You are on page 1of 54

Syncope.

Sudden cardiac death


Dr. Radu Vtescu
Pacing and Clinical Electrophysiology Lab., Cardiology Department
Clinic Emergency Hospital Bucharest

Syncope
Definition: transient loss of consciousness,
associated with loss of postural tone, with
complete, rapid, spontaneous return to baseline
neurologic function requiring no resuscitative
efforts. The underlying mechanism is global
hypoperfusion (30% ) of both the cerebral cortices
or focal hypoperfusion of the reticular activating
system
NB!
>1/3 associated with trauma
!! cardiac syncope (1/3 SCD in 5 years!)
RV - Syncope. SCD 2016

RV - Syncope. SCD 2016

Epidemiology

Sorteriades ES, et al. N Engl J Med 2002

Freed LA,, et al. Am J Cardiol 1997

- 2 peaks: 15years and >55 years (especially >70)


- ,,lifetime risk 1/3 !!!

RV - Syncope. SCD 2016

History physical examination


context

during / after effort


at rest
postmictional
pain
orthostatism
dehydration

prodroms

palpitations
thoracic pain
vertigo
visual
marked fatigue
sympathetic : transpiration,
pallor, nausea

loss of consciousness and of

postural tone

pallor
absent / weak pulse
superficial respiration
tonico-clonic contractions (face,
superior extremities)
sfincterian control
midriatic pupils
loss of conjunctival reflexes

RV - Syncope. SCD 2016

Etiology
Prevalence, percent
Men
Women
Cardiac

13.2

6.7

Stroke or transient ischemic attack

4.3

4.0

Seizure disorder

7.2

3.2

Vasovagal

19.8

22.2

Orthostatic hypotension

8.6

9.9

Medication

6.3

7.2

Other

9.5

6.1

Unknown

31.0

40.7
RV - Syncope. SCD 2016

Etiology
Reflex (neurally mediated)

Orthostatic hTA

-Vasovagal:

-Primary autonomic failure:

Emotional stress: fear, pain, fobia (blood)

pure autonomic failure, multisystemic atrophia,

Orthostatic Stress

b. Parkinson, Lewy body dementia

-Situational:

-Secondary autonomic failure:

Respiratory stimuli: cough, sneeze

DM, amiloidosis, uremia, spinal lesions

G-I stimulation: swallowing, defecation, visceral

-drug-related orthostatic hTA:

pain

Alcohol, v-d, diuretics, phenotyazine,

Mictional

antidepresives

Effort

-Hypovolemia:

Postprandial
Others (laugh, weight lifting)

Hemorrhage, diarea, emesis, etc

-Carotidian
-Atipical

Cerebro-vascular: vascular steal


- ocluzive disease of brahiocephalic trunk: ASC, tr.-emb., arteritis
(Takayasu)
-subclavicular steal

RV - Syncope. SCD 2016

Cardiac syncope
Arrhytmic:

Structural disease:

-Bradicardia:

-Cardiac:

fx SAN

valvulopaties / disfx valvular prosthesis, AMI,

AVB (II or III)

HOCM, intracardiac masses (mixoma, tumours,

PM/ICD malfunction

-Tachycardia:
Supraventricular
Ventricular (idiopatice, structural heart disease,

etc), pericardial disease/tamponade, cong.


coronary aN
-Others: DVT/PE, Ao disection, PHT

chanallopaties

-iatrogenic brady or tachyarrythmia

RV - Syncope. SCD 2016

Etiology vs prognostic

Sorteriades ES, et al. N Engl J Med 2002

RV - Syncope. SCD 2016

Risk stratification
High: structural heart disease
Intermediar
Low
young
wo comorbidities
ECG N
syncope
reflex
orthostatic
un-explained
RV - Syncope. SCD 2016

10

Initial screening
History
Physical exam
BP clino/ortho
neurologic
Carotid Sinus Compression

ECG

RV - Syncope. SCD 2016

11

Secondary screening
Ecocardiography
ECG monitoring
monitor ED
effort ECG
Holter

Tilt test
Biologic: myocardial necrosis, LV
dysfunction, inflammation, DVT/PE
RV - Syncope. SCD 2016

12

Specific tests

coronary angiography
CT
adenosine
ILR: rare but severe, recurrent symptoms
EPS
SAN
BB
CAD
CMP: H, ARVD
chanallopaties: Brugada
RV - Syncope. SCD 2016

13

Treatment
Objectives:
Recurrences prophylaxis
QoL
complications prophylaxis (head
trauma)

SCD prevention

RV - Syncope. SCD 2016

14

Treatment
Reflex syncope:
Patient education
re-assurance
life-style
prodromes recognition
maneuvers for venous retour
triggers avoidance/elimination

RV - Syncope. SCD 2016

15

RV - Syncope. SCD 2016

16

Definition
Sudden cardiac death (SCD)
death by circulatory arrest, usualy due to
cardiac arrhythmia, ocurring in less than 1h
after symptoms debut
Sudden cardiac arrest (SCA)
circulatory arrest, usualy due to cardiac
arrhythmia, ocurring in less than 1h after
symptoms debut. Medical intervention
(usualy defibrillation) prevents death
RV - Syncope. SCD 2016

17

le 3

Definitie - ESC 2015

Definitions of commonly used terms

Term
Sudden death

Non-traumatic, unexpected fatal event occurring within 1 hour of the onset of symptoms in an apparently healthy
subject.
If death is not witnessed, the
applies when the victim was in good health 24 hours before the event.

SUDS and SUDI

Sudden death without an apparent cause and in which an autopsy has not been performed in an adult (SUDS) or in an
infant <1 year of age (SUDI).

SCD

The term is used when:


A congenital, or acquired, potentially fatal cardiac condition was known to be present during life; OR
Autopsy has
a cardiac or vascular anomaly as the probable cause of the event; OR
by post-mortem examination and therefore an arrhythmic event
No obvious extra-cardiac causes have been
is a likely cause of death.

SADS and SIDS

Both autopsy and toxicology investigations are inconclusive, the heart is structurally normal at gross and histological
examination and non-cardiac aetiologies are excluded in adults (SADS) and in infants (SIDS).

Aborted cardiac
arrest

Unexpected circulatory arrest, occurring within 1 hour of onset of acute symptoms, which is reversed by successful
resuscitation manoeuvres (e.g.

Idiopathic ventricular

Clinical investigations are negative in a patient surviving an episode of ventricular

Primary prevention
of SCD

Therapies to reduce the risk of SCD in individuals who are at risk of SCD but have not yet experienced an aborted
cardiac arrest or life-threatening arrhythmias.

Secondary
prevention of SCD

Therapies to reduce the risk of SCD in patients who have already experienced an aborted cardiac arrest or lifethreatening arrhythmias.

RV - Syncope. SCD 2016

18

How sudden is SCD?

Muller D et al Circulation 2006

RV - Syncope. SCD 2016

19

Proportion of Patients, %

is extended to the 4 weeks preceding SCA. Second,


these symptoms seem to
bepain
frequently ignored or minChest
n = 90
40
Dyspnea
imized by patients in the
community, with at least two
Syncope or palpitations
0.84
thirds of affected patients
not seeking urgent medical
0.59
30
care, given that most symptoms recurred during the
n = 50
n = 49 24-hour period before
SCA. Finally, our findings sug0.120
20
gest thatnan
early
911
call
among patients with symp= 30
toms is associated
with betterESEARCH
survival because in most
RIGINAL
10
n = 13
patients,
symptoms
recurred
in
n
= 6the hours immediately
n
=
8
n=7
n=5
n=4
npreceding
=3
n = 2 the potential to
SCA. These findings
suggest
0
short-term
oftoSCA
with
h to
24 h
>1 dprevention
to 7 d >1 wk
4 wk in the future.
h enhance
Figure 1.1
Study
flow>1diagram.
The
term
sudden
has
classically
suggested that
due to
Presence of Symptoms Before SCA
collapse occurred without warning. Although previous
DifferInformation aboutcommunity-based
the timing of symptomstudies
onset wasthat
available
in 267 of the circuminvestigated
t for a
Sudden
arrest in persons
aged or palpitations. Er299 patients with
chestcardiac
pain, dyspnea,
or syncope
before
documented
the early warn35stances
to 65
y from
20022012
(n =have
1099)
5% CIs
ror bars correspond
to 95%
CIs.
SCASCA
= sudden
cardiac
arrest.
ing
symptoms
in
some
patients
(17,
18),
they were
STATA
mainly focused on symptoms occurring very shortly beAmong the 81 patients with symptoms who made a
0.78
fore SCA was witnessed. Further, findings were limited
911 call, 63 (78%) developed SCA before the arrival of
to those collected in the field by EMS providers and
0.170
emergency medical responders, whereas 18 (22%) had
underestimated
the
potential window for
e proSurvivors
(n = 114
[10%])
(n =probably
985 [90%])on
SCADecedents
in the ambulance
the way
to the
hospital.
Com0.75
timely intervention. Of note, most of our patients with
had
no
pared with patients who did not call 911 before SCA,
symptoms who eventually developed SCA did not call
study
0.72
those who called had witnesses more often (P = 0.001),
911. This is a noteworthy finding because most patients
pt for
a higher proportion
of bystander cardiopulmonary reSymptom
Symptom
(>90%)
who had symptoms during
the days and weeks
0.69
suscitation (P = assessment
0.001), and
a higher rate
of initially
assessment
not
beforepossible
SCAnot
also had recurrent
symptoms
in the hours
shockable rhythm (P = 0.02).
possible
0.010
before
the
event. Not surprisingly,
patients
(n = 242
[25%])
(n = 18
[16%])CI, with continSurvival to hospital discharge was 32.1%
(95%
uous symptoms or with known heart disease seem
21.8% to 42.4%) compared with 6.0% (CI, 3.5% to 8.5%)
more likely to call 911, probably because of a better
0.50
in patients who did not call 911 (P < 0.001). After adawareness of warning signs. However, two thirds of
0.31
d
justment for differences in patients and resuscitation
0.56
such patients did not call 911, so there is room for imvariables, and multiple imputation for missing data, a
0.29
provement (19).
ere
0.110in911 call remained significantly associated with survival
Our findings
emphasizeSymptoms
the need to encourage efhospiSymptoms
symptomsdischarge
symptoms
toNo
hospital
(odds No
ratio
[OR], 4.82 [CI, 2.23 to
that
target
public
of SCA as a largely
(n = 383
[52%])
(n = 360 [48%]) forts
(n = 47 [49%])
(n = 49
[51%])awareness
a0.140
were
10.43]; P < 0.001) (Appendix Table 3, available at www
fatal
event.
It
is
important
to
reinforce
knowledge of
ecause
.annals.org). A sensitivity analysis using complete-case
prodromal
symptoms
of
SCA
in
the
general
public and
gure 1
analysis found a significant association (OR, 3.27 [CI,
in
patients
affected
by
heart
disease
and
their
family
s.org).
0.160
1.37 to 7.79]; P = 0.008) as did analyses that controlled
members.
The
recent
impressive
advances
in
mobile
he abfor potential confounding due to the hospital (OR, 3.35
No 911
telecommunication
technologies
could help improve
No 911
e time
911 call and periods before
911 call
[CI, 1.47 to call
7.65]; P = 0.004)
and
call
the
management
of
patients
with
SCA
ed.
Per(n = 55)
(n = 26)who have warne area
(n
=
21)
after
2005
(OR,
5.64
[CI,
2.59
to
12.43];
P
=
0.001).
(n
=
328)
f known
ing symptoms, potentially affording a unique opportunesses
nity for early intervention (6). This may be particularly
ng
indata.
the
DISCUSSIONhelpful in patients with known heart disease because
ts); inMarijon
E.,
Uy-Evanado
A,
et al. Ann Intern
Med. 2016
instant transmission
To our knowledge,
this study isofthepoint-of-care
first compre-electrocardios, witdocugrams
and
the development
of automated
Characteristics
ofofSymptoms
and
hensive
evaluation
symptoms
in
theTemporal
4 weeks
preced- algorithms
onspe-

(n ! 81)
Study period
20022005
20062009
20102012

(n ! 349)
0.41

52 (64.2)
18 (22.2)
11 (13.6)

Demographic data
Mean age (SD), y
Male

198 (56.7)
103 (29.5)
48 (13.8)

54.2 (7)
52.2 (8)
61 (75.3) 259 (74.2)

0.020
0.84

Timing of SCA
Night (midnight5:59 a.m.)
Morning (6:0011:59 a.m.)
Afternoon (noon5:59 p.m.)
Evening (6:0011:59 p.m.)
Missing

11 (17.7)
16 (25.8)
20 (32.3)
15 (24.2)
19

29 (17.0)
55 (32.1)
42 (24.6)
45 (26.3)
178

Known heart disease


CAD

45 (55.6)
28 (34.8)

114 (32.7)
77 (22.1)

Type of symptoms
Chest pain
Dyspnea
Syncope/palpitation
Others
Missing

45 (55.6)
23 (28.4)
6 (7.4)
7 (8.6)
0

154 (44.6)
55 (15.9)
16 (4.6)
120 (34.8)
4

Onset of symptoms
1 h
1 d
1 wk
1 mo
Missing

21 (28.8)
32 (43.8)
17 (23.3)
3 (4.1)
8

57 (17.9)
142 (44.5)
108 (33.8)
12 (3.8)
30

Home occurrence
Missing

49 (60.5)
0

278 (79.7)
2

<0.001

Witnessed status
No witness
Witnessed without CPR
Witnessed with CPR
Missing

74 (91.4)
7 (8.6)
43 (53.1)
31 (38.3)
0

182 (52.6)
164 (47.4)
135 (39.0)
47 (13.6)
3

<0.001

Mean time from call to EMS


arrival (SD), min
Missing

6.9 (4)

0.90

<0.001
0.010
<0.001

0.56

Rhythm
Ventricular fibrillation/tachycardia
Pulseless electrical activity
Asystole
Missing

7.0 (3)

16

133

42 (58.4)
25 (34.7)
5 (6.9)
10

112 (45.7)
60 (24.5)
73 (29.8)
103

0.67

0.020

RV - Syncope. SCD 2016

20

Size of the issue: SUA

Stroke3

167,366

450,000
Lung
cancer
Breast cancer
AIDS1
1
2
3
4

157,400
40,600
42,156

MSC 4
#1 Killer
U.SA.

U.S. Census Bureau, Statistical Abstract of the United States: 2001.


American Cancer Society, Inc., Surveillance Research, Cancer Facts and Figures 2001.
2006 Heart and Stroke Statistical Update, American Heart Association.
Circulation. 2001;104:2158-2163.

RV - Syncope. SCD 2016 21

Major causes of death


1
SUA 1999
Septicemie
Nefrite

SCD is outweighted only by


combined mortality from all
cancer types

Alzheimer
Grip/pneumonie
Diabet
Accidente/atac armat
B.P.C.O
Boli cerebrovasculare

Alte cauze cardiace


MSC
All cancers

0%

5%

10%

15%

20%

25%

1 National
2

Vital Statistics Report, Vol 49 (11), Oct. 12, 2001


MMWR. State-specific mortality from sudden cardiac death US 1999.Feb 15, 2002;51:123-126.

RV - Syncope. SCD 2016 22

Survival SCA
only 17-25% of SCD/SCA resuscitated

Discharged:
SUA & Canada 5%
Vestern Europe 5%
Restul of the world << 1%
RV - Syncope. SCD 2016

23

Evolution SCD

Fox CS et al Circulation 2004


RV - Syncope. SCD 2016

24

Evolution SCD survivals

Rea TD et al Circulation 2003


RV - Syncope. SCD 2016

25

Etiology SCD
CHD
atherosclerosis
MI (acute and old/scar)
UA

coronary embolies
non-ASC coronary disease
arteritis
dissections
congenital anomalies

coronary spasm

Non-isch. struct. heart disease

CMP (D, H, ARVD)


Miocarditis
Ao dissection
Valvulopathies
Congenital heart disease
cardiac tamponade
Cardiac rupture

Heart diseases wo structural


involvement

idiopathic VF
Brugada
LQT/SQT
WPW
complete AVB
familial SCD
Chest trauma (commotio cordis)

noncardiac

PE
intracranial haemorrhage
Drawning
Pickwick (OSA)
Drug poissoning
Upper aiwais obstruction
Sudden infant death syndrome
RV - Syncope. SCD 2016

26

Huikuri HV, Castellanos A, Myerburg RJ. N Engl J Med 2001

RV - Syncope. SCD 2016

27

Myerburg RJ. J Cardiovasc Electrophysiol 2001.

RV - Syncope. SCD 2016

28

12%
Other Cardiac
Cause

88%
Arrhythmic
Cause

Albert CM. Circulation 2003

MSC
mechanism
VT
62%

TdP
13%
Bradycardia
17%

Primary VF
8%

Bays de Luna A. Am Heart J 1989

RV - Syncope. SCD 2016

29

Survival
asistole

50%

50 minute

10% 0-2%

electromechanical dissociation

25%

20 minute

23% 6%

VT/VF

25%

30 minute

40% 34%

Muller D et al Circulation 2006

RV - Syncope. SCD 2016

30

SCD: succesful resuscitation vs. time*


% Succes (*Nonlinear )

succes rate with 7 - 10% for each minute of delay


100
90
80
70
60
50
40
30
20
10

Timp (minute)
Cummins RO. Annals Emerg Med. 1989;18:1269-1275.
RV - Syncope. SCD 2016

31

Risc stratification
Necessary?

RV - Syncope. SCD 2016

32

SCD subgroups

General population
High coronary risk
History of coronary
event
LVEF <35%, CHF

SCD-HeFT

Previous cardiac
arrest

MADIT-II

AVID, CIDS, CASH


MADIT I - MUSTT

Hystory of MI, low EF,


VT
0

10

20

25

30

Incidence of Sudden Death


(% of group)

Myerburg RJ. Circulation 1998.

100,000 200,000 300,000


No. of Sudden Deaths
Per Year

RV - Syncope. SCD 2016

33

Myerburg RJ. J Cardiovasc Electrophysiol 2001.

RV - Syncope. SCD 2016

34

Risk stratification
Substrate

family history
Age
Sex
SCA
CHD (MI, UA)
Personality

Indicators of LV fx
Symptoms
Sincope
CHF

Trigger
EP parameters
Autonomic imbalance

HR rest/effort
HRV
HRT
BRS

AV conduction
QRSw
SAECG
EPS

Repolarisation dispersion
QT dispersion
MTWA

LVEF
LV mass
Natriuretic hormones
RV - Syncope. SCD 2016

35

CHF

Kannel WB et al, Am Hear J 1998


RV - Syncope. SCD 2016

36

Functional capacity vs type of death

NYHA III

NYHA II
12%

NYHA IV
26%
33%

24%

64%

59%

56%
15%
11%

N = 103

N = 103

N = 27
CHF
Other
Sudden Death

MERIT-HF Study Group Lancet 1999


RV - Syncope. SCD 2016

37

SCD vs LVEF in patients with CHF

% SCA Victims

7.5%

7
6

5.1%

5
4

2.8%

3
2

1.4%

LVEF

0
0-30%

31-40%

41-50%

>50%

Gorgels APM Eur Heart J 2003

RV - Syncope. SCD

38

SCD vs LVEF in asymptomatic


LVD patients

Wang TJ et al. Circulation 2003


RV - Syncope. SCD 2016

39

Whang W et al TOVA, Circulation 2005

RV - Syncope. SCD 2016

40

SCD vs LVH

Haider AW et al. J Am Coll Cardiol 1998


RV - Syncope. SCD 2016

41

SCD vs natriuretic hormones

Tapanainen JN et al. J Am Coll Cardiol 2004


RV - Syncope. SCD 2016

42

HR and SCD risk

Jouven X et al. N Engl J Med 2002


RV - Syncope. SCD 2016

43

QRSw vs SCD

Baldasseroni S et al, Am Hear J 2002


RV - Syncope. SCD 2016

44

dQRS120 msec

dQRS<120 msec

Moss AJ, Circulation 2005

RV - Syncope. SCD 2016

45

SCD Prophylaxis
Corection of ischemia
Revascularisation
B

inflammation and/or plaque rupture


prevention
Statines
ACEI
Aspirin

Autonomic balance
Beta-blocker
ACEI

Arrhythmia prevention

B
Amiodarone
polyunsaturated fatty acids (fish oil)?
Ablative therapy
percutaneous (catheter)
surgical

Arrhythmia termination
ICDs
AEDs

of LV systolic fx
ACEI
B

Prevention of cardiac remodeling and


collagen formation
aldosterone receptors blockers
ACEI

RV - Syncope. SCD 2016

46

Mortality
Trial
ACE-I Controls
RR (95% CI)
Chronic CHF
CONSENSUS I
39%
0.56 (0.34 - 0.91)
54%
SOLVD (Treatment)
35%
40%
0.82 (0.70 - 0.97)
16%
SOLVD (Prevention) 15%
0.92 (0.79 - 1.08)
Post- MI
SAVE
AIRE
TRACE
SMILE
Mean

20%
17%
35%
6.5%
21%

25%
23%
42%
8.3%
25%

0.81 (0.68 - 0.97)


0.73 (0.60 - 0.89)
0.78 (0.67 - 0.91)
0.78 (0.52 - 1.12)

RV - Syncope. SCD 2016

47

Automated External Defibrillator


AED
Automatic rhythm
analysis
determine
apropiateness of
an external shock
Visual and sound
alerts for guiding

RV - Syncope. SCD 2016

48

Survival after introduction of AEDs


30

26%

Before Early DF
After Early DF

VF Survival

25
19%

20

17%

15
10

11%

10%
7%
3%

4%

4%

3%

0
King County,
WA

Iowa

SE Minnesota NE Minnesota

Wisconsin

Ornato JP. Community experience in treating out-of-hospital cardiac arrest. In: Akhtar M.
Sudden Cardiac Death. Baltimore, Md: Williams & Wilkins; 1994.
RV - Syncope. SCD 2016

49

Implantable cardioverter-defibrillator ICD


? Defibrilattion
? Cardioversion
? Antitachycardic pacing

Ventricular lead

Atrial & Ventricular lead


? brady detection
? antibradycardia pacing

RV - Syncope. SCD 2016

50

ICD decrease mortality with ~ 40%


both in secondary and primary prevention
40
30

51%

73%

Control

54%

ICD

39%
20%

38%

20

36%

31%
41%

23%

10
0

Secondary Prevention

Primary Prevention

RV - Syncope. SCD 2016

51

Al-Khatib SM et al, Am Heart J 2005

RV - Syncope. SCD 2016

52

Clinical History
Angina pectoris or shortness of breath
Family history of premature SCD (age <40 years) or ealy-onset heart disease
ECG during tachycardia

Other transient
cause e.g.
Drugs
Electrolytes
Chest trauma

Acute ischemia
(STEMI, NSTEMI)

ECG
Echocardiogram
History and
Family history a

Urgent angiogram
and
revascularisation
Reverse
transient cause

Evaluate for
cardiovascular
diseases
ECG
Echocardiogram / CMR
History
Other tests

Evaluate for
complete
reversal of
cause

Secondary
prevention for
SCD (ACEi,
beta-blockers, statin,
antiplatelets)
Re-evaluate
LVEF
610 weeks
after event

Consider ICD
according to
secondary
prevention

Structural heart disease


and congenital heart
diseases
suspected (e.g. Stable CAD,
sarcoidosis, aortic valve
disease, DCM)

Sudden death victims


Autopsy in collaboration with pathologists
Obtain blood and tissue samples
Molecular autopsy after autopsy
Offer family councelling and support
Refer family for cardiology / SCD workup

No detectable
heart disease

Inherited
arrhythmogenic
disease or
cardiomyopathy
suspected

Further patient assessment, e.g.b


Stress test, Holter 48 hours,
Consider coronary angiogram
Refer patients to experienced centers for risk evaluation,
catheter ablation, drugs and ICD
Drug challenges, EPS
CMR, CT, myocardial biopsy
Signal averaged ECG, TOE based on suspected disease

Treatment of underlying
heart disease (e.g. valve
repair, medication)
Assess risk for SCD

Specific treatment
Genetic testing
Family screening
Assess risk for SCD

Consider to
obtain second opinion
on cause of
VT/VF

RV - Syncope. SCD 2016

53

However...
2/3 of patients with SCD had pre-existing proved/suspected
heart disease
3/4 of SCD at home
100% witnessed
90% had symptoms at least 10 before SCD (mean 1h !!)
Resuscitation attempted by witnesses: 8-23%
Survival:

25% if witneeses attempt BLS


4% if ambulance is waited

Key: Population education


RV - Syncope. SCD 2016

54

You might also like