You are on page 1of 4

CATs Helps Frogs By Pinpointing Pesticides Spring 2006

Capping a five-year-long effort, this research, the agency balked, trigger- Founded in 1982, Californians Summer
CATs is debuting a database of interna- ing several years of intense effort by for Alternatives to Toxics is a
2006
tional research detailing the most recent CATs that’s led to greater citizen input clearinghouse for information
and strategic action regarding
findings about the effects of pesticide to DPR’s registration process.
pesticides and other hazardous
use on amphibians and reptiles. The CATs was a major player in a suit chemicals and to promote
research comes from all over the world, that won increased protection from alternatives to their use. CATs
but particularly includes critical in-the- pesticides for the red-legged frog--the works to bring solutions to
field studies from California that are frog made famous by Mark Twain. toxic conditions occurring in
northern California, with
State Forced To Assess All Its Pesticide Programs
meshed with findings from the unique Again using the state's pesticide-use
actions that benefit people here
pesticide-use database database, CATs CATs won a precedent-setting victory in found in the new EIR analysis, the state will
and around the world. “The history of life on Earth
of the Department of mapped where frog state court that’s likely to affect all Califor- be required to change its control methods to
has been a history
Pesticide Regulation populations were Permission is granted to nia programs aimed at chemically eradicat- avoid harm.
of interaction
(DPR). threatened by the toxic reproduce this newsletter if ing a wide range of harmful pests. The decision was a defeat for the
Californians for Alternatives to
between living things
California is one sprays--and identified In a clearly worded opinion, an appeals powerful wine industry, which pressured
Toxics is fully credited. No part and their surroundings.”
of the "hot spots" in 66 pesticides that the court unanimously rejected the state’s plan agricultural agencies to begin intense
may be copied to websites; - Rachel Carson
the global decline of court later agreed the links to the CATs website are to contain the vine-destroying insect known emergency spraying when the sharpshooter
amphibian populations, EPA must study under encouraged. as the glassy-winged sharpshooter. The was discovered in 2000.
and native aquatic frog provisions of the decision effectively requires all agencies to Roadsides and residential areas were
and toad species have Endangered Species CATs is a not-for-profit, analyze the effects of the targeted along with plant nurseries and
been disappearing for Act. 501(c)(3) organization. pesticides they use in orchards. But now, five years after neighbor-
Donations are tax-deductible to
two decades. Central CATs’ database, control programs. hoods and malls in several towns have been
the extent allowed by law.
and southern California felt it first, but compiled by a biologist whose frog The ruling came just as drenched with powerful chemicals normally
the decline of frogs has come north--and research has taken him as far afield as the state Department of used in intensive agriculture, the DFA and
pesticide use has increasingly emerged West Africa, builds on an earlier one Food and Agriculture the public remain in the dark about possible
as one of the greatest threats to frog covering literature up to 1998 put (DFA) is embarking on a harmful effects.
survival. together by the Canadian Wildlife broad Environmental The court decision also has implications
For example, research by the U.S. Service. Impact Report (EIR) on for other state agencies. The California
Geological Survey since 1997 has Now CATs has attempted to bring control of a spectrum of Department of Forestry, for example, is
revealed dangerous levels of pesticides all the updated research into an easily agricultural pests— trying to revive its plan to “manage”
in both the bodies of frogs and in their accessible database. We have compiled a everything from beetles to vegetation to reduce fire risk around the
aquatic habitat in pristine areas of the list of 225 scientific papers published weeds—spreading state—a plan previously defeated in court by
Sierra Nevada. Entire populations of since 1999 on the effects of pesticides Photo: throughout the state. CATs and the Environmental Protection
native frogs have vanished, and research on amphibians, as well as 87 research CATs member Paul Frey (pictured
The three-judge panel said DFA had Information Center because of a faulty EIR.
315 P Street in his vinyard earlier this year)
has pinpointed pesticide sprays that have papers on pesticides' impacts on reptiles. described to the court how state failed to fully consider the environmental CATs was joined in its sharpshooter suit
Eureka, CA
drifted hundreds of miles from the Central Most have links to summaries or full pesticide programs, like that for effects of its glassy-winged sharpshooter by the Napa County citizens group People
Valley to settle in wilderness areas. texts of the papers. Links to lists of the glassy-winged sharpshooter, program, and that “this error infected the Opposed to Insecticide Spraying On Neigh-
But when CATs asked the DPR to books and to sites with related informa- impact organic farmers.
analysis of the impact from exposure to borhoods and the national organization
re-evaluate the danger to frogs based on tion are also available. Printed on 100% recycled, 100% pesticides on people in nonagricultural Public Employees for Environmental
post-consumer waste paper. areas.” Responsibility.
The court singled out people “suscep-
tible to health complications” as well as
NON-PROFIT ORG agricultural and nursery workers—and
U.S. POSTAGE PAID referred specifically to spraying in or near Inside
EUREKA, CA schools, parks, hospitals, nursing homes,
PERMIT NO. 318 organic farms and even wildlife. • Humboldt Tops in
CATs’ central argument—that DFA had Forest Herbicide Use
315 P Street Eureka, CA 95501
improperly deferred to the pesticide-
• Wilderness Creek
registration process rather than analyzing
“Execution” Stopped
the actual consequences of using pesticides
against the sharpshooter—was upheld by • The Low-down on
Return Service Requested
the court. “Roundup”
What this means is that DFA must
rewrite its EIR, and this time must include • Pesticides a Factor in
Photo: CATs
See member
page 5Josh assessments of area-wide pesticide use so Frog Woes
Strange inspects a healthy adult
chinook salmon during research that the potential for cumulative impacts is
at the mouth of the Klamath taken into account. If significant effects are
River.

Californians for Alternatives to Toxics 315 P Street, Eureka, CA 95501 (707) 445-5100 www.alternatives2toxics.org
Humboldt’s Dubious Distinction Toxicological Profile for Glyphosate
A new report from CATs shows tons “Humboldt County Tops in Forest Glyphosate is the active ingredient of pending on soil conditions. In aquatic
more herbicides were sprayed on Humboldt Timber Land Spraying” can be read or the herbicide best known commercially as environments, half may remain toxic for
County forests in 2004 than in any other downloaded from the CATs website or may “Roundup.” It is a non-selective, systemic several weeks to several months.
California county, according to data from be obtained by contacting the CATs office. herbicide for controlling weeds in agricul- Risk to Non-Target Flora & Fauna:
the Department of Pesticide Regulation. ture, forestry, rights-of-way and aquatic Because of drift and offsite movement from
More than 29 tons of potent pesticide systems. Glyphosate disrupts plant growth wind and rain, glyphosate poses a consider-
chemicals coated the forests, the report About Glyphosate and eventually causes death by inhibiting able risk to non-target plant and animal
reveals. That’s nearly six tons more than any synthesis of amino acids. Isopropylamine species. A significant amount of glyphosate
other county. When Monsansto's patent for salt is the most frequently used form of spray applications drift off-site (from 14% to
Unlike other counties, where public glyphosate expired in 2000, glyphosate. 78%), affecting plants 130 feet away, and
forests are also sprayed, only privately many companies entered the Human Health Risk Summary residues have been detected up to 1,300 feet
owned timberlands get doused in Humboldt. market as formulators of Acute Effects: Some formulations of downwind.
Although the total might seem stagger- herbicides containing the glyphosate cause extreme irritation of the Glyphosate has been shown to disrupt
ing, it actually was less than the five-year chemical. Today, 206 skin and eyes, such as blurred vision, the immune systems and cause genetic
average chalked up by Humboldt timber glyphosate products are burning eyes, rashes and skin blisters. Other abnormalities in fish. Similarly, it causes
companies: almost 55,000 pounds annually. registered in California, some symptoms reported following acute expo- genetic, developmental and reproductive
Green Diamond, formerly known as as well-known as "Roundup." sures include: nausea, sore throat, dizziness, mutations in amphibians.
Simpson, applied the most—an average of Other products are sold in gastrointestinal and respiratory tract injuries. The balance of soil organisms is dis-
38,758 pounds a year. Maxxam’s Pacific generic packaging in the Chronic Effects: Carcinogenicity: rupted by glyphosate, which leaches from the
Lumber came in second, at an average of garden section of many stores. Though evidence that glyphosate causes roots of sprayed plants into the surrounding
16,507 pounds annually, followed by Sierra cancer is yet to be established, several soil. Several studies have indicated that
Pacific and Barnum with an average of Widely considered the #1 animal and human population studies have pathogenic fungi and other crop pests increase
2,774 pounds and 2,564 pounds per year. most often used herbicide indicated that it may increase the risk of in numbers or have less competition when
That’s tons of toxics, with names like worldwide, glyphosate is also non-Hodgkin’s lymphoma, multiple my- glyphosate is present in soil.
triclopyr, atrazine, 2,4-D, glyphosate and, first in California, where eloma, pancreatic, thyroid and testicular Toxicity of Other Ingredients
more recently, imazapyr. agricultural and commercial cancers. Commercial products such as Roundup
They were applied to watersheds all uses were reported to be Reproductive & Developmental Toxicity: are composed of the active ingredient
over the county. Getting the most were 6,364,365 pounds of the Glyphosate exposure has been associated (approximately 40% of the solution) and
Redwood Creek, Maple Creek, Little River, active ingredient in 2004. with several manifestations of reproductive other ingredients that improve its effective-
Mad River, Freshwater Creek and Eel River. and developmental impairment. In animal ness. These compounds exhibit toxicity at
In human terms, that means communities studies, high dose or prolonged exposures much higher levels than glyphosate alone.
such as Fieldbrook, Blue Lake, Kneeland, have resulted in skeletal malformations, One such chemical, polyethoxylated
Carlotta, Scotia and Redcrest were close to disrupted organ development, and reduced tallowamine (POEA), is three times as
the spray sites—especially in the spring and sperm volume and quality. In human acutely toxic to humans as glyphosate alone.
fall, when most of the tonnage is unleashed. population studies, exposure to glyphosate A product commonly mixed with
And those at greatest risk from exposure has been connected to an increased rate of glyphosate formulations to improve perfor-
include the chemically sensitive, pregnant miscarriage, reduction in sex hormone mance in the environment was found to be
women and their fetuses, infants, the elderly, production, and disruptions to endocrine 100 times more toxic to aquatic inverte-
native plant gatherers—and those workers References system development. brates. Other added ingredients have been
applying the poisons themselves. Mutagenicity: Several studies on both shown to damage cellular DNA, cause
Humans aren’t the only ones suffering For a full list of citations to animals and humans have suggested that cancer or birth defects, and disrupt repro-
from often-wanton use of chemical poisons. the Toxicological Profile for exposure to glyphosate can cause chromo- ductive function in both humans and animals.
Recent research on amphibian populations, Glyphosate, see: somal aberrations, DNA breaks, and other Summary
which are in decline worldwide, has shown www.alternatives2toxics.org genetic mutations. Glyphosate and commercially available
that they are vulnerable to atrazine, triclopyr Ecological Hazard Summary products containing this compound are of
and glyphosate products. Environmental Fate: Glyphosate has particular concern to human health and the
Similarly, some of the most used Top 5 Forestry Herbicides, Humboldt County 2001-05 frequently been detected in surface water environment, due to: 1) some evidence of
herbicides—triclopyr, 2-4D and glyphosate 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005
nation-wide. It tends to bond strongly to soil carcinogenicity, reproductive/developmental
products—are toxic to salmon and other fish, Toxicological Profile by Center for particles and therefore may be displaced to toxicity, endocrine system and genetic
Triclopyr 28,019 14,761 17,799 15,806 9,406 Ethics and Toxics (CETOS) with
even though their local populations have surface water from movement of soil by toxicity to humans; 2) potential adverse
2,4-D 4,157 5,567 7,190 7,396 5,372 Californians for Alternatives to Toxics.
been drastically reduced from historic levels. wind, erosion, or storm runoff. Drift follow- effects to non-target plant and animal
Glyphosate 5,821 6,054 6,281 6,291 3,343
As if those pernicious effects were not ing aerial applications also contributes to the species due to overspray, drift, and displace-
Atrazine 6,650 23,668 11,034 10,267 3,855
enough, studies show that herbicides also presence of glyphosate in water. ment; and 3) the potentially severe impact of
Imazapyr 738 858 2,484 4,642 9,846
may be creating conditions more hospitable Glyphosate is moderately to highly many of its additives such as POEA, which
Total: 45,385 50,908 44,788 44,402 31,822
to the invasive species that are crowding out persistent, with half remaining toxic in soil have been identified as extremely hazardous
Source: 2005, Humboldt Co Agricultural Commissioner; 2001-04, CA Dept of Pesticide Regulation
native plants and animals. from 60 days to six months or more, de- to both humans and animals.

Californians for Alternatives to Toxics 315 P Street, Eureka, CA 95501 (707) 445-5100 www.alternatives2toxics.org Californians for Alternatives to Toxics 315 P Street, Eureka, CA 95501 (707) 445-5100 www.alternatives2toxics.org

2 7
Toxics Close to Home From the desk of the Director Feds’ herbicide treadmill CATs Corrals Creek Killer
CATS raised protection of air and water Why Be a Member? Both the U.S. Forest Service (USFS) Agencies’ Plan Blocked
to a new level in its Humboldt Bay area and the Bureau of Land Management (BLM) CATs stopped state and federal agencies
home base by filing two lawsuits in federal People often wonder about the perks that come with a CATs membership. have again gotten hooked on large-scale from “executing” a creek in a high Sierra
court against local polluters. They ask if a newsletter subscription is involved, or if we’ll help them rid our herbicide projects, an ominous sign for wilderness last fall so they could replant a
Significant and on-going violations of environment of toxic chemicals. federal public land management strategies. fish popular with anglers.
the federal air quality permit regulating The answer is YES! It’s all available, but the newsletter and information The USFS has at least 24 projects The stream sterilization plan was withdrawn
emissions of the pulp mill owned by Ever- are free for the asking to any who will use it to help create a non-toxic world. totaling more than 52,610 acres on the spray as a result of the CATs-prompted court decision,
green Pulp, Inc. — located across Humboldt So what’s special about being a member? The best way I can describe it is schedule in California alone. CATs has filed which also will affect similar proposals being
Bay from CATs’ office in Eureka — in how much louder and bolder CATs’ voice becomes when you add yours to suit to stop the two largest of these projects, made for scores of California streams and
the chorus. Whether it’s when we advocate before a government agency, file a Cottonwood in Tahoe National Forest and lakes by the U.S. Forest Service and the
lawsuit against an outrageous polluter or bring thousands of people together Larsen in Stanislaus National Forest. state Department of Fish and Game (DFG).
for the Organic Planet Festival, or even when raising money to pay for this Together they comprise 23,500 acres, almost A crew was already on-site and poised to
work, what CATs is made of – its members! – counts for everything. half of the state total. unleash the toxic chemicals when the
That’s why I’m asking you to pull out the gold envelope tucked into this The BLM is also fully on the federal injunction halted the poisoning of 11 miles of
newsletter, fill it out and mail it back ASAP. With that step, you’ll add your agency herbicide bandwagon, proposing to the Silver King Creek and a nearby lake in the
voice, strength and caring to CATs’ efforts to make our world a non-toxic triple annual spray totals, approaching a Carson-Iceberg Wilderness Area.
haven for healthy living and a living environment. That’s the best perk we million acres, in Western states. CATs is DFG initiated the plan to use the lethal
have to offer. vigorously opposing this plan too, which aquatic pesticide called rotenone to kill non-
involves 18 herbicides and heavy aerial native trout, which—ironically enough—the
Changes spraying. agency had planted originally. The goal now
The largest of the new USFS spray was to restock the stream with native Paiute
This newsletter marks the last time I’ll write for it as CATs’ Executive proposals includes herbicides, fungicides cutthroat trout, prized by anglers.
prompted one CATs’ lawsuit. The pulp Director. By the end of this year, I’ll be morphed to the position of Programs and rodenticides in the McNally Project on CATs argued that because rotenone was
mill’s owners had convinced regional air Director, one I currently hold, but minus the responsibilities that come with the Sequoia National Forest. Among the not just lethal to fish, other species —
quality regulators to let Evergreen off the keeping the doors open, budgets balanced and forms filled. more than 8,000 acres proposed for “treat- including some that are rare or endan-
hook for its local air quality permit. We still don’t know just who will take up the E.D. mantle or how the ment” to boost post-fire recovery are parts gered—would be eliminated. The judge
In documents filed with the North Coast transition will progress, but the ball is rolling and I’m REALLY looking of the Sequoia National Monument. agreed and insisted that an environmental
Unified Air Quality Management, Evergreen forward to being 100% focused on our core projects and helping make CATs did persuade Plumas National analysis was required.
admitted to exceeding emission limits northern California a center for non-toxic living. Forest officials to reduce borax applications He also blasted the plan for its “stark
regularly since purchasing the facility in Next year we plan to celebrate CATs’ 25th anniversary. It seems a fitting in their Empire Project to 21 finality; an execution in a very special place
January 2005. time to make this change! acres, instead of the origi- in our treasured mountains.”
CATs and co-plaintiff Environmental nally planned 3,947 acres, Rotenone has been used in efforts to
Protection Information Center joined forces Please join CATs as we step into the future. after we discovered that eradicate non-native species in other parts of
under provisions of the Clean Air Act that more borax was being the country, with mixed results. The poison-
allow citizens to file suit when government applied than scientific ing of California’s Lake Davis has been typical,
fails to act. literature supported. with chemicals lingering months beyond
Citizen suit claims filed under the Clean After CATs found out predictions and fish eradication a failure.
Water Act brought CATs into federal court that large amounts of this Aquatic ecosystems in the Sierra
with Humboldt Baykeeper, seeking an order sodium compound — which Nevada provide habitat for species found
to clean up toxic contamination at the old doesn’t occur naturally in nowhere else in the world, including certain
Simpson Plywood mill on Del Norte Street forests — were being used aquatic invertebrates that are essential for
in Eureka. with little to no environmen- ecosystem health and which provide food for
The groups sued Simpson Timber tal analysis, we convinced fish, birds, amphibians and mammals.
Company and Preston Properties because managers in a few forests to The Paiute cutthroat trout, one of the
dioxin-laden soil is impacting Humboldt change their application rarest trout species in the West, has suffered
Bay and the Eureka Marsh. Former owner criteria, resulting in greatly reduced acreage at the hands of state agencies that have
Simpson Timber Company had been negoti- and fewer pounds of borax used. brought competitive, non-native fish into its
ating with the North Coast Regional Water Invasive weed control on public lands habitat and now are poisoning watersheds to
Quality Control Board for more than fifteen remains a central issue. While both the kill off the introduced invaders.
years regarding the pollutants. USFS and BLM prefer to spray herbicides, “For years we’ve raised the issue that
Sampling undertaken by the plaintiff merely treating the symptoms of the prob- rotenone kills indiscriminately but the Forest
groups showed as much as 89,000 parts per lem, CATs is advocating non-toxic inte- Service ignored us,” said Nancy Erman, an
trillion of extremely toxic dioxin in mud Faces of CATs grated pest management practices, which aquatic invertebrate specialist from the
near the mill. Dioxin is a contaminant of From L-R: Organic Planet Festival organizers Michelle Fuller, Karen Sherman, CATs’ President
Perry Gray-Reneberg, Matt Lang, Serena Stockdale, and Executive Director Patty Clary.
incorporate prevention, species biology and University of California, Davis.
pentacholorphenol once used at the former ecosystem health without introducing toxic CATs was joined in the lawsuit by
mill site as a wood preservative. chemicals into our public lands. Wilderness Watch and two individuals.

Californians for Alternatives to Toxics 315 P Street, Eureka, CA 95501 (707) 445-5100 www.alternatives2toxics.org Californians for Alternatives to Toxics 315 P Street, Eureka, CA 95501 (707) 445-5100 www.alternatives2toxics.org

6 3
It’s an Organic Planet! Festival Schedule
Come join us Saturday, August 26, The Organic Planet Festival will be held in Eureka at Halvorsen Park.
to celebrate a world of organic and non- From Highway 101, take L Street toward Humboldt Bay and follow the signs.
toxic living at the 2nd annual Organic
Planet Festival! Building on last year’s 11:00 am - Gates Open; Pan Dulce - 30-piece steel drum calypso community band. These local favor-
successful event, CATs has planned a ites have recently released their first CD to much acclaim. [M.S.*]
day filled with music, information, food
and fun. 12:00 noon - Aphrodesia will host two workshops simultaneously: One on African drum and dance by
We’ll present the Eureka Natural band members recently returned from West Africa where they played the legendary New Africa Shrine
Foods World’s Largest Organic Salad in Nigeria; another on biodiesel, featuring Aphrodesia’s tourbus. [F.G.]
and commemo-
rate Eureka’s 12:30 pm - Featured speaker: School nutrition expert Ann Cooper will talk about “Organic School
150th birthday Lunch Programs.” An author and consultant, Chef Ann sits on the USDA National Organic Standards
with a North Board and is nutrition director for the Berkeley Unified School District. See www.chefann.com. [M.S.]
Coast Co-op
gigantic cake and 1:30 pm - “Why Be Organic?” - A four-member panel will discuss the multifaceted nature of organic
Humboldt food production. Organized by the Campus Center for Appropriate Technology (CCAT) from Humboldt
Creamery/ State University. [P.T.]
Organic Valley
ice cream. The Wildberries Marketplace - Serving of the World’s Largest Organic Salad!
Kids’ Village will stage a merry mid-day
parade. 1:45 pm - Clinton Fearon and the Boogie Brown Band - Jamaican roots reggae. Fearon is a living
Keeping revelers organically fueled legend of roots reggae, performing with some of the biggest names in the genre. [M.S.]
will be food from the Beachcomber
Cafe, Eel River Organic Beef, The Tofu 2:45 pm - “The Non-Toxic Home” - Louise Jeffery of Humboldt’s Integrated Waste Management
Shop and Pachanga Mexicana. Bever- Program and Angie Wood, Fortuna’s Solid Waste Coordinator, will describe options for non-toxic
ages will be offered from Santa Cruz cleaning and maintenance at home. [P.T.]
Organics, Butte Creek Brewing Com-
pany, the vinyards of Coates, Frey and 3:00 pm - “Recycled Music as Object and Idea” - Joe Craven’s family-oriented workshop. “Music
Mendocino Trading Company and more. that’s informally made and shared is a hallmark of folk music...and leads to the creative life”. [F.G.]
There’s lots to enjoy, from grooving
- Serving Organic ice cream and cake for Eureka’s 150th anniversary celebration!
on a great lineup of roots reggae, funky
rock-folk, Afro-beat, steel drum and
3:30 pm - Raining Jane - eclectic rock-folk. An all-women band from L.A. featuring stunning harmo-
bluegrass ‘n jazz to playing with face
nies and occasional surprise instrumentation. They have opened for many nationally known acts. [M.S.]
paint, crafts, and a petting zoo in the
Kids Village. Vendors will be showing
4:30 pm - “Safer Building” - Michelle Miller will talk about choosing alternatives to toxic chemicals
and selling the latest organic and non-
in traditional building materials and SaferBuildingTM certification for non-toxic construction. [P.T.]
toxic wares, while community groups
will demonstrate what they’re doing to - Start the Kids’ Parade!
improve our world.
Don’t miss the CATs Clearinghouse, 5:00 pm - Joe Craven Quartet - bluegrass, world music, jazz and beyond. A multi-instrumentalist
where festival-goers extraordinaire who, with friends, will perform selections from his new album, “Django Latino.” [M.S.]
can sign up to win
Help one of 50 shopping 5:15 pm - “Green Recycled Buildings” CCAT will discuss materials and design ideas incorporated in
Wanted: Be bags filled with their “new” house and Organic Planet Festival host CATs’ solar-powered and recycled office. [P.T.]
a Volunteer! samples of organic
Call 445-5100
ext 212
and non-toxic 6:15 pm - “Organic on a Budget” - Sean Armstrong, back by popular demand, will demonstrate how
items. to eat organic food while staying within a budget. [P.T.]
Our featured
speaker, Ann Cooper, will describe how - The Non-toxic and Organic door prize drawing!
to get wholesome food into school
cafeterias, while workshops on eating 6:45 pm - Aphrodesia - Super Afro-beat. From Lagos, Nigeria to the San Francisco Bay Area, these
organically on a budget, green building Afro-beat explorers take Fela Kuti’s African jazz-funk into the 21st century. [M.S.]
methods and healthy household cleaning
will be complimented by a panel on why * [key: M.S. = main stage; P.T. = presenter’s tent; F.G. = festival grounds]
being organic is important to our world.

Summer 2006 Californians for Alternatives to Toxics 315 P Street, Eureka, CA 95501 (707) 445-5100 www.alternatives2toxics.org

4 5

You might also like