October 25, 2016

An Open Letter to the Administration of the University of Toronto

First of all, we would like to commend and thank you for agreeing to host the series of
debates proposed to you by Professor Peterson. We believe that this is a step in the right
direction, and are looking forward to witnessing what constitutes an example of a free and
reasoned exchange of ideas on campus. We believe that fostering a climate where all topics, no
matter how controversial, are up for intellectual exploration is one of the fundamental functions
of a post-secondary institution, and, as such, we applaud the Universitys decision to host the
debates.
Nevertheless, we continue to be disturbed and appalled by the incidents that took place at
the Free Speech rally on October 11, 2016, and, most of all, by the Universitys response to the
aftermath of the event. We came to the rally to express our views in a respectful manner; we
were instead silenced by members of the UTSU and the Black Liberation Collective (BLC), then
slandered by members of these same groups, and finally left aghast at our administrations failure
to protect students fundamental rights and freedoms and their decision to muzzle Professor
Peterson.
The University has been quick to condemn online threats of physical violence against
members of the transgender community; it has also been quick to condemn the few racists and
transphobic slurs that were, unfortunately, voiced by a small minority at the Free Speech rally.
These fringe views are in no way representative of the opinion of the majority of free speech
protesters; in fact, we fully support the Universitys decision to denounce these acts. However,
we also believe that choosing to draw attention only to those incidents that were perpetrated
against the transgender and the Black community is dangerous and wrong.
Why did the administration not condemn the use of white noise machines, allegedly
rented by an executive member of the UTSU? Cassandra Williams and other counter-protesters
have clearly broken the Obstruction clause of the Universitys Free Speech policy. Although the
rally was technically held in a public space, the white noise machine was plugged into a power
outlet at Sidney Smith; thus, the University had a responsibility to prohibit and condemn such
actions [1].
Where is the Universitys response to co-founder of the BLC and student at the
University of Toronto, Yusra Khogali, calling an Ethiopian refugee a coon for politely
expressing his views on the state of free speech in his home country? This was the most evident
act of anti-Black racism at the rally - yet the University and media (including the Varsity) fail to
recognize this [2].

1
2

http://www.viceprovoststudents.utoronto.ca/publicationsandpolicies/rights-and-responsibilities.htm
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=awX_9mC8rX4 (see 3:24)

Where is the Universitys condemnation of an anti-Peterson protester assaulting a

journalist, Lauren Southern, and their response to Theo Williamson, the New College Equity
Director, lying about it to police? It should be noted that both of these individuals are having
criminal charges currently pressed against them. Furthermore, Williamson is having legal action
pressed for a completely different altercation, where they seem to have stolen a pro-free speech
attendees cell phone, assaulted the attendee with the phone, and then smashed it against the
pavement [3]. Why has the University not reprimanded Cassandra Williams who used her body to
physically block the attendee from trying to retrieve her phone [4]?
Why has the University failed to protect student organizers and supporters of the Free
Speech rally from slander? Unsurprisingly, it appears that the media narrative surrounding what
happened at the rally is based exclusively on the accounts of the counter-protestors, such as Theo
Williamson. These are the same individuals who have insinuated that we are no more than a
group of white supremacists and neo-Nazis. It is clear, at this point, that we must take these
accounts of events very skeptically considering that an active leader of the anti free-speech
movement has no problem lying - even to the police [5], [6], [7].
Why has the University failed to recognize the very real danger posed to students in
support of free speech and Professor Peterson? Wesley Williams (also known as Qaiser Ali),
another prominent leader in the anti-free speech movement has been documented proudly and
clearly declaring himself to be the death of the palefaces. What more is needed to constitute a
threat to a given demographic [8]?
Perhaps the actions of Yusra Khogali could be it. The fact that Khogali has not been
censured by the University for her words and actions is perplexing and disturbing, to say the
least. In her various media communications, she has claimed that white skin is sub-humxn;
used racial slurs against individuals respectfully sharing their opinion; and expressed a desire to
murder white ppl and men. It is difficult to put into words just how alienating and terrifying it
is to know that an open racist who advocates for the use of violence is advising the University on
pertinent matters, claiming to hold the secrets to anti-oppression and being allowed to ruin
peaceful demonstrations. What Khogalis actions amount to is bullying, at best [9].
Finally, where is the Universitys condemnation of the Black Liberation Collective a
racist activist group that openly embraces violence (We will strive for liberation by any means
necessary, including but not limited to: armed self-defense. [...] We condone whatever methods
Black people adopt to liberate themselves and their kin.)? We find the fact that the
administration has not availed itself of this openly available information baffling and hard to
3

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K-IFcCY0m3E
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ncdgR13qlbQ
5 http://thestrand.ca/petersons-transphobia-its-not-just-words-free-speech-is-not-the-same-as-hatespeech/
6 http://thevarsity.ca/2016/10/12/free-speech-rally-devolves-into-conflict-outbursts-of-violence/
7 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-AozOD5FlDI
8 http://i2.wp.com/www.genuinewitty.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/10/death-of-palefaces.jpg?w=768
9 http://www.genuinewitty.com/2016/04/10/blmto-unmasked-pt-i-yusra-khogali-is-worse-than-jerry-agarexposed-her-to-be/
4

believe. And if the University has been aware of the violent nature of the BLC, then why has the
administration not only failed to denounce this organization, but also continues to take antioppression training advice from this group [10]?
There is video footage and written evidence supporting every claim made in this letter. If
you choose to ignore this information, you are engaging in wilful ignorance, at the expense of
violating the fundamental rights and freedoms of the majority of your student body. If you ignore
this letter, you admit to condoning radical activist groups to silence, bully, assault and threaten
those who dare to disagree with their views.
In short, we no longer feel that the University of Toronto is a place where students are
free to share their ideas without risking being aggressively silenced, insulted, assaulted and
slandered. We contend that the University is choosing to pursue political gain at the risk of being
slandered by the BLC and the UTSU. It must be acknowledged that as long as militant, racist
groups are allowed on campus and, moreover, permitted to advise our University administration those who wish to espouse opinions not in line with the aforementioned groups are not safe.
We demand justice and equal treatment for all students, regardless of their sex, race,
gender identity, religion or political persuasion. As citizens of a democratic society and members
of your institution, we deserve the right to free speech and fair treatment. We deserve to have an
administration that cares about all students equally and takes a nonpartisan approach when
conflicts between various student groups and interests inevitably arise.
The University has failed to protect their students from violence, bullying, racism, sexism
and slander. We are speaking up we need you to listen. Whats happening is fundamentally
wrong, and against all values of this institution and of Western, liberal democracy.

Sincerely,

Concerned Students

10

http://www.blackliberationcollective.org/our-beliefs/