Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Thank you for taking an interest in and reading my exegetical analysis of 1 Timothy 3:1-
13 and I hope you will find the research and contextual exploration helpful in your understanding
and reading. I’m an academic at heart and a thinker by nature, so detailed analysis of Scripture is
truly enriching not just to my mind but also to my spirit. Hebrew 4:12 says, “For the Word of
God is living and active and sharper than any two-edged sword, and piercing as far as the
division of soul and spirit, of both joints and marrow, and able to judge the thoughts and
intentions of the heart” (NASB). While the historical and concordant information may be
interesting to you, don’t allow this read to just be an intellectual and theological exercise. To
conclude the exegetical analysis, I have included a “Significance” section that sums up the
information and explores the possible hermeneutical or practical applications of this section of
Scripture. The Bible is divided up into 66 books, 1,189 chapters, and 31,173 verses, but it is one
great story of God’s creation and redemptions of humanity and Paul’s writing is just one part of
For those that may be interested or curious, footnotes and formatting are in adherence
with Turabian’s A Manual for Writers of Term Papers, Theses, and Dissertations. I hope you
enjoy and benefit from this analysis and I am always open to thoughts, questions, and
suggestions.
Adam Young
ayoung@kencarylchurch.com
www.scribd.com/AdamDeanYoung
i
1
Setting
Biblical Context
The first letter to Timothy is placed together with the second letter to Timothy and
the letter to Titus to form what is known as the “Pastoral Epistles.” This term used by
scholars, first began to appear in the eighteenth century, but as early as the second
century these letters were grouped together within the Pauline letters. Not only because
these are the only three letters addressed by Paul to individual coworkers, but their
subject matter and linguistic similarities distinguishes them from the other Pauline
letters.1
Authorship
Although the first letter to Timothy begins with the Apostle Paul’s name, there
have been disagreements among scholars as to the genuineness of this claim and there are
four primary arguments used against Pauline authorship of all three of the Pastoral
Epistles. The first is a question of historical accuracy. The life events of Paul listed by the
author in the two Timothy Epistles and Titus do not appear to fit into the account of
Paul’s life found in Acts. The second problem is ecclesiastical; the discussion of bishops,
elders, and deacons seems to indicate a more advanced form of church government than
existed during the lifetime of Paul. The third and strongest argument concerns linguistic
style and vocabulary that differs from Paul’s other letters. The final argument is about
potential doctrinal emphases that differ from Paul’s other writings and teachings.2
Philip H. Towner, The Letters to Timothy and Titus, The New International
1
Commentary on the New Testament, ed. Gordon D. Fee (Grand Rapids: William B.
Eerdmans Publishing Co., 2006), 1.
2
Frank E. Gaebelein, ed. Ephesians – Philemon, The Expositors Bible
Commentary, vol. 11 (Grand Rapids: Zondervan Publishing House, 1997), 341.
2
regards to the historical differences, one must keep in mind that the Book of Acts was not
intended to be a complete historical record of the early church, but to show the spread of
Christianity from a small group of Jews in the heart of Jerusalem towards the ends of the
earth through the Gentiles. In addition, early church history and tradition teaches that
Paul was released from prison in early 60s AD, traveled towards Spain, and was
imprisoned a second time in which he was martyred under the hand of Emperor Nero in
late 60s AD. The Book of Acts ends with Paul’s first imprisonment and if he was
released through his appeal to Caesar, this could account for the actions of Paul in the
Pastoral Epistles that are not found in Acts. In the New Testament the terms “elder” and
“bishop” are used interchangeably and Paul addresses the “bishops and deacons” in the
his letter to the church at Philippi, which is almost unanimously believed to be Pauline
and was written approximately 60-61 AD, so the ecclesiastical argument does not stand.
There are linguistic style and vocabulary differences between these letters and the others
attributed to Paul, but not even those letters that are undisputed Pauline are completely
uniform in style. Varying circumstances, purpose, and audience all determine how an
author would write and we know by Paul’s own admission he, at times, used
amanuenses.3 The limited amount of data from the other Pauline letters does not allow for
proper numerical and statistical analysis.4 The doctrinal differences are weak and can
circumstances and addressees. While the issue deserves attention and careful
3
Towner, The Letters to Timothy and Titus, 23.
4
Gaebelein, Ephesians – Philemon, 343.
3
Date
The dating of 1 Timothy depends on what one believes about the outcome of
Paul’s imprisonment in Rome where the Book of Acts ends. If Paul was martyred during
this imprisonment which is believed to have taken place 59-61 AD, he most likely wrote
this letter in late 50s AD. To compensate for the differences between the life events in the
Pastoral Epistles and Acts, it would be assumed there were omitted details in the Acts
account. The early church almost unanimously testifies that Paul was put to death by
Emperor Nero who committed suicide in June of 68 AD and the second letter to Timothy
was written from his Roman imprisonment just before his execution, the first letter to
Timothy is thought to have been written between 62-66 AD. This second option seems
the most reliable and consistent with both Scripture and early church history.5
Historical Setting
1 Timothy identifies Ephesus as the location of the church in which Timothy had
been assigned to work. Ephesus was a strategic city identified by Paul in which he made
multiple visits to establish and build up a Christian community and spent several years.
This large harbor and economically robust city was a melting pot for diversity and
religious complexity. It was a place known for the practice of magic, sorcery, and
soothsaying and the Christian community there faced great opposition that required
Occasion
5
Ibid., 344.
6
Towner, The Letters to Timothy and Titus, 37-39.
4
The Pastoral Epistles are distinguished from the other Pauline letters because they
are addressed to individual pastors of churches to encourage them and lay out their
and maintain sound discipline.7 Specifically, to Timothy in the first letter Paul says in 1
Tim. 1:3, “remain on at Ephesus so that you may instruct certain men not to teach strange
doctrines” (NASB). Then Paul begins to instruct Timothy in his leadership, encourage
Timothy in the difficulties he is facing, and to instruct the church in Christian living and
Recipients
While this letter may have been addressed to Timothy, much of what is conveyed
to him is intended for the church in which he is being directed to minister. He is not only
instructed in the processes of being the leader of this church, but Paul also affirms his
authority for such leadership, suggesting that it may have been in question.8 This letter
was not only to be read privately by Timothy, but publicly to the entire church
congregation.
Structure
Literary Genre
1 Timothy gives the impression of being a much more personal letter than those
written by Paul to churches. But there are changes and breaks in Paul’s mood and even
the audience to whom he is addressing and writing to that prevent us from giving it just a
7
Gaebelein, Ephesians – Philemon, 344.
8
Towner, The Letters to Timothy and Titus, 10.
5
general classification. At times Paul switches from giving personal advice to public
advice. It is also apparent that over time theological material like hymns, creeds, baptism
and other preaching forms had developed throughout the broader Christian community
and Paul uses or adapts these for his writing. Paul also inserts a significant amount of
verbatim and at others adapted to communicate his message for Timothy and the church
in Ephesus.9 While this first letter to Timothy is more personal in nature, Paul takes a
variety of different known and common concepts from his contemporary context and uses
Syntax
Paul’s use of the word “overseer” is used interchangeably throughout the New
Testament for overseer, bishop, or pastor. The term was used to denote someone who
above reproach, and the word implies not only that the man is of good report, but that he
is deservedly so.11 “A husband of one wife” has proved to be a difficult phrase translating
The word used for hospitable refers to a man who’s official capacity has the duty
of keeping open house both for delegates traveling from church and for ordinary needy
members of the congregation. The word used for new convert, was used in a literal sense
9
Ibid., 31-32.
10
Cleon L. Rogers Jr. and Cleon L. Rogers III, The New Linguistic and Exegetical
Key to the Greek New Testament (Grand Rapids: Zondervan Publishing House, 1998),
491.
11
Ibid., 492.
12
William D. Mounce, Pastoral Epistles, Word Biblical Commentary, vol. 46
(Nashville: Thomas Nelson Publishers, 2000), 170.
6
to refer to a newly planted tree. Those “outside the church” is a term Paul uses for
unbelievers.13
The word “deacon” is translated from a word that is often used with those who do
menial tasks such as waiting on tables. It is used in various forms many times throughout
the New Testament and simply translated means “servant.”14 Deacons in the church were
to be servants to the needs of the Christian community and ministers of mercy to the
hurting and needy.15 In regards to deacons, Paul instructs them to not be “double-
tongued.” Some have thought this to imply gossip, but more literary means, “consistent in
what one says.” Not thinking one thing and saying another or saying one thing to
Semantics
While the term for overseer, bishop, elder, or pastor means very different things in
today’s churches, when it was first used by Paul in his various writings, it was used to
denote function rather than the status of anyone who exercised supervision or control.17
Paul’s instructions here are not intended to be a formula for church hierarchy but rather
are concerned with the type of person who would be in leadership. The term used that
means, “to be conceited,” is a difficult term to translate. But regardless of the exact
wording a scholar determines to use to translate it, it still conveys the same meaning. The
word is used only two other times in 1 Timothy, both referring to the opponents of Paul’s
13
Rogers & Rogers, Linguistic and Exegetical Key, 492.
14
Gaebelein, Ephesians – Philemon, 367.
15
Alexander Strauch, Minister of Mercy: The New Testament Deacon (Littleton:
Lewis & Roth Publishers, 1992), 156.
16
Rogers & Rogers, Linguistic and Exegetical Key, 492.
17
Ibid., 492.
7
mission and message, showing this was a problem in the Ephesian church and a young,
The word “deacon” presented a new paradigm for those in the Christian
community. The Greeks usually viewed serving others as a menial task; people were to
rule, not serve. Judaism saw service as something good, especially when it was directed
toward God, but it developed into a work of merit that was aimed not at the needy but the
righteous. Through the life and teachings of Jesus and furthered by the teaching of the
writers of the New Testament, serving the lowest peoples and those who could do
Summation
Beginning the process to exegete 1 Timothy 3:1-13, reference will be made to the
New American Standard Bible as the source for an accurate literal English translation, as
appearing five times and signified a recognized and familiar statement of key doctrines
and this would imply that well develop theology in these areas had already been
developed.21 Paul commends both the position and those that wish to hold the position of
overseer. But not everyone is a candidate for this position. Before Paul goes on to list
eleven qualities of those that wish to be an overseer, he opens the position to only men.
18
Mounce, Pastoral Epistles, 180.
19
Ibid., 197.
20
Jerry Vines and Jim Shaddix, Power in the Pulpit: How to Prepare and Deliver
Expository Sermons (Chicago: Moody Publishers, 1999), 110.
21
John MacArthur, 1 Timothy, The MacArthur New Testament Commentary
(Chicago: Moody Press, 1995), 32.
8
any kind of detailed list as to the duties an overseer should be engaged in. Paul here is
concerned with the type of person be appointed to leadership, a person whose personal
qualities set him apart.22 The first qualification stands as the general, overarching, all-
embracing quality over the other ten, an overseer must be above reproach; all that follows
The next qualification is one that has produced much debate that remains today
among scholars, pastor, and laymen. An overseer must be “the husband of one wife” (1
Tim 3:2, NASB). The phrase in Greek literally means “a one-woman man” and there are
four main arguments as to what Paul meant here: Overseers must be married, must not be
polygamists, must be married only once, or must be maritally and sexually above
reproach. While there are advantages to having a spouse and partner in ministry and the
Bible speaks of the blessings associated with marriage, based on Paul’s own instructions
the first argument is not to be taken. Polygamy was present in the culture and time of
Paul’s writing, but as Mounce describes, polygamy was not as common as some have
once thought it was and the chance of a polygamist vying for a leadership position within
the church is unlikely.24 On the surface, this interpretation seems to make sense but it
would be unlikely that Paul would address such an improbable situation. A much more
popular interpretation is that an overseer should be married only once. By examining the
teachings of both Jesus and Paul, remarriage for a widow is not only allowed, but Paul
22
Mounce, Pastoral Epistles, 159.
23
Alexander Strauch, Biblical Eldership: An Urgent Call To Restore Biblical
Church Leadership (Littleton: Lewis & Roth Publishers, 1995), 188.
24
Mounce, Pastoral Epistles, 172.
9
instigate the separation. Alexander Strauch’s conclusion seems most faithful to the whole
council of Scripture, “this phrase prohibits all deviation from faithful monogamous
marriage.”25 Paul’s intent was not to cover in detail every possible scenario, but that a
leader within the Christian community must be above reproach in every aspect of live
commitment to integrity, and by fasting and prayer will have to work through all the
The list continues in verse 2 with the characteristics of temperate, prudent, and
respectable. These qualities demand that an overseer must be a man who can practice
leader. Throughout the New Testament, practicing hospitality is something for all
believers to practice, but as a leader, overseers must provide the example of a loving and
accepting lifestyle.
The quality of being “able to teach” is the primary characteristic and skill that
separates elders from deacons. The ability to teach entails three primary elements:
knowledge of the Scriptures, the readiness to teach, and the ability to communicate.28
This doesn’t mean that an overseer must be a dynamic speaker, but in the face of false
teachers and an immature group of believers, they must know the truths of Scripture and
25
Strauch, Biblical Eldership, 192.
26
Ibid., 193.
27
John R.W. Stott, The Message of 1 Timothy & Titus, The Bible Speaks Today
Series, ed. John R.W. Stott (Leicester: Inter-Varsity Press, 1996), 95.
28
Strauch, Biblical Eldership, 195.
10
be able to communicate them in an effective way to encourage and instruct those they
have been entrusted to care for. Teaching does not necessarily have to take place on a
stage or platform, but an overseer or elder must have the knowledge and ability to instruct
An overseer should also be a man “not addicted to much wine.” A leader who is
to be above reproach should not be consumed with the desire or addiction for alcohol.
discipline, Paul does not require complete abstinence. It is important to note that during
Paul’s time water was impure. Mixing wine and water together both diluted the alcohol
content and purified the water. Which is why Paul instructed Timothy in chapter five to
not drink water exclusively.29 Today, the water that most Americans have access to is
safe and there is no need to add alcohol for purification, so a leader must keep in mind
that every aspect of their life must be above reproach. This should guide our decision-
making more than any consequential allowance found within Paul’s instructions.
A leader is constantly in the center of very tense and emotional situations and they
with being peaceable will earn and legitimize a leader’s place of authority and enable him
to be the most effective type of leader.30 While those attitudes may legitimize a leader’s
place of authority, the love of money will destroy it. A position of leadership that has
access to God’s money is no place for a man of greed, not only because of the potential
damage that could be done to the reputation of the Christian community, but because
The next and final three qualities deal with an overseer’s relationships. Paul
begins with the leader’s own household. Managing a household includes providing for a
“but if a man does not know how to manage his own household, how will he take care of
the church of God?” A leader’s household management is the litmus test for how they
will manage God’s household.32 The second relationship is that of the overseer’s with
Christ; an overseer must not be a “new convert.” There is nothing wrong with being a
new convert and much can be learned from their passion and excitement for their new
faith. However, maturity only comes with time and experience and without this
experience a new convert is susceptible to the pride that comes along with a place of
authority. While all men are susceptible and two thousand years of church history have
proved that even the “old” converts can be destroyed by pride, the wiser, older, and more
experienced man has acquired more tools to identify and disarm rising pride. The final
relationship is concerning the overseer’s relationship with those outside the Christian
community. In reality, the non-Christians may know more about the character and life of
an individual than those inside the church. They see them interact with people in the
workplace and public gatherings. The overseer may be more honest and transparent with
those he doesn’t expect to be examining him. A good reputation with those outside the
church proves that the leader is the same person both inside and outside the church
walls.33
In verse 8 Paul begins with a new position of leadership within the church as he
gives the qualifications for those who may be considered for the office of deacon. Nine
32
Strauch, Biblical Eldership, 199.
33
Ibid., 201.
12
individual qualifications for the deacon that will be broken up into 5 different categories
as suggested by Dr. John MacArthur in his commentary on 1 Timothy. The first division
for deacon qualification is personal character. Paul declares that deacons should be men
of dignity, worthy of respect, and spiritual devoted. This positive command is followed
by the next three qualifications stated in the negative. They should not be “double-
tongued, or addicted to wine or fond of sordid gain.” Some have interpreted double-
tongued to mean gossip, but it would be more accurately and appropriately translated as
hypocritical.34 The consumption of alcohol and its levels holds true, not only for the
overseer, but for the deacon as well. Lastly, because deacons would be handling money
within the church, it was imperative they have no desire to use their position for financial
gain.
In verse 9, Paul speaks to the spiritual condition of deacon candidates. Paul often
refers to the “mystery” of the faith as revealed truth that was previously hidden, now
believers, unity of Jews and Gentiles in Christ, and the saving gospel.35 Deacons must
hold on to this mystery with a clear conscience, not just believing these to be true, but by
Further, Paul speaks of the deacons’ Christian service in verse 10. It would be a
mistake to think that individuals within a leadership or exemplary position should only be
tested once. Being beyond reproach means living a continual lifestyle that embodies all
these qualifications. Moral purity is another aspect that not only overseers are to embody,
34
MacArthur, 1 Timothy, 127.
35
Ibid., 128.
13
In verse 11, Paul seems to break from deacon qualifications to give qualifications to
some unidentified “women.” The issues that arise in determining whom these “women”
are in this passage are divided into four possibilities: Wives of deacon husbands, deacon
interpretation. Some site that if Paul wanted to indentify these women as deaconesses, he
would have used the feminine form of the word deacon, however, that word wasn’t in
existence at the time of Paul’s writing.37 It seems odd that Paul would give deacon’s
wives certain qualification but not do so for the overseer, who would hold a higher place
of authority. In 1 Timothy 2 Paul gives instruction for all women in the Christian
community, so it would be unnecessary for him to revisit this topic or make a break in the
middle of a talk on deacons. The idea of deacon assistants seems only to be a last effort at
explaining the seemingly random discussion on women in the middle of a talk on deacons
and has no Scriptural support. After examining the arguments, it seems most appropriate
that Paul is referring to the office of female deacons or deaconesses. While 1 Timothy 2
does prohibit women from having leadership over men, but as previously discussed in
defining the word used for deacon, deacons are not a leadership body. The teaching and
leadership is reserved for overseers, deacons are to be a body of servants and Christian
living examples. The office of female deacons, therefore, does not contradict with other
parts of Scripture.
Paul revisits some qualifications that applied to the overseer, being a “one woman
man” and a good manager of their own household. While the deacons were to focus more
on loving and humble service and less on the leadership duties that would be taken by the
36
MacArthur, 1 Timothy, 130 and Strauch, Minster of Mercy, 112 – 126.
37
Mounce, Pastoral Epistles, 202.
14
overseers, deacons who serve well earn a place of high respect. The official authority of
the church is given to the office of overseer, but authority and leadership come with
faithfulness more than a title, therefore, deacons certainly hold a valuable and necessary
Significance
Church leadership has taken on as many different forms as there have been
churches over the last two centuries of Christian history. Placing Paul’s instruction to
Timothy for the leaders and potential leaders of the church in Ephesus in Biblical and
historical context, we should not see this as an exact formula for church government
structure. Rather it should be a reminder that who is in leadership is much more important
than the hierarchy of their position. Even Paul didn’t detail what the leaders should be
doing as much as who they are to be both inside and outside the church walls. The leaders
we choose to elect or hire into position within our churches must be above reproach in
every aspect of their lives. Not that we demand or expect them to be perfect, for only
Jesus was and is perfect, but that their lives need to be a living example of the truths
taught in Scripture.
each individual church is going to have to carefully examine of the whole counsel of
Scripture, desire to show love, grace, and forgiveness, along with persistent prayer and
fasting to stay committed to the integrity of obeying God’s instructions. Because other
parts of Scripture give allowance for divorce under certain circumstances we should be
cautious to create laws that even Jesus didn’t make. In the same way, a leader must be
38
Strauch, Minster of Mercy, 148-149.
15
someone who is committed to honor Christ with all of his relationships and Paul certainly
eliminates men from leadership who cannot manage their own households. In the same
way, while only appointing overseers who can manage their own households, we must be
careful of drawing too strict or too liberal a line in regards to their children’s walk with
Christ.
In the face of much debate regarding Paul’s use of the word “women,” each
individual church must decide how and who they will elect to the office on deacon. Most
scholars agree that Phoebe was a deaconess in Cenchrea (Rom 16:1) and the evidence
seems to suggest that Paul was talking about deaconesses in 1 Timothy 3:11. However, I
think Warren Wiersbe’s words on this matter are important to keep in mind, “We thank
God for the ministry of godly women in the local church, whether they hold offices or
Regardless of their official or unofficial positions, godly women are an invaluable part of
church life and ministry for local church contexts and leaders must constantly thank and
introduce and conclude his discussion on leadership: “It is a trustworthy statement: if any
man aspires to the office of overseer, it is a fine work he desires to do. An overseer, then,
must be above reproach… For those who have served well as deacons obtain for
themselves a high standing and great confidence in the faith that is in Christ Jesus”
(1 Timothy 3:1-2a, 13 NASB). In the day where a moral failure of a prominent pastor
makes news headlines almost daily, we must take time to thank God for the countless
1981), 49.
16
leaders who have served Him and their churches well for a lifetime. They may not make
the news headlines but are vital to God’s work through the local church community. The
focus of churches today needs not to be on arguing the nuances of Paul’s intent with
deacons/deaconesses who are above reproach and have devoted their lives to honoring
Gaebelein, Frank E. ed. Ephesians – Philemon. The Expositors Bible Commentary. vol.
11. Grand Rapids: Zondervan Publishing House, 1997.
Mounce, William D. Pastoral Epistles. Word Biblical Commentary. vol. 46. Nashville:
Thomas Nelson Publishers, 2000.
Rogers, Cleon L. Jr. and Cleon L. Rogers III. The New Linguistic and Exegetical Key to
the Greek New Testament. Grand Rapids: Zondervan Publishing House, 1998.
Stott, John R.W. The Message of 1 Timothy & Titus. The Bible Speaks Today Series. ed.
John R.W. Stott. Leicester: Inter-Varsity Press, 1996.
Strauch, Alexander. Minister of Mercy: The New Testament Deacon. Littleton: Lewis &
Roth Publishers, 1992.
Towner, Philip H. The Letters to Timothy and Titus. The New International Commentary
on the New Testament. ed. Gordon D. Fee. Grand Rapids: William B. Eerdmans
Publishing Co., 2006.
Vines, Jerry and Jim Shaddix. Power in the Pulpit: How to Prepare and Deliver
Expository Sermons. Chicago: Moody Publishers, 1999.
Wiersbe, Warren W. Be Faithful: 1&2 Timothy, Titus. Wheaton: Victor Books, 1981.
17