Professional Documents
Culture Documents
n e w e ng l a n d j o u r na l
of
m e dic i n e
review article
drug therapy
From the Liver Diseases Branch, National Institute of Diabetes and Digestive and
Kidney Diseases, National Institutes of
Health, Bethesda, MD. Address reprint
requests to Dr. Liang at the Liver Diseases Branch, National Institute of Diabetes
and Digestive and Kidney Diseases, National Institutes of Health, Bldg. 10-9B16,
10 Center Dr., Bethesda, MD 20892-1800,
or at jakel@bldg10.niddk.nih.gov.
N Engl J Med 2013;368:1907-17.
DOI: 10.1056/NEJMra1213651
Copyright 2013 Massachusetts Medical Society.
1907
The
n e w e ng l a n d j o u r na l
of
m e dic i n e
Lipoprotein
Binding and
entry
Lumen of
sinusoid
HCV
Cell
membrane
CLDN1
CD81
SCARB1
Occludin
GAG
Tight
junction
Bile
canaliculus
EGFR
LDLR
Endosome
NPC1L1
H+
H+
Secretion
Golgi
Cell-to-cell
transmission
Maturation
Hepatocyte
Trafficking
Assembly
Fusion and
uncoating
of capsid
Lipid
droplet
HCV
(+) RNA
Core proteins
Membranous
web
Nucleus
E1 and E2
surface proteins
miR-122
Miravirsen
Cytoplasm
3'
Telaprevir,
Boceprevir
Translation
Host
ribosome
P7
NS2
Daclatasvir
E2
Structural
proteins
Replication
NS5B
NS3
NS5A
Co r e
E1
NI and NNI
NS4B
NS4A
CypA
HCV
intermediate
() RNA
Alisporivir, SCY-635,
and NIM811
Nonstructural
proteins
Endoplasmic
reticulum
Replication complex in a
membranous web structure
C OLOR FIGURE
Draft 3
1908
4/25/2013
Author
Liang_ra1213651
1 j med 368;20 nejm.org may
Fig n
# engl
Current and Future Therapies
Title
of Hepatitis
C Journal of Medicine
The New
England
16, 2013
DE
Ingelfinger
Downloaded from nejm.org on September
16,
2015. For personal use only. No other uses without permission.
Moskowitz
ME
Copyright 2013
Medical Society. All rights reserved.
Williams
ArtistMassachusetts
Pub Date
5/16/2013
1909
The
n e w e ng l a n d j o u r na l
of
m e dic i n e
PIFN/R/Boc
HCV RNA undetectable at weeks 824
No prior therapy
PIFN/R/Boc
PIFN/R
PIFN/R
PIFN/R/Boc
HCV RNA detectable at week 8, undetectable at week 24
PIFN/R/Boc
Relapse after prior
therapy or partial
response
PIFN/R
PIFN/R/Boc
PIFN/R/Boc
PIFN/R
No response to
prior therapy
PIFN/R/Boc
PIFN/R
HCV RNA 100 IU/ml
Stopping Rule:
Week 0
Stopping Rule:
12
24
28
36
48
No prior therapy or
relapse after prior
therapy
PIFN/R/Tpv
PIFN/R
HCV RNA detectable at weeks 4, 12, or both
Partial or no response
to prior therapy
PIFN/R/Tpv
PIFN/R
in similar response rates but differ greatly with long) (Fig. 2).30-34 Neither boceprevir nor telaprerespect to the timing of administration (both vir should be used alone, nor should the dose of
when they should be administered and for how either drug be reduced, because drug-resistant
1910
nejm.org
1911
The
n e w e ng l a n d j o u r na l
HCV Genotype 1
No prior
therapy
m e dic i n e
of
Relapse after
prior therapy
No response to
prior therapy
None
Knowledge of brosis
stage (liver biopsy or
other means) helpful
No prior
therapy
No response to
prior therapy
No response to
prior therapy
Insufcient data on
role of interleukin-28B
testing
None
Special
pretreatment
assessment
Interleukin-28B
testing optional
Liver biopsy
optional
None
Treatment
recommendation
Consider treatment;
balance with disease severity
and side effects in patients who
had received no prior therapy
Expected
outcome
(SVR)
6375%
7583%
Consider treatment
based on likelihood of
disease progression
and treatment
response
Partial response,
4052%
Null response,
2938%
Consider
treatment
7080%
Wait for
new therapy
Consider
treatment
Wait for
new therapy
5070%
ribavirin. The patient must have documented viremia, no contraindications to therapy, and no
serious coexisting illness.25 It is particularly important to consider initiating treatment promptly
in patients with an advanced stage of fibrosis
(Ishak fibrosis score of 4, 5, or 6 on liver biopsy
[with scores ranging from 0 to 6 and higher
scores indicating greater degrees of fibrosis])
(see the Supplementary Appendix, available with
the full text of this article at NEJM.org) because
1912
Unknown
Unknown
Unknown
Possibly substantial
Unknown
* These inhibitors are in either the preclinical stage or early clinical trials (phase 12a).
Unknown
Unknown
Substantial
Drugdrug interactions
Minimal
Unknown
Possibly substantial
Unknown
Possibly substantial
Unknown
Modest
Dependent on
specific drug
Possibly substantial
Substantial
Side effects
Unknown
Unknown
Low
Low
High
Low (genotypedependent)
High
High
Low
Broad
Broad
Broad
Broad
Narrow
Medium
Probability of drug
resistance
Low to
medium
Narrow
Broad
Narrow (second-generation drugs have
broader coverage)
Medium
Medium
Low
nucleoside
analogue
nonnucleoside
analogue
High
NS5A
Inhibitors
NS5B Polymerase Inhibitors
High
High
Efficacy
Genotypic coverage
Variable
Low to
medium
HCV Entry
Inhibitors*
MiR122
Inhibitors
Cyclophilin A
Inhibitors
p7 and NS4B
Inhibitors*
NS3/4A Protease
Inhibitors
Property
Table 1. Pharmacologic Properties of Direct-Acting and Host-Targeting Anti-HCV Agents in Clinical Development.
Inhibitors
of Other
Host
Factors*
1913
The
n e w e ng l a n d j o u r na l
of
m e dic i n e
1914
Pr ecision Medicine in HC V
Ther a py
Advances in biomarker and genomic medicine
have provided a unique opportunity to personalize the approach to treatment for patients with
hepatitis C. Various clinical traits (e.g., the presence of cirrhosis) and virologic traits (e.g., genotype 1 vs. genotype 2 or 3) have already been incorporated into current regimens as the standard
of care. In addition, monitoring the virologic response during treatment often determines the
duration of therapy (response-guided therapy)
(Fig. 2). Demographic and other factors that have
previously been found to correlate with a response to peginterferon and ribavirin are also
important determinants of a response to the approved direct-acting antiviral regimens; these
factors include younger age (<45 years), nonblack race, lower body-mass index, no history of
diabetes, absence of cirrhosis on liver biopsy, low
baseline viral load (<800,000 IU per milliliter),
and HCV subtype 1b.30-33
New biomarkers (e.g., serum IP10 levels) and
genetic tests (e.g., to determine polymorphisms in
the IL28B gene) appear to have strong predictive
value with respect to interferon-based therapy.64
Polymorphisms in the inosine triphosphatase
gene were recently identified as pharmacogenomic markers of ribavirin-induced anemia65,66;
however, the polymorphisms conferring protection are rare in the general population, and
screening for those polymorphisms is therefore
not useful. Recent costbenefit analyses of data
C ONCLUSIONS
If the past is a harbinger of the future, therapy
for HCV infection will probably continue to advance at a brisk pace. Many additional potent
agents are in the clinical pipeline, and interferonfree regimens are likely to dominate the HCV
therapeutic landscape within the next 5 years. If
a simple treatment regimen becomes a reality, a
robust health care infrastructure will be needed
to identify, triage, and treat the millions of HCVinfected patients who are unaware of their status. The infrastructure in the current U.S. health
care system is woefully inadequate. The rate of
death from HCV infection has already outpaced
the rate of death from HIV infection in the United States.71 Successful treatment of HCV infection has undeniable long-term benefits with respect to reducing morbidity and mortality.26-29
Perhaps the most challenging issue is not whether there will be medical tools to effectively manage and treat HCV infection, but rather whether
the economic resources and societal commit-
1915
The
n e w e ng l a n d j o u r na l
ment will be adequate to embark on an ambitious agenda to eliminate this global public
health problem.
Dr. Ghany reports receiving payment for manuscript preparation from Clinical Care Options. No other potential conflict of
interest relevant to this article was reported.
of
m e dic i n e
References
1. Hanafiah KM, Groeger J, Flaxman
1916
1917