Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Ke
n Schoolland addressing the Bastiat Society
risky activity. Thus, in the new land they settle down, they have to work
twice better than those of the indigenous population if they are to succeed
in life.
Discrimination of migrants makes them work hard
Second, migrants always face subtle barriers in their new adoptive homes.
These barriers may take the form of racism or being labelled as outcasts in
social groups. Whatever it may be, they do not have a level playing field to
compete with indigenous businessmen. This factor starts a burning fire in
their system making them hardier in everything they do.
Furnham says that it is a positive development arising out of discriminatory
practices exercised against migrants because those migrants have to find
another way for leading a successful life with no well-trodden paths, leg-ups
or building success on family names.
Live together to ensure protection
Third, with discriminations and hurdles placed before them, the migrants
tend to build up social networks to support each other. Furnham says that it
is observable in big cities where certain parts are fully colonised by people
of certain countries or ethnic groups.
Living together gives them the needed economic, financial and emotional
protection and it in turn causes them to work together rather than alone.
Thus, migrants work together and work hard in order to avoid being
failures.
The lazy native populations living on migrants hard work
Fourth, when migrants work hard and create wealth, the natives too start
enjoying benefits disproportionately. Governments tax the migrants and
pass on the benefits to natives. But it would make the natives a privileged
class and that privileged position makes them complacent. This is the
reason why the second generation of the migrants is not so successful as
their forefathers. Once economic affluence is gained by a family or a nation,
the old ideals of working hard and creating wealth are easily abandoned.
Furnham says the best way to teach children about money is not to have
any so that they are exposed to the hard realities of societies from early
childhood. Even the successful indigenous entrepreneurs are migrants from
another part of the country and their second generations, in many cases,
are not as successful as the internally migrated first generations.
British planters in Ceylon were a different lot
The success story of the British planters who migrated to Sri Lanka in the
mid-19th century is a testimony of Furnhams thesis. For these British
planters, the life awaiting them in upcountry Ceylon as Sri Lanka was
called at that time was not pleasant or comfortable at all.
They had to work with a hostile local population, wild elephants and even
little insects like mosquitoes that brought in deadly malaria not only to
them but also to their workers. There was no banking system to transfer
money from England to Ceylon or vice versa and therefore, capital was
brought in the form of coins called specie in physical form.
Saradiel, the first anti-FDI gangster
Trunk-loads of specie as well as the provisions had to be transported in
caravans of bullock carts suffering immense hardships. These caravans
were often waylaid by highwaymen who operated outside the legal system.
One example was the exploits of the Saradiel of Uthuwankande who
waylaid the caravans in transit. He is reported to have shared a part of the
loot with the local population to win their allegiance as well as to ensure
their silence.
As a result, Saradiel had been hailed as a hero and not someone who had
destroyed the entrepreneurial spirits of planters and the fledgling foreign
direct investments to the country. But these migrant planters worked as a
group, created a modern plantation sector in Ceylon and contributed to the
economic growth of the country for centuries. The government taxed them
heavily and passed the benefit lavishly to the local population in the form of
subsidies, free goods etc. The result, as observed by Furnham, was the
creation of a complacent local population which even today expects free
goodies from the government including jobs for those who pass out from
universities. The sentiments of the local population have been exploited by
shrewd politicians at successive elections promising them everything under
the sun but forgetting their promises immediately after they return to
power.
Finally it boils down to good governance and establishing strong
institutions
What does this mean? It means that it is not open economic borders per se
that would help a country to become prosperous on a sustainable basis. It is
the economic environment that one faces that would force a person to work
hard and create new things. If the life is easy and looked after by someone
else, there is no incentive for a person to put in the maximum into what he
does whether he is in business or in the government service. Mere hard
work does not help if there is no protection of the fruits of his hard work
commonly known as the protection of property rights. Property rights
cannot be protected if there is no rule of law and an independent judicial
system.
Finally it boils down to having good governance in society. Good governance