Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Gordana Nikevi
far more studies in which organizational culture is taught people or taks. For the purposes of this research we will
from the perspective of structural functionalism, so the use Handy's classification of organizational culture, since
number of papers in which the leader shapes the culture is the questionnaire he constructed was available to the
significantly greater than the number of papers in which author.
the culture shapes the leader. In this sense, there is a small According to Handys classification (1983, 1979)
number of theoretical explanations of influence of organizational cultures differentiate according to two
organizational culture on leadership in organizations and criteria. The first criterion are values and norms
therefore the empirical studies to prove this influence. concerning distribution of power in an organization.
Therefore, the aim of this paper is to provide a theoretical According to this criterion there are cultures in which
explanation of the mechanism through which unequal distribution of power is present and cultures that
organizational culture shapes the leader and his style, as favor equal, i.e. egalitarian distribution of power in
well as, based on this explanation, to place hypotheses organizations. Another criterion for differentiation of
about the influence of culture on leadership, which could organizational culture relates to the primary component of
be empirically tested. an organization. Every organization consists of labor and
In this paper the first developed will be theoretical social component or tasks and people. Organizational
framework which will explain and operationalize two cultures differ according to which component
main variables of this research: organizational culture and organizations favour as the primary one. In this regard,
leadership and stated hypotheses about the relationship we distinguish between cultures which by their values and
between organizational culture and leadership. In the next norms favour orientation to people and cultures which by
section of the paper the research methodology will be their values and norms favour orientation to tasks. Using
presented: sample, instruments and research methods. both criteria at the same time, a matrix with four types of
Then, through presented research findings the way in organizational cultures can be constructed.
which organizational culture influences leadership style Power culture combines orientation to people with
will be presented. The research findings are given at the unequal distribution of power. This culture is oriented to
end of this paper, as well as some methodological and the leader, which is its main characteristic. Metaphor for
theoretical limitations of the same. this organization is family and the leader is, naturally "the
father of the family" who takes care of all its members,
2 Theoretical framework and they in turn show unquestioning obedience. The
leader personalizes the work of an organization to a large
Operationalization of organizational culture influence extent so everthing in it gets his personal touch and
on forming leadership in an organization is possible in depends on his style and competences. The organization
certain types of organizational culture and specific is informal and the relationships among its members are
leadership styles are brought into a causal relationship. To very close.
achieve this, it is necessary to identify the basic criteria Role culture combines orientation to tasks with
and dimensions of organizational culture relevant for unequal distribution of power. It is a bureaucratic culture
shaping the style of the leader and to identify the types of in which the organization represents a regulated social
organizational culture according to these dimensions. system governed by formal rules and procedures.
Then, it is necessary to identify the basic dimensions or Metaphor for organization in this culture is a machine.
criteria according to which leadership styles are Role culture is depersonalized so the basic elements of an
differentiated and identify main types of styles according organization are impersonally set roles and not
to these criteria. Finally, we should set up hypothesis individuals as persons.
about the relationship between certain types of Task culture combines orientation to tasks but also
organizational cultures on the one hand and leadership egalitarian distribution of power. In this culture,
styles they imply, on the other hand. everything is directed and subordinated to solving tasks in
There are numerous classifications of organizational an organization thus the organization exists in order to
cultures in the literature [7, 5, 11, 20, 9, 13, 14]. All these solve tasks. Everything is oriented towards the work that
classifications differ from each other according to the needs to be done and everything is subordinated to it.This
criteria based on which organizational cultures are culture highly values success and results. Values such as
differentiated: external vs. internal focus and flexibility autonomy, competence, development and flexibility rule
vs. stability [7, 11], needs and orientation of the people in the task culture.
[5], level of risk and speed of market feedback [9], People culture combines orientation to people and
egalitarity vs. hierarchy in distribution of power and egalitarian distribution of power. People culture is an
orientation to people vs. orientation to task [20, 13]. For individualistic culture. People culture is based on the
exploring the influence of organizational culture on assumption that the organization exists only to enable its
leadership the classification of culture is made according members to achieve their individual goals and interests.
to dimensions of influence that can be associated with it. Its main purpose, according to its members' assumptions,
These are classifications of leadership styles according to is to enable them to achieve their individual goals and
degree of involvement of employees in decision-making interests. The power in people culture is very widely
processes and manners of solving organizational problems distributed so, compared to all of the above mentioned
[3] as well as Handy's [13, 14] and Trompenaars's types of culture, people culture is "democratic" to the
classifications [20] that used the same dimensions: norms fullest extent.
related to distribution of power and norms related to As regards leadership operationalization, the two
most commonly used criteria or dimensions by which
calculated the average ranks of each respondent given to employees. Participative leader makes decisions including
each of four types of culture, and then constructed a employees in the process of decision-making and their
variable called "culttype" that shows what type of culture implementation in the company.
each respondent perceived as a dominant one in his Consequently, initial hypothesis is: Different leadership
organization. The variable "culttype" has the values 1, 2, styles correspond to different types of organizational
3 and 4 with the value of 1 meaning that the individual culture.
respondent perceived power culture as the dominant type The results obtained have shown that there is a
of culture in his company, the value of 2 means that he statistically significant relationship between leadership
perceived that the dominant culture in his organization styles and types of organizational culture (x = 8,11; p =
was the role culture, the value 3 implies that the dominant 0,044). Therefore, different types of organizational culture
one was the task culture and the value of 4 means that he imply different leadership styles. The leader in a particular
perceives people culture as the dominant type of culture organizational culture will choose the leadership style that
in his company. "Culttype" variable was then used to fits best to the assumptions contained in that culture.
analyse the influence of culture on job satisfaction. Otherwise, he will not be accepted as a leader.
Leadership style was operationalized through Power culture and the role culture are authoritarian
perception of respondents about the type of leader in his cultures with uneven distribution of power, which means
company and the manner in which he resolves problems that power is concentrated, i.e. centralized at the top. The
in the company i.e. whether he does it through work or leader is expected to make decisions alone, without
social structure and tasks. consulting his subordinates, so in case he tried to involve
employees in decision-making, he would be understood as
4.3 Research method indecisive and incompetent. As our research has shown,
authoritarian leadership style suits best to such cultures.
Research results were statistically analysed with an Therefore, the results obtained show that in the role culture,
adequate choice of statistical methods and depending on the the majority of respondents, i.e. 33 of them or 25,2 %, is of
type and distribution of data in order to provide an optimal opinion that their leader applies authoritarian leadership
model for consideration of influence, dependence and style. In the power culture 45,8 % of respondents believe
differences between the analysed data obtained in the that their leader applies authoritarian leadership style.
research. For investigation of relationship between two Task and people culture support are egalitarian cultures
discontinuous variables 2 test was used. Statistical with balanced distribution of power. Thus, power is not
significance was defined at the level of probability of the concentrated only on the top, but it is evenly distributed
null hypothesis of p 0,05 to p < 0,0001. Statistical within the company. In these cultures, the leader makes
processing and analysis were performed in the computer decisions with involvement of employees in the process of
program SPSS ver. 20 (Statistical Package for the Social decision-making. In this sense, participative leadership style
Sciences), a graphical and tabular presentation in Microsoft suits best to these cultures, which was also shown by the
Office (Excel and Word). data obtained. In the task culture, 68 % of respondents or
35,2 % holds that their leader applies participative
5 Research findings leadership style. In the power culture, 13 out of total of 15
respondents believe that their leader also applies
According to ranking of certain types of organizational participative leadership style. Therefore, the hypothesis of
culture, each respondent's perception as to what type of task culture and people culture imply participative
organizational culture his company belongs was determined. leadership style. If the leader tried to apply authoritarian
Of the total of 324 respondents, the largest number, i.e. 41 style, he would be seen as a dictator who does not respect its
% of them, perceived that the power culture is the most associates.
presented in their companies, 32 % perceived that it is the Hence, hypotheses about the relationship between
task culture, 22 % opted for role culture and 5 % for people organizational culture and leadership styles were fully
culture. confirmed. Based on the research we have shown that:
The role culture and power culture imply authoritarian
Table 1Type of organizational culture
leadership style.
Number of Structure of the
Type of culture Task culture and people culture imply participative
companies company
Power culture 133 41,0 leadership style.
Task culture 104 32,1
Role culture 72 22,2 = 8,11; df = 3; p = 0,044.
People culture 15 4,6
Total: 324 100,0 Depending on the manner of solving problems in the
company leaders may be oriented to people or tasks.
In this part of the study, we tested the influence of Leaders oriented to people solve problems through working
organizational culture on the choice of one of two leadership structure and tasks. Leaders oriented to tasks solve problems
styles: authoritarian and participative. Depending on the through social structure. In this regard, we distinguish
degree to which the leader involves employees in the between four types of leaders: authoritarian style oriented to
process of decision-making and their implementation, a people, authoritarian style oriented to tasks, participative
leader can be authoritarian and participative. As the word style oriented to people and participative style oriented to
itself says, the authoritarian leader relies on his authority tasks.
and makes decisions independently without including
Role culture is a bureaucratic culture where everything confirmed in this part, because it was not proven that the
is oriented to work, i.e. formal structure. In these cultures power culture implies authoritarian style oriented to people.
everything is formalized and everything is done in The reason is that, due to characteristics of already
accordance with formal division of labour in roles. In this mentioned Montenegrin national culture, the authoritarian
culture a leader does not include employees in decision leader, who solves problems through orientation to tasks, is
making and shaping of organizational action. He is more certainly more popular, as the results obtained have shown.
oriented towards formal structure of the organization In the task culture everything is subordinated to
(orders, procedures). We may conclude that in the role achieving goals and objectives of an organization through
culture the most effective leaders would be the ones who work, i.e. formal structure. Leader expects employees to
use authoritarian style oriented to tasks, as our research has participate in the process of decision-making and their
confirmed. Namely, in role culture, the majority of 72 implementation. He is not interested in interpersonal
respondents, i.e. 47 of them (65,3 %) believe that the leader relationships since they have to be adapted to working
in their company uses authoritarian style oriented to tasks environment. He is oriented only to formal structure and
when solving problems. tasks. In such cultures only leaders who combine a
Therefore, the hypothesis that organizational culture participative leadership style oriented to tasks can be
determines the leadership style has been confirmed, since it successful and effective. This has been confirmed by our
has been proven that the role culture implies authoritarian research. In the task culture 60,6 % of respondents believe
style oriented to tasks. that the leader in their company uses participative style
The power culture treats an organization as a family, oriented to tasks when solving problems. We conclude that
and a leader as father of the family. This culture is oriented the hypothesis about the influence of organizational culture
to people and their interrelations in organizational action. In on leadership has been confirmed in the part where the task
this culture leader regulates relationships through his culture implies a participative style oriented to tasks.
influence on employees, i.e. through social structure. It is The people culture means that an organization is
natural that the leader who uses authoritarian style of oriented to people and their needs and interests. The leader
leadership oriented to people suits such culture best. This who applies participative style oriented to people suits best
leader makes most of decisions alone and assumes to such cultures. This type of leader involves employees in
responsibility, but in implementation of these decisions he the process of decision-making and their implementation,
relies on his influence to people and their interrelations. but at the same time relies on his influence to people and
However, this study has not shown it. Only 19 out of 133 their interrelations, i.e. social structure. However, our
respondents (14,3 %) holds that their director is oriented to research did not show it. Namely, 86,7 % of respondents in
people when solving problems while greater number of people culture believe that their director solves problems in
respondents, i.e. 85 or 7 % of them believe that the leader is the company through tasks, orders and procedures, and only
nevertheless oriented to tasks when solving problems in the 13,3 % believes that their director relies on his influence to
company. Therefore, the hypothesis that organizational people and their interrelations, i.e. social structure when
culture affects the choice of leadership style has not been solving problems in the company. Therefore, the hypothesis
that organizational culture determines leadership style has methodological limitation of this paper is that in research
not been confirmed in the part that the people culture of relationship between culture and leadership numerous
implies participative style oriented to people. This culture factors were not controlled that could have an impact on
encompassed only 15 respondents, so it is disputable how this relationship. The research controlled the following
valid the conclusions may be based on perception of such influence on the relationship between culture and
significantly small number of employees. leadership: age, gender, type of ownership. However, the
influence of some potentially important factors such as
6 Conclusion company performance, type of organizational structure,
size of a company was not controlled.
Empirical research presented in this paper has shown
that organizational culture represents one of factors which 7 References
determine internal life of a company. As such, it also
affects leadership. Research results showed that there is a [1] Alavi, M.; Kayworth, T.R.; Leidner D.E. An Empirical
systematic and statistically significant connection Examination of the Influence of Organizational Culture on
between leadership styles and types of organizational Knowledge Management Practices. // Journal of
culture in sampled companies. Management Information Systems. 22, 3(2005/6), pp. 191-
224.
The main conclusion of this paper would be that the [2] Alvesson, M. Understanding Organizational Culture. Sage,
organizational culture is a factor that affects choice of London, 2002. DOI: 10.4135/9781446280072
leadership style in the company, i.e. due to different [3] Ashkanasy, C.; Wilderom, P. M.; Peterson, M. F. The
content of values and norms, different types of Handbook of Organizational Culture and Climate. Sage,
organizational culture dictate different leadership styles. Thousand Oaks, California, 2001.
Thus, power culture and role culture are authoritarian [4] Baird, K.; Harrison, G.; Reeve, R. The Culture of
cultures with balanced distribution of power and as such Australian Organizations and Its Relation with Strategy. //
they imply authoritarian leadership style. Task culture International Journal of Business Studies. 15, 1(2007), pp.
and people culture are egalitarian cultures, i.e. cultures in 15-41.
[5] Balthazard, P.; Cooke, R. E.; Potrer, R. A. Dysfunctional
which power is distributed unevenly and as such they Culture, dysfunctional organization: capturing the
imply participative leadership style. The above mentioned behavioral norms that form organizational culture and drive
research confirmed both hypotheses. Further investigation performance. // Journal of Managerial Psychology. 21,
confirmed that the role culture implies authoritarian style 8(2006), pp. 709-732. DOI: 10.1108/02683940610713253
oriented to tasks and that the task culture implies [6] Berson, Y.; Oreg, S.; Dvir, T. CEO Values, Organizational
participative style oriented to task. However, the Culture and Firm Outcomes. // Journal of Organizational
hypothesis that the power culture implies authoritarian Behavior. 29(2008), pp. 615-633. DOI: 10.1002/job.499
style oriented to people was not confirmed, the same as [7] Cameron, K. S.; Quinn, R. E. Diagnosing and changing
the hypothesis that people culture implies a participative organizational culture: The competing vales framework, 2nd
ed. Jossey-Bass, San Francisco, 2006.
style oriented to people. [8] De Long, D. W.; Fahey; L. Diagnosing Cultural Barriers to
What cannot be clearly seen from this study and what Knowledge Management. // Academy of Management
still needs to be explored is whether the organizational Executive. 14, 4(2000), pp. 113- 127.
culture, in addition to direct has also indirect or [9] Deal, T.; Kennedy, A. Corporate cultures: the rites and
moderating influence on leadership? This refers primarily rituals of corporate life. Addison Wesley, New York, 1982.
to the possibility that organizational culture affects some [10] Deem, J. M.; Barnes, B.; Segal, S.; Preziosi, R. 2010. The
of other leadership factors thus affecting leadership itself. relationship of organizational culture to Balanced Scorecard
It is important to emphasize that this study has some effectiveness. // SAM Advanced Management Journal. 75,
limitations both in theoretical framework and in research 4(2010), pp. 31-39.
[11] Denison, D.R. Organizational culture and effectiveness: can
methodology. Theoretical limitation of this paper is that American theory be applied in Russia? // Organization
the analysis of organizational culture was done from the Science. 14, 6(2003), pp. 686-706. DOI:
standpoint of perception of employees about the dominant 10.1287/orsc.14.6.686.24868
type of culture in their organization, and not the actual [12] Giberson, T. R.; Resick, C. J.; Dickson, M. W.; Mitchelson,
type of organizational culture present in the company. J. K.; Randall, K. R.; Clark M. A. Leadership and
Also, the model used in the study is quite sparse. Organizational Culture: Linking CEO Characteristics to
Namely, only the influence of two variables was explored Cultural Values. // Journal of Business Psychology.
in the paper, so the inclusion of some other variables 24(2009), pp.123-137. DOI: 10.1007/s10869-009-9109-1
would give a more accurate picture of influence of culture [13] Handy, C. Gods of management. Pan, London, 1979.
[14] Handy, C. Understanding organizations. Oxford University
on leadership. Press, New York, 1983.
As regards methodological limitations the basic [15] Henri, J. F. Organizational culture and performance
question is whether the sample was representative enough measurement systems. // Accounting, Organizations and
considering that there are very few organizations in which Society. 31(2006), pp. 77-103. DOI:
People culture dominates, i.e. how valid are conclusions 10.1016/j.aos.2004.10.003
based on a small number of respondents related to in this [16] Klein, A. Corporate culture: its value as a resource for
culture. Furthermore, when it comes to assessment of competitive advantage. // Journal of Business Strategy. 32,
organizational culture it is important to point out that only 2(2011), pp. 21-28. DOI: 10.1108/02756661111109743
the dominant type of organizational culture according to [17] Martin, J. Organizational Culture: Mapping the Terrain. Sage,
Newbury Park, California, 2002. DOI: 10.4135/9781483328478
perception of respondents was taken into account, not
other types present in that organization. Likewise,
Authors addresses