Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Ali Mirza the Engineer has claimed that he remained Barailvi for 31 years
of his life.
Then he was converted to Diubandism {A Subssect of Sunnism}.
Then he was converted to Shiism {Probebly Isna: Ashrism, a sub Sect
of Shiism}.
This he claims for a short period of time.
Then he does not state what did he became.
It may be suggested that he then became Ahlul H:adi:s . So this implies
that there are three consecutive conversions of Engineer Ali Mirza.
1} From Initial Barailvism to Diubandism {Deobandism, a subsect of
Ahlussunmnah}.
2} From Diubandism to Isna: Ashrism { One of the three Shiite sects i)
Buhriah {Mustaliah},2} Isna: Ashriah {Twelvers}, 3} Nizariah}.
3} From Isna: Ashrism to Ahlul H:adism { An other Sunni Sub Sects}.
But the self styles story Engineered by Ali: Mirza , the Engineer, is
incorrect and inaccurate.
First if he became a Ahlul H:adi:s then he must have become after he had
converted to Isna: Ashrism, and certainly not before that.
Since each one of the first two conversions of Ali: Mirza are consecutive
in the sense that there is not conversion between the two stated above
conversions.
So any third conversion must be after the first two conversions.
Two conversions do imply three sects to which Ali Mirza belonged to .
Since it is implied that he was a Barailvi by his birth. His initial sect.
So it is not possible that he was an Ahlul H:adi:s between the first to
conversion.
So the only thing that can be assumed that when he became an Ahlul
H:adi:s he underwent an other conversion, the third one.
This is one side of the story as it is stated and implied from the videos of
the Lectures Of Engineer Ali Mirza. But this story as stated seems to lack
Historicity.
Shaikh Ali: Zai {An Ahlul H:adi:s scholar with some differences from the
main stream of Ahlul H:adism} narrates an other picture of the story.
Fortunately the words of Shaikh Zubair {Ali Zai} are are recorded as an
IRREFUTABLE proof that at best one of the two stories is incorrect and
inaccurate, and at worst both of them are in correct and inaccurate.
Maulana Ali: Zai mensions :=
This shews that Engineer Ali: Mirza was converted to Ahlul H:adi:s
directly from Barailvism.
This is a direct contradiction of the former story.
When Shaikh Ali Zai said the word Ahlul H:asi:s the video fortunately
record the word AL H:AMDULILKA:H, STATED BY Engineer Ali: Mirza. The
sound is certainly of the Engineer Ali: Mirza. Shaikh Ali Zai considered
him as the speaker of truth. It is strongly improbable that Shaikh Ali Zai
concocted a false story. It is strongly probable that Ali Mirza told him and
he repeated the story as it was told to him, in public.
There is a very strong probability that Ali Mirza told a very different story
to Shaikh Ali Zai and he due to his simplicity accepted the story of
Engineer Ali: Mirza about his conversion to Ahlul H:adi:s from
Barailvism. The words AL H:AMDULIL LA:H said by Ali Mirza practically
implies that he is confirming what so ever was said by Maulana: Zubair
about him { i.e :Ali: Mirza of Jhelem, the Engineer whoprobebly
engineered the story to deceive Maulana: Shaikh Zubair Ali: Zai}.
So this means that at best on of the two stories are deprived of historicity.
I may be noted that the former story is more historical then the latter yet
none of them appears to be totallytrue .
1} First it is found that for some time Engineer Ali Mirza was with Doctor
Isra:r Ah:mad as well. But Doctor Isra:r was not a Diubandi , he had
some of his own views. He only respected some Diubandi Scholars. But he
cannot be declair as a Diubandi except by some stunch Barailvis who
define a Diubandi as any one who is not a Barailvi. Diubandi Subsect Of
Ahlussunnah do not recognize Homeo-Doctor Isr:ar Ah:mad as a
Diubandi. So if Engineer was with the Doctor he can only be declared as a
Diubandi by a stunch Barailvi and non other. This means that even when
the Engineer was with the Doctor he was still a Barailvi. The question is
why he was with Doctor Isra:r when he Was a Barailvi. The answer may
rest in the heart of the Engineer Ali Mirza: , but one may have a right to
suggest a probable reason for this.
The basic scheme appears to be that he wanted to know the internal
mechanism of the Tanz:i:m founded by Doctor Isra:r Ah:mad so that he
may organize his own organization /Tanz:i:m. So he was still a Barailvi and
he never became a Diubandi. (This is verified by the methods of his blind
followers who follow the Engineer. The pattern is a close approximation of
the methods employed by the Late Doctor Isra:r Ah:mad).
Then he claimed to become an Ahlul H:adi:s by narrating that he is a
Barailvi and he is researching. But he then became a Isna: Ashrite. That
is the reason of his Supreme Sympathy with them. His sympathy for them
knows no limit. So our research does shew that Engineer Ali: Mirza did
convert but the story of his conversion is different from what he did
narrate to Simple minded Shaikh
Ali: Zai , and what he does narrate now in his self styled lectures.
His first conversion is from Barailvism to AhlulH:adism .
Any other conversion is certainly from Ahlul H:adi:sism .