Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Date Adopted
2014-XX-XX
Effective Date
2014-XX-XX
galement disponible en franais sous le titre: Classification des produits la frontire entre
les aliments et les produits de sant naturels Produits sous forme daliment
Health Canada
Guidance Document: Classification of Products at the FoodNatural Health Products Interface: Products in Food Formats
FOREWORD
Guidance documents are meant to provide assistance to industry and health care professionals on
how to comply with governing statutes and regulations. Guidance documents also provide
assistance to staff on how Health Canada mandates and objectives should be implemented in a
manner that is fair, consistent and effective.
Guidance documents are administrative instruments not having force of law and, as such, allow
for flexibility in approach. Alternate approaches to the principles and practices described in this
document may be acceptable provided they are supported by adequate justification. Alternate
approaches should be discussed in advance with the relevant program area to avoid the possible
finding that applicable statutory or regulatory requirements have not been met.
As a corollary to the above, it is equally important to note that Health Canada reserves the right
to request additional information or material, or define conditions not specifically described in
this document, in order to allow the Department to adequately assess the safety, efficacy or
quality of a therapeutic product. Health Canada is committed to ensuring that such requests are
justifiable and that decisions are clearly documented.
This document should be read in conjunction with the accompanying notice and the relevant
sections of other applicable guidance documents.
Health Canada
Guidance Document: Classification of Products at the FoodNatural Health Products Interface: Products in Food Formats
TABLE OF CONTENTS
1.
INTRODUCTION ................................................................................................................. 3
2.
INTERPRETATION ............................................................................................................. 4
3.
SCOPE .................................................................................................................................... 5
4.
5.
ii
Health Canada
1.
Guidance Document: Classification of Products at the FoodNatural Health Products Interface: Products in Food Formats
INTRODUCTION
In Canada, natural health products and foods are regulated under the Food and Drugs Act (FDA)
and its associated regulations. Products that meet the definition of a natural health product
(NHP) as set out in the Natural Health Products Regulations (NHPR) are subject to the FDA as
it applies to drugs and to the NHPR. Products that are foods as defined in the FDA are subject to
the FDA as it applies to foods and to Parts A, B and D of the Food and Drug Regulations (FDR).
It is important to note that the provisions of the FDR do not apply to products classified as NHPs
except where such provisions are incorporated by reference into the NHPR, as per section 3 of
the NHPR.
Since the implementation of the NHPR on January 1, 2004, Health Canada has received several
hundred Product Licence Applications for products in food formats. Examples include energy
drinks, vitamin or mineral supplements in confectionery formats, and juices and waters with
added vitamins and minerals. Health Canada indicated its intent to resolve the confusion around
foods that are marketed as NHPs, and began working with manufacturers in May 2010 to safely
transition food products marketed as NHPs to the food regulatory framework. As a first step,
Health Canada announced in October 2011 its intent to transition caffeinated energy drinks to the
food regulatory framework. Additional categories of foods that were marketed as NHPs began
transitioning in April 2012, and the transition was completed in December 2012. The goal of the
transition process was to ensure that products that look like foods and are consumed as foods are
regulated as foods. In doing so, Canadians should be able to make more informed choices due to
consistent nutrition information and labelling requirements. For the food industry, this transition
levels the playing field, reduces red tape and continues to help support innovation.
This guidance document outlines the principles and considerations to be applied in determining
if a product in a food format is an NHP or a food1. It has been created and published with a view
to achieving greater consistency, transparency and quality of classification decisions relating to
products in food format. It is intended to be used in conjunction with other existing guidance
documents and policies2.
It should be noted that classification is completed on a category basis (See Appendix 1) and/or a case-by-case basis
taking account of the available facts relevant to whether a product meets the definition natural health product as
set out in the Natural Health Products Regulations or the definition food as set out in the Food and Drug
Regulations.
2
The criteria described in this document do not enable a determination of whether a product meets all the
requirements of the relevant legislation. It is the responsibility of the manufacturer of a product to ensure that it
complies with all the relevant requirements, legislation and associated regulations.
Page 3 of 15
Health Canada
2.
Guidance Document: Classification of Products at the FoodNatural Health Products Interface: Products in Food Formats
INTERPRETATION
The following definitions are provided to assist in the interpretation of this guidance document:
food (Section 2 of the FDA) means any article manufactured, sold or represented for use as a
food or drink for human beings, including chewing gum, and any ingredients that may be mixed
with food for any purpose whatever.
food-NHP interface product means any product that is in a food format and meets the scope
of this document as outlined in Section 3 below.
natural health product (Sections 1 and 2(2) of the NHPR) means a substance set out in
Schedule 13 of the NHPR or a combination of substances in which all the medicinal ingredients
are substances set out in Schedule 1, a homeopathic medicine or a traditional medicine, that is
manufactured, sold or represented for use in
(a) the diagnosis, treatment, mitigation or prevention of a disease, disorder or abnormal
physical state or its symptoms in humans;
(b) restoring or correcting organic functions in humans; or
(c) modifying organic functions in humans, such as modifying those functions in a manner
that maintains or promotes health.
However, a natural health product does not include a substance set out in Schedule 24, any
combination of substances that includes a substance set out in Schedule 2 or a homeopathic
medicine or a traditional medicine that is or includes a substance set out in Schedule 2. For the
purposes of these Regulations, a substance or combination of substances or a traditional
medicine is not considered to be a natural health product if its sale, under the FDR, is required to
Substances listed in Schedule 1 to the NHPR (Included Natural Health Product Substances) are:
1. A plant or a plant material, an alga, a bacterium, a fungus or a non-human animal material
2. An extract or isolate of a substance described in item 1, the primary molecular structure of which is
identical to that which it had prior to its extraction or isolation
3. Any of the following vitamins: biotin, folate, niacin, pantothenic acid, riboflavin, thiamine, vitamin A,
vitamin B6, vitamin B12, vitamin C, vitamin D, vitamin E, vitamin K1, vitamin K2
4. An amino acid
5. An essential fatty acid
6. A synthetic duplicate of a substance described in any of items 2 to 5
7. A mineral
8. A probiotic
4
Substances listed in Schedule 2 to the NHPR (Excluded Natural Health Product Substances) are:
1. A substance set out in Schedule C to the Act
2. A substance set out in Schedule D to the Act, except for the following:
(a) a drug that is prepared from any of the following micro-organisms, namely, an alga, a bacterium or a
fungus; and
(b) any substance set out on Schedule D when it is prepared in accordance with the practices of
homeopathic pharmacy
3. A substance regulated under the Tobacco Act
4. A substance set out in any of Schedules I to V of the Controlled Drugs and Substances Act
5. A substance that is administered by puncturing the dermis
6. An antibiotic prepared from an alga, a bacterium or a fungus or a synthetic duplicate of that antibiotic
Page 4 of 15
Health Canada
Guidance Document: Classification of Products at the FoodNatural Health Products Interface: Products in Food Formats
be pursuant to a prescription when it is sold other than in accordance with section C.01.043 of
those Regulations.
For the purposes of this guidance document, a product is in food format if it is sold in a
format consistent with food use. Examples of products in a food format include chewing gums,
hard candies, candy bars, juices and beverages. Capsules and pills are not considered to be food
formats.
For the purposes of this guidance document, therapeutic use means a product that is used for
the diagnosis, treatment, mitigation or prevention of a disease, disorder or abnormal physical
state or its symptoms in humans, or restoring or correcting organic function in humans, or
modifying organic functions in humans.
For the purposes of this guidance document, food purpose means a purpose that has been
established by history of use, or by being regulated, defined or implied by the FDR, or that has
been accepted following a novel food notification.
3.
SCOPE
This guidance document pertains to a product that is in a food format and that:
contains a substance listed in Schedule 1 to the NHPR at a level that is not permitted for
use in a food under the food provisions of the FDR; or
makes a claim for a therapeutic use that is not permitted to be made for a food under the
food provisions of the FDR.
4.
The following principles guide classification decisions to determine if a product in food format is
an NHP or a food:
1. The definition food in the FDA and natural health product in the NHPR must be
interpreted in a manner that respects the primary objectives of the Act and its associated
regulations: the protection of public health and safety.5
2. While potential health risks alone do not classify a product as either a food or an NHP, risk
can be taken into account in interpreting definitions and applying appropriate regulatory
frameworks that best achieve objectives relating to health protection. Additional steps may
be required to mitigate potential health risks following a classification decision. For example,
if a liquid product is classified as a NHP, the product would need to be packaged
appropriately and potentially include a measuring device to ensure that it is not perceived as
a beverage or food. Ingredients in NHPs are safe when consumed according to the
recommended conditions of use. However, if a liquid product is erroneously perceived as a
5
Consistent with the objectives of Health Canada and the applicable regulatory frameworks.
Page 5 of 15
Health Canada
Guidance Document: Classification of Products at the FoodNatural Health Products Interface: Products in Food Formats
food, the product may be consumed ad libitum rather than according to the recommended
conditions of use which could present a safety risk.
In deciding whether a product in food format is an NHP or a food, the following criteria will be
taken into account:
Product composition;
Product representation;
Product format; and
Public perception and history of use.
Page 6 of 15
Health Canada
Guidance Document: Classification of Products at the FoodNatural Health Products Interface: Products in Food Formats
For example, claims for therapeutic uses of a product outside the context of a diet, directions of
use and risk information on the labelling, the inclusion of a measuring device or placement of
sale among other NHPs suggest that a product is being manufactured, sold or represented for use
as an NHP. However, the presence of a health claim is not necessarily sufficient on its own to
result in the classification of a product as an NHP based on the other characteristics of the
product, Health Canada may interpret it as either an approved or unapproved health claim for a
food. For further details, see Appendix 1.
4.3 Product Format
Products in conventional food formats, as well as pre-packaged, ready-to-consume drink
products (see Appendix 1 for examples), are commonly consumed ad libitum, which is
consistent with foods. Products in these formats are generally regarded as foods, as part of the
regular diet, with the intent to provide nourishment, nutrition, hydration, satisfaction of
hunger/thirst or desire for taste, texture or flavour. Therefore, product format is a primary factor
in determining classification for these particular product categories.
NHPs are typically sold in a format that allows them to be consumed in measured or controlled
amounts (doses). If a product is sold in a particular food format (for example, a beverage) that
lends itself to dosing (for example, if it is sold with a measure that indicates it to be consumed in
controlled amounts) this is one indication that the product may be an NHP as defined in the
NHPR.
4.4 Public Perception and History of Use
If a product has a historical pattern of use as a food or if the public perceives the use of a product
in the marketplace as a food, these are indications that a product is a food rather than an NHP.
Conversely, if the public perception associated with a product and its history and pattern of use
indicate it is sold for a therapeutic purpose outside the context of a diet, this is one indication that
the product is an NHP.
Page 7 of 15
Health Canada
5.
Guidance Document: Classification of Products at the FoodNatural Health Products Interface: Products in Food Formats
Classification decisions are used to administer, monitor compliance with, and enforce the FDA
and its regulations; and in particular the NHPR and Parts A, B and D of the FDR. A
classification decision, however, is not a determination of whether a product meets all the
requirements of the relevant legislation. It is the responsibility of the manufacturer of a product
to ensure that it complies with all the relevant requirements, legislation and associated
regulations.
The criteria outlined in this guidance document are used by Health Canada to determine if a
product in food format is an NHP or a food. Other information that may be useful in arriving at
the appropriate classification will also be considered; for example, classification decisions of
other regulatory bodies.7
Representatives from both the Food Directorate and Natural Health Products Directorate with
expertise in the science underlying their respective product lines are involved in the classification
decision-making process.
For further information regarding the classification of products at the food-NHP interface, please
contact the Food Directorate at SMIU-UGDI@hc-sc.gc.ca or the Natural Health Products
Directorate at pla.info.dlmm@hc-sc.gc.ca.
Health Canada recognizes the global nature of trade in these products. Decisions of other regulatory bodies would
be interpreted to take account of the difference in legal systems, legislation and policies.
Page 8 of 15
Health Canada
Guidance Document: Classification of Products at the FoodNatural Health Products Interface: Products in Food Formats
Products classified as NHPs include those packaged in formats 90 mL or less, and to be consumed in a single dose
(not to be reconstituted as a beverage), or those packaged in formats greater than 90 mL and less than 125 mL
represented as shots and that do not meet the Pre-packaged, ready-to-consume drink products classification criteria.
Products classified as foods include those packaged in formats greater than 90 mL and less than 125 mL that meet
our Pre-packaged, ready-to-consume drink products classification criteria or products packaged in a format 125 mL
or greater that are represented as foods.
9
For information regarding pre-packaged, ready-to-consume energy drink products, please consult the Category
Specific Guidance for Temporary Marketing Authorization Caffeinated Energy Drinks, available on our website at
(http://www.hc-sc.gc.ca/fn-an/legislation/guide-ld/guidance-caf-drink-boiss-tma-amt-eng.php).
Page 9 of 15
Health Canada
Guidance Document: Classification of Products at the FoodNatural Health Products Interface: Products in Food Formats
Health Canada
Guidance Document: Classification of Products at the FoodNatural Health Products Interface: Products in Food Formats
Health Canada
Guidance Document: Classification of Products at the FoodNatural Health Products Interface: Products in Food Formats
Page 12 of 15
Health Canada
Guidance Document: Classification of Products at the FoodNatural Health Products Interface: Products in Food Formats
3.1 Granulated and Powdered Products and Other Formats - Beverage Mix Products:
The Department has determined that beverage mix products sold in formats including, but not
limited to, granules, powder, syrup or gels, and which are intended to be reconstituted for
consumption as a beverage and which embody the following criteria, fit the definition of a food
and will therefore be classified as foods:
Product format10: Since beverage products in granulated, powder, syrup or gel formats
are consistent with classification both as foods and as NHPs, format is not a primary
factor for classification. Characteristics of format which are supportive of a classification
as food include, but are not limited to: resealable packaging, sachets, pouches,
sticks/tubes or any other formats that are consistent with the ad libitum consumption as
foods.
Public perception and history of use: It is Health Canadas position that Canadians
perceive and consume beverage mix products as foods. Consumers perceive these
products as foods rather than as NHPs because they are expected to provide nourishment,
nutrition, hydration, satisfaction of hunger/thirst, or desire for taste, texture or flavour
regardless of any associated health claim. Beverage mixes have a long history of being
consumed as foods. This history of consumption, regardless of any specific directions of
use, promotes the public perception that these products can be consumed ad libitum.
Product representation to consumers: Representation is considered a primary factor for
product classification decisions for this category. Representation includes indications
of use, claims presented as a word, sentence, a picture, a symbol, a paragraph or an
implication on product labels, package inserts or advertisement, placement and location
of sale. Beverage mix products that use terms such as, but not limited to, meal
replacement, food, energy, energy drink, snack, drink/drink mix, beverage,
cocktail/cocktail mix, juice/juice mix; feature flavour prominently on the label; or are
marketed in retail establishments among conventional foods are typically represented to
consumers as foods. These products are normally regarded as foods, as part of the regular
diet and/or as part of a specialized diet (for example, weight reduction diet by means of
caloric reduction), with the intent to provide nourishment, nutrition, hydration,
satisfaction of hunger/thirst, or desire for taste, texture or flavour. The presence of a
health claim is not always a distinguishing factor for classification; however, the
products specific or implied representation for a health benefit within the context of the
diet supports classification of the product as a food.
Product composition: All ingredients contained in a beverage mix product should be
considered when making a product classification decision; however, composition is not a
primary factor for product classification decisions. Beverage mixes may contain
ingredients such as, but not limited to, caffeine, sweetening agents, fruit/vegetable
concentrates, vitamins, minerals and amino acids.
10
Products classified as foods include those packaged in formats of any size that are to be reconstituted for
consumption as a beverage and meet the Beverage mix classification criteria.
Page 13 of 15
Health Canada
Guidance Document: Classification of Products at the FoodNatural Health Products Interface: Products in Food Formats
3.2 Granulated and Powdered Products and Other Formats - Natural Health Products in
Powder, Granulated or Gel Formats:
The Department has determined that products in powder, granulated or gel formats which are not
represented as a beverage as defined in the Granulated and Powdered Products and Other
Formats - Beverage Mix Products document and are not conventional foods, which embody the
following criteria, fit the definition of an NHP and will therefore be classified as NHPs:
Product format: Since granulated, powder and gel formats are consistent with
classification both as foods and as NHPs, format is not a primary factor for classification.
Characteristics of format which are supportive of a classification as NHPs include, but
are not limited to security features, and packaging that includes measuring devices.
Public perception and history of use: It is Health Canadas position that Canadians
perceive and consume certain powdered, granulated or gel products as NHPs instead of
foods because they have not been typically sold amongst conventional foods in retail
establishments. These products are typically marketed under specific conditions of use,
for example, to a specific sub-population, for a specific purpose and with specific
directions of use. Although these products may be a source of macronutrients and may
provide nourishment, nutrition, hydration, satisfaction of hunger, thirst, or desire for
taste, texture or flavour, the history of consumption suggests that these products are used
as supplements to the diet, and that consumers recognize that these products are not
consumed in an ad libitum manner, but according to the recommended conditions of use.
Product representation to consumers: Representation is considered a primary factor for
product classification decisions for this category. Representation includes indications
of use, claims presented as a word, sentence, a picture, a symbol, a paragraph or an
implication on product labels, package inserts or advertisement, placement and location
of sale. Powdered, granulated or gel products that use terms such as, but not limited to,
multi-vitamin, multi-mineral, detox, resistance training, muscle gains, muscle
building, mass building, muscle recovery and increased protein synthesis, that
include pictures that depict the above terms, and are marketed in retail establishments
among other supplements to specific sub-populations, are typically represented to
consumers as NHPs. The presence of a health claim is not always a distinguishing factor
for classification; however, the products specific or implied representation for a health
benefit outside the context of the diet (for example, supplemental to the diet) supports
classification of the product as an NHP.
Product composition: All ingredients contained in a powdered, granulated or gel
product should be considered when making a product classification decision; however,
composition is not an important factor for classification decisions for this category. These
types of products may contain ingredients such as, but not limited to, vitamins and
minerals, protein or protein isolates (for example, whey, soy, rice proteins), amino acids,
carbohydrates, fatty acids, herbs, fibre, caffeine and other stimulants, sweetening agents,
fruit/vegetable concentrates or extracts.
Page 14 of 15
Health Canada
Guidance Document: Classification of Products at the FoodNatural Health Products Interface: Products in Food Formats
4.0 Tea Products and Herbal Tea Products at the Food-NHP Interface:
Canadians tend to perceive and consume many types of teas as beverages, as they are expected to
provide nourishment, nutrition, hydration, satisfaction of hunger/thirst, or desire for taste, texture
or flavour irrespective of any associated health claim. Teas have a long history of being
consumed as foods, which promotes consumer perception that they can be consumed ad libitum.
If a tea product is not intended for sale as a food in Canada, the product may be considered an
NHP subject to the NHPR. Herbal medicinal teas are a well-established product category subject
to the NHPR. Companies are encouraged to represent such products in a manner consistent with
other NHPs, and to distinguish them from food products through appropriate labelling,
packaging, product positioning and advertising at the point of sale. For general information
regarding the regulation of NHPs in Canada, please refer to the following web pages:
Health Canada information regarding product licensing requirements for NHPs
Health Canada information regarding site licensing requirements for NHPs
If a tea product is intended to be represented for sale as a food in Canada, the product claims
must meet the requirements summarized in the reference material listed below. If the product
claim has not already been assessed by Health Canadas Food Directorate, guidance is provided
among the web pages below for health claim submissions. The manufacturer is responsible for
ensuring that the tea product is in compliance with Sections 4 and 5 of the FDA.
Canadian Food Inspection Agency - Food Labelling and Advertising
Canadian Food Inspection Agency - Guide to Food Labelling and Advertising
Health Canada Health Claims
Health Canada Health Claim Assessments
Health Canada Guidance Documents for Preparing Health Claim Submissions
Page 15 of 15