peoples Republic of China. 1 (Now that four years have lapsed since the historical transition, everyone is still watchful for signs of a future postcolonial Chinese society, for signs of success or failure under the still transitory condition of historical transformations.) As the long-term socioeconomic impacts of the recent Asian nancial crisis are yet to be fully absorbed, the condition of hope in Hong Kong remains something nobody can rationally ascertain. If guarantees had existed when we had to bring ourselves across the threshold of 1997, they did seem to look increasingly limit- ing, as witnessed by the simmering sense of indifference toward that nearing future experienced by people in their everyday life during the nal stage of the colonial period. Or does it amount to falling back tacitly on a future secured with relatively reliable sources of return opened before the ofcial end of colonial capitalism in this always-already colonized place, a future that will never disap- point us, because won in the connes of possibilities promised by the here-and- now? What is important here, as Bloch would put it, is the imaginative gaze of the utopian function, loaded with hope, a gaze which alone may penetrate what is real in the anticipation itself (Bloch, 1988: 106). Let us now admit this: to the extent that we can solve, or appear to have solved, some of our critical cultural problems of the kind that engage our deepest anxiety, memory, desire and hope, among others we do so by virtue of the capacity of our collective imaginary to create, share, and re-create. But the cultural imaginary, let me stress, cannot be understood in the absence of socially instituted limits and constraints, of which it is always a constituent dimension. It seems to me that the cultural problems we are concerned with here are to be resolved ultimately in the order of the imaginary, with individual and collective efforts conditioned within the real social limits and concrete institutional con- straints it has in turn made possible. Cultural mediation is crucial in this context precisely because it is recognized as a concrete socio-symbolic process whereby individuals live their imaginary relationship to the real conditions of existence. 2 What follows is therefore an attempt to investigate the gures of hope in our cultural imaginary by reading a few contemporary Hong Kong lms in the popular genre of wuxia (literally, the martial hero, or for our purpose here, simply the swordsman (sic)). 3 They are based loosely on the popular works of the modern wuxia ction written by Hong Kong author Jin Yong, providing us in their fantastic lmic re-constructions with suggestive examples of deviation from the major norms in the generic convention. The lms to be considered are: The Buttery Murders (Die bian, Seasonal Films, 1979) directed by Tsui Hark (Xu Ke); Swordsman II (Dongfang bubai, Film Workshop, 1992) by Ching Siu-tong F I GURE S OF HOP E 4 8 9 D o w n l o a d e d
B y :
[ L i n g n a n
I n t e r n a t i o n a l
L i b r a r y ]
A t :
1 0 : 5 0
1 9
J u l y
2 0 1 0 (Cheng Xiaodong, director) and Tsui Hark (screenplay and producer); The Romance of Book and Sword (Shujian enchou lu, Sil-Metropole, 1987) by Ann Hui (Xu Anhua, director and screenplay); and Ashes of Time (Dongxie xidu, Scholar Films, 1994) by Wong Kar-wai (Wang Jiawei, director and screenplay). My analysis will be taken up along two interrelated lines of pursuit: namely: (1) the ideological signication of jianghu as a cultural imaginary (literally,rivers and lakes, which often connotes the world out there) where the activities of wuxia are supposed to take place; and (2) the gurative treatment and symbolic representation of wugong (the martial art proper, a generic term covering but not limited to such forms of military art as sword-play, st-play, and a range of other related skills). 4 My purpose is to examine what remains in our cultural anticipation imagination that tends toward a livable future following the dis- courses on hope put forth by Bloch (1986, 1988). Through reading the ideo- logical tendencies in our culture of disillusionment, frustration and cynicism registered in the world of lmic signication of jianghu and wugong, I intend to estimate the sociohistorical potentialities for resolving our core cultural prob- lems by working through gures of hope in the lmic imaginary, which allows us to see one image, or better read one narrative as another. Often lled with stories of fulllment and frustration, the martial arts world has for a long time been recognized as a key to understanding the Chinese popular imagination. Not only had martial artists been in great demand in real life since early colonial Hong Kong by workers who were often harassed by the local bandits and gangsters (Yang, 1995: 94), they were always admired as the sole heroes of the imaginary world of jianghu, where the richest cultural meanings always converge (Chen, 1992: 131). Though emerging at times as contradictory and inconsistent, the allegorical world of jianghu serve to engender a critical landscape on which to map the collective experiences of success, failure, hope and despair, which still hold us at the root of our cultural imagination today. At the core of the collective imagination is perhaps what Jameson (1981) has called the political unconscious of social text. Castoriadis offers an alternative conceptualization in terms of the so-called radical imaginary, which exists in and through the positing-creating of gures (1987: 369). With the creation of images and the image-world, the radical imaginary emerges as otherness and as the per- petual orientation of otherness, which gures and gures itself, exist in guring and in guring itself (Castoriadis, 1987: 369). But how could we expect to get at the meaning meaning as always gured/represented (Castoriadis, 1987: 369) of the kind of gurations we intend to analyse here? Castoriadis writes: In order to know, one must enter the labyrinths of the symbolic elabora- tion of the imaginary in the unconscious. What is at the end of it? Some- thing that is not there to represent something else; something that is instead the operative condition for every subsequent representation, that already itself exists in the mode of representation: the fundamental phantasy of the C ULT UR AL S T UDI E S 49 0 D o w n l o a d e d
B y :
[ L i n g n a n
I n t e r n a t i o n a l
L i b r a r y ]
A t :
1 0 : 5 0
1 9
J u l y
2 0 1 0 subject, his or her nuclear (and not primitive) scene, where that which constitutes the subject in his or her singularity exists. (Castoriadis, 1987: 142) Through a close look at the mode of representation, I shall be taking lm as cultural mediation, specically a socio-symbolic process whereby we are given a time and a space (material as well as symbolic) to realize ourselves as part of the imaginary collective, via the fantastic nuclear scene, as it were. Cultural criti- cism becomes in turn the symbolic process for registering our (limited) per- spective on the operative possibilities and limits of that cultural anticipation invoked through the lmic imaginary. From all utopian thinking a certain surplus of culture must be carried over into the future. 5 Having experienced the crisis of culture/identity in the late 1990s, we all want anxiously to cope with those fundamental problems in which we are bound together as a political com- munity today. Let us pause to see the possibility of criticism itself as an open and evolving process, and understand through its practice our own limitations for the political task of humanizing the world. 6 JIANGHU: an imaginary world of signication In the lmic world of signication, jianghu is a gure for the world at large, the world out there, as distinguished perhaps most usefully from home. 7 The popular Chinese idiom of renzai jianghu shenbu youji helps to depict the uid condition of human existence caught in the sheer immensity of this chaotic world at large; the saying literally reads: when a person (i.e. the xiake) is in the world of jianghu, it is not up to him to control his own body (disposition) . That the lmic imaginary of the martial arts world captures this portrait of the individual as a lone ghter has been well recognized by scholarships on the genre. 8 The generic convention is known to have required that the world of the wuxia vagrants or wanderers be ruled by its own set of laws, its own code of ethics, and its own social structure (Ng, 1981: 74); in short, that it be subject to a social order quite distinct from those of the ordinary world found at home. According to the literary imagination of wuxia ction, jianghu is also crucially distinguished as the arena for social combats; it is in the reckless and anarchic world there that everyone wants to perform and excel (Ng, 1981: 84; Chen, 1992: 146). As a dis- cursive world jianghu has come to symbolize the race for excellence and power; it provides in turn the symbolic context necessary for the material circulation of an imaginary of human desires conducive to the search for excellence and power. This popular imaginary, when visualized through the most suggestive lmic rep- resentations, often results in renewed imagings of the lone swordsman (sic.) in search of the (unknowable) key to the enigma of life. According to Lin Nien-tung, the martial arts lms have in their evolution F I GURE S OF HOP E 4 9 1 D o w n l o a d e d
B y :
[ L i n g n a n
I n t e r n a t i o n a l
L i b r a r y ]
A t :
1 0 : 5 0
1 9
J u l y
2 0 1 0 moved away from a heavy reliance on magical feats, and within this process of secularization, arrived at a realistic portrayal of martial skills and an adhesion to martial ideals (Lin, 1981: 12). Lin identies three major phases in the develop- ment of the hero image in post-war Hong Kong wuxia pian (martial arts lms). In the 1950s and early 1960s, drawing spirits from various sources of exotic powers, the martial hero was the masterful body of transformation that roamed jianghu with his supernatural feats. When King Hu and Zhang Che came onto the scene of martial arts lmmaking in the mid 1960s, the new style wuxia heroes were still capable of fantastic stunts (like the classic weightless leap), but they have generally appeared distinctly as righteous-minded commoners committed to the cause of justice (xiayi), either as part of their personal ambition (Zhang Che) or as an outshoot of their patriotic and political ideals (King Hu). Finally, a change in lm language resulted in the denial of the older forms of wuxia rep- resentation and a scepticism toward the ideals of traditional chivalry in martial arts lms produced after 1968 (Lin, 1981: 79, 124). Another veteran critic Law Kar (1997: 112) has a slightly different periodization to make but agrees with Lin on the effects of secularization found in the martial hero image, adding that the turn to some new-wave and high-tech special effects have come to domi- nate the rapid development and transformation of wuxia pian in Hong Kong since the early 1990s. However, the transition to this current stage in the transformation of the wuxia world imaginary had started more than a decade earlier. One of the most creative and energetic among the well-known new wave lmmakers of Hong Kong who have brought fresh new imagination to the local cinema during the late 1970s and early 1980s is Tsui Hark. He offers in his debut work The Butter- y Murders, one of the most original new-wave wuxia pian, a contemporary per- spective on the representation of the jianghu enigma in the world of changing values. As the critic Stephen Teo points out, Tsui depicts here the mythic world of the martial arts as a time when Chinas sciences and inventions were at their peak; and this notion of Chinese science and military prowess, combined with the popular mythologizing of the martial arts, form the substance of Tsuis (essentially pessimistic) nationalist theme (1997: 163). The plot focuses on the investigation of the killer butteries at a mysterious, almost futuristic medieval castle by a number of martial arts experts, who all try to answer the key question Who is the Buttery Killer? For us, aside from the new wave martial art special effects, the most interesting and unconventional approach taken by Tsui involves framing the lmic narrative of mystery-solving within the viewpoint and discourse of the lone, mysterious pseudo-swordsman. This peculiar swordsman, however, appears to be roaming jianghu not with a sword to resolve the real problems of that imaginary world, but with a pen to record the logic of its happening, asking How to write this history (of The Butter- y Murders)? Now writer Fang Hongye, from whose subjective stance the riddle of the buttery murders is represented (if never fully resolved), plays the peculiar C ULT UR AL S T UDI E S 49 2 D o w n l o a d e d
B y :
[ L i n g n a n
I n t e r n a t i o n a l
L i b r a r y ]
A t :
1 0 : 5 0
1 9
J u l y
2 0 1 0 role of an insider-outsider to the history of wulin (used loosely here as a substi- tute term for jianghu). This buttery historian of jianghu is depicted by Tsui as the solitary, wandering author of various fragmentary discourses on jianghu enyuan (the loves and hates of jianghu). He has a reputation of being the authori- tative witness to its ruthlessness. Tsuis insight here consists in juxtaposing the enigma of the unknown butteries with the even more unapproachable mystery of the alien loner in jianghu, who is supposed to be the denitive author of its history. Caught in the unfamiliar mise-en-scene of a chaotic and hybrid jianghu, viewers are driven by Tsuis acute lmic articulation to question the authenticity of this particular rendition of jianghu. Overwhelmed by the beautiful visual mystery, they are left with no choice but to accept that the horric logic of the signied world of jianghu remains the privileged reconstruction of a wandering intellectual, whose real stakes in life (through his masterful inscription of the jianghu enyuan) they have no way of knowing. Hence, as gures, the represented butteries conjure up a modern aesthetic order of mythical imagination, underlining the creation of a hybridized version of the martial arts hero as suggested in his three phases of development through- out post-war Hong Kong lm history (Lin, 1981). By the same token, the lmic discourse rendered in the subdued viewpoint and voice of the solitary storyteller (analogous to those of the lmmaker?) underlines the problem of mythmaking more than sharing a particular perspective of historical vision. Through such an imaginary representation, jianghu is invoked as a place with a strong sense of ahis- torical, mythical time, in which worldly enyuan (love-hate relationships) are bound to return in repeated cycles of terror and retribution. This conception takes a similar form in Swordsman II, one of the most popular lms made by Tsuis Film Workshop in the early 1990s, where the imaginary world of signication is revealed to be once again driven by the logic of power and chaos, Hong Kong style. Despite its setting in the Ming Dynasty, the lm allows us to imagine an order where time counts little clearly, one day in jianghu is much the same as another, one epoch but a repetition of another except when you should be concerned with the problem of nishing off an oppo- nent before you are made away with by another. So what is invoked is yet another signifying space for ruthless undertakings, in which the sense of time is usually de-historicized. Indeed, it comes close to what Foucault calls crisis heterotopia, (1986: 24) an extraordinary cultural space delimited within privileged places where individuals nd themselves living perpetually in a state of crisis con- ditioned by the human environment in which they dwell. Now, with regard to the imaginary world of signication in wuxia lms, there are basically two opposed sets of value adopted respectively by two differ- ent types of people gured in jianghu: those held by: (1) a community of xiake, or righteous swordsmen; and those held by: (2) people who continue to partake in the vanity and excitement of the privileged world without regard to any norm of righteousness (xiayi). The former are values that the smart, mysterious F I GURE S OF HOP E 4 9 3 D o w n l o a d e d
B y :
[ L i n g n a n
I n t e r n a t i o n a l
L i b r a r y ]
A t :
1 0 : 5 0
1 9
J u l y
2 0 1 0 sword/power-play in The Buttery Murders has effectively done away with; these same values are nonetheless well manifested in the no-less technologically sophisticated ghting style of Ling Huchong and his Huashan fraternity in Swords- man II. In contrast, the latter are captured in full by Ching Tsuis spectacular portrait of Asia-the-Invincible (or Dongfang bubai, the East-never-loses, played by the awless Lin Qingxia), and his quasi-supernatural Sun-Moon Sect. What could then be added to this stereotyped dichotomy is: (3) a third type of people, sometimes called jianghu yinshi (hermits), who are usually desperate loners willing to retire to the tranquility of life. In Swordsman II, we see Ling Huchong and his rank constantly caught in a rather deceptive self-rationalizing process of wanting to relinquish their jianghu status of xiake. But they must, in the manner of good swordsmanship, rst settle everything they are still tied to before they can take their noble leave. Ling, for one, has never been ready to leave the loves and hates of the troublesome world behind for the peacefulness of some place beyond until the very last moment, after the total (self-)destruc- tion of Asia, when his nal resolution to retreat with fellow Huashan followers to Japan (presumably, one wild place far away from the central plains of China) turns out to be pathetically unconvincing. The crisis situation for xiake Ling and his Huashan fraternity (whose domi- nant Han ethnicity is everywhere emphasized in the lm) has been typically rep- resented in an analogue to his encounter with various female gures in jianghu. His having to choose among the different loves, even between the two sexes, before making his symbolic way out of this world, is an act carefully calculated within a matrix of character types: (1) Yue Lingshan, a Huashan sister charac- terized as somewhat tomboyish and showing healthy affection for brother Ling; (2) his beloved Ren Yingying, the loyal and kind-hearted Miao chieftain and daughter of the sacked former head of Sun-Moon Sect, whose ethnic difference is all too explicitly shown in the non-standard dialect she speaks, and who has to cut short her long-standing relationship with Ling so as to stay behind to witness the future fate of her clan (such is Tsui Harks less than subtle allegorical ren- dition of one pro-nationalistic approach to the Hong Kong situation in the pre- 1997 decade); (3) Asia-the-Invincible, the all-powerful bi-gendered leader of Sun-Moon Sect on his/her way to usurping the championship of jianghu, for whom Lings affective ties offer rare relief and the only lead to escape from the cruel rules of game, in which he is by now the most ruthless player; and nally; and (5) Asias concubine Yang Shishi, on whose robe the beloved tyrant inscribes the entire secret text of wulin for fear of being disclosed by others, with whom Ling consummates a romantic relationship one evening on the assumption that she is indeed the Asia he loves (whose real (split) identity he only realizes later to be something totally unacceptable). 9 Traditionally, swordsmen of the xiake type are expected to live and cope with a world full of problems and opportunities; these offer them room for reconsidering the possible gains and losses resulting from the collective plight of C ULT UR AL S T UDI E S 49 4 D o w n l o a d e d
B y :
[ L i n g n a n
I n t e r n a t i o n a l
L i b r a r y ]
A t :
1 0 : 5 0
1 9
J u l y
2 0 1 0 jianghu, before they would decide on their future amid opposing alternatives during critical moments of decision. Such moments are what we typically understand today as crisis of culture. 10 In the generic context of jianghu, a series of fundamental values would normally be reinforced, values which often revolve around the idea of moral application of the self (hence the proper use of wugong) toward universal benevolence in the chaotic world of struggle for wulin championship. In the ctional world of wuxia, according to the literary historian Pingyuan Chen, crisis is more often than not an indication of opportunities for change, rather than the promise of a narrative closure. The human capacity of a xiake would be put to the most authentic test if he is seen to be trapped in the severest situation. By the end of the test, the immense power of his wugong would be fully revealed and realized in discursive visibility. Signicantly, there- fore, at the crux of the generic imaginary of the wuxia hero in crisis is such an opportunity for human potentials to be explored and developed to their utmost extremes (Chen, 1992: 155). In other words, only at the limits of jianghu may a real hero emerge as the xiake fully in command of his wugong. In Swordsman II, as we may see, the generic chaos of jianghu seems to have instituted itself into a ruling, rather than excep- tional, logic of jianghu. And the resultant crisis situation seems to suggest that, in this chaotic world of power-play, whatever the root cause of our collective problems may be, order is held only by the winning hands and may only be restored through maximal demonstration of violence subsequently authorized in the name of legitimacy, retribution, or justice (or law and order and stability and prosperity, etc., insofar as the rhetoric of the dominant Hong Kong discourse goes). As for the lmic imaginary, what then are the limits of the xiakes jianghu, out there in the realm where it is normally not possible for the communal home to be located? (To be sure, one leaves home for jianghu, which in this sense is the very antithesis of home.) In such a world, the extent of cultural identication is usually stretched across a signied spectrum of enyuan the loves-hates or rewards-retributions of life as represented in the jianghu imaginary of Swordsman II which may end only where the network of social relationships stops in our represented real world. Under the mythopoeic perspective of Tsui Hark, the complexity of human enyuan has to be understood in specic historical context, something that the spectacular action scenes of jianghu enyuan tend to over- shadow. Hence, it is not surprising, as Tsui also admitted, that non-Chinese audi- ence would have great difculty in decoding the historical subtext of his wuxia lms (Law et al., 1997: 56). If the spectrum of human relationships typically manifests itself in the antagonism between East and West in Tsui Harks jianghu lms, the approach to enyuan is given a more subtle political treatment under the historico-allegorical perspective on jianghu adopted by Ann Hui in The Romance of Book and Sword. Both lms show that as power corrupts, it alienates the individuals concerned F I GURE S OF HOP E 4 9 5 D o w n l o a d e d
B y :
[ L i n g n a n
I n t e r n a t i o n a l
L i b r a r y ]
A t :
1 0 : 5 0
1 9
J u l y
2 0 1 0 caught in power-play (Asia-the-Invincible on the one hand, Emperor Qianlong (17361795) on the other). Values seem to have been fading away in jianghu, with xiake like Ling Huchong (Swordsman II) or Chen Jialuo (Romance) hardly capable of resisting their erosion. Their total collapse, now recognized almost as a fact of life (in jianghu as in colonized Hong Kong), is saved only by being kept negatively intact, as it were, in our imaginary dimension, by the xiakes often non-violent acts of resisting the hegemony of success as of power. But Ling Huchongs symbolic escape from jianghu after the elimination of Asia-the-Invincible can only be read as a passively compromising act of keeping oneself aloft of (the rewards of) success. In Romance, Chen Jialuos equally sym- bolic retreat, on the other hand, may be recognized as a tragic act of deep affec- tion all its own, taken in powerful deance of the appalling waste people would make of life. Characters capable of the kind of waste are highlighted in the lm: Qianlong, for sure, but also the legendary Mamia who dies for higher than worldly values. An exception may be the Wei princess Xianxian, whose suicide in resistance to Qianlongs sexual proposal looks more like a hopelessly con- servative step taken in vain. Obliged to recognize Chen Jialuo as his own brother, Qianlong took no chance by killing all the rioters of the formers counter-revol- utionary Red-Flower Society. Chen eventually withholds from taking the wasted life of his brother Emperor: instead, he resolves to walk away from it all, not in order to retire to some faraway land outside of jianghu, but in silent anticipation of perhaps something better something missing. 11 (Were I to kill you, some- body worse than you would have been there to succeed you as Emperor, Chen tells his brother Qianlong as he takes his sword off the latters throat, and walks away disappointedly into the distant future.) Such an approach to future is, I imagine, substantially different from the one as adopted in Swordsman II; for, as a radical imaginary, it resorts to a historicized allegorical perspective on under- standing the real (constraints of) worldly possibilities we face here and now. As we know, unication of all sects of wulin swordsmen through the art and power of wugong is a common theme governing the imaginary signication of jianghu. Amid the violent struggle for the legitimacy of ones ruling art/power, hegemony is won (rst by force, then by consent) along with the nal usurpa- tion of a certain holistic value system, the denial of which can only be made nega- tively possible (i.e. allegorically representable) on the basis of its very positive assertion. The wuxia world of Tsui Hark is a fantastic demonstration of this logic. In Swordsman II, this is revealed in a series of mutual negations between Asia-the- Invincible and Ling Huchong (sweepingly destructive power vs noncommittal procreative force), between Ling and Ren Yingying (leaver vs stayer), and between Ren and her father (the simple good vs the simple evil), who is in turn a predictable repetition of Asias oriental success story before the latters rise to full perfection of power through subsequent self-castration (in acquisition of the ultimate wugong). Now if the search for unication is a recurrent motif, then in Tsui Chings jianghu it compels us to look beyond its cohesive tendency, C ULT UR AL S T UDI E S 49 6 D o w n l o a d e d
B y :
[ L i n g n a n
I n t e r n a t i o n a l
L i b r a r y ]
A t :
1 0 : 5 0
1 9
J u l y
2 0 1 0 fostering traditional values of swordsmanship. In this way, we are able to bypass some of the contradictions invoked (such as the dichotomies of male/female, power/affection, success/failure, etc.). This, ironically, leaves the dominating logic of (a typically anti-utopian) imagination intact, since one has no room to imagine otherwise as long as one is kept within such limits of juanghu. Stay and corrupt, or leave at your own risk, was the historic logic at the threshold of the 1997 social imaginary. However, the value of coherence and the urge for unication are treated with signicant difference by Huis The Romance of Book and Sword and Wong Kar-wais Ashes of Time. Both attempt to re-afrm life at the darkest moments of its crisis. In Romance, the lmmaker possibly shares Chen Jialuos evolving critical per- spective on the problem of cultural-political identity, thus conceived: Which is the more desirable approach to the undertakings in jianghu, yong jian (the use of sword), or yong qing (the use of feeling)? Huis answer comes out strongly in favour of the latter, which, when re-imagined in the context of the Han-centred re-unication, brings us beyond the problematic of power reconguration to the key question of cultural anticipation: the question of hope. The imaging of jianghu is presented by Hui through an aesthetics of contrast. Memorable imagery in the lm generates striking visual effect and emotional impact in, for instance, the towering waves that attack a limitless gray horizon on which the loner stands; or, the labyrinth of one strange desert, etc. (Drawn away by the grand emptiness of nature, Emperor Qianlong laments: What is the history of thousands of years of empire but waves splitting against this shoreline . . .) Through an evolving sequence of gurative moves, Huis allegorical vision is creatively and productively made, resulting in the imaging of a series of natural contrasts turned historical oppositions (desert/ocean, winds/waves, sword/book, qian/qing, betrayal/hope). And thus a very different version of jianghu enyuan is mapped onto the cultural imaginary. If one cannot help but feel desperate and alienated by Huis allegorical rep- resentation of jianghu, one must admit that the tragic sense of tension invoked in its cultural space does have an unmistakably clear ethico-political dimension to it. Teo offers a succinct summary of the heroic action portrayed in Huis re- imagined jianghu: Based on a novel by martial arts writer Jin Yong, the lm proposes that the Emperor Qianlong, one of the Manchu Qing Dynastys most successful emperors who reigned between 17351796, was a Han Chinese and not of Manchu stock. The Red Flower Society, headed by a young Han named Chen Jialuo, captures the emperor and tries to persuade him to re-estab- lish Han rule under a restored Ming Dynasty. To convince Qianlong that he is really a Han, Chen Jialuo disclosed that he is his brother, offering proof in the shape of a letter written by their natural mother just before her death. Together, they discuss the premise of a Chinese society prospering F I GURE S OF HOP E 4 9 7 D o w n l o a d e d
B y :
[ L i n g n a n
I n t e r n a t i o n a l
L i b r a r y ]
A t :
1 0 : 5 0
1 9
J u l y
2 0 1 0 under Manchu rule and the possibility that it might be foolhardy for the emperor to overthrow his own government to make way for the Hans. Chen Jialuo appears to agree, but a commitment to Han rule overpowers him and his Red Flower Society members. The theme of Han discontent brings up the issue of ethnic purity which lies behind Huis treatment of history. She questions the thesis that Chins historical tragedy for three hundred years stemmed from the Hans loss of power and offers the counter-thesis of a greater China, one encompassing different ethnic groups and cultures living together. (Teo, 1997: 151) By framing the activities of xiake like Chen Jialuo and his Red-Flower Society in an (imagined) historical context, Hui offers a controlled treatment of a critical- hermeneutic re-understanding of the Han-national cause: under the gurative, historical guise of fan-Qing fu-Ming, this is read as the anti-Manchurian struggle by the Han Chinese for the restoration of the Ming Dynasty during the very suc- cessful reign of Qianlong. While it is obvious that the lm deals explicitly with the theme of China engulfed by discontent among its majority citizens of the Han ethnic variety (Teo, 1997: 151), the kind of cultural-political questions it con- jures up through the particular imaginary of jianghu enyuan for the Hong Kong audience remains to be specied. Where will success lead us to in the end? Questions we are compelled to consider anew under Huis critical and his- torical re-vision, in an allegorical mode of reception, would include, for in- stance: 12 who are our enemies? (or rather, what are our enemies?) what do we struggle against? (e.g. the Qing regime, its Han Emperor Qianlong, or the entire Manchu people?) what are we ghting for? (national integrity? ethnic identity? or cultural pride?) what is the nature of our cultural crisis? (one of legitimacy? sovereign power or identity?). But what is in an identity, or in power? and how could all these (our own jianghu enyuan, as it were) be conceived, resolved, and historically imagined? in what perspectives? with reference to what meaning, feeling, and hope? In her subtle but ambitious allegorical vision, Hui invites her viewers to see such questions (posed perhaps far too explicitly here) as highly relevant to the enigma of life on encounters in jianghu, and to ask their own versions of such questions from the imagined perspective of a marginalized position such as that of their Hong Kong. Indeed, one critic has pointed out that, despite their differ- ent subject matters and sociohistorical settings, most of Huis works have been allegorical readings of the Hong Kong situation (Shu, 1988). In other words, Huis questions are asked, and imagined, from within the historical perspective of Hong Kong, which have necessarily been constrained by and limited to the social and ideological contradictions as we experience them in what we call the Hong Kong imaginary on the verge of our unique encounter with postcolonial- ity. As critics of this imaginary, we need to try to understand and describe the C ULT UR AL S T UDI E S 49 8 D o w n l o a d e d
B y :
[ L i n g n a n
I n t e r n a t i o n a l
L i b r a r y ]
A t :
1 0 : 5 0
1 9
J u l y
2 0 1 0 cultural logic of that necessity and attempt to grasp its historical roots before one can fruitfully mean, feel, and hope for anything. 13 Hence, if Red-Flower Society can align with the Wei people in its struggle against the Manchus, why should the Han people not wear their bianzhi (Manchurian braids) and mingle freely with the ruling Manchus? Why must the ordinary people wake up from their dream of a peaceful and prosperous social order under the Qing Dynasty to recognize that the Manchurians were indeed usurpers of the Han power and must therefore be thrown out of their rank? Why, in short, must there be revolutionary acts of subversions (zhaofan yundong), or any movements of cultural and political resistance at all? The irony here is that one instance of ethnic harmony (the Han-Wei alliance through friendship and courtship) must be consolidated on the basis of another, in which, as the lm reveals, ethnic conict (Han vs zei, or thieves) is to be recognized as part of a more complex case of cultural-political antagonism. An attempt to understand the latter would then lead, not to a simplistic move to retreat from jianghu, but to Chens nal moment of more lasting realization, which might end up in stronger deance of the ruling logic. A further set of questions would hopefully be opened in the course of that realization, asking: are the Han Chinese all as non-statist and anti-establishment as Chen? With what legitimation can the Red-Flower Society and its anti- Manchurian resistance movement justify its claim to represent the perspective of the ordinary people, whose readiness to indulge in the stability and prosperity of life one can hardly doubt? And as Chen leads the zhaofan campaign through secret subversive acts to apply and move qian in the perspective of qing, one wonders if political alliance and alignment obviously a strategy of modern swordplay are a necessary source or precondition of (ethnic) friendship, love and affection (the cornerstone of qing). All these were no doubt gurative prob- lems of the kind of jianghu enyuan saturated in real contradictions of our own colonial society. Such points of intervention are still articulated in vaguely ambivalent tones in Huis Romance, but they do open up slowly to more histori- cized approaches to imagining the dual issues of nationhood and livelihood in the context of the crisis of culture we experience today, at the new historical junc- ture where all social and political changes are related to articulating the collec- tive imaginary for a new postcolonial identity. The slowly evolving tensions in Huis subdued lmic imaginary could well be sources of our own articulation of tension experienced in living, presently, the cultural politics of identity via an imminent critique of nationhood. In relation to that, amid the political fanfare during the current extended process of transition, we might also want to draw on such a rare set of problematics for rethinking the cultural politics of daily life through which a hopefully more productive and just mapping of our collective livelihood could be silently accom- plished. Like a good traditional Chinese swordsman, Chen has promised, through Huis utopian imagination, that he would go on with his life using qing to forge F I GURE S OF HOP E 4 9 9 D o w n l o a d e d
B y :
[ L i n g n a n
I n t e r n a t i o n a l
L i b r a r y ]
A t :
1 0 : 5 0
1 9
J u l y
2 0 1 0 his own way of becoming a genuinely worthwhile qian-ke (a proper gure of swordsman). As he tries to cope (through allegory) with a world full of histori- cally woven human contradictions, one hopes that time would be with us amid the disguised danger of our own state of existence; and that our remaining qing could still be forged as a function of qian, so as to allow one to make real an affec- tive politics out of the dusty and muddy power-play of life prior to the launch of the new institution of society signied by the birth of the HKSAR. And yet ones hope cannot be xed, much less secured, but only overdeter- mined in the changing ux of time and in the context of its condition of possi- bilities for realization as for disappointment . From power to affect: the imagined thrust of wugong So, will hope be disappointed? The answer one gets from Wong Kar-wai in Ashes of Time is also afrmative, with history (or is it destiny?) offering those distorted minor people of jianghu there not so much the gloomy and (almost always) unrealizable political opportunities, as uncompromizing patches of a sort of cinematic breathing space for anyone who cares to experience anew what cul- tural disappointment might amount to this time. Despite the popularity of a certain thoroughly patriarchal trend of gangster- heroism in the local lm industry during mid- to late-1980s, there has been little room for more sustained reection on the contemporary relevance of tragic heroism in Hong Kong popular culture. (Hence the signicance of such a rare attempt to investigate the historical limits and necessities of the human will as made by Ann Hui in her un-heroic version of The Romance of Book and Sword.) With Ashes of Time we are thrown into a world not of generic heroism, but one where the erosion of all heroic values had just completed its transitional historical course; in this jianghu we have all tacitly accepted that neither the urge for uni- cation nor the value of coherence can be realized. Indeed neither of them is granted any chance for negative afrmation: hope not given a single critical moment for it to be disappointed. The world out there is no longer the moral, teleological or counter-hegemonic jianghu we used to imagine, framed in spec- tacles packed and packaged with bloody tensions and melodramatic conicts. Instead, everywhere we see patches of gloomy, fragmentary brownishness, where one may pause only to let a passing doubt go, to rest on no totalizing sense of certainty. And the limits of our tolerance are at times caught glittering in the stark indifference of the killing desert heat, or, as in the opening scene of the lm, when the limitless expanse of ocean allows us to cast a distant view into its passionless world where no gaze is readily fathomed. For this is a world of still signication, and stillness in its absolute form is now visualized without ready-made objective correlatives, conventionally acceptable goals, or organized human motivations. It is the symbolic signication C ULT UR AL S T UDI E S 50 0 D o w n l o a d e d
B y :
[ L i n g n a n
I n t e r n a t i o n a l
L i b r a r y ]
A t :
1 0 : 5 0
1 9
J u l y
2 0 1 0 of a world of ambivalent tolerance, where any objects of desire in life are cap- tured in the institutional function of indifference. There seem to be neither myth- ical nor historical projections of the use of power here, and hence no human conicts. With Ashes of Time Wong Kar-wai dares us to rest in a world that cannot endure through his unique vision of jianghu, a world of uniformity without (lasting) meaning, of sameness without (valuable) identity, where any meaning- ful differences (or relationships) among individuals are efciently ironed out and forgotten in its intertwined but controlled cinematic ow and logic bordering by the limits of worldly tolerance. There is no doubt that Wong has not been fully successful in providing life in his world of jianghu with the most accessible and effective details. He has indi- cated that this want for concrete details in the desert life of West had been caused in part by budgetary constraint (Ngai, 1995: 200). The cinematic logic of jianghu in Ashes of Time though is that one cannot rest assured where the concrete home is not. Where does one want to settle? And for what cause? Such doubts have indeed been the key point of departure for imagining the lmic world of jianghu. By the same logic, it would be the function of swordplay or wugong to point to and open up ways for the xiake to cope with restlessness in full lmic materi- ality. Now Wong Kar-wai is not interested in doing yet another lmic version of Jin Yongs famous modern wuxia novel The Eagle Shooting Heroes (Shediao ying- xiong zhuan). Rather, he takes the point of departure seriously in his radical representation of the degenerated world of xiake and jianghu, but pushes it so far against its own limits as to twist its basic logic. For there are virtually no xiake in the jianghu of Ashes of Time. Most swordsmen are professional killers working with Ouyang Feng (Xi Du, or the Malicious West, played by Leslie Cheung Kwok- wing) as their agent; as a result, there is no value attached to swordplay beyond its function in getting the practical job done (in Wests words, jiejue mafan, getting rid of your troubles or solving your problems). In short, wugong becomes totally instrumental in this changed world of jianghu. It is now, to say the least, incapable of releasing either meaning (as in Swordsman II) or feeling (as in The Romance of Book and Sword), and may in the end subject only to the aesthetic power of pure cinematic stylization for its coherent and signicant represen- tation. In other words, it might well be true that one can no longer rely on under- standing the represented wugong as the means toward resolving the cultural crisis of a chaotic jianghu. For signifying neither power (qian) nor affect (qing), wugong now provides no material outlet for one to deal with the root problems of human enyuan. I believe this total denial of familiarity in the wuxia genre is at the core of the lms radical nature as a lmic gure of hope: hence its immedi- ate controversy and apparent inaccessibility. 14 Though not entirely useless, wugong is restricted to its utilitarian value. In limited signication, carrying a sword on ones shoulder is no longer even powerful by default; there is no longer cultural conicts (East vs West) or ethnic conicts (Han vs Manchu) to be dealt with. Neither can differences F I GURE S OF HOP E 5 0 1 D o w n l o a d e d
B y :
[ L i n g n a n
I n t e r n a t i o n a l
L i b r a r y ]
A t :
1 0 : 5 0
1 9
J u l y
2 0 1 0 between good and evil be usefully resolved by the sword, which now faces no serious crisis of legitimation, and therefore will guarantee no chance, because there being no need for resistance of any sort. Still, the difcult links between home (past) and jianghu (present) remain a crucial problem for Kar-Wai Wong. In Ashes of Time, everyone (except Hong Qi, the Beggar Swordsman) leaves behind something (something missing) which comes back perpetually from memory to haunt the present. As a result, the unsettling human enyuan end up in fragments after fragments of recurrent experiences driven by pride, envy and despair. These are carried in images of the desert, sand, heat, mountain, bird- cage, etc., which are punctuated by motifs of the horse, stream, wine, towel, etc. as if invoked in a sort of perpetual compensation. We see in this world what prevails is not so much human evil as human vulnerability: ones tendency to feel proud, too proud of oneself; ones readiness to envy others, in narcissistic admiration/alienation of the self; and ones inescapable fate to suffer deeply in life. Such are the fragmentary traces of human enyuan that trouble us in jianghu when the resting place (home) is only imaged in moments of lost tranquility, stillness, and rootlessness. In what way could human beings be tested pragmatically by their own desires, against the limits of their very captivity in themselves? Under the status quo of such a signifying world, it seems that one is out there merely to test the limits of ones anxiety, memory, as well as hope. With the resolution of enyuan in the disguise of business or even professionalism, jianghu is now a privileged place for transaction only. In this world, albeit marked still by the ruthlessness of its undertakings (though of a very different nature now), success leads not to happiness but to the indifferent want for further success. As professional killers take the place of xiake, (monetary) interests take the place of (cultural) values. Consequently, there is now no place for that missing something where Bloch locates the source of hope. For evaluation (the representation of values) is here based exclusively on the logic of pure exchange relations, of swordplay as busi- ness, and power play as being redened in terms of an entirely different set of human interest. By solving problems for you, the professionals employ their expertise (mere swordplay here) to take care of the troubles, which you do not consider worthy of your own life to deal with. But then of course there are other troubles feeling, anxiety, memory, desire, hope that invest in the other, affective eld of the signied jianghu, which constitutes its invisible cultural dimension. 15 In the absence of the funda- mental values promised by traditional swordsmanship, cultural anticipation must now be reoriented. Beyond its functional task as dened in the practice of pro- fessionalism, wugong does not seem to have any other intrinsic or extrinsic values. Accordingly, scenes of swordplay are also represented in an unusual manner. Its instrumentality is not lmed in a realistic mode, but impressionisti c one. In Teos analysis, Christopher Doyles grainy colour photography imparts an impressionist quality, while the pastel lighting recalls motifs from Chinese C ULT UR AL S T UDI E S 50 2 D o w n l o a d e d
B y :
[ L i n g n a n
I n t e r n a t i o n a l
L i b r a r y ]
A t :
1 0 : 5 0
1 9
J u l y
2 0 1 0 painting, pointed up appropriately by the desert location and other more tem- perate landscapes (creeks, ponds). The slow-motion action scenes convey a feeling of an artist daubing paint freely on a canvas, Using a Chinese phrase, the genre is a heavenly steed soaring across the skies (tianma xingkong) and Wong has goaded it to a distant heaven, which explains why the lm, for all its cohesive- ness, is emotionally rather distant from its audience (Wong, 1997: 199). Distance, however, is not a matter of psychological measure in Ashes of Time, but of aesthetic guration and symbolic signication. Thus the synchronization of sound and image is deliberately avoided in many swordplay scenes so as to invest in jianghu a peculiar sense of chaos as routine. We must now hear the movement of swords playing against words, but they all add up to a kind back- ground music all its own, which does not fully depict the real complexity of human actions we see in play. This is how you get in Wongs work the stylized play of lmic patches of sound and shadows, of narrative and camera move- ments giving the viewer a truly different look at the way cinema has grown professionally in Hong Kong. So with a sword in hand, you kill only for cash, not for passion, not for power, not for dealing with any human contradictions of a cultural-political nature. In fact West never appears to kill at all, though he talks about killing as a matter of course in his role as a trouble-shooting agent. The whole thing involves no value judgement, as swordplay is now transformed into the sophisticated application of skills for the end of successful elimination of what one wants not to be remem- bered, in full indifference. Thus, as an agent responsible functionally for the elimination of others memory, West is most disturbed by his own sense of pride, his own inability to forget what the self wants most, which fully explains his nature as the (professionally) malicious one. Indeed, not only is West the tyrant of his own self, but everyone else is also subject to the terror of ones very blind- ness to the desiring productions of others, including the viewer/narratee (often addressed directly as you in the lm) who might from time to time need to resort to professional service of one kind or another to take care of some unwanted troubles in everyday life. In dealing with the troubling problem of selfhood, Benjamin points specic- ally to the ways the individual forms an image of the self, and reminds us to con- sider how that imaging process, as I call it here, is one that makes possible the returning of the present to the past, the re-unication of anxiety with memory; under such a view, the crux of our cultural problem could be re-understood in the mediation through which memory forges the chain of tradition that passes events on from generation to generation. 16 What drives the present self to look back to the past is the realization in him/her of a fundamental lack, now experi- enced as fragments (ruins) of some already lost totality that can no longer be fully re-presented, even with the most vigorous imagination or creativity. One wants to be reunited with oneself, as it were, through the re-articulation of the experi- ence or anxiety derived from ones sense of incompleteness of the present (self), F I GURE S OF HOP E 5 0 3 D o w n l o a d e d
B y :
[ L i n g n a n
I n t e r n a t i o n a l
L i b r a r y ]
A t :
1 0 : 5 0
1 9
J u l y
2 0 1 0 with the problem of memory, rooted in the fragmentary ruins discovered sud- denly to be part of a forever lost collectivity. Let us now consider the ways in which individuals in Wongs signied world of jianghu form their images of self. First it is interesting to see how the lmic imaginary enables the present self (such as that of the male Murong Yan) to dis- cover a lost part of itself (in the other, female, Murong Yan) via the mediation of another (here, through the supposedly neutral service offered by Malicious West). In relation to the changed function of wugong discussed above, we may recognize in the ultimate split-identity transformation of Murong Yan, whose bisexuality is by now a popular motif, a typical case of the reunication of anxiety with memory with anxiety experienced as the loss of value in sexual identi- cation, and memory embodied in the imagined ways in which one deals with ones split identity. The end result in this particular process of self-imaging is the making (as announced by West in his role as narrative agent) of the unique swordsperson who would years later have come to call him/herself Loner/Self- in-search-of-Defeat/Failure (Dugu qiubai), as established identity in jianghu now famous for practicing swordplay with his/her own shadow (self) in the water. What is anticipated here, in the split imagining of a swordplay personality, is the tyrannical gure of self we are going to nd in the spectrum of jianghu charac- ters ranging from Evil East (Dong Xie) to Malicious West in this lm called Dongxie Xidu. How does one manage to terrorize oneself? In the case at issue, the event involves the schizophrenic Murong Yan (played also by Brigitte Lin Qingxia who is by now renowned for her role as Asia-the-Invincible in Swordsman II) and the sexual contradiction he/she experiences within the self through the mediation of the common object of desire. Murong Yan the sister wants to consummate her love for Huang Yaoshi (Evil East, played by Tony Leung Kar-fai), but her double, Murong Yan the brother would not let her (for reasons that are ambivalent Is his hatred for her rooted equally in desire? Or is it a result of envy, because he also wants East?) West comes in here as the killer-mediator, presumably to offer an outlet for their problem through his professional expertise. We are reminded of that key question in the imagined world of jianghu enyuan: Can the thrust of the sword help solve the problems (and cut the pain) caused by the human affect problems of love, desire, hope and betrayal? But there is no real need to turn to swordplay here, though its function to terminate is often routinely invoked. In a sequence of talks (negotiations), rather than ghts (confrontations), we learn that Yan the brother rst wants West to kill East, and then Yan the sister wants West to kill her brother (her other-self), etc. Through the narrative/professional agency of West, we also learn that the weakness of the one (manhood) is fully embodied in the existence of the other (womanhood), and vice versa. As the present self, with a rather useless sword still in hand, turns to look into the watery image of the past (or shadow of the future), we see that he/she is beginning to accept and/or regret in any case recognize in her/him a C ULT UR AL S T UDI E S 50 4 D o w n l o a d e d
B y :
[ L i n g n a n
I n t e r n a t i o n a l
L i b r a r y ]
A t :
1 0 : 5 0
1 9
J u l y
2 0 1 0 fundamental lack or twist of something already missing (as suggested in Ben- jamins ruins). Something, that is, always experienced now as the displaced frag- ments of an absent totality that can never be fully reconstructed, except in a perpetual process of re-reading the here-and-now as a story that belongs else- where, of re-experiencing the present as something that feels otherwise. Surely one wants to be re-united with oneself, if only allegorically. One would there- fore be prepared now to see the split-identity formation as derived, rst and fore- most, from the sense of incompleteness one feels about the present, and represented subsequently in the fragmentary ruins of life which one discovers suddenly to be part of a forever lost experience of collectivity. This sense of loss can be re-articulated with the experience of personal anxiety and its related problem of collective amnesia identiable in the Hong Kong imaginary today, thus resulting in the recognition of our total incapacity to accept any radical form of cultural anticipation. Let us take as gure of this lack Malicious Wests own identity as the incompetent swordsman. Two remarks are in order here: (1) on the swordsmans professionalism; we realize that, though supposed to kill, West has not done a thing throughout his encounter with Murong Yan except to listen (to witness someone elses painful experience in stark objectivity); as it turns out, he even refuses to take the job on the appar- ent ground that he would not be able to collect his professional fee, since both the murderer and murdered will have been nished off in one; and (ii) on his capacity to feel otherwise; being, as we can see, fully capable of reading anothers story as part of his own (which he has yet to nd a way to cope with), West must turn to the ruthless undertakings of an indifferent killer-professional by repress- ing every single desire of his own, which results in a totally detached view on life adopted with no sense of regret, and driven by no will to hope. The irony, of course, consists in the lmic impact that even the waving of the sword is rarely highlighted during his professional encounters with others. One might even be led to ask whether there is any true sign of the presence of his wugong. What we are left to see, in any case, is someone deprived in every sense of his signicance as a functioning swordsman. Indeed, according to the critic Jimmy Ngai, West is the prototype of a living corpse roaming the desert of life: He who roams the desert world is no Malicious West Ouyang Feng, but Living Corpse Ouyang Feng. To win, he cannot die; he has to live like a walking corpse, so as to allow Huang Yaoshi (his drinking partner) to see him exactly like that during the latters annual visits and to bring the news of this walking corpse to the woman (West loves) (Ngai, 1995: 93; my translation). In other words, to win, West must avenge his loss of love by killing the womans best love by denying himself as a functioning xia swordsman. And as he kills the xia in himself, he denies the possi- bility of swordsmanship in our jianghu and turns us around to face a desert of passion, marked allegorically as the imaginary status quo everyone has had desires for. That West the professional leads a life of perpetual self-imprisonment is F I GURE S OF HOP E 5 0 5 D o w n l o a d e d
B y :
[ L i n g n a n
I n t e r n a t i o n a l
L i b r a r y ]
A t :
1 0 : 5 0
1 9
J u l y
2 0 1 0 suggested beautifully in a number of images and motifs. The revolving cage that separates him and Murong Yan is one such readily received image; its recurrent motif of trap brings us eventually to the realization that the worst enemy one has to guard against is self. Wests sense of identity is split between a lost passionate past and a dreadfully untouchable present. Through a seemingly never-ending voice-over monologue, he takes some pride in telling us, and reminding himself, that (in contrast to innocent Hong Qi, played by Jacky Cheung Hok-yau) he has no desire whatsoever to see what might be there for one to explore beyond the limits of the mountain in view. As one listens to the uniquely endless and gura- tive off-screen narration in the lm, one cannot but wonder whether irony, cyni- cism or pure aesthetic indifference is at the core of the human voice. In this regard, West resembles not so much the self-reexive Murong Yan as the self-deceptive Blind Swordsman, whose future seems to have stood still in a void, trapped forever by the blinding light of the pragmatic here-and-now. If one is to assure oneself that behind the mountain standing ahead of us is only another much like the one you have before you, then one might as well turn to blindness. Turning blind that appears now to be one function of the decadent swordsman, imaginable perhaps today as the harmless intellectual pillar of the ruling, phantasmagoric status quo. Wong begins with a clich in Ashes of Time: you suffer most when you cannot be united with your best love; and turns us away with an enigma: if you may dis- cover your deepest affection only as you betray it, is there anything left for one to look forward to, except the deepest disappointment? Maybe everyone should accept being trapped hopelessly in a cage of self, for it seems that only in betrayal can one seek to invoke hope, a typically altruist imagination. And yet none of us can take qing too seriously today. At its root, this question of hope rests on the issue of an affective identity. The question is frequently repeated in this world of fading values: Who are you? Whom do you love most? The answer can only come in a lovers discourse that does not commit: tell a lie, relate a story, (mis)recog- nize a handkerchief, a gaze, or a hand, or drink up the wine of forgetfulness and play the joke. (Murong takes West for East, asking him to utter a word of love; West takes Murong for another woman back home who seemed to have asked the same. In dream, the caressing hand tells its own tale, with Murongs drunken hand touching East (in the guise of West) becoming another hand caressing him at another time, a time that seems to have gone into ashes just now, before your own eyes). And the outcome looks most unbecoming: hysterical Murong slaying his/her own shadow, Blind Swordsman screaming to look for a way out of his daily struggle to survive another slice of empty life in the absence of hope and affection, and Malicious West bargaining now and then for business as usual, a professional routine which (because so safe) shall never again put him in the role of the betrayed and defeated. Ironically, as it can no longer involve any element of risk, wugong settles into a gure of self-alienation, self-defeat, and self-betrayal. Swordplay signies not anymore the legitimate way out of the complexities of jianghu enyuan. Rather, C ULT UR AL S T UDI E S 50 6 D o w n l o a d e d
B y :
[ L i n g n a n
I n t e r n a t i o n a l
L i b r a r y ]
A t :
1 0 : 5 0
1 9
J u l y
2 0 1 0 it has now become that which gives you the only excuse to be out there, allow- ing you to tell yourself: be a swordsman, stay where you would still be identied as one; or, perhaps with equal relevance: be a viewer, lest this movie about wuxia and jianghu be forgotten in the culture industry where power as norm alone counts. Would one be disappointed, and be thus deeply affected? But then, seri- ously, what is left to be betrayed in us, except this utopian trap for something missing that might still be open to hope. If human beings are caught in the affective drives of evil and malice, nothing can escape their inward turn to cultivate envy and jealousy in everything they see. Now the Blind Swordsman, whom West recruits for his professional project, is constantly being haunted by a past that betrays him, or rather, one that he has betrayed by not seeing that invisible something of it from the limiting perspec- tive of his own vision of life. He thinks he can absorb and redress all the pain caused by the wearing away of love. But turning blind will not change the situ- ation; not wanting to forget (unlike West who rejects memory), he remains to the end a victim of blind memory. Hence, he can never see and deal with the complexities of human enyuan (beyond the dashing burst of his own blood he imagines he sees at his dying moment). Fed in envy and jealousy, this swordsman is an obvious loser whose apparent ties to home are revealed to be less utopian than ideological. For there is no peach blossom back home, only a woman by that vain name (Peach Blossom, or Taohua, played by Lau Ka-ling) who has a strong tendency to long for something more unpredictable (such as Evil East, who will years later come to settle down in his own world of Peach Blossom Island). One wonders whom the woman has been waiting to return from the wild world of jianghu? One is then shown, in memorable slow motion, the blinded swords- mans last fatal struggle in life (his professional assignment to kill a gang of horse- thieves single-handedly), which registers his painful desire to be taken away from it all to retreat from jianghu by giving oneself to its predictably ruthless way of life. Another story of self-betrayal thus comes to an end. But, for sure, our jianghu enyuan will return and repeat themselves through fragments after fragments of life remembered. The lost, rootless, and self-defeat- ing swordsman offers thus a peculiar perspective on this jianghu of ours. You see the eyes blink, or hear the wind whistle as you take your last breath of life! But this is a view, or better, a feel of life activated by none other than the voice and perspective of the impossible narrator (in the narrative stance of one dying blind swordsman). 17 We remember from the Murong case that you kill someone most ruthlessly by taking away the most loved. During the Blind Swordsmans last swordplay, memory of Peach Blossom waiting by the stream returns from the past in brief cuts, when, howling in pain, the mans last play of sword is inter- rupted suddenly by the silent scene of Poor Girl (Huansha, played by Yeung Choi- Nei) waiting persistently for something unknown to turn up that will help her avenge his brother. Such moments of betrayal haunt this particular swordsman. His wugong now becomes the signication of his very state of captivity: neither F I GURE S OF HOP E 5 0 7 D o w n l o a d e d
B y :
[ L i n g n a n
I n t e r n a t i o n a l
L i b r a r y ]
A t :
1 0 : 5 0
1 9
J u l y
2 0 1 0 has he been able to turn back home (leaving this jianghu) to rediscover the truth of his past love, nor can he lift himself from the mud and dust of the here-and- now (and stay) to help Poor Girl ght for the liberation of her future (being tied at the moment to the total of her life-investment in a donkey and a basket of eggs). Hence, it is possible to see, in a sort of Benjaminian projection of memory as chaos, that the identity of the dispassionate agent of swordplay (as of its narra- tive) is running toward complete disintegration. West turns a blind eye to life as well, having resolved to withdraw himself from any affective commitment long since he has left home for jianghu; unlike Murong and Poor Girl, however, he knows he cannot resort to any professional agent for help. Thus, Malicious West becomes the prototype of the cynically self-defeating swordsman, who feels it all too deeply in his guts that he himself is the sole agent for any possible change, but, for reasons yet to be fully recognized, will not put himself together for any single radical move! What now can he rely on outside of his plain, powerless professional sword? If it can be said that jianghu is for Wong Kar-wais swordsman such an imaginary space of cultural erosion, one may now see that we are really plunged into an exceptional crisis of the kind appropriate to our captivated state of existence at this particular historical juncture of time, when crisis connotes something very exceptional indeed: a protracted period of wear and tear, of corrosion of the world of imaginary signication which animate societys institutions and which hold society together (Castoriadis, 1991: 221). As ones personal sense of enyuan may have eroded along with our collective sense of cultural judgment (our sense of shifei, or the difference between right and wrong), there seems to be little left for us to carry through the current state of transition. Poor Girl in Ashes of Time who waits persistently for something missing (something hopeful) to turn up offers a test case for us to re-assess the function and value of wugong and of those who must live by it. West makes the telling remark that Poor Girl, like everybody else, seems to be striving for something very basic in life that others can never fully comprehend. She asks the Blind Swordsman why he has left his wife at home, and seems to insist on believing that someone would somehow turn around and lend her the help the affection she needs. Poor Girl does remind the Blind Swordsman of his wife Peach Blossom (who wants to be in love with East); she also reminds West of his beloved back home (who is now a sister-in-law). Both women seem to be per- petually waiting for something to happen. The Blind Swordsman, before his last ght, asks West to look for East in case he would not return from his job, and tells the latter that someone is waiting for him back home. East, in turn, is making frequent visits to Wests hometown, wanting to see Wests sister-in-law (played by actress Maggie Cheung (Zhang Manyu)). But unlike Poor Girl, their desires are rooted in a place they still call home, respectively, while what they long for tends to be drifting aimlessly in jianghu. Only Poor Girl takes her case C ULT UR AL S T UDI E S 50 8 D o w n l o a d e d
B y :
[ L i n g n a n
I n t e r n a t i o n a l
L i b r a r y ]
A t :
1 0 : 5 0
1 9
J u l y
2 0 1 0 out there, right in the middle of mens jianghu, as it were. There, she insists on getting an answer to her totally irregular request (Nobody would dare touch the government ofcers (murderers of her brother) for the price of one donkey and a basket of eggs, she is told by agent West). Rejected by West, she eventu- ally acquires the assistance of Hong Qi, the Beggar Swordsman who is the only person to roam jianghu with his wife, some rare creature still interested in nding out whether the desert behind that mountain would look different from the one over here. In between the two extremes, it is interesting to note the response of someone like Blind Swordsman, whose obsession with an irretriev- able past we have already discussed. He resolves to give no help to Poor Girl (even if we would accept that his sword is still instrumental for the job), but would rather step knowingly into an assignment that brings him the omen of fate. Before he goes, he cannot help himself from pressing his lips onto those of Poor Girl (only to say sorry after the fact), before walking helplessly into the ever so suffocating dust of our jianghu. One is tempted to conclude that such anxious crushing of history into ashes, such corrosion of time in empty anticipation of something to turn up with ground-breaking freshness, might have already pointed to what Castoriadis char- acterizes as the deterioration of a societys capacities for self-repair (1991: 221). In Ashes of Time Wong has forged a totally unfamiliar world of jianghu with what Teo characterizes as a freestyle approach that works against Hong Kong cinemas wholly commercialized styles which demand conventional narratives; this is indeed what conrms Wong as an uncompromising artist who is nevertheless able to command respect in the industry, as is evident from the directors ability to assemble all-star casts for his lm and to command big budgets (Teo, 1997: 198). Outside the cinema, where others may speak of lack, many in Hong Kong would indeed prefer to joke complacently or lament with a sense of nostalgia about that extra something they thought they had been able to secure in life in the decades leading up to days of 1997. In this very sense the lmic imaginary of jianghu we invoke here helps to undermine that extra dimension of culture where intense negotiations are revealed to be under way, allowing viewers to see what it is that they want to live for and live with. Is there no crisis? What is the nature of our crisis? Wherein lies our radical chance? How would we deal with the jianghu enyuan in our society, a community where the value and power of wugong have of late been wearing away? There are still much traces of despair and disappointment at a time when the future is deantly standing in front of you unknowable, though not unapproachable. Should despair and disappointment be piled up to the height of hope, one wonders if it might not still be possible to resist time with the utopian vision to lift oneself up from the mud and dust of the here-and-now. One wonders, indeed, if the worn affective edge of our wugong could still be sharp- ened, and activated, so as to allow us to stay on to re-imagine our past, present, and future in what Bloch would call a landscape of hope (Bloch, 1988: 717), F I GURE S OF HOP E 5 0 9 D o w n l o a d e d
B y :
[ L i n g n a n
I n t e r n a t i o n a l
L i b r a r y ]
A t :
1 0 : 5 0
1 9
J u l y
2 0 1 0 that invisible dimension of culture which we may still anticipate to be realized as our cultural imaginary in transit. For a politics of promise is so much more pragmatic than a politics of hope that when we are used to feeling indifferent toward the one, we tend to forget that rigorous engagement with the other can still make a difference. In this paper I have tried to analyse the utopian will to imagination for a livable future as bound in the gured time and space of the Hong Kong cultural imaginary of jianghu in the last phase of its colonial era. Through an extensive allegorical reading of lms, we have been looking at the world of lmic signi- cation conjured up through what I call the jianghu imaginary. My analysis traces the ideological and utopian impulses captured in relation to a whole emotional complex of anxiety, bewilderment and despair by some of the most creative local lmmakers: Ching, Hui, Tsui and Wong. In this way, I have attempted to outline the form and problematic of the cultural imaginary of Hong Kong in the tran- sitional years leading up to the historical handover of power in 1997. I have drawn theoretically from Castoriadiss notion of the social imaginary and Blochs aes- thetics of hope to focus on the textual and contextual re-constructions of the wuxia world. I have read allegorically a number of very unconventional martial arts swordplay lms made by and for Hong Kong in the last two decades, and identied different images/moments of the gurative martial hero in the genres imaginary signication of the swordsman: the mysterious and ambivalent pop-cultural historian in Tsuis dark Buttery Murders (1979), the disillusioned benevolent intellectual and the heartless, anti-nationalistic emperor in Huis deeply pessimistic Romance of Book and Sword (1987), the pragmatic hermit and the schizophrenic power-seeker in Ching/Tsuis euphoric Swordsman II (1992), and, nally the whole spectrum of heart-broken professionals, pseudo- professionals and anti-professionals in Wongs non-systemic Ashes of Time (1994). Pointing to the very uid ideological and affective moments in the lmic imagin- ary world, this range of wuxia gures have enabled us to estimate what has been left in a ruined culture for any utopian functions that remain. It allows us to immerse ourselves in deep, perhaps hopeful longings that tend toward the cul- tural anticipation for an unknown and unknowable future through and beyond 1997. It is my contention that the understanding of the popular imaginary at that unusual juncture of Hong Kongs history could begin with such an attempt to cope with this non-rewarding practice of hope. For we might indeed be able to recognize (or reject) it as a strangely subtle mediation in the process of our sur- vival through that collective crisis in our history shaped by so many unsettling forms of cultural anticipation and (mis)identication. C ULT UR AL S T UDI E S 51 0 D o w n l o a d e d
B y :
[ L i n g n a n
I n t e r n a t i o n a l
L i b r a r y ]
A t :
1 0 : 5 0
1 9
J u l y
2 0 1 0 Notes 1 For discussions of the impacts on the cultural imagination of Hong Kong, see Chan (1995, 1997a, b). 2 This, of course, is the function of ideology as proposed by Althusser in Ideol- ogy and ideological state apparatuses. See Althusser (1971: 162). 3 The distinction between wuxia and kungfu is usefully summarized by Teo (1997: 98). The difference in ghting style is crucial: sword-ghting is domi- nant in wuxia lms while st-ghting is almost exclusively for kungfu lms. Though the northern style wuxia and the southern style kungfu can be con- sidered two sides of the same coin, in the 1960s cinema audiences saw these action pictures as markedly different formats and action styles. Kungfu and sword-ghting wuxia pictures were clearly delineated (Teo, 1997: 98). By the early 1970s, the wuxia trend was already giving way to kungfu (Teo, 1997: 102), with the emergence later of such mega-stars as Bruce Lee and Jackie Chan. However, only the wuxia, set usually in fantastic medieval worlds, is the concern for this paper. For a detailed treatment of the kungfu genre, see Siu Leung Lis article in this issue. 4 The source of the martial world is the traditional wuxia ction, in which jianghu is often located beyond the reach of the government and its sphere of inuence. Jianghu and xiake are almost always inter-related; hence, the martial artist is supposed to lead a wandering life in jianghu, often as a result of deep disillusionment with the ofcial culture or civil service. In the imaginary world of wuxia, thus, the xiake can only excel when situated in jianghu. See Chen (1992: 1301). 5 Bloch (1988: 11):Without the utopian function it is impossible to explain the intellectual surplus that went beyond the status quo, because all anticipation must prove itself to the utopian function, the latter seizing all possible surplus content of the anticipation. 6 It must be emphasized that Bloch understands the utopian function not as a means for achieving an impossible ideal, but as the imagination for a real and concrete nal state that must be struggled for politically. See Plaice et al. (1986: xxviixxviii). 7 The lmic world of jianghu draws naturally from the tradition of wuxia ction since the Tang dynasty, when the typical xiake was returned to jianghu to prac- tise his heroic martial arts. For a historical trajectory of the imaginary of jianghu in the literary world of wuxia, see Chen (1992: 13061). Chen points out that the ctional world of jianghu is one of the basic generic features to mark the identity of the wuxia xiaoshuo (the wuxia novel). According to the literary tradition, this imaginary world of jianghu is cut off distinctly from the real world (where home belongs to), thereby providing the proper environment for the symbolic emergence of a proletariat da-xia (the master of xia), who would then perform his extraordinary deeds (realized discursively in formulaic conventions) in jianghu to save the world (Chen, 1992: 140). F I GURE S OF HOP E 5 1 1 D o w n l o a d e d
B y :
[ L i n g n a n
I n t e r n a t i o n a l
L i b r a r y ]
A t :
1 0 : 5 0
1 9
J u l y
2 0 1 0 8 See, for example, Chen (1992), Law et al. (1997), Lin (1981), and Liu (1967). 9 For a discussion of the patriarchal representation of women in the tradition of wuxia lms, see Koo (1981). For a reading of the sexual politics in Swordsman II, see Yau (1995). 10 See Castoriadis (1991: 220). 11 To borrow from Blochs phrase to capture the possible content of hope. In Bloch and Adorno (1964). 12 According to Benjamin,Allegories are in the realm of thought what ruins are in the realm of things . . . In other words, the object is henceforth incapable of projecting any meaning on its own it can only take on that meaning which the allegorist wishes to lend it; as cited in Jameson (1971: 71). 13 See Chan (1995) and Wong et al. (1997). 14 When it opened two months after Chungking Express, it was both condemned and praised in equal measure for its apparent inaccessibility (Teo, 1997: 197). 15 Culture is in this light taken to be the register of whatever goes beyond the merely instrumental or functional in a given institution of a society . . . and that which presents an invisible dimension cathected or invested positively as such by the individuals in the given society. See Castoriadis (1991: 220). 16 As cited in Jameson (1971: 62), where he writes of the Benjaminian approach to memory, thus:Psychologically, the drive toward unity takes the form of an obsession with the past and with memory. 17 The aesthetic strategy of this activation is what Bloch calls anticipatory illumi- nation. Due to this anticipatory illumination, art is not at all a totality, but rather only a perspective about something, an elaborated perspective of the portrayed objects themselves in regard to the immanent completion of these objects (emphasis added); see Bloch, Wish-landscape perspective in aes- thetics, in Bloch (1988: 70). References Althusser, Louis (1971) Ideology and ideological state apparatuses. In his (ed.) Lenin and Philosophy. Trans. Ben Brewster. London: NLB. Ashes of Time (Dongxie xidu) (1994) Dir. and written by Wong Kar-wai (Wang Jiawei), Scholar Films. Bloch, Ernst (1986) The Principle of Hope (19381947, rev. 1953, 1959), 3 vols. Trans. Neville Plaice, Stephen Plaice and Paul Knight. Cambridge, Mass.: MIT Press. (1988) The Utopian Function of Art and Literature: Selected Essays by Ernst Bloch. Trans. J. Zipes and F. Mecklenburg. Cambridge, Mass.: MIT Press. and Theodor W. Adorno (1964) Somethings missing: a discussion between Ernst Bloch and Theodor W. Adorno on the contradictions of Utopian longing. In Bloch (1988), 117. C ULT UR AL S T UDI E S 51 2 D o w n l o a d e d
B y :
[ L i n g n a n
I n t e r n a t i o n a l
L i b r a r y ]
A t :
1 0 : 5 0
1 9
J u l y
2 0 1 0 Buttery Murders, The (Die bian) (1979) Dir. Tsui Hark (Xu Ke), Seasonal Films. Castoriadis, Cornelius (1987) The Imaginary Institution of Society. Trans. Kathleen Blamey. Cambridge, Mass.: MIT and Oxford: Polity (Originally published 1975). (1991) The crisis of culture and the state. In David Ames Curtis (ed.) Phil- osophy, Politics, Autonomy: Essays in Political Philosophy. Oxford: Oxford Uni- versity Press, 21942. Chan, Ching-kiu Stephen (1995) Future un-imagined. Hong Kong Cultural Studies Bulletin, 4, 206. A modied Chinese version is included in Wong, Li and Chan (1997), 26580. (ed.) (1997a) Cultural Imaginary and Ideology: Studies in Contemporary Hong Kong Cultural Politics. Hong Kong: Oxford University Press. (1997b) The time and space of cultural imaginary: writing on the verge of postcolonial Hong Kong. In Chan (ed.) (1997a), xixx. Chen Pingyuan (1992) Qiangu Wenren Xiakemeng (Dreams of Xiake in the Literary Tra- dition). Beijing: Renmin wenxue. Foucault, Michel (1986) Of other spaces. Trans. Jay Miskowiec. Diacritics 16.1. Koo Siu-Feng (1981) Philosophy and tradition in the swordplay lm. In Lau and Leong (eds) (1981), 1732. Jameson, Fredric (1971) Marxism and Meaning: Twentieth-Century Dialectical Theories of Literature. Princeton: Princeton University Press. (1981) The Political Unconscious: Narrative as a Socially Symbolic Act. Ithaca: Cornell University Press. Lau Shing-hon, and Leong Mo-ling (eds) (1981) A Study of the Hong Kong Swordplay Film (19451980). Hong Kong: Hong Kong International Film Festival. Law Kar, Ng Ho and Cheuk Pak-tong (1997) Generic Studies in Hong Kong Cinema. Hong Kong: Oxford University Press. Li Cheuk-to (ed.) (1988) Changes in Hong Kong Society Through Cinema. Hong Kong: Hong Kong International Film Festival. Lin Nien-tung (1981) The Martial Arts Hero. In Lau and Leong (ed.) (1981), 716. Liu, James (1967) The Chinese Knight-Errant. London: Routledge. Ng Ho (1981) Jianghu re-visited: towards a reconstruction of the martial arts world. In Lau and Leong (ed.) (1981), 6386. Ngai, S. Y. Jimmy (1995) Four Films of Wong Kar-wai, Los Angeles. Hong Kong: Chan Mi-Ke. Plaice, Neville, Stephen Plaice and Paul Knight (1986) Translators introduction to The Principle of Hope. In Bloch (1986), xxviixxviii. Romance of Book and Sword, The (Shujian enchou lu), (1987) Dir. and written Ann Hui (Xu Anhua), Sil-Metropole. Shu Kei (1988) The television work of Ann Hui. In Li Cheuk-To (ed.) (1988), 4252. Swordsman II (Dongfang bubai) (1992) Dir. Ching Siu-tong (Cheng Xiaodong), written and produced by Tsui Hark, Film Workshop. Teo, Stephen (1997) Hong Kong Cinema: The Extra Dimension. London: BFI. F I GURE S OF HOP E 5 1 3 D o w n l o a d e d
B y :
[ L i n g n a n
I n t e r n a t i o n a l
L i b r a r y ]
A t :
1 0 : 5 0
1 9
J u l y
2 0 1 0 Wong, Wang-chi, Li Siu-leung, and Chan Ching-kiu Stephen (1997) Hong Kong Un- Imagined: History, Culture and the Future. Taipei: Rye Field. Yang, Mingyu (1995) China: once upon a time/Hong Kong: 1997, a critical study of contemporary Hong Kong martial arts lms. PhD Diss. University of Mary- land. Yau Ching (1995) Welcome to the show. Today, 28, 15360. C ULT UR AL S T UDI E S 51 4 D o w n l o a d e d