Professional Documents
Culture Documents
N
o
i
s
e
S
p
e
c
s
C
o
n
f
u
s
i
n
g
A
N
-
1
0
4
National Semiconductor
Application Note 104
May 1974
Noise Specs Confusing
Its really all very simpleonce you understand it Then
heres the inside story on noise for those of us who havent
been designing low noise amplifiers for ten years
You hear all sorts of terms like signal-to-noise ratio noise
figure noise factor noise voltage noise current noise pow-
er noise spectral density noise per root Hertz broadband
noise spot noise shot noise flicker noise excess noise
IF noise fluctuation noise thermal noise white noise pink
noise popcorn noise bipolar spike noise low noise no
noise and loud noise No wonder not everyone understands
noise specifications
In a case like noise it is probably best to sort it all out from
the beginning So in the beginning there was noise and
then there was signal The whole idea is to have the noise
very small compared to the signal or conversely we desire
a high signal-to-noise ratio SN Now it happens that SN is
related to noise figure NF noise factor F noise power
noise voltage e
n
and noise current i
n
To simplify matters it
also happens that any noisy channel or amplifier can be
completely specified for noise in terms of two noise genera-
tors e
n
and i
n
as shown in Figure 1
TLH74141
FIGURE 1 Noise Characterization of Amplifier
All we really need to understand are NF e
n
and i
n
So here
is a rundown on these three
NOISE VOLTAGE e
n
or more properly EQUIVALENT
SHORT-CIRCUIT INPUT RMS NOISE VOLTAGE is simply
that noise voltage which would appear to originate at the
input of the noiseless amplifier if the input terminals were
shorted It is expressed in nanovolts per root Hertz nV0Hz
at a specified frequency or in microvolts in a given frequen-
cy band It is determined or measured by shorting the input
terminals measuring the output rms noise dividing by am-
plifier gain and referencing to the input Hence the term
equivalent noise voltage An output bandpass filter of
known characteristic is used in measurements and the
measured value is divided by the square root of the band-
width 0B if data is to be expressed per unit bandwidth or per
root Hertz The level of e
n
is not constant over the frequen-
cy band typically it increases at lower frequencies as shown
in Figure 2 This increase is 1f NOISE
NOISE CURRENT i
n
or more properly EQUIVALENT
OPEN-CIRCUIT RMS NOISE CURRENT is that noise which
TLH74142
FIGURE 2 Noise Voltage and Current for an Op Amp
occurs apparently at the input of the noiseless amplifier due
only to noise currents It is expressed in picoamps per root
Hertz pA0Hz at a specified frequency or in nanoamps in a
given frequency band It is measured by shunting a capaci-
tor or resistor across the input terminals such that the noise
current will give rise to an additional noise voltage which is
i
n
x R
in
(or X
cin
) The output is measured divided by amplifi-
er gain referenced to input and that contribution known to
be due to e
n
and resistor noise is appropriately subtracted
from the total measured noise If a capacitor is used at the
input there is only e
n
and i
n
X
cin
The i
n
is measured with a
bandpass filter and converted to pA0Hz if appropriate typi-
cally it increases at lower frequencies for op amps and bipo-
lar transistors but increases at higher frequencies for field-
effect transistors
NOISE FIGURE NF is the logarithm of the ratio of input
signal-to-noise and output signal-to-noise
NF e 10 Log
(SN)
in
(SN)
out
(1)
where S and N are power or (voltage)
2
levels
This is measured by determining the SN at the input with
no amplifier present and then dividing by the measured SN
at the output with signal source present
The values of R
gen
and any X
gen
as well as frequency must
be known to properly express NF in meaningful terms This
is because the amplifier i
n
x Z
gen
as well as R
gen
itself pro-
duces input noise The signal source in Figure 1 contains
some noise However e
sig
is generally considered to be
noise free and input noise is present as the THERMAL
NOISE of the resistive component of the signal generator
impedance R
gen
This thermal noise is WHITE in nature as it
contains constant NOISE POWER DENSITY per unit band-
width It is easily seen from Equation 2 that the e
n
2
has the
units V
2
Hz and that (e
n
) has the units V0Hz
e
R
2 e 4kTRB (2)
where T is the temperature in K
R is resistor value in X
B is bandwidth in Hz
k is Boltzmans constant
C1995 National Semiconductor Corporation RRD-B30M115Printed in U S A
RELATION BETWEEN e
n
i
n
NF
Now we can examine the relationship between e
n
and i
n
at
the amplifier input When the signal source is connected
the e
n
appears in series with the e
sig
and e
R
The i
n
flows
through R
gen
thus producing another noise voltage of value
i
n
x R
gen
This noise voltage is clearly dependent upon the
value of R
gen
All of these noise voltages add at the input in
rms fashion that is as the square root of the sum of the
squares Thus neglecting possible correlation between e
n
and i
n
the total input noise is
e
N
2 e
e
n
2 a
e
R
2 a
i
n
2 R
gen
2
(3)
Further examination of the NF equation shows the relation-
ship of e
N
i
n
and NF
NF e 10 log
S
in
x N
out
S
out
x N
in
e 10 log
S
in
G
p
e
N
2
S
in
G
p e
R
2
where G
p
e power gain
e 10 log
e
N
2
e
R
2
e 10 log
e
n
2 a
e
R
2 a
i
n
2 R
gen
2
e
R
2
NF e 10 log
1 a
e
n
2 a i
n
2
R
gen
2
e
R
2 J
(4)
Thus for small R
gen
noise voltage dominates and for large
R
gen
noise current becomes important A clear advantage
accrues to FET input amplifiers especially at high values of
R
gen
as the FET has essentially zero i
n
Note that for an
NF value to have meaning it must be accompanied by a
value for R
gen
as well as frequency
CALCULATING TOTAL NOISE e
N
We can generate a plot of e
N
for various values of R
gen
if
noise voltage and current are known vs frequency Such a
graph is shown in Figure 3 drawn from Figure 2 To make
this plot the thermal noise e
R
of the input resistance must
be calculated from Equation 2 or taken from the graph of
Figure 4 Remember that each term in Equation 3 must be
squared prior to addition so the data fromFigure 4 and from
Figure 2 is squared A sample of this calculation follows
TLH74143
FIGURE 3 Total Noise for the Op Amp of Figure 2
TLH74144
FIGURE 4 Thermal Noise of Resistor
Example 1 Determine total equivalent input noise per unit
bandwidth for an amplifier operating at 1 kHz from a source
resistance of 10 kX Use the data fromFigures 2 and 4
1 Read e
R
fromFigure 4 at 10 kX the value is 127 nV0Hz
2 Read e
n
fromFigure 2 at 1 kHz the value is 95 nV0Hz
3 Read i
n
fromFigure 2 at 1 kHz the value is 068 pA0Hz
Multiply by 10 kX to obtain 68 nV0Hz
4 Square each term individually and enter into Equation 3
e
N
e
0
e
n
2 a
e
R
2 a
i
n
2
R
gen
2
e
0
95
2 a 12
2 a 68
2 e
0
279
e
N
e 174 nV0Hz
This is total rms noise at the input in one Hertz bandwidth at
1 kHz If total noise in a given bandwidth is desired one
must integrate the noise over a bandwidth as specified This
is most easily done in a noise measurement set-up but may
be approximated as follows
1 If the frequency range of interest is in the flat band ie
between 1 kHz and 10 kHz in Figure 2 it is simply a
matter of multiplying e
N
by the square root of the band-
width Then in the 1 kHz10 kHz band total noise is
e
N
e 17409000
e 165 mV
2 If the frequency band of interest is not in the flat band of
Figure 2 one must break the band into sections calculat-
ing average noise in each section squaring multiplying
by section bandwidth summing all sections and finally
taking square root of the sum as follows
e
N
e
0
e
R
2
B a
i
1
(e
n
2 a i
n
2
R
gen
2
)
i
B
i
(5)
where i is the total number of sub-blocks
For most purposes a sub-block may be one or two octaves
Example 2 details such a calculation
Example 2 Determine the rms noise level in the frequency
band 50 Hz to 10 kHz for the amplifier of Figure 2 operating
from R
gen
e 2k
1 Read e
R
fromFigure 4 at 2k square the value and multi-
ply by the entire bandwidth Easiest way is to construct a
table as shown on the next page
2 Read the median value of e
n
in a relatively small frequen-
cy band say 50 Hz100 Hz fromFigure 2 square it and
enter into the table
2
3 Read the median value of i
n
in the 50 Hz100 Hz band
from Figure 2 multiply by R
gen
e 2k square the result
and enter in the table
4 Sum the squared results from steps 2 and 3 multiply the
sum by Df e 10050 e 50 Hz and enter in the table
5 Repeat steps 24 for band sections of 100 Hz300 Hz
300 Hz1000 Hz and 1 kHz10 kHz Enter results in the
table
6 Sum all entires in the last column and finally take the
square root of this sum for the total rms noise in the 50
Hz10000 Hz band
7 Total e
n
is 162 mV in the 50 Hz10000 Hz band
CALCULATING SN and NF
Signal-to-noise ratio can be easily calculated from known
signal levels once total rms noise in the band is determined
Example 3 shows this rather simple calculation from Equa-
tion 6 for the data of Example 2
SN e 20 log
e
sig
e
N
(6)
Example 3 Determine SN for an rms e
sig
e 4 mV at the
input to the amplifier operated in Example 2
1 RMS signal is e
sig
e 4 mV
2 RMS noise from Example 2 is 162 mV
3 Calculate SN from Equation 6
SNe 20 log
4 mV
162 mV
e 20 log (247 x 10
3
)
e 20 (log 10
3 a log 247)
e 20 (3 a 0393)
SN e 68 dB
It is also possible to plot NF vs frequency at various R
gen
for
any given plot of e
n
and i
n
However there is no specific all-
purpose conversion plot relating NF e
n
i
n
R
gen
and f If
either e
n
or i
n
is neglected a reference chart can be con-
structed Figure 5 is such a plot when only e
n
is considered
It is useful for most op amps when R
gen
is less than about
200X and for FETs at any R
gen
(because there is no signifi-
cant i
n
for FETs) however actual NF for op amps with
R
gen
l
200X is higher than indicated on the chart The
graph of Figure 5 can be used to find spot NF if e
n
and R
gen
are known or to find e
n
if NF and R
gen
are known It can
also be used to find max R
gen
allowed for a given max NF
when e
n
is known In any case values are only valid if i
n
is negligible and at the specific frequency of interest for NF
and e
n
and for 1 Hz bandwidth If bandwidth increases the
plot is valid so long as e
n
is multiplied by 0B
TLH74145
FIGURE 5 Spot NF vs R
gen
when ConsideringOnly e
n
and e
R
(not valid when i
n
R
gen
is significant)
THE NOISE FIGURE MYTH
Noise figure is easy to calculate because the signal level
need not be specified (note that e
sig
drops out of Equation
4) Because NF is so easy to handle in calculations many
designers tend to lose sight of the fact that signal-to-noise
ratio (SN)
out
is what is important in the final analysis be it
an audio video or digital data system One can in fact
choose a high R
gen
to reduce NF to near zero if i
n
is very
small In this case e
R
is the major source of noise over-
shadowing e
n
completely The result is very low NF but
very low SN as well because of very high noise Dont be
fooled into believing that low NF means low noise per se
Another term is worth considering that is optimum source
resistance R
OPT
This is a value of R
gen
which produces the
lowest NF in a given system It is calculated as
R
OPT
e
e
n
i
n
(7)
This has been arrived at by differentiating Equation 4 with
respect to R
gen
and equating it to zero (see Appendix) Note
that this does not mean lowest noise
For example using Figure 2 to calculate R
OPT
at say 600
Hz
R
OPT
e
10 nV
07 pA
e 14 kX
TABLE I Noise Calculations for Example 2
B (Hz) Df (Hz) e
n
2
(nVHz) a i
n
2
R
gen
2
SUM x Df e (nV
2
)
50100 50 (20)
2 e 400 (87 x 20k)
2 e 302 702 x 50 35000
100300 200 (13)
2 e 169 (8 x 20k)
2 e 256 425 x 200 85000
3001000 700 (10)
2 e 100 (7 x 20k)
2 e 196 296 x 700 207000
10k10k 9000 (9)
2 e 81 (6 x 20k)
2 e 144 225 x 9000 2020000
5010000 9950 e
R
2 e (53)
2 e 28 28 x 9950 279000
Total e
N
e
02626000 e 1620 nV e 162 mV
The units are as follows (20 nV0Hz)
2 e 400 (nV)
2
Hz
(87 pA0Hz x 20 kX)
2 e (174 nA0Hz)
2 e 302 (nV)
2
Hz
Sum e 702 (nV)
2
Hz x 50 Hz e 35000 (nV)
2
3
Then note in Figure 3 that e
N
is in the neighborhood of
20 nV0Hz for R
gen
of 14k while e
N
e 10 nV0Hz for
R
gen
e 0100X STOP Do not pass GO Do not be fooled
Using R
gen
e R
OPT
does not guarantee lowest noise UN-
LESS e
sig
2 e kR
gen
as in the case of transformer coupling
When e
sig
2 l
kR
gen
as is the case where signal level is
proportional to R
gen
(e
sig
e kR
gen
) it makes sense to use
the highest practical value of R
gen
When e
sig
2 k
kR
gen
it
makes sense to use a value of R
gen
k
R
OPT
These conclu-
sions are verified in the Appendix
This all means that it does not make sense to tamper with
the R
gen
of existing signal sources in an attempt to make
R
gen
e R
OPT
Especially do not add series resistance to a
source for this purpose It does make sense to adjust R
gen
in transformer coupled circuits by manipulating turns ratio or
to design R
gen
of a magnetic pick-up to operate with pre-
amps where R
OPT
is known It does make sense to increase
the design resistance of signal sources to match or exceed
R
OPT
so long as the signal voltage increases with R
gen
in at
least the ratio e
sig
2
* R
gen
It does not necessarily make
sense to select an amplifier with R
OPT
to match R
gen
be-
cause one amplifier operating at R
gen
e R
OPT
may produce
lower SN than another (quieter) amplifier operating with
R
gen
i
R
OPT
NF e10 log
e
R
2 a e
n
2 a i
n
2 R
gen
2
e
R
2
10 log
1 a
e
n
2 a i
n
2 R
gen
2
e
R
2 J
eNF
eR
e
0435
(4 kTRB)
2
4 kTRB (2R i
n
2) b(e
n
2 a i
n
2 R
2
)4 kTB
1 a (e
n
2 a i
n
2 R
2
)4 kTRB
where R e R
gen
Set this e 0 and
4 kTRB(2R i
n
2) e 4 kTB (e
n
2 a i
n
2 R
2
)
2 i
n
2 R
2 e e
n
2 a i
n
2 R
2
i
n
2 R
2 e e
n
2
R
2 e e
n
2i
n
2
R
OPT
e
e
n
i
n
APPENDIX II
Selecting R
gen
for highest SN
SN e
e
sig
2
B(e
R
2 a e
n
2 a i
n
2 R
2
)
For SN to increase with R
eSN
eR
l
0
eSN
eR
e
2e
sig
(ee
sig
eR) (e
R
2 a e
n
2 a i
n
2 R
2
) be
sig
2
(4 kT a 2 i
n
2R)
B(e
R
2 a e
n
2 a i
n
2 R
2
)
2
6
APPENDIX II (Continued)
If we set
l
0 then
2 (ee
sig
e R) (e
R
2 a e
n
2 a i
n
2 R
2
)
l
e
sig
(4 kT a 2 i
n
2 R)
For e
sig
e k
1 0R ee
sig
eR e
k
1
20R
(2 k
1
20R) (e
R
2 a e
n
2 a i
n
2 R2)
l
k
10R (4 kT a 2 i
n
2 R)
e
R
2 a e
n
2 a i
n
2 R
2 l
4 kTR a 2 i
n
2 R
2
e
n
2
l
i
n
2 R
2
R
k
e
n
i
n
Therefore SN increases with R
gen
so long as R
gen
s
R
OPT
For e
sig
e k
1
R ee
sig
eR e k
1
2 k
1
(e
R
2 a e
n
2 a i
n
2 R
2
)
l
k
1
R (4 kT a 2 i
n
2 R)
2 e
R
2 a 2 e
n
2 a 2 i
n
2 R
2 l
4 kTR a 2 i
n
2 R
2
e
R
2 a 2 e
n
2
l
0
Then SN increases with R
gen
for any amplifier
For any e
sig
k
k
1 0R an optimum R
gen
may be determined Take for example e
sig
e k
1
R
04
ee
sig
eR e 04k
1
R
b06
(08 k
1
R
06
) (e
R
2 a e
n
2 a i
n
2 R
2
)
l
k
1
R
04
(4 kT a 2 i
n
2 R)
08 e
R
2 a 08 e
n
2 a 08 i
n
2 R
2 l
4 kTR a 2 i
n
2 R
2
08 e
n
2
l
02 e
R
2 a 12 i
n
2 R
2
Then SN increases with R
gen
until
025 e
R
2 a 15 i
n
2 R
2 e e
n
2
7
A
N
-
1
0
4
N
o
i
s
e
S
p
e
c
s
C
o
n
f
u
s
i
n
g