2016 / / -

The Mediator Impact of Behavioral Integrity for Leader in the

Relationship Between Workplace Spirituality and
Organizational Commitment
Analytical Research to a Sample Opinions from Members of
the Teaching Staff at the University of Karbala

. .
/ /

fehrer313@yahoo.com

..
/ /

Huss5ien@yahoo.com

,
, , , (
)Simons et al. , 2007( )Kinjerski & Skrypnek , 2006( )
, , ( ,
)Allen & Meyer , 1990( )
( . ) 161(
)
.)Baron & Kenny , 1986(

. ,

Abstract
This research seeks to identify the mediator role of behavioral integrity for the leader in the
relationship between workplace spirituality and organizational commitment, and in order to
achieve this has been the adoption of the dimensions of workplace spirituality (engaging work,
sense of community, spiritual connection and mystical experience) based on the (Kinjerski &
Skrypnek, 2006) was the based of the Scale (Simons et al., 2007) for measure of behavioral
integrity for Leader , as has been the adoption of dimensions of organizational commitment
(affective commitment, continuous commitment, and normative commitment) based on (Allen &
Meyer, 1990) . Has been chosen some faculties of the University of Karbala a field to search
through a questionnaire form included 161 members of the faculty. Have been using
confirmatory factor analysis (Structural equation modeling) and some of descriptive statistics,
correlation analysis and simple regression analysis and multiple regression analysis, according to
a in the test of mediator variable set out in the study (Baron & Kenny, 1986) . Has been reached
to a set of conclusions that of the most important that variable of the behavioral integrity for
Leader of partially mediates the relationship between workplace spirituality and the
organizational commitment at the level the educational environment in the colleges of the
University of Karbala, research has concluded a number of appropriate recommendations .

190

 - /2016 /

,

, .


. ( )
.
,
,
, .
:
:
:

,


,
.
:
(
)
:
,
(
) ,

,

( )
( ) ( ).
:
:
.1 .
.2 .
.3 .
.4
.
.5 .
:
:
.1 : , ( )Kinjerski & Skrypnek, 2006
, : ( )7 , ()3
, )3( , ( )5 .
.2 : , ( )Simons et al. , 2007
, )8( .

191

 - /2016 /
.3 : , ( )Allen & Meyer , 1990
, : )8( , ( )8 ,
( )8.
( )Cronbach's Alpha . . )1(
( : )1

EW

SAW

SOC

& Kinjerski
Skrypnek,
2006

BIL

OC

SC

ME

1-7

AC

CC

NC

8-10
11-13

0.798

14-18
Simons et al. ,
2006

(
)

19-26

0.849

27-34
& Allen
Meyer , 1990

35-42

0.813

43-50

: .
:
:
: ( ,
.1
, , ) .
: .
.2
:
.3
( , , , ) .
:

, ,
(.)1

H1

( : )1

192

H2
H3

 - /2016 /
:
-1 : ( )7 ( ,
, , , , ,
).
-2 : ( ) 2015 / 9 / 14 , ) 2015 / 12 / 16(
.
:

( )187 ,
( )161 ( )14 )12( , )2(
.
( : )2

- 53

- 46

53

53

35

76

53

11 -1

01-11

111

35

15

60

65

37

- 01

51

: .
:

() .
, , ( )Likert ( )1-5
( . ) 1 ( ) ,
, , , ,
)SPSS V.20( (. )Amos V.21
:

:
: Workplace Spirituality
,
, 1920 , 1990 ,
, , ,
( )Giacalone & Jurkiewicz , 2005 : 515
. ()Ashmos & Duchon , 2000 : 135
.
( )Marschke et al. , 2009 : 36 ,
, .Karakas , 2010 : 7-(
) 9
, ( ) Denton
,
,
.

,
, , ( )Belwalkar , 2012 : 4-5 ( & Bhunia
) Das , 2012 : 1-2
,
.

193

 - /2016 /
( ) Wainaina et al. , 2014 : 282


.
, ,
, ( , , , ,)

)Ajala , 2013 : 4( .
( Nicou ,
) 2002 : 3-4

,

(.)Petchsawanga & Duchon , 2012 : 190-191
,
,
, ( Makgoba
) , 2014 : 41-42
( )Geigle , 2012 : 14-15 ( )Mcghee & Grant , 2008 : 66-67
,

,

.

,,
,
. ( )Kinjerski & Skrypnek, 2006
( )7 , ( )3 , )3( , ()5
,
.
: Behavioral Integrity for Leader

Palanski & Yammarino , (
) 2010 : 203 - 204 ,

)Prottas , 2008 : 313(
( )Palanski & Yammarino , 2011 : 767 :


. ( )Prottas , 2013 : 52

,
.
)Simons , 1999 : 90(
,

,
.
( )Moorman & Grover , 2009 : 104-105 ,
, .
( ) Simons , 2013 : 392

194

 - /2016 /

. ( )Hannes et al. , 2012 : 1

.
( )Palanski & Vogelgesang , 2011 : 259


,
.
,
. )Simons et al. , 2007 : 561(
( ) Hung , 2011 : 52-53 ,
.

(.)Simons , 2008 : 7
( ) Moorman et al. , 2012 : 2
,
.
()Martin et al. , 2013 : 446-447
( )Moorman et al. , 2013 : 428
,
( )
, .

, , , , ,
. ( ) Tony L. Simons ,
( )Simons et al. , 2007
( )8 .
: Organizational Commitment

,
, ,
,
, . ( )Chen et al. , 2002 : 339
,
.
)Lagomarsino & Cardona , 2003 : 5(
, , . ( Gardner et al. , 2008
) : 5-6

. )Tatlah et al. , 2011 : 1294(
.
)Radillo et al. , 2011 : 121( . ( )Hassanzadeh , 2011 : 536

.
( )Emami & Darabi , 2012 : 10148

.
( ) Guag et al. , 2015 : 4
. ( )Moynihan & Pandey , 2007 : 3-4

. ( )Cheasakul & Varma , 2015 : 1

195

 - /2016 /

.


( ) Khan et al. , 2014 : 897

( )Brockner & Senior , 2010 : 4

(.)Kappagoda , 2013 : 3
,

.
( )Allen & Meyer , 1990 , ,
: )8( , ( )8 , )8( .
:

,
, :
:

,
,
,
,
( , )Albright & Park , 2009 : 3
( . )Amos Version 21
)Schumacker & Lomax, 2010 : 169( :
.1 ( : )Parameter Estimates ( )Latent Var.
( )Unobserved Var.
( , )%0.40
,
(.)Holtzman & Sailesh , 2011 : 13( )C.R
.2 ()Model Fit Index's
.
)3( .
:

( )2 ( )0.40
,
( )C.R 1 ( )1.96 ( )0.05
.
, )4(
( )18 )4( .
: )3( ()Amos V. 21

( )2 ()2CIMN/df

( )0.05 , ()0.02

1 ( )2 .
)CIMN( 2 , ( )2
,
()Byrne , 2010 : 75( )CIMN/df( : )Amos V. 21

196

 - /2016 /
2

()GFI

()NFI

(The Comparative Fit Index )CFI

()RFI

()IFI

()TLI

()RMSEA
The Root Mean Square Error of Approximation

The Goodness-of-Fit Index

, ( )0.05
)1 - 0(
()0.90

The Normed Fit Index

The Relative Fit Index

, )1 - 0(
( )0.90 ( )0.95

The Incremental Fit Index

The Tucker-Lewis Index
( )0.05 , - 0.05(
)0.08 , )0.10 - 0.08(
, ( )0.10

: ()Byrne , 2010 : 73-84

( : )2
: ()Amos 21

197

 - /2016 /
( : )4

CIMN/df

04046

GFI

04915

NFI

04909

CFI

04918

RFI

04951

IFI

04962

TLI

04930

RMSEA

0.071

: ()Amos V. 21

( )3 ()0.40
,
( )C.R ( )2 ( )1.96 ( )0.05
.
, )5(
.

( : )3
: ()Amos 21

198

 - /2016 /
( : )5

CIMN/df

04051

GFI

04904

NFI

04931

CFI

04977

RFI

04902

IFI

04958

TLI

04911

RMSEA

0.058

: ()Amos V. 21

( ) 4 ( )0.40
,
( )C.R ( )2 ( )1.96 ( )0.05
.
, )6(
( )8.

( : )4
: ()Amos 21

199

 - /2016 /
( : )6

CIMN/df

04039

GFI

04901

NFI

04936

IFI

04965

TLI

04997

CFI

04921

RFI

04941

0.082

RMSEA

: ()Amos V. 21

:
)7( ( M ) SD
, :

( : )7
M
SD
1
2
3
4
5

Variables

0.45

3.18

EW

.120

0.49

3.39

SOC

.032

**.255

0.57

3.17

SC

.092

.024

.047

0.54

3.20

ME

**.315

**.355

**.378

**.287

0.36

3.17

BIL

**.450

**.366

**.249

**.405

**.283

3300

03.3

OC

P** < 0.01 , N=161 .

: (.)SPSS

.1
)7( ( SOC=3.39 , ME=3.20 ,
)EW=3.18 , SC=3.17 ( )3 ,
( )SOC=0.49 , ME=0.54 , EW=0.45 , SC=0.57
,
.
.2
)7( ( )3.17
( )3 , )0.36(

.
.3
)7( ( )3.25
( )3 , )0.33(

.

, )7( ,
)0.450-0.249(
.

200

 - /2016 /
:
( Multiple Regression
)Analysis ( )Simple Regression Analysis ()F
( )B ( )t ( )R2
, :
.1
)8(
.
( : )8

BIL
Constant

EW
SOC
SC

.162

ME

Sig.

.350

5.926

.000

.330

5.771

.000

.466

7.918

.000

.349

6.135

.000

R2

.500

Sig.

39.073

.000

: (4)SPSS
: )8(
( )F ( )39.073 .
.
2
( ) R ( ).500 )% 50.0(
. ( )%50.0 .
( SC=.466 , EW=.350 , ME=.349 , ( )Beta
.
)SOC=.330 )t( . )8(
.
.2
)9(
.
( : )9

N=161

OC
Constant

Sig.

R2

Sig.

BIL
N=161
: (.)SPSS
: )9(
( )F ( )40.342 .
.
( ) R2 ( ).202 )%20.2( .
( )%79.8 .
( ).450( )Beta ( )t . )9(
.
)1( ( ).450 .
.
2.156

.450

6.351

201

.000

0.202

40.342

.000

 - /2016 /
.3

( , , , ) .
( )Mediation Model Test :
()Baron & Kenny , 1986 : 1176-1177
,
.
.
,
.
.
. . :
.1
( )Partial Mediator .
.2 ( )Beta
( )Perfect mediation ,

.
)8(
( , , , ) ( )
. )9( ( )
.
)10( ,
( ,
, , ) .

.
( : )10

OC
Con
.

EW

SOC
SC

5.625 .315
.606

ME
SOC

ME

BIL

6.548 .354
6.864 .382

.485

EW
SC

9.002

.000
.000

5.724 .341

.000

.526

8.797

: (.)SPSS

202

.552

484045

.000

4.827 .259

7.862 .429

.000

.000

5.678 .296
.590

Sig.

R2

Chang
e R2

.000
.000

.560

.008

394434

.000

N=161

 - /2016 /
)10( :
( )F ( )48.045 . ( )R ( ).552
.1
)%55.2( .
( )%44.8 .
( ) ( ME=.485 , SC=.382 , SOC=.354 ,
.2

)EW=.315 )t( . )10(

.
)10( :
( )F ( )39.434 . ( )R2 ( ).560
.1
( ).008
( ) .
( )Beta :
.2

,
.
( )Beta ( )B=.315 )B=.259( .
,
.
( )Beta ( )B=.354 )B=.296( .
,
.
( )Beta )B=.382( )B=.341( .
,
.
( )Beta ( )B=.485 )B=.429( .
2

( ) (
) ( ) )Baron & Kenny , 1986 : 1177(
( )Sobel . ( )Sobel Test
( )Preacher & Loenardelli , 2001 .
:
= )a( .1 .
= )b( .2 (
).
= )Sa( .3 (.)a
= )Sb( .4 (.)b
( )Sobel Test ( )P - value .
( )11 .

203

 - /2016 /

( : )11 ()Sobel

a , Sa = EW-BIL
b , Sb = EW-BIL-OC

a , Sa = SOC-BIL
b , Sb = SOC-BIL-OC

a , Sa = SC-BIL
b , Sb = SC-BIL-OC

a , Sa = ME-BIL
b , Sb = ME-BIL-OC

Sobel

a=.288
b=.146
Sa=.060
Sb=.045

.3322

a=.274
b=.146
Sa=.053
Sb=.042

.3..3

a=.222
b=.315
Sa=.046
Sb=.059

3.580

a=.207
b=.178
Sa=.049
Sb=.036

3.212

P-value

.039

.003

.000

.001

: (.)Sobel
)11( )P - value(
.
:
:
, :
.1
,
,
.
.2
,
.
.3 , ,

.
.4

,
.
.5 ,


.

204

 - /2016 /
.6

, , ,
.
.7
, , , ,


.
.8



.
.9
,


.
:
, :
.1
, :
.
.
. , , ,
.
.
, , .
.
.
.
.
.2 ,
:
.
.
.
.
.
.
. ,

.

.
()
.
.3
, :
.
.

205

2016 / / -
.
.
.

.
.
.
.
.
.4

.
.5


.

Ajala, E. (2013) " The Impact of Workplace Spirtuality and Employees Wellbeing at The
Industrial Sector: The Nigerian Experience ", The African Symposium: An online journal of
the African Educational Research Network, Vol. 13, No. 2, December, Pp. 3-13.
2. Brockner, J. & Senior, D. (2010) " Corporate Volunteerism, the Experience of a Positive SelfConcept, and Organizational Commitment: Evidence from Two Field Studies ", Columbia
Business School Research, SSRN, October 12, pp. 1-33.
3. Benefiel, M. & W.Fry, L. & Geigle, D. (2014) " Spirituality and Religion in the Workplace:
History, Theory, and Research ", American Psychological Association, Psychology of Religion
and Spirituality, Vol. 6, No. 3, pp. 175187.
4. Bhunia, A. & Das, S. (2012) " Explore the Impact of Workplace Spirituality on Motivations for
Earnings Management-An Empirical Analysis ", International Journal of Scientific and
Research Publications, Volume 2, Issue 2, February, Pp. 1-5.
5. Belwalkar, S. (2014) " Workplace Spirituality ", https://www.inter-disciplinary.net/publishing/?
6. Chen, Z. , Tsui, A. & Farh, J. (2002) " Loyalty to supervisor vs. organizational commitment:
Relationships to employee performance in China ", Journal of Occupational and Organizational
Psychology ,75, Pp. 339356.
7. Cheasakul , U. & Varma , P. (2015) " The Influence of Passion and Empowerment on
Organizational Citizenship Behavior of Teachers in Assumption University Mediated by
Organizational Commitment ", XIV International Business and Economy Conference,
Bangkok, Thailand, January 58, pp. 1-19.
8. Emami, M. & Darabi, M. (2012) " Organizational commitment and the implications for
employees and organizations ", Elixir Psychology 49 , pp. 10147-10151.
9. Gardner, T. , Moynihan, L. & Wright, P. (2008) " The Influence of Human Resource Practices
and Collective Affective Organizational Commitment on Aggregate Voluntary Turnover ",
Cornell University ILR School,March 6, pp.1-43.
10. Geigle, D. (2012) " Workplace Spirituality Empirical Research: A Literature Review ",
Business and Management Review Vol. 2(10), December, pp. 14-27.
11. Guay, R. , Choi, D. , Oh, I. , Mitchell, M. , Mount, M. & Shin, K. (2015) " Why People Harm
the Organization and Its Members: Relationships among Personality, Organizational
Commitment, and Workplace Deviance ", Human Performance, January 16, Pp. 1-36.
12. Hannes, L. , Dierynck B, A. , Simons, T. , Halbesleben, M., Savage , S. (2012) " Behavioral
integrity for safety, priority of safety, psychological safety, and patient safety: a team-level
study ", J App Psychol, Nov 97(6), Pp. 1-27.
1.

206

2016 / / -
13. Hassanzadeh, H., Emami, M. , Beiruti, M. , Ghasemi, R. & Fahimi, V. (2011) " Job
Appropriateness Survey and its Relationship with Staff Organizational Commitment (The Case
Study in National Iranian Oil Refining and Distribution Company ", European Journal of
Scientific Research, Vol.58 No.4, Pp .532-541.
14. Hung, Y. (2011) " Exploring Core Values Moderating Perceived Leader Behavioral Integrity
and Trust: A Contractarian Perspective ", Department of Business Administration National Sun
Yat-sen University Doctorate Dissertation, Pp. 1-130.
15. Karakas, F. (2010) " Spirituality and Performance in Organizations: A Literature Review ",
Journal of Business Ethics, 94(1), pp. 89106.
16. Khan, M. & Din, Z. (2010) " The impact of Organizational Commitment on Employees Job
Performance. A study of Oil and Gas sector of Pakistan ", International Islamic University,
Islamabad, SSRN, March 14, Pp.1-15.
17. Khan, N. , Awang, M. ,& Ghouri, A. (2014) " Organizational Commitment Construct :
Validity Measure Using SEM ", Sci.Int.(Lahore),26(2), Pp.897-902.
18. Kappagoda, S. (2013) " The Impact of Five Factor Model of Personality on Organizational
Commitment of English Teachers in Srilankan Government Schools ", International Journal of
Physical and Social Sciences, Volume 3, Issue 1, Pp. 1-10.
19. Lagomasino, R. & Cardona, P. (2003) " Relationships Among Leadership Organizational
Commitment and OCB in Uruguayan Health Institutions " , IESE, Business School, University
of Navarra, No 494, February , Pp. 1-20.
20. Lee, J. & Kim, S. (2011) " Exploring the Role of Social Networks in Affective Organizational
Commitment: Network Centrality, Strength of Ties, and Structural Holes ", The American
Review of Public Administration, 41(2), Pp. 205 223.
21. Lovakov, A. (2014) " Antecedents and Consequences of Organizational Commitment Among
Russian University Teachers ", National Research University Higher School of Economics
(Moscow), December 31, No30 psy, Pp 1-19.
22. Martin, G. , Keating, M. , Resick, C. , Szabo, E. , Kwan, H. & Peng, C. (2013) " The meaning
of leader integrity: A comparative study across Anglo, Asian, and Germanic cultures ", The
Leadership Quarterly 24, Pp. 445461.
23. Makgoba, T., A.JApril, K. & Al Ariss., A. (2014) " Understanding Spirituality at Work,
Organizations and in Management ", University of Cape Town. South Africa, Pp. 41-52.
24. Mcknight, R. (1984) " Spirituality in the Workplace ", Miles River Press.
25. McGhee, P. & Grant, P. (2008) " Spirituality and Ethical Behavior in the Workplace: Wishful
Thinking or Authentic Reality ", EJBO Electronic Journal of Business Ethics and Organization
Studies, Vol. 13, No. 2, Pp. 61-69.
26. Mitroff, L. & Denton, E. (1999) " A study of spirituality in the Workplace ", Sloan
management Review, summer, Pp. 83-92.
27. Moynihan, D. & Pandey, S. (2007) " Finding Workable Levers over Work Motivation:
Comparing Job Satisfaction, Job Involvement and Organizational Commitment ", La Follette
School of Public Affairs, at the University of Wisconsin-Madison, No3, Pp. 1-45.
28. Moorman, R. & Grover, S. (2009) " Why Does Leader Integrity Matter to Followers? An
Uncertainty Management-Based Explanation ", International Journal of Leadership Studies,
Vol. 5 Issue. 2, Pp. 102-114.
29. Moorman, R. , Darnold, T. , Priesemuth, M. & Dunn, C. (2012) " Toward the Measurement of
Perceived Leader Integrity: Introducing a Multidimensional Approach ", Journal of Change
Management, 14 November, Pp. 1-16.
30. Moorman, R. , Darnold, T. & Priesemuth, M. (2013) " Perceived leader integrity: Supporting
the construct validity and utility of a multi-dimensional measure in two samples ", The
Leadership Quarterly 24, Pp. 427444.
31. Muir, C. (2007) " Managerial Integrity: Are Black Employees More Sensitive to Behavioral
Breaches ", Academy of Management Perspectives, Vol. 21, No. 4 ,Novmber, pp. 77-78.

207

2016 / / -
32. Nicou, K. (2002) " Spirituality in The Workplace : What are the Implications For Modern
Organizations As Society Embraces New Concepts of Spiritualism? ". Extracts from
Spirituality in the Workplace, pp .1-17.
33. Palanski, M. , Kahai, S. & Yammarino, F. (2010) " Team Virtues and performance: An
Examination of Transparency, Behavioral integrity and Trust " , springer, Journal of Business
Ethics 99, Pp. 201-216.
34. Palanski, M. & Yammarino, F. (2011) " Impact of behavioral integrity on follower Job
performance: A Three-study examination ", The Leadership Quarterly 22, Pp. 765-786.
35. Palanski, M. & Yammarino, F. (2009) " Integrity and leadership: A multi-level conceptual
framework ", The Leadership Quarterly 20 , Pp. 405420.
36. Palanski, M. & Vogelgesang, G. (2011) " Virtuous Creativity: The Effects of Leader
Behavioural Integrity on Follower Creative Thinking and Risk Taking ", Canadian Journal of
Administrative Sciences, 28, pp. 259269.
37. Petchsawanga, P. & Duchon, D. (2012) " Workplace Spirituality, Meditation, and Work
Performance ", Published in Journal of Management, Spirituality & Religion 9:2 ,June, pp.
189- 208.
38. Prottas, D. (2008) " Perceived Behavioral integrity: Relationships with Employee Attitudes,
Well-Being, and Absenteeism ", springer, Journal of Business Ethics 81, Pp. 313-322.
39. Prottas, D. (2013) " Relationships Among Employee Perception of Their Managers
Behavioral Integrity, Moral Distress, and Employee Attitudes and Well-Being " , Journal of
Business Ethics 113, Pp. 51-60.
40. Radillo, S., Jimnez, A. & Prieto, R. (2011) " EL Compromiso Organizational Del Personal
Administrative EN UNA Universidad Publica " , Revista International Adminstracion &
Finanzas, Volumen 4 , Numero 4 , Pp. 121-131.
41. Simons, T. (1999) " Behavioral integrity as a critical ingredient for transformational leadership
", Journal of Organizational Change Management, Vol. 12 No. 2, pp. 89-104.
42. Simons, T. , Friedman, R. , Liu, L. & Parks, J. (2007) " Racial Differences in Sensitivity to
Behavioral Integrity: Attitudinal Consequences, In-Group Effects, and Trickle Down Among
Black and Non-Black Employees ", Journal of Applied Psychology, Vol 92, No3, Pp. 650-665.
43. Simons, T. , Friedman, R. , Liu, L. & Parks, J. (2008) " The Importance of Behavioral Integrity
in a Multicultural Workplace ", The Center for Hospitality Research, Cornell University, Pp.
6-16.
44. Simons, T. (2013) " Toward a broader but still rigorous definition of leader integrity:
Commentary ", The Leadership Quarterly 24, pp. 391394.
45. Tatlah, I. , Ali, Z. & Saeed, M. (2011) " Leadership Behavior and Organizational
Commitment: An Empirical Study of Educational Professionals ", International Journal of
Academic Research , Vol. 3. No. 2. March, Part IV, Pp. 1293-1298.
46. Wainaina, L. , Iravo, M. & Waititu, A. (2014) " Workplace Spirituality as a Determinant of
Organizational Commitment amongst Academic Staff in the Private and Public Universities in
Kenya ", International Journal of Academic Research in Business and Social Sciences,
December , Vol. 4, No. 12, Pp. 280-293.
: )1(


/
(
) :
,
.
: ,
. ) ( .1

208

 - /2016 /
.2 , .
.3 .
,
.

:

. :
:

. :
. :
. :

: :
, , ,
.
.1 :

1
.
2 .
3 .
4 .
,
5
.
6 .
7 , .
.2 :

8
.

9
.
10 "" .
.3 :

11
.
12 .

13
.

209

 - /2016 /

.4 :

14
15
16
17
18

, " " .

.
,
.

.
,
.

: : , , , ,
, .

1 .
2 .
3 .
4 .
5 .
6 .
,
7
.
8 , .
: :

.
.1 :

1 .
2 .
3 .
4 .
5 .
6 .
7 .
8
, .

210

 - /2016 /
.2 :

9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16

.
,

.
.
, .

.

.3 :

17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24

,
.

.

.
.

( : )2

P

C.R.

S.E.

***
***
***
***
***
***

15.177
13.542
11.986
9.603
8.908
13.765

.062
.059
.073
.081
.098
.064

***
***
***
***
***

13.190
11.056
14.162
12.755
10.310

.084
.089
.043
.039
.038

***
***
***
***

11.819
11.757
12.490
13.747

.105
.103
.104
.099

Estimate
1.000
.941
.799
.875
.778
.873
.881
1.000
1.108
.984
.609
.625
.598
1.000
1.241
1.211
1.299
1.361

Engaging in Work
Engaging in Work
Engaging in Work
Engaging in Work
Engaging in Work
Engaging in Work
Engaging in Work
Sense of Community
Sense of Community
Sense of Community
Spiritual Connection
Spiritual Connection
Spiritual Connection
Mystical Experience
Mystical Experience
Mystical Experience
Mystical Experience
Mystical Experience

211

<--<--<--<--<--<--<--<--<--<--<--<--<--<--<--<--<--<---

EW7
EW6
EW5
EW4
EW3
EW2
EW1
SOC3
SOC2
SOC1
SC3
SC2
SC1
ME5
ME4
ME3
ME2
ME1

2016 / / -

BIL8
BIL7
BIL6
BIL5
BIL4
BIL3
BIL2
BIL1

AC8
AC7
AC6
AC5
AC4
AC3
AC2
AC1
CC8
CC7
CC6
CC5
CC4
CC3
CC2
CC1
NC8
NC7
NC6
NC5
NC4
NC3
NC2
NC1

<--<--<--<--<--<--<--<---

<--<--<--<--<--<--<--<--<--<--<--<--<--<--<--<--<--<--<--<--<--<--<--<---

Behavioral Integrity of Leader

Behavioral Integrity of Leader
Behavioral Integrity of Leader
Behavioral Integrity of Leader
Behavioral Integrity of Leader
Behavioral Integrity of Leader
Behavioral Integrity of Leader
Behavioral Integrity of Leader

Affective Commitment
Affective Commitment
Affective Commitment
Affective Commitment
Affective Commitment
Affective Commitment
Affective Commitment
Affective Commitment
Continuance Commitment
Continuance Commitment
Continuance Commitment
Continuance Commitment
Continuance Commitment
Continuance Commitment
Continuance Commitment
Continuance Commitment
Normative Commitment
Normative Commitment
Normative Commitment
Normative Commitment
Normative Commitment
Normative Commitment
Normative Commitment
Normative Commitment

212

Estimate
1.000
.893
.920
.882
.753
.829
.797
.971

Estimate
1.000
.839
.917
.844
.872
.790
.826
.839
1.000
1.045
1.191
1.283
1.411
.913
1.166
.997
1.000
.569
.398
.471
.633
.436
.399
.463

S.E.

C.R.

.097
.093
.086
.082
.090
.087
.085

9.206
9.892
10.255
9.182
9.211
9.160
11.423

***
***
***
***
***
***
***

S.E.

C.R.

.097
.082
.089
.079
.071
.072
.084

8.649
11.182
9.483
11.037
11.126
11.472
9.9880

***
***
***
***
***
***
***

.094
.092
.101
.098
.100
.104
.106

11.117
12.945
12.702
14.397
9.13
11.211
9.405

***
***
***
***
***
***
***

.057
.039
.048
.051
.034
.042
.036

9.9824
10.201
9.812
12.411
12.823
9.5
12.861

***
***
***
***
***
***
***