Professional Documents
Culture Documents
2
persecuted by Eurystheus ... Eurystheus invaded Attica, but perished in the attempt ....
All the sons of Eurystheus lost their lives ...
with him, so that the Perseid family was now
represented only by the Herakleids ....
by a revolution in Peloponnesus so complete that, except in the rugged province of Arcadia, nothing remained
unaltered.[8]
In 1824 Karl Otfried Mller's Die Dorier was published in German and was translated into English by
Tufnel and Lewis for publication in 1830. They use
such terms as the Doric invasion[9] and the invasian
of the Dorians[10] to translate Mllers Die Einwanderung von den Doriern (literally: the migration of the
Dorians),[11] which was quite a dierent concept.
The Dorians derived their origin [der Ursprung des dorischen Stammes] from those districts in which the Grecian nation bordered
toward the north upon numerous and dissimilar races of barbarians. As to the tribes
which dwelt beyond these borders we are indeed wholly destitute of information; nor is
there the slightest trace of any memorial or
tradition that the Greeks originally came from
those quarters.
Mller goes on to propose that the original Pelasgian language was the common ancestor of Greek and Latin,[13]
that it evolved into Proto-Greek and was corrupted in
Macedon and Thessaly by invasions of Illyrians. This
same pressure of Illyrians drove forth Greeks speaking
Achaean (including Aeolian), Ionian, and nally Dorian
in three diachronic waves, explaining the dialect distribution of Greek in classical times.[14]
THRACIAN
MACEDONIAN
ILLYRIAN
Propontis
Chalcidice
Lemnos
Larissa
Epirus
Corcyra
Dodona
Thessaly
Ambracia
Lesbos
Delphi
Boeotia
Euboea
Thebes
Cephallonia
Zacynthos
Achaea
Elis
Olympia
Ionian Sea
Corinth
Argolis
Arcadia Argos Epidaurus
Messenia Sparta
Pylos
Chalkis
Megara Attica
Athens
Pergamum
Aeolia
Skyros
Leucas
Smyrna
Aegean Sea
LYDIAN
Chios
Ionia
Ephesus
Andros
Samos
Miletus
Cyclades
CARIAN
Naxos
Laconia
Kos
Thera
Rhodes
Northwest Greek
Achaean Doric
Sea of Crete
Central group:
Aeolic
Arcado-Cypriot
Crete
Eastern group:
Attic
Cyprus
Ionic
Additional progress in the search for the Dorian invasion resulted from the decipherment of Linear B inscriptions. The language of the Linear B texts is an early form
of Greek now known as Mycenaean Greek. Comparing it with the later Greek dialects scholars could trace
the development of the dialects from the earlier Myce- In another ten years the alternative view was becoming
naean. For example, classical Greek anak-s (), the standard one. JP Mallory wrote in 1989 concerning
the various hypotheses of proto-Greek that had been put Blegen follows Furumark[28] in dating Mycenaean IIIB
forward since the decipherment:[25]
to 13001230 BC. Blegen himself dated the Dorian invasion to 1200 BC.
Reconciliation of all these dierent theories seems out of the question ... the current state of our knowledge of the Greek dialects can accommodate Indo-Europeans entering Greece at any time between 2200 and
1600 BC to emerge later as Greek speakers.
A destruction by Dorians has its own problems (as discussed in the next section) and is not the only possible
explanation. At approximately this time Hittite power in
Anatolia collapsed with the destruction of their capital
Hattusa, and the late 19th and the 20th dynasties of Egypt
suered invasions of the Sea Peoples. A theory, reported
for instance by Thomas and Conant, attributes the ruin of
[29]
By the end of the 20th century the concept of an invasion the Peloponnesus to the Sea Peoples:
by external Greek speakers had ceased to be the mainstream view, (although still asserted by a minority); thus
Evidence on the Linear B tablets from the
Georey Horrocks writes:[26]
Mycenaean kingdom of Pylos describing the
dispatch of rowers and watchers to the coast,
for instance, may well date to the time that the
Greek is now widely believed to be the
Egyptian pharaoh was expecting the arrival of
product of contact between Indo-European imfoes.
migrants and the speakers of the indigenous
languages of the Balkan peninsula beginning c.
2,000 B.C.
The identity of the foes remained a question. The evidence suggests that some of the Sea Peoples may have
If the dierent dialects had developed within Greece no been Greek. However, most of the destroyed Mycenaean
subsequent invasions were required to explain their pres- sites are far from the sea, and the expedition against Troy
at the end of this period shows that the sea was safe. Desence.
borough believes that the sea was safe in central and south
Aegean in this period.[30]
5
clans moved southward gradually over a number of years, The scholars were now faced with the conundrum of an
and they devastated the territory, until they managed to invasion at 1200 but a resettlement at 950. One explaestablish themselves in the Mycenaean centres.[34]
nation is that the destruction of 1200 was not caused by
them, and that the quasi-mythical return of the Heracleidae is to be associated with settlement at Sparta c. 950.
It is possible that the destruction of the Mycenaean cen6 Invasion or migration
tres, was caused by the wandering of northern people (Illyrian migration). They destroyed the palace of Iolcos
(LH III C-1), the palace of Thebes ( late LH III B), then
they crossed Isthmus of Corinth (end of LH III B) they
destroyed Mycenae, Tiryns and Pylos, and nally they
returned northward. However Pylos was destroyed by
a sea-attack, the invaders didn't leave behind traces of
weapons or graves, and it cannot be proved that all the
sites were destroyed about the same time.[36] It is also possible that the Doric clans moved southward gradually over
a number of years, and they devastated the territory, until
they managed to establish themselves in the Mycenaean
centres.[34]
9 NOTES
speaking, do not exist. That is, there is no cultural trait surviving in the material record for
the two centuries or so after 1200 which can
be regarded as a peculiarly Dorian hallmark.
Robbed of their patents for Geometric pottery, cremation burial, iron-working and, the
unkindest prick of all, the humble straight pin,
the hapless Dorians stand naked before their
creator or, some would say, inventor.
C.Moss suggests that there is not any archaeological evidence that a Doric civilization substituted the Achaean
civilization, and that the Dorian methods of a war-society,
was a myth created by the scientists who were based on
the Spartan delusion. The Dorians who spoke a dierent dialect were mixed with the local population, when
they migrated to the new lands [38]
The question remains open to further investigation.
8 See also
A dark age of poverty, low population and metals starvation is not compatible with the idea of great population movements of successful warriors wielding the latest
military equipment sweeping into the Peloponnesus and
taking it over to rebuild civilization their way. This dark
age consists of three periods of art and archaeology: subMycenaean, Proto-geometric and Geometric. The most
successful, the Geometric, seems to t the Dorians better, but there is a gap, and this period is not localized to
and did not begin in Dorian territory. It is more to be
associated with Athens, an Ionian state.
Historical linguistics
Comparative method
Dorians
Doric Greek
Doris
Dorus, the eponymous founder
Greek Dark Ages
Sparta
Vedic Period
9 Notes
[1] About the so-called Dorians Issue cf. Francesco Perono Cacciafoco, Sulle piste dei Dori. Ipotesi a confronto tra
Linguistica, Archeologia e Storia [On the Traces of the Dorians. Compared Hypotheses According to Linguistics, Archaeology, and History], Pisa University Press (Edizioni
PLUS), Pisa 2009, link book.
[2] Hogan, C. Michael (10 January 2008). Lato Hillfort.
The Modern Antiquarian. Julian Cope.
[3] Liddell, Henry George; Scott, Robert (2007) [1940].
"". Greek-English Lexicon. Medford: Perseus
Digital Library, Tufts University.
[4] "". Liddell & Scott.
[5] George Grote, Greece Part I, Chapter XVIII, Section I:
Return of the Herakleids into Peloponnesus.
[6] George Grote, Greece Chapter IV: Heroic Legends : Exile of the Herakleids.
[7] Mitfords single-volume rst edition came out in 1784 to
be followed by a second edition containing Volumes I and
II in 1789. The remainder of the initial 8-volume set was
published by 1810. The third edition of 1821 had more
volumes. Some 29 editions more followed. Mitfords
work features marginal notes stating the ancient sources.
[8] Mitford, William. The History of Greece. Volume I.
Boston: Timothy Bedlington and Charles Ewer, Cornhill.
p. 197.
[9] Mller 1830, p. 107.
[10] Mller 1830, p. 97.
[11] Mller 1844, p. 85.
[12] Mller 1830, p. 1.
[13] Mller 1830, pp. 67.
[14] Mller 1830, pp. 1119.
[15] A.Thumb: Handbuch der griechischen Dialekte 1932 :
Martin Nilsson Die Geschichte der Griechische Religion
C.F.Beck Verlag, Munchen, p. 330
[16] J.L.Myres, Who were the Greeks? 1930 : Martin Nilsson
Die Geschichte der Griechische Religion C.F.Beck Verlag,
Munchen, p. 330
[17] Paparigopoulos, K., 1902, History of the Greek Nation,
(re-edited in demotic Greek, 1995), v. 1, p. 189
[18] Hall, Jonathan M. (2002). Between Ethnicity and Culture.
Chicago: University of Chicago Press. p. 40. ISBN 0226-31329-8. Paul Kretschmer ... had pointed to elements in Greek vocabulary ... that appeared to be nonHellenic, and therefore pre-Hellenic ... for example, the
-nth- sux in Tirynthos ... which Kretschmer believed
had been transmitted to Greece from Anatolia.
[19] Drews 1988, p. 8. Paul Kretschmer concluded that
there had been three Greek invasions of Greece during
the Bronze Age. The last of these, ca. 1200 B.C., was
surely the Dorian Invasion.
[20] A survey of the problems connected with the historicity
of the Dorian invasion may be found Hall, J.M. (2007).
A History of the Archaic Greek World ca. 1200479 BCE.
Malden, MA: Blackwell Publishing. Chapter 3. A number of ISBNs, including 0631226672.
[21] Drews 1993, p. 63. The old view that the Dorian
invasion proceeded from the central Balkans and that it
occurred ca. 1200 is now maintained by only a few
archaeologists and against increasing evidence to the contrary.
[22] Risch, Ernst (1955). Die Gliederung der griechischen
Dialekte in neuer Sicht. Museum Helveticum 12: 6175.
The argument is summarized, and Risch is cited, in Drews
1988, p. 39.
[23] Chadwick, John (1976). The Mycenaean World. Cambridge University Press. pp. 23. ISBN 0-521-21077-1.
[24] Georgiev, Vladimir Ivanov (1981). Introduction to the history of the Indo-European languages. Pub. House of the
Bulgarian Academy of Sciences. p. 156.
[25] Mallory, J.P. (1991). In Search of the Indo-Europeans:
Language, Archaeology and Myth. New York: Thames
and Hudson. p. 71. ISBN 0-500-27616-1.
[26] Horrocks, Georey (1997). Homers Dialect. In Morris, Ian; Powell, Barry B. A New Companion to Homer.
Leiden, Boston: Brill. pp. 193217. ISBN 90-04-099891.
[27] Blegen, Carl (1967), The Mycenaean Age: The Trojan
War, the Dorian Invasion and Other Problems, Lectures
in Memory of Louise Taft Semple: First Series, 19611965,
Princeton: Princeton University Press, p. 30, LC 6714407.
[28] Furumark, Arne (1972). Mycenaean Pottery. Svenska institutet i Athen. ISBN 91-85086-03-7. This book, a pottery lookup reference, arranges pottery by stylistic groups,
assigning relative dates correlated when possible to calendar dates, along with the evidence. It is the standard pottery reference for Mycenaean times.
[29] Thomas, Carol G.; Craig Conant (2005). The Trojan War.
Westport, Connecticut: The Greenwood press. p. 18.
ISBN 0-313-32526-X.
[30] G.Mylonas (1966) Mycenae and the Mycenaean age,
Princeton University Press pp. 230,231
[31] Wood, Michael (1987). In Search of the Trojan War. New
York: New American Library. pp. 251252. ISBN 0452-25960-6.
[32] Chadwick, John (1976). Who were the Dorians?".
Parola del Passato 31: 103117. Chadwicks point of
view is summarized and critiqued in Drews 1988, Appendix One: The End of the Bronze Age in Greece
[33] Paleolexicon.
[34] G. Mylonas, Mycenae and the Mycenaean age, pp. 231,
232
[35] Michell, H. (1964). Sparta. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. p. 7.
[36] G. Mylonas Mycenae and the Mycenaean age, pp. 227,
228
[37] Cartledge, Paul (2002). Sparta and Lakonia: A Regional
History, 1300362. Routledge. p. 68. ISBN 0-41526276-3.
[38] C.Moss (1984). La Grce archaique, d' Homre Eschyle. Editions du Seuil, p.p 34,35
10 Bibliography
Francesco Perono Cacciafoco, Sulle piste dei Dori.
Ipotesi a confronto tra Linguistica, Archeologia e Storia [On the Traces of the Dorians. Compared Hypotheses According to Linguistics, Archaeology, and
11
History], Pisa University Press (Edizioni PLUS),
Pisa 2009, link book.
Drews, Robert (1988). The Coming of the Greeks:
Indo-European Conquests in the Aegean and the
Near East. Princeton, N.J.: Princeton University
Press. ISBN 0-691-02951-2.
Drews, Robert (1993). The End of the Bronze Age:
Changes in Warfare and the Catastrophe CA. 1200
B.C. Princeton, New Jersey: Princeton University
Press.
Hall, Jonathan M. (2000). Dorians and Heraklidai. Ethnic Identity in Greek Antiquity. Cambridge
University Press. pp. 5665. ISBN 0-521-78999-0.
Hall, Jonathan M. (2006). Dorians: Ancient Ethnic Group. In Wilson, Nigel. Encyclopedia of Ancient Greece. New York: Routledge Taylor & Francis Group. pp. 240242. ISBN 0-415-97334-1.
Mller, C.O.; Henry Tufnell (Translator); George
Cornewall Lewis (Translator) (1830). The History
and Antiquities of the Doric Race. Volume I. London: John Murray.
Mller, Karl Otfried (1844). Geschichten hellenischer Stmme und Stdte. Zweiter Band: Die Dorier.
Breslau: J. Max and Company.
Mylonas, George E. (1966). Mycenae and the Mycenaean Age. Princeton UP. ISBN 0-691-03523-7.
Pomeroy, Sarah B.; Stanley M. Burstein; Walter
Donlan; Jennifer Tolbert Roberts (1999). Ancient
Greece: A Political, Social, and Cultural History.
Oxford University Press. ISBN 0-19-509742-4.
11
External links
EXTERNAL LINKS
12
12.1
Text
12.2
Images
File:Amphora_protogeometric_BM_A1123.jpg
Source:
https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/7/7c/Amphora_
protogeometric_BM_A1123.jpg License: Public domain Contributors: Marie-Lan Nguyen (2006) Original artist: Unknown
File:AncientGreekDialects_(Woodard)_en.svg
Source:
https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/d/de/
AncientGreekDialects_%28Woodard%29_en.svg License: Public domain Contributors: Own work by uploader. Data after Woodard
(2008), see below. Base map Image:Greece map blank.svg (public domain) Original artist: Fut.Perf.
File:Athena_Herakles_Staatliche_Antikensammlungen_2648.jpg Source: https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/4/4f/
Athena_Herakles_Staatliche_Antikensammlungen_2648.jpg License: Public domain Contributors: User:Bibi Saint-Pol, own work, 200702-13 Original artist: Python (potter) and Douris (painter)
File:Flag_of_Greece.svg Source: https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/5/5c/Flag_of_Greece.svg License: Public domain
Contributors: own code Original artist: (of code) cs:User:-xfi- (talk)
File:Horses_manger_Louvre_A513.jpg Source:
https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/2/24/Horses_manger_Louvre_
A513.jpg License: CC BY 2.5 Contributors: Own work Original artist: Marie-Lan Nguyen
File:NAMA_Linear_B_tablet_of_Pylos.jpg Source:
https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/5/55/NAMA_Linear_B_
tablet_of_Pylos.jpg License: CC BY 2.0 Contributors: originally posted to Flickr as How Cool Is Writing? Original artist: Sharon Mollerus
File:Question_book-new.svg Source: https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/9/99/Question_book-new.svg License: Cc-by-sa-3.0
Contributors:
Created from scratch in Adobe Illustrator. Based on Image:Question book.png created by User:Equazcion Original artist:
Tkgd2007
File:Rider_BM_B1.jpg Source: https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/a/a9/Rider_BM_B1.jpg License: Public domain Contributors: Jastrow (2006) Original artist: Rider Painter
File:Wells_Hellenic_races.png Source: https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/e/ec/Wells_Hellenic_races.png License: Public domain Contributors: Wells, H. G. (1920). The Outline of History. Garden City, New York: Garden City Publishing Co., Inc.. Original
artist: H. G. Wells
File:William_Faden._Composite_Mediterranean._1785.I.jpg Source:
https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/1/19/
William_Faden._Composite_Mediterranean._1785.I.jpg License: Public domain Contributors:
This le has an extracted image: File:William Faden. Composite Mediterranean. 1785.jpg.
Original artist: William Faden
12.3
Content license