Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Menu
Home
>
Special Forum
Special Forum
July 31,2015
Special Forum
Share
Prev
List
Next
The Impact of South China Sea (SCS) Tensions on ASEAN: An Eye-of-the-Beholder Dilemma | The Asan Forum
ASEAN
failed for the frst time in its history to issue a joint
communiqu in 2012 due to disagreements on the SCS
the
SCSs disputes can be made if one evaluates the main
arguments about the purposes, challenges, and prospects
of ASEAN.
The Impact of South China Sea (SCS) Tensions on ASEAN: An Eye-of-the-Beholder Dilemma | The Asan Forum
least of
ASEANs community-building problems. If one thinks
ASEAN
does detract in a
to lowest
common denominator norms, incremental regionalism,
and pragmatism, ASEANs position on the SCS is
Goldilocks right. If one thinks ASEANs problems are
mostly internal cohesion and capacity and not external
relations, then SCS tensions are doubly problematic
because they create complications for both external
relations and cohesion and capacity.
http://www.theasanforum.org/the-impact-of-south-china-sea-scs-tensions-on-asean-an-eye-of-the-beholder-dilemma/#[12.12.2015 18:30:47]
The Impact of South China Sea (SCS) Tensions on ASEAN: An Eye-of-the-Beholder Dilemma | The Asan Forum
http://www.theasanforum.org/the-impact-of-south-china-sea-scs-tensions-on-asean-an-eye-of-the-beholder-dilemma/#[12.12.2015 18:30:47]
The Impact of South China Sea (SCS) Tensions on ASEAN: An Eye-of-the-Beholder Dilemma | The Asan Forum
He
characterizes these competencies as strengthening the
diplomatic voice of ASEAN countries, legitimizing the
and
constructing orders in the regions.3
His basic assessment
is that ASEAN is frst and foremost a tool for an
unfnished nation and state-building project in Southeast
regionalism as a
pragmatism as a diplomatic
virtue.5
The Impact of South China Sea (SCS) Tensions on ASEAN: An Eye-of-the-Beholder Dilemma | The Asan Forum
The Impact of South China Sea (SCS) Tensions on ASEAN: An Eye-of-the-Beholder Dilemma | The Asan Forum
salience of
SCS disputes in consideration of ASEANs future may
refect a savvy assessment of reality: only the United
http://www.theasanforum.org/the-impact-of-south-china-sea-scs-tensions-on-asean-an-eye-of-the-beholder-dilemma/#[12.12.2015 18:30:47]
The Impact of South China Sea (SCS) Tensions on ASEAN: An Eye-of-the-Beholder Dilemma | The Asan Forum
the SCS.
of 2015
despite plans to declare one. How then should ASEANs
handling of SCS disputes be viewed in the context of its
http://www.theasanforum.org/the-impact-of-south-china-sea-scs-tensions-on-asean-an-eye-of-the-beholder-dilemma/#[12.12.2015 18:30:47]
The Impact of South China Sea (SCS) Tensions on ASEAN: An Eye-of-the-Beholder Dilemma | The Asan Forum
centrality to ASEAN as an
organization. First, of the ten member countries, only four
(Brunei, Malaysia, Philippines and Vietnam) have claims
to features in the SCS. These four in turn have, to a lesser
or greater degree, overlapping claims with each other as
well as with Chinaand Taiwanthat have not been
resolved. Indonesias offcial position is that is not party
to a territorial dispute in the SCS, but experts question
that stance. SCS specialist Bill Hayton notes that the
government of Indonesias offcial position is that it does
not share a maritime boundary with China, but China
appears to think it does.14
At a minimum, fve ASEAN
members including Cambodia, land-locked Laos,
Myanmar, Thailand, and Singapore (six if one accepts
in freedom of
its total
http://www.theasanforum.org/the-impact-of-south-china-sea-scs-tensions-on-asean-an-eye-of-the-beholder-dilemma/#[12.12.2015 18:30:47]
The Impact of South China Sea (SCS) Tensions on ASEAN: An Eye-of-the-Beholder Dilemma | The Asan Forum
by China)before
the present ten-member ASEAN confguration. Vietnams
violent clashes with China on the SCS go back almost
four decades, long before it joined ASEAN in 1995.
The Impact of South China Sea (SCS) Tensions on ASEAN: An Eye-of-the-Beholder Dilemma | The Asan Forum
in
disputes with China; and the Philippines with Taiwan,
although diplomatic efforts have been underway to
resolve this bilateral dispute.
http://www.theasanforum.org/the-impact-of-south-china-sea-scs-tensions-on-asean-an-eye-of-the-beholder-dilemma/#[12.12.2015 18:30:47]
The Impact of South China Sea (SCS) Tensions on ASEAN: An Eye-of-the-Beholder Dilemma | The Asan Forum
ASEAN
claimant, the Republic of the Philippines, has had
signifcant tensions with China for two decades and has
had much more diffculty in managing bilateral ties with
China (and Taiwan) than Vietnam, Malaysia and Brunei
or even Japan and Taiwanall of whom are pursuing a
range of confdence-building and crisis-management
http://www.theasanforum.org/the-impact-of-south-china-sea-scs-tensions-on-asean-an-eye-of-the-beholder-dilemma/#[12.12.2015 18:30:47]
The Impact of South China Sea (SCS) Tensions on ASEAN: An Eye-of-the-Beholder Dilemma | The Asan Forum
The Impact of South China Sea (SCS) Tensions on ASEAN: An Eye-of-the-Beholder Dilemma | The Asan Forum
position, if not
unanimous, is getting more coherent and more explicit.
Fourth, a more diffcult metric of ASEAN coherence is
attitudes towards China in light of SCS tensions. With the
exception of Malaysia (Brunei was not polled), claimant
states do not view China favorably. Only 16 percent of
Vietnamese and 38 percent of Filipinos regard China
favorably in a 2014 poll; this rating would likely be even
The Impact of South China Sea (SCS) Tensions on ASEAN: An Eye-of-the-Beholder Dilemma | The Asan Forum
http://www.theasanforum.org/the-impact-of-south-china-sea-scs-tensions-on-asean-an-eye-of-the-beholder-dilemma/#[12.12.2015 18:30:47]
The Impact of South China Sea (SCS) Tensions on ASEAN: An Eye-of-the-Beholder Dilemma | The Asan Forum
Conclusion
among
member states in certain areas, enhancing security of
member countries, and constructing orders in the region.
In this vision,
The Impact of South China Sea (SCS) Tensions on ASEAN: An Eye-of-the-Beholder Dilemma | The Asan Forum
If one privileges ASEANs nationalist project and a midpath commitment to regionalism, norms and pragmatism
as does Chong, ASEAN has
The Impact of South China Sea (SCS) Tensions on ASEAN: An Eye-of-the-Beholder Dilemma | The Asan Forum
already
sketchy, of ASEAN itself.
Thailand and
Malaysia, and increased diversity of regime types with
the
http://www.theasanforum.org/the-impact-of-south-china-sea-scs-tensions-on-asean-an-eye-of-the-beholder-dilemma/#[12.12.2015 18:30:47]
The Impact of South China Sea (SCS) Tensions on ASEAN: An Eye-of-the-Beholder Dilemma | The Asan Forum
big money. 26
The Impact of South China Sea (SCS) Tensions on ASEAN: An Eye-of-the-Beholder Dilemma | The Asan Forum
1.
The views expressed here are entirely personal. Satu Limaye gratefully
acknowledges the research assistance of Neil Datar and Clarence Cabanero.
2.
Barry Desker, ASEAN Integration Remains an Illusion, PacNet, no. 17,
Center for Strategic and International Studies, March 16, 2015,
http://csis.org/publication/pacnet-17-asean-integration-remains-illusion.
3.
Muthiah Alagappa, Community Building: ASEANs Millstone?
PacNet, no. 18, Center for Strategic and International
http://www.theasanforum.org/the-impact-of-south-china-sea-scs-tensions-on-asean-an-eye-of-the-beholder-dilemma/#[12.12.2015 18:30:47]
The Impact of South China Sea (SCS) Tensions on ASEAN: An Eye-of-the-Beholder Dilemma | The Asan Forum
4.
Alan Chong, The State of Regional Community in the Southeast Asian
Region: Community Hemmed in between Politics of Nationalism, ASEAN
Norms and Pragmatism, http://www.jpi.or.kr/eng/regular/print_ok.sky?
id=5273.
5. Ibid.
7. Ibid.
12. Ibid.
13. Michael Auslin, The Rohingyan Crisis and ASEAN Disunity, The
Wall Street Journal , May 27, 2015, http://www.wsj.com/articles/therohingyan-crisis-and-asean-disunity-1432740154.
http://www.theasanforum.org/the-impact-of-south-china-sea-scs-tensions-on-asean-an-eye-of-the-beholder-dilemma/#[12.12.2015 18:30:47]
The Impact of South China Sea (SCS) Tensions on ASEAN: An Eye-of-the-Beholder Dilemma | The Asan Forum
14.See Bill Hayton, Inside Chinas Historic Claim to the South China
Sea, Strategic Review, July-September 2015, http://sr-indonesia.com/inthe-journal/view/inside-china-s-historic-claim-in-the-south-china-sea.
15.The author thanks Professor Pek Koon Heng for this point.
16.Michael
17.Our
the
26th ASEAN Summit, Kuala Lumpur and Langkawi, April 27, 2015,
http://www.asean.org/images/2015/april/26th_asean_summit/Chairman%
20Statement%2026th%20ASEAN%20Summit_fnal.pdf
21.Moeldoko,
22.http://www.aiibank.org/html/pagemembers/.
http://www.theasanforum.org/the-impact-of-south-china-sea-scs-tensions-on-asean-an-eye-of-the-beholder-dilemma/#[12.12.2015 18:30:47]
The Impact of South China Sea (SCS) Tensions on ASEAN: An Eye-of-the-Beholder Dilemma | The Asan Forum
23.See Sharon Chen, U.S. Navy Urges Southeast Asian Patrols of South
China Sea, Bloomberg Business, March 17, 2015,
http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2015-03-18/u-s-navy-urgesjoint-southeast-asia-patrols-of-south-china-sea. In the same article, leading
analysts assessed the prospects as very low given technical, let alone
political, problems.
27.A
Of course, this is by no
means suggesting that they must stay away from
Post Views: 1,422
Tag
ASEAN unity
Regionalism
South China Sea
http://www.theasanforum.org/the-impact-of-south-china-sea-scs-tensions-on-asean-an-eye-of-the-beholder-dilemma/#[12.12.2015 18:30:47]
The Impact of South China Sea (SCS) Tensions on ASEAN: An Eye-of-the-Beholder Dilemma | The Asan Forum
Prev
List
Next
Related Posts
Dec 07,2015
Open Forum
Alternative Scenarios
Alternative Scenarios
Search
Search
Archive
Select the archive
Contributor
Select the contributor
Latest
Sunflowers and Umbrellas: Government Responses to St..
Syaru Shirley Lin
http://www.theasanforum.org/the-impact-of-south-china-sea-scs-tensions-on-asean-an-eye-of-the-beholder-dilemma/#[12.12.2015 18:30:47]
The Impact of South China Sea (SCS) Tensions on ASEAN: An Eye-of-the-Beholder Dilemma | The Asan Forum
Editorial Staf
Tags
effusive receptions
2+2 Meetings
ROK-US Alliance
Multiplexity
ASAN ACADEMY
RSS
http://www.theasanforum.org/the-impact-of-south-china-sea-scs-tensions-on-asean-an-eye-of-the-beholder-dilemma/#[12.12.2015 18:30:47]