Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The online version of this article, along with updated information and services, is
located on the World Wide Web at:
http://stroke.ahajournals.org
51.
52.
53.
54.
55.
56.
57.
58.
59.
60.
61.
62.
63.
64.
65.
precursors and progenitors to increase production of fetal hemoglobin. J Clin Invest 75: 547-557, 1985
Rosa RM, Bierer BE, Thomas R, Jeffrey BS, Stoff JS, Kruskall M,
Robinson S, Bunn HF, Epstein FH: A study of induced hyponatremia in the prevention and treatment of sickle-cell crisis. New Eng J
Med303: 1138-1143, 1980
Leary M, Abramson N: Induced hyponatremia for sickle-cell crisis.
New Engl J Med 304: 844-845, 1980
Benjamin LJ, Kokkini G, Peterson CM: Cetiedil: Its potential usefulness in sickle cell disease. Blood 55: 265-270, 1980
Schmidt WF HI, Asakura T, Schwartz E: Effect of cetiedil on
cation and water movements in eryrhrocytes. J Clin Invest 69:
589-594, 1982
Kaul DK, Fabry ME, Nabel RL: Pentoxifylline modifies the rheology of SS cells but does not inhibit polymerization of HbS. In
Workshop on development of therapeutic agents for sickle cell
disease. Lister Hill center National Institutes of Health, Betbesda,
Maryland, May 15-17, 1983
Heilmnnn E, Laage HM, Zimmermann E, Dorst K-G: Therapeutic
influence on flexibility of erythrocytes in sickle-cell anaemia. Inn
Med 9: 277-280, 1982
Keller F, Leonhardt H: Verbesserung der blutviskositat bei sichelzellanamie durch pentoxifyllin. Dtsch Med Wschr 105: 898-900,
1980
SirchiaG, Lewis SM: Paroxysmal nocturnal hemoglobinuria. Clin
Haematol 4: 199-229, 1975
Donhowe WP, Lazaro RP: Dural sins thrombosis in paroxysmal
nocturnal hemoglobinuria. Clin Neurol Neurosurg 86: 149-152,
1984
Donhowe SP, Lazard RP: Dural sinus thrombosis in paroxysmal
nocturnal hemoglobinuria. Clin Neurol Neurosurg 86: 149-152,
1984
Haddock DR: Cerebrovascular accidents in Ghana. Neurology
(Minneap) 20: 681-686, 1970
Spencer JAD: Paroxysmal nocturnal hemoglobinuria in pregnancy.
Br J Obstet Gynaecol 87: 246-248, 1980
Wozniak AJ, Kitchens CS: Prospective hemostatic studies in a
patient having paroxysmal nocturnal hemoglobinuria, pregnancy,
and cerebral venous thrombosis. Am J Obstet Gynecol 142:
591-593, 1982
Rosse WF: Treatment of paroxysmal nocturnal hemoglobinuria.
Blood 60: 20-23, 1982
Hartmann RC, Jenkins DE Jr., McKee LC, Heyssel RM: Paroxysmal nocturnal hemoglobinuria; clinical and laboratory studies relat-
66.
67.
68.
69.
70.
71.
72.
73.
74.
75.
76.
77.
78.
79.
80.
81.
82.
817
ing to iron metabolism and therapy with androgen and iron. Medicine 45: 331, 1966
Firkin F, Goldberg H, Firkin BG: Clucocorticoid management of
paroxysmal nocturnal haemoglobinuria. Aust Ann Med 17: 127,
1968
Rosse WF, Gutterman LA: The effect of iron therapy in paroxysmal nocturnal hemoglobinuria. Blood 36: 559, 1970
Dacie JV, Firtin D: Blood transfusion in nocturnal hemoglobinuria.
Br Med J 1: 626, 1943
Adamson JW, Fialkow PJ, Murphy S, Prchal JF, Steinman L:
Polycythemia vera: stem cell and probable clonal origin of the
disease. N Engl J Med 295: 913-916, 1976
Wurster-Hill D, Whang-Peng J, Mclntyre OR, Hsu LYF, Hirschhom K, Modan B, Pisciotta AV, Pierre R, Balcerzak SP, Weinfeld
A, Murphy S: Cytogenetic studies in polycythemia vera. Seminars
Hematol 13: 13-32, 1976
Berlin NI: Diagnosis and classification of the polycythemias. Seminars Hematol 12: 339-351, 1975
Silverstein MN: The evolution into and the treatment of late stage
polycythemia veTa. Seminars Hematol 13: 79-84, 1976
Silverstein A, Gilbert H, Wusserman LR: Neurologic complications of polycythemia. Ann Intern Med 57: 909-916, 1962
Thomas DJ, Marshall J, Ross Russell RW, et al: Cerebral blood
flow in polycythemia. Lancet 2: 161-163, 1977
Harrison MJ: The hematocrit and cerebrovascular accidents. Presse
Med 12: 3095-3097, 1983
Fieschi C, Iadecola C: Hemorrbeological changes in cerebrovascular disease. Ric Clin Lab 3: 189-193, 1983
Schmid-Schonbein H: Macrorheology and microrheology of blood
in cerebrovascular insufficiency. Eur Neurol 22: Suppl 1: 2-22,
1983
Lechner H, Ott E: Clinical significance of changes in blood viscosity in cerebrovascular insufficiency. Munch Med Wochenschr 117:
1599-1602, 1975
Lowe GD, Jaap AJ, Forbes CD: Relation of atrial fibrillation and
high haematocrit to mortality in acute stroke. Lancet 1: 784-786,
1983
Tohgi H, Uchiyama S, Ogawa M, Tabuchi M, Naguara H, Yamanouchi H: The role of blood constituents in the pathogenesis of
cerebral infarction. Acta Neurol Scand 72 (suppl): 616-617, 1966
Chievitz E, Thiede T: Complications and causes of death in polycythemia vera. Acta Med Scand 172: 513-523, 1962
Siekert RG, Whisnant JP, Millikan CH: Anemia and intermittent
focal cerebral arterial insufficiency. Arch Neurol 3:386-390,1960
Diaschisis
DENNIS M. FEENEY, P H . D . , AND JEAN-CLAUDE BARON,
M.D.
818
STROKE
primary injury. These older theories of recovery, although quite different from recent objective observations of sprouting or denervation supersensitivity proposed to mediate recovery of function, are not
mutually exclusive. The unspecified mechanisms for
the alleviation of diaschisis could involve the growth
of new axon terminals or the multiplication of postsynaptic receptors.
While changes in neuronal function are common to
all of these theories, recovery of function is clearly a
multifactorial process including: the resolution of extracellular and/or intracellular edema; reestablishment
of cerebral blood flow (CBF) in "penumbral" areas
after ischemic stroke or subarchnoid hemorrhage-related vasospasm; and restitution of tissue function after
intracerebral hemorrhage (mass effect). Interventions
to promote these events may directly improve clinical
outcome by reducing the extent of initial damage.
Thus, acknowledging the many different approaches
to recovery after brain injury,5'n-8 this review will discuss only diaschisis.
Although the term diaschisis has often been used
loosely, few publications5' " l2 adhere to Von Monakow's original description written in German,1 language barriers having contributed to the confusion and
debates.1J~15 Diaschisis (from the Greek meaning
"shocked throughout") has been simplistically described as the cerebral counterpart of spinal shock.
Recent experimental, neurophysiological and metabolic data support the initial interpretation of spinal
shock as due to the loss of descending facilitory activity producing a transient loss of spinal reflexes below
the level of cord transection. Because the brain circuitry is relatively more complex than that of the spinal
cord, understanding the mechanisms underlying cerebral diaschisis will be more difficult.
In the 1870's, Brown-Sequard, the most notable
predecessor to the concept of diaschisis, described remote effects of focal brain damage ("actions at a distance"). He proposed that brain lesions produced excitatory and inhibitory effects causing disruption of
function in regions distant from the site of damage.5
Von Monakow, developing these ideas more fully,
introduced the term diaschisis to describe "abolition of
excitability" and "functional standstill". His theory of
diaschisis, which excluded previously held concepts of
irritation and active neural inhibition, was necessarily
dependent upon the interpretation of functional brain
organization. In contrast to the discrete localization of
cortical function held by many of his contemporaries,
Von Monakow noted:1 "The generally accepted theory
according to which aphasia, agnosia, apraxis, etc., are
due to destruction of narrowly circumscribed appropriate praxia, gnosia, and phasia centres, must be finally
discarded on the basis of more recent clinical and anatomical studies. It is just in the case of these focal
symptoms that the concept of complicated dynamic
disorders in the whole cortex becomes indispensible."
Von Monakow's perspective of "distribution of nervous function along several sections of the medullar
tube" (neuroaxis), was "Jacksonian" in nature.
VOL 17, No
5, SEPTEMBER-OCTOBER
1986
819
As discussed above, the term diaschisis can be considered analogous to spinal shock, and is used by some
clinicians in this context only. Supporting the classic
interpretation that spinal shock is due to the loss of
descending excitatory input is the report of immediate
alpha motor neuron hyperpolarization after cooling
and rewarming, respectively at higher cord levels.24
Post-cord transection measurements of glucose utilization using 14C-deoxyglucose (2DG) in the monkey have
recently indicated more complex and widespread effects appearing in many segments above and below the
level of the injury.23 Increased CMRGlu in some lamina was interpreted as a loss of tonic descending inhibition, and while reminiscent of diaschisis, the loss of
active neural inhibition was not included in Von Monakow's theory. The observation of hypermetabolic lamina adjacent to hypometabolic lamina after cord transection suggest caution in the interpretation of data,
especially negative results, when measures from large
regions of neuropil are combined.
Brainstem Lesions
Since a vast number of pathways interconnect brainstem, diencephalic and telencephalic neuronal aggregates, a brainstem vascular lesion might be expected to
exert transynaptic effects at many distant loci. In
stroke patients, brainstem lesions inducing stupor or
coma are associated with diminution of supratentorial
perfusion and metabolism roughly correlating with
both the state of arousal and altered EEG patterns.26
Conversely, patients with severe brainstem stroke resulting in total paralysis but normal arousal ("locked-in
syndrome"), have normal CBF.27
The classic work demonstrating coma in the cerveau
isole" preparation was interpreted as a remote effect of
the diffusely projecting mesencephalic reticular formation altering forebrain function.28 Although the critical
involvement of the mesencephalic region in the regulation of wakefulness has long been accepted, recent
work has focused on the complex interactions of di-
820
STROKE
verse nuclei within this region, and has utilized strategically placed lesions.
In the rat, large unilateral lesions interrupting most
of the brainstem-forebrain pathways resulted in
marked ipsilateral decreases in CMRGlu in cortical
and subcortical gray matter.29 Destruction of the rostral
reticular formation in stages30firston one side and then
after some time period, the contralateral side, did not
produce enduring coma. This attenuated effect was
interpreted as lesions performed in sequence producing less diaschisis. Lesions done in stages may be
likened to slowly growing tumors which produce less
symptomatology than acute lesions of the same magnitude. This effect of the Jacksonian "momentum" of a
lesion or "slowly creeping diaschisis" is still poorly
understood.
Experimental animal studies have examined
changes in forebrain metabolism after stereotaxic lesions of specific brainstem nuclei. Electrolytic lesions
of the rat raphe serotonergic somata resulted in moderate depression of CMRGlu in other brainstem nuclei
and the hippocampal dentate gyms without altering
metabolism in other forebrain regions.31 Unilateral lesions of the locus coeruleus (LC) reportedly caused
either very moderate or no change in cerebral metabolism. Glucose utilization was markedly reduced in the
ipsilateral cerebral cortex and latero-ventral thalamus
(by 10% and 15% respectively)32 or unchanged.2933
Cortical resting metabolic rates measured using the
histochemical stain alpha-glycerophosphate dehydrogenase (a-GPDH) were unchanged.19 In contrast, the
depression of a-GPDH in the entire ipsilateral cortex
following focal cortical injury34 is exaggerated by lesions of the LC.19 This data is compatible with the
hypothesis that the LC "modulates" activity of other
systems.35
In the rat, 6-hydroxydopamine-induced substantia
nigra lesions have simulated the dopamine (DA) deafferentation of Parkinson's disease. Resulting physiologic changes include mildly deceased CMRGlu in the
ipsilateral frontal cortex, not reversed by administration of DA agonists, mild ipsilateral strial metabolic
depression and marked hypermetabolism in the ipsilateral habenula and globus pallidus. These latter effects,
in contrast to the frontal cortex hypometabolism, are
alleviated by apomorphine or L-Dopa. These metabolic changes, which are associated with ipsilateral
DA postsynaptic hypersensitivity and behavioral abnormalities, are not found in animals showing spontaneous recovery of function.29' 3*~38 Although these studies satisfy most of die criteria for diaschisis they are
rarely discussed in this framework. That the target
structure of the substantia nigra shows only a mild
metabolic depression despite the almost total DA deafferentation may result from the sparing of the nonDA afferents constituting the major inputs to the striatum. There may be no presently detectable direct
metabolic counterpart to the presumptive primary neural abnormality of Parkinson's Disease i.e. the loss of
nigro-striatal input. Transneuronal hyperactivity resulting from loss of tonic inhibition, reflected by in-
VOL 17, No
5, SEPTEMBER-OCTOBER
1986
creased pallidal glucose utilization following substantia nigra lesions, can occur after brain injury and
incorporating this concept is essential to present-day
revision of the theory of diaschisis.
hi summary, remote supratentorial functional effects of brainstem reticular and nigro-striatal lesions
have been clearly demonstrated using cerebral metabolic measurements. Transient, transynaptic effects
secondary to lesions of either of these anatomically and
physiologically unique systems could potentially be
considered diaschisis.
Thalamus
The thalamus constitutes a major relay and integrative nuclear cluster, including the sensory, motor, limbic systems, as well as the ascending brainstem reticular formation. Thus, interruption of neuronal function
such as occurs in thalamic stroke, can give rise to a
constellation of different clinical expressions including
sensory loss, ataxis, speech alterations (thalamic aphasia), visual-spatial deficits, global or selective amnesia, hemi-inattention (neglect), psychomotor retardation, akinetic mutism, thalamic dementia and possibly
coma. Apart from designated functional roles of the
ventrobasal complex and geniculate bodies, precise
clinico-anatomic correlations of other thalamic nuclei
are lacking. However, selected human studies (including sterotaxic thalamotomy) have suggested the dominant ventral-lateral and intralaminar nuclei play a significant role in the mechanisms of attention. Lesions of
the left or right medio-dorsal nucleus may produce
verbal and visual amnesia respectively, while bilateral
lesions may result in global amnesia or dementia.40'41
Some of these thalamic injury syndromes have also
been reproduced in nonhuman primates.42
In view of the dense thalamocortical projections, it
has been speculated that these behavioral consequences of thalamic damage result from cortical dysfunction after loss of these important cortical afferents
perhaps a loss of cortical "activation."43-44 Some
particular patterns of symptoms may only reflect "specialized cortical functions." This could be interpreted
as a diaschisis, since such effects would be remote
from the lesion and recovery is often remarkable after
thalamic stroke even when initial symptoms are severe.
Electrophysiological data from both human and animal experimentation shows that there is marked ipsilateral cortical EEG slowing following unilateral lesions in many of the "non-sensory" thalamic nuclei,
particularly the intralaminar, medio-dorsal, ventralanterior and the reticular nuclei.45"" These effects,
which depending on the size of the lesion last for
weeks or longer, reportedly affect the entire ipsilateral
cortical mantle. Lesions of a "specific" projection nucleus, such as the ventral-posterior-lateral nucleus may
notresultin EEG slowing or die effects are restricted to
the somatosensory cortical projection area.45' ** Unilateral lesions of the rostral pole of the thalamus (anterior-ventral and reticular nuclei) in the cat, depressed
both seizure activity and sleep spindles over the ipsilat-
821
822
STROKE
VOL. 17, No
5, SEPTEMBER-OCTOBER
1986
transient effects.43 In humans, "pure" white matter lesions are difficult to confirm, and small infringements
on neighboring grey matter (e.g. thalamus, pallidum)
contributing to the lesions' manifestations, may go
undetected by present imaging techniques. Physiological observations in deep hemispheric syndromes have
included; 1) lack of the normal sensorimotor cortex
cerebral blood flow activation during contralateral
hand movements in patients with capsulo-thalamic infarcts;83 2) reduced CMRGlu in cortical and thalamic
regions ipsilateral to caudate and internal capsule lacunar lesions;69 3) reduction in precentral and central
cortical blood flow ipsilateral to internal capsule infarcts.86'" Other studies of smaller white matter lesions have shown no cortical metabolic impairments.88' w Taken together, these observations suggest
that damage to the thalamus itself or to thalamo-cortical fibers is necessary for development of behavioral
symptoms and cortical hypometabolism.87"90
Lesions of the optic radiations reportedly induce
ipsilateral metabolic depression in the deafferented visual cortices.68'TO'""M Patients studied weeks after the
onset of lateral homonomous hemianopia still exhibit
this visual cortex depression.92 The discrepancy between the transient metabolic effects of enucleation16
and the lasting metabolic depression following optic
radiation lesions, although possibly species specific,
more likely results from the different points of interruption of this multiple relay circuit.
Transcallosal Diaschisis
Kempinsky's experimental contributions to the
study of diaschisis should not be overlooked.94"97 He
primarily studied electrophysiological responses contralateral to unilateral cortical lesions produced by diverse methods (ablation, electric cautery, vascular ligation, and freezing). However there are some
shortcomings which limit intrepretation of his data
which include possible variations in the depth of etherinduced anesthesia, lack of quantification of evoke
potential and EEG data, and the absence of histological
verification of prior corpus callosum section done in
some cats. In none of the animals with the callosal
section was a depression of evoke potentials observed,
however some of the cats with large lesions did show
EEG amplitude reduction contralateral to the cortical
injuries. Despite these factors, Kempinsky interpreted
his data as strong support for Von Monakow's theory
of diaschisis.
Although it is tempting to invoke a mechanism of
transcallosal diaschisis for the commonly reported
CBF depression contralateral to a stroke, such studies
areflawedby confounding variables prior to or following the acute event.55-98"107 Such factors include chronic hypertension, previous cerebral infarction, large
vessel occlusion and "steal" phenomenon, increased
intracranial pressure, transtentorial herniation, drug
effects, and changes in PaCO2, hematocrit, and arterial
blood pressure. The effect of these variables on cortical function, contralateral to a stroke, as measured by
CBF, CMR02, or CMRGlu is unknown.
Animal experiments circumvent some of these confounding variables in the human studies. In models of
and Baron
823
824
STROKE
VOL 17, No
5, SEPTEMBER-OCTOBER
1986
In an attempt to explain the mechanisms of hemiplegia following motor cortex damage, Von Monakow
described "diaschisis cortico-spinalis", a reversible
functional depression of remote intact structures. Experimental pharmacologic manipulations in hemiplegic animals have been shown to accelerate recovery
while also affecting cerebral metabolism and neurotransmitter release at a site remote from the primary
lesion. Unilateral sensorimotor cortex ablation in the
rat produced pronounced but transient contralateral
hemiplegia evident on the beam-walking task. Amphetamine, administered in moderate doses was combined with the beam-walking experience. A single administration of the drug one day post-operatively
enhanced recovery compared to saline controls and the
beneficial effects endured and were maintained long
after the drug was metabolized. In animals given amphetamine and kept in a small cage to prevent ballistic
movements during intoxication, no promotion of recovery was observed indicating the necessity to combine drug and experience. Haloperidol blocked this
treatment effect and when given alone in a single dose,
also markedly retarded recovery, implicating the catecholamines (CA) inrecoveryof function.'" This effect
has been replicated in the cat whose more severe
hemiplegia responds favorably to delayed (10 days
post-surgery) multiple but spaced administrations of
amphetamine combined with beam-walking experience.164
The mechanism of these effects is uncertain but
diaschisis has been suggested to explain the rapid behavioral improvements produced by this pharmacologic treatment plus behavioral experience.19 Alternative
interpretations include: the reversal of lesion-induced
input or depleted neurotransmitter, longterm potentiation,63-165-l66 and behavioral substitution. A CA-related
diaschisis is supported by the observations that single
infusions of NE,167 or systemic administration of the
amphetamine analogs phentermine168 or phenolpropanolamine,169 combined with experience also promote
recovery from hemiplegia. The DA agonist apomorphine and the DA uptake-blocker methylphenidate do
not promote recovery from hemiplegia in this model.170- m Further biochemical support for CA-related
diaschisis is the observation in post-operative treated
animals of increased NE turnover in the ipsilateral LC
(whose neurons project to forebrain and cerebellum172)
and the cerebellum contralateral to the cortical lesion
compared to saline treated controls. Such changes
could indicate a treatment-induced alleviated or compensated "crossed cerebellar diaschisis" which has
been associated with supratentorial stroke discussed
below. Metabolic studies in this model suggest a
diaschisis as there is a widespread depression of 2DG
utilization especially prominent in the ipsilateral red
nucleus and LC following unilateral sensorimotor
cortex lesions.19 Paralleling the pharmacological manipulation of behavioral recovery is the respective improvement or worsening of post-surgical hypometabolism by amphetamine and haloperidol.19 However,
since these CNS metabolic effects are diffuse, delineation of anatomically selective effects is necessary before a specific structural correlate of treatment-accelerated functional recovery can be established.
Crossed Cerebellar Diaschlsis
Cerebellar hemisphere hypometabolism contralateral to supratentorial infarction was first described by
Baron et al using PET and the steady-state oxygen-15
method.173"175 This phenomenon has since been reported in about 50% of patients with stroke and those with
supratentorial neoplasms, studied by tomographic
mapping of perfusion CMRO 2 , CMRGlu, or I-iodoamphetamine uptake.53' " 107 ' 139 ' '"176"185
Significant contralateral cerebellar hypometabolism
(CCH) has been observed in patients with isolated lesions of the frontal cortex, 5 5 ' l 7 6 ' m parietal cortex, 107179183
thalamic
and
basal
ganglia
areas 53 ' m - l77 ' m-183 and internal capsule.89 The CCH is
most prominent with large lesions involving two or
three cerebral lobes, or after smaller lesions destroying
most of the internal capsule at the level of the basal
ganglia. The size and location of the lesion rather than
severity of hemiparesis appear to be the best predictors
of CCH in stroke patients. Additionally, CCH has been
seen in patients with pure motor hemiparesis related to
an internal capsule lacune, 8889 as well as in patients
with large infaxcts and no hemiparesis176' m-179, but not
in hemiparetic patients with a presumed pontine lacune.
Interruption of the cerebro-cerebellar loop is
thought to be the most likely mechanism of this remote
transneuronal metabolic depression.174'175 Its frequent
association with frontal and parietal cortical lesions
the origin of the cortico-pontine fiber tract186"188 fits this
hypothesis. Since cortico-pontine projections provide
predominantly excitatory input to the contralateral
cerebellar granule cells,189' l9 damage to this system
could "deactivate" the contralateral cerebellum, hence
the term "crossed cerebellar diaschisis."173'll* Although CCH was not specifically studied, experiments
in monkeys'49'191 have shown ipsilateral pontine nuclei
hypometabolism after cortical ablation. CCH has been
difficult to observe in rats 19 ' l49 ' l59 ' "" m presumably
because the cerebro-cerebellar loop is well developed
only in primates.186
In conflict with the theoretical interpretation of CCH
as a diaschisis are examples where CCH persists or
even worsens post-infarction. 53107176177179181 Furthermore, CCH may develop in association with slowly growing supratentorial tumors,178-183 indicating that
acute brain injury is not essential for its development.
Thus, two essential criteria for a diaschisis, namely
sudden onset and a transient response are lacking in
CCH. While other examples of slowly developing
diaschisis have been discussed, the lack of CCH reversibility is a major theoretical problem. Other possible explanations include anterograde transneuronal degeneration, known to occasionally develop years after
adult-onset supratentorial stroke.193' l94 Since dendritic
alterations as early as 2-3 days after deafferentation
have been described, 195196 the acutely detectable
825
CCH177 might represent early metabolic responses expected to preceed irreversible morphological alterations .179 The lack of recovery of CCH and its apparent
progression to degeneration sharply contrast with the
other examples of transynaptic depression discussed
above. Nevertheless, recovery of CCH has actually
been reported in a few stroke patients175'177-179 suggesting that this process is not necessarily inescapable.
While the mechanisms for recovery are unclear, they
may represent a link between reversible diaschisis and
irreversible degeneration.179
As yet, there is no well established clinical expression of CCH. In a recent study of seven patients with
pure internal capsular infarcts, no obvious association
between CCH and ipsilateral limb ataxia was found.89
Thus, until large scale prospective studies are undertaken, the phenomenon of CCH, although the most
consistent evidence of transneuronal functional depression in humans, will remain poorly understood in
terms of pathophysiology, clinical correlations and
therapeutic implications.
In addition to effects on the contralateral cerebellum, supratentorial lesions may result in a mild, less
profound metabolic depression in the ipsilateral cerebellum. 5 5 1 0 7 1 7 6 1 7 8 This observation has been challenged179 because of the lack of an adequately matched
control group with respect to age and vascular risk
factors, as well as a nonhomogeneous study group.
Furthermore, its reported association with impaired
consciousness,107 suggests a role for supratentorial
edema and herniation.
Concussion
Experimental data suggest that the sequelae of cerebral concussion may reflect midbrain muscarinic cholinergic hyperactivity.197 Supporting this theory is the
reproduction in cats of transient behavioral and EEG
changes mimicking concussion following acetylcholine agonist (carbachol) infusion. An increased 2DG
utilization in cholinergic neurons remote from the site
of trauma was observed in a concussion model. Such a
cholinergic pathological hyperactivity may act upon
other intact systems to produce symptoms of concussion. These findings are compatible with the theory of
diaschisis if it is modified to incorporate disruptive
hyperactivity as well as loss of facilitatory input from
damaged areas.
Permanent Diaschisis
Schneider15 first conceptualized a permanent
diaschisis, "diaschisis protractiva," to explain the surgical alleviation of the hemianopsia contralateral to
posterior cortical ablation in cats.198 Animals with
longstanding loss of orienting responses to stimuli in
the visual field contralateral to a large unilateral posterior cortex ablation recovered after a lesion of the contralateral superior colliculus or intercollicular commissure. The subcortical lesions were thought to abolish a
pathological intercollicular tonic inhibition resulting
from the unilateral cortical ablation.198'199 Another possible example of permanent diaschisis is the amphetamine plus visual experience restoration of depth perception after bilateral visual cortex ablation in cats.200
826
STROKE
VOL 17, No
5, SEPTEMBER-OCTOBER
1986
parallel improvement with time and response to manipulations. With prolonged lack of normal afferent
input or function, diaschisis may result in morphologic
alterations. The disruption of function in the target
structure may result from a loss of either excitation or
inhibition. In cases of low afferent input activity or in
the presence of numerous other inputs to the target
structure, diaschisis may not occur. Conversely, if the
lesioned area constitutes the sole or major input to the
target structure, a readily detectable diaschisis must
occur. Diverse mechanisms, possibly including repair
processes such as sprouting and/or denervation supersensitivity, could allow the target structure to accomodate for the loss of input from the lesioned area.
While none of the experiments discussed in this
review completely satisfy all the criteria for diaschisis,
they do provide persuasive evidence for certain aspects
of the theory. Only if this concept stimulates future
work which provides some understanding of recovery
of function will such a general theory of reaction to
brain injury prove worthwhile.
Acknowledgments
We wish to express our gratitude to Elise Scott and Dr. Irene
Meissner for assistance in the preparation of this manuscript.
References
1. Von Monakow C: Diaschisis [1914 article translated by G. Harris]. In: Brain and Behavior I: Mood States and Mind. Pribram
KH, ed. Baltimore: Penguin, 27-36, 1969
2. Easter JR, Purves D, Rakic P, Spitzer NC: The changing view of
neural specificity. Science 230: 507-511, 1985
3. Feeney DM, Sutton RL: Pharmacotherapy for recovery of function. Critical Reviews in Clinical Neurobiology. (in Press)
4. Finger S (ed): Recovery from Brain Damage: Research and Theory. New York: Plenum Press, 165, 1978
5. Finger S, Stein DG: Brain Damage and Recovery: Research and
Clinical Perspectives. New York: Academic Press, 1982
6. Ledeen RW, Yu RK, Rapport MM, Suzuki (ed): Ganglioside
structure, function and bioniedical potential. New York: Plenum
Press, 575, 1984
7. Marshall JF: Neural plasticity and recovery after brain injury. In:
Int Rev Neurobiol, Vol 26, Smythes JP, Bradley (EOS). New
York: Academic Press, 201-220, 1985
8. Marshall JF: Brain function: Neural adaptations and recovery
from injury. Ann Rev Psychol 35: 277-308, 1984
9. Nichols JG (ed.): Repair and Regeneration of the nervous system.
Berlin: Springer-Verlag, 1982
10. Raisman G: What hope for repair of the brain. Ann Neurol 3:
101-106, 1978
11. Riese W: Aphasia in brain tumors. Confinia Neurologica 9:
64-79, 1984
12. Riese W: The principle of diaschisis. International Record of
Medicine 171: 73-82, 1958
13. Markowitsch HJ, Pritzel M: Von Monakow's diaschisis concept:
Comments on West et al. Behavioral Biology 22: 411-412, 1978
14. West JR: The concept of diaschisis: A reply to Markowitsch and
Pritzel. Behavioral Biology 22: 413-416, 1978
15. Teuber HL: Recovery of function after injury in man. In: Outcome of severe damage to the central nervous system (Ciba Foundation Symposium). Amsterdam: Elsevier, pp. 159-186, 476,
1975
16. Cooper RM, Thurlow GA: Depression and recovery of metabolic
activity in rat visual system after eye removal. Exp Neurol 89:
322-336, 1985
17. Feeney DM, Hovda DA: Amphetamine and apomorphine restore
tactile placing after motor cortex injury in the cat, Psychopharmacology 79: 67-71, 1983
18. Feeney DM, Hovda DA: Reinstatement of binocular depth perception by amphetamine and visual experience after visual cortex
ablation. Brain Research 342: 352-356, 1985
46.
47.
48.
49.
50.
51.
52.
53.
54.
55.
56.
57.
58.
59.
60.
61.
62.
63.
64.
65.
66.
67.
827
828
STROKE
91.
92.
93.
94.
95.
96.
97.
98.
99.
100.
101.
102.
103.
104.
105.
106.
107.
108.
109.
110.
111.
112.
113.
114.
VOL
17,
No
5,
SEPTEMBER-OCTOBER
1986
115.
116.
117.
118.
119.
120.
121.
122.
123.
124.
125.
126.
127.
128.
129.
130.
131.
132.
133.
134.
135.
136.
137.
138.
829
139. Heiss WD, Pawlick G, Wagner R, Ilsen HW, Herholz K, Wienhard K: Functional hypometabolism of non-infarcted brain regions in ischemic stroke. J Cereb Blood Flow Metabol 3 (Suppl
1): S582-583, 1983
140. Gibbs JM, Wise RJ, LeendersICL, Jones T: Evaluation of cerebral
perfusion reserve in patients with carotid-artery occlusion. Lancet
1: 310-314, 1984
141. Samson Y, Baron JC, Bousser MG, Rey A, Derlon JM, David P,
et Comoy J: Effects of extra-intracranial arterial bypass on cerebral blood flow and oxygen metabolism in humans. Stroke 16:
609-616, 1985
142. Sgouropoulos P, Baron JC, Samson Y, Bousser MG, ComarD, et
Castaigne P: Stenoses et occlusions persistances d 1'artere dibrale moyenne: consequences himodynamiques et mdtaboliques
itudiees parTomographie a Positons. Revue Neurologique (Paris)
141: 698-705, 1985
143. Mies G, Auer LM, Ebhardt G, Traupe H, Heiss WD: Flow and
neuronal density in tissue surrounding chronic infarction: Stroke
14: 22-27, 1983
144. Raynaud C, Rancutel G, Samson Y, et al: Pathophysiologic study
of chronic brain infarcts with 1-123. Isopropyl-Iodo-amphetamine
(IMP), the importance of peri infarct area. Stroke (In Press), 1986
145. Strong AJ, Tomlinson BE, Venables GS, Gibson G, Hardy JA:
The cortical ischemic penumbra associated with occlusion of the
middle cerebral artery in the cat: studies of histopathology water
content and in vitro neurotransmitter uptake. J Cereb Blood Row
Metabol 3: 97-108, 1983
146. Lassen NA: Incomplete cerebral infarction. Stroke 13: 522-523,
1982
147. Nedergaard M, Astrup J, Klinken L: Cell density and cortex
thickness in the border zone surronding old infarcts in the human
brain. Stroke 15: 1033-1039, 1984
148. Cooper RM, Thurlow GA: 2-Deoxyglucose uptake in the thalamus of awake rats after neocortical ablations. Exp Neurol 86:
261-271, 1984
149. Hosokawa S, Kato M, Aiko Y, Shima F: Altered local cerebral
glucose utilization by unilateral frontal cortical ablations in rats.
Brain Res 343: 8-15, 1985
150. Deuel RK, Collins RC: The functional anatomy of frontal lobe
neglect in the monkey: clinical and quantitative 2-Deoxyglucose
studies. Ann Neurol 15: 521-529, 1984
151. WiseRJS, Bemardi S, FrackowiakRSJ, et al: Serial observations
on the pathophysiology of acute stroke: the transition from ischaemia to infarction as reflected in regional oxygen extraction. Brain
106: 197-222, 1983
152. Baron JC, Bousser MG, Comar D, Soussaline F, Castaigne P:
Non invasive tomographic study of cerebral blood flow and oxygen metabolism in vivo: potentials, limitations and clinical applications in cerebral ischemic disorders. Europ Neurol 20:
273-284, 1981
153. Ackerman RH, Correia JA, Alpert NM, et al: Pet studies of stroke
in "Positron Emission Tomography". Reivich M, Alavi A (eds).
New York, Alan R. Liss, pp 249-262, 1985
154. Metter EJ, Riege WH, Hanson WR, Campas LR, Phelps ME,
Kuhl DE: Correlations of glucose metabolism and structural damage to language function in aphasia. Brain Lang 21: 187-207,
1984
155. Dauth GW, Gilman S, Frey KA, Penney JB Jr Basal Ganglia
glucose utilization after recent precentral ablation in the monkey.
Ann Neurol 17: 431-438, 1985
156. Cooper RM, Thurlow GA, Rooney BJ: 2-Deoxyglucose uptake
and histologic changes in rat thalamus after neocortical ablations.
Exp Neurol 83: 134-143, 1984
157. Scatton B, Worms P, Lloyd KG, Bartholini P: Cortical modulation of striatal function. Brain Res 232: 331-343, 1982
158. Schallert T, Hernandez, Berth TM: Recovery of function after
brain damage: Severe and chronic disruption by diazepam. Brain
Res (In Press), 1986
159. Sutton RL, Chen MJ, Hovda DA, Feeney DM: Effects of amphetamine on cerebral metabolism following brain damage as revealed
by quantitative cytochrome oxidase histochemistry. Neuro Sci
Abst 12 (In Press), 1986
160. West JR, DeadwylerSA, Cotman CW, Lynch GS: An experimental test of diaschisis. Behavioral Biology 18: 419-425, 1976
161. Steward O, Smith LK: Metabolic changes accompanying dener-
830
162.
163.
164.
165.
166.
167.
168.
169.
170.
171.
172.
173.
174.
175.
176.
177.
178.
179.
180.
181.
182.
183.
184.
STROKE
vation and reinnervation of the dentate gyrus of the rat measured
by [3H]2-deoxyglucose autoradiography. Exp Neurol 69:
513-527, 1980
Kameyama M, Wasterlain CG, Ackermann RF, Fuich D, Lear J,
Kuhl DE: Neuronal response of the hippocampal formation to
injury: Blood flow, glucose metabolism, and protein synthesis.
Exp Neurol 79: 329-346, 1983
Feeney DM, Gonzalez A, Law WA: Amphetamine, haloperidol
and experience interact to affect rate of recovery after motor
cortex injury. Science 217: 855-857, 1982
Hovda DA, Feeney DM: Amphetamine with experience promotes
recovery of locomotor function after unilateral frontal cortex injury in the cat. Brain Research 298: 358-361, 1984
Wenzel Von J, Schmidt C, Duwe G, Skrebitski, Kudrjatshow I:
Stimulations-induzierte veranderungen der ultrastruktur von synapzen in hippocampus wakrend porttentanischer potenzerung. J
Himforsch 26: 573-583, 1985
Teyler TJ, Discenna P: Long-term potentiation as a candidate
mnemonic device. Brain Res Rev 7: 15-28, 1984
Boyeson MG, Feeney DM: The role of norepinephrine in recovery
from brain injury. Society for Neuroscience, Abstracts 10, 68,
1984
Hovda DA, Bailey B, Montoya S, Salo AA, Feeney DM: Phentermine accelerates recovery of function after motor cortex injury in
rats and cats. Fed Am Soc Exp Biol 42: 1157, 1983
Chen MJ, Sutton RL, Feeney DM: Recovery of function following brain injury in rat and cat: Beneficial effects of phenylpropanolamine. Soc for Neuroscience Abstracts 12 (In Press), 1986
Ross SB: The central stimulatory action of inhibitors of dopamine
uptake. Life Sci 24: 159, 1979
Sutton RL, Hovda DA, Salo AA, Feeney DM: Effect of catecholamine agonists on recovery of motor ability after unilateral frontal cortex ablation in rat and cat. Submitted for publication.
Steindler DA: Locus coeruleus neurons have axons that branch to
the forebrain and cerebellum. Brain Research 223:367-373,1981
Baron JC, Bousser MG, Comar D, Castaigne P: "Crossedcerebellar diaschisis" in human supratentorial infarction (abstract). Ann
Neurol 8: 128, 1980
Baron JC, BousserMG.ComarD, Castaigne P: "Crossed cerebellar diaschisis" in human supratentorial brain infarction. Trans
Amer Neurol Ass 105: 459-461, 1980
Baron JC, Bousser MG, Comar D, Duquesnoy N, Sastre J, Castaigne P: "Crossed Ccrebellar Diaschisis": a remote functional
depression secondary to supratentorial infarction of man. J Cereb
Blood Row Metabol 1 (suppl 1): S5OO-501, 1981
Martin WRW, Raichle ME: Cerebellar blood flow and metabolism in cerebral hemisphere infarction. Ann Neurol 14: 168-176,
1983
Meneghetti G, Vorstrup S, Mickey B, Lindewald H, Lassen NA:
Crossed cerebellar diaschisis in ischemic stroke: a study of regional cerebral blood flow by l33 Xe inhalation and single photon
emission computerized tomography. J Cereb Blood Flow Metab
4: 235-240, 1984
KuschnerM, Alair A, Reivich M, DannR, Burke A, Robinson G:
Contralateral cerebellar hypometabolism following cerebral insult: a positron emission tomographic study. Ann Neurol 15:
425-434, 1984
Pantano P, Baron JC, Samson Y, Bousser MG, De Rouesne C,
Comar D: Crossed cerebellar diaschisis: further studies. Brain (in
press), 1986
Cesaro P, Moretti JL, Caron JP, et al: Tomoscintigraphie cerebrale utilisant la l.iodo I 123 isopropyl amphetamine. Presse Med
14: 205-218, 1985
BiersackHJ, Hartmann A, FriedrichG,etal:On the occurence of
crossed cerebellar diaschisis in cerebrovascular disease. Nucl
Med 23: 227-230, 1984
Pantano P, Di Piero V, Triulzi F, Fazio F, Savi AR, Fieschi C,
Lenzi GL: Crossed cerebellar diaschisis in supratentorial cerebral
ischemia: a study with 1-123 HPIDM. J Cerebral Blood How
Metab 5 (Suppl 1): S14-S16, 1985
Patronas NJ, Di Chiro G, Smith BH, Dela Paz R, Brooks RA,
Milam HL, Komblith PL, Bairamian D, Mansi L: Depressed
cerebellar glucose metabolism in supratentorial tumors. Brain
Research 291: 93-101, 1984
Baron JC, Lebrun-Grandie P, Collard P, et al: Noninvasive mea-
185.
186.
187.
188.
189.
190.
191.
192.
193.
194.
195.
196.
197.
198.
199.
200.
201.
202.
203.
204.
205.
206.
VOL
17,
No
5,
SEPTEMBER-OCTOBER
1986
surement of blood flow, oxygen consumption and glucose utilization in the same brain regions in man by positron emission tomography: Concise communication. J Nucl Med 23: 391-399, 1982
Baron JC, Rougemont D, Soussaline F, Bustany P, Crouzel C,
Bousser MG, Comar D: Local inter relationship of cerebral oxygen consumption and glucose utilization in normal subjects and in
ischemic stroke patients: a positron tomography study: Journal of
Cerebral Blood Flow Metabolism 4: 140-149, 1984
Brodal A: Neurological anatomy in relation to clinical medicine.
New York, Oxford University Press, 1969
Brodal P: The corticopontine projection in the rhesus monkey.
Origin and principles of organization. Brain 101: 251-283, 1978
Gliskstein M, May JG, Mercier BE: Corticopontine projection in
the macaque: the distribution of labelled cortical cells after large
injections of horseradish peroxydase in the pontine nuclei. J
Comp Neurol 235: 343-359, 1985
Allen GI, Tsukahara N: Cerebrocerebellar communication systems. Physiol Rev 54: 957-1006, 1974
Sasaki K, Oka H, Kwaguchi S, Jinnai K, Yasuda T: Mossy fibre
and climbing fibre responses produced in the cerebellar cortex by
stimulation of the cortex in monkeys. Exp Brain Res 29:
419-428, 1977
Dauth G, Gilman S, Frey K, Penney J: 14C-2-Deoxyglucose uptake in monkeys with hypotonic hemiplegia afer precentral and
postcentral lesions (abstract), Neurology 30: 407, 1980
Naritomi H: Transtentorial diaschisis: reduction of cerebellar
blood flow caused by supratentorial local cerebral ischemic in the
gerbil. Stroke 14: 213-218, 1983
Baudrimont M, Gray F, Meininger V, Escourolle R, Castaigne P:
Atrophie ccrtbelleuse croisee apres lesion he'misphe'rique survenue a l'age adulte. Rev Neurol (Paris), 139: 485-495, 1983
Pappata S, Tran-Dinh S, Baron JC, Cambon H, Syrota A: Remote
metabolic effects of cerebrovascular lesions: magnetic resonance
and positron tomography imaging. Neuroradiology (in press),
1986
Mouren-Mathieu AM, Colonnier M: The molecular layer of the
adult cat cerebellar cortex after lesion of the parallel fibers: an
optic and electron microscope study. Brain Research 16:
307-323, 1969
Wong-Riley MTT: Changes in the dorsal lateral geniculate nucleus of the squirrel monkey after nilateral ablation of the visual
cortex. J Comp Neur 146: 519-572, 1972
Hayes RL, Pechura CM, Katayama Y, Povlishock JT, Giebel
ML, Becker DP: Activation of pontine cholinergic sites implicated in unconsciousness following cerebral concussion in the cat.
Science 223: 301, 1984
Sprague JM: Interaction of cortex and superior colliculus in mediation of visually guided behavior in the cat. Science 153:
1544-1547, 1966
Goodale MA: Cortico-tectal and intertectal modulation of visual
responses in the rats superior colidulus. Exp Brain Res 17:75-86,
1973
Hovda DA, Feeney DM: Haloperidol blocks the amphetamine
restoration of stereopsis in cats after visual cortex ablation. Proceedings of the Western Pharmacological Society 28: 209-211,
1985
Hovda DA, Sutton RL, Feeney DM: Amphetamine with experience restores depth perception after visual cortex ablation: measurements of thresholds and cerebral metabolism. Submitted for
publication
Davis JN, Crisostomo EA, Duncan PW, Propst M, Feeney DM:
Amphetamine and physical therapy facilitate recovery from
stroke: correlative animal and human studies. In Scheinberg (ed)
Cerebrovascular Diseases, Raven Press, (In Press), 1986
Porch B, Wyckes J, Feeney DM: Haloperidol thiazides and some
antihypertensives slow recovery from aphasia. Society for Neuroscience Abstracts 11, 52, 1985
Porch BE, Callaghan S: Predicting recovery from aphasia: Is there
hope? Clin Aphasiology Proceed BRK Pub. Minneapolis 181,
1981
Lendrem W, Lincoln NB: Spontaneous recovery of language in
patients with aphasia between 4 and 34 weeks after stroke. J
Neuro Neurosurg Psychiatry 48: 743-748, 1985
Brailowsky S, Knight RT, Efron R: Phenytoin increases the severity of cortical hemiplegia in rats. Brain Res (In Press), 1986