Professional Documents
Culture Documents
A Thesis Proposal
presented to the
In Partial Fulfillment
By:
Alcarde, Alfred S.
Rendaje, Reycian G.
This study would not have been possible without the guidance and help of
several individuals who, in one way or another, contributed and extended their valuable
We would like to express our most sincere gratitude to Engr. Hans Bosshard, for
having him as our adviser whose patience, motivation, enthusiasm, and immense
knowledge have helped us all throughout our research and writing process. We
could not have imagined having a better mentor other than him.
We are deeply indebted to Engr. Luis Angelo Sevilla for sponsoring our
thesis, for lending his time and patience to us, without him our study will not be a success.
We would like to thank the rest of our panel members: Dr. Manuel Belino, the
Anastasio, and Engr. Jaime Honra, for their encouragement, insightful comments, and
questions.
We would also like to thank our parents for their unwavering support
Above all, to our Almighty God for the countless blessings He has bestowed
upon us. For this achievement, we give back all the glory and praises to the omnipotent
Father Almighty.
Abstract
cooling for a residential house application. It involves the design, fabrication and
installation of the open-loop geothermal cooling system for an eight by ten ft.
conditioned room. The system was composed of three subsystems for an open loop
geothermal cooling system which were the centrifugal air blower system, piping system and
damper system.
The operation of the designed geothermal cooling system utilizes the cold
temperature of the soil which can serve as a heat sink. It promotes conduction and
convection heat transfer process between the air from the conditioned room and the heat
exchanger burrowed to the soil at a depth of 10 feet. With this, the study could provide
The results gathered proved that the geothermal cooling system can provide a
comfort cooling and that the soil of the Philippines is applicable for the geothermal
after two hours of continuous operation and with an average air-flow discharge velocity of
5m/s.
Based on the computation which compared the window type air conditioning
unit versus the installed geothermal cooling system (based from power consumption)
electricity consumption for one month, it showed that it is more economical to use a
INTRODUCTION
1.1 Overview
Geothermal cooling systems work by utilizing the principle of transferring the heat from
the room to an underground heat sink. The medium utilized for heat transfer is a refrigerant,
which is usually air or a liquid (water or a solution). The selection of the medium for the
underground heat exchanger varies with both the application and the required capacity. In this
study, the medium considered was air based from the systems design and availability.
The system for the study was composed of three subsystems for an open loop geothermal
cooling system which were the centrifugal air blower system, piping system and damper system.
The centrifugal air blower was used to induce air flow for the system through suction and
discharge between the room and the piping system. The piping system served as the heat
exchanger where conduction and convection heat transfer occurred. The damper system was
installed to regulate the humidity and the temperature of the room. The design of these three
subsystems varied with both the application and the capacity of the system.
The geothermal cooling system served as an alternative means for providing the benefits
the ambient temperature and humidity in the Philippines. Also, the application of geothermal
cooling system can provide the benefits of a conventional air conditioning system but with a
cooling processes for the room to be economical, environmental and practical that can be shown
from a small scale design. The dependence of the air conditioning unit to refrigerants, such as
R12, will be minimized while the utilization of the Philippines soil temperature will be the
In consideration to the climate of the Philippines, the group focused on the necessity to
find much sustainable and environmental ways to provide comfort cooling, as compared to
traditional air-conditioning systems. The study considered an open loop geothermal cooling
system.
The open loop geothermal cooling system was studied to provide convenience and
alternatives for an air conditioning unit to help lessen the electricity consumption. The selection
of subsystems such as damper and centrifugal air blower for the geothermal cooling system was
evaluated based from the theoretical computation to maximize the efficiency of the operation of
The operation of the subsystems damper and centrifugal air blower was needed to
function simultaneously, to lessen the excessive use of electricity and refrain the system from
being overused. Over usage occurs when the centrifugal air blower continuously discharges cool
air to the room while the damper introduces fresh air. Thus, the cooling comfort is not achieved.
Selection and installation of thermostat control system was also needed in order for the system to
function effectively.
The computation for the design of the geothermal cooling system was based from
existing studies available only from foreign countries. Most of the standard values used for the
computation for the designed system, such as length of the piping system for heat exchanger and
selection of centrifugal air blower, were approximate values and empirical formulas based from
other countries due to the absence of the necessary data in the Philippines.
The system was developed to investigate the feasibility and practicability of the system
for local residential use. The materials needed for the study were easily available and could
provide an inexpensive means for achieving the small scale geothermal cooling system.
The effectiveness of using subterranean soil as a heat sink in the Philippines has not yet
been proven widely by many institutions. This study relied mostly on empirical formulas and
data from the studies of other countries in evaluating the properties of the Philippine soil.
However, small groups from the Philippines had studied the geothermal cooling system and it
resulted to an effective comfort cooling. These results proved the possibility of installing a
The design of the geothermal cooling system was made to promote comfort cooling in a
conditioned room by satisfying the standards of a room temperature based on the Philippine
The group aimed to design, fabricate, install and test an open loop geothermal
cooling system with an automatic temperature control using a thermostat and a damper in
1.3.2.3 Design, fabricate and install an open loop earth-coupled heat exchanger/
piping system
1.3.2.7 Compare the outdoor temperature (ambient), room temperature and soil
temperature
The geothermal cooling system provides a more environment friendly air conditioning
alternative because of the absence of hazardous refrigerants. Instead of using a refrigerant, the
system used air from the room and brought it to the geothermal heat exchanger with the use of a
blower. Upon passing the heat exchanger, the air was cooled and returned to the conditioned
room.
The use of thermostat control system for automatic temperature control installed at the
damper system provided convenient comfort inside the conditioned room. The function of the
thermostat control system at the damper was to maintain the computed effective temperature
needed for comfort cooling. When the geothermal cooling system reached the set temperature
(computed effective temperature), the controller of the air blower will send a cut-off signal that
will turn off the air blower. The conditioned room is then supplemented by a damper with
ambient air. The damper operates by introducing fresh air (10% of total volumetric flow in the
heat exchanger) and change the humidity of the room until it reaches the effective comfort
cooling of 60% relative humidity. The application of these two thermostat controllers assists in
the minimization of the electricity consumption of the geothermal cooling system by limiting the
The installation of the geothermal cooling system provides Filipinos more access to air
conditioning system with low electric costs. With a properly designed geothermal cooling
system, the long term benefit it can offer in the electric bill will be noticed through a less air-
The thesis topic concentrated on the design, fabrication and installation of a small scale
geothermal cooling system that was applied to a constructed room in Limay, Bataan with the
dimensions of 8ft. by 10ft. The system was composed of three systems: piping system, air blower
and damper system with a thermostat device which served as the control system for delivering
the cooled air to the room. Its function was not evaluated continuously for one whole day rather
it was done at predetermined intervals for every two hours. The evaluation of operation of
geothermal cooling system must not be compared to the operation of an air-conditioning unit.
The use of existing geothermal studies was the basis of this study to avoid in-depth
analysis of the soil property for standard values used in the computations. The maximum depth
of the heat exchanger is 10 ft. as limited by the design and the innate difficulty for excavation of
the site. Soil and temperature gradient analysis was not included in the study.
The installation was done in the month of June only. The data used for performance
testing of the system was limited to those gathered during the same period. The design
computations and the operation of the developed system were limited to the available data on the
characteristics of air during the said period. Moreover, the data gathered by the group focused
The group purchased materials based on the design computation such as the air blower,
black iron pipes and damper. The damper was modified to install the electronic control system
with the thermostat. The damper system was attached to the room beside the suction pipe of the
centrifugal air blower so that the introduced fresh air may go directly to the designed heat
exchangers underground. The reason for installing the thermostat controller in both the single
phase motor of the air blower and the actuator of the damper was to maintain the desired
temperature inside the room, lessen the electricity consumption of the system by not having
excessive operation and for the damper and the geothermal cooling system to function efficiently
in uniform. In-depth details about the thermostat control system are not part of the discussion of
the study.
To prove the economic benefits of the small scale geothermal cooling system, only the
electric bill for one month based on the theoretical MERALCO computations.
Options for site selection were minimal because of the expensive labor and works needed
in an installation of a geothermal cooling system. It required a large area of empty lot, which will
be dug to a depth of 10 feet. Also, it was necessary to have the consent of the landlord since there
This chapter provides a review of various studies and literature related to geothermal
cooling.
This section will highlight different kinds of related studies on geothermal cooling.
2.1.1 Investigating the Potential Benefits and Risks for Low to Zero Energy Air-
Sourced Earth Coupled Cooling and Heating Systems. (Butler, Littlewood and
Tucker 2011)
consumption and greenhouse gas emissions for buildings. It also discussed the
technology of the ASECch systems that provide potential benefits in designing an energy
saving building that operates in both cooling and heating depending on its purpose.
Criteria were also proposed in this paper for the calculation of the performance for a
One objective of this paper is to maintain healthy indoor air quality which
maintains relative concentrations of carbon dioxide (CO2) below the standard levels. A
study from Health Canada suggests that CO2 concentrations above 1800 are indicative
that inadequate or no fresh air is introduced in the room though complaints have been
recorded at concentrations as low as 1100 .
Through this study, the group prioritized supplying fresh air into the system to
ensure that CO2 concentration was not above the standards. The effect of supplying fresh
air in the system is very important to lessen the possibility of having a sick building
syndrome and to lessen the possibility of causing loss of productivity and possible
2.1.2 Study on Using the Ground as a Heat Sink for a 12,000-Btu/h Modified Air
12,000-Btu/h that used the ground as a heat sink for the condenser. The objective of the
study was to reduce the energy consumption of air conditioning, particularly in household
and building, using sink reservoir. Generally, there were two large sources of sink
reservoirs that can be applied, namely water (i.e. sea and lake) and ground (Odey 1993).
Regarding the ground, two methods were proposed: earth/air tunnel and ground source
The experiment was performed in a room with a nearby soil. A modified air
conditioner was used by extending the copper coils 1 meter below the ground acting as a
heat sink varied in four values of lengths: 67, 50, 40, and 30 m in length. The test runs
were done during day time from 8am to 5pm for a week per different values of
(compressor and evaporating fan) was also measured during test runs to maintain similar
The COP values of M-AC were higher than that of C-AC except for the case of 30-
m coil length. Through this experiment, the group will surely have an idea that if the
The paper mentioned above was the researchers primary source of information
about geothermal cooling system. The study was very relevant since it was done in the
Philippines. The study aimed to design and develop an air-conditioning system using the
underground temperature to cool down the temperature of the ventilation air or using the
soil as heat sink. The study also aimed to provide a suitable environment for a process
being carried out regardless of heat inside the house and external weather conditions.
The group used polyvinyl chloride pipe as the material for the ground loop. The
ground loop was on a depth of 6 ft. and used 36 square feet of area. The length of the
ground loop amounted to 107 ft. The cooling system had an option of getting air from the
The study was able to reach a temperature difference between the supply and
The average relative humidity of the ambient air and the supply air was recorded 70% and
75% respectively.
2.1.4 Air Conditioning Earth Coupled Water Source Heat Pumps - Closed and
The paper focuses on the thermodynamic and heat transfer principles as applied to
earth-coupled. There are two types of loops being discussed in this paper namely: open
loop and closed loop system. In open loop system, water under the ground is being
withdrawn by an aquifer and used for cooling or heating purposes then discharged into an
injection back in the aquifer. In closed system, water inside the pipe is circulated in a
continuous closed pipe loop from the soil through the heat exchanger and then back into
This section will focus on the different related literature on geothermal cooling.
There are only two seasons in the Philippines, wet and dry. The northern
part of the Philippines is cooler in the months of November to February and the
hottest in the months of April and May. In big cities like Metro Manila, concrete and
place in the soil such as chemical reactions and biological interactions. Soil
through the soil surface. These effects are propagated into the soil profile by
transport processes and are influenced by such things as the specific heat capacity,
seasonal swings in overlying air temperature, local vegetation cover, type of soil,
These soil thermal properties depend strongly on soil porosity and moisture
project will require knowing the soil texture and the average groundwater level at the
Because the weight of air varies with pressure and temperature, it has to be
defined accurately. The following figures may be used. The weight of dry air (no
pressure of 1000 mbar (1 Bar) is 1.275 kg/m3 (Frazer 1999). Table 2-2 shows the
temperature to lower temperatures. Therefore, if a hot fluid and a cold fluid are
separated by a heat conducting surface, heat can be transferred from the hot fluid
to the cold fluid (Cripps 2006). Figure 2-1 shows the simplified heat exchanger.
Figure 2-1 Simplified Heat Exchanger
(Source: http://www.vesma.com)
2.2.5.1 The rate of heat flow at any point depends on the following:
2.2.5.1.1 Heat transfer coefficient (U), itself a function of the properties of the
2.2.5.2 Total heat transferred (Q) depends on the factors mentioned below:
2.2.5.2.3 Average temperature difference between the streams, strictly the log
Thus, total heat transferred Q = UADTLM. However, the larger the area, the
temperature object. Heat transfer changes the internal energy of both systems
particles (atoms, molecules, ions, electrons, etc.) in the intervening space (Elert
1998). The nature of the transfer of energy from the pipes and the soil is
matter from a hot region to a cool region, as opposed to the microscopic transfer
of heat between atoms involved with conduction (Drakos 1998). As this air
heats, the molecules spread out, causing this region to become less dense than
that of the surrounding. Being less dense than the surrounding cooler air, the hot
air will subsequently rise due to buoyant forces - this movement of hot air into a
cooler region is then said to transfer heat by convection. Convection will take
place inside the pipe where the air flow transfers heat to the pipe. The transfer
of the heat is called convection because the moving hot air transfers the heat to
Warm air can hold much more mass of water vapor than cold air.
However, if the temperature is changed by 40F, then the warm air can hold 11
grams of water vapor. Thus, the 10 grams at new temperature holds 95%
temperatures are typically closer to the current temperature in cold air, making
the relative humidity, or the percent of water vapor in the air from what the
water can hold, much higher. If the same temperature is considered and raised
while keeping the same amount of water vapor, the maximum amount of water
that can be held is much higher, making the relative humidity much lower
(Ahrens 2007).
value may be less for a higher temperature and high for a lower temperature as
it denotes the ratio of the amount of water vapor actually present to the amount
measuring the velocity of fluid over a known area. Air flow rate is important
systems, tap into the constant, moderate temperatures found a few feet below the
surface of the earth, to offer the finest in home comfort conditioning. The shallow
Geothermal systems use the earth as a heat source or heat sink. A series of
pipes, commonly called a "loop," carry a fluid used to connect the geothermal
system's heat pump to the earth. The different types of geothermal systems are
passed through the heat pumps heat exchanger, and is discharged to the
same aquifer through a second well at a distance from the first. Generally,
two to three gallons per minute per ton of capacity is necessary for
constant throughout the year, open loops are a popular option in areas
the heat pump's heat exchanger. Such situations may require precautions
to keep carbon dioxide and other gases in the water solution. Other options
include the use of cupronickel heat exchangers and heat exchangers that
(Source: http://www.energysavers.gov)
2.2.7.1.2 Closed Loops
Closed loop systems are the most commonly used loop orientation
design. (Some heat pumps work well with larger inlet temperature
(Source: http://www.energysavers.gov)
example, most large commercial buildings and schools use vertical loops
because the land area required for horizontal loops would be prohibitive.
Vertical loops are also used where the soil is too shallow for trenching.
conditions in the ground may vary greatly, loop lengths can range from
130 to 300 feet per ton of heat exchange. Multiple drill holes are required
for most installations, where the pipes are generally joined in parallel or
series-parallel configurations.
A vertical loop well field, being used for the Finger Lakes
and number of wells was determined by the estimated heat and cooling
(Source: http://www.energysavers.gov)
Pond closed loops are a special kind of closed loop system. Where
there is a pond or stream that is deep enough and with enough flow, closed
loop coils can be placed at the bottom of the pond. Fluid is pumped just as
have been shown. Figure 2-5 shows a diagram of a closed loop system at a
pond or lake.
(Source: http://www.energysavers.gov)
effective where cooling needs are significantly larger than heating needs.
wells are drilled. Water is drawn from the bottom of a standing column
and returned to the top. During periods of peak heating and cooling, the
system can bleed a portion of the return water rather than re-injecting it
all, causing water inflow to the column from the surrounding aquifer. The
bleed cycle cools the column during heat rejection, heats it during heat
source heat pumps, has been named "the most energy-efficient and
the earth's constant temperature, approximately 55F, to heat and cool a building.
By tapping this steady flow of heat from the earth in the winter, and displacing
heat in the earth in the summer, a geothermal heat pump can save homeowners 40
be maintained without active heating and cooling systems (Adamson 1987 and
Feist 1988). The house heats and cools itself, hence "passive".
annual heating requirement that is less than 15 kWh/(ma) (4755 Btu/ft/yr), not to
be attained at the cost of an increase in use of energy for other purposes (e.g.,
Btu/ft/yr) for heat, hot water and household electricity. A passive house is cost-
effective when the combined capitalized costs (construction, including design and
installed equipment, plus operating costs for 30 years) do not exceed those of an
THEORETICAL CONSIDERATIONS
This chapter discusses concepts necessary for the design, fabrication and installation of a
The design of the geothermal cooling system was meant to control and modify the given
room temperature as affected by the ambient temperature and other possible sources of
temperature that could affect the controlled room temperature. The cooling was done by the
temperature difference between the room temperature and the soil temperature that occurs at the
system that was designed to have three subsystems which were thermostat controlled air blower
The process starts with the provided air with certain temperature inside the piping system
which circulates at a closed loop system. The air was cooled through conduction heat transfer
between the temperature difference of air flowing in the pipe and the cold soil temperature at the
depth of 6 feet for the first layer of horizontal loop, 8 feet for the secondary layer of horizontal
loop and 10 feet for the third and last layer from the ground. The air was brought by a centrifugal
air blower from the room with a high temperature to the piping system which served as the heat
exchanger so that convection heat transfer could take place between the air flowing from the
pipes and the piping system design and acted as a cooling coil. Conduction heat transfer took
place from the temperature difference between the soil and the piping system.
Electricity consumption only took place at centrifugal air blower and damper, to promote
efficient electricity consumption. The use of control system was introduced to the air blower and
the damper to work uniformly. The air blower and the damper were set to achieve and maintain
the room temperature equivalent to the computed effective temperature for comfort cooling.
The piping system served as the passage and the heat exchanger of the geothermal
cooling system. The air travelled from the room to the piping system that acted as the heat
exchanger.
The air that underwent conduction and convection heat transfer carries the lower
temperature from the soil and is used to control the room temperature to achieve comfort cooling
The design of piping system for small scale geothermal system was classified into
two loops: closed and opened loop. The loop applied to the study was an open loop with
air as the medium in carrying the cold temperature. The cycle took place inside the
An open loop system is a process where the cooled medium is at cycle inside the
contaminants. In the studys case, the air flowing through the system was affected by the
outside air when the dampers thermostat control detected that the room temperature was
The piping system underground is classified into two: Horizontal loop and
Vertical loop. The loop applied for the study is a horizontal loop where the conduction
This piping system is placed underground with a depth of 6 feet for the first
horizontal layer, 8 feet for second horizontal layer and 10 feet for third horizontal layer. It
is considered to be the most cost effective for small installation such as for private uses
(Geothermal Heating & Cooling systems 2005). Figure 3-1 shows an example of a
(Source: http://www.hydro.mb.ca)
3.3 Selection of Air Blower System
The air blower unit was used to distribute the cold temperature harnessed from the soil to
the room using conduction and convection heat transfer. The design was composed of piping
system where the geothermal cooling system was coupled while the single phase air blower
The selection of the air blower unit varied with the air temperature it was carrying, air
flow, operational efficiency, power consumption, size occupied for its room installation and its
initial price. In the study, the air blower unit was a single phase centrifugal blower.
The heat transfers that were present at the Geothermal Cooling System were convection
and conduction. Conduction occurred between the piping system and soil while convection
The system followed the 2nd law of thermodynamics which stated that energy has
quality as well as quantity, and actual process occurs in the direction of decreasing quality of
energy. The 2nd law of thermodynamics was followed when the horizontal loop gave off heat
Conduction was the transfer of energy from the more energetic particles of a
substance to the adjacent less energetic ones as a result of interaction between particles.
This occurred at the horizontal loop burrowed under the ground with the depth of 6 feet
for first horizontal loop, 8 feet for second horizontal loop and 10 feet for third horizontal
loop. The heat transfer occurred between the cold soil and flowing warm air from the
(3.1)
Where:
=heat transfer
U= overall conductance
3.4.2 Convection
Convection was the transfer of energy between a solid surface and the
adjacent fluid that was in motion. It involved the combined effects of conduction
and fluid motion. This occurred at the piping system when the warm air flowed
through the pipe at a turbulent flow. The air flow was induced by the centrifugal
air blower. Equation 3.2 shows the effect of the temperature difference, mass flow
rate, and the specific heat on the convection heat transfer rate.
Where:
= heat transfer
= specific heat
The room temperature was evaluated with relation to the ambient temperature, water at
underground temperature, and sources of heat gain through heat load calculation and
psychrometric chart.
the study of moist air and of the changes in its conditions. The psychrometric
same temperature.
chart.
the psychrometric chart by a third set of sloping lines, near to, but
confusion, there are no lines shown, but external scales are given
on two sides.
temperature.
3.5.1.7 Latent heat is the heat content due to the presence of water vapour
The terms above were easily evaluated and measured for the difference
brought by the system applied to the room through the use of psychrometric chart.
Considering that the study centers with the air conditioning system, the effect of
the installation at one room will be graphically evaluated to see the air
conditioning process.
The sensible and latent heat gains were considered in the room. The
design cooling load (or heat gain) was the amount of heat energy to be removed
from a house by the HVAC equipment to maintain the house at indoor design
temperature. There were two types of cooling loads, namely: sensible cooling
The sensible cooling load was related to the dry bulb temperature of the
building and the latent cooling load is related to the wet bulb temperature of the
building.
One source of sensible and latent heat gains in the computation was from people. It
greatly varied from the number of people inside the room and the activities undertaken. The
values used for people were taken from carrier system design manual (Carrier 1965). Table 3.1
shows the diversity factors for the different usage of the room. Table 3-2 shows the room heat
Table 3.1 Typical Diversity Factor for Large Buildings (Carrier 1965)
3.7 Sensible Heat and Latent heat from Light and other Electric Equipment
Appliances that consumed electricity also contributed to the heat gain in the room. Table
3-3 shows the usual power consumption of appliances as well as the rate of usage.
Appliances Quantity Wattage Time of use per Days per month of consumption
day
Lights 1 32 6 30
Television 1 110 10 30
19
Electric Fan 1 80 12 30
14
The values written above are used in the computation of the grand total heat of the room
using the carriers heat load form. Factor used in the heat load form being Factor = 0.5 (Carrier
1965).
3.8 Soil Temperature Variations with Time and Depth
Soil temperature fluctuates annually and daily and is affected mainly by variations in air
temperature and solar radiation. The annual variation of daily average soil temperature at
different depths is described with the following sinusoidal function (Hillel 1982), as shown in
equation 3.3.
'
+ , & - 1 ,
!" # $ % &( $ !) * ./0
+2 (3.3)
Where:
Once the room heat load has been determined, the ground loop length can then be
The ground loop is a heat exchanger that is similar to a cooling coil or an evaporator in a
chiller. The goal is to transfer energy from the heat pump loop fluid to/from the ground. The
purpose of loop design is to estimate the required loop length. Equation 3.4 shows the formula of
the heat needed to lower the temperature of the room. (McQuay 2002)
6789 & 8: ;
Q <
(3.4)
Where:
>?
R is the thermal resistance to heat transfer= @ A
Ground heat exchanger sizing is concerned mainly with the determination of heat
exchanger length. The method used in the Ground Source Heat Pump (GSHP) Project Model is
largely adapted from International Ground-Source Heat Pump Association (IGSHPA) (1988).
Equation 3.5 shows the formula of needed length of the pipe. (RETScreen 1965)
DEFGH
7IJ KIL MN ;
B C DEF
S (3.5)
OPQ &OR
Where:
b
Fc is the part load factor for cooling, h b N
ij
3.9.3 Czech Technical Universitys Design of earth-to-air heat exchanger loop calculation
The method allows the design of EAHXs. Particularly, the method is beneficial for the
preliminary design phase when conceptual variants of building ventilation and cooling are
lP +,e m
k >P ?P
(3.6)
Where:
@
ha is the air-to-pipe convective heat transfer coefficient =>p qA
rs
ma is the mass air flow rate = A
t
Ca is the specific thermal capacity of air =rs qA
The mass flow rate of cooling air needed is shown on equation 3.7.
u v (3.7)
Where:
m is the mass flow rate of air (kg/s)
Q is the flow rate (. /s), Supply Air Quantity from heat load form, as shown on
equation 3.8.
1923: represented by a set of equal comfort lines drawn on the psychrometric chart. It is defined
as the temperature of a still, saturated atmosphere, which would, in the absence of radiation,
produce the same effect as the atmosphere in question. Equation 3.9 shows the formula for the
Iy
0.4 $ 10 $ =1 z44
A !) (3.9)
Where:
ET = effective temperature
RH = designed room RH
the subject would experience the same feeling of comfort as experienced in the actual
1965)
CHAPTER 4
METHODOLOGY
This chapter discusses the processes and methods of geothermal cooling that is important
in the study as well as the appropriate equipment and pipes to be selected for installation. Figure
4-1 shows the step-by-step procedures that were undertaken by the group.
Site selection
Excavation
Installation of geothermal cooling system and damper
Testing
Collection of data
In the site selection process, the group had considered the convenience and proximity of
the site. The group had chosen a private property located at Limay, Bataan as its location for it
was the only place that was available for excavation. The location was the most convenient
because the excavation site is owned by the family of Mr. John Luigi Manansala and was the
The excavation was done by hired and trusted workers from Limay, Bataan. A small
room was built on the above mentioned plot of land for the purpose of this study.
4.2 Evaluation of Room Properties
The room was evaluated with the use of equipment and proper standards in evaluating the
properties of the room. Evaluation of room properties was important before the installation of the
geothermal heat exchanger. It could help the group to select the proper type of materials and
The different parameters measured were the dry bulb temperature, wet bulb temperature,
air flow rate, relative humidity, sources of heat gain: light sensible heat, sensible and latent heat
The apparatus needed for measuring these parameters were the digital hygrometer for
measuring wet bulb temperature, dry bulb temperature and relative humidity of the room, the
speedometer for measuring the air flow rate of the intake and discharge pipes, the heat load
calculation and the carrier psychometric chart for measuring heat gain and room properties.
4.3 Geothermal Cooling System
The Geothermal Cooling System consists of the three subsystems which are the blower
system, piping system and damper system. Figure 4-2 shows the schematic diagram of the
The operation of geothermal cooling system as described by the diagram started at the
suction of air to the intake pipe. The air was taken to the heat exchanger using the air blower.
The air at the heat exchanger would have undergone through a conduction and convection heat
transfer process, wherein the air from the room would gradually decrease its temperature after
the air passed through the pipes. The air from the underground heat exchanger with a lower
The damper operates with the help of the thermostat which serves as a control system for
an automatic open or close operation. When the room temperature is below 27oC, then the
damper opens itself to let the fresh air enter the room. However, when the room temperature is
The air blower also operates with the help of the thermostat. It automatically turns off
when the temperature inside the room is below 27oC, and it turns itself on if the temperature
For the medium of heat transfer to be used, air was chosen to simplify the geothermal
cooling system, since it was free, safe and non-toxic. The air from the room is cooled by passing
through the ground which has a lower temperature; this is done by using pipes which will act as
heat exchangers. Conduction heat transfer occurs between the heat exchanger and the soil from
the ground while convection heat transfer occurs between the heat exchanger and the air flowing
The pipe used for the ground loop design was a black iron steel pipe. It was chosen for its
durability, thermal conductivity and it was cheaper compared to the other pipes being considered
in the design of the piping system. The black iron steel pipe was designed to be a three layer
parallel connecting pipes and was made for the passage of air from the room to the ground, hence
The piping system was designed to have three layers, the first layer starts at 6 feet, the
The horizontal ground loop piping design was chosen because of the available depth at
the selected site and lack of equipment necessary for the depth required in a vertical loop piping
system installation (usually 100 feet). The horizontal ground loop piping system does not require
high depth compared to vertical loop. Also, the horizontal set-up was much more ideal for the
process and the system would have smaller scales in the pipe. Existing studies show that
The draining system was placed at the bottom part of the heat exchanger where liquid
condensate accumulates. The system was designed to be opened manually using a lever attached
to the ball valve and functions through pulling the lever up. The lever was located beside the
discharge pipe. Furthermore, the heat exchanger was tilted so that the liquid condensate will
Selection of blowers was dependent on the system design, on such cases, the piping and
The group identified the internal heat load of the room, room temperature, air flow rate
and the pressure head that was necessary in selecting the blower. Along with the parameters
considered, computation of flow characteristics to determine the turbulent flow, pressure drop
The electricity consumption of the geothermal cooling system was evaluated based from
The selection of damper system varied with the size of the room and the air flow needed
The damper was mounted to an actuator for an automatic operation. The air flow passing
through the damper was set to be at 10% of the total ambient air. The 10% ambient air helped
affect the rooms properties such as humidity and temperature to achieve comfort cooling.
4.7 Excavation
The excavation site at Limay, Bataan is owned by the family of Mr. John Luigi
Manansala.
The design of the excavation was highly dependent on the existing studies that were
used in the field of geothermal heat pump such as the standard depth at which the temperature of
the soil was most likely effective for the soil conductivity.
The total depth of the excavation was 10 feet with 3 layers of horizontal piping system
burrowed at 6 feet for the first layer, 8 feet for the second layer and 10 feet for the third layer.
Workers were hired to do the excavation. They were able to accomplish the work within
one month. Apart from the soil excavation, removal of large stones was necessary and made the
work difficult.
After the installation of the piping system, the soil was filled back. New soil was added
due to the removal of large boulders. No pressure was applied while filling back the soil to avoid
damaging the piping system. Hence, the soil still sank and addition of new soil was required.
4.8 Installation of geothermal cooling system and damper
After the excavation and the installation of the piping system, the air blower was
mounted to the intake pipe of the piping system. Furthermore, the intake and the discharge pipe
The damper system was installed to the wall of the house and located near the intake pipe
of the piping system. The installation helps the cooling process to maintain the effective
4.9 Installation of thermostat controller at air blower and damper for automatic cut on/cut
The thermostat controller which was attached to both the damper and the centrifugal air
blower operates by controlling the voltage input in the actuator of the damper and the single
phase motor of the centrifugal air blower. The thermostat controller for the centrifugal air blower
was set to have a cut-off of electricity to automatically turn off the motor of air blower when the
effective temperature (set temperature) was met. The blower continuously operates when the
room temperature does not meet the set temperature that is affixed at the thermostat. The set
The thermostat controller for the damper is set to have a cut-in voltage to automatically
turn on the dampers actuator and to intake fresh air. It is designed to intake 10% of ambient air
flow when the room temperature is below the desired temperature (which is the computed
effective temperature) and closes when the room temperature is above the desired temperature.
The desired temperature for the damper controller was modified through the controller attached
to the thermostat.
4.10 Testing and Evaluation of Open Loop Geothermal Cooling System
After the installation of the open loop geothermal cooling system, the group evaluated the
The rooms comfort cooling properties were evaluated using the apparatus which were
the digital hygrometer, anemometer, analog thermometer. The digital hygrometer was used for
evaluating the air properties of the room after the cooling process such as the dry bulb
temperature, wet bulb temperature and relative humidity. The analog thermometer was used for
calibration of the digital hygrometer and anemometer. Anemometer was used to measure the air
Parameters considered for evaluating the effectiveness of the geothermal cooling system
were the relative humidity, temperature of the ambient air and temperature of the conditioned
room before the system was used for its operation, and also the velocity and temperature of the
intake and discharge air flow, the relative humidity and temperature after the geothermal cooling
DATA ANALYSIS
This chapter discusses the data and analysis of the tests conducted on the geothermal
cooling system.
The group observed the geothermal cooling system for one week. They gathered data in
three time intervals to prevent the blower from overheating. The three time intervals were 9-11
The parameters that were observed are dry bulb temperature, relative humidity, and
velocity of air at the suction and discharge ends of the piping system. In naming the parameters,
T represents the Dry Bulb Temperature. RH represents the Relative humidity. Vintake
represents the velocity at the suction end of the pipe. Vdis represents the velocity at the
discharge end of the pipe. Room signifies that the parameter represented is taken inside the
room. Out signifies that the parameter represented is taken from ambient surroundings outside
the room. T signifies the difference in temperature, thus T1 represents the difference
The following data were gathered during the first day of operation. The
general weather experienced throughout the day was sunny. The summary of data
Date 7/1/2012
Time 9-11 am 1-3 pm 5-7 pm
Weather Sunny
At Start After 2 Hours At Start After 2 Hours At Start After 2 Hours
Troom, (C) 28.7 27.1 31.8 29.8 28.8 26.8
RHroom, (%) 80.5 85 78 79.3 85.2 84.2
Tout, (C) 28.2 29.3 31.5 32 29.3 28.6
RHout, (%) 80.7 77.6 75.4 76.7 80.4 82.3
Tintake, (C) 28 28 29.5 29.5 28.5 28.5
Vintake, (m/s) 2.1 2.1 2.1 2.1 2.1 2.1
Tdis, (C) 26.3 26.3 27.1 27.1 26.5 26.5
Vdis, (m/s) 5.2 5.2 5 5 5.1 5.1
Tout - Troom, (C) 0.5 2.2 0.3 2.2 0.5 1.8
Tintake-Tdis, (C) 1.7 1.7 2.4 2.4 2 2
The previous data were represented in graphs as shown in Figure(s) 5.1, 5.2, and 5.3.
34
32
T
e
m 30
p
e 28 Troom
r
a Tout
t 26
u Tintake
r 24 Tdis
e
( C)
22
20 Time
9am 11am 1pm 3pm 5pm 7pm
geothermal cooling. Tout increased during the 9-11 am interval and 1-3 pm
interval while it decreased during the 5-7 pm interval. Troom decreased all
90
80
T
e 70
m
p 60
e RHroom
r 50
a RHout
t 40
u Vintake
r 30
Vdis
e
( C) 20
10
0 Time
9am 11am 1pm 3pm 5pm 7pm
Figure 5.2 Relative humidity and velocity in the intake and discharge pipes
Vintake and Vdis remained constant throughout the operation. RHout
decreased during 9-11 am interval while it increased during the 1-3 pm and 5-7
pm interval.
2.5
V
e
l
2
o
c
T1
1.5
i T2
t
y 1 T3
( )
0.5
0 Time
9am-11am 1pm-3pm 5pm-7pm
There was a minimal temperature difference from Troom and Tout at the start
of the operation, as represented by T1. T2 is equal and at its highest during the
9-11 am and 1-3 pm. T3 was at its highest during the 1-3 pm interval and lowest
The following data were gathered during the second day of operation. The
general weather experienced throughout the day was sunny. The summary of data
Date 7/2/2012
Time 9-11 am 1-3 pm 5-7 pm
Weather Sunny
At Start After 2 Hours At Start After 2 Hours At Start After 2 Hours
Troom, (C) 29.4 27.8 32.6 30.5 28 26.8
RHroom, (%) 81.7 80.9 75 78.5 83.4 82.2
Tout, (C) 29.1 30.2 31.2 32.4 27.6 27.2
RHout, (%) 80.4 79.5 77.6 77.5 79.6 80.2
Tintake, (C) 28.4 28.4 29.6 29.6 27.5 27.5
Vintake, (m/s) 2.1 2.1 2.1 2.1 2.1 2.1
Tdis, (C) 26.6 26.6 27.8 27.8 26.3 26.3
Vdis, (m/s) 5.2 5.2 5.1 5.1 5 5
Tout - Troom, (C) 0.3 2.4 1.4 1.9 0.4 0.4
The previous data were represented in graphs as shown in Figure(s) 5.4, 5.5, and 5.6.
34
T 32
e
m 30
p
e Troom
28
r Tout
a 26
t Tintake
u 24
r Tdis
e 22
( C)
20 Time
9am 11am 1pm 3pm 5pm 7pm
geothermal cooling. Troom. . Tout increased during the 9-11 am interval and 1-3
pm interval while it decreased during the 5-7 pm interval. Troom decreased
90
80
T
e 70
m
p 60
e RHroom
r 50
a RHout
t 40
u Vintake
r 30
Vdis
e
20
( C)
10
0 Time
9am 11am 1pm 3pm 5pm 7pm
Figure 5.5 Relative humidity and velocity in the intake and discharge pipes
decreased during 1-3 pm interval and 5-7 pm interval while it increased during the
1-3 pm and 5-7 pm interval. RHroom decreased during the 9-11 am interval and 5-7
2.5
V
e
l 2
o
c T1
i
1.5
t T2
y 1 T3
( )
0.5
0 Time
9am-11am 1pm-3pm 5pm-7pm
T1 is lowest during 9-11 am and 1-3 pm while it is highest during the 1-3
pm interval. T2 is at its highest during the 9-11 am and at its lowest during the 5-
7 pm interval. T3 is equal during 9-11 am interval and 1-3 pm interval and at its
The following data were gathered during the third day of operation. The
general weather experienced throughout the day was rainy. The summary of data
Date 7/3/2012
Time 9-11 am 1-3 pm 5-7 pm
Weather Rainy
At Start After 2 Hours At Start After 2 Hours At Start After 2 Hours
Troom, (C) 28.2 28.2 28.6 27.9 28.3 28.1
RHroom, (%) 84.4 79 83.3 74 85.8 83
Tout, (C) 29.3 30.4 30.4 31.7 27.8 27.6
RHout, (%) 78.5 80.1 77.1 79.9 82.3 83.3
Tintake, (C) 27.4 27.4 27.4 27.4 26.9 26.9
Vintake, (m/s) 2.1 2.1 2.1 2.1 2.1 2.1
Tdis, (C) 26.3 26.3 26.1 26.1 26.2 26.2
Vdis, (m/s) 4.9 4.9 5.2 5.2 5.1 5.1
Tout - Troom, (C) 1.1 2.2 1.8 3.8 0.5 0.5
Tintake-Tdis, (C) 1.1 1.1 1.3 1.3 0.7 0.7
The previous data were represented in graphs as shown in Figure(s) 5.7, 5.8, and 5.9.
34
T
32
e
m
p 30
e
r 28 Troom
a
t
Tout
u 26
Tintake
r
e 24 Tdis
( C)
22
20 Time
9am 11am 1pm 3pm 5pm 7pm
geothermal cooling. Tout increased during the 9-11 am interval and 1-3 pm
interval while it decreased during the 5-7 pm interval. Troom decreased all
100
90
T 80
e
m 70
p
e 60 RHroom
r
a 50 RHout
t
u
40 Vintake
r 30 Vdis
e
( C) 20
10
0 Time
9am 11am 1pm 3pm 5pm 7pm
Figure 5.8 Relative humidity and velocity in the intake and discharge pipes
operation.
4
3.5
V
e 3
l
o 2.5
c T1
i 2
t T2
y 1.5
T3
( ) 1
0.5
0 Time
9am-11am 1pm-3pm 5pm-7pm
T1 was at its highest during the 1-3 pm interval while it was at its lowest
during the 5-7 pm interval. T2 was at its highest during the 1-3 pm interval while
it was at its lowest during the 5-7 pm interval. T3 was at its highest during the 1-
The following data were gathered during the fourth day of operation. The
general weather experienced throughout the day was rainy. The summary of data
Date 7/4/2012
Time 9-11 am 1-3 pm 5-7 pm
Weather Rainy
At Start After 2 Hours At Start After 2 Hours At Start After 2 Hours
Troom, (C) 27.7 27.1 29.7 28.1 28.8 27.1
RHroom, (%) 86.3 87 80.8 82.1 83.5 79.3
Tout, (C) 28.4 29.8 31.3 30.2 27.9 27.8
RHout, (%) 80.7 78.9 77.8 76.1 79.6 82
Tintake, (C) 27.3 27.3 28.4 28.4 27.8 27.8
Vintake, (m/s) 2.1 2.1 2.1 2.1 2.1 2.1
Tdis, (C) 25.6 25.6 26.4 26.4 25.5 25.5
Vdis, (m/s) 4.8 4.8 5.1 5.1 4.4 4.4
Tout - Troom, (C) 0.7 2.7 1.6 2.1 0.9 0.7
Tintake-Tdis, (C) 1.7 1.7 2 2 2.3 2.3
The previous data were represented in graphs as shown in Figure(s) 5.10, 5.11, and 5.12.
32
T
e 30
m
p 28
e
r
Troom
a 26 Tout
t
u Tintake
r 24
e Tdis
( C)
22
20 Time
9am 11am 1pm 3pm 5pm 7pm
geothermal cooling. Tout increased during the 9-11 am interval and 1-3 pm
interval while it decreased during the 5-7 pm interval. Troom decreased all
100
T 90
e
80
m
p 70
e
r 60 RHroom
a
50 RHout
t
u 40 Vintake
r
e 30 Vdis
( C)
20
10
0 Time
9am 11am 1pm 3pm 5pm 7pm
Figure 5.11 Relative humidity and velocity in the intake and discharge pipes
decreased during the 9-11 am and the 1-3 pm interval while it increased during
the 5-7 pm interval. RHroom increased during the 9-11 am interval and the 1-3 pm
2.5
V
e
l 2
o
c T1
i 1.5
t T2
y
1 T3
( )
0.5
0 Time
9am-11am 1pm-3pm 5pm-7pm
T1 was at its highest during the 1-3 pm interval and was at its lowest
during the 9-11 am interval. T2 was at its highest during the 9-11 am interval
and was at its lowest during the 5-7 pm interval. T3 was at its highest during the
5-7 pm interval and was at its lowest during the 9-11 am interval.
The following data were gathered during the fifth day of operation. The
general weather experienced throughout the day was rainy. The summary of data
Date 7/5/2012
Time 9-11 am 1-3 pm 5-7 pm
Climate Rainy
At Start After 2 Hours At Start After 2 Hours At Start After 2 Hours
Troom, (C) 27.7 27.3 28.1 27.1 28.7 27.5
RHroom, (%) 82.1 76.3 85 77.6 84.2 83
Tout, (C) 29.3 30 30.5 29.6 28.9 27.7
RHout, (%) 77 79.4 77.4 76.2 77.3 79.2
Tintake, (C) 27.2 27.2 27.3 27.3 26.5 26.5
Vintake, (m/s) 2.1 2.1 2.1 2.1 2.1 2.1
Tdis, (C) 26.5 26.5 26.4 26.4 25.9 25.9
Vdis, (m/s) 5.2 5.2 5 5 4.9 4.9
Tout - Troom, (C) 1.6 2.7 2.4 2.5 0.2 0.2
Tintake-Tdis, (C) 0.7 0.7 0.9 0.9 0.6 0.6
The previous data were represented in graphs as shown in Figure(s) 5.13, 5.14, and 5.15.
31
30
T
e 29
m
p 28
e Troom
r 27 Tout
a
t 26 Tintake
u
r Tdis
25
e
( C)
24
23 Time
9am 11am 1pm 3pm 5pm 7pm
geothermal cooling. Tout increased during the 9-11 am interval while it decreased
during the 1-3 pm interval and the 5-7 pm interval. Troom decreased all throughout
the operation.
90
80
T
e 70
m
p 60
e RHroom
r 50
a RHout
t 40
u Vintake
r 30
Vdis
e 20
( C)
10
0 Time
9am 11am 1pm 3pm 5pm 7pm
Figure 5.14 Relative humidity and velocity in the intake and discharge pipes
decreased during the 1-3 pm interval while it increased during the 9-11 am and 5-
V 2.5
e
l
o 2
c
i T1
t 1.5
y T2
1 T3
( )
0.5
0 Time
9am-11am 1pm-3pm 5pm-7pm
T1 was at its highest during the 1-3 pm interval and was at its lowest
during the 5-7 pm interval. T2 was at its highest during the 9-11 am interval and
was at its lowest during the 5-7 pm interval. T3 was at its highest during the 1-3
The following data were gathered during the sixth day of operation. The
general weather experienced throughout the day was sunny. The summary of data
Date 7/6/2012
Time 9-11 am 1-3 pm 5-7 pm
Weather Sunny
At Start After 2 Hours At Start After 2 Hours At Start After 2 Hours
Troom, (C) 28.2 27.3 31.7 29.4 28.4 27.1
RHroom, (%) 80.1 79.8 73.5 75.7 82.2 81.4
Tout, (C) 28.1 29.9 29.7 29.2 28.2 27.7
RHout, (%) 80 79.3 78.2 80.1 80.8 81.5
Tintake, (C) 27.3 27.3 29.7 29.7 27.1 27.1
Vintake, (m/s) 2.1 2.1 2.1 2.1 2.1 2.1
Tdis, (C) 25.2 25.2 27.3 27.3 25.3 25.3
Vdis, (m/s) 5 5 5.2 5.2 5.2 5.2
Tout - Troom, (C) 0.1 2.6 2 0.2 0.2 0.6
Tintake-Tdis, (C) 2.1 2.1 2.4 2.4 1.8 1.8
The previous data were represented in graphs as shown in Figure(s) 5.16, 5.17, and 5.18.
34
T 32
e
m
p 30
e
r 28 Troom
a
Tout
t
u
26
Tintake
r
e 24 Tdis
( C)
22
20 Time
9am 11am 1pm 3pm 5pm 7pm
geothermal cooling. Tout increased during the 9-11 am interval while it decreased
during 1-3 pm interval and the 5-7 pm interval. Troom decreased all throughout the
operation.
90
T 80
e
m 70
p
e
60
r RHroom
50
a
RHout
t 40
u Vintake
r 30
e Vdis
( C) 20
10
0 Time
9am 11am 1pm 3pm 5pm 7pm
Figure 5.17 Relative humidity and velocity in the intake and discharge pipes
decreased during 9-11 am interval while it increased during the 1-3 pm and 5-7
pm interval. RHroom decreased during the 9-11 am interval and the 5-7 pm interval
2.5
V
e
l 2
o
c
i T1
1.5
t T2
y
1 T3
( )
0.5
0 Time
9am-11am 1pm-3pm 5pm-7pm
T1 was at its highest during the 1-3 pm interval while it was at its lowest
during the 9-11 am interval. T2 was at its highest during the 9-11 am interval
while it was at its lowest during the 1-3 pm interval. T3 was at its highest during
the 1-3 pm interval while it was at its lowest during the 5-7 pm interval.
The following data were gathered during the seventh day of operation. The
general weather experienced throughout the day was sunny. The summary of data
Date 7/7/2012
Time 9-11 am 1-3 pm 5-7 pm
Climate Sunny
At Start After 2 Hours At Start After 2 Hours At Start After 2 Hours
Troom, (C) 29 28.1 30.4 28.6 28.8 27.5
RHroom, (%) 76.9 78.3 75.7 78.3 83.2 80.8
Tout, (C) 29.4 31.3 30.8 31.5 27.9 26.8
RHout, (%) 77.3 79 76.4 77.8 78.4 80.4
Tintake, (C) 28.5 28.5 29.9 29.9 27.2 27.2
Vintake, (m/s) 2.1 2.1 2.1 2.1 2.1 2.1
Tdis, (C) 26.4 26.4 27.4 27.4 25.9 25.9
Vdis, (m/s) 5.1 5.1 4.9 4.9 5 5
Tout - Troom, (C) 0.4 1.3 0.4 2.2 0.9 0.4
Tintake-Tdis, (C) 2.1 2.1 2.5 2.5 1.3 1.3
The previous data were represented in graphs as shown in Figure(s) 5.19, 5.20, and 5.21.
34
T 32
e
m
p 30
e
r 28 Troom
a Tout
t 26
u Tintake
r
e 24 Tdis
( C)
22
20 Time
9am 11am 1pm 3pm 5pm 7pm
geothermal cooling. Tout increased during the 9-11 am interval and 1-3 pm
interval while it decreased during the 5-7 pm interval. Troom decreased all
90
80
T
e 70
m
p 60
e RHroom
r 50
a RHout
t 40
u Vintake
r 30
e Vdis
( C) 20
10
0 Time
9am 11am 1pm 3pm 5pm 7pm
Figure 5.20 Relative humidity and velocity in the intake and discharge pipes
increased throughout the operation. RHroom increased during the 9-11 am interval
and the 1-3 pm interval while it decreased during the 5-7 pm interval.
3.5
3
V
e
l 2.5
o
c
2
i T1
t
y 1.5 T2
T3
( )
1
0.5
0 Time
9am-11am 1pm-3pm 5pm-7pm
T1 was at its highest during the 5-7 pm interval. T2 was at its highest
during the 1-3 pm interval while it was at its lowest during the 5-7 pm interval.
T3 was at its highest during the 1-3 pm interval while it was at its lowest during
Date Average
Time 9-11 am 1-3 pm 5-7 pm
Weather Sunny
After 2 After 2 After 2
At Start At Start At Start
Hours Hours Hours
Troom, (C) 28.41429 27.55714 30.41429 28.77143 28.54286 27.27143
RHroom, (%) 81.71429 80.9 78.75714 77.92857 83.92857 81.98571
Tout, (C) 28.82857 29.85714 30.77143 30.84286 28.22857 27.78571
RHout, (%) 79.22857 79.11429 77.12857 77.75714 79.77143 81.27143
Tintake, (C) 27.72857 27.72857 28.82857 28.82857 27.52857 27.52857
Vintake, (m/s) 2.1 2.1 2.1 2.1 2.1 2.1
Tdis, (C) 26.12857 26.12857 26.92857 26.92857 25.94286 25.94286
Vdis, (m/s) 5.057143 5.057143 5.071429 5.071429 4.957143 4.957143
Tout - Troom, (C) 0.414286 2.3 0.357143 2.071429 0.314286 0.514286
Tintake-Tdis, (C) 1.6 1.6 1.9 1.9 1.585714 1.585714
The average data were represented in graphs as shown in Figure(s) 5.22, 5.23, 5.24.
32
T 31
e
m 30
p
e
29
r Troom
28
a
Tout
t 27
u Tintake
r 26
e Tdis
( C) 25
24
23 Time
9am 11am 1pm 3pm 5pm 7pm
geothermal cooling. Tout increased during the 9-11 am interval and 1-3 pm
interval while it decreased during the 5-7 pm interval. Troom decreased all
Based on the graph above, the geothermal cooling system can successfully
decrease the temperature of the room after a continuous operation for 2 hours,
T
80
e 70
m
p 60
e RHroom
r 50
a RHout
t 40
u Tintake
r 30
e Tdis
( C) 20
10
0 Time
9am 11am 1pm 3pm 5pm 7pm
decreased during 9-11 am interval while it increased during the 1-3 pm and 5-7
operation. Vintake and Vdis does not affect the RHroom based on the graph.
2.5
V
e 2
l
o
c 1.5
i T1
t
y T2
1
T3
( )
0.5
0 Time
9am-11am 1pm-3pm 5pm-7pm
There was a minimal temperature difference from Troom and Tout at the
start of the operation, as shown from the graph. T2 was at its highest during the
9-11am interval while it was at its lowest during the 5-7pm interval.T3 was at its
highest during the 1-3pm interval and was its lowest during the 5-7pm interval.
This section shows the comparison of the geothermal cooling system and conventional
air-conditioning under the operation of 6 hours in one day. Table 5.9 shows the power
Table 5.9 Data Comparison of Geothermal Cooling System and Conventional Air-
Conditioning Unit For Computing Payoff Period
0.75 HP. It was compared to conventional air-conditioning system with a power consumption of
1.27 HP which was the recommended air-conditioning unit for an 8ft X 10ft floor plan.
The comparisons of the two systems were observed under the operation of six hours
The initial cost of the geothermal cooling system, composing of three subsystems, was
P21726.00, as compared to an air-conditioning unit with an initial cost of P12000.00. The labor
cost for geothermal cooling system was P14000.00 which included the excavation, assembly,
and other labor works. With this, the monthly operational cost for an installed geothermal
cooling system was computed to P571.809.00 while air-conditioning system was computed to
P964.768.00. The computation was done using MERALCO monthly estimated computation.
This proves that the geothermal cooling system, based from power consumption, costs less.
The payoff period was 66.396 months. It was based from the computation using break-
even analysis as shown from Computation of Pay-off Period using Break-Even Analysis for
This section discusses the conclusion and recommendation after the accomplishment of
the study.
6.1 Conclusion
The group was able to design, fabricate, install and test an open loop geothermal cooling
system with an automatic temperature control using thermostat for the centrifugal air blower and
the damper with actuator in a controlled room for residential house application.
Weather conditions were a huge factor during the excavation since the work was done
outdoors. The excavation took one month due to removal of big rocks. During the installation of
the pipes, rains were imminent which added difficulty on the process. The selection of the site
was highly dependent on the availability of the lot on where the excavation and the installation
will be done and therefore, the group was not able to install the geothermal cooling system at a
Measurement and evaluation of the room and ambient properties before the installation
were successfully done and were used throughout the computation. The design of geothermal
cooling system was done with the aid of heat load calculations and carrier handbook manual.
Measurements were done using hygrometer which measured relative humidity and analog
The design of the Geothermal Cooling System started with the design of the heat
exchanger which is also the piping system. The computation of total length of the pipe was done
using the standards that was gathered by the group from previous existing studies and was
included to the studys reference. Fabrication was done in a machine shop near the site to ensure
that every small detail was being followed and finished on time. The installation of the heat
exchanger was not a problem for the group since the group hired a heavy equipment boom truck
The selection of the centrifugal air blower was based on the computation done by the
group. Its performance capacity was evaluated by its computed output power, pressure head and
velocity. Installation of the centrifugal air blower was done by mounting the suction pipe and
discharge pipe to the room. The centrifugal air blower was located outside the house due to the
design of the piping system. After the installation of the centrifugal air blower which completed
geothermal cooling system, the addition of a thermostat controller added further the efficiency of
the single phase motor. The thermostat controller system that was connected to the motor was
fabricated and designed for automatic cut off and cut on of the voltage supply. The thermostat
controller cuts off the voltage supply when the cooling system meets the set temperature that is
considered for comfort cooling. This completes the process of cooling the room by taking air
from the room using a centrifugal pump, taking it to a designed piping system and bringing it
In the completion of the study, it was necessary for the addition of a damper with an
actuator controlled by a thermostat for automatic cut on/cut off of voltage. The damper served
as a heater by introducing a hot air to maintain the effective temperature designed for comfort
cooling. The design temperature of the room was 27C with a relative humidity of 60%.
However, based from studies, comfort cooling was evaluated mainly by one parameter which
was the effective temperature. The effective temperature computed was 25C. The damper was
designed to have a cut on when the temperature of the room reached below this temperature to
maintain the effective temperature throughout the process and maintain a comfort cooling
The geothermal cooling system was able to bring down the temperature inside the room
by taking the air from the room and let the air pass through the heat exchanger that was designed
to remove heat from the air, through conduction and convection heat transfer, and putting it back
on the room. Through this continuous process, the design heat exchanger can lower the
temperature of the room at 2C at most. The evaluation of the soil temperature was based from
existing studies and was proved to provide a consistent temperature regardless of the ambient
change of 2C between the suction and discharge temperature at the start of the operation.
By comparing the capital cost and monthly operational cost of a conventional 1.27 HP
window type air conditioning unit versus the installed geothermal cooling system (based from
power consumption), the group was able to get an approximation on how long will the
investment return by break-even analysis. The payback period was calculated to be 67 months.
After that period of time, the geothermal cooling system will be able to cool the room at a rate
For further improvement of the study of the geothermal cooling system, several
The system must be constructed during the dry season. If the system is constructed during
the rainy season, problems with the digging will be experienced because water may cause
Before the piping system installation, it is highly advisable for the fabricated pipes to
undergo a hydrostatic test before placing it at the excavated lot. Hydrostatic test is a test which
involves filling the vessel or pipe system with a liquid, usually water, which may be dyed to aid
in visual leak detection, and pressurization of the vessel to the specified test pressure. This will
ensure that there are no defective parts in the pipe which could lead to leakage. After the pipe is
placed under the earth, the soil must be left to subside naturally. If the soil is compressed by
force, the pipe will experience undue damages. The same with what the group did, it is
recommended to put a foundation to the piping system because the soil, after excavation and
removal of stones for efficient conduction heat transfer weakened when the soil was dug.
It is required to place a drain section in the pipe to remove the water present in the pipe
due to condensation. The placement of the drain pipe must be secured in order to prevent the
The damper should be placed near the suction fan to let the fresh air enter the room
instead of using induced fan. However, for a more effective fresh air flow, use an induced fan.
Induced fan should be attached along with the dampers actuator to the thermostat controller so
that they can turn on and off at the same time as the damper.
The soil conditions should be considered in choosing the site because the type of soil
present will also affect the ground temperature and the rate of heat transfer between the soil and
the induced air flow. In site selection, the place where the excavation was done was the only
available vacant slot that the group could find and was therefore the site chosen to where the
source to improve the cooling effect of the geothermal cooling system. The group only based the
calculated values based on current studies and available equipment to properly evaluate the soil
conductivity, temperature, stability and other properties such as thermocouple and parameter.
APPENDICES:
A.1 Data:
q
1.006 qsq
>p
16.4109510&/
; !)%3! ! !3
19
%)!"% %3
1.08 $ %!% %%3% !%%)%
2542.50
1.08 $ 12.8h
3 . . u
183.9193 0.086803
!) % v
.
u v 0.086803 $ 1.1519 .
%
u 0.099988
%
Solving for the temperature entering and leaving the heat exchanger
By temperature balance:
mR TR + mOTO = mm Tm ; mm = mR + mO
mR = mdR + mvR
b z|..z. 4. x(g
mdR= =
= 11.9031 >
z..4/+
dc(g
x(g xeL x
mR = mdR + mvR = 11.9031 >
+ 0.16188 >
= 12.06498>
mO = mdO + mvO
b z|..z. 4.z x(g
mdO= =
= 1.2757 >
z.z/
dc(g
x(g xeL x
mO = mdO + mvO = 1.2757 + 0.02679 = 1.30249
> > >
dc dc
=z+.4/| A|4./MK =z..4+ A..M
Tm = dc dc
=z+.4/| AK=z..4+ A
Tm = 81.8472F = 27.6929C
Solving for Temperature leaving Heat Exchanger:
1
Oy 4216.64 1.2355 1235.46
3413
Oy 1235.46
Using 1 layer:
l
1000
1235.46 0.101269 1.006 33.4 3m
1
3m 21.2730
1000
0.101269 1.006 27.6929 21.2730
1
654.0377
;
where
1
1
#
where
15
+
@
= thermal conductivity of GI pipe = 73 >?
1
14.9831 +
1 0.04445 0.03896
#
15 + 73
b
;
oOeQgPdd
654.0377
>
654.0377
14.9831 + 27.6929 19
5.02153 + ; Area of Heat Transfer at 1 layer
Solving for the heat the 1st layer can remove with .
14.9831 1.6738+ 27.6929 19
+
218.0067
1000
218.0067 0.101269 1.006 27.6929
1
25.5530
Solving for the heat the 2nd layer can remove with .
14.9831 1.6738+ 25.5530 19
+
164.3408
1000
164.3408 0.101269 1.006 25.5530
1
Solving for the heat the 3rd layer can remove with .
14.9831 1.6738+ 23.9399 19
+
123.8863
1000
123.9399 0.101269 1.006 23.9399
1
Total ;
506.2874
3
10 3.048 ; %!% %" !3%
Data of B.I. Pipe:
Circumference = 0.23939m
@
= thermal conductivity of B.I. pipe = 73 >?
Total resistance:
O #
For
;
1
where
@
%3 3)% %!!%)3 15 ;
>p ?
1
=15 + A
0.06667
For ;
r ln = A
where
3.5in
0.03896 =ln = AA
3.068in
=73 A
7.0308 $ 10&
R
# R
>? > ?
RT=0.06667 + 7.0308 $ 10&
@ @
RT= 0.06737
For ;
1
where
+,
S = conduction shape factor of the pipe =
p( p( p
= AK= A &z
e e
where
d = total depth
} ..0 z~ z>
d = depth +
+
= 10ft + +
=z+ A = 10.1458ft =..+|4|~A = 3.09249m
= outside diameter
@
= thermal conductivity = 0.9 >q
(clay and sand)
+,
= 1.27307
p.-p p.-p p
= AK = A &z
-.- -.-
1
0.87278
1.27307 =0.9 A
ax
where
k
v 1.1519 =9.81 A 11.3001
. + .
.
0.086803
%
v + B
a %%
2
where
v 1.1519
.
B 103 # 103 # 103 303 9.14411
0.0762
3
10 3.048
!3! ) 3
$
%
where
3
10 3.048 ; %!% %" !3%
0.0762
&/
+
!)%3! ! !3 16.4109510
3.048 $ 0.0762
%
+
16.4109510&/
% 14152.5993; 3"%)3 "
1 2.51 1
2" #
% 3.7
where
0.16587
Solving for pressure drop;
+
1.1519 =3.048 A 0.165879.14411
.
20.0762
106.5048 a
ax
k . k
ax 11.3001 .
C0.086803 S 106.5048 +
%
ax 104.4687
ax 0.1044687 $ 0.1400385; 14
0.746
Thermal diffusivity:
v
= thermal diffusivity
v = density (kg/m)
0.15
1000
1.15 . 0.8
1
&
+
1.630434783 10
Damping depth:
2
2
365
2
2
365
+ 24 3600
2 1.630434783 10&
1 1
2
365
40.4557
Soil temperature
1 2 3 34
!" # $ % & $ !)
365 2
= average temperature oC
!" 19.100
B 3s 3
Solving for L:
where
# 0.06737 # 0.87278 0.94015
heat to lower the temperature of the room
506.2874
bI
L=
Pg &s
D
04/.+|@=4.4z0 A
L=
+./+? &z?
L 54.7557
`a # 1
7 # h ;
B `a
s
where:
506.2874
`a 4.8463
x 104.4687
506.2874
h 0.4098
ym 1235.46
4.8463 # 1
=7.0308 $ 10& # 0.87278 0.4098A
B 506.2874 4.8463
27.6929 19
B 25.1787
Assumption:
A horizontal GHX(geothermal heat exchange) consists of a series of pipes laid out in trenches,
usually one to two meters below the surface.Typically, about 35 to 55 meters of pipe are installed
per kW of heating /cooling capacity.
B 55 $ 55 $ 0.50629
B 27.8458
2 B
k
3 3 # 3 3 % &nOo
&
-k ") = e& L A
L
22.9399 19
k ")
33.4 19
k 1.2961
k
B
2
1000
1.2961 0.101269 1.006 = A
1
B
=15 A 0.077928
+
1000
1.2961 0.101269 1.006 = A
1
B
=15 A 0.077928
+
B 35.9566
Using;
1.2 k 2.5
Theoretically, we should increase NTU as much as possible to increase the exchanger efficiency.
It would lead to a combination of minimal airflow rate and a very long pipe. However, when a
certain value of NTU (2.0 2.5) is reached, there is only a minor gain in efficiency. Therefore,
NTU should be higher than 1.2, but it should not exceed2.5. Such a range leads to efficiency
from 70 % to92 %.
k 2
*EAHX efficiency ZVT[-] represents how much the outlet air temperature comes close to the
internal pipe surface temperature.
1 1 % &nOo
1
1 % &+
1
0.864665 86.466%
1000
2 0.099988 % 1.006 = A
1
B
0.077928
15 + 2 = 2 A
B 54.7824
3 19 # 33.4 19% &+
3 20.9488
A.6 Computation of Pay-off Period using Break-Even Analysis for Geothermal Cooling
System:
0.746 %
)3" "%3!" 3 "0.75 $ $6 $ 365 $ 5.6
1 %
% 1 % %
)3" "%3!" 3 6861.708 $ 571.809
% 12 )3 )3
1 %
)3" "%3!" 3 944 $ $6 $ 365 $ 5.6
1000 %
% 1 % %
)3" "%3!" 3 11577.216 $ 964.768
% 12 )3 )3
To compute how many years will it take to get back the Investment:
1 1 # !& 1 1 # !&
hz # h+ #
! !
Where:
i is the inflation rate (average year-to-date inflation rate for June is 3%,
source: http://www.bsp.gov.ph/publications/media.asp?id=2913 )
35716 120000.03
") 1
11577.216 6861.708
)
")1 # 0.03
12 )3
) 5.533 % $ 66.396 )3
1 %
Sp ace used f o: r A p p r o ve :
Siz e : 7 x 8 = 54 7 = 378 cu. f t .
GR A N D T OT A L HEA T 4 2 16 .6 4
B.2 Computation of Heat Load (without geothermal cooling)
Outside Conditions:
Temperature: 34.11 C or 93.4 F
%RH = 60%
Room Dimension:
Length = 7 feet
Width = 8 feet
Height = 9 feet
Glass factor = 1.00 from Table 16, page 52; Carrier System Design Manual
Exposure Sun Gain for the Month of April
South 14
North 25
Table 6 Equivalent Temperature Difference page 30
Walls:
South Wall: Width x Height
(8 ft x 8 ft) (16 ft2) = 48 ft2
x 0
1 ( in. thick), Concrete (Sand and Gravel) from Table 25, page 69; Carrier System Design
~ p z/
Manual
z
Wall factor = 0.26 for in insulation board from Table 25, page 69; Carrier System Design
+
Manual
Roof:
Length x Width
(10 ft x 8 ft) = 80 ft2
x 0
2 ~ p (z/ in. thick), Sheet Metal from Table 28, page 72; Carrier System Design Manual
z
Roof factor = 0.26 for + in insulation board from Table 28, page 72; Carrier System Design
Manual
x
Sun Gain (roof) = 6.4 from Table 20 at 2 ~ p(Exposed to sun), page 63; Carrier System Design
Manual
Floor:
(Length x Width)
(10 ft x 8 ft) = 80 ft2
x 0
7 ~ p (| in. thick), plywood from Table 29, page 73; Carrier System Design Manual
Factor = 0.22 for no insulation Table 29, page 73; Carrier System Design Manual
Heat Gain = (Area, sq. ft.) x (U value) x (outdoor temp. inside temp 5 F)
Heat Gain = (80 ft2) x (0.22) x (86 F 78 F 5 F)
Heat Gain = 52.8
Internal Heat:
People: Apartment/Hotel = 0.5(Table 14, page 38) x 390(Table 48, page 100) = 195
Appliances Quantity Wattage Time of use per Days per month of consumption
day
Lights 1 32 6 30
Television 1 110 10 30
19
Electric Fan 1 80 12 30
14
Factor = 0.5 (recommended value) table 50, page 101; Carrier System Design Manual
49
PSYCHROMETRIC
Voa = 14.4167
Enthalpy at saturation, Btu per pound of dry air Grains of moisture Pounds of moisture
48
CHART
Norm al Tem perature
per pound of dry air per pound of dry air
47
I-P Units 0.35
SEA LEVEL 180
46
BAROMETRIC PRESSURE: 29.921 in. HG .025
45
170
WBoa=81.9
44
.024
43
.023 0.40
160
42
80
.022
41
150
40
OA .021
0.45
V rm= 13.9062
39
140 .020
38
14.5
37
75 .019 0.50
B.3Psychrometric Chart
130
36
Btu
9 0%
.018
-0.1
35
0.55
120
34
.017
tu
33
80%
WBrm=70.2
0.60
70 .016
-0 .2 B
110
32
0.65
31
.015
%
MIXTURE 0.70
30
100
70
ROOM .014
0.75
29
65
26
.013
28
1
90 0.80
4.0
%
0.85
25
27
60
.012 0.90
VOL
24
80 0.95
UM E
60
.011 1.00
23
- CU
2Btu
22
%
-.0
.FT.
tu
50 70 .010 Sensible
4B
P ER
-.0
21
Heat
Btu
55
.009 Factor
18
LB. D
20
-.06
Btu
60
RY A
17
19
-.08
%
IR
40 .008
50
16
13.5 50
.007
15
45
14
3 0% .006
40
13
40
11
.005
-0.3 Btu - Enthalpy deviation Btu per pound of dry air
12
35
10
30
2 0% .004
9
13.0
30
Btu
8
0 .1 .003
25 20
Btu
7
0 .2 MIDITY
IVE H U
Wet-Bulb Btu 10% REL AT .002
12.5
Dewpoint or 0.3
Saturation 10
Btu
Temperature F 0 .4 .001
0
.000
Dry-Bulb
20 25 30 35 40 45 50 55 60 65 70 75 80 85 90 95 100 105 110
Temperature F
Below 32 F, properties and enthalpy dev iation lines are for ice. Chart by: HANDS DOWN SOFTWARE, www.handsdownsoftware.com
DBrm=80.6
DBoa=93.4
DBmx=81.84
Dewpoint=66.8
C. Pictures of the Geothermal Cooling System
i
C.3 Fabricated Piping System (Heat Exchanger)
i
C.5 Discharge Pipe and Suction Pipe (Centrifugal Air Blower at Suction Pipe)
C.6 Installation of Damper System and Thermostat Control for Centrifugal Air Blowers Single
i
REFERENCES:
i
http://hyperphysics.phy-astr.gsu.edu/hbase/thermo/heatra.html
[17] Heat Conduction last modifies 1998,
http://physics.info/conduction/
[18] Heat Convection last modified 1999,
http://theory.uwinnipeg.ca/mod_tech/node76.html
[19] Temperature and Humidity last modified 2007,
Conceptual Physics C. Donald Ahrens
[20] Fluid Flow last modified 2012,
http://www.toolingu.com/definition-570210-31848-fluid-flow-rate.html
[21] Geothermal Energy last modified 2012,
http://www.renewableenergyworld.com/rea/tech/geothermal-energy
[22] How Does Geothermal Energy Work for Heating and Cooling? last modified 2009,
http://www.all-energy-solutions.com/how-does-geothermal-energy-work.html
[23] Passive House last modified 2012,
http://www.passivehouse.com/English/PassiveH.HTM
[24] "Geothermal Heating & Cooling systems" last modified 2005,
http://welldrillingschool.com/courses/pdf/geothermal.pdf
[25] "Geothermal Heating and Cooling Introduction"last modified 2001,
http://fli.hws.edu/pdf/GEOTHERMAL%20HEATING%20AND%20COOLING.pdf
[26] "geothermal heat pump design manual"last modified 2002,
http://www.mcquay.com/mcquaybiz/literature/lit_systems/AppGuide/AG_31-
008_Geothermal_021607b.pdf
copyright @ 2002 McQuay International
[27] "Air Conditioning Air Flow Rates"last modified 2005,
http://www.arca53.dsl.pipex.com/index_files/airflow.htm
[28 ] Geothermal Source Heat Pump; Length Computation last modified
2009http://www.retscreen.net/download.php/ang/479/0/Textbook_GSHP.pdf, pg.49
[31] C.P. Arora Refrigeration and Air Conditioning, Comfort Cooling, pg. 451-455
i
[32] AndrisAuliciems and Steven V. Szokolay Thermal Comfort Effective Temperature, pg.
24 last modified 2009, http://www.scribd.com/doc/74707001/4/Basic-psychrometry/
[33] J.P. Holman, Heat transfer Table A-5: Properties of air at atmospheric pressure, pg. 649
[35] J.P. Holman Heat Transfer Overall Heat transfer eq. (10-2) pg. 554
[36] J.P. Holman Heat Transfer Overall heat transfer pg. 554; last modified 2009
http://cmrt.centrale-marseille.fr/cpi/ever09/documents/papers/re7/EVER09-paper-166.pdf; pg
116
[40] J.P. Holman 8th Ed Heat Transfer Thermal Conductivity of pipes; p. 638;
[41]Frank Incropera 6th Ed Introduction to Heat transfer by Frank Incropera August 28, 2005
page 645.
[42] Thermal Cinductivity, k value for clay and sand last modified 2009,
learn.greeanlux.org/packages/clear/thermal/buildings/building
fabric/properties/conductivity.html
[44] J.P. Holman Heat transfer Table A-5: Properties of air at atmospheric pressure, pg. 649
i
[48] Damping depth last modified 2009;
http://soilphysics.okstate.edu/software/SoilTemperature/document.pdf
[54] Soil Temperature McQuay Geothermal Heat Pump Design Manual: last modified 2008
http://www.mcquay.com/mcquaybiz/literature/lit_systems/AppGuide/AG_31-
008_Geothermal_021607b.pdf