Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Abstract Wireless body area network has gained much As shown in figure 1 Wireless Body Area Network is a
interest and became emerging technology at health service special kind of network, which is designed and develops
facilities due to its wide range of utility and vital role to for Human body, to monitor, manage and communicate
improve the human health. In this research paper, we are different vital signs of the human body like temperature,
conducting a comprehensive survey of wireless Body Area
Network (WBAN) and also introducing a virtual doctor
Blood pressure and ECG etc. These vital signs can be
server (VDS) in existing WBAN architecture. Existing monitored by using different sensor installed on clothes
architecture of WBAN consists of: wireless sensor, wireless or on the body or even under the human skin. Any kind of
actuator node , wireless central unit and wireless Personal drug can be injected using actuator installed on the
Device (PD). Personal Digital Assistant (PDA) or smart human body like, to control the blood pressure,
phone can be used as PD. Based on the existing architecture temperature or can inject any life-saving drugs. Central
mentioned above, we propose a design concept for a virtual unit is responsible to establish communication between
doctor server (VDS) to support various patient health care
services. VDS will keep the historical data about the patient,
sensors, actuators and cellular phone in wireless fashion.
generate the daily tips and advices for him, call the doctor or Cellular phone of that person can be used to transmit all
emergency squad if required and can provide first aid information to and from the human body to the external
assistance instructions on patient or any of his close world (physician, emergency). This kind of wireless
relatives PDA's. personal network around and near the human body is
called Wireless Body Area Network (WBAN) where each
Keywords:- Wireless Body Area Network, Client Server body is assigned an IP address. IEEE 802.15 Task Group
architecture for E-health , E-health technologies survey, 6 standard is assigned to develop energy-efficient devices
Innovation in health care. and to develop applications for WBAN.
I. INTRODUCTION In what follows we present a survey of major existing
WBAN applications, technologies, architectures,
A wireless body area network (WBAN) is a radio protocols, available infrastructure and available standards.
frequency (RF) based wireless networking technology that
interconnects tiny nodes with sensor or actuator II. BACKGROUND
capabilities in, on, or around a human body. As describe In this section we will provide a survey of all the
in [1], the transmissions of these nodes cover a short applications and areas of life where WBAN is providing
range of about 2 m, and other specifications of WBAN are its vital role and giving quality to human life. We will also
shown in conduct a server of different devices already available to
Table 1. build WBAN.
Table 1: WBAN Specifications A. Applications of wban
Attribute Value
Distance 2 meter stander 5 meter special case Application of WBAN can categorized depending on
Start up time < 100 ns the domain of application. In what follow we present
Network Setup time <1 sec / device major WBAN domains of application.
Power consumption ~ 1mW/Mbps
1) WBAN Application for medical treatment and
Network density 2-4 Nets / m2
Latency (end to end) 10 ms diagnosis
Network size Max 100 devices /Network There are myriad of possibilities where WBANs are
useful for diagnosis or treatment of diseases. Many
researchers have conducted research in this regards
[2],[3],[4],[5][6][22] as summarized in table 2.
Figure 1 : WBAN
215
III. PROPOSED VIRTUAL DOCATOR BASED solution. WBAN is facing both ethical and technical
WBAN ARCHITECTURE challenges like privacy is most important and critical
In figure 3 we are introducing the concept of virtual ethical issue yet to be addressed properly, and main
doctor server (VDS) that is based on WBAN architecture technical issue is to provide better Human Computer
shown in figure 2: The VDS integrated various Interaction (HCI). Other technical challengers are shown
applications of WBAN to manage the health service bellow table 3.
provided to the patient and provides assistance to health
Table 4: Common Challenges in WSN and WBAN
care service providers in emergency situation.. Challenges Wireless Sensor Network Wireless Body Area Network
Monitored environment Human body (centimeters /
Scale
Figure 2: Existing WBAN Architecture (meters / kilometers) meters)
Many redundant nodes for
Node Density Fewer, limited in space
wide area coverage
Through node accuracy and
Result accuracy Through node redundancy
robustness
Node performs a dedicated
Node Tasks Node performs multiple tasks
task
Small is essential low on
complexity, light in weight,
Small is preferred, but not
Node Size power efficient, easy to use and
important
reconfigurable, storage devices
need to facilitate remotely
Network Very likely to be fixed or More variable due to body
Topology static movement
Figure 3: Proposed VDS architecture Monitoring human
Event based monitoring
physiological activities
Data Rates Events can happen
Vary in a more periodic
irregularly
manner
Latency
Nodes are usually
considered to be Nodes affiliated with the same
Mobility stationary, and any node wearer move together and in
mobility does not occur in the same direction
groups
Node Performed easily, nodes Replacement of implanted
Replacement even disposable nodes difficult
Several years / months, smaller
Node Lifetime Several years / months
battery capacity
Accessible and likely to be Inaccessible and difficult to
In particular, VDS may have following Power Supply replaced more easily and replaced in an implantable
frequently setting
responsibilities: Likely to be large, energy Likely to be lower, energy
x Keep the history of patient Power Demand
supply easier supply more difficult
Energy
x keep track of medicines taken by patient and Remind Scavenging
Most likely solar and wind Most likely motion (vibration)
power and thermal (body heat)
him to take the medicines on time by PD unit Source
Not a consideration in A must for implants and some
x Gives advices to the patient/patient helper, on the Biocompatibility
most applications external sensors
Higher, to protect patient
bases of best practices and vital signs taken by Security Level Lower
information
sensors More significant, may require
Impact of Data Likely to be compensated additional measures to ensure
x Call paramedic /emergency squad or ambulance if Loss by redundant nodes QoS and real-time data
delivery.
necessary Wireless Bluetooth, ZigBee, GPRS, Low power technology
x Maintain QOS, security, confidentiality and privacy Technology WLAN required
Authenticity of Needs to install sensors on
Patient can give his input like his condition and nod installed on No need correct place and correct
feelings by using PD unit and vital signs will be taken by correct place person
Real time Not required in all the Need grantee of accuracy and
sensor, VDS will give advices based on patient history + communication cases on time delivery of message
database + best practices + vital signs. Advices are like: Wires nodes communicate Sensor, Actuator and central
x Its normal dont worry Architecture in wifi are ad-hoc mode
fashion
unit communicate through
PDA
x Patient should take some action like take rest ect.
x Patient should take first aid action liken take
emergency medicine; lay down straight and no V. OPEN RESEARCH ISSUES
movement till doctor/paramedic will arrive ect. The discussions above clearly show that, although a
x If patient will become unconscious then VSD will lot of research is going on, still a lot of open issues exist.
advice the helper for first aid steps like hart pumping, A. Physical layer Issues
given artificial breathing, give emergency pills ect. Several researchers have already started studying the
propagation of electromagnetic waves in, and on the body
IV. THE MAIN CHALLENGES IN WBAN: and a few models for the physical layer are proposed. It
WBAN is an emerging technology, lots of issues still should be noticed that none of them take the movements
needs to address, and still many problems require better of the body into account, although movements can have a
216
severe impact on the received signal strength. Further, In addition to energy harvesting methods (e.g., based on
new emerging technologies such as galvanic coupling and body movements) many researchers are studying, recently
transformation of information via the bones offer researchers at MIT have reported wireless energy
promising results and need to be investigated more transmission to power electronic devices over a short
thoroughly. range (i.e., several meters) using evanescent waves.
B. Data Link Layer issues G. Energy issues
Although some protocols already exist that take care The use energy scavenging was not addressed in
of the data link layer and networking, this area still has a detail. With a smart combination of lower energy
lot of open research issues. On the data link layer, more protocols and energy scavenging, the optimal solution for
WBAN specific MAC-protocols need to be developed that achieving autonomous Body Area Networks can be
take into account the movement of the body, i.e. the reached. For a WBAN, energy scavenging from on-body
mobility of the nodes, additional low-power features such sources such as body heat and body vibration seems very
as an adaptive duty cycle for lowering the idle listening well suited.
and overhearing, the use of the human physiology such as All the devices in wireless sensor networks are
heart beat to ensure time synchronization and so on. battery operated therefore, power challenge is present in
almost every area of application of wireless sensor
C. Network layer
networks, but limitation of a smart sensor implanted on a
A promising research track is the combination of person still poses even further challenge. In a full active
thermal routing with more energy-efficient mechanisms. mode a node cant operate more than a month because a
More efficient QoS-mechanisms are needed, for example, typical alkaline battery provides about 50 watt-hours of
based on the Body Qos framework. Other interesting open energy. Any commercial applications have to guarantee
research issues are mobility support embedded in the that all the devices will work for at least a year without
protocol, security, inter operability and so on. In order to any maintenance / replacement. For example heart
define a globally optimal system, it might be necessary to pacemakers devices. The developers have to design
unite several of these mechanisms in a cross-layer better scheduling algorithms and power management
protocol. schemes to deal with these power issues. Critical
D. Physical characteristics of sensor/actuator materials parameters in the design of a power efficient WBAN
and electronic circuits system are described as follows:
Average bandwidth Influences the active communication time of
As sensors/actuators are going to be put on human wireless controllers and therefore the duty cycle
bodies or even implanted, their size, form factor, and of the system
physical compatibility to human tissues are crucial. This Maximum required Critical for bursts of urgent messages, and affects
bandwidth the maximum latency for data transmissions
motivates the search for and synthesis of novel materials. Active power Determines the type, size and weight of the
At the same time, concerns regarding electronic and battery, as well as the battery life.
magnetic energy absorbed by human tissues from RF Standby power Determines the maximum battery life, as a
circuits placed in close proximity to humans mean that function of the system duty cycle
Startup time Represents the overhead and determines the
WBAN devices need to employ low transmission power efficiency of individual transmissions
and low transmission duty cycles. In this regard, Ultra- Communication Protocol-related timing parameter that represents
wideband (UWB) outperforms conventional transmission setup time necessary to (re)establish a connection
methods and thus attracts much attention. between nodes or a node and a gateway
Standards based Influences the system interoperability and
E. Networking and resource management schemes communication application development time
technology
As the application scenarios of WBANs are different Protocol stack size Determine characteristics of the wireless sensor
from traditional sensor networks, problems like power and processing platform
management, sensor calibration, and context-aware requirements
network configuration need to be revisited as well. Sensor H. Computation
node scans to join/leave the network at any time, and thus Due to both limited power as well as memory,
impose the requirements of configuring the devices on the computation should also be limited. The biosensors
fly. Dynamic management of resources, including both
cannot perform large bit computations due to lack of
sensor functionalities and communication bandwidth, is enough memory. Unlike conventional wireless sensor
also necessary. network nodes, biosensors do not have much that
F. Power supply issues computational power. Since communication is vital and
As all WBAN devices require an energy source for memory is low, little power remains for computation. A
data collection, processing, and transmission, solution is that some sensors may have varying
development of suitable power supplies becomes capabilities that communicate with each other and send
paramount. Most WBAN devices are powered by out one collaborative data message.
batteries, which may not even be replaceable in cases I. Security, authentication, and privacy issues
where the devices are implanted in the human body; thus, The communication of health-related information
techniques like remote battery recharging are important. between sensors in a WBAN and over the Internet to
217
servers is strictly private and confidential and should be engagement in ambulatory environments, providing point
encrypted to protect the patient's privacy. The medical of care without limitation of the wearers
staff collecting the data needs to be confident that the data location/mobility while protecting the patients privacy.
is not tampered with and indeed originates from that Interoperability protocols at the application or domain
patient. Further, it cannot be expected that an average level (e.g., sample rate, data precision,
person or the medical staff is capable of setting up and association/disassociation, device descriptions, and
managing authentication and authorization processes. nomenclature) should all be addressed, and vendor-
Moreover, the network should be accessible when the user independent attributes and user interfaces shall be made
is not capable of giving the password (e.g.to guarantee available.
accessibility by paramedics in trauma situations). Security
N. Quality of Service and Reliability
and privacy protection mechanisms use a significant part
of the available energy and should therefore be energy- According to [1], [20], [21] proper quality of service
efficient and lightweight. The communication of health- (QoS) handling is an important part in the framework of
related information between sensors in a WBAN is risk management of medical applications. A crucial issue
subject to the following security requirements: is the reliability of the transmission in order to guarantee
that the monitored data is received correctly by the health
Data It means that the transmitted information is strictly care professionals. The reliability can be considered either
confidentiality private and can only be accessed by authorized end-to-end or on a per link base. Examples of reliability
persons, e.g. the doctor attending the patient. It is
include the guaranteed delivery of data (i.e. packet
usually achieved by encrypting the information
before sending it using a secret key and can be both delivery ratio), in-order-delivery. Moreover, messages
symmetrically and asymmetrically. should be delivered in reasonable time. The reliability of
Data It provides a means for making sure that the the network directly affects the quality of patient
authenticity information is sent by the claimed sender. For this,
monitoring and in a worst-case scenario, it can be fatal
a Message Authentication Code (MAC3) is
calculated using a shared secret key. when a life-threatening event has gone undetected.
Data integrity It makes sure that the received information has not WBAN QoS for all network layers is as under:
been tampered with. This can be inspected by
verifying the MAC. Application (usually specified by users): It includes system
Guarantee that the received data is recent and not a layer: lifetime, response time, data novelty, detection
replayed old message to cause disruption. A probability, data reliability and data resolution.
famous t is to add a counter who is increased every Transport It includes reliability, bandwidth, latency, and cost.
time a message is sent. layer:
Network layer: It includes path latency, routing maintenance,
J. Material Constraints congestion probability, routing robustness and
Another issue for wireless sensor network application energy efficiency.
Connectivity it includes network diameter, network capacity,
to healthcare is material constraints. A biosensor should average path cost, connectivity, robustness and
Maintenance
be implanted within the human body; therefore, the shape, layer connectivity maintenance
size, and materials might be harmless to the body tissue. Coverage It includes coverage percentage, coverage
For example, a smart sensor designed to support the retina Maintenance reliability, coverage robustness, coverage
layer: maintenance.
prosthesis might be small enough to fit within an eye. It includes communication range, throughput,
MAC layer:
Furthermore, chemical reactions with body tissue and the transmission reliability, and energy efficiency
disposal of the sensor are of extreme importance. Physical layer: It includes physical capabilities impose resource
K. Robustness O. Usability
Whenever the sensor devices are deployed in harsh or In most cases, a WBAN will be set up in a hospital by
hostile environments, Robustness rates of device failure medical staff, not by ICT-engineers. Consequently, the
become high. Protocol designs must therefore have built- network should be capable of configuring and maintaining
in mechanisms, that the failure of one node should not itself automatically, i.e. self-organization and self-
cause the entire network to cease operation. maintenance should be supported. Whenever a node is put
on the body and turned on, it should be able to join the
L. Continuous operation
network and set up routes without any external
Continuous operation must be ensured along the life intervention. The self-organizing aspect also includes the
cycle of a biosensor, as it is expected to operate for days, problem of addressing the nodes. An address can be
sometimes weeks without operator intervention. Hence, it configured at manufacturing time (e.g. the MAC-address)
is important to keep the amount of communications to the or at setup time by the network itself. Further, the network
minimum. It is necessary that those communications should be quickly reconfigurable, for adding new services.
which occur for purposes other than the actual data When a route fails, a backup path should be set up. The
communication should be minimized if it is impossible to devices may be scattered over and in the whole body. The
eliminate them. exact location of a device will depend on the application,
M. Rules of engagement e.g. a heart sensor obviously must be placed in the
neighborhood of the heart. A temperature sensor can be
However, intelligent monitoring and treatment placed almost anywhere. There is no consensus of
systems employing WBANs require standardized rules of researchers over the ideal body location for some sensor
218
nodes, i.e. motion sensors, as the interpretation of the International Conference of the IEEE Engineering in Medicine and
Biology Society, 2006, vol. 1, pp. 5977-80.
measured data is not always the same. The network [10] J.-L. Lin et al., The development of wireless sensor network for
should not be regarded as a static one. The body may be in ECG monitoring., in Annual International Conference of the IEEE
motion (e.g. walking, running, twisting, etc.) which Engineering in Medicine and Biology Society, 2006, vol. 1, pp.
induces channel fading and shadowing effects. The nodes 3513-6.
[11] Facts & statistics, Spinal Injuries Association, 2011. [Online].
should have a small form factor consistent with wearable Available: http://www.spinal.com.au/information/facts-statistics/.
and implanted applications. This will make WBANs [12] H. Zhou and H. Hu, Human motion tracking for rehabilitationA
invisible and unobtrusive. survey, Biomedical Signal Processing and Control, vol. 3, no. 1,
pp. 1-18, Jan. 2008.
P. Signal & Path Performance [13] Diabetes Statistics, Association, American Diabetes, 2011.
[Online]. Available: http://www.diabetes.org/diabetes-
The structure of a human body (flash and bones) is a
basics/diabetes-statistics/.
factor and plays a vital role in signal and path loss for [14] J. Zhao, S. Carolina, O. Mems, I. Diabetes, U. States, and U.
Wireless body area network and this property of WBAN States, A MEMS Viscometric Glucose Monitoring Device, in
entirely different from convention WSN. Many 13th International Conference on Solid-State Sensors, Actuators
and Microsystems, 2005, pp. 1816-1819.
researchers have been conducted to model signal loss
[15] Asthma Statistics, American Academy of Allergy Asthma &
throughout in a human body. Another interesting research Immunology, 2011. [Online]. Available:
area is to use human body as a medium to transmit the http://www.aaaai.org/about-the-aaaai/newsroom/asthma-
electrical signals and human body itself is used to transmit statistics.aspx.
[16] Stroke, U.S News Health, 2011. [Online]. Available:
signal form one area of a body to another area.
http://health.usnews.com/health-conditions/brain-health/stroke.
[17] Visual impairment and blindness, World Health Organization,
VI. CONCLUSIONS 2011. [Online]. Available:
The aim of this survey paper was to investigate the http://www.who.int/mediacentre/factsheets/fs282/en/.
[18] Statistics on Parkinsons, Parkinsons Disease Foundation, 2011.
role of WBAN in improving human Quality of life. In this [Online]. Available: http://www.pdf.org/en/parkinson_statistics.
survey, we tried to scan all possible application of WBAN [19] Neurology and public health, World Health Organization, 2011.
in daily life, the challenges WBAN facing nowadays and [Online]. Available:
open research issues. We have also explained existing http://www.who.int/mental_health/neurology/en/.
[20] M. Ameen, A. Nessa, and K. S. Kwak, QoS Issues with Focus on
architecture of WBAN and proposed a new component Wireless Body Area Networks, in 2008 Third International
VSD in addition. WBAN is very useful emerging Conference on Convergence and Hybrid Information Technology,
technology having immense utilities and benefits in daily 2008, pp. 801-807.
life not only for Healthcare but also for Athletic training, [21] C. Li, H.-B. Li, and R. Kohno, Performance Evaluation of IEEE
802.15.4 for Wireless Body Area Network (WBAN), in 2009
Public safety, Consumer electronics, secure authentication IEEE International Conference on Communications Workshops,
and Safeguarding of uniformed personnel. The challenges 2009, no. 60725105, pp. 1-5.
and open research area discussed in this study will be [22] Martin Brandl, Julius Grabner, Karlheinz Kellner, Franz Seifert,
considered as a source of inspiration for future research Johann Nicolics, Sabina Grabner, and Gerald Grabner,A Low-
Cost Wireless Sensor System and Its Application in Dental
directions. Retainers, IEEE SENSORS JOURNAL, VOL. 9, NO. 3, MARCH
2009
REFERENCES
219