Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Review
Medicinal
Chemistry
Mariacristina Gagliardi*,1
& Barbara Mazzolai1
Center for Micro Bio-Robotics @ SSSA,
Istituto Italiano di Tecnologia, viale
Rinaldo Piaggio 34, 56025, Pontedera,
Pisa, Italy
*Author for correspondence:
mariacristina.gagliardi@iit.it
polymers with molecular recognition capabilities toward a template molecule introduced in the reaction during the synthesis. A
conventional method to obtain a MI polymer
is in liquid phase and can be schematized in
four steps[3] (Figure 1) : Figure 1A shows in
solution the template molecule and the
functional monomers are well dissolved
in the reaction medium; Figure 1B shows
complexation (or self-assembly) monomer
functionalities interact with the template
molecule forming a stable chemical complex, characterized by covalent or noncovalent interactions, after a self-assembling
procedure; Figure 1C shows locking functional monomers are cross-linked around the
template molecule and frozen in the position assumed during the complexation step;
Figure 1D shows extraction the template
molecule is extracted from the cross-linked
matrix leaving functional cavities into the
formed polymer; functionalized sites are
complementary to the template in terms
of shape and position of functional groups
involved in the complexation process.
As previously mentioned, there are two
main approaches to obtain complexes
between template and functional monomers: covalent and noncovalent. These two
part of
ISSN 1756-8919
123
approaches differ in the type of chemical bonds arising during the formation of the complexes. In the case
of the covalent approach, chemical bonds result which
are difficult to cleave during the extraction phase; in
the noncovalent approach, bonds are electrostatic,
hydrogen-bonds or ionic and the template can be easily
extracted through a simple washing procedure.
Considering that more stable complexes give higher
molecular recognition, the covalent approach seems to
be the better way to increase the performance of a MI
system. Covalent bonds between functional monomers
and template may be reversible or cleavable through
a simple chemical procedure. Obtained molecularly
imprinted polymers can recognize the template molecule used for the preparation after the extraction in
two different ways: formation of covalent bonds after a
chemical reaction; or formation of noncovalent bonds
(semicovalent approach). The recognition based on
the formation of covalent bonds between template and
MI polymer in rebinding tests was the first case investigated in the literature [1,4] . The main advantage of
this approach is represented by the stoichiometric ratio
between monomer and molecule to be recognized and
the homogeneous distribution of the recognition sites
in the polymeric structure. Even if recognition sites
obtained via covalent imprinting are more efficient than
those obtained through the noncovalent procedure, the
binding kinetics may be slow, therefore making this
route impractical for several applications. In late years,
in order to speed up the binding kinetics without the
loss of control of the topochemistry in the smart
cavities, the concept of the covalent MI was refined and
124
Review
www.future-science.com
125
126
immunoassays. Attempts to combine two functionalities of MI particles, recognition and signaling, were
reported in the work of Shutov et al. [75] where the
preparation of MI composite magnetic core/shell
nanoparticles (Fe3O4/MI polymer) were developed to
obtain a biomimetic assay.
Sensors & biosensors: label-free detection
The ability of MI polymers to selectively recognize specific molecules has been exploited to obtain label-free
molecular sensors. Three different noteworthy applications reported in the literature are: luminescence,
thermometric and electrochemical sensors.
Luminescence MI sensors are MI polymers containing fluorescent moieties which respond to the binding
events with significant fluorescence changes (Figure 2) .
Lieberzeit et al. [76] have reported a polyurethanebased MI system double-imprinted against polycyclic
aromatic hydrocarbons, obtaining a sensor with very
sensitive detection limits (e.g., 30ng/l for pyrene),
underlining also the beneficial effect of the multiple
imprinting. In the work of Nguyen and Ansell [77]
two fluorescent monomers, 6-styrylcoumarin-4-carboxylic acid and 6-vinylcoumarin-4-carboxylic acid,
were synthesized and used to obtain MI polymers
against (-)-ephedrine as template; polymers exhibited a quenching of fluorescence after recognition of
the template and a selectivity for the template over its
enantiomer (+)-ephedrine and other analogues for low
concentrations of ephedrine.
The thermometric detection through MI polymers
is grounded on the quantification of the heat of binding developed during a recognition process. When
the recognition sites bind the complementary molecule a thermal event occurs thus interactions can be
followed without any additional labelling. The first
application in thermometric detection of MI polymers
was proposed by Lettau and co-workers [78] . They
reported the preparation and the characterization of
an MI thermistor device with a combined activity,
molecular recognition and catalysis, obtained through
a covalent approach. The same principle was applied
in the work of Rajkumar et al. [79] to develop an MI
thermistor toward fructosyl valine and in the work of
Athikomrattanakul et al. [80] for the sensing of nitrofurantoin through noncovalent imprinting. Thermosensing by MI polymers is a synthetic evolution of
the common enzymatic thermistor: enzymatic reactions are commonly followed by calorimetric studies
and it consolidates the biomimicry properties of MI
polymers.
The detection limit of MI polymers can be further
improved by combining with electrochemical methods. The incorporation of metals [81] , grafene [82] or
Membrane separation is a well consolidated process based on the passive transport properties of the
membranes that are dependent on the porosity of the
membrane. Generally, membranes used for the separation are able to retain classes of compound basing
on the molecular dimension. Thus, common commercial membranes generally do not allow the separation
of one specific molecule. The preparation of molecule
specific membranes is a challenging issue that can be
tackled by using MI technology. Thus selective MI
membranes can find interesting bioapplications in
extra corporeal purification systems for the recognition
of solutes in the bloodstream. The literature reports
the development of MI membranes able to recognize
uric acid [93] , low density lipoproteins and cholesterol[94,95] as proof of concept of the final application.
Cell-imprinted membranes were also reported for the
retention of bacteria [96,97] .
In the field of tissue engineering, the use of smart
scaffolds able to guide cell proliferation and differentiation is currently an open challenge. The main goal
of tissue engineering is to reproduce the topography of
the physiological extracellular matrix at the nanoscale,
providing to cells an optimal structure for their
arrangement. The literature reports the use of microor nanopatterned scaffolds capable to align growing
cells helping the wound healing, obtained in the form
of membranes [98,99] or fibers [100] by nanoimprinting
soft-lithography. As a further improvement of this
approach, MI scaffolds can be studied to increase the
biomimicry of the device. A functionalized nanoenvironment for cell differentiation in an MI membrane
was also developed by imprinting biocompatible polymers (polydimethylsiloxane) against mature and dedifferentiated chondrocytes [101] , obtaining a biomimicking substrate for inducing stem cell differentiation.
The literature refers to a 2D scaffold for cell differentiation but the technique may be also extended to 3D
structures.
Addition of the
molecule to be
retained
Dispersion of
fluorescent MIPs
Partially quenched
MIPs after rebinding
Fluorescence
Review
Decreasing in
concentration of
retained molecule
Wavelength (nm)
Figure 2. Molecular imprinting particles for labelfree detection. Luminescence molecular imprinting
sensors show changes in fluorescence after binding
events; the figure schematizes one possible case in
which fluorescent molecular imprinting particles are
quenched after the rebinding.
MIP: Molecular imprinting particle.
The exploitation of the MI technology in the preparation of drug delivery systems has been introduced
only in recent years, because of the difficulty in optimizing the material preparation for this application.
Synthesis of polymers for drug delivery systems may
be clean, controlled, biocompatible and with high
yield and to combine these aspects with the MI technology is not a simple task. MI polymers in the form
of gels, scaffolds and particles were formulated for
this aim. In the review of Alvarez-Lorenzo and Concheiro [102] the importance of molecularly imprinted
materials as excipients for drug delivery systems was
highlighted, indicating the three main strategies that
these systems may fulfil: rate-programmed, activation-modulated or feedback-regulated drug delivery
(Figure 3) . Rate-programmed drug delivery systems
are a class of device able to control the drug diffusion outward from the system with a specific kinetic
profile; these systems are able to furnish high delivery rates or prolonged treatments depending on the
delivered drug and the therapeutic treatment. Activation-modulated drug delivery systems are devices in
which the delivery starts after a physical, chemical or
biochemical stimulus, such as the binding of a specific molecule or a chemical variation of the environment. The feedback-regulated drug delivery systems
are triggered by a specific molecule (a chemical or
biochemical compound) having a blood or plasma
concentration dependent on the drug itself.
www.future-science.com
127
Imprinted
Not imprinted
Time
Time
Time
Figure 3. Molecular imprinting particles for controlled drug delivery. (A) Rate-programmed drug delivery: thanks
to the recognition properties of molecular imprinting particles, the release of the active molecule is retarded
and thus a more prolonged drug release than conventional particles is obtained; (B) activation-modulated drug
delivery: the release of the active principle starts when molecular imprinting particles bind a specific molecule;
(C)feedback-regulated drug delivery: the release of the drug is governed by the presence/concentration of a
specific molecule regulated by the pharmacological activity of the released drug.
The use of polymers with smart recognition properties are also interesting in that the activities of the
drugs are significantly influenced by molecular recognition phenomena. The biological environment is
generally characterized by a high number of binding
events with large association constants (in the order
of magnitude of 103 1012 l/mol [103]). Optimized MI
systems can reach similar values and then can be
considered interesting candidates for such applications.
The major interest in the use of MI polymers as
drug delivery systems is related to their capability to
attenuate the delivery rate thanks to the high affinity toward the template molecule. Allender et al. [104]
reported a transdermal delivery system composed of
poly(methacrylic acid) cross-linked with EGDMA and
able to release with a controlled kinetics the loaded
drug (propanolol). Obtained systems were capable to
furnish prolonged delivery profiles, in particular in the
case of the system with the lower drug loading. Similar
results were reported in the work of Cai et al. [105] for
the release of tetracycline. In this paper the MI system
(poly(methacrylic acid) cross-linked with EGDMA)
128
materials, composed of diethylaminoethyl methacrylate and 2-hydroxyethylmethacrylate [116,117] , opening the way to zero-order kinetics release systems.
The literature reports the use of these materials for
the delivery of chemotherapic agents, such as 5-fluorouracil [118] , metal-based drugs [119] , anti-inflammatory [120,121] , anticonvulsant [122] , proton pump
inhibitor [123] and for the enantioselective release of
therapeutic agents[123125] . This interesting MI application consists of a controlled release of one enantiomer of a racemic mixture of active principle (Figure 4) .
The necessity to release only one of the enantiomers
is related to the different pharmacological activity
that drugs can exert: the favorable release of the more
active enantiomer promotes a better therapeutic effect.
Racemic mixtures are cheaper to produce than pure
single enantiomers and also separation of enantiomers
after production is not straightforward in many cases.
Another interesting result obtained by combining
drug delivery systems with MI technology is the possi-
Racemic mixture
Imprinting solution
Review
bility to obtain a kinetics that is responsive in the presence of a specific molecule. This is the case in the study
reported by Sreenevasar [126] . This work reports an MI
system composed of 2-hydroxy ethyl methacrylate and
EGDMA and imprinted against hydrocortisone. The
system was capable of releasing the drug of interest
(testosterone) with a significantly enhanced kinetics in
the presence of the template molecule.
The synthetic approach in the preparation of the MI
systems can influence the delivery kinetics and the final
properties of the polymers. A systematic study of recognition properties combined to delivery performances
were evaluated in the work of Salian et al. [127] . In this
paper the synergic effect of the synthesis scheme (living radical polymerization vs conventional free radical
polymerization) and MI technology was demonstrated.
Obtained gels showed an increased template binding
capacity and decreased delivery kinetics parameters.
Attempts to further control the delivery kinetics
were made by using environmental stimuli-responsive
MIP
Extracted MIP
Drug-loaded MIPs
(specific + non-specific absorption)
Released drug
Reloading mixture
Time
Figure 4. Molecular imprinting particles toward enantiomers. Particles are imprinted toward one of the enantiomers
of the racemate; after the template removal, obtained MIPs can be used for two different applications:
(A) separation of racemic mixtures; and (B) enantioselective-controlled delivery of racemic drugs.
MIP: Molecular imprinting particle.
www.future-science.com
129
130
Review
MIP
MMP
TIMP
Myocardium (post infarct), high MMPs/TIMPs ratio
www.future-science.com
131
Cell to be treated,
overexpressed receptors
Cell to be treated
132
polymer that provide molecular recognition capabilities. Functional cavities can recognize the template
molecule on the basis of the size, the shape but also
the topochemistry. In addition to the recognition
properties, molecularly imprinted cavities can retain
the molecule used during the imprinting process,
opening the possibility to obtain molecule-selective
separation systems. Molecular imprinting is a cheap
process but the optimization of the final products
may require significant efforts. MI polymers show
interesting properties that can be exploited in the
biomedical field and in nanomedicine. Sensors, synthetic immunoassays, molecular separation devices
or scaffolds for tissue engineering can be produced
by using customized MI polymers with great advantages in terms of stability, sensitivity, reduced costs
and reproducibility. Molecular recognition properties on MI polymers may completely substitute biologically-derived molecules in biohybrid polymeric
systems (e.g. peptide-functionalized particles), with
a significant increase of the safety of final products.
MIPs can find potential uses in nanomedicine as
excipients or drug carriers. The application of MI in
drug delivery systems preparation is still at an early
stage but promising proof of concepts have been
developed and well documented in the literature.
There are several advantaged in the exploitation of
MIPs as drug carrier, mainly related to the delivery
kinetics. MI polymers can significantly prolong the
delivery, foreseeing the possibility of a zero-order
Review
kinetics. Furthermore, obtained systems are reloadable providing the possibility to re-trigger in vivo
an exhaust system after the complete release of the
starting drug cargo. Completely synthetic targeted
drug delivery systems can be prepared via molecular
imprinting technique with an opportune choice of
the template molecule. Thus, drug-loaded surfaceimprinted particles against proteins, nutrients or
receptors involved in physiological cell internalization processes may show high internalization capabilities. Moreover, MIPs can be used as themselves
for a drug-free treatment involving the removal, from
the blood or a pathological site, of metals, viruses,
bacteria, enzymes or other different molecules causing a disease. The constantly growing literature on
molecularly imprinted polymers confirms the great
potential of this technology, opening the way to their
actual application as drug delivery systems, scaffold for tissue engineering, membranes for specific
separations, sensors and immunoassays.
Financial & competing interests disclosure
The authors have no relevant affiliations or financial involvement with any organization or entity with a financial interest in or financial conflict with the subject matter or materials discussed in the manuscript. This includes employment,
consultancies, honoraria, stock ownership or options, expert
testimony, grants or patents received or pending, or royalties.
No writing assistance was utilized in the production of this
manuscript.
Executive summary
Molecular imprinting (MI) is a chemical procedure that is used to introduce molecular recognition properties
in polymers in the form of monoliths, membranes, gels and particles.
The imprinted polymer is obtained around a target molecule (template) that is removed after the synthesis,
leaving molecular cavities complementary in size, shape and chemical functionalities to the extracted
template.
Molecular recognition properties of MI polymers are enough specific toward the template molecule that they
provide the recognition of the template in respect to homologous and enantiomers.
Synthetic immunoassays based on MI polymers are more stable and cheaper than biological ones.
Molecular sensors composed of MI polymers are more sensitive than conventional ones.
MI membranes are useful for molecular separation based on the chemical properties of the molecule to be
retained and not on its molecular dimension; this property opens a way to more efficient dialysis processes.
MI scaffolds represent a further enhancement of micro- or nanopatterned scaffolds for tissue engineering
providing a more controlled guidance of cell growth.
Drug delivery based on MI particles results more controlled in terms of release kinetics, providing more
prolonged administrations than conventional systems and showing the capability to be reloaded after the
complete release of the drug cargo.
MIPs can immobilize and remove pathogens from the bloodstream (synthetic antibodies) or specific molecules
in a pathological site to restore the physiological conditions.
A targeted drug delivery system can be obtained from particles imprinted against cell receptors or other
molecules abundant at the pathological site (Trojan horse).
The development of biodegradable MI polymers represents a big challenge and it allows combining high
biocompatibility with molecular recognition properties.
www.future-science.com
133
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
10
134
11
26
12
27
13
28
29
43
30
44
31
45
32
Fang L, Chen S, Guo X, Zhang Y, Zhang H. Azobenzenecontaining molecularly imprinted polymer microspheres with
photo- and thermoresponsive template binding properties in
pure aqueous media by atom transfer radical polymerization.
Langmuir 28(25), 97679777 (2012).
33
46
47
34
35
48
36
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
37
38
39
Liu M, Li Y, Han J, Dong X. Synthesis of tetracyclineimprinted polymer microspheres by reversible additionfragmentation chain-transfer precipitation polymerization
using polyethylene glycol as a co-porogen. J. Sep. Sci.
37(910), 111825 (2014).
Yang M, Zhang Y, Lin S et al. Preparation of a bifunctional
pyrazosulfuron-ethyl imprinted polymer with hydrophilic
external layers by reversible addition-fragmentation chain
transfer polymerization and its application in the sulfonylurea
residue analysis. Talanta 114, 143151 (2013).
Southard GE, Van Houten KA, Ott EW Jr, Murray
GM. Luminescent sensing of organophosphates using
europium(III) containing imprinted polymers prepared by
RAFT polymerization. Anal. Chim. Acta 581(2), 202207
(2007).
40
41
Review
www.future-science.com
135
71
57
58
72
59
73
74
60
75
61
76
77
78
79
80
81
62
63
64
65
136
70
66
67
68
Xu ZX, Gao HJ, Zhang LM, Chen XQ, Qiao XG. The
biomimetic immunoassay based on molecularly imprinted
polymer: a comprehensive review of recent progress and
future prospects. J. Food Sci. 76(2), R6975 (2011).
82
69
83
84
85
86
87
88
Li BL, Luo JH, Luo HQ, Li NB. A novel strategy for selective
determination of d-penicillamine based on molecularly
imprinted polypyrrole electrode via the electrochemical
oxidation with ferrocyanide. Sens. Act. B Chem. 186, 96102
(2013).
103 van Nostrum CF. Molecular imprinting: a new tool for drug
90
93
94
95
96
97
98
99
92
89
91
Yim EK, Reano RM, Pang SW, Yee AF, Chen CS, Leong KW.
Nanopattern-induced changes in morphology and motility of
smooth muscle cells. Biomaterials 26(26), 54055413 (2005).
Cristallini C, Cibrario Rocchietti E, Accomasso L et al.
The effect of bioartificial constructs that mimic myocardial
structure and biomechanical properties on stem cell
Review
www.future-science.com
137
polymers as drug delivery vehicles for metal-based antiinflammatory drug. Int. J. Pharm. 349(12), 3037 (2008).
138
horse for quantum dot cell transport. Angew. Chem. Int. Ed.
Engl. 53(3), 810814 (2014).
139 Yan L, Wang H, Jiang Y et al. Cell-penetrating peptide-