Professional Documents
Culture Documents
RelationshipBetweenFlowCoefficientandDischargeCoefficientEngineeredSoftwareKnowledgeBaseEngineeredSoftwareKnowledgeBase
EngineeredSoftwareKnowledgeBase / / TheoryEquationsandCalculatedResultsQuestions
RelationshipBetweenFlowCoefficientandDischarge
Coefficient
CreatedbyProductEngineer,lastmodifiedbyProductEngineer2onJan09,2015
WhatistherelationshipbetweentheFlowCoefficient(Cv)and
theDischargeCoefficient(Cd)?
Goodcommunicationbetweenvariousgroupsinvolvedwithfluidpipingsystemsiscriticalfortheproperdesign,operation,and
determinationofcostformanysystemsinresidential,commercial,andindustrialapplications.Itiscrucialthattheengineerunderstand
andapplyequationscorrectlytopreventcostlymistakesinthesizingandselectionofequipment,operatingwithinsafetylimits,and
avoidingunnecessarymodificationslaterinplantlife.Onepotentialareaforcostlymiscommunicationistheuseofcoefficientsfor
devicesthathaveafluidflowingthroughthem.Manufacturersofvariousequipmentusedifferentcoefficientstocharacterizethehydraulic
performanceoftheirdevices,andthesedifferencemustbeunderstoodwhenapplyingthemtocalculationsinvolvingpipingsystems.
Inapreviousarticle,thedifferencebetweentheResistanceCoefficient(K)andFlowCoefficient(Cv)wasevaluatedandarelationship
betweenthetwowasderived.TheFlowCoefficient(CvinUSunits,KvinSIunits)istypicallyassociatedwiththehydraulicperformance
ofacontrolvalve,butotherdevicessuchassafetyreliefvalvesarecharacterizedbytheDischargeCoefficient(Cd,sometimes
designatedbyKd),whichisalsoassociatedwithorificesandnozzles.Theyarenotnumericallyequivalent,sowhatistherelationship
betweenthetwo?
TherearevariousstandardsintheU.S.andinternationallythatareusedtosizeandselectcontrolvalvesandreliefvalves,mostnotably
theANSI/ISA75.01.01FlowEquationsforSizingControlValves(IEC6053421equivalent)andtheAPIStandard520Part1,Sizing,
Selection,andInstallationofPressurerelievingDevicesinRefineries.Thesetwostandardscanbeusedtoderivetherelationship
betweentheFlowCoefficient(Cv)andtheDischargeCoefficient(Cd)forreliefvalves.Thereareminordifferencesinthenomenclature
usedineachstandard,soforthepurposeofthisarticle,thenomenclaturewillbedefinedfortheequationsbelowalongwiththe
engineeringunitsbeingused.
ControlValveSizingEquations:
Whensizingacontrolvalve,theminimumrequiredflowcoefficientiscalculatedbasedonthedesignflowrateandexpectedpressure
dropacrossthevalve,andavalveisselectedthathasaflowcoefficientgreaterthanthecalculatedvalue.Here'sthegeneralsizing
equationforcontrolvalvesforincompressiblefluidsaccordingtoANSI/ISA75.01.01Equation1,nonchokedturbulentflow:
(1)
Cv =
N1
dP
Where:
Q=volumetricflowrate(gpm,m3/hr,orlpm)
dP=pressuredropacrossthevalve(psi,kPa,orbar)
1=densityofthefluidflowingthroughthevalve(lb/ft3orkg/m3)
0=densityofthefluidflowingthroughthevalve(lb/ft3orkg/m3)
1/0=specificgravityofthefluid(dimensionless)
N1=constantthatdependsontheunitsusedforQanddP(N1=1.0forunitsofgpmandpsi)
Thereareotherfactorsthatmaybeincludedinthesizingequationtoaccountforpipinggeometry,highviscosity,orchokedflow
conditions.UsingU.S.unitsofgpmandpsi,theflowcoefficientequationinitssimplestformis:
(2)
SG
Cv
= Q
dP
ReliefValveSizingEquations
Whensizingareliefvalve,theminimumrequiredeffectiveareaiscalculatedandareliefvalveisselectedthathasaneffectivearea
greaterthanthecalculatedvalue.ThesizingequationforreliefvalvesforliquidsusingU.S.unitsaccordingtoEquation28intheAPI520
standardis:
http://kb.engsoftware.com/display/ESKB/Relationship+Between+Flow+Coefficient+and+Discharge+Coefficient
1/4
7/15/2015
RelationshipBetweenFlowCoefficientandDischargeCoefficientEngineeredSoftwareKnowledgeBaseEngineeredSoftwareKnowledgeBase
(3)
SG
A =
38K d K w K c K v
P1 P2
Where:
A=requiredeffectiveorificearea(in2)
Q=volumetricflowrate(gpm)
SG=specificgravityofthefluid(dimensionless)
P1=upstreamrelievingpressure(psig)
P2=backpressure(psig)
Kd=rateddischargecoefficient(dimensionless)=Cd=(actualflowrate)/(idealflowrate)
Kw=correctionfactorforbackpressure(=1ifdischargingtoatmosphereorifbackpressureislessthan50%ofinletpressure)
Kc=rupturedisccorrectionfactor,ifinstalled(=1ifnoneinstalled)
Kv=viscositycorrectionfactor(=1ifRe>105)
38=allunitconversionscompiledintooneconstant
Assumingnorupturediscisinstalled,noviscositycorrection,andbackpressure<50%inletpressure,theAPI520equation(usingCd
insteadofKd)boilsdownto:
Q
(4)
A =
SG
38C d
dP
RearrangingEquation4yields:
SG
(5)
38AC d = Q
dP
RelationshipBetweenCvandCd
TherighthandsideofEquation5iscommonwiththeflowcoefficientequation,Equation2above.Therefore,forliquids:
(6)
C v = 38AC d
Asimilarevaluationcanbedoneforcompressiblegasesandvapors(usingEquation11aintheANSI/ISA75.01.01standardand
Equation3intheAPIstandard520Part1,forexample),buttherelationshipbecomes:
(7)
C v = 27.66AC d
Thenextquestionis:"Whyaretheconstantsdifferent?"Theansweristhatthedischargecoefficientforagivenvalveissmallerfora
liquidthanitisforagasduetotheexpansionofthegasasitpassesthroughthevalve.Forexample,onemanufacturershowsthe
dischargecoefficientforoneoftheirvalvesinliquidserviceis0.579,butforgasserviceis0.801.Theratioofthedischargecoefficients
is0.801/0.579=1.38.Theratiooftheconstantsintheaboveequationsis38/27.66=1.37,roughlyequal.
DerivingtheNumericalConstantinCvtoCdRelationship
Thenextquestionagoodengineerwillaskis:"Wheredoestheconstant38comefrom?"Theanswertothatrequiressomeunitanalysis
oftheonedimensionalisentropicnozzleflowenergybalanceequation,whichisgiveninAppendixBoftheAPI520standard.
UsingU.S.unitsforliquid,themassflowrateperunitareathroughanozzle(massflux,G)usingEquationB.1andB.6intheAPI
standard,is:
w
(8)
G =
= (2)(g)(144)dP
Where:
G=massfluxinlb/secft2
w=theoreticalmassflowrateinlb/sec
http://kb.engsoftware.com/display/ESKB/Relationship+Between+Flow+Coefficient+and+Discharge+Coefficient
2/4
7/15/2015
RelationshipBetweenFlowCoefficientandDischargeCoefficientEngineeredSoftwareKnowledgeBaseEngineeredSoftwareKnowledgeBase
a=flowareainft2
g=32.174ft/sec2
=fluiddensityinlb/ft3
dP=pressuredropacrosstherelief,inlb/in2
144=conversionbetweenin2andft2
Disregardingtheunitconversionneededforthemoment,themassflowrateisrelatedtothevolumetricflowrateby:
(9)
w = Q
Therefore,themassfluxis:
w
(10)
G =
Q
=
= (2)(g)(144)dP
a
Solvingforarea(a)andtakingthefluiddensityintothesquareroot:
2
Q
(11)
a =
(2)(g)(144)dP
(2)(g)(144)dP
= Q
(2)(g)(144)dP
Thedensity()inEquation11isthefluiddensity,butthevalvesizingequationsusethespecificgravity.Specificgravityis:
(12)
SG =
Where=densityofwaterat60F=62.37lb/ft3.
lb
(13)
= (SG)(
) = (62.37
ft
)(SG)
Takingthisrelationshipintotheareaequationyields:
lb
(62.37
)(SG)
3
ft
a = Q
(14)
(2)(g)(144
in
ft
)dP
Beforewethrowinalltheunits,weneedtheareainsquareinches,notsquarefeet,so:
in
(15)
A = a(144
ft
in
) = (144
ft
lb
(62.37
)(SG)
)Q
ft
(2)(g)(144
in
ft
2
2
)dP
Nowlet'sputinalltheunits:
144in
A =
2
ft
(16)
ft
Qgal min
62.37lb 1
sec
ft
3
2
2 32.174f t
144in
ft
(SG)
in
dP lb
SG
Q
SG
A = 0.02632Q
=
dP
38
dP
Thedischargecoefficientcomesintotheequationabovebecausetheflowrate,Q,isthetheoreticalflowrateassumingincompressible
isentropicflow.Thedischargecoefficientistheratiooftheactualflowtothetheoreticalflow:
http://kb.engsoftware.com/display/ESKB/Relationship+Between+Flow+Coefficient+and+Discharge+Coefficient
3/4
7/15/2015
RelationshipBetweenFlowCoefficientandDischargeCoefficientEngineeredSoftwareKnowledgeBaseEngineeredSoftwareKnowledgeBase
Q
(17)
Cd =
actual
theoretical
Rearranged:
Q
(18)
theoretical
actual
Cd
Substitutingintotheareaequationabove(Equation16)yieldsthereliefvalvesizingequation:
Q
(19)
A =
actual
38C d
SG
dP
InConclusion
Overthecourseofhistory,thescientificandengineeringstudyinvolvingfluidflowinpipingsystemshasresultedindevelopingdifferent
coefficientstocharacterizethehydraulicperformanceofvariousdevicesthatobstructfluidflow.Becauseengineersviewthehydraulic
performanceofdevicesdifferently,mistakescanbemadeiftheproperconceptsandequationsarenotappliedcorrectly.Thesecan
becostlymistakesinsizingandselectingthewrongequipmentwhichcanmeanthedifferencebetweenthesystemhavingsufficient
pressurerelievingcapacityorthesystemrupturingduringahighpressurereliefincident.
1Comment
ProductEngineer2
Reviewed
http://kb.engsoftware.com/display/ESKB/Relationship+Between+Flow+Coefficient+and+Discharge+Coefficient
4/4