Professional Documents
Culture Documents
4.
a. Reconciliation of social work values
b. Places value of social justice at center stage
c. Does not blame the individual for their difficulties
d. Encourages us to adopt a multi dimensional analysis
e. Ensures social workers recognize the effects of cultural and social
structures on service users lives
f. Values the contribution of local change processes can make in achieving
on social change
5.
a. Collaborative, highly structures, time limited, problem focused
b. Crisis intervention is a form of problem solving used for the treatment of
trauma
c. Joint effort between social worker and service user
d. Develops clients capacities
6. Parton: structures of knowledge, claims and practices through we understand,
explain and decide things. They are frameworks of social organization that make
some actions possible while precluding others.
a. Sets of language practices that shape our thoughts, actions and words
b. Ex. Biomedicine, economics and law
7. What is theory:
• Devised to analyze, predict, or explain the nature or behaviour of a phenomena
that could be used for the basis for action
• It is socially constructed
9. What would the development of Healy’s “framework of practice” involve for you?
What does yours “look” like now?
• Framework of practice: refers to the combination of formal knowledge and skills
and informal knowledge and skills developed by the social worker in practice
• So basically, how does theory impact your everyday practical work, living, and
view?
• It is meant to provide direction and guidance for understanding the process of life
and for striving to achieve well-being
• Looks for balance and well being in life. If one of the wheel sections is not in tune
it affects the performance of the others
• Elders are seen as the most valuable to the community because of their ability to
pass down wisdom
• Hierarchy- (can’t really remember and don’t have any notes on it but think…) it
starts with earth, then nature, then elders….
12. what are the waves of systems theories? How are they different?
1) 1st wave: General systems theory
• Developed in the 1930’s, and adopted to social work in the 1960’s
- Create a partnership
- Ask how client sees situation and what they want to achieve
• Behaviour of the whole system is greater than the sum of its parts (143)
• Do not see people as victims of their social context; nor see them as entirely free
agents
21. (p117)
• Pre intervention phase: understanding the contect of the intervention (prior to
and during session 1)
• Step 1: Defing target problems (session 1)
• Step 2: Contracting (Session 2)
• Step 3: Problem-solving implementation (Session 3-7)
• Step 4: Termination (Last session)
23. p 139-140
• An ecomap is a graphic system for viewing the relevant connected case elements
together within a boundary that clarifies for the practitioner, the case system as
the focus of work
• It can enhance client opportunities to participate in the system
• The service provider and the service user work together to gather data about an
analyze the impact of multiple systems on the service users situation
• Many theorist use an ecomap to assist in the assessment process
• Many social workers use the Brofenbrenners approach in which rings represent
different levels (Micro, Macro, Mezzo)
26. Audre Lorde is a Carribean-American write, poet and activist. She criticized first-
wave feminists for only focusing on the white, middle-class experience of women. She is
considered a founder of "black feminism" she focused on the intersectionality of race &
gender and the differences in the female experience
27. pg 197 Post-structuralism: critiques the idea that we can deconstruct a structure
without coming from a specific context. Post-modernism: truth is subjective. Post-
colonialism: a reaction to the idea of superiority/progress
28. pg 206-212 adopt a curious & open, rather than "truth-seeking" position towards the
service user. Seek to assess and transform the narratives that construct our lives, seperate
the person from the problem, extrenalize conversations
29. Black pg 12 group work instills hope, provides cohesion, is altruistic, models
behaviour, promotes interpersonal learning and offers support. Group work is necessary
because of oppressive societal culture which isolates, seperates and creates a feeling of
powerlessness and alienation
31. Solution focused: don't focus on the problem, but on the solution,
there is no connection between the problem and solution. Focus on behaviour, orientation
is future, not interested in problem manifestation and pastTask-centred: work on small
parts of the big picture, practical concerns rather than emotional problems
33. (personal preference based, so you may all choose something different) Task-centred
because you need to solve what immediate practical concerns you can to keep the people
alive and well-nourished
34. (personal preference based, so you may all choose something different) Strengths
Perspective, because it emerged in that field and focuses on skills rather than deficits and
labels
36. (personal preference based, so you may all choose something different) Narrative
therapy, because it focuses on the narratives that shape us
37. Both. Grand theories deal with the larger understanding of social phenomena, the
aboriginal worldview qualifies as such, Aboriginal approaches also include practice
concepts Hanohano
• This can conflict with client’s needs, and also employer demands
• Can provide us with insights into the dilemmas facing service users and diversify
our options for responding
• Healy takes on a post-modern perspective by saying that all the theories presented
in her book, have pros and cons and that there isn’t one good way to practice
Healy chapter # 5
Theories for practice draw on discourses from other discipline & fields (i.e. AOP from
sociology & consumer rts)
- ideas from service discourses + specific purposes & experiences = Theory for Practice
- i.e. problem solving approaches developed from service users having difficulty
w/adjusting to daily living
Barriers to theory
- traditional forms of theory building have separated theory development from its
application
Theory can:
- i.e. Strengths Perspective helps us see clients’ strengths & capacities that might be
invisible to us & others
- i.e. Task-centred approach – one of the best known examples of this drive to create
scientifically grounded SW practice
- Evidence based practice theory is effective in child protection, as is high risk & so
requires validation & helps to formulate reasoning & evaluate their own work
- Decisions are often based on perceptions & feelings as well as material facts (therefore
shit is messy)
- In assessing baby: (whether they are neglected). i,e, curdled milk in bottle, age-
appropriate weight, affection for child
Reflective approach
Reflection in Action
Reflexive Approach
– recognizes SW’s are always making knowledge in practice, but prioritizes experiential
& tacit knowledge over formal knowledge.
5 Theories of SW Practice
1. Problem-Solving Perspective
2. Systems Perspective
3. Strengths Perspective
4. AOP
1. institution
3. frameworks of practice
Chap 6 (Jordan)
Paper – suggests ways in which students can be helped to remain in uncertainty &
interrogate their knowledge & case reasoning
Min points:
- SW often receives conflicting info & interpretations (i.e. Mother, child and previous
case worker)
- i.e. Victoria Climbie key staff failed to process accurately & decisively upon medical
info. On other hand, Laming report stated that SW was criticized for failing to critically
analyze info, given to her by aunt
- Report: SW was too passive & critical for carving too much certainty from
contradictory info
- Through confirmation bias, whereby people will seek out info that supports original
hypothesis, people often miss important info as in case w/Victoria
- necessary to interrogate carefully how we use theory to what purpose & to what effect
- In many situations, the certain thing is not necessarily the right thing
- Pressure to ‘handle cases quickly & efficiently’ may predispose SW’s to use formal
knowledge in way that shores up anchor hypothesis when we may instead want to
encourage destabilization
- Through problem based enquiry & action learning models, experiential techniques
(roleplay)
Conclusion
- broader approach that encompasses practical reasoning, emotion, & most of all
intelligence that is disciplined & creative
• It was done to prove that theory is always used. Participant said she didn’t use
theory, although evident proved contrary
Questions
7. What is theory:
• Devised to analyze, predict, or explain the nature or behaviour of a phenomena
that could be used for the basis for action
• It is socially constructed
9. What would the development of Healy’s “framework of practice” involve for you?
What does yours “look” like now?
• Framework of practice: refers to the combination of formal knowledge and skills
and informal knowledge and skills developed by the social worker in practice
• So basically, how does theory impact your everyday practical work, living, and
view?
• It is meant to provide direction and guidance for understanding the process of life
and for striving to achieve well-being
• Looks for balance and well being in life. If one of the wheel sections is not in tune
it affects the performance of the others
• Elders are seen as the most valuable to the community because of their ability to
pass down wisdom
• Hierarchy- (can’t really remember and don’t have any notes on it but think…) it
starts with earth, then nature, then elders….
12. what are the waves of systems theories? How are they different?
1) 1st wave: General systems theory
• Developed in the 1930’s, and adopted to social work in the 1960’s
- Create a partnership
- Ask how client sees situation and what they want to achieve
• Behaviour of the whole system is greater than the sum of its parts (143)
• Do not see people as victims of their social context; nor see them as entirely free
agents
Parish, Burry and Pabst: Providing Comprehensive Case Management Services to
Urban Women with HIV/AIDS and Their Families
• Although HIV/Aids does not make any racial, gender or cultural distinctions for
women, particular urban-dwelling women of colour, it represents a challenge that
is unparalleled by any other disease
• Comprehensive, multi-systems case management, including home visits,
transportation, and housing support, provides a means by which problem solving
and advocacy are provided and an effective way of coordinating the use of and
communication among multiple agencies
• Poor women are at a disproportionate risk of HIV/AIDS, regardless of their
lifestyles
• In the face of challenges to survival such as poverty, domestic violence, high-
crime neighborhoods, homelessness, and other difficulties in meeting basic needs,
the management of HIV/AIDS related needs easily becomes compromised. Such
compromises can jeopardize the survival of women
Women's Risk Factors and Case Management Issues
• Case managements has gone through many transitions
• First developed as a means of coordinating the complex needs of recently
deinstitutionalized chronically mentally ill persons, case management has also
evolved into an effective means of coordinating services that are needed by an
array of at risk populations, such as persons with disabilities, elderly people,
cancer patients etc.
• Case management reflects various core social work principles of problem solving
within a clients environmental context and achieving change in the person, the
environment, or both
• Case management provides a crucial means of providing continuity and
coordination of services among various agencies and providers and minimizing
the risk of separate agencies proposing duplicating or contradictory interventions
• Case management is also a means of ensuring accountability for providing
services to clients in need
• Especially when families who are living in chronic poverty are accustomed to and
distrustful of the intrusive elements that are common to many public agencies,
comprehensive case management provided by a single source can both enhance
the effective use of resources and minimize the potentially detrimental
intrusiveness of multiple providers efforts
o Ex. The historical and medical patterns may further contribute to the
reluctance of African American and other women of colour to accept
traditional Western medical treatment protocols
**Case managers are in an ideal position to advocate and negotiate
systems on behalf of those who need such prescriptions to manage
their medical conditions
• Through effective case management, persons living with HIV/AIDS can be
provided more comprehensive services to coordinate the complexities od their
medical regimes, find housing, receive adequate nutrition etc.
• Comprehensive case management is also suited to providing he linkages
necessary to sustain abstinence and reduce the risks of relapse in cases involving
substance abuse
The Back to Basics Project
• Initiated in 1999, the back to basics project was a 3 year intervention that was
designed to serve as a national demonstration project
• It provided comprehensive, multi-system case management services to 145
families in an urban mid Atlantic city who had been homeless and ho had a
member whose HIV/Aids status was either newly diagnosed or newly disclosed
• The majority of the families had multiple members with HIV/AIDS
• The project had several major goals
o To provide 80 families with crisis intervention services
Affordable housing, food, clothing etc.
o Enhance the stability of the participant
o Wanted the participants to become part of a supportive, interactive
community of families with members living with HIV/AIDS
• Back to basics had a focus group for clients where clients and their family
members could discuss both their difficulties and their success
Descriptive Findings
Clients
• 145 families completed the intake process
• The projects original goal of providing service for 80 families over a 3 year period
was exceeded by over 80%
• Most of the clients and their families were in crisis and had an immediate need for
food, clothing and shelter
Rent, Utilities, Housing and Food
• Over 2/3 of the families had histories of delinquent payments of rent that
compromised their eligibility for establishing utility services and or being
accepted for leases
• Other challenges to providing assistance with rent and utilities included the
shrinking rental housing market and clients with criminal backgrounds
• Housing needs: clients housing needs remained a crucial aspect of case
management throughout the project
• Food: during the course of the project 58% needed food once, 25% needed food
twice and 10% needed food on as many as five occasions
Income
• Poverty is a consistently significant issue for women with HIV/AIDS
• Sources of income included;
o Supplemental Security Income
o EI
o Disability funds
o Transitional Emergence Medical Assistance
Out of Home Placements of Children
• Women with HIV/AIDS and a history of homelessness are at a high risk of haing
their children place in out of home care because of their unstable housing and the
potential for medical crises
• It was therefore important that these women identify and establish child care
resources, so that places could be in place if out of home care was necessary
Ongoing HIV/AIDS Education and Support Services
• Back to Basics project was to establish a system of ongoing support services that
would be readily accessible to families.
• At the end of the project several support services were in place, and others were
being developed and pilot tested
Barriers to Achieving Stability
• Four primary barriers in clients achieving stability in the project
o Poverty
o Limitations resulting from poor credit histories
o Difficulty following through on tasks
o Substance abuse
• Other barriers
o Lack of transportation
o Limited housing resources for clients
o Limited follow through on tasks
DISCUSSION AND IMPLICATIONS
• Relatively small caseloads (approx 15) allowed staff to work closely in an
empowering manner with the women to contribute to their movement toward
independence
• The most important implication of this project was the complexity of the lives and
needs of women with HIV/AIDS
• The lives and needs of women with HIV/AIDS are multi-faced and demanding
• The back to basics project provided comprehensive, community based case
management services for women who were otherwise at risk of receiving
inadequate services to meet their needs