Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Strategies: The
Effectiveness of Soft Power
Student Name: Bader Emad Mohammed Ali Mahdi Almaskati
Student ID: 601653
Supervisor: Prof. Dr Stephen Hopgood
Word Count: 9805
MA International Studies and Diplomacy
15/09/2014
Plagiarism Declaration
Abstract
Soft power and nation branding are essential factors for a state to
communicate with global audiences around the world. A state's
investments in public diplomacy, and nation branding campaigns
can prove to be effective in terms of establishing relationships with
other countries, promoting tourism, and to gain influence in the
international community. Qatar has established various soft power
resources such as the Al Jazeera news network, FIFA World Cup
2022, and several cultural and educational exchange programs with
countries from around the world. This dissertation will conclude that
soft
power
has
proved
to
be
an
effective
strategy
to
be
Table of Contents
1. Introduction..........................................................................................................p4-5
2. Analyzing Soft power and Nation Branding ................. p6-17
A Creating an Identity........................................................................................p6-8
B
1. Introduction:
3
community.
In
recent
years,
Qatar
has
proved
diplomatic
strategies
to
distinguish
the
state
as
soft
power
and
global
image.
Having
made
major
learn
much
about
other
places.
The
clichs
and
sovereign
state
Qatar
is
looking
for
regional
neighboring countries.
understood and that the world is getting the right message that the
state is aiming to deliver. However, the support of the Qatari
government to the Muslim brotherhood over the role of political
Islam within the region has led to major disputes between the Qatari
government and member states of the Gulf Cooperation Council
(GCC) in March 2014. These diplomatic disputes led to the
withdrawal of the ambassadors of Saudi Arabia, UAE, and Bahrain
from Qatar. Interestingly the Qatari government are standing firm to
their decision of supporting the Muslim brotherhood which makes
Qatars situation diplomatically sophisticated.
Moreover, these actions have further enhanced Qatars
credibility to the west as being a sovereign state that is acting in its
own interest and being a state that is capable of making its own
decisions regardless of its neighboring countries. The emir of Qatar,
Sheikh Tamim Al Thani has made it very clear that the changes in
the status quo within the region need to take place in order to
challenge the stereotypical view of the international pubic towards
the Qatari state. From a realist perspective in international relations
it may be argued that the dispute between the GCC states and
Qatar was a cause of classical balance of power dynamics. The
decisions taken by the Qatari government to support the Muslim
brotherhood in Egypt had a negative effect on its relationship with
its
neighboring
countries.
However,
having
the
US
security
guarantee which backs Qatar, has allowed the small Gulf island to
8
Qatar
has
proved
to
be
an
influential
relationships
and
establish
national
brand
through
10
11
disappoint. The same implies on states using soft power and public
diplomacy strategies they have to deliver what is expected by the
public. A product with a famous name is one you can usually
depend on to do what it is meant to do, one thats made with quality
ingredients or components, and backed by a substantial company
which probably cares enough about its reputation to work hard to
remedy any problems you may have with the product later on. A
branded service, one hopes, invests constantly in the best training
for the best people (Anholt, 2007, p.3).
Qatar has managed to enhance its soft power strategies and
global
image
by
gaining
reputation
as
peacemaker.In
13
preference
among
international
audience.
Public
and
using
the
word
Qatar
in
its
advertising
and
shopping
malls.
The
fundamental
advantage,
is
power
reality,
Competitive
struggles
over
16
that
Qatar
taking
the
leadership
17
role
in
the
recent
Qatars
image
as
regional
mediator
that
18
19
focuses
on
freedom
of
speech,
democracy,
and
20
the hearts and minds of millions of Arabs through its support and
coverage throughout the Arab Spring. The networks public
discourse reveals a consistent theme emphasizing Al Jazeeras
obligation to its transnational Arab and Muslim audience, part of a
rhetorical trope that taps into one of the defining characteristics of
todays new public diplomacy: understanding communication as
dialogue(Powers and Gliboa, 2007, p.71). Officials in the West
relied upon Al Jazeeras transmissions to monitor developments that
were taking place in Egypt during the uprisings. Although skeptics
can argue that Qatar was biased and was supporting the Muslim
Brotherhood, the actions taken by Al Jazeera showed that Qatar was
a progressive society. The tiny island has become a major influential
actor in Middle Eastern politics, by proving that their media channel
was a powerful advocate that has the ability to influence and shape
public opinion in foreign societies.
After the attacks of 9/11 is when Al Jazeera became a
significant player in international politics being the only international
news organization with an operating bureau in Kabul. This provided
the news channel with firsthand exposure to the events that took
place during the Western intervention. The delivery of the news
focused on the damages that were caused in Afghanistan due to the
western intervention. Al Jazeeras cameras focused on the civilian
and the infrastructural damage caused by the American-led
invasion, producing images that were seen quite unfavorably by an
American government struggling to build international support of
22
23
The press gained more freedom in delivering news through the lens
of the Middle Eastern people. Conflicts that were rising in the Muslim
world that were viewed as insignificant by global media started to
gain more attention, allowing opposition groups space to criticize
their repressive governments. Aljazeera has been the only Arab
broadcaster to make serious inroads with western audiences,
challenging
the
stereotype
that
globalization
must
mean
24
western
audiences
view
Al
Jazeeras
news
as
26
influence,
strengthening
27
international
alliance,
and
28
incorrect
or
stereotyped
associations,
Qatars
Hosting the FIFA World Cup 2022 is a major step forward for Qatar
in terms of international recognition and in gaining leverage over its
neighboring countries. Hosting the World Cup will provide Qatar a
unique opportunity to enhance its public diplomacy externally and
internally. Mega-sporting events as large as the World Cup will gain
major media attention and will put Qatar in the global spotlight. The
tiny Gulf state will finally get the opportunity to communicate with
the world and enhance its attractiveness by the shared cultural
value of sport. This is not a new development in international
relations, for the Nazis attempted to influence foreign public opinion
of their regime through a bombastic Olympics as early as 1936 with
the first true sports mega-event. Because of the centrality of
universally admired values in international sporting events, hosting
states can enhance their attractiveness to others by demonstrating
that they not only share those values, but also that they wish to
champion and collectively celebrate these within the context of their
own distinctive cultural social and political values.(Grix and Lee,
2013, p.528). Hosting the World Cup will enhance Qatars image as
31
argued
that
globalization
has
turned
the
world
into
another
through
increasing
dialogue
and
cultural
year later China reciprocated the visit. Ping pong led to formal
diplomatic relations between the two states and led to an advent
relationship in terms of trade, investment, and politics.
Qatars sport diplomacy aims at increasing the prestige of the
country, creating a unique brand, and towards assuring the
legitimacy of the state in international relations. Sports has become
more than just a game, sports can be used as a means to solidify a
states reputation. Public visibility allows states to attract publicity,
hosting a sports-mega event will attract cameras and will be
mentioned in top-selling newspapers from around the world. The
absence of Qatar in sports over the years has not given them the
benefit of communicating with the world through sharing the
commonalities and passion those sports has to offer. Hosting the
world cup will draw the attention of almost every nation in the
world. The World Cup will have a generally liberalizing effect on
Qatars international politics. As a developing nation hosting the
World Cup, Qatar is sending a geopolitical message demonstrating
that they have taken their place on the international stage. Qatars
sports diplomacy is creating a positive impression among foreign
audiences as well as playing a major role in attracting tourism and
foreign investments.
33
and
re-present
their
previous
cultural
achievements
of
its
crucial
resources
are
outside
the
control
of
miss
the
point.
Simple
propaganda
often
lacks
36
37
education system for the Qatari youth and to diversify the states
economy by becoming a center for educational excellence within
the region. The educational city has enabled alternative pathways to
expose Qatars culture throughout the world. Education is the key
for changes and development within a society.
educational
exchange
programs
enable
Cultural and
students
to
better
and
cultural
exchange
provides
students
the
The
Bi-lateral
continents.(Qatar
Ministry
of
Foreign
Affairs,
2013).
41
The
strategic
objectives
behind
the
cultural
diplomacy
East.
Dubai
and
Abu
Dhabi
have
become
strategic
44
7. Conclusion:
This dissertation has aimed to focus on how Qatar has used
soft power strategies to create a national identity for itself, and how
these strategies can have a positive effect on the country in terms
of creating a national brand to communicate in various diplomatic
approaches with the international community. The implementation
of soft power strategies by states generates leverage. States
practice soft power to generate a sense of legitimacy and credibility
so that they can be accepted in the international community.
Investing and developing public diplomacy campaigns can help
states expose their national identity to the world. The concept of
soft power gives states the ability to shape the preferences of
others.
that you wantco-opts people rather than coerce them (Nye, p.4,
2004). In Qatars case, using soft power resources was an effective
strategy to enhance the states reputation, image, and leverage in
the international community. The small state has seized the
spotlight in the Middle East region, identity has become one that is
much more attractive than it has ever been. Qatar has managed to
effectively promote soft power in various ways.
The investments placed by the government to promote public
diplomacy proved to be a major success for the small island to rise
on the global stage. Al Jazeera, has become a major international
media channel that is recognized worldwide, the news channel has
45
proved its influence on the hearts and minds of the Muslims and
Arabs around the world during the 9/11 crisis and throughout the
Arab Spring. Qatars major involvement in the sporting industry has
lifted the states activity in terms of international communication;
the FIFA World Cup 2022 has raised the states reputation sky high
and has given the tiny island an opportunity to expose its identity to
the world by hosting the mega sporting event. Also, the states
investments in bi-lateral exchange programs have been a major
success for the Gulf country in terms of strengthening its long-term
relationships with countries around the world. Qatars efforts to
familiarize its culture and expose it to the world is proving to be a
beneficial factor to the country by improving its tourism sector,
attracting foreign investments, and in maintaining its stability in a
political environment that is not conducive to stability. By building
its reputation and credibility through its soft power resources Qatar
has took the role of the regional mediator within the Middle East and
is going forward in reaching its foreign policy objectives to gain
regional leverage.
Overall, Qatars rise on the global stage proves that soft power
is a realistic concept that is effective in world politics. The image
and identity of a state are essential elements for a state to establish
a brand for itself so that it can gain influence and further its foreign
policy objectives. Soft power and nation branding are two closely
linked concepts. Nation branding concerns how a nation as a whole
presents and represents itself to other nations (Anholt, 2006).
46
States in the Middle East have not been investing in nation branding
as much as they should have. In Qatars case, the small island has
seized the initiative in investing towards creating a national brand,
an identity that will differentiate the small state from its Middle
Eastern neighbors, and so far they have been successful in
attracting the international community by developing the states
soft power resources. The concept of nation branding is a new form
of soft power, it has changed the way information is received and
how public opinion is formed. As a small state having limited
military capabilities, Qatar has proved that it still can have a say in
making an impact and being involved in shaping up policies in the
global arena.
47
Bibliography
Heinemann.
Anholt, S. (2007). Competitive identity. 1st ed. Basingstoke [England]:
Palgrave Macmillan.
Anholt, S. (2011). 17. Beyond the nation brand: The role of image and identity
London: Routledge.
Blanchard, C. (2010). Qatar: Background and US relations.
Boyle, R. (1963). Sport: mirror of American life. 1st ed. Boston: Little,
Brown.
Brannagan, P. and Giulianotti, R. (2014). Qatar, Global Sport and the 2022
48
pp.53-80.
GinestaPortet, X., San Eugenio Vela, J. and others, (2013). The Use of
Football as a Country Branding Strategy. Case Study: Qatar and the Catalan
536.
Kinninmont, J. (2013). From football to military might, how Qatar wields
global power. [online] the Guardian. Available at:
http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2013/feb/03/qatar-tiny-gulf-state49
Revisited.
Lukes, S. (2005). Power. 1st ed. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.
Marsh, D. and Fawcett, P. (2011). Branding, politics and democracy. Policy
Palgrave Macmillan.
Nauright, J. (2013). Selling nations to the world through sports: mega-events
and nation branding as global diplomacy. Public Diplomacy Magazine, pp.22--
27.
Nye, J. (2004). Soft power. 1st ed. New York: Public Affairs.
Nye, J. (2008). The powers to lead. 1st ed. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Peterson, J. (2006). Qatar and the world: Branding for a micro-state. The
Books.
Singh, J. (2010). International cultural policies and power. 1st ed.
Publishers.
Zhang, L. and Zhao, S. (2009). City branding and the Olympic effect: A case
study of Beijing. Cities, 26(5), pp.245--254.
51
52