Professional Documents
Culture Documents
www.ijirset.com
4241
ISSN: 2319-8753
International Journal of Innovative Research in Science,
Engineering and Technology
(An ISO 3297: 2007 Certified Organization)
Copyright to IJIRSET
www.ijirset.com
4242
ISSN: 2319-8753
International Journal of Innovative Research in Science,
Engineering and Technology
(An ISO 3297: 2007 Certified Organization)
Model 5: When shear wall placed at centre and four shear wall placed at outer edge parallel to X and Y direction.
Copyright to IJIRSET
www.ijirset.com
4243
ISSN: 2319-8753
International Journal of Innovative Research in Science,
Engineering and Technology
(An ISO 3297: 2007 Certified Organization)
VBx (KN)
VBy (KN)
Model 1
Model 2
Model 3
Model 4
Model 5
3995.92
4112.82
4131.55
4099.7
4242.98
3995.92
4112.82
4131.55
4099.7
4242.98
30
model1
25
model2
20
Storey no
model3
15
model4
10
moodel5
5
0
0
1000
2000
3000
4000
5000
Copyright to IJIRSET
www.ijirset.com
4244
ISSN: 2319-8753
International Journal of Innovative Research in Science,
Engineering and Technology
(An ISO 3297: 2007 Certified Organization)
Copyright to IJIRSET
M-5
47.88
46.52
45.07
43.52
41.86
40.09
38.21
36.22
34.13
31.95
29.69
27.36
24.98
22.56
20.12
17.69
15.28
12.91
10.61
8.42
6.36
4.48
2.83
1.47
0.48
www.ijirset.com
4245
ISSN: 2319-8753
International Journal of Innovative Research in Science,
Engineering and Technology
(An ISO 3297: 2007 Certified Organization)
M-1
61.12
60.25
59.20
57.93
56.48
54.84
53.04
51.08
48.98
46.74
44.37
41.88
39.27
36.56
33.75
30.83
27.83
24.74
21.56
18.29
14.94
11.51
8.03
4.62
1.60
M-2
55.26
54.26
53.12
51.83
50.40
48.82
47.09
45.23
43.23
41.11
38.87
36.52
34.06
31.51
28.86
26.13
23.32
20.44
17.51
14.54
11.56
8.61
5.78
3.19
1.08
M-3
43.23
42.50
41.66
40.71
39.63
38.43
37.12
35.69
34.16
32.53
30.79
28.97
27.05
25.06
22.99
20.85
18.65
16.40
14.10
11.77
9.42
7.08
4.82
2.73
0.96
M-4
37.90
36.92
35.88
34.77
33.58
32.32
30.98
29.56
28.07
26.51
24.88
23.18
21.43
19.62
17.77
15.88
13.96
12.03
10.10
8.19
6.33
4.56
2.94
1.55
0.51
M-5
33.80
32.87
31.88
30.85
29.75
28.58
27.35
26.06
24.70
23.28
21.81
20.28
18.69
17.07
15.41
13.72
12.01
10.30
8.59
6.93
5.32
3.82
2.46
1.30
0.44
M-5
35.44
34.26
33.04
31.78
30.47
29.11
27.70
26.24
24.73
23.18
21.58
19.95
18.28
16.58
14.87
13.14
11.42
9.71
8.03
6.41
4.88
3.46
2.20
1.15
0.38
4246
ISSN: 2319-8753
International Journal of Innovative Research in Science,
Engineering and Technology
(An ISO 3297: 2007 Certified Organization)
Storey
no
M-1
M-2
M-3
M-4
M-5
25
0.364
0.434
0.351
0.471
0.456
25
0.432
0.544
0.597
0.436
0.589
24
0.457
0.497
0.415
0.507
0.488
24
0.537
0.624
0.628
0.504
0.616
23
0.554
0.562
0.48
0.546
0.52
23
0.65
0.718
0.663
0.58
0.643
22
0.647
0.631
0.548
0.59
0.556
22
0.758
0.816
0.704
0.659
0.674
21
0.731
0.699
0.614
0.636
0.594
21
0.858
0.911
0.747
0.736
0.707
20
0.808
0.767
0.676
0.681
0.632
20
0.948
1.003
0.791
0.807
0.74
19
0.876
0.83
0.734
0.724
0.668
19
1.028
1.084
0.832
0.873
0.77
18
0.937
0.886
0.787
0.763
0.703
18
1.1
1.158
0.871
0.933
0.799
17
0.99
0.936
0.834
0.799
0.733
17
1.163
1.221
0.906
0.986
0.825
16
1.035
0.98
0.875
0.83
0.76
16
1.217
1.276
0.936
1.033
0.846
15
1.074
1.017
0.911
0.856
0.783
15
1.262
1.323
0.961
1.073
0.863
14
1.106
1.047
0.941
0.877
0.8
14
1.3
1.361
0.98
1.107
0.874
13
1.132
1.072
0.965
0.892
0.813
13
1.331
1.391
0.993
1.132
0.88
12
1.151
1.09
0.983
0.902
0.819
12
1.354
1.415
0.998
1.152
0.879
11
1.166
1.103
0.996
0.904
0.819
11
1.371
1.43
0.994
1.164
0.871
10
1.174
1.109
1.003
0.899
0.811
10
1.382
1.439
0.983
1.171
0.855
1.178
1.109
1.003
0.887
0.796
1.386
1.442
0.963
1.169
0.83
1.177
1.102
0.997
0.865
0.772
1.385
1.438
0.931
1.16
0.796
1.172
1.086
0.983
0.833
0.738
1.379
1.426
0.886
1.141
0.752
1.163
1.06
0.959
0.788
0.692
1.368
1.405
0.828
1.112
0.694
1.148
1.019
0.922
0.728
0.632
1.35
1.368
0.752
1.069
0.625
1.125
0.955
0.864
0.648
0.555
1.319
1.304
0.655
1.006
0.54
1.078
0.856
0.776
0.542
0.457
1.255
1.182
0.533
0.908
0.436
0.95
0.69
0.634
0.398
0.333
1.087
0.939
0.378
0.732
0.31
0.519
0.347
0.337
0.186
0.161
0.574
0.435
0.169
0.36
0.144
4247
ISSN: 2319-8753
International Journal of Innovative Research in Science,
Engineering and Technology
(An ISO 3297: 2007 Certified Organization)
Storey
no
M-1
M-2
M-3
M-4
M-5
Storey
no
M-1
M-2
M-3
M-4
M-5
25
0.337
0.41
0.305
0.393
0.364
25
0.404
0.499
0.481
0.397
0.447
24
0.435
0.48
0.368
0.426
0.391
24
0.516
0.599
0.51
0.467
0.469
23
0.537
0.544
0.427
0.46
0.416
23
0.633
0.707
0.537
0.537
0.49
22
0.625
0.611
0.479
0.493
0.441
22
0.734
0.801
0.565
0.6
0.509
21
0.695
0.672
0.525
0.523
0.464
21
0.815
0.877
0.591
0.651
0.529
20
0.752
0.723
0.564
0.55
0.486
20
0.88
0.935
0.615
0.696
0.545
19
0.8
0.768
0.599
0.575
0.506
19
0.936
0.983
0.638
0.736
0.561
18
0.843
0.808
0.63
0.597
0.524
18
0.986
1.027
0.657
0.771
0.574
17
0.882
0.844
0.66
0.618
0.54
17
1.034
1.07
0.676
0.805
0.585
16
0.919
0.877
0.687
0.636
0.555
16
1.077
1.109
0.693
0.836
0.596
15
0.951
0.907
0.713
0.653
0.568
15
1.115
1.145
0.707
0.865
0.604
14
0.979
0.935
0.737
0.667
0.579
14
1.147
1.176
0.72
0.89
0.61
13
1.005
0.959
0.759
0.679
0.589
13
1.177
1.204
0.729
0.914
0.613
12
1.03
0.982
0.779
0.689
0.596
12
1.206
1.23
0.736
0.936
0.615
11
1.054
1.002
0.795
0.697
0.6
11
1.234
1.255
0.74
0.953
0.613
10
1.075
1.02
0.809
0.701
0.601
10
1.26
1.278
0.739
0.968
0.608
1.094
1.034
0.821
0.701
0.597
1.283
1.294
0.733
0.98
0.598
1.11
1.044
0.828
0.695
0.589
1.301
1.306
0.72
0.986
0.582
1.124
1.05
0.832
0.683
0.573
1.318
1.314
0.699
0.988
0.56
1.14
1.05
0.829
0.661
0.549
1.335
1.324
0.667
0.983
0.529
1.156
1.038
0.816
0.627
0.513
1.351
1.329
0.622
0.969
0.487
1.164
1.003
0.786
0.574
0.462
1.355
1.31
0.556
0.938
0.432
1.138
0.925
0.726
0.493
0.391
1.314
1.228
0.464
0.872
0.358
1.005
0.765
0.608
0.373
0.293
1.14
1.003
0.339
0.721
0.264
0.534
0.392
0.33
0.18
0.148
0.585
0.475
0.157
0.363
0.129
4248
ISSN: 2319-8753
International Journal of Innovative Research in Science,
Engineering and Technology
(An ISO 3297: 2007 Certified Organization)
1.
2.
3.
IV. CONCLUSION
The seismic analysis of reinforced concrete frame structure is done by both static and dynamic analysis to
determine and compare the base shear; it has been found that maximum base shear in model-5 along longitudinal
and transverse direction as compared to the other models.
In equivalent static analysis it has been found that model-5 shows lesser displacement as compared to other models
in longitudinal direction. In response spectrum analysis model-5 shows lesser displacement as compared to other
models in longitudinal direction. In equivalent static analysis it has been found that model-5 shows lesser interstorey drift as compared to other models in longitudinal direction. In response spectrum analysis model-5 shows
lesser inter-storey drift as compared to other models in longitudinal direction.
The presence of shear wall can affect the seismic behavior of frame structure to large extent, and the shear wall
increases the strength and stiffness of the structure.It has been found that the model-5 shows better location of
shear wall since lateral displacement and inter-storey drift are less as compared to other models.
In case of shear wall at exterior corners the structure is subjected to less displacement against the structure with shear
wall at Centre. From the above study we conclude that model-5 shows better performance among the other models.
REFERENCES
[1] Bryan Stafford Smith and Alex Coull Tall Building Structures: Analysis And Design A Wiley-intersceince publication, New York 1991.
[2] Kasliwal Sagar K. and Anantwad Shirish, Effects of number and position of shear walls on seismic behavior of multi-storey structure ISSN:
2278-7844,University of Pune .
[3] P. S. Kumbhare, A. C. Saoji, Effectiveness of changing of RC shear wall location in multi-storey building, International Journal of Engineering
Research and Applications Vol. 2, Issue 5, pp.1072-1076 Sant Gadge Baba Amravati University, Amravati, Maharashtra.
[4] Anuj Chandiwala, Earthquake Analysis of Building Configuration withDifferent Position of Shear Wall, International Journal of Emerging
Technology and Advanced Engineering ISSN 2250-2459, ISO 9001:2008 Certified Journal, Volume 2, Issue 12, December 2012, Adhoc Lecturer in
Sarvajanik College of Engineering & Technology, Athvalines, Surat, Gujarat, India.
[5] B. L. Brueggen, C. W. French, N. Jung, and S. D. Nakaki, rectangular reinforced concrete shear walls ACI Committee 318, 2002. Building
Code Requirements for Structural Concrete, University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, MN 55414
[6] Romy Mohan and C Prabha, Dynamic analysis of Rcc Buildings with Shear Wall
International Journal of Earth Sciences and Engineering ISSN 0974-5904, Volume
04, No 06 SPL, October 2011, pp 659-662.
[7] IS 1893(Part 1):2002 Criteria For Earthquake Resistant Design of Structures BIS, New Delhi
[8] ETABS - v9.7 Integrated Building Design Software Manual, CSI, USA
[9] Pankaj Agarwal and Manish Shrikande Earthquake Resistant Design Of Structures PHI Learning Private Limited New Delhi 2010
[10] S.K.Duggal Earthquake Resistant Design of Structures Oxford University Press, New Delhi 2010
Copyright to IJIRSET
www.ijirset.com
4249