White Trash: the 400 year-old untold history of class in America. By Nancy Isenberg. 2016. 480 pps. Viking. ISBN: 9780670785971. $28.00. The American Dream is a belief that any American, regardless of their background, can rise to prosperity, success and leadership through upward social mobility, opportunity and hard work. The United States was, by design, engineered to break away from kings, queens and nobility. Bill Gates, Steve Jobs and Bill Clinton did not come from the privileged families of an aristocracy. Author Nancy Isenberg tells us, however, that the United States has been, and remains a class-based society with roots going back to the original colonies of the 1500s. Isenberg claims that England emptied its jails and shipped vagrants, the feeble-minded, beggars, orphans and the homeless to the New World to do the heavy work in agriculture and mining. This human waste from the bowels 1
of England remain as todays American white trash having
been relegated to generations of manual labor and poverty. Skilled labor, sent to the colonies artisans, millers, tailors, cobblers, coopers and tinkers had access to indentured servants with longer-than-usual contracts of five to seven years, instead of two to four years. The servants were essentially property that could be sold off or traded. Upon completion of servitude, the workers would not have had enough money to buy property from wealthy landowners, and would have instead lived a life of lowincome wages and perpetual debt. Isenberg tells of life after the US Civil War: the lowest of White classes, refugees from the civil war, were distinct from the freed Blacks, who were prepared to work and better themselves. White trash were perceived as shiftless morons, and given to living off subsidies and hand-outs during the Southern Reconstruction. Their social issues were long in place, and ran deeper than war-related problems this, according to The New York Times articles on southern
poverty in the late 1860s, which reported on the prevalence
of dirt-eating among the White rural poor, and the relevant medical issues that arose with such a diet. But Isenbergs evidence is largely anecdotal, and she would have done well to have provided quantitative analysis in the form of hard data. For example, what are the white trash infant mortality rates? What percentage of White Americans are and were living off of government subsidies, as compared to Black Americans? How have these numbers changed or stayed in place over time? Where is the data on incarceration and recidivism? This is not to take away from the reality of social segregation in todays United States. Isenberg is correct in that the salaried middle class have their backyard barbeques and baseball fields in their parks, which are located in leafy green suburbs. The wage-earning working class have their bowling alleys and diners, and are closer to the urban centers. The white trash have their notorious trailer-parks, which are far and away from prime real estate but close to
the temporary employment agencies, pay-day loans and
pawn shops. The hillbillies in the Appalachian Mountains southern Ohio, northern Kentucky and upper West Virginia still languish in their tar paper shanties, outhouses, and with shoeless children running in the yard among chickens and pigs. I grew up in Ohio, and have seen it. Today, one does not have to stray too far off the interstate highway to witness the fetid squalor. Isenberg is astute: even when despairing in hopeless generations of abject poverty, one has an identity, a place, a social group and an ancestry. In order to move out of the lowest social class, one must leave their identity behind, while watching the upper classes categorize them as coming from poor white trash and with all the cruel stereotypes of in-bred relatives, mental retardation, and bizarre religious practices that invoke snake handling and speaking in tongues.
If there is an irony to upward mobility, it can be seen in
this years presidential election. Bill Clinton, a two-term president, came from a broken home, with an abusive alcoholic step-father, and from one of the poorest states in the union. Frequently in his political career, Clinton was called the white trash candidate, who self-admittedly brought in the cracker vote. However, today the Clintons are widely criticized as being part of the elite class, who are working in the interests of Wall Street and the corporations: oblivious to the needs of the working poor. Instead, Americas white trash, the poorly educated, are preparing to elect a billionaire child of privilege, Donald Trump. Pete Willows is a contributing writer to The Egyptian Gazette, and its weekly magazine version, The Egyptian Mail. He can be reached at willows@aucegypt.edu