Professional Documents
Culture Documents
5 for wind
power plants with a power output
greater than 11 kW
4.1
REV.
DESCRIPTION
30.9.2010
DATE
SFJ/KDJ
NAME
PREPARED
CHECKED
REVIEWED
APPROVED
55986/10
Energinet.dk
Revision view
Chapter
Text
Version
Date
4.1
30.9.2010
All
4.0
29.9.2010
All
Public consultation
3.0
16.6.2010
All
2.0
1.12.2009
All
1.0
1.9.2009
2/74
List of contents
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
Protection.................................................................................... 47
7.
8.
3/74
To the reader
This regulation includes the technical and functional minimum requirements
which wind power plants with a rated power greater than 11 kW must comply
with if they are to be connected to the Danish grid.
The regulation is structured so that chapter 1 outlines the terminology and
definitions used; chapter 2 describes the regulatory provisions and relevant
references, while the technical and functional requirements are described in
chapter 3 onwards.
The technical requirements in the regulation are divided in relation to the total
rated power in the same point of connection:
-
Wind power plants with a power output range of 25 kW to 1.5 MW requirements and power limits are defined in accordance with Danish
legislation, which requires that local development plans be prepared.
Wind power plants with a power output range of 1.5 MW to 25 MW requirements and power limits have been harmonised with other technical
regulations for electricity-generating plants.
The regulation makes extensive use of terminology and definitions, the most
important of which are described in chapter 1. In the regulation, terminology
and definitions are written in italics.
The regulation can also be found on our website, and in the event of
discrepancies between the English and Danish versions, the Danish version shall
apply.
The regulation is published by the transmission system operator (TSO) and can
be downloaded from www.energinet.dk.
4/74
1.
1.1
1.2
Plant owner
The plant owner is the legal owner of the wind power plant. The plant owner is
entitled to hand over the operational responsibility to a wind turbine generator
system operator.
1.3
COMTRADE
1.4
1.5
1.6
The electricity supply undertaking is the enterprise to whose grid a wind power
plant is connected electrically. For voltage levels up to 100 kV it is the local
distribution network operator, and for voltage levels greater than 100 kV it is
the regional transmission operator.
1.7
Flicker
1.8
Frequency control
The control of active power with a view to stabilising the grid frequency is called
frequency control. A more detailed description can be found in chapter 5.2.1.
1.9
Generator convention
The sign for active/reactive power indicates the power flow seen from the
generator. The consumption/import of active/reactive power is indicated by
5/74
1.10
A small wind turbine is one or several wind turbine generator systems with a
total rated power of up to 25 kW which has been connected to the public
electricity supply network, see IEC 61400-2 [ref. 13]. A small wind turbine is
most often installation connected.
1.11
1.12
Short-circuit power
The short-circuit power, Sk, is the size of the three-phase short-circuit power in
the point of connection.
1.13
The point of common coupling (PCC) is the point in the public electricity supply
network where consumers are or can be connected. Electrically the point of
common coupling and the point of connection may coincide. The point of
common coupling is always placed closest to the public electricity supply
network, see Figure 1 and Figure 2. The electricity supply undertaking
determines the point of common coupling.
1.14
The rated power of a wind turbine generator system is the highest active power
at which a wind turbine generator system is designed to continuously supply
electricity. The rated power can be seen from the type approval, see IEC
60050-415-04-03 (modified) and Danish Executive Order no. 651 of 26 June
2008) [ref. 21].
1.15
The rated power of a wind power plant, Pn, is the highest active power which a
wind power plant is approved to supply continuously in the point of common
coupling. The rated power must appear from the project approval, see IEC
60050-415-04-04 (modified) and Danish Executive Order no. 651 of 26 June
2008 [ref. 21].
1.16
Rated current
The rated current, In, is defined as the maximum continuous current a wind
power plant is designed to provide under normal operating conditions, see IEC
61400-21 [ref. 16].
6/74
1.17
The rated wind speed is the average wind speed at which a wind turbine
generator system achieves its rated power, see IEC 60050-415-03-04 [ref. 28].
The average wind speed is calculated as the average value of wind speeds
measured at hub height over a period of 10 minutes.
1.18
1.19
Nominal voltage
1.20
1.21
Power infrastructure
1.22
1.23
1.24
Voltage fluctuation
1.25
A voltage reference point is a metering point that is used for voltage control.
The voltage reference point is either in the point of connection or the point of
common coupling or a point in between. Out of consideration for a possible tap
changer, the voltage reference point is normally found at the high-voltage side
of the plant transformer. The electric supply undertaking chooses the location of
the voltage reference point, see Figure 2.
7/74
1.26
Droop
The droop is the angle of a curve which a control function must comply with.
1.27
The cut-out wind speed is the maximum wind speed at hub height at which a
wind power plant is designed to generate power, see IEC 60050-415-03-06.
Cut-out-wind speed is calculated as the average value measured at hub height
over a 10-minute period.
1.28
1.29
Point of connection
The point of connection (POC) is the point in the public electricity supply
network where the wind power plant is or can be connected; see Figure 1 and
Figure 2 for the typical placing of the point of connection.
All requirements in this regulation apply to the point of connection. Following
agreement with the electricity supply undertaking, reactive compensation at no
load can be placed somewhere else in the public electricity supply network. The
electricity supply undertaking determines the point of connection.
Figure 1 illustrates how a small wind turbine is typically connected to the grid
and where the point of connection (POC) and the point of common coupling are
typically placed. In the situation shown, the point of common coupling (PCC)
and the point of connection (POC) coincide.
Small scale wind power plants can be connected in the same way as small wind
turbines.
8/74
Figure 2 illustrates how wind power plants are typically connected to the grid
and where the point of connection (POC) and the point of common coupling
(PCC) are typically placed.
Consumption
Voltage > 1 kV
POC
PCC
Voltage reference point
POC
POC
1.30
1.31
1.32
UTC
1.33
A wind power plant is one or several wind turbine generator systems with a
total rated power greater than 25 kW which has been connected to the public
electricity supply network, see IEC 61400-1 [ref. 12].
A wind power plant comprises all necessary power supply and auxiliary
equipment, and it is therefore the entire wind power plant that must be
designed in accordance with the requirements in this regulation.
9/74
In this regulation, the term wind power plant is used as the umbrella term for
small wind turbines and wind turbine generator systems. A wind power plant
only has one point of connection.
1.34
A wind power plant controller is a set of control functions that makes it possible
to control a wind power plant as one plant in the point of connection. The set of
control functions must be a part of the wind power plant.
1.35
1.36
The wind turbine generator system operator is the enterprise responsible for the
operation of the wind power plant, either through ownership or contractual
obligations.
10/74
2.
2.1
2.2
Scope
A wind power plant connected to the public electricity supply network must
throughout its lifetime comply with the provisions of this regulation.
New wind power plants
This regulation applies to all wind power plants with a rated power greater than
11 kW connected to the public electricity supply network and commissioned on
1 December 2010 or later.
Existing wind power plants
A wind power plant with a rated power greater than 11 kW which were
connected to the public electricity supply network before 1 December 2010
must comply with the regulation in force at the time of commissioning.
Changes to existing wind power plants
Existing wind power plants to which substantial functional modifications are
made must comply with the provisions of this regulation relating to such
changes. In case of doubt, the transmission system operator decides whether a
modification is substantial.
A substantial modification is one that changes the properties of the wind power
plant, involving the replacement of one or several plant parts. The
documentation described in chapter 9 must be updated and forwarded in a
version showing any modifications made.
11/74
2.3
Delimitation
2.4
Statutory authority
The regulation has been issued under the authority of Section 26(1) of the
Danish Electricity Supply (Consolidation) Act no. 516 of 20 May 2010 in
pursuance of Section 7(1), paras 1, 3 and 4, of the Danish (Consolidation) Act
no. 1463 of 19 December 2005 on transmission system operation and the use
of the electricity transmission grid etc.
12/74
2.5
Commencement
2.6
Complaints
Any complaints in respect of this regulation must be lodged with the Danish
Energy Regulatory Authority, Nyropsgade 30, DK-1780 Copenhagen V.
Complaints of the transmission system operator's enforcement of the provisions
of the regulation can also be lodged with the Danish Energy Regulatory
Authority.
Complaints about how the individual electricity supply undertaking enforces the
provisions of the regulation can be lodged with the transmission system
operator. Complaints about how the individual electricity supply undertaking's
enforcement of the provisions of the regulation can be lodged with the
transmission system operator. A complaint lodged in respect of an electricity
supply undertaking will always oblige the transmission system operator to ask
for the electricity supply undertaking's comments on the complaint.
2.7
Non-compliance
It is the responsibility of the plant owner to ensure that the provisions of this
Regulation are complied with throughout the useful life of the wind power plant.
The wind power plant must be subjected to regular maintenance checks to
ensure that the provisions of this regulation are complied with.
Expenses incurred in complying with the provisions of this Regulation must be
paid by the plant owner.
2.8
Sanctions
If a wind power plant does not comply with the provisions of chapters 3-8 of
this regulation, the electricity supply undertaking is entitled as a last resort to
cut off the electrical connection to the wind power plant until the provisions are
complied with.
Document no. 55986/10, Technical Regulation 3.2.5
13/74
2.9
2.10
References
The standards listed are only to be used in relation to the topics mentioned in
connection with the references in this regulation.
8.
9.
10.
11.
Bestemmelser for HV-maskinel for spndinger over 1000 V a.c. eller 1500
V d.c. og ikke overstiger 36 kV.
IEC-60870-5-101: Telecontrol equipment and systems, part 5-101.
IEC-60870-5-104: Telecontrol equipment and systems, part 5-104.
IEC TR 61000-3-6: EMC limits. Limitation of emissions of harmonic
currents for equipment connected to medium and high voltage power supply
systems (February 2008).
IEC TR 61000-3-7: EMC-limits. Limitation of voltage fluctuations and
flicker for equipment connected to medium and high voltage power supply
systems (February 2008).
14/74
15/74
16/74
3.
A wind power plant must be able to withstand frequency and voltage deviations
in the point of connection under normal and abnormal operating conditions
while reducing the active power as little as possible.
Normal operating conditions and abnormal operating conditions are described in
chapter 3.2 and chapter 3.3, respectively.
3.1
The electricity supply undertaking determines the voltage level for the wind
power plant within the voltage limits stated in Table 1.
The typical operating voltage differs from location to location, and the electricity
supply undertaking must therefore state the typical operating voltage, U, for
the point of connection.
The typical operating voltage forms the basis for determining the normal
voltage area U10%. The electricity supply undertaking must ensure that the
maximum voltage stated in Table 1 is not exceeded.
If the normal voltage area U is 10% lower than the minimum voltage
indicated in Table 1, the requirements for production in the event of
frequency/voltage variations must be adjusted so as not to overload the wind
power plant.
Typical
designation
Medium voltage
(MV)
Low voltage
(LV)
Table 1
Nominal
voltage
Un
[kV]
400
Minimum
voltage
Umin
[kV]
320
Maximum
voltage
Umax
[kV]
420
220
245
150
135
170
132
119
145
60
54.0
72.5
50
45.0
60.0
33
30.0
36.0
30
27.0
36.0
20
18.0
24.0
15
13.5
17.5
12.0
10
9.00
0.69
0.62
0.76
0.40
0.36
0.44
Maximum (Umax) and minimal (Umin) voltage limits are determined using the
standards EN50160 (10-minute average values) [ref. 1] and IEC60038, table
III, note 2 [ref. 2].
17/74
The wind power plant must be able to briefly withstand voltages exceeding the
maximum voltages within the required protective functions specified in chapter
6.
3.2
It must be possible to continuously start and operate a wind power plant within
the area designated 'normal production' within the design requirements,
restricted only by the settings for over- and undervoltage protection as
described in chapter 6.
In the 'normal production' area, the typical operating voltage is U10%, see
chapter 3.1, while the frequency area is 49.50 to 50.20 Hz.
Automatic connection of a wind power plant can at the earliest take place three
minutes after the voltage has come to lie within the typical operating voltage
and the frequency lies within 47.00 and 50.20 Hz. The setting of the frequency
limits is determined by the electricity supply undertaking upon commissioning.
The requirement for variable frequency limits must be implemented not later
than 18 months after the commencement date of this technical regulation.
The requirements outlined in the following section are to be considered
minimum requirements.
NORMAL
PRODUCTION
The overall requirements for active power production which a wind power plant
must comply with in the case of frequency and voltage deviations are illustrated
in Figure 3.
Figure 3
18/74
The wind power plant must remain connected to the public electricity supply
network in accordance with the required settings for protective functions, as
specified in chapter 6.
U +10%
U -5%
NORMAL
PRODUCTION
90 100 % of
normal production for minimum
5 hours
U +5%
90 100 % of
normal production for minimum
30 minutes
80 100 % of
normal production for minimum
20 seconds
85 100 % of
normal production for minimum
3 minutes
60 -100 % of
normal production for
minimum
15 minutes
No req.
for produktion
U -10%
Umin
47.00
Figure 4
47.50
48.00
48.50
49.00
49.50
50.00
50.50
50.20
51.00
51.50
52.00
52.50
Frequency [Hz]
The wind power plant must remain connected to the public electricity supply
network in accordance with the required settings for protective functions, as
specified in chapter 6.
3.2.3 Wind power plants with a power output greater than 1.5 MW
In addition to complying with the requirements in chapter 3.2.2, the wind
power plant must remain connected to the public electricity supply network in
case of abnormal operating conditions, as specified in chapter 3.3.
3.3
The following requirements apply to wind power plants with a power output
greater than 1.5 MW.
The wind power plant must be designed to withstand sudden phase jumps of up
to 20 in the point of connection without disconnecting or reducing its output.
The wind power plant must after a settling period supply normal production not
later than 5 s after the operating conditions in the point of connection have
reverted to the normal production area.
19/74
The wind power plant must be designed to withstand voltage drops, as shown in
Figure 5 and supply reactive power as shown in Figure 6 without
disconnecting or reducing its output. The wind power plant must after a settling
period supply normal production not later than 5 s after the operating
conditions in the point of connection have reverted to the normal production
area.
Irrespective of the requirements outlined in the following chapters, the
protective settings must be as specified in chapter 6.
Documentation to the effect that the wind power plant complies with the
specified requirements must be as specified in chapter 8.
3.3.1
In the point of connection a wind power plant must be able to withstand voltage
drops down to 20% of the voltage in the point of connection over a period of
minimum 0.5 s (line-to-line voltages for the 50 Hz component) without
disconnecting, as shown in Figure 5.
It is allowed to use the voltage measurement for the individual wind turbine
generator system to perform regulation during voltage drops.
Figure 5
Area A: The wind power plant must stay connected to the network and
uphold normal production.
Area B: The wind power plant must stay connected to the network. The
wind power plant must provide maximum voltage support by supplying a
20/74
Figure 6
Control must follow Figure 6 so that the reactive power follows the control
characteristic with a tolerance of 20% after 100 ms.
The supply of reactive power has first priority in area B, while the supply of
active power has second priority.
If possible, active power must be maintained during voltage drops, but a
reduction in active power within the wind power plant's design specifications is
acceptable, however.
The requirement for control as indicated in Figure 6 must be implemented 18
months after the commencement date of this technical regulation at the latest.
21/74
The requirements apply in the point of connection, but the fault sequence lies at
a random place in the public electricity supply network.
Based on compliance with the requirements for voltage drops as stated in
chapter 3.3.1, the requirements in Table 2 must be verified by documenting
that the wind power plant has been designed to withstand recurring faults with
the specifications stated.
Type
Fault duration
Three-phase short-circuit
Two-phase short-circuit
with/without earth contact
Table 2
Fault types in the public electricity supply network and their duration
Wind power plant capacity must be sufficient to comply with the requirements
specified in Table 2 if at least two independent faults of the types specified
occur within two minutes.
The energy reserves provided by auxiliary equipment such as emergency supply
equipment, the hydraulic system and the pneumatic system should be sufficient
in order for the wind power plant to operate with at least six independent faults
of the types specified in Table 2 at 5-minute intervals.
22/74
Electricity quality
4.
4.1
Electricity quality
General requirements
voltage fluctuations:
o
o
harmonics
inter-harmonics
disturbances greater than 2 kHz.
23/74
Electricity quality
The plant owner must subject each of the type of wind turbine generator
system making up the wind power plant to type tests performed in accordance
with IEC 61400-21. As a supplement to the type test, the plant owner may
provide an emission model for the wind turbine generator systems for the
purpose of determining high-frequency currents. The result of the type tests
can be seen from the type approvals. In general, the rated value of the
apparent power Sn,i for each wind turbine generator system will be used in
combination with specific data for the individual types of disturbances.
For wind power plants with a power output greater than 1.5 MW consisting of
more than one wind turbine generator system, the plant owner must also
provide a model for the power infrastructure for the purpose of determining
high-frequency voltages.
The electricity supply undertaking must provide data for the public electricity
supply network in the point of connection. For the calculation of voltage
fluctuations, see IEC 61400-21, the public electricity supply network can be
defined by the minimum short-circuit power Sk and the similar grid impedance
angle k, in the point of connection.
Where the connection of wind power plants with a power output greater than
1.5 MW is concerned, the electricity supply undertaking must also provide data
for the frequency dependency of the impedance in the public electricity supply
network for the purpose of calculating the emission high-frequency voltages in
the relevant frequency range up to 9 kHz.
4.1.3 Verification
The plant owner is responsible for verifying that the wind power plant observes
the defined emission limit values in the point of connection. The electricity
supply undertaking must approve the verification performed by the plant owner.
24/74
Electricity quality
4.2
Table 3
d (%)
Un 35 kV
4%
Un > 35 kV
3%
Excepted are rare voltage changes such as voltage drops as a result of the
energising of the power infrastructure with connected step-up transformers.
4.2.3 Verification
The voltage change factor kU is determined for the public electricity supply
network in the point of connection for all types of wind turbine generator
systems and for all types of switching's through simple interpolation between
the values for k, as specified in the type approval. Therefore kU,i(k) is
25/74
Electricity quality
determined as the largest voltage change factor for the various types of
switching's for of each wind turbine generator system i.
The voltage change di(%) is then determined for each wind turbine generator
system:
d i (%) = 100% ku ,i ( k )
S n ,i
Sk
d(%) is then determined as the highest value of di(%). Finally, it is verified that
the calculated voltage change d(%) is below the limit values specified in Table
3.
4.3
Flicker
Table 4
Pst
Plt
Un 1 kV
0.35
0.25
Un > 1 kV
0.30
0.20
Limit values for short-term flicker (Pst) and long-term flicker (Plt)
26/74
Electricity quality
4.3.2.2 Wind power plants with a power output greater than 1.5 MW
The maximum flicker contribution Plt and Pst from wind power plants connected
at the same voltage level and to the same substation must not exceed the limit
values in Table 5.
Table 5
Pst
Plt
Un 35 kV
0.50
35 kV < Un 100 kV
0.35
Un > 100 kV
0.30
0.20
Limit values for short-term flicker (Pst) and long-term flicker (Plt)
4.3.3 Verification
It must be verified that flicker emission from continuous operation of the wind
power plant and from switching's is lower than the limit value for the point of
connection.
4.3.3.1 Continuous operation
The flicker coefficient must be determined for the public electricity supply
network in the point of connection and the wind power plant concerned through
simple interpolation between the network impedance phase angle k and annual
average wind speed va values, which are specified in the type certification test
specification.
Flicker emission for each individual wind turbine generator system i is calculated
as:
Pst,i = c i ( k , va ,i )
S n,i
Sk
The emission from the entire wind power plant is then calculated as:
Pst = Plt = 2
(P )
st,i
It must be checked that the calculated values are below the limit values.
4.3.3.2 Switching
The flicker step factor is determined for switching's in the public electricity
supply network at the point of connection through simple interpolation between
the network impedance phase angle k values, which are specified in the type
approval. Then kU,i(k) is determined as the largest flicker step factor for
switching's.
The flicker emission is then determined for each of the wind turbine generator
systems i that form part of the wind power plant by using the flicker step factor
kf(k):
27/74
Electricity quality
Pst ,i = 18 N100,31
min, i k f , i ( k )
0 , 31
Plt ,i = 8 N120
min,i k f , i ( k )
Sn ,i
Sk
S n ,i
Sk
The emission from the wind power plant is then calculated as:
Pst = 3
(P )
st,i
Plt = 3
(P )
lt,i
It must be checked that the calculated values are below the limit values.
4.4
Harmonics
THDI =
h = 40
I h2
and
h=2
h = 40
h I
PWHDI =
h =14
2
h
Odd-order harmonics h
(no multiple of 3)
Even-order harmonics h
(no multiple of 3)
11
13
17h49
8h50
Un 1 kV
4.8
3.3
1.3
0.9
Un > 1 kV
4.0
4.0
2.0
2.0
400 *)
h2
0.8
0.2
0.1
28/74
Electricity quality
The limit values for total harmonic current distortion can be seen in Table 7.
Voltage level
(AC)
THDI
PWHDI
Un 1 kV
6.0
10.5
Un > 1 kV
Table 7
Odd-order harmonics h
(no multiple of 3)
Even-order harmonics h
(no multiple of 3)
11
13
17h49
8h50
Un 1 kV
3.6
2.5
1.0
0.7
Un > 1 kV
4.0
4.0
2.0
2.0
400
*
h2
0.8
0.2
0.1
THDI
PWHDI
Un 1 kV
4.5
7.9
Un > 1 kV
Table 9
4.4.2.3 Wind power plants with a power output greater than 1.5 MW
The electricity supply undertaking determines emission limits for harmonic
voltage in the point of connection. The emission limits aim to ensure that the
electricity supply undertaking's design limits for the individual harmonic
voltages and THDU are not exceeded in the point of connection.
An example of design limits for harmonic voltage from IEC TR 61000-3-6 is
shown below. Table 10 shows limits for odd-order harmonics, Table 11 the
limits for even-order harmonics and Table 12 the total harmonic voltage
distortion.
Odd-order harmonics h (no multiple of 3)
Voltage level
(AC)
5
7
11
13
17h49
3
9
15
Un 35 kV
5.0
4.0
3.0
2.5
Un > 35 kV
2.0
2.0
1.5
1.5
1,9
17
0 ,2
h
1,2
17
h
*)
*)
4.0
1.2
0.3
0.2
2.0
1.0
0.3
0.2
21h45
29/74
Electricity quality
Voltage level
(AC)
Un 35 kV
1.8
1.0
0.5
0.5
0,25
10
+ 0 ,22
h
Un > 35 kV
1.4
0.8
0.4
0.4
0,19
10
+ 0,16
h
Table 11
Even-order harmonics h
Voltage level
(AC)
THDU
Un 35 kV
6.5
Un > 35 kV
3.0
Table 12
10h50
Limit values for total harmonic voltage distortion THDU (% of Un) for
even-order harmonics h.
The emission limits for the wind power plant will typically be lower than the
design limits as the electricity supply undertaking must take emissions from
other plants in the public electricity supply network into account.
Emission limits for wind power plants that are electrically connected without
interfering consumption can be modified to values higher than the standard
design limits.
4.4.3 Verification
4.4.3.1 Wind power plants with a power output range of 11 kW to 1.5 MW
It must be verified that the limit values are observed at all levels of generated
power. Therefore the value from the level of generated power at which the
individual harmonic current is the greatest is used to verify observance of the
limit values for individual harmonic currents h.
Similarly, values from the level of generated power that collectively yields the
highest THD and PWHD values, respectively, are used to verify observance of
the THD and PWHD limit values.
As regards wind power plants consisting of several wind turbine generator
systems, contributions from the individual wind turbine generator systems must
be added up in accordance with the general summation law in IEC 61000-3-6
and IEC 61400-21:
Ih =
h ,i
30/74
Electricity quality
(alpha)
h<5
5 h 10
1.4
h > 10
Table 13
4.4.3.2 Wind power plants with a power output greater than 1.5 MW
The high-frequency emission model for the public electricity supply network is
used to verify limit values for harmonic voltage in the point of connection. Input
to this emission model can either be the measured and aggregated values for
harmonic current emissions in accordance with the above, or values provided by
a validated emission model.
4.5
Interharmonics
Voltage level
(AC)
75 Hz
125 Hz
Un 1kV
0.53
0.80
Un > 1kV
0.44
0.66
>175 Hz
100
*)
f
83
*)
f
31/74
Electricity quality
Voltage level
(AC)
75 Hz
125 Hz
Un 1kV
0.40
0.60
Un > 1kV
0.44
0.66
>175 Hz
75
*)
f
83
*)
f
f < 100 Hz
0.2%
0.5%
Table 16
The emission limits for the wind power plant will typically be lower than the
design limits as the electricity supply undertaking must take account of
emissions from other plants in the public electricity supply network.
Emission limits for wind power plants electrically connected without interfering
consumption can be modified to values higher than the standard design limits.
4.5.3 Verification
4.5.3.1 Wind power plants with a power output range of 11 kW to 1.5 MW
It must be verified that the wind power plant complies with the limit values for
interharmonic current emissions in the same way as it does where harmonic
current emissions are concerned. The exponent =2 must be used, however.
4.5.3.2 Wind power plants with a power output greater than 1.5 MW
It must be verified that the wind power plant complies with the limit values for
interharmonic voltage emissions in the same way as it does where harmonic
currents are concerned. The exponent can be seen in Table 13.
32/74
4.6
4.6.3 Verification
It must be verified that the wind power plant complies with the limit values for
the emission of frequencies higher than 2 kHz in the same way as it does where
interharmonic emissions are concerned.
33/74
5.
5.1
All control functions mentioned in the following chapters refer to the point of
connection. It must be possible to activate/deactivate all the control functions
and set them using external signals, as described in chapter 7 and the
associated Appendix 4. The current settings must be agreed with the
electricity supply undertaking before the wind power plant can be connected to
the public electricity supply network.
The signs used in all figures follow the generator convention. The required
active (MW) and reactive (Mvar) power will be reduced on a pro-rata basis in
relation to the number of wind turbine generator systems in operation in the
wind power plant.
After a wind power plant has been disconnected due to a fault in the public
electricity supply network, the wind power plant must at the earliest be
automatically connected three minutes after the voltage and the frequency have
once again come to lie within the limits stated in chapter 3.1 and chapter 3.2.
A wind power plant which has been disconnected by an external signal prior to a
fault occurring in the public electricity supply network must not be connected
until the external signal has been eliminated, and the voltage and the frequency
have once again come to lie within the limits stated in chapter 3.1 and
chapter 3.2.
Wind power plants with an output greater than 1.5 MW must be equipped with
the control functions specified in Table 17. The purpose of the various control
functions is to ensure overall control and monitoring of the wind power plant's
generation. The various control functions can be implemented in the individual
wind turbine generator system or be gathered in a wind power plant controller,
provided there is only one communication interface, as illustrated on Figure 7.
Figure 7
34/74
5.2
A wind power plant must be equipped with active power control functions
capable of controlling the active power supplied by a wind power plant in the
point of connection using orders containing setpoints and gradients.
The current parameter settings for active power control functions are
determined by the electricity supply undertaking in collaboration with the
transmission system operator before commissioning.
In addition to the general requirements in chapter 5.1, the active power
control functions must comply with the requirements outlined in the following
chapters.
5.2.1
Frequency control
35/74
The purpose of the frequency control function is to reduce active power if grid
frequencies exceed f3, as shown in Figure 8 and Figure 9.
Figure 8
Frequency control for wind power plants with a power output higher than
25 MW, as shown in connection with a minor downward regulation PDelta
Active power
Dead band
Pavailable
Droop 1
fmax
PDelta
Droop 2
Droop 3
fmin
f7
Pmin
0
47.00
48.00
49.00
f1
Figure 9
50.00
f2
51.00
f3 f4
52.00
Frequency
[Hz]
Frequency control for wind power plants with a power output higher than
25 MW, as shown in connection with a major downward regulation PDelta
36/74
performed and of the setpoint must not deviate by more than 2% of the
setpoint value or by 0.5% of the rated power, depending on which yields the
highest tolerance.
5.2.2
Constraint functions
37/74
the setpoint value or by 0.5% of the rated power, depending on which yields
the highest tolerance.
In, the active power constraint functions are illustrated on Figure 10.
Active power
Deactivation of absolut
production constraint
Activation of delta
production constraint
Spinning
reserve
Activation of gradient
production constraint
Time
A wind power plant must be equipped with reactive power control functions
capable of controlling the reactive power supplied by a wind power plant in the
point of connection as well as a voltage control function capable of controlling
the voltage in the point of connection via orders using setpoints and gradients.
The reactive power and voltage control functions are mutually exclusive, which
means that only one of the three functions can be activated at a time.
The current parameter settings for reactive power control and voltage functions
must be determined before commissioning by the electricity supply undertaking
in collaboration with the transmission system operator.
In addition to complying with the general requirements in chapter 5.1, the
reactive power and voltage control functions must comply with the
requirements laid down in the following chapters.
38/74
5.3.1
Q control
5.3.2
39/74
5.3.3
Voltage control
40/74
5.4
System protection
A wind power plant must be equipped with system protection, which is a control
function capable of automatically downward regulating the active power from a
wind power plant to one or several predefined setpoints. The setpoints are
determined by the electricity supply undertaking upon commissioning.
It must be possible to set up at least five different setpoints for the wind power
plant.
If the system protection setpoint is to be changed, such change must be
commenced within one second and completed not later than 10 seconds after
receipt of an order to change the setpoint. The accuracy of the control
performed and of the setpoint must not deviate by more than 2% of the
setpoint value or by 0.5% of the rated power, depending on which yields the
highest tolerance.
5.5
The individual control functions of a wind power plant must be ranked in order
of priority vis--vis each other. A priority 1 control function takes precedence
over a priority 2 control function etc. The order of priority recommended is as
follows:
1.
2.
3.
System protection
Frequency control
Constraint functions
5.6
Wind power plants with a power output greater than 1.5 MW must be equipped
with the control functions specified in Table 17. The table shows the minimum
requirements divided on the basis of the total rated power in the point of
connection.
The specifications and regulation functions specified must comply with the
international standard IEC 61400-25-2 [ref. 17].
P > 25 MW
Q control (5.3.1)
Control function
Table 17
41/74
*) A wind power plant must not perform frequency control or voltage control
without having entered into a specific agreement to this effect with the
electricity supply undertaking.
5.7
42/74
5.8
5.9
43/74
When the wind power plant has been disconnected or is not producing any
power, no compensation is required for the reactive power from the wind power
plant cabling and infrastructure.
P / Pn
1.0
0.6
Inductive
Q-import
Capacitive
Q-export
0.8
0.4
0.2
0.0
- 0.480
- 0.410
- 0.330
0.900
0.925
0.950
- 0.228 - 0.100
0.00
0.100
0.228
0.330
0.410
0.995
1.000
0.995 0.975
0.950
0.925
0.975
Q/Pmax
Cos
Figure 14 Reactive power requirements for wind power plants with a power
output range of 1.5 kW to 1.5 MW
44/74
Figure 15 Reactive power requirements for wind power plants with a power
output range of 1.5 MW to 25 MW
Wind turbine types already type-approved must be able to control reactive
power in accordance with the current type approval or the wind turbine
manufacturer's technical specifications applying at the time of commencement
of this technical regulation.
45/74
P / Pn
1.0
0.8
0.6
InductivE
Q-import
0.4
Capacitive
Q-export
0.2
0.0
- 0.480
- 0.410
- 0.330
- 0.228
0.00
0.228
0.330
0.410
0.900
0.925
0.950
0.975
1.000
0.975
0.950
0.925
Q/Pmax
Cos
Figure 16 Reactive power requirements for wind power plants with a power
output greater than 25 MW
U
Nominal voltages see table 1
Umax
U +10%
U +6%
U +5%
U -5%
U -10%
Umin
Figure 17
- 0.410
- 0.330
- 0.228
0.00
0.228
0.330
0.410
0.925
0.950
0.975
1.000
0.975
0.950
0.925
Q/Pmax
Cos
Requirements for voltage control range for wind power plants with
a power output greater than 25 MW
46/74
Protection
6.
Protection
6.1
General
Protection functions must be available to protect the wind power plant and to
ensure a stable public electricity supply network.
The plant owner is responsible for ensuring that a wind power plant is
dimensioned and equipped with the necessary protection functions so that the
wind power plant:
-
6.2
The wind power plant's protection functions and associated settings must be as
specified in the following subsections. Settings deviating from the requirements
can only be used if authorised by the electricity supply undertaking.
All settings are stated as RMS values. The wind power plant must be
disconnected or stopped if a measuring signal deviates more from its nominal
value than the setting.
The function time stated is the measuring time in which the trip condition must
constantly be complied with in order for the protection function to issue a trip
signal. It is not a question of the trip signal being subjected to a simple time
lag.
The use of vector jump relays as protection against island operation and loss of
mains is not allowed.
It is assumed that the nominal voltage of the wind turbine generator system is
determined on the low-voltage side of the step-up transformer. As regards
47/74
Protection
Protection function
Symbol
Overvoltage (step 2)
U>>
1.10 Un
200
ms
Overvoltage (step 1)
U>
1.06 Un
60
Undervoltage (step 1)
U<
0.90 Un
1060
Overfrequency
f>
52
Hz
200
ms
Underfrequency
f<
47
Hz
200
ms
df/dt
2.5
Hz/s
200
ms
Frequency change
Table 18
Setting
Function time
48/74
Protection
Protection function
Symbol
Overvoltage (step 3)
U>>>
1.20 Un
5100
ms
Overvoltage (step 2)
U>>
1.10 Un
200
ms
Overvoltage (step 1)
U>
1.06 Un
60
Undervoltage (step 1)
U<
0.90 Un
1060
Overfrequency
f>
52
Hz
200
ms
Underfrequency
f<
47
Hz
200
ms
Table 19
Setting
Function time
Protection function
Symbol
Overvoltage (step 3)
U>>>
1.20 Un
5100
ms
Overvoltage (step 2)
U>>
1.15 Un
Overvoltage (step 1)
U>
1.10 Un
60
Undervoltage (step 1)
U<
0.90 Un
1060
Overfrequency
f>
52
Hz
200
ms
Underfrequency
f<
47
Hz
200
ms
Table 20
Setting
Function time
49/74
7.
7.1
Out of consideration for the operation of the public electricity supply network, it
is necessary to prepare for communication between the wind turbine generator
system operator and the transmission system operator in accordance with the
version of the regulation applicable at any given time.
7.1.3 Wind power plants with a power output greater than 1.5 MW
Wind power plants must be prepared for receiving an external start signal
(released) and an external stop signal. The signals must be accessible via
commands in accordance with the specifications in chapter 7.3.
It must be possible to obtain correct measurements and maintain data
communication in all situations, including when wind power plants are shut
down and the grid is dead. Local back-up supply must as a minimum ensure the
logging of relevant measurements and data and ensure the controlled shutdown of the wind power plant's control and monitoring system. Logging in
connection with a shut-down must be performed at minute level.
All measurements and data relevant to recording and analysis must be logged
with a time stamp and an accuracy ensuring that such measurements and data
can be correlated with each other and with similar recordings in the public
electricity supply network. Time stamping must refer to UTC or GPS with an
accuracy and precision of minimum 10 ms. The UTC modifier is +1 hour for
winter time and +2 hours for summer time.
7.2
The requirements specified in this chapter apply to wind power plants of all
sizes.
Specific requirements for installed measuring equipment, measuring accuracy
and master data that must be available in order for a wind power plant to be
connected to the public electricity supply network are specified in the following
regulations:
50/74
7.3
Data communication
The requirements apply to wind power plants with a power output greater than
1.5 MW.
The information for a wind power plant must as a minimum be modelled and
grouped as specified in the IEC 61400-25-2 standard [ref. 17].
The signal list relating to the exchange of information with a wind power plant
must as a minimum comprise the signals specified by the IEC 61400-25-2
standard [ref. 17] as 'mandatory'.
For a wind power plant the information exchange must as a minimum be
implemented using a protocol stack for IEC 61400-25-4 Annex D (IEC-60870-5104) [ref. 20]. The configuration of the IEC-60870-5-104 protocol stack must
be performed in such a way as to allow the wind power plant to communicate
with at least two master units.
The specific requirements for information and signals are specified in Appendix
4.
The current settings for the wind power plant must be defined in collaboration
with the electricity supply undertaking and documented in accordance with the
requirements in chapter 8.
7.4
The requirement for recording fault incidents in the public electricity supply
network applies to wind power plants with a power output greater than 25 MW.
Logging must be performed using electronic equipment that can be configured
to log all incidents in the point of connection in case of faults in the public
electricity supply network.
The plant owner must install in the point of connection logging equipment
capable of recording at least the following information about the wind power
plant:
-
51/74
7.5
The requirements apply to wind power plants with a power output greater than
25 MW.
The electricity supply undertaking and the transmission system operator are
always entitled to request relevant information about a wind power plant. The
expenses relating to requesting such information must be paid by the plant
owner.
The transmission system operator can request meter data and fault recorder
data collected for the wind power plant for a period of three months back in
time.
The electricity supply undertaking and the transmission system operator are
always entitled to request that a wind power plant verify and document its
compliance with the provisions of this regulation. Such verification and
documentation must be based on the metered data and/or calculations specified
by the electricity supply undertaking or the transmission system operator.
52/74
8.
The plant owner is responsible for ensuring that the wind power plant complies
with this technical regulation and documents that the requirements are being
complied with.
The documentation which the wind power plant is required to provide is
specified in this chapter, which has been arranged in accordance with the total
rated power in the point of connection.
The general procedure as regards the approval and issue of an operating permit
for a wind power plant is as follows:
-
Where wind power plants with a power output greater than 1.5 MW are
concerned, documentation as outlined in the following sections must be
provided.
8.1
The documentation to be provided must be in the form of data valid at the time
of commissioning:
-
8.2
The documentation to be provided must be in the form of data valid at the time
of commissioning:
-
53/74
8.3
The documentation to be provided must be in the form of data valid at the time
of commissioning:
-
8.4
54/74
Documentation
Appendix 1 Documentation
Appendix 1 covers the total documentation requirement for a wind power plant.
Appendix 1 must be filled in and sent electronically to the electricity supply
undertaking.
Appendix A1.1 Master data shows the general information about the wind power
plant which the electricity supply undertaking uses to register the wind power
plant in the electronic self-service portal.
Appendix A1.2 Technical documentation comprises all other information
necessary for the electricity supply undertaking in respect of operational and
computational issues.
The technical information must be provided in the form of commissioning data
applying to the wind power plant at the time of commissioning.
If information is changed after the time of commissioning, updated
documentation must be forwarded, as stipulated in chapter 2.2 (Changes to an
existing wind power plant).
Template for appendix is only available in Danish and can be found at
www.energinet.dk.
55/74
Documentation
Text
Identification:
Name of electricity supply
undertaking
Plant name
GSRN number
Planned commissioning
Technical data:
Manufacturer
Type designation (model)
Type approval
Approval authority
Installed kW (rated power)
Cos (rated power)
Cos (20% rated power)
Cos (no load)
3-phase short-circuit current
immediately in front of wind power
plant (RMS)
Rotor diameter (m)
Hub height (m)
Point of connection
Voltage level
60 kV substation
56/74
Documentation
Description
Text
Plant address:
Contact person (technical)
Address1
House number
Letter
Postal code
BBR municipality
X/Y coordinates
Title number
Owners' association on titled land
Owner:
CVR number
or civil registration number (CPR)
Company name
Contact person (administrative)
Address1
House number
Letter
Floor
To the right/left
Postal code
Email address
57/74
Documentation
Value
Make
Type
Comments
Description
Symbol
Unit
Sn
MVA
Up
kV
Us
kV
dutp
%/trin
phitp
degree/st
ep
ntpmin
ntpmax
ntp0
uk
Copper loss
Pcu
kW
uk0
ukr0
No-load current
I0
No-load loss
P0
Value
Primary side
Secondary side
As an alternative to filling in the above form, similar data can be enclosed in the
form of a data sheet for the transformer and a possible tap changer.
58/74
Documentation
Recommended
value
Symbol
Unit
U>
kV
Un x 1.06
T>
60
U>>
kV
Un x 1.10
T>>
0.2
Symbol
Unit
Recommended
value
U>
kV
Un x 1.06
T>
60
U>>
kV
Un x 1.10
T>>
0.2
U>>>
kV
Un x 1.20
T>>>
ms
5..100
Current
value
Make
Type
Yes
No
Comments
Current
value
Make
Type
Yes
No
Comments
59/74
Documentation
Recommended
value
Symbol
Unit
U>
kV
Un x 1.10
T>
60
U>>
kV
Un x 1.15
T>>
U>>>
kV
Un x 1.20
T>>>
ms
5..100
Symbol
Unit
Recommended
value
U<
kV
Un x 0.90
T<
1060
Symbol
Unit
Recommended
value
f>
Hz
52.0
T>
ms
200
Current
value
Make
Type
Yes
No
Comments
Current
value
Make
Type
Is there an undervoltage relay?
(U<)
Yes
No
Comments
Current
value
Yes
No
Comments
60/74
Documentation
Recommended
value
Symbol
Unit
f<1
Hz
47.0
T<1
ms
200
Make
Type
Is there an underfrequency relay?
(f<)
If yes, setting 1 of underfrequency
relay (frequency)
If yes, setting 1 of underfrequency
relay (function time)
Current
value
Yes
No
Comments
Recommended
value
Symbol
Unit
(df/dt)1
Hz/s
+2.5
T1
ms
200
(df/dt)2
Hz/s
-2.5
T2
ms
200
Current
value
Yes
No
Comments
61/74
Documentation
form for flicker coefficient, voltage changes and flicker caused by switching
in accordance with IEC 61400-21 Annex A
form for harmonic overtones in accordance with IEC 61400-21 Annex A
necessary calculations in accordance with chapter 4
62/74
Documentation
A1.2.8. PQ diagram
This applies to all wind power plants with a rated power greater than 1.5 MW in
the same point of connection.
The appendix includes a PQ diagram showing the reactive power which the wind
power plant can produce/consume in accordance with the requirements
specified in chapter 5.3.
63/74
Documentation
All wind turbine generator systems in the wind power plant are connected
The wind power plant produces the rated power
Current values are calculated in the point of connection
Symmetrical voltage drop is indicated as a percentage (dU) of the output
voltage
The wind power plant's protection functions/settings are included
The short-circuit power in the point of connection is set to 10 x Pn with an
X/R of 10
Iactive [A]
Ireactive [A]
Ipeak [A]
0
5
10
20
50
100
150
200
300
500
dU=30%
Time [ms]
Iactive [A]
Ireactive [A]
Ipeak [A]
0
5
10
20
50
100
150
200
300
500
64/74
Documentation
dU=50%
Time [ms]
Iactive [A]
Ireactive [A]
Ipeak [A]
0
5
10
20
50
100
150
200
300
500
dU=80%
Time [ms]
Iactive [A]
Ireactive [A]
Ipeak [A]
0
5
10
20
50
100
150
200
300
500
65/74
Simulation model
The plant owner must not later than three months after commissioning send
a simulation model of each individual wind turbine generator system in the
wind power plant.
The plant owner must provide data for the power infrastructure upon request.
preliminary data for the dynamic simulation model, covering each individual
type of wind turbine generator system in the wind power plant
data for a dynamic simulation model of the wind power plant controller
data for the power infrastructure consisting of cables and ?switching? and
relay protection equipment.
The simulation model of the wind power plant controller and the simulation
model of the various types of wind turbine generator systems must have a
contents and be so detailed that they can be immediately integrated and
66/74
Simulation model
67/74
Simulation model
It should be possible to use simulation models for simulating RSM values in the
individual phases during asymmetrical incidents and faults in the public
electricity supply network.
It must as a minimum be possible to use the simulation models in the 47-53 Hz
frequency range and in the 0-1.4 p.u. voltage range.
Simulation models must be able to describe the dynamic reply from the wind
power plant for at least 30 seconds after any incident and fault in the public
electricity supply network.
It must be possible to initialise the simulation models direct on the basis of a
load-flow solution without subsequent iterations.
Simulation models must be numerically stable and capable of utilising numerical
equation solvers with variable time step.
68/74
Simulation model
The time-series measurements used for validating the simulation model must
be enclosed (in COMTRADE format) with the validation report.
69/74
d (%) = 100% k u ( k )
Sn
1
= 100% 0,5
= 1%
Sk
50
The result is lower than the limit value, and the requirements in relation to
rapid voltage change can therefore be regarded as having been complied with.
A3.2. Flicker
A3.2.1. Limit values
If the connected rated power is lower than 0.4% of the minimum short-circuit
power in the point of connection, the wind power plant can be connected
without any additional examinations being performed.
If the connected power is greater than 0.4% of the minimum short-circuit
power in the point of connection, the following procedure must be applied:
Wind power plants with a power output up to 1.5 MW
The limit values indicated in Table 4 can be applied directly.
Wind power plants with a power output greater than 1.5 MW
The limit value (Plt,i) for the emission from the wind power plant, i, is calculated
as:
Plt ,i = Glt 3
Si
S prod ,tot
Where:
Glt is the total permissible emission from the wind power plant in the
connection point, see Table 5.
Si is the power produced by wind power plant i
Sprod, tot is the maximum concurrent wind power generation, including Si,
which is expected to be connected to the public electricity supply
network.
Plt ,i = Glt 3
Si
S prod ,tot
70/74
2
= 0,275
12
Flicker emission from the wind turbine generator system is then calculated as
shown in the previous examples, and the computed values are compared with
the flicker emission limit.
Pst = c( k , v a )
Sn
1
= 2
= 0,04
50
Sk
As Pst can be assumed to be equal to Plt during continuous operation, and the
value computed lies below the limit values, the requirement regarding flicker
during continuous operation can then be regarded as having been complied
with.
A3.2.3. Switching
A 1 MVA wind turbine generator system is connected to the public electricity
supply network at 10 kV level. The electricity supply undertaking has calculated
a short-circuit effect of 50 MVA and a short-circuit angle of 84 in the point of
connection. It can be seen from the data sheet for the IEC 61400-21 type test,
which is included in the type approval for the wind turbine generator system,
that the flicker step factor is 0.1.
Assuming that there is a maximum of two switching's per hour, the flicker
contribution can now be calculated as:
0 , 31
Plt ,i = 8 N 120
min,i k f ,i ( k )
S n ,i
Sk
= 8 4 0,31 0,1
1
= 0,02
50
As the computed value lies below the limit value, the requirement regarding
flicker during continuous operation can be considered as having been complied
with.
71/74
A3.3. Harmonics
Wind power plants with a power output range of 1.5 MW to 25 MW
The limit value for the emission from the individual wind power plant, i, is
calculated as:
Ei ,h = LMV ,h LHV ,h
| S last ,max,MV + LV
Si
| + | S prod ,max,MV + LV |
Where:
Ei,h is the emission limit for order h harmonics for wind power plant i
LMV,h is the design limit for order h harmonics h at medium-voltage level
LMV,h is the design limit for order h harmonics h at high-voltage level
Si is the power produced by wind power plant i
Slast,, max, MV+LV is the maximum load provided by the medium-voltage grid
concerned. The value is determined taking account of future consumption
increases.
Slast,, max, MV+LV is the maximum harmonics-generated production capacity
in and below the medium-voltage grid concerned. The value is
determined taking account of future production increases.
IEC TR 61000-3-6 and IEC 61000-3-12 gives examples of design values for the
medium-voltage and the high-voltage grids, the most important of which can be
seen in Table 10, Table 11 and Table 12 in chapter 4.4.2.3. As regards
wind power plants whose point of connection is far away from the point of
common coupling, the electricity supply undertaking can normally authorise
emissions in the point of connection higher than the stated limit values applying
in the point of common coupling.
A 2 MVA wind turbine generator system is connected to the public electricity
supply network at 10 kV level. 10 MVA of wind power generation has already
been connected to the 10 kV network concerned, and there is a 10 MVA load.
No additional systems are expected to be connected. When using the 5th
harmonics as an example and the IEC's recommended values, the emission
limit for the new system can be calculated as:
Ei , 5 =
1, 4
5%1, 4 2%1, 4 1, 4
2
= 0,72%
12 + 10
Here, the emission limit has been set as a voltage value, and the wind power
plant's permissible current emission must be determined taking account of the
specific circumstances in the public electricity supply network, including possible
resonance reinforcement.
72/74
Signal list
73/74
Commissioning report
74/74