Professional Documents
Culture Documents
their arms
Grounding versus Stacking Arms in the Continental Army
(With Notes on British and German Practices)
John U. Rees
What did Continental troops do with their weapons when they did not need them, or
were halted on a march? In camp simple musket racks made of two forked sticks with a
straight pole, branch, or sapling laid between them sufficed. In the Charles Wilson Peale
portrait of Colonel Walter Stewart (completed 1781) such a device can be seen in the
camp behind him. Most notably, that rack is built very low to the ground so that the
muskets rather recline than stand up. Brig. Gen. Anthony Wayne's orders, Totaway, New
Jersey, 9 July 1780, mentioned building musket supports: "As soon as the tents are
Pitched and the Bowers made, the Troops will attend to Claning and repearing their
Cloths & Arms. Racks or Forks are to be fixed in front of each regt to bear the
arms against."1
In 1782 Sublieutenant Jean-Baptiste-Antoine de Verger, Royal DeuxPonts Regiment, described musket racks.
17 September We crossed the Hudson at Kings Ferry. En route to the
crossing we marched under the fort at Stony Point that was captured
When such contrivances were not available, for much of the war
American soldiers simply grounded their arms. Eventually (circa 1779),
they adopted the British method of stacking (or piling) arms (locking
firelocks together to form conical stacks). One reason why Continental
troops grounded rather than stacked their arms has been posited as
being due to the lack of uniformity in the mens firelocks or an
insufficient supply of bayonets. The reasoning behind this supposition
is that bayonets were needed to form a musket stack. Perhaps, but as
anyone knows who has worked with reproduction muskets of the
period, a stack can also built by partially drawing out the ramrods of
three muskets and interlocking them.
To date I have found no early-war mentions of American troops
stacking arms. By contrast Rhode Island soldier Jeremiah Greenman
mentioned grounding arms six times in summer and autumn of 1777,
but only twice in 1778. On the other hand, he never wrote of stacking
arms in his eight-year diary.3 General George Washington army orders
tell only of grounding arms up to May 1778.
Head-Quarters, Middle-Brook, June 12, 1777 The General thinks it
necessary to establish the following regulations for guards; and hopes
that officers will consider them as the rule of practice, and make
themselves well acquainted with them .
After placing his Sentries, the officer of the new guard is to make his
men lodge their arms, first giving them the orders necessary, to govern
their conduct. Care must be taken to lodge their arms, in such a
manner, that each man may have recourse to his in a moment, without
bustle or confusion. In most cases it is best, the arms should be
grounded on the guard-parade, during the day. 4
Head Quarters, Wilmington, September 4, 1777 ... The tents of Genl.
Sullivan's, Lord Stiriing's and Wayne's divisions, and Nash's brigade,
are to be struck and packed by five o'clock to morrow morning (if the
weather permit) these corps, together with Genl. Potter's brigade, are
to hold themselves in readiness to march at a moment's warning
afterwards upon receiving orders. For which purpose, each brigade
should be paraded, their arms grounded, and the men ready to
take them up at the first call.5
Head-Quarters, White Marsh, November 28, 1777 ... Such of the troops
as are not already furnished with cooked provisions for to morrow, are
to draw and cook them to night. At day break a cannon will be fired as
a signal for the whole army to parade, ready to march. When the
whole are completely formed, they may ground their arms, but
be ready to take them up again at a minute's warning. If it
should rain or snow the men are not to parade.6
Head Quarters, White Marsh, December 6, 1777 ... The troops are to
ground their arms at their alarm posts; and as soon as
possible, draw and cook their provisions for to day and to
morrow, and immediately set about making the best provision
they can of wood and huts for to night.7
Head Quarters, V[alley]. Forge, Tuesday, May 5, 1778 ... The several
Brigades are to be assembled for this Purpose at nine o'Clock tomorrow
morning when their Chaplains will communicate the Intelligence
contain'd in the Postscript to the Pennsylvania Gazette of the 2nd.
instant and offer up a thanksgiving and deliver a discourse suitable to
the Occasion. At half after ten o'Clock a Cannon will be fired, which is
to be a signal for the men to be under Arms. The Brigade Inspectors
will then inspect their Dress and Arms, form the Battalions according to
instructions given them and announce to the Commanding Officers of
Brigades that the Battalions are formed. The Brigadiers or
Commandants will then appoint the Field Officers to command
the Battalions, after which each Battalion will be ordered to
load and ground their Arms.8
Army orders:
Head Quarters, Tarrytown, Monday, July 2, 1781 ... No drum to beat
without particular order. Officers and Soldiers are to refresh
themselves and be within call of their Arms which are for the
present to be Stacked.14
Head Quarters, Newburgh, Friday, August 30, 1782. [directions for the
movement by water from West Point to Verplanks Point] When the
signal for landing is given, the boats are to close up without crouding
and row for the shore, falling in upon the left of each other, in which
order they are to debark at their respective landing places, ascend the
bank, and form as fast as they get up into brigade Collumns. In this
order the head of each Collumn will be conducted by the brigade Qr.
Master to the right of its encampment, where it will display to the left,
and each regiment take its own ground, Stack their arms, bring
up their tents and baggage and establish their camp. 15
But, even at this late date, there were drawbacks and problems with
stacking arms. Orders for the Marquis de Lafayettes small army in
Virginia,
Camp Near New Castle, August 18, 1781 ... The whole of the Troops
are to parade at 10 oclock to-morrow in as soldierly a manner as
possible. They will be reviewed, and then form in the Wood near the
Church to attend Divine Service. It is expected that no trifling excuse
will prevent any from attending. The Officers to which any Delinquents
belong, will be Judges of their ability or inability, and will excuse or
punish them accordingly. The new Guards will remain with their
Regiments until Service is over. Horses or cross-trees for the arms
to be laid against must be fixed in front of the Tents, to
prevent injury which the arms receive frequently falling after
having been stacked.16
It seems some soldiers just never became adept with that method of
lodging arms.
(Above and following page) Detail of part of a group of Continental soldiers from Pierre
Charles L'Enfant (1754-1825) painting of West Point and dependencies. View is from the
east side of the Hudson River, at the top is the lower part of Constitution Island. This was
done after August 1782, as service chevrons, worn on the saluting soldiers left sleeve, were
first authorized on the 7th of that month. Several soldiers in group are wearing knapsacks,
and what appears to be a rolled blanket can be seen on top of three of the packs. Library of
Congress, http://www.loc.gov/pictures/item/2004678934/
As for British troops, they were stacking their firelocks before the war, though when
the practice began is not known. Eric Schnitzer notes, There are many references
in journals for the British stacking their arms in the Northern campaign
of 1777 One journal (that of Enos Hitchcock, Patterson's Brigade
specifically mentions that on the day of the surrender (17 October
1777) the British Troops locked [stacked]
their Arms, the Germans grounded theirs .... Also, the British system of
stacking arms is commonly referred to as locking (as this journal
mentions) or piling. Eric also point out that one of the circa 1771
paintings of the 25th Regiment at Minorca shows a whole row of
stacked arms in the background, proving that it was practiced by
British forces prior to the American War.17
Just how did British troops pile their muskets? The answer is
supplied by two friends and fellow researchers. Steve Rayner found
one answer in Thomas Simes 1780 work, The Regulator - or
Instructions to Form the Officer and Complete the Soldier:
Directions for fixing up their Firelocks by Files.By locking the bayonets and ram-rod tops together, and spreading out
the but-end to an exact triangle, at such a distance as to form a steady
foundation.18
(Preceding page and detail below) Lady Louisa Lennox with Her
Husbands Regiment, 25th Regiment of Foot, Minorca, circa 1771,
by Giuseppe Chiesa. Note the line of stacked firearms across the
background. (National Army Museum)
Acknowledgements.
Thanks to those who contributed to this work, truly a group effort: Don
Hagist, Matthew Keagle, Steve Rayner, and Eric Schnitzer.
______________________
Endnotes
1. William Henry Egle, ed., A Yorktown Orderly Book, Notes and
Queries Historical and Genealogical chiefly relating to interior
Pennsylvania, two volumes, vol. 2 (Harrisburg: Harrisburg Publishing
Co., 1895), 255.
2. Howard C. Rice and Anne S.K. Brown, eds. and trans., The American
Campaigns of Rochambeau's Army 1780, 1781, 1782, 1783, vol. I
(Princeton, N.J. and Providence, R.I.,: Princeton University Press, 1972),
165.
3. Robert C. Bray and Paul E. Bushnell, eds., Diary of a Common Soldier
in the American Revolution: An Annotated Edition of the Military Journal
of Jeremiah Greenman (DeKalb, Il., 1978),
. Greenman mentioned
grounding arms six times in 1777: once on 15 or 16 June, twice 17 June,
twice on 28 November, and once on 11 December; in 1778 he noted
doing so on June 25th and July 31st. Here is a small selection of other
references:
Lt. Charles Willson Peale, 2d Battalion, Philadelphia Associators, 2d
Trenton/Princeton campaign:.
"Jan. 1st, 1777... After remaining some time in this order, we retired a
little back to an orchard, which joined the field, ground our arms, and
made fires with the fences [later the same day] We now marched to
the skirts of the field, ground our arms, made fires with the fence rails,
and talked over the fatigues of the day; and some, after eating, laid
themselves down to sleep."
"4th ... I then returned, and received the order to stop, ground arms,
and set to making fires." Horace Wells, Sellers, ed., "Charles Willson
Peale, Artist-Soldier," Pennsylvania Magazine of History and Biography,
vol. XXXVIII, no. 3 (Philadelphia: Historical Society of Pennsylvania,
1914), 278-279, 283.
Sgt. Ebenezer Wild, 1st Massachusetts Regiment:
November 8, 1777 - "About sunrise our regt. paraded and grounded our
arms, and then struck our tents and carried them with the rest of our
baggage down to the side of the river and loaded them on board of
batteaux... [After crossing]... we marched about 6 miles... to Center
hoock [Kinderhook]. There we lodged in barns."
December 6, 1777 - "... a little after sunrise we marched to our alarm
posts & grounded our arms. In the afternoon it clouded up. We moved
back a little in the woods and built huts with the dry bushes, for we had
no axes to cut any." "Journal of Ebenezer Wild," Proceedings of the
Massachusetts Historical Society, 2nd series, vol. VI (Boston, Ma., 1891),
100, 104.
4. General orders, 12 June 1777, John C. Fitzpatrick, ed., The Writings of
George Washington from the Original Manuscript Sources 1745-1799,
vol. 8 (Washington, DC, 1933). Available online at
http://international.loc.gov/ammem/gwhtml/gwhome.html
"Diary of Events... from Aug. 1, 1780, to Dec. 31, 1780. From the Journal
of Capt. Joseph McClellan, of Ninth Penn'a." John B. Linn and William H. Egle,
eds., Pennsylvania Archives, second series, vol. XI (Harrisburg: Clarence M. Busch, State Printer,
1896), 606-607.
Col. Israel Shreve listed muskets purchased for the 2nd New Jersey
Regiment in spring 1776, including one each with Curld, Dutch, and
Spanish stocks, two with Buckanear stocks, one old and ugly, and
a Queen Anne Musket. A letter from Brig. Gen. Thomas Mifflin
described arms supply for the two Pennsylvania battalions at Fort
Washington: Col Magaw [5th Pennsylvania] has not more than 125
[firelocks] in his Regim[ent]. Fit for service [total rank and file strength of
401] Col Shee [3rd Pennsylvania, whose regiment consisted of 435 rank
and file] about 300 [muskets] includg all the Carbines which they recd
lately Uneven supply and a lack of standardization was one reason
for this mix of arms; another factor was the Custom of hiring them [i.e.,
paying soldiers for muskets they brought from home] for the Campaign.
This practice alone resulted in a real hodge-podge of weaponry.
Israel Shreve, 1776, (transcription no. 31), Israel Shreve Papers,
Alexander Library, Rutgers University, New Brunswick, N.J. Thomas
Mifflin to George Washington, 2 July 1776, George Washington Papers,
series 4, reel 36.
_______________________
On 14 July 1777 Washington noted, as soon as the Men are settled in
their quarters, the Officers are critically to inspect their arms and
accoutrements, and have them put in the best order possible The
Commander in Chief was surprised to day to see the bad condition of
many arms they being not only unfit for fire, but very rusty, which latter
defect it is certainly in the power of every man to prevent, and the
neglect of it must arise from an inexcusable inattention of the officers.
General orders, 5 August 1777: The want of Armourers gives the
Officers a fair Opportunity of attributing many things, which are really
owing to their inattention to their men And it is no uncommon thing to
find Arms returned as defective, [which] upon close inspection want
only rubbing and cleaning.
Another serious difficulty resulted from the different caliber firelocks used
within regiments. General orders, 13 October 1777, As many great and
valuable advantages, would result, from having the arms of a division, or even
of a brigade, of the same bore, the Commander in Chief directs, that each
officer commanding a brigade would have a return instantly made to him of the
different Calibers and number of each kind in his brigade if such a disposition
of arms can be effected many happy consequences would flow from it.
General orders, 14 July 1777, John C. Fitzpatrick, ed., The Writings of
_______________________
Townshend, A plan of discipline for the use of the Norfolk militia ...,
The 2d ed., greatly improved. To which is now added, the present
manual exercise for the army, as ordered by His Majesty and the
Adjutant general. With encampments for infantry and cavalry
(London: Printed for J. Millan, 1768), Plate 1, after page xxxii.