Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Where:
Ar = is the absorption rate
h = is the height of water
t = time
Determining the Drainage Actual Water Capacity:
Where:
Q = is the drainage water capacity
38
Ac = is the cover area of drainage
Ar = is the absorption rate
Determining the Volume of Precipitation:
NOTES
1.
en.wikipedia.org/wiki
2.
Microsoft Office Project 2007
39
Chapter 3
PRESENTATION, ANALYSIS AND DESIGN RESULT
This chapter presents the findings of the study. It includes the Project
Design and Computations, Design Result and Analysis and Interpretation of
Result. Tables, Figures and Design Computations will be presented with the
accompanying textual presentation that gives the information and analysis of
data presented.
Project Design Computations
The project design includes application of pervious concrete,
determination of the design section of the drainage, calculation of the total land
area and drainage cover area, calculation for the actual capacity of the drainage
cover, determining the volume of precipitation, design of reinforced concrete slab
and the design results.
Application of Pervious Concrete
This section shows the conventional concrete mix proportions, cross-
section of pervious concrete used in drainage sample, and pervious concrete
sample failure load (KN) tested by UTM.
Ratios of cement, fine and coarse aggregate are the common method of
expressing the proportion of ingredients of concrete mixture. For example, the
conventional mixture shows a concrete mix proportion 1:2:4 means that for every
part of cement used in the mixture, a corresponding two parts fine aggregate and
40
four parts coarse aggregates should also be added. But for the applying the
proportions developed by the researcher of the pervious concrete, as they
treated this as a special type of concrete (pervious concrete) with no sand as fine
aggregate and only use 3/8 in pea size of coarse aggregate and certain amount
of cement, we come up to use the pervious concrete mix proportioned by
conventional method.
Table 1
Pervious Concrete Mix Proportioned by Conventional Method
CLASS MIXTURE CEMENT (40 KG/ BAG) GRAVEL (cu.m.)
A 1: 4 1/3 1 4 1/3 box
B 1: 4 1 4 1/2box
Table 1 shows the pervious concrete mix proportioned by mass and it
explained that for every part of cement used in the mixture, a corresponding four
and one third parts to four and a half coarse aggregate should also be added.
The water cement ratio is usually expressed in mass. The cement and aggregate
ratio are still the same, the amount of the cement is changed and corresponding
amount of aggregate follows.
Table 2
Pervious Concrete Mix Proportioned by Mass (kg/m
3
)
MATERIAL MIX 1 MIX 2 MIX 3 MIX 4
Cement (kg/m
3
) 356 360 362 366
Coarse Aggregate,
3/8 (kg/m
3
)
1547 1560 1573 1587
Water (kg/m
3
) 96 97 96 101
w/cm 0.27 0.27 0.27 0.28
41
Table 2 explained that the mixture of pervious concrete is in mass (kg)
and for every 1 cubic meter of pervious concrete it should have a 360 kg of
cement plus 1547 kg of 3/8 (inch) pea size gravel and 96 kg of water.
The table 3 shows the pervious concrete sample failure load in Kilo
Newton (KN) tested by the Universal Testing Machine (UTM).
Table 3
Pervious Concrete Sample Failure Load (KN)
DAYS MIX 1 MIX 2 MIX 3 MIX 4
7 - - - 200
14 173 222 150 -
28 205 335 110 295
The figure below shows the detail of said sample of pervious concrete.
Figure 16
Pervious Concrete
42
The estimated cement water and aggregates for the sample of pervious
concrete are shown below.
For Cement (Class A Mixture)
TOTAL VOLUME = 0.38 m x 1.2 m x 0.08 m = 0.0365 m
3
= 1.2885ft
3
Cement used = (1.2885 ft
3
) = 11.894Kg
For Gravel;
Gravel used = total volume
= 0.35 m x 1.2 m x 0.08 m = 0.0365 m
3
= 1.2885 ft
3
For Water;
Water used = x 0.0365 m
3
= 3.504 Kg.
=
= 3.504 x 10
-3
m
3
x
= 3.504 liters of water
Summary;
Cement = 11.894 Kg
3/8 Gravel = 1.2885 ft
3
Water = 3.504 Kg (mass) = 3.504 liters (volume)
43
Determination of the Design Section of the Drainage
The researcher provides the design section of the Bio-Ecological Planter
Box Drainage Design which can suit to the discharge capacity of the drainage
cover.
Figure 17
Bio-Ecological Planter Box Drainage
The top cover area of the Planter Box Drainage Design with a sample
width (0.35m) and length (L) will used in determining the discharge capacity of
the drainage cover.
The analysis of the velocity on common drainage refers to the total
distance traveled over the period of time. This by applying the concept of Dr.
Apostol an expert on the water studies. Determining the velocity of water through
a simple experiment by putting the small piece of paper on the drainage and then
record the time such paper passes over the length of the drainage. But the
researchers conduct the special type of drainage (Planter Box Drainage Design)
Grass Turfing
Soil Less Potting Medium
Soil
Coconut Husk
Geotextile / Used Clothes
Pervious Concrete
44
which has its critical velocity or absorption rate flows on its drainage cover
(pervious concrete with soil and plants).
For further understanding, the researcher conducted the experiments on
calculating the absorption rate of the drainage cover with respect to the different
mediums and its thickness.
Figure 18
Cylindrical Sample
Below are the procedures of the experiment
1. Make a sample cover of the planter box drainage design.
2. Calculate the volume of water to use in attaining the water height of 0.1 m.
3. Pour the water to the sample cover and record the time it will take for the
water to have a zero value of height (H).
45
4. Repeat steps 2 and 3 up to five trials.
5. Calculate the average velocity.
Table 4
Trials for Absorption Rate
Trials Height of water Time(s) Rate(m/s)
1 0.010 m 9.36 0.001068
2 0.010 m 9.12 0.001096
3 0.010 m 9.40 0.001064
4 0.010 m 9.45 0.001058
5 0.010 m 9.34 0.001071
Trial 1 comes up with a rate of 0.001068m/sec by dividing the measured
0.01m height to the conducted time measured 9.36sec. Trial 2 comes up with a
rate of 0.001096m/sec by dividing the measured 0.01m height and the conducted
time measured 9.12sec. Trial 3 comes up with a rate of 0.001064m/sec by
dividing the measured 0.01m height and the conducted time measured 9.40sec.
Trial 4 comes up with a rate of 0.001058m/sec by dividing the measured 0.01m
height and the conducted time measured 9.45sec. Trial 5 comes up with a rate of
0.00107m/sec by dividing the measured 0.01m height and the conducted time
measured 9.34sec.
After accomplishing the trial and errors for the absorption rate, the
researchers compute the average rate with respect to the five trials and use the
computed average as the top cover absorption rate of the Planter Box Drainage
46
Design. From the computation done by the researchers, the computed mean
absorption rate is 0.0010714m/sec.
Calculate the Total Land Area and Drainage Cover Area
The total land area refers to the areas of lots concerned for the purpose of
calculating the volume of precipitation while drainage cover area is for computing
the covers capacity and their comparison. The researchers provide sample
areas as shown in the table.
Table 5
Average Land Area and Drainage Cover Area
Classification
Average Lot
Area
Drainage
Width
Drainage
Length
Total
Drainage
Cover Area
Residential 400 sq.m 0.35 m 10 m 3.5 sq.m
School 5,000 sq.m 0.4 m 25 m 10.0 sq.m
Barangay 500,000 sq.m 0.5 m 750 m 375 sq.m
Table 5 shows the average lot area in each different classification with the
specified drainage cover area. Average lot area is specified by the researchers
as assumed to be the average in different classifications. The total drainage
cover areas were computed by multiplying the width of the drainage to its actual
length.
47
Calculate for the Actual Capacity of the drainage cover
The researchers calculated the actual capacity of the drainage cover
design by using same formula from hydraulics and fluid mechanics. Thus, to
determine the capacity (Q), it will be equal to the product of the mean Absorption
rate (Ar) and top cover area (Ac). Using this formula, the researchers can now
compute for the discharge capacity of the drainage cover design.
The average Absorption rate (Ar) was calculated through the experiment
of the researchers which happens to be equal to 0.0010714m/sec. The area of
the top cover drainage design (see Figure 16) on the other hand was determined
through direct measurements that have a width of 0.35 m with the drainage
length (L), the drainage cover area will then be equal to 0.35 x L (m
2
) for
residential and so on.
For Residential For School
Q = Ac Ar Q = Ac Ar
Q = 0.35m (10m) (0.0010714m/sec)
Q=0.40m(25m)(0.0010714m/sec)
Q = 0.00375m
3
/s Q = 0.010714m
3
/s
For Barangay
Q = Ac Ar
Q = 0.50m (750m) (0.0010714m/sec) Q = 0.401775m
3
/s
Therefore the amount of the discharge that the planter box drainage
design can hold is 0.00375m
3
/s for residential area, 0.010714m
3
/s for school
48
area, and 0.401775m
3
/s for barangay. This magnitude will serve as reference to
see if the drainage could carry the volume of precipitation in particular areas. If
the computed actual discharge of the drainage cover is lower than the volume of
precipitation in different classification, the drainage needs to have improvement.
Determining the Volume of Precipitation
In determining intensity duration of the rainfall and frequency data the
researchers gathered data from the Philippine Atmospherical Geophysical
Astronomical and Service Administration (PAGASA). The said office conducted
studies about the classification of rainfall intensity in specified time as shown in
the table below.
Table 6
Rainfall Intensity Classification
Category 6-Hour 12-Hour 24-Hour
Light <15mm <30mm <60mm
Moderate 15 45mm 30 - 90mm 60 - 180mm
Heavy >45mm >90mm >180mm
The table shows the classification of a different rainfall intensity based on
PAGASA.
49
Table 7
Equivalent Average Intensity (mm/Hr) Of Computed Extreme Values
Category Light Moderate Heavy
Intensity <2.5 2.5-7.5 >7.5
This table shows the corresponding Intensity in mm/hr of rainfall
classifications. Light rain comes up with the intensity of 2.5 mm/hr by dividing
15mm to corresponding 6hrs. Moderate rain comes up with the intensity of 2.5-
7.5 mm/hr by dividing 15-45 mm to corresponding 6hrs. Heavy rain comes up
with the intensity of 7.5mm/hr by dividing 45mm to corresponding 6hrs.
To determine the volume of precipitation the researchers used the
illustrated data. The table contains rainfall intensity in every gauging period and
also the projected time (return period) when rain intensity is in different category.
For further understanding the researchers computed the volume of precipitation
in different land classification as shown in the table below.
Table 8
Comparison of Volume of Precipitation to the Actual Discharge of Drainage
Cover
Category Light Moderate Heavy Actual Discharge
Residential
0.000267
m
3
/s
0.00056
m
3
/s
0.000844
m
3
/s
0.00375 m
3
/s
School
0.00333
m
3
/s
0.006944
m
3
/s
0.01056
m
3
/s
0.010714 m
3
/s
Barangay
0.333
m
3
/s
0.694
m
3
/s
1.0556
m
3
/s
0.401775 m
3
/s
50
Therefore the drainage design is applicable in residential and school area
since the resulted volume of precipitation which classified as light, moderate and
heavy rain are less than its actual capacity. But for barangay area, the drainage
failed to hold the heavy and moderate rainfall intensity, therefore the drainage
needs to have improvement for this area since it could only holds light rainfall
intensity. See computations below.
Computing the volume of precipitation in residential;
1. Vp(light rain) = Rainfall Intensity (light rain) x Land Area
= (2.4mm/hr x 1m/1000mm x 1hr/3600sec) x 400 sq.m
Vp(light rain) = 0.0002667 m
3
/s
2. Vp(moderate rain) = Rainfall Intensity (moderate rain) x Land Area
= (5.0 mm/hr x 1m/1000mm x 1hr/3600sec) x 400 sq.m
Vp(moderate rain) = 0.0005556 m
3
/s
3. Vp(heavy rain) = Rainfall Intensity (heavy rain) x Land Area
= (7.6 mm/hr x 1m/1000mm x 1hr/3600sec) x 400 sq.m
Vp(heavy rain) = 0.000844 m
3
/s
Computing the volume of precipitation in schools;
1. Vp(light rain) = Rainfall Intensity (light rain) x Land Area
= (2.4mm/hr x 1m/1000mm x 1hr/3600sec) x 5,000 sq.m
Vp(light rain) = 0.00333 m
3
/s
2. Vp(moderate rain) = Rainfall Intensity (moderate rain) x Land Area
= (5.0 mm/hr x 1m/1000mm x 1hr/3600sec) x 5,000 sq.m
51
Vp(moderate rain) = 0.006944 m
3
/s
3. Vp(heavy rain) = Rainfall Intensity (heavy rain) x Land Area
= (7.6 mm/hr x 1m/1000mm x 1hr/3600sec) x 5,000 sq.m
Vp(heavy rain) = 0.01056 m
3
/s
Computing the volume of precipitation in Barangay;
1. Vp(light rain) = Rainfall Intensity (light) x Land Area
= (2.4 mm/hr x 1m/1000mm x 1hr/3600sec) x 500,000 sq.m
Vp(light rain) = 0.333 m
3
/s
2. Vp(moderate rain) = Rainfall Intensity (moderate) x Land Area
= (5 mm/hr x 1m/1000mm x 1hr/3600sec) x 500,000 sq.m
Vp(moderate rain) = 0.694 m
3
/s
3. Vp(heavy rain) = Rainfall Intensity (heavy rain) x Land Area
= (7.6 mm/hr x 1m/1000mm x 1hr/3600sec) x 500,000 sq.m
Vp(heavy rain) = 1.0556 m
3
/s
Design of Reinforced Concrete Slab
In designing of slab, the researchers adopted the design of reinforced
concrete one way slab through satisfying its condition (the ratio of short span to
long span which is less than 0.5). The researchers 80mm thick and used section
7.6.5(ACI Code 388-77) says In wall and slabs other than concrete joist
construction, primarily flexural reinforcement shall not be spaced farther apart
than 3 times the wall/slab thickness, nor 18 in.
The reinforcement is summarized in the table below.
52
Table 9
Schedule of Reinforcement for Slab
Description Thickness Dimension Location Short Span Long Span
Slab 80mm 0.5m x 1.2m
Bottom
Bars
12mm dia @
240mm
-
Top
Bars
-
10mm dia @
240mm
Estimate of Costs
In accordance to the book Simplified Construction Estimate published by
Max B. Fajardo Jr., one method in proportioning the concrete into its components
is called the Volume Method. It is the most common and convenient method that
had been practiced in estimating then cost of concrete construction.
The table below is vital in estimating concrete proportion by using volume
method.
Table 10
Concrete Proportions
Class Mixture
Cement Sand Gravel
40kg/bag 50kg/bag cu.m cu.m
AA 1 : 1 : 3 12.0 9.5 0.50 1.0
A 1 : 2 : 4 9.0 7.0 0.50 1.0
B 1 : 2 : 5 7.5 6.0 0.50 1.0
C 1 : 3 : 6 6.0 5.0 0.50 1.0
53
By following the procedures in Volume Method, the researchers needed to
calculate the total volume of concrete used. To do so, they determined the total
length of the drainage, the cross-sectional width and thickness of the cover.
The volume of concrete subtracted by the volume of reinforcement
assumed to be 25% of the volume of concrete computed will show the way to the
gross volume of concrete.
Setting for a 40 kg bag of cement, the researchers used table 10 to
determine the multiplier needed for calculating the fractions of cement, sand, and
gravel.
After determining the amount or quantity of each material used, the
researchers determined the cost of each quantities. The proceeding table
presents the cost of the materials used in the construction of drainage system.
To be able to estimate the total costs of each material, the researchers
multiply the total quantity of materials to their corresponding costs; the results
were tabulated as follows:
Table 11
Material Cost for Conventional Drainage
Materials Unit Qty. Price Cost
Cement (PORTLAND) 1 bag 1.762 bags 230.00 405.26
Gravel 1 cu.m 0.098 cu.m 700.00 68.60
Sand 1 cu.m 0.196 cu.m 650.00 127.40
G.I. (tie wire) 1 kilo 0.032 80.00 2.56
12mm 1 piece 1.8 180.00 324.00
10mm 1 piece 2 128.00 256.00
Total Cost = Php. 1183.82
54
Table 12
Material Cost for Bio-Ecological Planter Box Drainage
Materials Unit Qty. Price Cost
Cement
(PORTLAND)
1 bag 1.3302 bags 230.00 305.946
Gravel 1 cu.m 0.0739 cu.m 700.00 51.73
Sand 1 cu.m 0.1478 cu.m 650.00 96.07
10mm 1 piece 1.4 pcs 128.00 179.20
12mm 1 piece 1.4 pcs 180.00 252.00
Cement 1 kg 10.955 Kg 7.00 76.685
3/8 Gravel 1 balde(1 ft
3
) 1.1867 ft
3
40.00 47.468
Geotextile / Used Clothes 1 m
2
0.456 m
2
40.00 18.24
Total Cost = Php. 1027.339
Planter Box Drainage Design costs Php. 1027.339 which is less than the
cost of Conventional Drainage Design, Php.1,183.82. This means that it is more
economical to construct the Bio-Ecological Planter Box Drainage.
55
Chapter 4
SUMMARY OF DESIGN RESULT, CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATIONS
This chapter includes the summary of design result, conclusions and
recommendations.
Summary of Design Result
Based from the results of analysis and computations done for the design
of the drainage, the following findings were finalized and adopted:
1. The most effective mix proportion of the pervious concrete applicable for
Bio-Ecological Planter Box Drainage Design, considering 0.38 m width,
120 m length and 0.08 m thick is composed of 11.894 kg of cement,
1.2885