Professional Documents
Culture Documents
This article is about the classical Greek philosopher. For As for discovering the real-life Socrates, the diculty is
other uses of Socrates, see Socrates (disambiguation).
that ancient sources are mostly philosophical or dramatic
Not to be confused with Isocrates.
texts, apart from Xenophon. There are no straightforward
histories, contemporary with Socrates, that dealt with his
own time and place. A corollary of this is that sources
[2]
Socrates (/skrtiz/; Greek: [skrts],
[1]
Skrts; 470/469 399 BC) was a classical Greek that do mention Socrates do not necessarily claim to be
historically accurate, and are often partisan. For instance,
(Athenian) philosopher credited as one of the founders
of Western philosophy. He is an enigmatic gure known those who prosecuted and convicted Socrates have left
chiey through the accounts of classical writers, espe- no testament. Historians therefore face the challenge of
cially the writings of his students Plato and Xenophon and reconciling the various evidence from the extant texts in
the plays of his contemporary Aristophanes. Platos di- order to attempt an accurate and consistent account of
alogues are among the most comprehensive accounts of Socrates life and work. The result of such an eort is not
Socrates to survive from antiquity, though it is unclear necessarily realistic, even if consistent.
the degree to which Socrates himself is hidden behind Amid all the disagreement resulting from dierences
his 'best disciple', Plato.[3]
within sources, two factors emerge from all sources perhe was
Through his portrayal in Platos dialogues, Socrates has taining to Socrates. It would seem, therefore, that
[11][12]
ugly,
and
that
Socrates
had
a
brilliant
intellect.
become renowned for his contribution to the eld of
ethics, and it is this Platonic Socrates who lends his name
to the concepts of Socratic irony and the Socratic method,
or elenchus. The latter remains a commonly used tool in
a wide range of discussions, and is a type of pedagogy in
which a series of questions is asked not only to draw individual answers, but also to encourage fundamental insight
into the issue at hand. Platos Socrates also made important and lasting contributions to the eld of epistemology,
and his ideologies and approach have proven a strong
foundation for much Western philosophy that has followed.
Socratic problem
1.2
2 BIOGRAPHY
Socrates as a philosopher
Biography
2.4
Arrest of Leon
2.1
Early life
3
vivors of foundered ships to pursue the defeated Spartan
navy.[23][37][38]
According to Xenophon, Socrates was the Epistates for
the debate,[39] but Delebecque and Hatzfeld think this is
an embellishment, because Xenophon composed the information after Socrates death [40]
The generals were seen by some to have failed to uphold the most basic of duties, and the people decided
upon capital punishment. However, when the prytany
responded by refusing to vote on the issue, the people
reacted with threats of death directed at the prytany itself. They relented, at which point Socrates alone as
epistates blocked the vote, which had been proposed by
Callixeinus.[41][42] The reason he gave was that in no case
would he act except in accordance with the law.[43]
The outcome of the trial was ultimately judged to be a
miscarriage of justice, or illegal, but, actually, Socrates
decision had no support from written statutory law, instead being reliant on favouring a continuation of less
strict and less formal nomos law.[42][44][45]
2.3
the
Epistates at the trial of the six com- Claiming loyalty to his city, Socrates clashed with
current course of Athenian politics and society.[50] He
manders
praises Sparta, archrival to Athens, directly and indirectly
2 BIOGRAPHY
of the state (as the gady stings the horse into action, so
Socrates stung various Athenians), insofar as he irritated
some people with considerations of justice and the pursuit
of goodness.[51] His attempts to improve the Athenians
sense of justice may have been the cause of his execution.
According to Platos Apology, Socrates life as the gady of Athens began when his friend Chaerephon asked
the oracle at Delphi if anyone were wiser than Socrates;
the Oracle responded that no-one was wiser. Socrates
believed the Oracles response was not correct, because
he believed he possessed no wisdom whatsoever. He
proceeded to test the riddle by approaching men considered wise by the people of Athensstatesmen, poets,
and artisansin order to refute the Oracles pronouncement. Questioning them, however, Socrates concluded:
while each man thought he knew a great deal and was
wise, in fact they knew very little and were not wise at
all. Socrates realized the Oracle was correct; while socalled wise men thought themselves wise and yet were
not, he himself knew he was not wise at all, which, paradoxically, made him the wiser one since he was the only
person aware of his own ignorance. Socrates paradoxical
wisdom made the prominent Athenians he publicly questioned look foolish, turning them against him and leading to accusations of wrongdoing. Socrates defended his
role as a gady until the end: at his trial, when Socrates
was asked to propose his own punishment, he suggested
a wage paid by the government and free dinners for the
rest of his life instead, to nance the time he spent as
Athens benefactor.[52] He was, nevertheless, found guilty
of both corrupting the minds of the youth of Athens and
of impiety (not believing in the gods of the state),[53]
and subsequently sentenced to death by drinking a mixture containing poison hemlock.[54][55][56][57]
3.2
Philosophical beliefs
death was the purifying remedy for Athens misfortunes. ideas of Socrates himself, but which have been subseIn this view, the token of appreciation for Asclepius quently deformed or changed by Plato, and some scholars
would represent a cure for Athens ailments.[51]
think Plato so adapted the Socratic style as to make the
literary character and the philosopher himself impossible to distinguish. Others argue that he did have his own
theories and beliefs.[62] There is a degree of controversy
3 Philosophy
inherent in the identifying of what these might have been,
owing to the diculty of separating Socrates from Plato
and the diculty of interpreting even the dramatic writ3.1 Socratic method
ings concerning Socrates. Consequently, distinguishing
the philosophical beliefs of Socrates from those of Plato
Main article: Socratic method
and Xenophon has not proven easy, so it must be remembered that what is attributed to Socrates might actually be
Perhaps his most important contribution to Western
more the specic concerns of these two thinkers instead.
thought is his dialectic method of inquiry, known as
the Socratic method or method of elenchus, which he The matter is complicated because the historical Socrates
largely applied to the examination of key moral concepts seems to have been notorious for asking questions but not
such as the Good and Justice. It was rst described by answering, claiming to lack wisdom concerning the sub[63]
Plato in the Socratic Dialogues. To solve a problem, it jects about which he questioned others.
would be broken down into a series of questions, the an- If anything in general can be said about the philosophswers to which gradually distill the answer a person would ical beliefs of Socrates, it is that he was morally, intelseek. The inuence of this approach is most strongly lectually, and politically at odds with many of his fellow
felt today in the use of the scientic method, in which Athenians. When he is on trial for heresy and corrupting
hypothesis is the rst stage. The development and prac- the minds of the youth of Athens, he uses his method of
tice of this method is one of Socrates most enduring con- elenchos to demonstrate to the jurors that their moral valtributions, and is a key factor in earning his mantle as the ues are wrong-headed. He tells them they are concerned
father of political philosophy, ethics or moral philosophy, with their families, careers, and political responsibilities
and as a gurehead of all the central themes in Western when they ought to be worried about the welfare of their
philosophy.
souls. Socrates assertion that the gods had singled him
To illustrate the use of the Socratic method, a series of
questions are posed to help a person or group to determine their underlying beliefs and the extent of their
knowledge. The Socratic method is a negative method
of hypothesis elimination, in that better hypotheses are
found by steadily identifying and eliminating those that
lead to contradictions. It was designed to force one to examine ones own beliefs and the validity of such beliefs.
An alternative interpretation of the dialectic is that it
is a method for direct perception of the Form of the
Good. Philosopher Karl Popper describes the dialectic
as the art of intellectual intuition, of visualising the divine originals, the Forms or Ideas, of unveiling the Great
Mystery behind the common mans everyday world of
appearances.[60] In a similar vein, French philosopher
Pierre Hadot suggests that the dialogues are a type of spiritual exercise. Hadot writes that in Platos view, every
dialectical exercise, precisely because it is an exercise of
pure thought, subject to the demands of the Logos, turns
the soul away from the sensible world, and allows it to
convert itself towards the Good.[61]
3.2
Philosophical beliefs
3 PHILOSOPHY
on the other hand, considered Socrates association with promnestiks) in that he matches the young man to
the Anaxagoreans to be evidence of Platos philosophical the best philosopher for his particular mind. Howseparation from Socrates.
ever, he carefully distinguishes himself from a panderer
( proagogos) or procurer. This distinction is
echoed in Xenophons Symposium (3.20), when Socrates
3.3 Socratic paradoxes
jokes about his certainty of being able to make a fortune,
if he chose to practice the art of pandering. For his part
Many of the beliefs traditionally attributed to the histori- as a philosophical interlocutor, he leads his respondent to
cal Socrates have been characterized as paradoxical be- a clearer conception of wisdom, although he claims he
cause they seem to conict with common sense. The fol- is not himself a teacher (Apology). His role, he claims, is
lowing are among the so-called Socratic paradoxes:[66]
more properly to be understood as analogous to a midwife
( maia).[75][76]
No one desires evil.
In the Theaetetus, Socrates explains that he is himself barren of theories, but knows how to bring the theories of
others to birth and determine whether they are worthy or
mere "wind eggs" ( anemiaion). Perhaps sig Virtueall virtueis knowledge.
nicantly, he points out that midwives are barren due to
Virtue is sucient for happiness.
age, and women who have never given birth are unable
to become midwives; they would have no experience or
The term, "Socratic paradox" can also refer to a self- knowledge of birth and would be unable to separate the
referential paradox, originating in Socrates utterance, worthy infants from those that should be left on the hillwhat I do not know I do not think I know,[67] often para- side to be exposed. To judge this, the midwife must have
experience and knowledge of what she is judging.[77][78]
phrased as "I know that I know nothing.
No one errs or does wrong willingly or knowingly.
3.4
Knowledge
3.5 Virtue
The statement "I know that I know nothing" is often attributed to Socrates, based on a statement in Platos Apology.[68] The conventional interpretation of this is that
Socrates wisdom was limited to an awareness of his own
ignorance. Socrates considered virtuousness to require
or consist of phronsis, thought, sense, judgement, practical wisdom, [and] prudence.[69][70] Therefore, he believed that wrongdoing and behaviour that was not virtuous resulted from ignorance, and that those who did
wrong knew no better.[71]
The one thing Socrates claimed to have knowledge of
was the art of love (ta ertik). This assertion seems
to be associated with the word ertan, which means to
ask questions. Therefore, Socrates is claiming to know
about the art of love, insofar as he knows how to ask
questions.[72][73]
The only time he actually claimed to be wise was within
Apology, in which he says he is wise in the limited sense of having human wisdom.[74] It is debatable
whether Socrates believed humans (as opposed to gods
like Apollo) could actually become wise. On the one
hand, he drew a clear line between human ignorance and
ideal knowledge; on the other, Platos Symposium (Diotimas Speech) and Republic (Allegory of the Cave) describe a method for ascending to wisdom.
In Platos Theaetetus (150a), Socrates compares his treatment of the young people who come to him for philosophical advice to the way midwives treat their patients,
and the way matrimonial matchmakers act. He says
that he himself is a true matchmaker ( Bust of Socrates in the Palermo Archaeological Museum.
3.7
Covertness
medium of Sophocles, Euripides, and the ctions of theatre, may reect the ever-interpretable nature of his writings, as he has been called a dramatist of reason. What
is more, the rst word of nearly all Platos works is a signicant term for that respective dialogue, and is used with
its many connotations in mind. Finally, the Phaedrus and
the Symposium each allude to Socrates coy delivery of
philosophic truths in conversation; the Socrates of the
Phaedrus goes so far as to demand such dissembling and
mystery in all writing. The covertness we often nd in
Plato, appearing here and there couched in some enigmatic use of symbol and/or irony, may be at odds with the
mysticism Platos Socrates expounds in some other dialogues. These indirect methods may fail to satisfy some
readers.
LEGACY
Satirical playwrights
Prose sources
6 Legacy
6.2
6.1
Immediate inuence
9
Cynicism.
The idea of asceticism being hand in hand with an ethical life or one with piety, ignored by Plato and Aristotle
and somewhat dealt with by the Cynics, formed the core
of another philosophy in 281 BCStoicism when Zeno
of Citium would discover Socrates works and then learn
from Crates, a Cynic philosopher.[93]
10
8 NOTES
room and law school discourse to expose underlying is- 6.4 In literature
sues in both subject and the speaker. He has been rec Socrates is a major character in Mary Renault's hisognized with accolades ranging from frequent mentions
torical novel The Last of the Wine. The books proin pop culture (such as the movie Bill & Teds Excellent
tagonists, Alexias and Lysis, study under him in
Adventure and a Greek rock band called Socrates Drank
Athens.[101]
the Conium) to numerous busts in academic institutions
in recognition of his contribution to education.
A humorous version of the deceased Socrates apOver the past century, numerous plays about Socrates
pears in John Kendrick Bangs's comic novel A
have also focused on Socrates life and inuence. One of
House-Boat on the Styx and its sequels.[102]
the most recent has been Socrates on Trial, a play based
on Aristophanes Clouds and Platos Apology, Crito, and
Phaedo, all adapted for modern performance.
7 See also
6.3
Criticism
Evaluation of and reaction to Socrates has been undertaken by both historians and philosophers from the time
of his death to the present day with a multitude of conclusions and perspectives. Although he was not directly
prosecuted for his connection to Critias, leader of the
Spartan-backed Thirty Tyrants, and showed considerable personal courage in refusing to submit to [them]",
he was seen by some as a gure who mentored oligarchs
who became abusive tyrants, and undermined Athenian
democracy. The Sophistic movement that he railed at in
life survived him, but by the 3rd century BC, was rapidly
overtaken by the many philosophical schools of thought
that Socrates inuenced.[97]
Socrates death is considered iconic and his status as a
martyr of philosophy overshadows most contemporary
and posthumous criticism. However, Xenophon mentions
Socrates arrogance and that he was an expert in the art
of pimping or self-presentation.[98] Direct criticism of
Socrates the man almost disappears after this time, but
there is a noticeable preference for Plato or Aristotle over
the elements of Socratic philosophy distinct from those of
his students, even into the Middle Ages.
Some modern scholarship holds that, with so much of
his own thought obscured and possibly altered by Plato,
it is impossible to gain a clear picture of Socrates amid
all the contradictory evidence. That both Cynicism and
Stoicism, which carried heavy inuence from Socratic
thought, were unlike or even contrary to Platonism further illustrates this. The ambiguity and lack of reliability serves as the modern basis of criticismthat it
is nearly impossible to know the real Socrates. Some
controversy also exists about Socrates attitude towards
homosexuality[99] and as to whether or not he believed
in the Olympian gods, was monotheistic, or held some
other religious viewpoint.[100] However, it is still commonly taught and held with little exception that Socrates
is the progenitor of subsequent Western philosophy, to
the point that philosophers before him are referred to as
pre-Socratic.
8 Notes
[1] Chisholm, Hugh, ed. (1911). "Socrates". Encyclopdia
Britannica (11th ed.). Cambridge University Press.
[2] Jones, Daniel; Roach, Peter, James Hartman and Jane Setter, eds. Cambridge English Pronouncing Dictionary. 17th
edition. Cambridge UP, 2006.
[3] Kofman, Sarah (1998). Socrates: Fictions of a Philosopher. p. 34. ISBN 0-8014-3551-X.
[4] Roberson, C. (8 December 2009). Ethics for Criminal Justice Professionals. CRC Press. p. 24. ISBN
1420086723.
[5] Rubel, A.; Vickers, M. (11 September 2014). Fear and
Loathing in Ancient Athens: Religion and Politics During the Peloponnesian War. Routledge. p. 147. ISBN
1317544803.
[6] Dorion, Louis-Andr.
The Rise and Fall of the
Socratic Problem (pp. 123) (The Cambridge ComCambridge University Press.
panion to Socrates).
doi:10.1017/CCOL9780521833424.001.
ISBN
9780521833424. Retrieved 2015-05-07.
[7] May, H. (2000).
Learning,. p. 20.
On Socrates.
Wadsworth/Thomson
[8] catalogue of Harvard University Press - Xenophon Volume IV. Retrieved 2015-3-26.
[9] Kahn, CH', Plato and the Socratic Dialogue: The Philosophical Use of a Literary Form, Cambridge University
Press, 1998, p. xvii.
11
[10] Many other writers added to the fashion of Socratic dialogues (called Sokratikoi logoi) at the time. In addition to
Plato and Xenophon, each of the following is credited by
some source as having added to the genre: Aeschines of
Sphettus, Antisthenes, Aristippus, Bryson, Cebes, Crito,
Euclid of Megara, and Phaedo. It is unlikely Plato was the
rst in this eld (Vlastos, p. 52).
[13] CH Kahn, Plato and the Socratic Dialogue: The Philosophical Use of a Literary Form (p. 75), Cambridge University Press, 1998, ISBN 0521648300.
[14] Cohen, M., Philosophical Tales: Being an Alternative History Revealing the Characters, the Plots, and the Hidden
Scenes That Make Up the True Story of Philosophy, John
Wiley & Sons, 2008, p. 5, ISBN 1-4051-4037-2.
[15] D Nails, Agora, Academy, and the Conduct of Philosophy
(p. 9), Springer, 1995, ISBN 0792335430.
[16] Ahbel-Rappe, S., Socrates: A Guide for the Perplexed (p.
2 and footnote 10 on pp. 1578), A&C Black, 2009.
[17] Bett, R. A Companion to Socrates (pp. 299-30). John Wiley & Sons, 2009, ISBN 1405192607. Retrieved 201504-17. (A translation of one fragment reads: But from
them the sculptor, blatherer on the lawful, turned away.
Spellbinder of the Greeks, who made them precise in language. Sneerer trained by rhetoroticians, sub-Attic ironist.)
[18] Lieber, F. Encyclopedia Americana (pp. 266-7), published 1832 (original from Oxford University).
[19] CS. Celenza (2001), Angelo Polizianos Lamia: Text,
Translation, and Introductory Studies (note 34), BRILL,
2010, ISBN 9004185909.
[20] Ong, pp. 7879.
[21] P.J. King, One Hundred Philosophers (p. 23), Zebra,
2006, ISBN 1770220011.
[22] G.W.F. Hegel (trans. Frances H. Simon), Lectures on
History of Philosophy
[23] Nails, D, Socrates - A Chronology of the historical
Socrates in the context of Athenian history and the dramatic dates of Platos dialogues, The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (Spring 2014 Edition), Edward N. Zalta
(ed.). Retrieved 2015-04-17.
[24] Howatson, M.C. (2013). The Oxford Companion to Classical Literature (reprint, 3rd ed.). Oxford University
Press. p. 528. ISBN 0199548552.
[25] Plato (1999) [1921]. Theaetetus. Translated by Fowler,
Harold N. (reprint of London, William Heinemann Ltd.
ed.). Cambridge, MA.: Harvard University Press. p.
149a. Retrieved April 2015. Check date values in:
|access-date= (help)
12
[44] Harris, E.M. The Rule of Law in Action in Democratic Athens. Oxford University Press, 2013, ISBN
0199899169. Retrieved 2015-04-18.
8 NOTES
[46] Ober, J. in Morrisson, D.R. (ed.), The Cambridge Companion to Socrates Cambridge University Press, 2011, pp.
167-169. ISBN 0521833426.
[71] Amlie Rorty, Essays on Aristotles Ethics (p. 267), University of California Press, 1980, ISBN 0520040414
[75] Boys-Stones, G., Rowe, C., The Circle of Socrates: Readings in the First-Generation Socratics, Hackett Publishing,
2013, pp. 173-175.
[56] Socrates (Greek philosopher)". Encyclopedia Britannica. Retrieved September 12, 2013.
[80] Nichols, M.P. (1987). Socrates and the Political Community: An Ancient Debate. SUNY Press. p. 67.
13
9 References
Brun, Jean (1978). Socrate (sixth edition). Presses
universitaires de France. pp. 3940. ISBN 2-13035620-6. (French)
May, Hope (2000). On Socrates. Belmont, CA:
Wadsworth. ISBN 0-534-57604-4.
Ong, Walter (2002). Orality and Literacy. New
York: Routledge. ISBN 0-415-28129-6.
Kagan, Donald. The Fall of the Athenian Empire.
First. Ithaca, New York: Cornell University Press,
1987.
Pausanias, Description of Greece. W. H. S. Jones
(translator). Loeb Classical Library. Cambridge,
MA: Harvard University Press; London, William
Heinemann Ltd. (1918). Vol. 1. Books III: ISBN
0-674-99104-4. Vol. 4. Books VIII.22X: ISBN
0-674-99328-4.
Thucydides; The Peloponnesian War. London, J. M.
Dent; New York, E. P. Dutton. 1910.
Vlastos, Gregory (1991). Socrates, Ironist and
Moral Philosopher. Ithaca: Cornell University
Press. ISBN 0-8014-9787-6.
Bernas, Richard, cond. Socrate. By Erik Satie.
LTM/Boutique, 2006
Bruell, C (1994).
On Platos Political Philosophy.
Review of Politics.
56: 26182.
doi:10.1017/s003467050001843x.
[97] Wilson, E.R. (2007). The Death of Socrates: Hero, Villain, Chatterbox, Saint. Prole Books. pp. 6162.
[98] Danzig, G. (2010). Apologizing for Socrates: How Plato
and Xenophon Created Our Socrates. Lexington Books.
pp. 6667.
[99] W. K. C. Guthrie, Socrates, Cambridge University Press,
1971, p. 70.
[100] A.A. Long How Does Socrates Divine Sign Communicate with Him?", Chapter 5 in: A Companion to Socrates,
John Wiley & Sons, 2009, p. 63.
[101] Gomez, Alex (July 10, 2010). Mary Renaults 'The Last
of the Wine' Reviewed. Banderas News. Retrieved
2014-10-14.
[102] Bangs, John Kendrick (1901). A House-Boat on the Styx.
Harper & Bros. pp. 164170. Retrieved 2014-10-14.
14
10
10
External links
Socrates at DMOZ
Nails, Debra. Socrates. Stanford Encyclopedia of
Philosophy.
Ambury, James M. Socrates. Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy.
Socrates at the Indiana Philosophy Ontology Project
EXTERNAL LINKS
15
11
11.1
Socrates Source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Socrates?oldid=738681074 Contributors: Magnus Manske, General Wesc, MichaelTinkler, Brion VIBBER, The Anome, Amillar, Larry Sanger, BenBaker, XJaM, Fubar Obfusco, Karen Johnson, William Avery, Ray Van
De Walker, SimonP, Graft, Hephaestos, Tbarron, AntonioMartin, Elian, Stevertigo, Thomas Mills Hinkle, Patrick, Gbroiles, Gryphon202,
Dhum Dhum, BoNoMoJo (old), Stephen C. Carlson, Ixfd64, Ahoerstemeier, Stan Shebs, William M. Connolley, Snoyes, Kingturtle, Alvaro, Bogdangiusca, LouI, Poor Yorick, Cimon Avaro, Deisenbe, Jeandr du Toit, Evercat, Mxn, Quizkajer, Adam Conover, Mewok, RodC,
Charles Matthews, Adam Bishop, Timwi, EmphasisMine, RickK, Radgeek, Dandrake, WhisperToMe, Hao2lian, SatyrTN, Haukurth, CBDunkerson, Tpbradbury, Dinopup, Furrykef, Buridan, Jim Mahoney, Banno, Pollinator, JorgeGG, Jni, Bearcat, Nufy8, Robbot, Pfortuny,
Mazin07, TomPhil, Fredrik, Kizor, PBS, Wblakesx, RedWolf, Mirv, Merovingian, Academic Challenger, T2space, Timrollpickering, Sunray, Hadal, JackofOz, Aggelophoros, Guy Peters, Cyrius, Nagelfar, Alan Liefting, Jsan, NewSocrates, Centrx, TOO, Giftlite, Christopher
Parham, ScudLee, Oberiko, Sj, Nadavspi, Nunh-huh, Fudoreaper, BenFrantzDale, Tom harrison, Meursault2004, Brian Kendig, Mark
Richards, Obli, Peruvianllama, Everyking, Alison, Gamaliel, WHEELER, Varlaam, Guanaco, Per Honor et Gloria, Beowulf king, Eequor,
Taak, Solipsist, Chameleon, Jackol, Wildt~enwiki, Wmahan, Gadum, Utcursch, Pgan002, Andycjp, Ruy Lopez, Calm, R. end, Gdr, Regin
LARSEN~enwiki, DCrazy, Blankfaze, Antandrus, HorsePunchKid, OverlordQ, Piotrus, Slarto, Jossi, Sean Heron, Rdsmith4, Girolamo
Savonarola, JimWae, Mitaphane, RetiredUser2, Bodnotbod, M.e, Pmanderson, Two Bananas, Arcturus, Beginning, Neutrality, Didactohedron, Trevor MacInnis, Canterbury Tail, Lacrimosus, Chrisbolt, Dryazan, Natrij, Shahab, Freakofnurture, Poccil, Haiduc, Jiy, Discospinster, ElTyrant, Rich Farmbrough, FranksValli, Masudr, FiP, Vsmith, Jpk, Francis Schonken, Peccavimus, Xezbeth, Ponder, Ibagli,
Paul August, Bender235, ESkog, Waxwing slain, Furius, Brian0918, Lycurgus, Kwamikagami, Clayboy, Shanes, Spoon!, Wareh, Bastique,
Bobo192, Vervin, Circeus, Harley peters, Whosyourjudas, Panzuriel, Smalljim, Jguk 2, Pokrajac, Jojit fb, Nk, Darwinek, NickSchweitzer,
Pazouzou, Rje, Cherlin, PWilkinson, Martg76, Alexalderman, Nsaa, Kingsindian, Espoo, Knucmo2, Ranveig, Jumbuck, Jamesmoran,
ChristopherWillis, Eric Kvaalen, Joolz, Visviva, Andrew Gray, ABCD, Riana, Maccoinnich, SlimVirgin, Fwb44, Mailer diablo, Batmanand, InShaneee, Cdc, Plange, Bart133, NTK, DreamGuy, Sir Joseph, Binabik80, Circular~enwiki, Sphivo, Leoadec, VivaEmilyDavies,
Harej, CloudNine, TheMolecularMan, H2g2bob, ThomasWinwood, Versageek, Alai, Zereshk, Redvers, Tobyc75, Kazvorpal, Nudas veritas, Mahanga, Stephen, Gkelly17, Weyes, Thryduulf, Velho, Simetrical, Mel Etitis, OwenX, Woohookitty, Henrik, FeanorStar7, Ptomato,
Blair P. Houghton, TigerShark, Realbrvhrt, MamaGeek, The Brain, GRizzle428, ^demon, Ruud Koot, JeremyA, Lgallindo, Chochopk,
MONGO, Sdgjake, Howabout1, Clemmy, Bkwillwm, Schzmo, Plrk, Pictureuploader, EvilOverlordX, Wayward, Prashanthns, Nema Fakei,
Stefanomione, Dysepsion, MrSomeone, RichardWeiss, Graham87, Noit, Magister Mathematicae, A Train, BD2412, Galwhaa, Deadcorpse, Kbdank71, FreplySpang, Peter Maggs, RxS, NebY, AllanBz, Pmj, Search4Lancer, Canderson7, Sjakkalle, Rjwilmsi, Seidenstud,
Nightscream, Koavf, Quale, CyberGhostface, Supermatt2, Jweiss11, Vary, JHMM13, MZMcBride, Mentality, SMC, Heah, Infosocialist,
The wub, Bhadani, M A Mason, FlavrSavr, Bgura, STarry, Sango123, Yamamoto Ichiro, Leithp, Exeunt, Arivne, FlaBot, RobertG, Musical Linguist, Nihiltres, Crazycomputers, Nivix, RexNL, Gurch, Live4golfjmr, BonreBuddhist, Goudzovski, Dr.Diane Crystal, Piniricc65,
Argyrios Saccopoulos, Joonasl, Planetneutral, BMF81, Abackstrom, King of Hearts, VolatileChemical, Bgwhite, Hall Monitor, Digitalme,
Therefore, Gwernol, Flcelloguy, Roygbiv666, Banaticus, EamonnPKeane, Roboto de Ajvol, YurikBot, Spacepotato, RobotE, Taurrandir,
Kafziel, JAS, RussBot, Killervogel5, Splash, RJC, SpuriousQ, Stephenb, Cryptic, KSchutte, Wimt, Big Brother 1984, NawlinWiki, Matia.gr, Nowa, Wiki alf, Bachrach44, Thunderforge, Aeusoes1, Bwaquin, Chick Bowen, Cquan, Johann Wolfgang, Justin Eiler, Thoughts77,
MiloAndreasWagner, Retired username, Banes, Xdenizen, Philosofool, Blitterbug, Semperf, ICanAlwaysChangeThisLater, Histprof,
RentACop, Dbrs, Lockesdonkey, Kyle Barbour, CDA, DeadEyeArrow, Darkfred, Cze, Tomisti, Nlu, Nick123, Wknight94, Searchme,
Crisco 1492, Ke6jjj, FF2010, Sandstein, 21655, Deville, El benito, Dast, Andrew Lancaster, EarlyBird, Raistolo, Tsimmons, Theda,
Closedmouth, Mike Selinker, Spring Rubber, Fang Aili, E Wing, Pb30, Th1rt3en, Dr.alf, Doktor Waterhouse, MaNeMeBasat, GraemeL,
Haddock420, JoanneB, Barbatus, Scoutersig, Whobot, Anclation~enwiki, Diogo sfreitas, Kungfuadam, Junglecat, GrinBot~enwiki, Bigash,
DVD R W, CIreland, Brentt, Quadpus, Gohto, Mhardcastle, VinceyB, Sardanaphalus, David.hillshafer, Jessica3405, A bit iy, SmackBot, Amcbride, Burtonpe, Selfworm, David Kernow, Reedy, Tarret, InverseHypercube, Larvatus, Hydrogen Iodide, KerryB, McGeddon, Kimon, Pgk, Jacek Kendysz, Davewild, AndreasJS, Anastrophe, Bradtcordeiro, Alksub, Delldot, Monty Cantsin, Dpwkbw, Frymaster, HalfShadow, Ollieollieollie, Gilliam, Jmac800, RJH555, Hmains, Betacommand, Sbz5809, Wilson Delgado, Saros136, Mossman93,
KaragouniS, Quinsareth, Asclepius, Persian Poet Gal, Sandycx, Ordie, Mordac, Grimhelm, Miquonranger03, MalafayaBot, Kashami, Aeidein, SchftyThree, Tetraglot, Interstate295revisited, Go for it!, Baronnet, DHN-bot~enwiki, Slumgum, Darth Panda, Emurphy42, Sct72,
Royboycrashfan, Suicidalhamster, Rvcx, Xchbla423, Can't sleep, clown will eat me, Egsan Bacon, Shalom Yechiel, HoodedMan, Cplakidas, Akhilleus, Tyche151, Addshore, SundarBot, Zincion, Phaedriel, Grover cleveland, AndySimpson, Stevenmitchell, Dharmabum420,
Krich, ConMan, ShadowPanther66, Cybercobra, Cka3n, Nakon, alyosha, Dream out loud, S Roper, Dreadstar, Ryan Roos, Lcarscad,
Andrew c, Stroika, Mtelewicz, KeithB, Judgement~enwiki, N Shar, Risker, Tangsyde, Pilotguy, Kukini, Thejerm, CIS, SashatoBot, Lambiam, Eliyak, Rory096, BrownHairedGirl, TheTruth12, Giovanni33, Kuru, John, AmiDaniel, KlausBartels, Ocee, SilkTork, Disavian,
Ishmaelblues, ACzernek, Edwy, Merchbow, Accurizer, Minna Sora no Shita, Badman89, Goodnightmush, Wren337, IronGargoyle, Outofcommission, Cielomobile, Across.The.Synapse, JHunterJ, Shimmera, David Blyth, Filterking, Slakr, Werdan7, Mr Stephen, Ferhengvan, Emurph, Ravenloft, Funnybunny, Sharnak, Dr.K., RichardF, Jose77, Isokrates, Squirepants101, Hectorian, Tawkerbot, Norm mit,
BranStark, Iridescent, Xinyu, CzarB, Shoeofdeath, J Di, Sjb72, Boreas74, MJO, Dp462090, CapitalR, Richard75, Blehfu, RyanDaniel,
Rojogirl14, Courcelles, Tawkerbot2, Alegoo92, FrenchieAlexandre, JForget, PavelCurtis, Wolfdog, Tanthalas39, Bridesmill, PorthosBot, Comrade42, Lorddakar, Scohoust, Macg4cubeboy, Ruslik0, THF, Dialector, OMGsplosion, Moreschi, Talented Mr Miller, Fordmadoxfraud, Lookingforgroup, MaxEnt, Gregbard, Qrc2006, Nilfanion, Cydebot, Radiohawk, Abeg92, Reeses1066, TheTooth, Reywas92,
ParmenidesII, Atticmouse, Gogo Dodo, Wikipediarules2221, WonderfulWiki, Tawkerbot4, Chrislk02, Nonomy, Lady way, FastLizard4,
Ssilvers, Jamie.a.small, Billyodell, Garik, Mikewax, Fairyre, Omicronpersei8, Zalgo, Daniel Olsen, Lo2u, Gimmetrow, Sesarocks,
Epbr123, Biruitorul, Jastern949, Coelacan, TonyTheTiger, Willworkforicecream, Mime, Urdna, Andyjsmith, Tobz1000, John254, A3RO,
Ctu2485, Merbabu, Davidhorman, Dgies, CharlotteWebb, Tocino, Chillysnow, Spoons For Thought, Mwhs, AntiVandalBot, Chaleyer61,
Docmartincohen, Tangerines, Autocracy, Zurgiea, Julia Rossi, Mal4mac, Dr who1975, Jj137, Jhawk1024, Fayenatic london, D. Webb, Dylan Lake, Credema, Chill doubt, Wisl, Papipaul, Spencer, LegitimateAndEvenCompelling, Stradkid27, Ioeth, JAnDbot, Almwi, Deective,
Husond, NapoliRoma, Barek, MER-C, Dsp13, The Transhumanist, Andrasnm, Matthew Fennell, Instinct, Taospark, Nancehixon, Seddon,
OLP1999, Awien, Johnman239, Coolhandscot, 1nertia, Kerotan, GoodDamon, SteveSims, Cdg1072, Meeples, , Doomhydra,
Starquin, VoABot II, MartinDK, AuburnPilot, Adam keller, ZooTVPopmart, Dhmartin99, Jereydiehl, Rivertorch, Tedickey, Cic, Froid,
Avicennasis, Midgrid, Seski, Catgut, Indon, Ali'i, Nposs, Allstarecho, Schumi555, Vssun, DerHexer, Lukegerard, CCS81, Debashish,
Hbent, RichMac, Kridily, Rickterp, Adriaan, FisherQueen, Vampiretrees, Fullquiver, Hdt83, MartinBot, Phantomsnake, PaulLev, Pdraig
Coogan, Poeloq, AnthonyMastrean, Keith D, Uriel8, Mschel, Tropador, AlexiusHoratius, Creol, Lilac Soul, Pomte, Iamryan365, Tinoket,
16
11
RockMFR, Jira123, J.delanoy, Andrewgigg7, I.mikey, EscapingLife, Numbo3, Athaenara, Jreferee, Brenda maverick, Kyrathnom, Nothingofwater, Gltackett, DanielEng, Chocobear, Crocadog, Brother Ocer, Impy156, Katharineamy, Broker of darkness, Jmohblonde, (jarbarf), Chiswick Chap, Allreet, NewEnglandYankee, Cadwaladr, SJP, Jakea1020, Tanaats, Smitty, MetsFan76, Khokhar976, Tonytula,
Atheuz, Cometstyles, Evb-wiki, Vanished user 39948282, VicVega123, Natl1, Pdcook, Inwind, JavierMC, Useight, Vinsfan368, Idiomabot, Spellcast, Idarin, Jonas Mur~enwiki, Christopher Mann McKay, Deor, Hammersoft, VolkovBot, Johnfos, Orphic, CSumit, Rucha58,
Hersfold, Laurent1976~enwiki, Jmrowland, Nburden, Orthologist, Joeveale, Bsroiaadn, Chitrapa, Barneca, Suprcel, Amboisvert, Philip
Trueman, Af648, TXiKiBoT, Eeldrop, Tgrams, FitzColinGerald, Solidwolf19, Ridernyc, Anonymous Dissident, Leon Blade, Mocko13,
Brett epic, Qxz, Lradrama, Ontoraul, Seraphim, MackSalmon, GregX102, Broadbot, Abdullais4u, Kmcc138, LeaveSleaves, Delbert Grady,
Starseeker shkm, Cremepu222, Jeeny, Pishogue, Anarchangel, Redrocker, Jermerc, Maxim, Isis4563, Themat21III, Chillowack, Leopabe,
Billinghurst, RandomXYZb, Enigmaman, BobTheTomato, Synthebot, Aweihgiwurhg, Wikidan829, JesterCountess, Sylent, Kazra61,
Dorkules, WatermelonPotion, HiDrNick, Dessymona, Cindamuse, AlleborgoBot, Symane, TehPoep, Malachiluke, Legoktm, Mustard9000,
Nick Denkens, EmxBot, Xolaam, Givegains, Demmy, AHMartin, Cosprings, Newbyguesses, EJF, MikeRumex, SieBot, Negrot, iginnte,
Whiskey in the Jar, Jwray, Jpdohler, Tresiden, Fixer1234, Tiddly Tom, Scarian, Meldor, Callipides~enwiki, Invisible Noise, Mikeg2000,
Caltas, Rainbowparakeet1996, Triwbe, I, Podius, Keilana, Footballman101, Tiptoety, Oda Mari, Sbowers3, Filos96, Jarrod1937, Oxymoron83, BjrnEF, Avnjay, Steven Crossin, Poindexter Propellerhead, QuinnTheAspie, Techman224, BenoniBot~enwiki, Aiden Fisher,
Kostatoronto3, Mitya1, Vanished user ewsn2348tui2f8n2o2utjfeoi210r39jf, Hsf-toshiba, Winterheat, Tradereddy, Doom2099, Burtonwilliams, JL-Bot, Myrvin, Troy 07, Naturespace, ImageRemovalBot, Lucascp, Athenean, Schipbob, Martarius, Linkycheng, ClueBot, SouthernThule, Bratz10019, Wikievil666, Postmortemjapan, Headpantsnow, Jan1nad, Lawrence Cohen, RODERICKMOLASAR,
Herakles01, Leavemeto, Franamax, Nealal, Seanwhim(evil), Mogtheforgetfulcat, Migz Nexus, Timberframe, Hafspajen, Ryoutou, CounterVandalismBot, Blanchardb, Ashmedai 119, CptCutLess, LisaMarie777, Singinglemon~enwiki, Neverquick, Puchiko, Privatemusings,
Liltikigrl nhw, Mspraveen, Handcloud returns, Tyleer1, Somno, Dawn suns, Robert Skyhawk, Bagworm, Jusdafax, Greencircle, WikiZorro, Mwasheim, Nada Issa, Abrech, Gtstricky, Vivio Testarossa, Lartoven, Godluke4, Manomre, Scottydo09, Cenarium, Monty88,
Sbfw, JamieS93, Ember of Light, Prince eagle, Kwright4, AliciaSim, Sprrinkles, Polly, BK4ME, Thehelpfulone, Calor, Aprock, Bald Zebra, Catalographer, Thingg, Aitias, BVBede, RQAYOOM, Juggernaut12, Emubob59, Ginandlove, Jaaches, Finalnight, Chronicler~enwiki,
Bletchley, XLinkBot, AgnosticPreachersKid, Gladwellnicola, Freshbakedpie, Lolmonger, Madmartigan1340, SilvonenBot, Cubecubecube,
Mifter, Jigen8, Vegas949, Padfoot79, Noctibus, Good Olfactory, Collegekdr, EEng, Spacecadet8, Madabe, Kbdankbot, Janinho, Paperfaye, Addbot, Wran, Cooldood221, Kenkenkenkenyay, Grkballa94, Dude its nick, Beamathan, Imhairy, M.nelson, DougsTech, LightSpectra, Older and ... well older, The Alan Smithee, Zomgallthenamesaretaken, CanadianLinuxUser, Leszek Jaczuk, MrOllie, Mentisock,
Download, Jackabaw, Flowgam, CarsracBot, Bassbonerocks, Spittlespat, XxHikari, LinkFA-Bot, Dudedeek, AgadaUrbanit, Numbo3-bot,
Asargent275, Vikaszt, Rottenotten, Wiggles77, Tide rolls, Lightbot, Jojocool117, TCKOTB, Teles, Zorrobot, BennyQuixote, Monsosa22,
Jarble, Luckas-bot, Yobot, 2D, JJARichardson, Tohd8BohaithuGh1, Cm001, Tp 2k7, SEMTEX85, THEN WHO WAS PHONE?, James
Cantor, KamikazeBot, Knownot, Palamabron, IW.HG, AnomieBOT, Rubinbot, Bsimmons666, JackieBot, Wikipedian132, EryZ, Materialscientist, Jacksonroberts25, Rtyq2, Citation bot, D.bryan.coalt, Bob Burkhardt, MoeMan08, Tahu9050, Frankenpuppy, Neurolysis, Gemtpm, TheRealNightRider, Xqbot, Timir2, Allaboardington, PrometheusDesmotes, , Ched, Almabot, GrouchoBot, Ute
in DC, Omnipaedista, RibotBOT, IPlayBbAll, GhalyBot, Zosterops, FreeKnowledgeCreator, FrescoBot, Sokratka, Endofskull, DtemiankaHT, OreL.D, Servus Triviae, Startarrant, Pinethicket, I dream of horses, Blubro, Dazedbythebell, Codwiki, RedBot, Hessamnia,
AustralianMelodrama, C messier, Electricmaster, 0zlw, Greco22, TobeBot, Retired user 0001, Standardfact, Crowe86, Vrenator, Aurorion, Hellomate1224, Brian the Editor, Satdeep Gill, Tbhotch, Whisky drinker, TjBot, Bento00, Flatbmx, Xindhus, Peaceworld111,
Mandolinface, DASHBot, DiogenesTCP, EmausBot, Mzilikazi1939, WikitanvirBot, Gfoley4, Dewritech, Syncategoremata, ZxxZxxZ,
Mo ainm, J. Clef, Tommy2010, Euclidthalis, Evanh2008, AvicBot, Kkm010, ZroBot, PBS-AWB, Hydao, A2soup, AvicAWB, Aeonx,
AndrewOne, Neddy1234, Brandmeister, NichlausRN, Chewings72, ChuispastonBot, Herk1955, ClueBot NG, GoetheFromm, AerobicFox, Alis9, Snotbot, Braincricket, Oxford73, Ryan Vesey, Helpful Pixie Bot, BG19bot, Pine, LouisAlain, Nachhattardhammu, Davidiad,
Zsgoldberg, Blue Mist 1, Drift chambers, Rowan Adams, MeanMotherJr, Bill.D Nguyen, Arr4, Funeralunicorn, ChrisGualtieri, Vanished user sdij4rtltkjasdk3, Asisman, All Worlds, Dexbot, Musicnotes117, Mogism, Jackninja5, Bonesforsure, VIAFbot, REfreakk5555,
Me, Myself, and I are Here, Hillbillyholiday, BreakfastJr, NHCLS, Jodosma, 7532665a, Carol788, ArmbrustBot, Sophiahounslow, JiggyWittit, Pietro13, Inanygivenhole, MagicatthemovieS, 08opateman, Mathscienced, Gunduu, Trackteur, Statelaw1944, Rpearlstuart, Tetra
quark, Grandevampire, Whalestate, Mj thenovelatre, Nkkenbuer, KasparBot, BobBobson43, Eperoton, IhateINORDER, Kirk Leonard,
Reallysomething123 and Anonymous: 1585
11.2
Images
11.3
Content license
17
11.3
Content license