You are on page 1of 120

Project : Proposed Reclamation at Tuas Finger One Project

Structure Type : SHUTTER BOX Date : 2016.09.19 Check Date :


Reference DWG: HSPBV-C0550-TEM-042-0001~0008 Prep : RJT Checked : JS LEE

DESIGN OF SHUTTER BOX CULVERT

2016.09.19

Prepared by HSPBV JV
I. Introduction
Design analysis and calculation are presented to support the provided detailed drawings for the caisson
shutter box culvert . This steel structure will prevent the sea water to pass through the caisson culvert
during construction in the permanent location.

II. Reference
SS EN 1990, Eurocode : Basis of Structural Design
BS EN 1990:2002, Eurocode: Basis of Structural Design
BS EN 1991-1-1:2002, Eurocode 1: Actions on structures; Part 1-1: General Actions- Densities,
Selfweight, Imposed Loads for buildings
NA to SS EN 1991-1-4:2009, Eurocode 1: Basis of Structural Design
NA to SS EN 1991-1-4:2009, Eurocode 3: Design of Steel Structures; Part 1-8: Design of joints
Part 1-1: General rules and Rules for Buildings
BS EN 1993-1-1:2005, Eurocode 3: Design of Steel structures; Part 1-1: General rules and rules
for buildings
BS EN 1993-1-8:2005, Eurocode 3: Design of Steel structures; Part 1-8: Design of joints

III. Design Criteria


A. General View
Location of caisson shutter box shown in figure below. Detailed drawings and sections are provided
in appendix 1.

C. Design Load
- Dead Load - Live Load
a) Selfweight b) Hydraulic Pressure
Factor = -1 9.81 kN/m 3 = Gradient intensity (g)
3.408 m = Water Height
33.43 kPa = Bottom Uplift Pressure = g x H
Water Level at Caisson Corbel
B. Material Properties

Item Properties Steel Grade Remarks


1 H 300x300x147 kgf/m S235JR Top Longitudinal Horizontal Beam
2 H 250x250x72.4 kgf/m S235JR Top Transverse Horizontal Beam
3 H 250x250x72.4 kgf/m S235JR Side Vertical Beam (Mid)
4 H 100x100x14.8 kgf/m S235JR Side Horizontal Beam
5 H 100x100x14.8 kgf/m S235JR Side Vertical Beam (End)
6 H 100x100x14.8 kgf/m S235JR Bottom Longitudinal Horizontal Beam
7 H 200x200x49.9 kgf/m S235JR Bottom Transverse Horizontal Beam
8 H 100x100x14.8 kgf/m S235JR Rear Horizontal and Vertical Beams
9 PL 6mm S235JR Side Plate
10 PL 8mm S235JR Bottom Plate

D. Load Case
LOAD CASE Permanent Leading Combination
ULS 1.35 1.50 1.35DL + 1.50LL
SLS 1.00 1.00 1.0DL + 1.0LL

Refer to Table NA.A2.4 in NA to SS EN 1990:2008+A1:2010


IV. Design Information
A. Model

Analysis Model and Boundary Condition

Loading Condition (Sea Water Pressure)


B. Analysis Result

Analysis Result : My (kN-m)

Analysis Result : Fz (kN)


Analysis Result : Fx (kN)

Reaction Force (kN)

Stress Ratio Check (Combined)


C. Deflection Check

D. Beam and Plate Stress


V. Summary of Forces

My (kNm) Fz (kN) Fx (kN) Combined Stress


Panel
Max Min Max Min Max Min Max Min
Top 218.90 -145.32 735.56 -735.63 152.82 -86.21 192.62 -198.13
Rear 4.42 -6.83 25.01 -24.04 33.84 -47.21 82.89 -112.67
Side 100.55 -100.70 109.89 -110.02 313.79 -697.83 153.15 -254.76
Bottom 23.65 -3.92 40.88 -68.93 75.09 -143.66 207.52 -189.61
Internal Support 2.52 -7.14 11.89 -5.98 -6.01 -168.43 -5.98 -186.65

MIDAS/ MODS Software was used for the beam design of each members of the structure. Attached in the
Appendix 2 are the MODS result.

VI. Welded Connection


i) Bottom Panel
Setion 1 - Plate Setion 2 - Channel (100x100x14.8)
B = 1300 mm B = 100 mm
D = 8 mm D = 100 mm
2
A = 10400 mm A = 1915.84 mm2
y/2 = 4 mm y/2 = 50 mm
IXX = 55466.67 mm 4 IXX = 26741.67 mm4

1 Centeroid of Composite
10400 4 + 1916 50 = 11.156 mm
10400 + 1916
2 Moment of inertia for composite section,I
IXX + A ( X - y/2 ) 2

2
= 55466.67 + 10400 ( 11.16 - 4 ) +
2
26741.67 + 1915.84 ( 11.16 - 50 )
4
= 3505502

3 Shear flow by bending moment at connection, f


f = V Q / I
f = 143.66 74419 / 3505502 1000
= 3049.80 N/
Q = A ( X - y/2 )
= 10400 ( 11.16 - 4 ) = 74419 mm 2

4 Welding Check
Throat Thickness : 3.5 mm
Leg length : 5 mm
Weld length : 15 mm
Number of welding side : 2ea
Capacity of throat thickness 3.5mm : 875 N/m
(refer to BS 5950-1 :2000, BS EN 440, 499, 756, 758, 1668)
Allowable shear force, fa = 26250 N
f lw < fa
= lw < fa / f
= 26250 / 3049.80 = 8.61

so, welding length : 15 mm and 3.5 mm thick fillet welding with 9 mm spacing to be provid

ii) Side and Rear Panel


Setion 1 - Plate Setion 2 - Channel (100x100x14.8)
B = 1300 mm B = 100 mm
D = 6 mm D = 100 mm
2
A = 7800 mm A = 1915.84 mm 2
y/2 = 3 mm y/2 = 50 mm
IXX = 23400.00 mm 4 IXX = 26741.67 mm 4

1 Centeroid of Composite
7800 3 + 1916 50 = 12.268 mm
7800 + 1916

2 Moment of inertia for composite section,I


IXX + A ( X - y/2 ) 2

2
= 23400.00 + 7800 ( 12.27 - 3 ) +
2
26741.67 + 1915.84 ( 12.27 - 50 )
4
= 3447718
3 Shear flow by bending moment at connection, f
f = V Q / I
f = 697.83 72289 / 3447718 1000
= 14631.51 N/
Q = A ( X - y/2 )
= 7800 ( 12.27 - 3 ) = 72289 mm2

4 Welding Check
Throat Thickness : 3.5 mm
Leg length : 5 mm
Weld length : 30 mm
Number of welding side : 2ea
Capacity of throat thickness 3.5mm : 875 N/m
(refer to BS 5950-1 :2000, BS EN 440, 499, 756, 758, 1668)
Allowable shear force, fa = 52500 N
f lw < fa
= lw < fa / f
= 52500 / 14631.51 = 3.59

so, welding length : 30 mm and 3.5 mm thick fillet welding with 4 mm spacing to be provid

iii) Member Joint Connection (Refer to EN 1993-1-8 :2005 (E) 4.5.3)


The design resistance of a fillet weld should be determined using either th Directional method or
the Simplified method.
Directional method
Size of fillet weld : 5.00 mm
Length of weld : 0.30 m
Area of yield : 1.50E+02
Max Shear stress(in the pane of the throat) perpendicular to the axis of the weld throat,
: 137.98 N/
Nominal ultimate tensile strength of the weaker part joined, fu : 360 N/
Appropriate correlation factor, w : 0.80
Partial factor M2 : 1.25
Design resistance of the fillet weld will be sufficient if the the following are both satified ;
2 2
[ + 3( + 2)]0.5 fu/(wM2) and 0.9fu / M2
[ 2
+ 3( 2
+ 2)]0.5 = 238.99 < fu/(wM2) = 360.00 N/ = 0.66 OK
< 0.9fu / M2 = 259.20 N/ OK
VII. Plate Bracket
A. Model
Nodal Load from Support reaction of main structure

Loading and Boundary Condition - Loading Unit


B. Analysis Condition
Item Properties Steel Grade Remarks
1 10mm thick plate S235JR Bracket

C. Design Load
- Deadload
Selfweight of steel member
Nodal load from support reaction of main structure

D. Load Case
LOAD CASE Permanent Leading Combination
ULS 1.35 1.00 1.35DL
Note: 1.0 is applied because load factor to leading action is applied already in the beam analysis

E. Result
Plate Stress < 235 MPa
VIII. Lifting Lug Check
Self weight = 9800 kg
Load Factor = 1.35
Yield Strength = 235 Mpa
No. of Lifting Points = 6 pts

Shear Check for Lifting Point


Ved / VcRd 1.0
VcRd = 0.60 x fy x Av / M0
VcRd = 0.60 x fy x Av
VcRd = 0.6 x 235 x 50 x 10
VcRd = 63.45 kN
Ved = 48.07 kN (consider weight to be concentrated to 2 lugs) therefore OK

Weld Connection for Lifting Lug


Directional method
Size of fillet weld : 3.00 mm
Length of weld : 150.00 mm x 2 (both sides)
Area of yield : 9.00E+02
Shear stress(in the pane of the throat) perpendicular to the axis of the weld throat,
: 70.50 N/
Nominal ultimate tensile strength of the weaker part joined, fu : 360 N/
Appropriate correlation factor, w : 0.80
Partial factor M2 : 1.25
Design resistance of the fillet weld will be sufficient if the the following are both satified ;
2 2
[ + 3( + 2)]0.5 fu/(wM2) and 0.9fu / M2
[ 2
+ 3( 2
+ 2)]0.5 = 122.11 < fu/(wM2) = 360.00 N/ = OK
< 0.9fu / M2 = 259.20 N/ OK
Project : Proposed Reclamation at Tuas Finger One Project
Structure Type : SHUTTER BOX Date : 2016.09.19 Check Date :
Reference DWG: HSPBV-C0550-TEM-042-0001~0008 Prep : RJT Checked : JS LEE

APPENDIX 2

2016.09.19

Prepared by HSPBV JV
QUANTITY OF 1 UNIT BOX CULVERT SHUTTER

Total No of Unit
Number
Member numbers Structur No of weight
SN Location of Required Strength Remark
Property of e per member (kg/m)/
Caisson
member caisson (kg/m)

1 H 300x300x147 2 1 1 2 6.00 m 147.0 S235JR

2 I 250x250x72.4 3 1 1 3 6.00 m 72.4 S235JR

3 I 200x200x49.9 2 1 1 2 6.00 m 49.9 S235JR

4 I 100x100x14.8 34 1 1 34 6.00 m 14.8 S235JR

BOX CULVERT
5 6t Plate 4 1 1 4 8x20 ft S235JR
SHUTTER

6 8t Plate 2 1 1 2 8x20 ft S235JR

7 10t Plate 1 1 1 1 8x20 ft S235JR

8 M12 Anchor Bolt 154 1 1 154 Gr8.8

9 M20 Anchor Bolt 16 1 1 16 Gr8.8


Project : Proposed Reclamation at Tuas Finger One Project
Structure Type : SHUTTER BOX Date : 2016.09.19 Check Date :
Reference DWG: HSPBV-C0550-TEM-042-0001~0008 Prep : RJT Checked : JS LEE

APPENDIX 1

2016.09.19

Prepared by HSPBV JV
MIDAS/Civil Steel Checking Result
Company Project Title
Author File Name D:\...utter Box_option 2_sept5.mcb
z
1. Design Information
Design Code : Eurocode3-2:05

21
Unit System : N, mm
Member No : 839

300
y
Material : S235 (No:1)

150.00
20
(Fy = 235.000, Es = 210000)
Section Name : H 300x300x20/21 (No:1) 150.00

(Built-up Section).
300
Member Length : 570.000

2. Member Forces Depth 300.000 Web Thick 20.0000


Axial Force Fxx = -36740 (LCB: 1, POS:J) Top F Width 300.000 Top F Thick 21.0000
Bot.F Width 300.000 Bot.F Thick 21.0000
Bending Moments My = 218898143, Mz = -49408096
Area 18038.1 Asz 6000.00
End Moments Myi = -16406699, Myj = 218898143 (for Lb) Qyb 52263.0 Qzb 11250.0
Iyy 278632099 Izz 94729844
Myi = -16406699, Myj = 218898143 (for Ly) Ybar 150.000 Zbar 150.000
Mzi = -11608160, Mzj = -49408096 (for Lz) Wely 1857547 Welz 631532
ry 124.285 rz 72.4682
Shear Forces Fyy = 118125 (LCB: 1, POS:I)
Fzz = -735628 (LCB: 1, POS:I)

3. Design Parameters
Unbraced Lengths Ly = 570.000, Lz = 570.000, Lb = 570.000
Effective Length Factors Ky = 1.00, Kz = 1.00
Equivalent Uniform Moment Factors Cmy = 1.00, Cmz = 1.00, CmLT = 1.00

4. Checking Results
Axial Resistance
N_Ed/MIN[Nc_Rd, Nb_Rd] = 36740/4238959 = 0.009 < 1.000 .......................... O.K
Bending Resistance
M_Edy/M_Rdy = 218898143/491272200 = 0.446 < 1.000 ................................. O.K
M_Edz/M_Rdz = 49408096/228138000 = 0.217 < 1.000 .................................. O.K
Combined Resistance
RNRd = MAX[ M_Edy/Mny_Rd, M_Edz/Mnz_Rd ]
Rmax1 = (M_Edy/Mny_Rd)^Alpha + (M_Edz/Mnz_Rd)^Beta
Rcom = N_Ed/(A*fy/Gamma_M0), Rbend = M_Edy/My_Rd + M_Edz/Mz_Rd
Rc_LT1 = N_Ed/(Xiy*A*fy/Gamma_M1)
Rb_LT1 = (kyy*M_Edy)/(Xi_LT*Wply*fy/Gamma_M1) + (kyz*Msdz)/(Wplz*fy/Gamma_M1)
Rc_LT2 = N_Ed/(Xiz*A*fy/Gamma_M1)
Rb_LT2 = (Kzy*M_Edy)/(Xi_LT*Wply*fy/Gamma_M1) + (Kzz*Msdz)/(Wplz*fy/Gamma_M1)
Rmax = MAX[ RNRd, Rmax1, (Rcom+Rbend), MAX(Rc_LT1+Rb_LT1, Rc_LT2+Rb_LT2) ] = 0.715 < 1.000 .. O.K
Shear Resistance
V_Edy/Vy_Rd = 0.069 < 1.000 ..................................................... O.K
V_Edz/Vz_Rd = 0.876 < 1.000 ..................................................... O.K

Modeling, Integrated Design & Analysis Software Print Date/Time : 09/20/2016 09:07
MIDAS/Civil Steel Checking Result
Company Project Title
Author File Name D:\...utter Box_option 2_sept5.mcb
z
1. Design Information
Design Code : Eurocode3-2:05

7
Unit System : N, mm
Member No : 72

100
y
Material : S235 (No:1)

50.0
5
(Fy = 235.000, Es = 210000)
Section Name : H 100x100x5/7 (No:3) 50.0

(Built-up Section).
100
Member Length : 433.333

2. Member Forces Depth 100.000 Web Thick 5.00000


Axial Force Fxx = -89074 (LCB: 1, POS:J) Top F Width 100.000 Top F Thick 7.00000
Bot.F Width 100.000 Bot.F Thick 7.00000
Bending Moments My = 9432542, Mz = -141560
Area 1915.84 Asz 500.000
End Moments Myi = -288375, Myj = 9432542 (for Lb) Qyb 7434.50 Qzb 1250.00
Iyy 3440847 Izz 1169788
Myi = -288375, Myj = 9432542 (for Ly) Ybar 50.0000 Zbar 50.0000
Mzi = 149541, Mzj = -141560 (for Lz) Wely 68816.9 Welz 23395.8
ry 42.3792 rz 24.7101
Shear Forces Fyy = 671.772 (LCB: 1, POS:I)
Fzz = -22476 (LCB: 1, POS:I)

3. Design Parameters
Unbraced Lengths Ly = 433.333, Lz = 433.333, Lb = 433.333
Effective Length Factors Ky = 1.00, Kz = 1.00
Equivalent Uniform Moment Factors Cmy = 1.00, Cmz = 1.00, CmLT = 1.00

4. Checking Results
Axial Resistance
N_Ed/MIN[Nc_Rd, Nb_Rd] = 89074/ 450223 = 0.198 < 1.000 .......................... O.K
Bending Resistance
M_Edy/M_Rdy = 9432542/17471075 = 0.540 < 1.000 .................................... O.K
M_Edz/M_Rdz = 141560/8351313 = 0.017 < 1.000 ..................................... O.K
Combined Resistance
RNRd = MAX[ M_Edy/Mny_Rd, M_Edz/Mnz_Rd ]
Rmax1 = (M_Edy/Mny_Rd)^Alpha + (M_Edz/Mnz_Rd)^Beta
Rcom = N_Ed/(A*fy/Gamma_M0), Rbend = M_Edy/My_Rd + M_Edz/Mz_Rd
Rc_LT1 = N_Ed/(Xiy*A*fy/Gamma_M1)
Rb_LT1 = (kyy*M_Edy)/(Xi_LT*Wply*fy/Gamma_M1) + (kyz*Msdz)/(Wplz*fy/Gamma_M1)
Rc_LT2 = N_Ed/(Xiz*A*fy/Gamma_M1)
Rb_LT2 = (Kzy*M_Edy)/(Xi_LT*Wply*fy/Gamma_M1) + (Kzz*Msdz)/(Wplz*fy/Gamma_M1)
Rmax = MAX[ RNRd, Rmax1, (Rcom+Rbend), MAX(Rc_LT1+Rb_LT1, Rc_LT2+Rb_LT2) ] = 0.807 < 1.000 .. O.K
Shear Resistance
V_Edy/Vy_Rd = 0.004 < 1.000 ..................................................... O.K
V_Edz/Vz_Rd = 0.321 < 1.000 ..................................................... O.K

Modeling, Integrated Design & Analysis Software Print Date/Time : 09/20/2016 09:07
MIDAS/Civil Steel Checking Result
Company Project Title
Author File Name D:\...utter Box_option 2_sept5.mcb
z
1. Design Information
Design Code : Eurocode3-2:05

12
Unit System : N, mm
Member No : 96

200
y
Material : S235 (No:1)

100.0
8
(Fy = 235.000, Es = 210000)
Section Name : H 200x200x8/12 (No:10) 100.0

(Rolled : H 200x200x8/12).
200
Member Length : 344.000

2. Member Forces Depth 200.000 Web Thick 8.00000


Axial Force Fxx = -77404 (LCB: 1, POS:I) Top F Width 200.000 Top F Thick 12.0000
Bot.F Width 200.000 Bot.F Thick 12.0000
Bending Moments My = 23650140, Mz = -98377
Area 6353.00 Asz 1600.00
End Moments Myi = 23650140, Myj = 11849873 (for Lb) Qyb 32072.0 Qzb 5000.00
Iyy 47200000 Izz 16000000
Myi = 23650140, Myj = 11849873 (for Ly) Ybar 100.000 Zbar 100.000
Mzi = -98377, Mzj = -85037 (for Lz) Wely 472000 Welz 160000
ry 86.2000 rz 50.2000
Shear Forces Fyy = 40.8386 (LCB: 2, POS:I)
Fzz = 34416.7 (LCB: 1, POS:J)

3. Design Parameters
Unbraced Lengths Ly = 344.000, Lz = 344.000, Lb = 344.000
Effective Length Factors Ky = 1.00, Kz = 1.00
Equivalent Uniform Moment Factors Cmy = 1.00, Cmz = 1.00, CmLT = 1.00

4. Checking Results
Axial Resistance
N_Ed/MIN[Nc_Rd, Nb_Rd] = 77404/1492955 = 0.052 < 1.000 .......................... O.K
Bending Resistance
M_Edy/M_Rdy = 23650140/123610000 = 0.191 < 1.000 .................................. O.K
M_Edz/M_Rdz = 98377/57340000 = 0.002 < 1.000 .................................... O.K
Combined Resistance
RNRd = MAX[ M_Edy/Mny_Rd, M_Edz/Mnz_Rd ]
Rmax1 = (M_Edy/Mny_Rd)^Alpha + (M_Edz/Mnz_Rd)^Beta
Rcom = N_Ed/(A*fy/Gamma_M0), Rbend = M_Edy/My_Rd + M_Edz/Mz_Rd
Rc_LT1 = N_Ed/(Xiy*A*fy/Gamma_M1)
Rb_LT1 = (kyy*M_Edy)/(Xi_LT*Wply*fy/Gamma_M1) + (kyz*Msdz)/(Wplz*fy/Gamma_M1)
Rc_LT2 = N_Ed/(Xiz*A*fy/Gamma_M1)
Rb_LT2 = (Kzy*M_Edy)/(Xi_LT*Wply*fy/Gamma_M1) + (Kzz*Msdz)/(Wplz*fy/Gamma_M1)
Rmax = MAX[ RNRd, Rmax1, (Rcom+Rbend), MAX(Rc_LT1+Rb_LT1, Rc_LT2+Rb_LT2) ] = 0.266 < 1.000 .. O.K
Shear Resistance
V_Edy/Vy_Rd = 0.000 < 1.000 ..................................................... O.K
V_Edz/Vz_Rd = 0.129 < 1.000 ..................................................... O.K

Modeling, Integrated Design & Analysis Software Print Date/Time : 09/20/2016 09:07
MIDAS/Civil Steel Checking Result
Company Project Title
Author File Name D:\...utter Box_option 2_sept5.mcb
z
1. Design Information
Design Code : Eurocode3-2:05

14
Unit System : N, mm
Member No : 803

250
y
Material : S235 (No:1)

125.0
9
(Fy = 235.000, Es = 210000)
Section Name : H 250x250x9/14 (No:11) 125.0

(Rolled : H 250x250x9/14).
250
Member Length : 450.000

2. Member Forces Depth 250.000 Web Thick 9.00000


Axial Force Fxx = -695987 (LCB: 1, POS:J) Top F Width 250.000 Top F Thick 14.0000
Bot.F Width 250.000 Bot.F Thick 14.0000
Bending Moments My = -100700220, Mz = 18305019
Area 9218.00 Asz 2250.00
End Moments Myi = -51251008, Myj = -100700220 (for Lb)Qyb 52049.4 Qzb 7812.50
Iyy 108000000 Izz 36500000
Myi = -51251008, Myj = -100700220 (for Ly)Ybar 125.000 Zbar 125.000
Mzi = -5632238, Mzj = 18305019 (for Lz) Wely 867000 Welz 292000
ry 108.000 rz 62.9000
Shear Forces Fyy = -53194 (LCB: 1, POS:I)
Fzz = 109887 (LCB: 1, POS:I)

3. Design Parameters
Unbraced Lengths Ly = 450.000, Lz = 450.000, Lb = 450.000
Effective Length Factors Ky = 1.00, Kz = 1.00
Equivalent Uniform Moment Factors Cmy = 0.85, Cmz = 0.85, CmLT = 1.00

4. Checking Results
Axial Resistance
N_Ed/MIN[Nc_Rd, Nb_Rd] = 695987/2166230 = 0.321 < 1.000 .......................... O.K
Bending Resistance
M_Edy/M_Rdy = 100700220/225835000 = 0.446 < 1.000 ................................. O.K
M_Edz/M_Rdz = 18305019/104340000 = 0.175 < 1.000 .................................. O.K
Combined Resistance
RNRd = MAX[ M_Edy/Mny_Rd, M_Edz/Mnz_Rd ]
Rmax1 = (M_Edy/Mny_Rd)^Alpha + (M_Edz/Mnz_Rd)^Beta
Rcom = N_Ed/(A*fy/Gamma_M0), Rbend = M_Edy/My_Rd + M_Edz/Mz_Rd
Rc_LT1 = N_Ed/(Xiy*A*fy/Gamma_M1)
Rb_LT1 = (kyy*M_Edy)/(Xi_LT*Wply*fy/Gamma_M1) + (kyz*Msdz)/(Wplz*fy/Gamma_M1)
Rc_LT2 = N_Ed/(Xiz*A*fy/Gamma_M1)
Rb_LT2 = (Kzy*M_Edy)/(Xi_LT*Wply*fy/Gamma_M1) + (Kzz*Msdz)/(Wplz*fy/Gamma_M1)
Rmax = MAX[ RNRd, Rmax1, (Rcom+Rbend), MAX(Rc_LT1+Rb_LT1, Rc_LT2+Rb_LT2) ] = 0.943 < 1.000 .. O.K
Shear Resistance
V_Edy/Vy_Rd = 0.054 < 1.000 ..................................................... O.K
V_Edz/Vz_Rd = 0.290 < 1.000 ..................................................... O.K

Modeling, Integrated Design & Analysis Software Print Date/Time : 09/20/2016 09:07
MIDAS/Civil Steel Code Checking Result

PROJECT TITLE : Design of Shutter Box Culvert

Company HDEC Client Reclamation at Tuas Finger One


Author RJT File Name Shutter Box_option 2_sept5.acs

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MIDAS/Civil - Steel Code Checking[ Eurocode3-2:05 ] Version 8.5.5
==========================================================================================

+============================================================+
| MIDAS(Modeling, Integrated Design & Analysis Software) |
| MIDAS/Civil - Design & checking system for windows |
+============================================================+
| Steel Member Applicable Code Checking |
| Based On KSCE-LSD15, KSCE-ASD10, KSCE-RAIL-ASD11, |
| KSCE-ASD05, KSCE-ASD96, AASHTO-LRFD12, |
| AASHTO-LRFD02, AASHTO-LFD96, AASHTO-ASD96, |
| AISC-LRFD2K, AISC-LRFD93, AISC-ASD89, |
| Eurocode3-2:05, BS5950-90, JTJ025-86, |
| IS:800-2007, IS:800-1984, TWN-BRG-LSD90, |
| TWN-BRG-ASD90 |
| |
| |
| (c)SINCE 1989 |
+============================================================+
| MIDAS Information Technology Co.,Ltd. (MIDAS IT) |
| MIDAS IT Design Development Team |
+============================================================+
| HomePage : www.MidasUser.com |
+============================================================+
| MIDAS/Civil Version 8.5.5 |
+============================================================+

*. DEFINITION OF LOAD COMBINATIONS WITH SCALING UP FACTORS.


--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
LCB C Loadcase Name(Factor) + Loadcase Name(Factor) + Loadcase Name(Factor)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1 1 DEADLOAD( 1.350) + MWHS( 1.500)
2 1 DEADLOAD( 1.350) + Manweight( 1.500)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Modeling, Integrated Design & Analysis Software Print Date/Time : 09/20/2016 09:08
http://www.MidasUser.com
MIDAS/Civil V 8.5.5 - 1 / 94 -
MIDAS/Civil Steel Code Checking Result

PROJECT TITLE : Design of Shutter Box Culvert

Company HDEC Client Reclamation at Tuas Finger One


Author RJT File Name Shutter Box_option 2_sept5.acs

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MIDAS/Civil - Steel Code Checking[ Eurocode3-2:05 ] Version 8.5.5
==========================================================================================

*. PROJECT :
*. MEMBER NO = 839, ELEMENT TYPE = Beam
*. LOADCOMB NO = 1, MATERIAL NO = 1, SECTION NO = 1
*. UNIT SYSTEM : N, mm

*. SECTION PROPERTIES : Designation = H 300x300x20/21


Shape = H - Section. (Built-up)
Depth = 300.000, Top F Width = 300.000, Bot.F Width = 300.000
Web Thick = 20.000, Top F Thick = 21.000, Bot.F Thick = 21.000

Area = 1.80381e+004, Avy = 1.26000e+004, Avz = 6.19200e+003


Ybar = 1.50000e+002, Zbar = 1.50000e+002, Qyb = 5.22630e+004, Qzb = 1.12500e+004
Wely = 1.85755e+006, Welz = 6.31532e+005, Wply = 2.09052e+006, Wplz = 9.70800e+005
Iyy = 2.78632e+008, Izz = 9.47298e+007, Iyz = 0.00000e+000
iy = 1.24285e+002, iz = 7.24682e+001
J = 2.59620e+006, Cwp = 1.83899e+012

*. DESIGN PARAMETERS FOR STRENGTH EVALUATION :


Ly = 5.70000e+002, Lz = 5.70000e+002, Lb = 5.70000e+002
Ky = 1.00000e+000, Kz = 1.00000e+000

*. MATERIAL PROPERTIES :
Fy = 2.35000e+002, Es = 2.10000e+005, MATERIAL NAME = S235

*. FORCES AND MOMENTS AT (J) POINT :


Axial Force Fxx =-3.67399e+004
Shear Forces Fyy = 1.18125e+005, Fzz =-7.35028e+005
Bending Moments My = 2.18898e+008, Mz =-4.94081e+007
End Moments Myi =-1.64067e+007, Myj = 2.18898e+008 (for Lb)
Myi =-1.64067e+007, Myj = 2.18898e+008 (for Ly)
Mzi =-1.16082e+007, Mzj =-4.94081e+007 (for Lz)

*. Sign conventions for stress and axial force.


- Stress : Compression positive.
- Axial force: Tension positive.

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CLASSIFY LEFT-TOP FLANGE OF SECTION (BTR).
======================================================================================

( ). Determine classification of compression outstand flanges.


[ Eurocode3:05 Table 5.2 (Sheet 2 of 3), EN 1993-1-5 ]
-. e = SQRT( 235/fy ) = 1.00
-. b/t = BTR = 5.81
-. sigma1 = 157.641 MPa.
-. sigma2 = 116.247 MPa.
-. BTR < 9*e ( Class 1 : Plastic ).

Modeling, Integrated Design & Analysis Software Print Date/Time : 09/20/2016 09:08
http://www.MidasUser.com
MIDAS/Civil V 8.5.5 - 2 / 94 -
MIDAS/Civil Steel Code Checking Result

PROJECT TITLE : Design of Shutter Box Culvert

Company HDEC Client Reclamation at Tuas Finger One


Author RJT File Name Shutter Box_option 2_sept5.acs

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MIDAS/Civil - Steel Code Checking[ Eurocode3-2:05 ] Version 8.5.5
==========================================================================================

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CLASSIFY RIGHT-TOP FLANGE OF SECTION (BTR).
======================================================================================

( ). Determine classification of compression outstand flanges.


[ Eurocode3:05 Table 5.2 (Sheet 2 of 3), EN 1993-1-5 ]
-. e = SQRT( 235/fy ) = 1.00
-. b/t = BTR = 5.81
-. sigma1 = 97.246 MPa.
-. sigma2 = 55.852 MPa.
-. BTR < 9*e ( Class 1 : Plastic ).

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CLASSIFY LEFT-BOTTOM FLANGE OF SECTION (BTR).
======================================================================================

( ). Determine classification of tension outstand flanges.


-. Not Checking the Section Classification.

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CLASSIFY RIGHT-BOTTOM FLANGE OF SECTION (BTR).
======================================================================================

( ). Determine classification of tension outstand flanges.


-. Not Checking the Section Classification.

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CLASSIFY WEB OF SECTION (HTR).
======================================================================================

( ). Determine classification of bending and compression Internal Parts.


[ Eurocode3:05 Table 5.2 (Sheet 1 of 3), EN 1993-1-5 ]
-. e = SQRT( 235/fy ) = 1.00
-. d/t = HTR = 11.10
-. sigma1 = 79.522 MPa.
-. sigma2 = -75.449 MPa.
-. Psi = [2*(Nsd/A)*(1/fy)]-1 = -0.983
-. Alpha = 0.518 > 0.5
-. HTR < 396*e/(13*Alpha-1) ( Class 1 : Plastic ).

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] APPLIED FACTORS.
======================================================================================

( ). Calculate equivalent uniform moment factors (Cmy,Cmz,CmLT).


[ Eurocode3:05 Annex A. Table A.1, A.2 ]
-. Cmy,0 = 0.774
-. Cmz,0 = 0.839
-. Cmy (Default or User Defined Value) = 1.000
-. Cmz (Default or User Defined Value) = 1.000
-. CmLT (Default or User Defined Value) = 1.000

Modeling, Integrated Design & Analysis Software Print Date/Time : 09/20/2016 09:08
http://www.MidasUser.com
MIDAS/Civil V 8.5.5 - 3 / 94 -
MIDAS/Civil Steel Code Checking Result

PROJECT TITLE : Design of Shutter Box Culvert

Company HDEC Client Reclamation at Tuas Finger One


Author RJT File Name Shutter Box_option 2_sept5.acs

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MIDAS/Civil - Steel Code Checking[ Eurocode3-2:05 ] Version 8.5.5
==========================================================================================

( ). Partial Factors (Gamma_Mi).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1 ]
-. Gamma_M0 = 1.00
-. Gamma_M1 = 1.10
-. Gamma_M2 = 1.25

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CHECK AXIAL RESISTANCE.
======================================================================================

( ). Check slenderness ratio of axial compression member (Kl/i).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.3.1 ]
-. Kl/i = 7.9 < 200.0 ---> O.K.

( ). Calculate axial compressive resistance (Nc_Rd).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1, 6.2.4 ]
-. Nc_Rd = fy * Area / Gamma_M0 = 4238959.14 N.

( ). Check ratio of axial resistance (N_Ed/Nc_Rd).


N_Ed 36739.90
-. ----- = --------------- = 0.009 < 1.000 ---> O.K.
Nc_Rd 4238959.14

( ). Calculate buckling resistance of compression member (Nb_Rdy, Nb_Rdz).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.3.1.1, 6.3.1.2 ]
-. Beta_A = Aeff / Area = 1.000
-. Lambda1 = Pi * SQRT(Es/fy) = 93.913
-. Lambda_by = {(Ky*Ly/iy)/Lambda1} * SQRT(Beta_A) = 0.049
-. Ncry = Pi^2*Es*Iyy / (Ky*Ly)^2 = 1777462618.39 N.
-. Lambda_by < 0.2 or N_Ed/Ncry < 0.04 --> No need to check.

-. Lambda_bz = {(Kz*Lz/iz)/Lambda1} * SQRT(Beta_A) = 0.084


-. Ncrz = Pi^2*Es*Izz / (Kz*Lz)^2 = 604304946.34 N.
-. Lambda_bz < 0.2 or N_Ed/Ncrz < 0.04 --> No need to check.

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CHECK SHEAR RESISTANCE.
======================================================================================

( ). Calculate shear area.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.2.6, EN1993-1-5:04 5.1 NOTE 2 ]
-. eta = 1.2 (Fy < 460 MPa.)
-. Avy = 2*B*tf = 12600.0000 mm^2.
-. Avz = eta*hw*tw = 6192.0000 mm^2.

( ). Calculate plastic shear resistance in local-y direction (Vpl_Rdy).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1, 6.2.6 ]
-. Vpl_Rdy = [ Avy*fy/SQRT(3) ] / Gamma_M0 = 1709534.15 N.

Modeling, Integrated Design & Analysis Software Print Date/Time : 09/20/2016 09:08
http://www.MidasUser.com
MIDAS/Civil V 8.5.5 - 4 / 94 -
MIDAS/Civil Steel Code Checking Result

PROJECT TITLE : Design of Shutter Box Culvert

Company HDEC Client Reclamation at Tuas Finger One


Author RJT File Name Shutter Box_option 2_sept5.acs

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MIDAS/Civil - Steel Code Checking[ Eurocode3-2:05 ] Version 8.5.5
==========================================================================================

( ). Check ratio of shear resistance (V_Edy/Vpl_Rdy).


( LCB = 1, POS = J )
-. Applied shear force : V_Edy = 118124.80 N.
V_Edy 118124.80
-. ------- = --------------- = 0.069 < 1.000 ---> O.K.
Vpl_Rdy 1709534.15

( ). Calculate plastic shear resistance in local-z direction (Vpl_Rdz).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1, 6.2.6 ]
-. Vpl_Rdz = [ Avz*fy/SQRT(3) ] / Gamma_M0 = 840113.92 N.

( ). Shear Buckling Check.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.2.6 ]
-. HTR < 72*e/Eta ---> No need to check!

( ). Check ratio of shear resistance (V_Edz/Vpl_Rdz).


( LCB = 1, POS = I )
-. Applied shear force : V_Edz = 735627.56 N.
V_Edz 735627.56
-. ------- = --------------- = 0.876 < 1.000 ---> O.K.
Vpl_Rdz 840113.92

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CHECK BENDING MOMENT RESISTANCE ABOUT MAJOR AXIS.
======================================================================================

( ). Calculate plastic resistance moment about major axis.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1, 6.2.5 ]
-. Wply = 2090520.0000 mm^3.
-. Mc_Rdy = Wply * fy / Gamma_M0 = 491272200.00 N-mm.

( ). Check ratio of moment resistance (M_Edy/Mc_Rdy).


M_Edy 218898142.96
-. ------ = --------------- = 0.446 < 1.000 ---> O.K.
Mc_Rdy 491272200.00

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CHECK BENDING MOMENT RESISTANCE ABOUT MINOR AXIS.
======================================================================================

( ). Calculate plastic resistance moment about minor axis.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1, 6.2.5 ]
-. Wplz = 970800.0000 mm^3.
-. Mc_Rdz = Wplz * fy / Gamma_M0 = 228138000.00 N-mm.

( ). Check ratio of moment resistance (M_Edz/Mc_Rdz).


M_Edz 49408096.15
-. ------ = --------------- = 0.217 < 1.000 ---> O.K.
Mc_Rdz 228138000.00

Modeling, Integrated Design & Analysis Software Print Date/Time : 09/20/2016 09:08
http://www.MidasUser.com
MIDAS/Civil V 8.5.5 - 5 / 94 -
MIDAS/Civil Steel Code Checking Result

PROJECT TITLE : Design of Shutter Box Culvert

Company HDEC Client Reclamation at Tuas Finger One


Author RJT File Name Shutter Box_option 2_sept5.acs

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MIDAS/Civil - Steel Code Checking[ Eurocode3-2:05 ] Version 8.5.5
==========================================================================================

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CHECK LATERAL-TORSIONAL BUCKLING RESISTANCE.
======================================================================================

( ). Calculate lateral-torsional buckling resistance (Mb_Rd).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1, 6.3.2 ]
-. Por = 0.300
-. Gs = Es / [ 2*(1+Por) ] = 80769.231 MPa.
-. Ncr = Pi^2*Es*Izz / Lu^2 = 604304946.34 N.
-. psi = -0.075
-. C1 = 1.285
-. Mcr = C1 * Ncr * SQRT [ (Cwp/Izz) + (Gs*Ixx)/Ncr ] = 1.09e+011 N-mm.

-. Lambda_LT_bar = SQRT [ Wply*fy / Mcr ] = 0.067


-. Lambda_LT_bar0 = 0.200

-. Lambda_LT_bar = 0.067 < Lambda_LT_bar0 = 0.200


-. M_Ed/Mcr = 0.002 < Lambda_LT_bar0^2 = 0.040
If Lambda_LT_bar < Lambda_LT_bar0 or M_Ed/Mcr < Lambda_LT_bar0^2,
No allowance for lateral-torsional buckling necessary.

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CHECK INTERACTION OF COMBINED RESISTANCE.
======================================================================================

( ). Calculate Major reduced design resistance of bending and shear.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.2.8 (6.30) ]
-. In case of V_Edz / Vpl_Rdz > 0.5 (equal flanges)
-. Rho = { 2*(V_Edz/Vpl_Rdz) - 1 }^2 = 0.562
-. My.V_Rd1= [ Wply - {Rho*Aw^2/(4*tw)} ]*fy / Gamma_M0 = 447297658.87 N-mm.
-. My_Rd = MIN [ My.V_Rdy1, Mc_Rdy ] = 447297658.87 N-mm.

( ). Calculate Minor reduced design resistance of bending and shear.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.2.8 (6.30) ]
-. In case of V_Edy / Vpl_Rdy < 0.5
-. Mz_Rd = Mc_Rdz = 228138000.00 N-mm.

( ). Check general interaction ratio.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.2.1 (6.2) ] - Class1 or Class2
N_Ed M_Edy M_Edz
-. Rmax1 = ------ + ------- + -------
N_Rd My_Rd Mz_Rd
= 0.715 < 1.000 ---> O.K.

( ). Check interaction ratio of bending and axial force member.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.2.9 (6.31 ~ 6.41) ] - Class1 or Class2
-. n = N_Ed / Npl_Rd = 0.009
-. a = MIN[ (Area-2b*tf)/Area, 0.5 ] = 0.301
-. Alpha = 2.000
-. Beta = MAX[ 5*n, 1.0 ] = 1.000

Modeling, Integrated Design & Analysis Software Print Date/Time : 09/20/2016 09:08
http://www.MidasUser.com
MIDAS/Civil V 8.5.5 - 6 / 94 -
MIDAS/Civil Steel Code Checking Result

PROJECT TITLE : Design of Shutter Box Culvert

Company HDEC Client Reclamation at Tuas Finger One


Author RJT File Name Shutter Box_option 2_sept5.acs

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MIDAS/Civil - Steel Code Checking[ Eurocode3-2:05 ] Version 8.5.5
==========================================================================================

-. N_Ed < 0.25*Npl_Rd = 1059739.78 N.


-. N_Ed < 0.5*hw*tw*fy/Gamma_M0 = 606300.00 N.
Therefore, No allowance for the effect of axial force.
-. Mny_Rd = Mply_Rd = 447297658.87 N-mm.
-. Rmaxy = M_Edy / Mny_Rd = 0.489 < 1.000 ---> O.K.

-. N_Ed < hw*tw*fy/Gamma_M0 = 1273230.00 N.


Therefore, No allowance for the effect of axial force.
-. Mnz_Rd = Mplz_Rd = 228138000.00 N-mm.
-. Rmaxz = M_Edz / Mnz_Rd = 0.217 < 1.000 ---> O.K.

[ | M_Edy |^(Alpha) | M_Edz |^(Beta) ]


-. Rmax2 = [ |--------| + |--------| ]
[ | Mny_Rd | | Mnz_Rd | ]
= 0.456 < 1.000 ---> O.K.

( ). Check interaction ratio of bending and axial compression member.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.3.1, 6.2.9.3 (6.61, 6.62), Annex A ]
-. N_Ed = -36739.90 N.
-. M_Edy = 218898142.96 N-mm.
-. M_Edz = -49408096.15 N-mm.
-. kyy = 0.998
-. kyz = 0.688
-. kzy = 0.528
-. kzz = 1.382
-. Xiy = 1.000
-. Xiz = 1.000
-. XiLT = 1.000
-. N_Rk = A*fy = 4238959.14 N.
-. My_Rk = Wply*fy = 491272200.00 N-mm.
-. Mz_Rk = Wplz*fy = 228138000.00 N-mm.
-. N_Ed*eNy = 0.0 (Not Slender)
-. N_Ed*eNZ = 0.0 (Not Slender)
N_Ed M_Edy + N_Ed*eNy M_Edz + N_Ed*eNz
-. Rmax_LT1 = ----------------- + kyy * ------------------- + kyz * ----------------
Xiy*N_Rk/Gamma_M1 XiLT*My_Rk/Gamma_M1 Mz_Rk/Gamma_M1
= 0.662 < 1.000 ---> O.K.
N_Ed M_Edy + N_Ed*eNy M_Edz + N_Ed*eNz
-. Rmax_LT2 = ----------------- + kzy * ------------------- + kzz * ----------------
Xiz*N_Rk/Gamma_M1 XiLT*My_Rk/Gamma_M1 Mz_Rk/Gamma_M1
= 0.598 < 1.000 ---> O.K.

-. Rmax = MAX[ MAX(Rmax1, Rmax2), MAX(Rmax_LT1, Rmax_LT2) ] = 0.715 < 1.000 --->
O.K.

Modeling, Integrated Design & Analysis Software Print Date/Time : 09/20/2016 09:08
http://www.MidasUser.com
MIDAS/Civil V 8.5.5 - 7 / 94 -
MIDAS/Civil Steel Code Checking Result

PROJECT TITLE : Design of Shutter Box Culvert

Company HDEC Client Reclamation at Tuas Finger One


Author RJT File Name Shutter Box_option 2_sept5.acs

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MIDAS/Civil - Steel Code Checking[ Eurocode3-2:05 ] Version 8.5.5
==========================================================================================

*. PROJECT :
*. MEMBER NO = 31, ELEMENT TYPE = Beam
*. LOADCOMB NO = 1, MATERIAL NO = 1, SECTION NO = 2
*. UNIT SYSTEM : N, mm

*. SECTION PROPERTIES : Designation = H 100x100x5/7


Shape = H - Section. (Built-up)
Depth = 100.000, Top F Width = 100.000, Bot.F Width = 100.000
Web Thick = 5.000, Top F Thick = 7.000, Bot.F Thick = 7.000

Area = 1.91584e+003, Avy = 1.40000e+003, Avz = 5.16000e+002


Ybar = 5.00000e+001, Zbar = 5.00000e+001, Qyb = 7.43450e+003, Qzb = 1.25000e+003
Wely = 6.88169e+004, Welz = 2.33958e+004, Wply = 7.43450e+004, Wplz = 3.55375e+004
Iyy = 3.44085e+006, Izz = 1.16979e+006, Iyz = 0.00000e+000
iy = 4.23792e+001, iz = 2.47101e+001
J = 2.67417e+004, Cwp = 2.52263e+009

*. DESIGN PARAMETERS FOR STRENGTH EVALUATION :


Ly = 4.33333e+002, Lz = 4.33333e+002, Lb = 4.33333e+002
Ky = 1.00000e+000, Kz = 1.00000e+000

*. MATERIAL PROPERTIES :
Fy = 2.35000e+002, Es = 2.10000e+005, MATERIAL NAME = S235

*. FORCES AND MOMENTS AT (I) POINT :


Axial Force Fxx = 2.35848e+004
Shear Forces Fyy = 1.60840e+004, Fzz = 1.29432e+004
Bending Moments My = 2.20194e+006, Mz = 3.81837e+006
End Moments Myi = 2.20194e+006, Myj =-3.42546e+006 (for Lb)
Myi = 2.20194e+006, Myj =-3.42546e+006 (for Ly)
Mzi = 3.81837e+006, Mzj =-3.15135e+006 (for Lz)

*. Sign conventions for stress and axial force.


- Stress : Compression positive.
- Axial force: Tension positive.

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CLASSIFY LEFT-TOP FLANGE OF SECTION (BTR).
======================================================================================

( ). Determine classification of tension outstand flanges.


-. Not Checking the Section Classification.

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CLASSIFY RIGHT-TOP FLANGE OF SECTION (BTR).
======================================================================================

Modeling, Integrated Design & Analysis Software Print Date/Time : 09/20/2016 09:08
http://www.MidasUser.com
MIDAS/Civil V 8.5.5 - 8 / 94 -
MIDAS/Civil Steel Code Checking Result

PROJECT TITLE : Design of Shutter Box Culvert

Company HDEC Client Reclamation at Tuas Finger One


Author RJT File Name Shutter Box_option 2_sept5.acs

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MIDAS/Civil - Steel Code Checking[ Eurocode3-2:05 ] Version 8.5.5
==========================================================================================

( ). Determine classification of compression outstand flanges.


[ Eurocode3:05 Table 5.2 (Sheet 2 of 3), EN 1993-1-5 ]
-. e = SQRT( 235/fy ) = 1.00
-. b/t = BTR = 5.36
-. sigma1 = 124.754 MPa.
-. sigma2 = 44.169 MPa.
-. BTR < 9*e ( Class 1 : Plastic ).

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CLASSIFY LEFT-BOTTOM FLANGE OF SECTION (BTR).
======================================================================================

( ). Determine classification of tension outstand flanges.


-. Not Checking the Section Classification.

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CLASSIFY RIGHT-BOTTOM FLANGE OF SECTION (BTR).
======================================================================================

( ). Determine classification of bending and compression outstand flanges.


[ Eurocode3:05 Table 5.2 (Sheet 2 of 3), EN 1993-1-5 ]
-. e = SQRT( 235/fy ) = 1.00
-. b/t = BTR = 5.36
-. sigma1 = 65.518 MPa.
-. sigma2 = -15.067 MPa.
-. Psi = sigma2 / sigma1 = -0.230
-. Alpha = 1.000
-. BTR < 9*e/Alpha ( Class 1 : Plastic ).

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CLASSIFY WEB OF SECTION (HTR).
======================================================================================

( ). Determine classification of bending and compression Internal Parts.


[ Eurocode3:05 Table 5.2 (Sheet 1 of 3), EN 1993-1-5 ]
-. e = SQRT( 235/fy ) = 1.00
-. d/t = HTR = 13.20
-. sigma1 = 7.237 MPa.
-. sigma2 = -31.858 MPa.
-. Psi = [2*(Nsd/A)*(1/fy)]-1 = -1.105
-. Alpha = 0.348 < 0.5
-. HTR < 36*e/Alpha ( Class 1 : Plastic ).

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] APPLIED FACTORS.
======================================================================================

( ). Calculate equivalent uniform moment factors (Cmy,Cmz,CmLT).


[ Eurocode3:05 Annex A. Table A.1, A.2 ]
-. Cmy,0 = 0.655
-. Cmz,0 = 0.616

Modeling, Integrated Design & Analysis Software Print Date/Time : 09/20/2016 09:08
http://www.MidasUser.com
MIDAS/Civil V 8.5.5 - 9 / 94 -
MIDAS/Civil Steel Code Checking Result

PROJECT TITLE : Design of Shutter Box Culvert

Company HDEC Client Reclamation at Tuas Finger One


Author RJT File Name Shutter Box_option 2_sept5.acs

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MIDAS/Civil - Steel Code Checking[ Eurocode3-2:05 ] Version 8.5.5
==========================================================================================

-. Cmy (Default or User Defined Value) = 1.000


-. Cmz (Default or User Defined Value) = 1.000
-. CmLT (Default or User Defined Value) = 1.000

( ). Partial Factors (Gamma_Mi).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1 ]
-. Gamma_M0 = 1.00
-. Gamma_M1 = 1.10
-. Gamma_M2 = 1.25

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CHECK AXIAL RESISTANCE.
======================================================================================

( ). Check slenderness ratio of axial tension member (l/i).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.3.1 ]
-. l/i = 17.5 < 300.0 ---> O.K.

( ). Calculate parameters for combined resistance.


-. Lambda1 = Pi * SQRT(Es/fy) = 93.913
-. Lambda_bz = (KLz/iz) / Lambda1 = 0.187

( ). Calculate axial tensile resistance (Nt_Rd).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.2.3 ]
-. Nt_Rd = fy * Area / Gamma_M0 = 450222.57 N.

( ). Check ratio of axial resistance (N_Ed/Nt_Rd).


N_Ed 23584.78
-. ----- = --------------- = 0.052 < 1.000 ---> O.K.
Nt_Rd 450222.57

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CHECK SHEAR RESISTANCE.
======================================================================================

( ). Calculate shear area.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.2.6, EN1993-1-5:04 5.1 NOTE 2 ]
-. eta = 1.2 (Fy < 460 MPa.)
-. Avy = 2*B*tf = 1400.0000 mm^2.
-. Avz = eta*hw*tw = 516.0000 mm^2.

( ). Calculate plastic shear resistance in local-y direction (Vpl_Rdy).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1, 6.2.6 ]
-. Vpl_Rdy = [ Avy*fy/SQRT(3) ] / Gamma_M0 = 189948.24 N.

( ). Check ratio of shear resistance (V_Edy/Vpl_Rdy).


( LCB = 1, POS = I )
-. Applied shear force : V_Edy = 16083.96 N.
V_Edy 16083.96
-. ------- = --------------- = 0.085 < 1.000 ---> O.K.
Vpl_Rdy 189948.24

Modeling, Integrated Design & Analysis Software Print Date/Time : 09/20/2016 09:08
http://www.MidasUser.com
MIDAS/Civil V 8.5.5 - 10 / 94 -
MIDAS/Civil Steel Code Checking Result

PROJECT TITLE : Design of Shutter Box Culvert

Company HDEC Client Reclamation at Tuas Finger One


Author RJT File Name Shutter Box_option 2_sept5.acs

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MIDAS/Civil - Steel Code Checking[ Eurocode3-2:05 ] Version 8.5.5
==========================================================================================

( ). Calculate plastic shear resistance in local-z direction (Vpl_Rdz).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1, 6.2.6 ]
-. Vpl_Rdz = [ Avz*fy/SQRT(3) ] / Gamma_M0 = 70009.49 N.

( ). Shear Buckling Check.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.2.6 ]
-. HTR < 72*e/Eta ---> No need to check!

( ). Check ratio of shear resistance (V_Edz/Vpl_Rdz).


( LCB = 1, POS = J )
-. Applied shear force : V_Edz = 13029.44 N.
V_Edz 13029.44
-. ------- = --------------- = 0.186 < 1.000 ---> O.K.
Vpl_Rdz 70009.49

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CHECK BENDING MOMENT RESISTANCE ABOUT MAJOR AXIS.
======================================================================================

( ). Calculate plastic resistance moment about major axis.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1, 6.2.5 ]
-. Wply = 74345.0000 mm^3.
-. Mc_Rdy = Wply * fy / Gamma_M0 = 17471075.00 N-mm.

( ). Check ratio of moment resistance (M_Edy/Mc_Rdy).


M_Edy 2201936.62
-. ------ = --------------- = 0.126 < 1.000 ---> O.K.
Mc_Rdy 17471075.00

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CHECK BENDING MOMENT RESISTANCE ABOUT MINOR AXIS.
======================================================================================

( ). Calculate plastic resistance moment about minor axis.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1, 6.2.5 ]
-. Wplz = 35537.5000 mm^3.
-. Mc_Rdz = Wplz * fy / Gamma_M0 = 8351312.50 N-mm.

( ). Check ratio of moment resistance (M_Edz/Mc_Rdz).


M_Edz 3818368.64
-. ------ = --------------- = 0.457 < 1.000 ---> O.K.
Mc_Rdz 8351312.50

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CHECK LATERAL-TORSIONAL BUCKLING RESISTANCE.
======================================================================================

Modeling, Integrated Design & Analysis Software Print Date/Time : 09/20/2016 09:08
http://www.MidasUser.com
MIDAS/Civil V 8.5.5 - 11 / 94 -
MIDAS/Civil Steel Code Checking Result

PROJECT TITLE : Design of Shutter Box Culvert

Company HDEC Client Reclamation at Tuas Finger One


Author RJT File Name Shutter Box_option 2_sept5.acs

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MIDAS/Civil - Steel Code Checking[ Eurocode3-2:05 ] Version 8.5.5
==========================================================================================

( ). Calculate lateral-torsional buckling resistance (Mb_Rd).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1, 6.3.2 ]
-. Por = 0.300
-. Gs = Es / [ 2*(1+Por) ] = 80769.231 MPa.
-. Ncr = Pi^2*Es*Izz / Lu^2 = 12911656.19 N.
-. psi = -0.643
-. C1 = 1.285
-. Mcr = C1 * Ncr * SQRT [ (Cwp/Izz) + (Gs*Ixx)/Ncr ] = 799799432.23 N-mm.

-. Lambda_LT_bar = SQRT [ Wply*fy / Mcr ] = 0.148


-. Lambda_LT_bar0 = 0.200

-. Lambda_LT_bar = 0.148 < Lambda_LT_bar0 = 0.200


-. M_Ed/Mcr = 0.003 < Lambda_LT_bar0^2 = 0.040
If Lambda_LT_bar < Lambda_LT_bar0 or M_Ed/Mcr < Lambda_LT_bar0^2,
No allowance for lateral-torsional buckling necessary.

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CHECK INTERACTION OF COMBINED RESISTANCE.
======================================================================================

( ). Calculate Major reduced design resistance of bending and shear.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.2.8 (6.30) ]
-. In case of V_Edz / Vpl_Rdz < 0.5
-. My_Rd = Mc_Rdy = 17471075.00 N-mm.

( ). Calculate Minor reduced design resistance of bending and shear.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.2.8 (6.30) ]
-. In case of V_Edy / Vpl_Rdy < 0.5
-. Mz_Rd = Mc_Rdz = 8351312.50 N-mm.

( ). Check general interaction ratio.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.2.1 (6.2) ] - Class1 or Class2
N_Ed M_Edy M_Edz
-. Rmax1 = ------ + ------- + -------
N_Rd My_Rd Mz_Rd
= 0.636 < 1.000 ---> O.K.

( ). Check interaction ratio of bending and axial force member.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.2.9 (6.31 ~ 6.41) ] - Class1 or Class2
-. n = N_Ed / Npl_Rd = 0.052
-. a = MIN[ (Area-2b*tf)/Area, 0.5 ] = 0.269
-. Alpha = 2.000
-. Beta = MAX[ 5*n, 1.0 ] = 1.000

-. N_Ed < 0.25*Npl_Rd = 112555.64 N.


-. N_Ed < 0.5*hw*tw*fy/Gamma_M0 = 50525.00 N.
Therefore, No allowance for the effect of axial force.
-. Mny_Rd = Mply_Rd = 17471075.00 N-mm.
-. Rmaxy = M_Edy / Mny_Rd = 0.126 < 1.000 ---> O.K.

Modeling, Integrated Design & Analysis Software Print Date/Time : 09/20/2016 09:08
http://www.MidasUser.com
MIDAS/Civil V 8.5.5 - 12 / 94 -
MIDAS/Civil Steel Code Checking Result

PROJECT TITLE : Design of Shutter Box Culvert

Company HDEC Client Reclamation at Tuas Finger One


Author RJT File Name Shutter Box_option 2_sept5.acs

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MIDAS/Civil - Steel Code Checking[ Eurocode3-2:05 ] Version 8.5.5
==========================================================================================

-. N_Ed < hw*tw*fy/Gamma_M0 = 141470.00 N.


Therefore, No allowance for the effect of axial force.
-. Mnz_Rd = Mplz_Rd = 8351312.50 N-mm.
-. Rmaxz = M_Edz / Mnz_Rd = 0.457 < 1.000 ---> O.K.

[ | M_Edy |^(Alpha) | M_Edz |^(Beta) ]


-. Rmax2 = [ |--------| + |--------| ]
[ | Mny_Rd | | Mnz_Rd | ]
= 0.473 < 1.000 ---> O.K.

-. Rmax = MAX[ Rmax1, Rmax2 ] = 0.636 < 1.000 ---> O.K.

Modeling, Integrated Design & Analysis Software Print Date/Time : 09/20/2016 09:08
http://www.MidasUser.com
MIDAS/Civil V 8.5.5 - 13 / 94 -
MIDAS/Civil Steel Code Checking Result

PROJECT TITLE : Design of Shutter Box Culvert

Company HDEC Client Reclamation at Tuas Finger One


Author RJT File Name Shutter Box_option 2_sept5.acs

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MIDAS/Civil - Steel Code Checking[ Eurocode3-2:05 ] Version 8.5.5
==========================================================================================

*. PROJECT :
*. MEMBER NO = 72, ELEMENT TYPE = Beam
*. LOADCOMB NO = 1, MATERIAL NO = 1, SECTION NO = 3
*. UNIT SYSTEM : N, mm

*. SECTION PROPERTIES : Designation = H 100x100x5/7


Shape = H - Section. (Built-up)
Depth = 100.000, Top F Width = 100.000, Bot.F Width = 100.000
Web Thick = 5.000, Top F Thick = 7.000, Bot.F Thick = 7.000

Area = 1.91584e+003, Avy = 1.40000e+003, Avz = 5.16000e+002


Ybar = 5.00000e+001, Zbar = 5.00000e+001, Qyb = 7.43450e+003, Qzb = 1.25000e+003
Wely = 6.88169e+004, Welz = 2.33958e+004, Wply = 7.43450e+004, Wplz = 3.55375e+004
Iyy = 3.44085e+006, Izz = 1.16979e+006, Iyz = 0.00000e+000
iy = 4.23792e+001, iz = 2.47101e+001
J = 2.67417e+004, Cwp = 2.52263e+009

*. DESIGN PARAMETERS FOR STRENGTH EVALUATION :


Ly = 4.33333e+002, Lz = 4.33333e+002, Lb = 4.33333e+002
Ky = 1.00000e+000, Kz = 1.00000e+000

*. MATERIAL PROPERTIES :
Fy = 2.35000e+002, Es = 2.10000e+005, MATERIAL NAME = S235

*. FORCES AND MOMENTS AT (J) POINT :


Axial Force Fxx =-8.90738e+004
Shear Forces Fyy = 6.71772e+002, Fzz =-2.23897e+004
Bending Moments My = 9.43254e+006, Mz =-1.41560e+005
End Moments Myi =-2.88375e+005, Myj = 9.43254e+006 (for Lb)
Myi =-2.88375e+005, Myj = 9.43254e+006 (for Ly)
Mzi = 1.49541e+005, Mzj =-1.41560e+005 (for Lz)

*. Sign conventions for stress and axial force.


- Stress : Compression positive.
- Axial force: Tension positive.

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CLASSIFY LEFT-TOP FLANGE OF SECTION (BTR).
======================================================================================

( ). Determine classification of compression outstand flanges.


[ Eurocode3:05 Table 5.2 (Sheet 2 of 3), EN 1993-1-5 ]
-. e = SQRT( 235/fy ) = 1.00
-. b/t = BTR = 5.36
-. sigma1 = 177.352 MPa.
-. sigma2 = 174.364 MPa.
-. BTR < 9*e ( Class 1 : Plastic ).

Modeling, Integrated Design & Analysis Software Print Date/Time : 09/20/2016 09:08
http://www.MidasUser.com
MIDAS/Civil V 8.5.5 - 14 / 94 -
MIDAS/Civil Steel Code Checking Result

PROJECT TITLE : Design of Shutter Box Culvert

Company HDEC Client Reclamation at Tuas Finger One


Author RJT File Name Shutter Box_option 2_sept5.acs

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MIDAS/Civil - Steel Code Checking[ Eurocode3-2:05 ] Version 8.5.5
==========================================================================================

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CLASSIFY RIGHT-TOP FLANGE OF SECTION (BTR).
======================================================================================

( ). Determine classification of compression outstand flanges.


[ Eurocode3:05 Table 5.2 (Sheet 2 of 3), EN 1993-1-5 ]
-. e = SQRT( 235/fy ) = 1.00
-. b/t = BTR = 5.36
-. sigma1 = 172.373 MPa.
-. sigma2 = 169.385 MPa.
-. BTR < 9*e ( Class 1 : Plastic ).

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CLASSIFY LEFT-BOTTOM FLANGE OF SECTION (BTR).
======================================================================================

( ). Determine classification of tension outstand flanges.


-. Not Checking the Section Classification.

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CLASSIFY RIGHT-BOTTOM FLANGE OF SECTION (BTR).
======================================================================================

( ). Determine classification of tension outstand flanges.


-. Not Checking the Section Classification.

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CLASSIFY WEB OF SECTION (HTR).
======================================================================================

( ). Determine classification of bending and compression Internal Parts.


[ Eurocode3:05 Table 5.2 (Sheet 1 of 3), EN 1993-1-5 ]
-. e = SQRT( 235/fy ) = 1.00
-. d/t = HTR = 13.20
-. sigma1 = 130.231 MPa.
-. sigma2 = -37.244 MPa.
-. Psi = [2*(Nsd/A)*(1/fy)]-1 = -0.604
-. Alpha = 1.000 > 0.5
-. HTR < 396*e/(13*Alpha-1) ( Class 1 : Plastic ).

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] APPLIED FACTORS.
======================================================================================

( ). Calculate equivalent uniform moment factors (Cmy,Cmz,CmLT).


[ Eurocode3:05 Annex A. Table A.1, A.2 ]
-. Cmy,0 = 0.783
-. Cmz,0 = 0.588
-. Cmy (Default or User Defined Value) = 1.000
-. Cmz (Default or User Defined Value) = 1.000
-. CmLT (Default or User Defined Value) = 1.000

Modeling, Integrated Design & Analysis Software Print Date/Time : 09/20/2016 09:08
http://www.MidasUser.com
MIDAS/Civil V 8.5.5 - 15 / 94 -
MIDAS/Civil Steel Code Checking Result

PROJECT TITLE : Design of Shutter Box Culvert

Company HDEC Client Reclamation at Tuas Finger One


Author RJT File Name Shutter Box_option 2_sept5.acs

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MIDAS/Civil - Steel Code Checking[ Eurocode3-2:05 ] Version 8.5.5
==========================================================================================

( ). Partial Factors (Gamma_Mi).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1 ]
-. Gamma_M0 = 1.00
-. Gamma_M1 = 1.10
-. Gamma_M2 = 1.25

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CHECK AXIAL RESISTANCE.
======================================================================================

( ). Check slenderness ratio of axial compression member (Kl/i).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.3.1 ]
-. Kl/i = 17.5 < 200.0 ---> O.K.

( ). Calculate axial compressive resistance (Nc_Rd).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1, 6.2.4 ]
-. Nc_Rd = fy * Area / Gamma_M0 = 450222.57 N.

( ). Check ratio of axial resistance (N_Ed/Nc_Rd).


N_Ed 89073.77
-. ----- = --------------- = 0.198 < 1.000 ---> O.K.
Nc_Rd 450222.57

( ). Calculate buckling resistance of compression member (Nb_Rdy, Nb_Rdz).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.3.1.1, 6.3.1.2 ]
-. Beta_A = Aeff / Area = 1.000
-. Lambda1 = Pi * SQRT(Es/fy) = 93.913
-. Lambda_by = {(Ky*Ly/iy)/Lambda1} * SQRT(Beta_A) = 0.109
-. Ncry = Pi^2*Es*Iyy / (Ky*Ly)^2 = 37978714.90 N.
-. Lambda_by < 0.2 or N_Ed/Ncry < 0.04 --> No need to check.

-. Lambda_bz = {(Kz*Lz/iz)/Lambda1} * SQRT(Beta_A) = 0.187


-. Ncrz = Pi^2*Es*Izz / (Kz*Lz)^2 = 12911656.19 N.
-. Lambda_bz < 0.2 or N_Ed/Ncrz < 0.04 --> No need to check.

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CHECK SHEAR RESISTANCE.
======================================================================================

( ). Calculate shear area.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.2.6, EN1993-1-5:04 5.1 NOTE 2 ]
-. eta = 1.2 (Fy < 460 MPa.)
-. Avy = 2*B*tf = 1400.0000 mm^2.
-. Avz = eta*hw*tw = 516.0000 mm^2.

( ). Calculate plastic shear resistance in local-y direction (Vpl_Rdy).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1, 6.2.6 ]
-. Vpl_Rdy = [ Avy*fy/SQRT(3) ] / Gamma_M0 = 189948.24 N.

Modeling, Integrated Design & Analysis Software Print Date/Time : 09/20/2016 09:08
http://www.MidasUser.com
MIDAS/Civil V 8.5.5 - 16 / 94 -
MIDAS/Civil Steel Code Checking Result

PROJECT TITLE : Design of Shutter Box Culvert

Company HDEC Client Reclamation at Tuas Finger One


Author RJT File Name Shutter Box_option 2_sept5.acs

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MIDAS/Civil - Steel Code Checking[ Eurocode3-2:05 ] Version 8.5.5
==========================================================================================

( ). Check ratio of shear resistance (V_Edy/Vpl_Rdy).


( LCB = 1, POS = J )
-. Applied shear force : V_Edy = 671.77 N.
V_Edy 671.77
-. ------- = --------------- = 0.004 < 1.000 ---> O.K.
Vpl_Rdy 189948.24

( ). Calculate plastic shear resistance in local-z direction (Vpl_Rdz).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1, 6.2.6 ]
-. Vpl_Rdz = [ Avz*fy/SQRT(3) ] / Gamma_M0 = 70009.49 N.

( ). Shear Buckling Check.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.2.6 ]
-. HTR < 72*e/Eta ---> No need to check!

( ). Check ratio of shear resistance (V_Edz/Vpl_Rdz).


( LCB = 1, POS = I )
-. Applied shear force : V_Edz = 22476.02 N.
V_Edz 22476.02
-. ------- = --------------- = 0.321 < 1.000 ---> O.K.
Vpl_Rdz 70009.49

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CHECK BENDING MOMENT RESISTANCE ABOUT MAJOR AXIS.
======================================================================================

( ). Calculate plastic resistance moment about major axis.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1, 6.2.5 ]
-. Wply = 74345.0000 mm^3.
-. Mc_Rdy = Wply * fy / Gamma_M0 = 17471075.00 N-mm.

( ). Check ratio of moment resistance (M_Edy/Mc_Rdy).


M_Edy 9432541.76
-. ------ = --------------- = 0.540 < 1.000 ---> O.K.
Mc_Rdy 17471075.00

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CHECK BENDING MOMENT RESISTANCE ABOUT MINOR AXIS.
======================================================================================

( ). Calculate plastic resistance moment about minor axis.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1, 6.2.5 ]
-. Wplz = 35537.5000 mm^3.
-. Mc_Rdz = Wplz * fy / Gamma_M0 = 8351312.50 N-mm.

( ). Check ratio of moment resistance (M_Edz/Mc_Rdz).


M_Edz 141560.35
-. ------ = --------------- = 0.017 < 1.000 ---> O.K.
Mc_Rdz 8351312.50

Modeling, Integrated Design & Analysis Software Print Date/Time : 09/20/2016 09:08
http://www.MidasUser.com
MIDAS/Civil V 8.5.5 - 17 / 94 -
MIDAS/Civil Steel Code Checking Result

PROJECT TITLE : Design of Shutter Box Culvert

Company HDEC Client Reclamation at Tuas Finger One


Author RJT File Name Shutter Box_option 2_sept5.acs

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MIDAS/Civil - Steel Code Checking[ Eurocode3-2:05 ] Version 8.5.5
==========================================================================================

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CHECK LATERAL-TORSIONAL BUCKLING RESISTANCE.
======================================================================================

( ). Calculate lateral-torsional buckling resistance (Mb_Rd).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1, 6.3.2 ]
-. Por = 0.300
-. Gs = Es / [ 2*(1+Por) ] = 80769.231 MPa.
-. Ncr = Pi^2*Es*Izz / Lu^2 = 12911656.19 N.
-. psi = -0.031
-. C1 = 1.285
-. Mcr = C1 * Ncr * SQRT [ (Cwp/Izz) + (Gs*Ixx)/Ncr ] = 799799432.23 N-mm.

-. Lambda_LT_bar = SQRT [ Wply*fy / Mcr ] = 0.148


-. Lambda_LT_bar0 = 0.200

-. Lambda_LT_bar = 0.148 < Lambda_LT_bar0 = 0.200


-. M_Ed/Mcr = 0.012 < Lambda_LT_bar0^2 = 0.040
If Lambda_LT_bar < Lambda_LT_bar0 or M_Ed/Mcr < Lambda_LT_bar0^2,
No allowance for lateral-torsional buckling necessary.

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CHECK INTERACTION OF COMBINED RESISTANCE.
======================================================================================

( ). Calculate Major reduced design resistance of bending and shear.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.2.8 (6.30) ]
-. In case of V_Edz / Vpl_Rdz < 0.5
-. My_Rd = Mc_Rdy = 17471075.00 N-mm.

( ). Calculate Minor reduced design resistance of bending and shear.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.2.8 (6.30) ]
-. In case of V_Edy / Vpl_Rdy < 0.5
-. Mz_Rd = Mc_Rdz = 8351312.50 N-mm.

( ). Check general interaction ratio.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.2.1 (6.2) ] - Class1 or Class2
N_Ed M_Edy M_Edz
-. Rmax1 = ------ + ------- + -------
N_Rd My_Rd Mz_Rd
= 0.755 < 1.000 ---> O.K.

( ). Check interaction ratio of bending and axial force member.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.2.9 (6.31 ~ 6.41) ] - Class1 or Class2
-. n = N_Ed / Npl_Rd = 0.198
-. a = MIN[ (Area-2b*tf)/Area, 0.5 ] = 0.269
-. Alpha = 2.000
-. Beta = MAX[ 5*n, 1.0 ] = 1.000

Modeling, Integrated Design & Analysis Software Print Date/Time : 09/20/2016 09:08
http://www.MidasUser.com
MIDAS/Civil V 8.5.5 - 18 / 94 -
MIDAS/Civil Steel Code Checking Result

PROJECT TITLE : Design of Shutter Box Culvert

Company HDEC Client Reclamation at Tuas Finger One


Author RJT File Name Shutter Box_option 2_sept5.acs

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MIDAS/Civil - Steel Code Checking[ Eurocode3-2:05 ] Version 8.5.5
==========================================================================================

-. N_Ed < 0.25*Npl_Rd = 112555.64 N.


-. N_Ed > 0.5*hw*tw*fy/Gamma_M0 = 50525.00 N.
Therefore, Allowance for the effect of axial force.
-. Mny_Rd = MIN[ Mply_Rd*(1-n)/(1-0.5*a), Mply_Rd ] = 16194751.14 N-mm.
-. Rmaxy = M_Edy / Mny_Rd = 0.582 < 1.000 ---> O.K.

-. N_Ed < hw*tw*fy/Gamma_M0 = 141470.00 N.


Therefore, No allowance for the effect of axial force.
-. Mnz_Rd = Mplz_Rd = 8351312.50 N-mm.
-. Rmaxz = M_Edz / Mnz_Rd = 0.017 < 1.000 ---> O.K.

[ | M_Edy |^(Alpha) | M_Edz |^(Beta) ]


-. Rmax2 = [ |--------| + |--------| ]
[ | Mny_Rd | | Mnz_Rd | ]
= 0.356 < 1.000 ---> O.K.

( ). Check interaction ratio of bending and axial compression member.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.3.1, 6.2.9.3 (6.61, 6.62), Annex A ]
-. N_Ed = -89073.77 N.
-. M_Edy = 9432541.76 N-mm.
-. M_Edz = -141560.35 N-mm.
-. kyy = 0.974
-. kyz = 0.595
-. kzy = 0.497
-. kzz = 1.530
-. Xiy = 1.000
-. Xiz = 1.000
-. XiLT = 1.000
-. N_Rk = A*fy = 450222.57 N.
-. My_Rk = Wply*fy = 17471075.00 N-mm.
-. Mz_Rk = Wplz*fy = 8351312.50 N-mm.
-. N_Ed*eNy = 0.0 (Not Slender)
-. N_Ed*eNZ = 0.0 (Not Slender)
N_Ed M_Edy + N_Ed*eNy M_Edz + N_Ed*eNz
-. Rmax_LT1 = ----------------- + kyy * ------------------- + kyz * ----------------
Xiy*N_Rk/Gamma_M1 XiLT*My_Rk/Gamma_M1 Mz_Rk/Gamma_M1
= 0.807 < 1.000 ---> O.K.
N_Ed M_Edy + N_Ed*eNy M_Edz + N_Ed*eNz
-. Rmax_LT2 = ----------------- + kzy * ------------------- + kzz * ----------------
Xiz*N_Rk/Gamma_M1 XiLT*My_Rk/Gamma_M1 Mz_Rk/Gamma_M1
= 0.541 < 1.000 ---> O.K.

-. Rmax = MAX[ MAX(Rmax1, Rmax2), MAX(Rmax_LT1, Rmax_LT2) ] = 0.807 < 1.000 --->
O.K.

Modeling, Integrated Design & Analysis Software Print Date/Time : 09/20/2016 09:08
http://www.MidasUser.com
MIDAS/Civil V 8.5.5 - 19 / 94 -
MIDAS/Civil Steel Code Checking Result

PROJECT TITLE : Design of Shutter Box Culvert

Company HDEC Client Reclamation at Tuas Finger One


Author RJT File Name Shutter Box_option 2_sept5.acs

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MIDAS/Civil - Steel Code Checking[ Eurocode3-2:05 ] Version 8.5.5
==========================================================================================

*. PROJECT :
*. MEMBER NO = 769, ELEMENT TYPE = Beam
*. LOADCOMB NO = 1, MATERIAL NO = 1, SECTION NO = 4
*. UNIT SYSTEM : N, mm

*. SECTION PROPERTIES : Designation = H 100x100x5/7


Shape = H - Section. (Built-up)
Depth = 100.000, Top F Width = 100.000, Bot.F Width = 100.000
Web Thick = 5.000, Top F Thick = 7.000, Bot.F Thick = 7.000

Area = 1.91584e+003, Avy = 1.40000e+003, Avz = 5.16000e+002


Ybar = 5.00000e+001, Zbar = 5.00000e+001, Qyb = 7.43450e+003, Qzb = 1.25000e+003
Wely = 6.88169e+004, Welz = 2.33958e+004, Wply = 7.43450e+004, Wplz = 3.55375e+004
Iyy = 3.44085e+006, Izz = 1.16979e+006, Iyz = 0.00000e+000
iy = 4.23792e+001, iz = 2.47101e+001
J = 2.67417e+004, Cwp = 2.52263e+009

*. DESIGN PARAMETERS FOR STRENGTH EVALUATION :


Ly = 5.25000e+002, Lz = 5.25000e+002, Lb = 5.25000e+002
Ky = 1.00000e+000, Kz = 1.00000e+000

*. MATERIAL PROPERTIES :
Fy = 2.35000e+002, Es = 2.10000e+005, MATERIAL NAME = S235

*. FORCES AND MOMENTS AT (J) POINT :


Axial Force Fxx =-3.94672e+004
Shear Forces Fyy = 2.60340e+003, Fzz =-1.44492e+004
Bending Moments My = 5.75212e+006, Mz =-1.36299e+006
End Moments Myi =-1.83370e+006, Myj = 5.75212e+006 (for Lb)
Myi =-1.83370e+006, Myj = 5.75212e+006 (for Ly)
Mzi = 3.12306e+004, Mzj =-1.36299e+006 (for Lz)

*. Sign conventions for stress and axial force.


- Stress : Compression positive.
- Axial force: Tension positive.

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CLASSIFY LEFT-TOP FLANGE OF SECTION (BTR).
======================================================================================

( ). Determine classification of compression outstand flanges.


[ Eurocode3:05 Table 5.2 (Sheet 2 of 3), EN 1993-1-5 ]
-. e = SQRT( 235/fy ) = 1.00
-. b/t = BTR = 5.36
-. sigma1 = 136.325 MPa.
-. sigma2 = 107.560 MPa.
-. BTR < 9*e ( Class 1 : Plastic ).

Modeling, Integrated Design & Analysis Software Print Date/Time : 09/20/2016 09:08
http://www.MidasUser.com
MIDAS/Civil V 8.5.5 - 20 / 94 -
MIDAS/Civil Steel Code Checking Result

PROJECT TITLE : Design of Shutter Box Culvert

Company HDEC Client Reclamation at Tuas Finger One


Author RJT File Name Shutter Box_option 2_sept5.acs

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MIDAS/Civil - Steel Code Checking[ Eurocode3-2:05 ] Version 8.5.5
==========================================================================================

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CLASSIFY RIGHT-TOP FLANGE OF SECTION (BTR).
======================================================================================

( ). Determine classification of compression outstand flanges.


[ Eurocode3:05 Table 5.2 (Sheet 2 of 3), EN 1993-1-5 ]
-. e = SQRT( 235/fy ) = 1.00
-. b/t = BTR = 5.36
-. sigma1 = 88.383 MPa.
-. sigma2 = 59.617 MPa.
-. BTR < 9*e ( Class 1 : Plastic ).

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CLASSIFY LEFT-BOTTOM FLANGE OF SECTION (BTR).
======================================================================================

( ). Determine classification of tension outstand flanges.


-. Not Checking the Section Classification.

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CLASSIFY RIGHT-BOTTOM FLANGE OF SECTION (BTR).
======================================================================================

( ). Determine classification of tension outstand flanges.


-. Not Checking the Section Classification.

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CLASSIFY WEB OF SECTION (HTR).
======================================================================================

( ). Determine classification of bending and compression Internal Parts.


[ Eurocode3:05 Table 5.2 (Sheet 1 of 3), EN 1993-1-5 ]
-. e = SQRT( 235/fy ) = 1.00
-. d/t = HTR = 13.20
-. sigma1 = 71.665 MPa.
-. sigma2 = -30.464 MPa.
-. Psi = [2*(Nsd/A)*(1/fy)]-1 = -0.825
-. Alpha = 0.754 > 0.5
-. HTR < 396*e/(13*Alpha-1) ( Class 1 : Plastic ).

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] APPLIED FACTORS.
======================================================================================

( ). Calculate equivalent uniform moment factors (Cmy,Cmz,CmLT).


[ Eurocode3:05 Annex A. Table A.1, A.2 ]
-. Cmy,0 = 0.723
-. Cmz,0 = 0.785
-. Cmy (Default or User Defined Value) = 1.000
-. Cmz (Default or User Defined Value) = 1.000
-. CmLT (Default or User Defined Value) = 1.000

Modeling, Integrated Design & Analysis Software Print Date/Time : 09/20/2016 09:08
http://www.MidasUser.com
MIDAS/Civil V 8.5.5 - 21 / 94 -
MIDAS/Civil Steel Code Checking Result

PROJECT TITLE : Design of Shutter Box Culvert

Company HDEC Client Reclamation at Tuas Finger One


Author RJT File Name Shutter Box_option 2_sept5.acs

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MIDAS/Civil - Steel Code Checking[ Eurocode3-2:05 ] Version 8.5.5
==========================================================================================

( ). Partial Factors (Gamma_Mi).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1 ]
-. Gamma_M0 = 1.00
-. Gamma_M1 = 1.10
-. Gamma_M2 = 1.25

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CHECK AXIAL RESISTANCE.
======================================================================================

( ). Check slenderness ratio of axial compression member (Kl/i).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.3.1 ]
-. Kl/i = 21.2 < 200.0 ---> O.K.

( ). Calculate axial compressive resistance (Nc_Rd).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1, 6.2.4 ]
-. Nc_Rd = fy * Area / Gamma_M0 = 450222.57 N.

( ). Check ratio of axial resistance (N_Ed/Nc_Rd).


N_Ed 39467.21
-. ----- = --------------- = 0.088 < 1.000 ---> O.K.
Nc_Rd 450222.57

( ). Calculate buckling resistance of compression member (Nb_Rdy, Nb_Rdz).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.3.1.1, 6.3.1.2 ]
-. Beta_A = Aeff / Area = 1.000
-. Lambda1 = Pi * SQRT(Es/fy) = 93.913
-. Lambda_by = {(Ky*Ly/iy)/Lambda1} * SQRT(Beta_A) = 0.132
-. Ncry = Pi^2*Es*Iyy / (Ky*Ly)^2 = 25874135.82 N.
-. Lambda_by < 0.2 or N_Ed/Ncry < 0.04 --> No need to check.

-. Lambda_bz = {(Kz*Lz/iz)/Lambda1} * SQRT(Beta_A) = 0.226


-. Ncrz = Pi^2*Es*Izz / (Kz*Lz)^2 = 8796452.09 N.
-. Lambda_bz < 0.2 or N_Ed/Ncrz < 0.04 --> No need to check.

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CHECK SHEAR RESISTANCE.
======================================================================================

( ). Calculate shear area.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.2.6, EN1993-1-5:04 5.1 NOTE 2 ]
-. eta = 1.2 (Fy < 460 MPa.)
-. Avy = 2*B*tf = 1400.0000 mm^2.
-. Avz = eta*hw*tw = 516.0000 mm^2.

( ). Calculate plastic shear resistance in local-y direction (Vpl_Rdy).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1, 6.2.6 ]
-. Vpl_Rdy = [ Avy*fy/SQRT(3) ] / Gamma_M0 = 189948.24 N.

Modeling, Integrated Design & Analysis Software Print Date/Time : 09/20/2016 09:08
http://www.MidasUser.com
MIDAS/Civil V 8.5.5 - 22 / 94 -
MIDAS/Civil Steel Code Checking Result

PROJECT TITLE : Design of Shutter Box Culvert

Company HDEC Client Reclamation at Tuas Finger One


Author RJT File Name Shutter Box_option 2_sept5.acs

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MIDAS/Civil - Steel Code Checking[ Eurocode3-2:05 ] Version 8.5.5
==========================================================================================

( ). Check ratio of shear resistance (V_Edy/Vpl_Rdy).


( LCB = 1, POS = I )
-. Applied shear force : V_Edy = 2707.93 N.
V_Edy 2707.93
-. ------- = --------------- = 0.014 < 1.000 ---> O.K.
Vpl_Rdy 189948.24

( ). Calculate plastic shear resistance in local-z direction (Vpl_Rdz).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1, 6.2.6 ]
-. Vpl_Rdz = [ Avz*fy/SQRT(3) ] / Gamma_M0 = 70009.49 N.

( ). Shear Buckling Check.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.2.6 ]
-. HTR < 72*e/Eta ---> No need to check!

( ). Check ratio of shear resistance (V_Edz/Vpl_Rdz).


( LCB = 1, POS = J )
-. Applied shear force : V_Edz = 14449.19 N.
V_Edz 14449.19
-. ------- = --------------- = 0.206 < 1.000 ---> O.K.
Vpl_Rdz 70009.49

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CHECK BENDING MOMENT RESISTANCE ABOUT MAJOR AXIS.
======================================================================================

( ). Calculate plastic resistance moment about major axis.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1, 6.2.5 ]
-. Wply = 74345.0000 mm^3.
-. Mc_Rdy = Wply * fy / Gamma_M0 = 17471075.00 N-mm.

( ). Check ratio of moment resistance (M_Edy/Mc_Rdy).


M_Edy 5752123.95
-. ------ = --------------- = 0.329 < 1.000 ---> O.K.
Mc_Rdy 17471075.00

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CHECK BENDING MOMENT RESISTANCE ABOUT MINOR AXIS.
======================================================================================

( ). Calculate plastic resistance moment about minor axis.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1, 6.2.5 ]
-. Wplz = 35537.5000 mm^3.
-. Mc_Rdz = Wplz * fy / Gamma_M0 = 8351312.50 N-mm.

( ). Check ratio of moment resistance (M_Edz/Mc_Rdz).


M_Edz 1362994.06
-. ------ = --------------- = 0.163 < 1.000 ---> O.K.
Mc_Rdz 8351312.50

Modeling, Integrated Design & Analysis Software Print Date/Time : 09/20/2016 09:08
http://www.MidasUser.com
MIDAS/Civil V 8.5.5 - 23 / 94 -
MIDAS/Civil Steel Code Checking Result

PROJECT TITLE : Design of Shutter Box Culvert

Company HDEC Client Reclamation at Tuas Finger One


Author RJT File Name Shutter Box_option 2_sept5.acs

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MIDAS/Civil - Steel Code Checking[ Eurocode3-2:05 ] Version 8.5.5
==========================================================================================

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CHECK LATERAL-TORSIONAL BUCKLING RESISTANCE.
======================================================================================

( ). Calculate lateral-torsional buckling resistance (Mb_Rd).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1, 6.3.2 ]
-. Por = 0.300
-. Gs = Es / [ 2*(1+Por) ] = 80769.231 MPa.
-. Ncr = Pi^2*Es*Izz / Lu^2 = 8796452.09 N.
-. psi = -0.319
-. C1 = 1.285
-. Mcr = C1 * Ncr * SQRT [ (Cwp/Izz) + (Gs*Ixx)/Ncr ] = 553986630.22 N-mm.

-. Lambda_LT_bar = SQRT [ Wply*fy / Mcr ] = 0.178


-. Lambda_LT_bar0 = 0.200

-. Lambda_LT_bar = 0.178 < Lambda_LT_bar0 = 0.200


-. M_Ed/Mcr = 0.010 < Lambda_LT_bar0^2 = 0.040
If Lambda_LT_bar < Lambda_LT_bar0 or M_Ed/Mcr < Lambda_LT_bar0^2,
No allowance for lateral-torsional buckling necessary.

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CHECK INTERACTION OF COMBINED RESISTANCE.
======================================================================================

( ). Calculate Major reduced design resistance of bending and shear.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.2.8 (6.30) ]
-. In case of V_Edz / Vpl_Rdz < 0.5
-. My_Rd = Mc_Rdy = 17471075.00 N-mm.

( ). Calculate Minor reduced design resistance of bending and shear.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.2.8 (6.30) ]
-. In case of V_Edy / Vpl_Rdy < 0.5
-. Mz_Rd = Mc_Rdz = 8351312.50 N-mm.

( ). Check general interaction ratio.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.2.1 (6.2) ] - Class1 or Class2
N_Ed M_Edy M_Edz
-. Rmax1 = ------ + ------- + -------
N_Rd My_Rd Mz_Rd
= 0.580 < 1.000 ---> O.K.

( ). Check interaction ratio of bending and axial force member.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.2.9 (6.31 ~ 6.41) ] - Class1 or Class2
-. n = N_Ed / Npl_Rd = 0.088
-. a = MIN[ (Area-2b*tf)/Area, 0.5 ] = 0.269
-. Alpha = 2.000
-. Beta = MAX[ 5*n, 1.0 ] = 1.000

Modeling, Integrated Design & Analysis Software Print Date/Time : 09/20/2016 09:08
http://www.MidasUser.com
MIDAS/Civil V 8.5.5 - 24 / 94 -
MIDAS/Civil Steel Code Checking Result

PROJECT TITLE : Design of Shutter Box Culvert

Company HDEC Client Reclamation at Tuas Finger One


Author RJT File Name Shutter Box_option 2_sept5.acs

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MIDAS/Civil - Steel Code Checking[ Eurocode3-2:05 ] Version 8.5.5
==========================================================================================

-. N_Ed < 0.25*Npl_Rd = 112555.64 N.


-. N_Ed < 0.5*hw*tw*fy/Gamma_M0 = 50525.00 N.
Therefore, No allowance for the effect of axial force.
-. Mny_Rd = Mply_Rd = 17471075.00 N-mm.
-. Rmaxy = M_Edy / Mny_Rd = 0.329 < 1.000 ---> O.K.

-. N_Ed < hw*tw*fy/Gamma_M0 = 141470.00 N.


Therefore, No allowance for the effect of axial force.
-. Mnz_Rd = Mplz_Rd = 8351312.50 N-mm.
-. Rmaxz = M_Edz / Mnz_Rd = 0.163 < 1.000 ---> O.K.

[ | M_Edy |^(Alpha) | M_Edz |^(Beta) ]


-. Rmax2 = [ |--------| + |--------| ]
[ | Mny_Rd | | Mnz_Rd | ]
= 0.272 < 1.000 ---> O.K.

( ). Check interaction ratio of bending and axial compression member.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.3.1, 6.2.9.3 (6.61, 6.62), Annex A ]
-. N_Ed = -39467.21 N.
-. M_Edy = 5752123.95 N-mm.
-. M_Edz = -1362994.06 N-mm.
-. kyy = 0.989
-. kyz = 0.658
-. kzy = 0.513
-. kzz = 1.526
-. Xiy = 1.000
-. Xiz = 1.000
-. XiLT = 1.000
-. N_Rk = A*fy = 450222.57 N.
-. My_Rk = Wply*fy = 17471075.00 N-mm.
-. Mz_Rk = Wplz*fy = 8351312.50 N-mm.
-. N_Ed*eNy = 0.0 (Not Slender)
-. N_Ed*eNZ = 0.0 (Not Slender)
N_Ed M_Edy + N_Ed*eNy M_Edz + N_Ed*eNz
-. Rmax_LT1 = ----------------- + kyy * ------------------- + kyz * ----------------
Xiy*N_Rk/Gamma_M1 XiLT*My_Rk/Gamma_M1 Mz_Rk/Gamma_M1
= 0.573 < 1.000 ---> O.K.
N_Ed M_Edy + N_Ed*eNy M_Edz + N_Ed*eNz
-. Rmax_LT2 = ----------------- + kzy * ------------------- + kzz * ----------------
Xiz*N_Rk/Gamma_M1 XiLT*My_Rk/Gamma_M1 Mz_Rk/Gamma_M1
= 0.556 < 1.000 ---> O.K.

-. Rmax = MAX[ MAX(Rmax1, Rmax2), MAX(Rmax_LT1, Rmax_LT2) ] = 0.580 < 1.000 --->
O.K.

Modeling, Integrated Design & Analysis Software Print Date/Time : 09/20/2016 09:08
http://www.MidasUser.com
MIDAS/Civil V 8.5.5 - 25 / 94 -
MIDAS/Civil Steel Code Checking Result

PROJECT TITLE : Design of Shutter Box Culvert

Company HDEC Client Reclamation at Tuas Finger One


Author RJT File Name Shutter Box_option 2_sept5.acs

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MIDAS/Civil - Steel Code Checking[ Eurocode3-2:05 ] Version 8.5.5
==========================================================================================

*. PROJECT :
*. MEMBER NO = 727, ELEMENT TYPE = Beam
*. LOADCOMB NO = 1, MATERIAL NO = 1, SECTION NO = 5
*. UNIT SYSTEM : N, mm

*. SECTION PROPERTIES : Designation = H 100x100x5/7


Shape = H - Section. (Built-up)
Depth = 100.000, Top F Width = 100.000, Bot.F Width = 100.000
Web Thick = 5.000, Top F Thick = 7.000, Bot.F Thick = 7.000

Area = 1.91584e+003, Avy = 1.40000e+003, Avz = 5.16000e+002


Ybar = 5.00000e+001, Zbar = 5.00000e+001, Qyb = 7.43450e+003, Qzb = 1.25000e+003
Wely = 6.88169e+004, Welz = 2.33958e+004, Wply = 7.43450e+004, Wplz = 3.55375e+004
Iyy = 3.44085e+006, Izz = 1.16979e+006, Iyz = 0.00000e+000
iy = 4.23792e+001, iz = 2.47101e+001
J = 2.67417e+004, Cwp = 2.52263e+009

*. DESIGN PARAMETERS FOR STRENGTH EVALUATION :


Ly = 4.50000e+002, Lz = 4.50000e+002, Lb = 4.50000e+002
Ky = 1.00000e+000, Kz = 1.00000e+000

*. MATERIAL PROPERTIES :
Fy = 2.35000e+002, Es = 2.10000e+005, MATERIAL NAME = S235

*. FORCES AND MOMENTS AT (J) POINT :


Axial Force Fxx =-3.68952e+004
Shear Forces Fyy =-1.50864e+003, Fzz = 2.73982e+003
Bending Moments My =-2.09266e+006, Mz = 2.62194e+005
End Moments Myi =-8.59744e+005, Myj =-2.09266e+006 (for Lb)
Myi =-8.59744e+005, Myj =-2.09266e+006 (for Ly)
Mzi =-4.16692e+005, Mzj = 2.62194e+005 (for Lz)

*. Sign conventions for stress and axial force.


- Stress : Compression positive.
- Axial force: Tension positive.

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CLASSIFY LEFT-TOP FLANGE OF SECTION (BTR).
======================================================================================

( ). Determine classification of tension outstand flanges.


-. Not Checking the Section Classification.

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CLASSIFY RIGHT-TOP FLANGE OF SECTION (BTR).
======================================================================================

( ). Determine classification of tension outstand flanges.


-. Not Checking the Section Classification.

Modeling, Integrated Design & Analysis Software Print Date/Time : 09/20/2016 09:08
http://www.MidasUser.com
MIDAS/Civil V 8.5.5 - 26 / 94 -
MIDAS/Civil Steel Code Checking Result

PROJECT TITLE : Design of Shutter Box Culvert

Company HDEC Client Reclamation at Tuas Finger One


Author RJT File Name Shutter Box_option 2_sept5.acs

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MIDAS/Civil - Steel Code Checking[ Eurocode3-2:05 ] Version 8.5.5
==========================================================================================

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CLASSIFY LEFT-BOTTOM FLANGE OF SECTION (BTR).
======================================================================================

( ). Determine classification of compression outstand flanges.


[ Eurocode3:05 Table 5.2 (Sheet 2 of 3), EN 1993-1-5 ]
-. e = SQRT( 235/fy ) = 1.00
-. b/t = BTR = 5.36
-. sigma1 = 45.561 MPa.
-. sigma2 = 40.028 MPa.
-. BTR < 9*e ( Class 1 : Plastic ).

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CLASSIFY RIGHT-BOTTOM FLANGE OF SECTION (BTR).
======================================================================================

( ). Determine classification of compression outstand flanges.


[ Eurocode3:05 Table 5.2 (Sheet 2 of 3), EN 1993-1-5 ]
-. e = SQRT( 235/fy ) = 1.00
-. b/t = BTR = 5.36
-. sigma1 = 54.784 MPa.
-. sigma2 = 49.250 MPa.
-. BTR < 9*e ( Class 1 : Plastic ).

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CLASSIFY WEB OF SECTION (HTR).
======================================================================================

( ). Determine classification of compression Internal Parts.


[ Eurocode3:05 Table 5.2 (Sheet 1 of 3), EN 1993-1-5 ]
-. e = SQRT( 235/fy ) = 1.00
-. d/t = HTR = 13.20
-. sigma1 = 37.836 MPa.
-. sigma2 = 0.680 MPa.
-. HTR < 33*e ( Class 1 : Plastic ).

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] APPLIED FACTORS.
======================================================================================

( ). Calculate equivalent uniform moment factors (Cmy,Cmz,CmLT).


[ Eurocode3:05 Annex A. Table A.1, A.2 ]
-. Cmy,0 = 0.876
-. Cmz,0 = 0.657
-. Cmy (Default or User Defined Value) = 0.850
-. Cmz (Default or User Defined Value) = 0.850
-. CmLT (Default or User Defined Value) = 1.000

Modeling, Integrated Design & Analysis Software Print Date/Time : 09/20/2016 09:08
http://www.MidasUser.com
MIDAS/Civil V 8.5.5 - 27 / 94 -
MIDAS/Civil Steel Code Checking Result

PROJECT TITLE : Design of Shutter Box Culvert

Company HDEC Client Reclamation at Tuas Finger One


Author RJT File Name Shutter Box_option 2_sept5.acs

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MIDAS/Civil - Steel Code Checking[ Eurocode3-2:05 ] Version 8.5.5
==========================================================================================

( ). Partial Factors (Gamma_Mi).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1 ]
-. Gamma_M0 = 1.00
-. Gamma_M1 = 1.10
-. Gamma_M2 = 1.25

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CHECK AXIAL RESISTANCE.
======================================================================================

( ). Check slenderness ratio of axial compression member (Kl/i).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.3.1 ]
-. Kl/i = 18.2 < 200.0 ---> O.K.

( ). Calculate axial compressive resistance (Nc_Rd).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1, 6.2.4 ]
-. Nc_Rd = fy * Area / Gamma_M0 = 450222.57 N.

( ). Check ratio of axial resistance (N_Ed/Nc_Rd).


N_Ed 36895.21
-. ----- = --------------- = 0.082 < 1.000 ---> O.K.
Nc_Rd 450222.57

( ). Calculate buckling resistance of compression member (Nb_Rdy, Nb_Rdz).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.3.1.1, 6.3.1.2 ]
-. Beta_A = Aeff / Area = 1.000
-. Lambda1 = Pi * SQRT(Es/fy) = 93.913
-. Lambda_by = {(Ky*Ly/iy)/Lambda1} * SQRT(Beta_A) = 0.113
-. Ncry = Pi^2*Es*Iyy / (Ky*Ly)^2 = 35217573.76 N.
-. Lambda_by < 0.2 or N_Ed/Ncry < 0.04 --> No need to check.

-. Lambda_bz = {(Kz*Lz/iz)/Lambda1} * SQRT(Beta_A) = 0.194


-. Ncrz = Pi^2*Es*Izz / (Kz*Lz)^2 = 11972948.68 N.
-. Lambda_bz < 0.2 or N_Ed/Ncrz < 0.04 --> No need to check.

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CHECK SHEAR RESISTANCE.
======================================================================================

( ). Calculate shear area.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.2.6, EN1993-1-5:04 5.1 NOTE 2 ]
-. eta = 1.2 (Fy < 460 MPa.)
-. Avy = 2*B*tf = 1400.0000 mm^2.
-. Avz = eta*hw*tw = 516.0000 mm^2.

( ). Calculate plastic shear resistance in local-y direction (Vpl_Rdy).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1, 6.2.6 ]
-. Vpl_Rdy = [ Avy*fy/SQRT(3) ] / Gamma_M0 = 189948.24 N.

Modeling, Integrated Design & Analysis Software Print Date/Time : 09/20/2016 09:08
http://www.MidasUser.com
MIDAS/Civil V 8.5.5 - 28 / 94 -
MIDAS/Civil Steel Code Checking Result

PROJECT TITLE : Design of Shutter Box Culvert

Company HDEC Client Reclamation at Tuas Finger One


Author RJT File Name Shutter Box_option 2_sept5.acs

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MIDAS/Civil - Steel Code Checking[ Eurocode3-2:05 ] Version 8.5.5
==========================================================================================

( ). Check ratio of shear resistance (V_Edy/Vpl_Rdy).


( LCB = 1, POS = J )
-. Applied shear force : V_Edy = 1508.64 N.
V_Edy 1508.64
-. ------- = --------------- = 0.008 < 1.000 ---> O.K.
Vpl_Rdy 189948.24

( ). Calculate plastic shear resistance in local-z direction (Vpl_Rdz).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1, 6.2.6 ]
-. Vpl_Rdz = [ Avz*fy/SQRT(3) ] / Gamma_M0 = 70009.49 N.

( ). Shear Buckling Check.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.2.6 ]
-. HTR < 72*e/Eta ---> No need to check!

( ). Check ratio of shear resistance (V_Edz/Vpl_Rdz).


( LCB = 1, POS = J )
-. Applied shear force : V_Edz = 2739.82 N.
V_Edz 2739.82
-. ------- = --------------- = 0.039 < 1.000 ---> O.K.
Vpl_Rdz 70009.49

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CHECK BENDING MOMENT RESISTANCE ABOUT MAJOR AXIS.
======================================================================================

( ). Calculate plastic resistance moment about major axis.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1, 6.2.5 ]
-. Wply = 74345.0000 mm^3.
-. Mc_Rdy = Wply * fy / Gamma_M0 = 17471075.00 N-mm.

( ). Check ratio of moment resistance (M_Edy/Mc_Rdy).


M_Edy 2092663.31
-. ------ = --------------- = 0.120 < 1.000 ---> O.K.
Mc_Rdy 17471075.00

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CHECK BENDING MOMENT RESISTANCE ABOUT MINOR AXIS.
======================================================================================

( ). Calculate plastic resistance moment about minor axis.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1, 6.2.5 ]
-. Wplz = 35537.5000 mm^3.
-. Mc_Rdz = Wplz * fy / Gamma_M0 = 8351312.50 N-mm.

( ). Check ratio of moment resistance (M_Edz/Mc_Rdz).


M_Edz 262193.97
-. ------ = --------------- = 0.031 < 1.000 ---> O.K.
Mc_Rdz 8351312.50

Modeling, Integrated Design & Analysis Software Print Date/Time : 09/20/2016 09:08
http://www.MidasUser.com
MIDAS/Civil V 8.5.5 - 29 / 94 -
MIDAS/Civil Steel Code Checking Result

PROJECT TITLE : Design of Shutter Box Culvert

Company HDEC Client Reclamation at Tuas Finger One


Author RJT File Name Shutter Box_option 2_sept5.acs

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MIDAS/Civil - Steel Code Checking[ Eurocode3-2:05 ] Version 8.5.5
==========================================================================================

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CHECK LATERAL-TORSIONAL BUCKLING RESISTANCE.
======================================================================================

( ). Calculate lateral-torsional buckling resistance (Mb_Rd).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1, 6.3.2 ]
-. Por = 0.300
-. Gs = Es / [ 2*(1+Por) ] = 80769.231 MPa.
-. Ncr = Pi^2*Es*Izz / Lu^2 = 11972948.68 N.
-. psi = 0.411
-. C1 = 1.409
-. Mcr = C1 * Ncr * SQRT [ (Cwp/Izz) + (Gs*Ixx)/Ncr ] = 815278069.56 N-mm.

-. Lambda_LT_bar = SQRT [ Wply*fy / Mcr ] = 0.146


-. Lambda_LT_bar0 = 0.200

-. Lambda_LT_bar = 0.146 < Lambda_LT_bar0 = 0.200


-. M_Ed/Mcr = 0.003 < Lambda_LT_bar0^2 = 0.040
If Lambda_LT_bar < Lambda_LT_bar0 or M_Ed/Mcr < Lambda_LT_bar0^2,
No allowance for lateral-torsional buckling necessary.

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CHECK INTERACTION OF COMBINED RESISTANCE.
======================================================================================

( ). Calculate Major reduced design resistance of bending and shear.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.2.8 (6.30) ]
-. In case of V_Edz / Vpl_Rdz < 0.5
-. My_Rd = Mc_Rdy = 17471075.00 N-mm.

( ). Calculate Minor reduced design resistance of bending and shear.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.2.8 (6.30) ]
-. In case of V_Edy / Vpl_Rdy < 0.5
-. Mz_Rd = Mc_Rdz = 8351312.50 N-mm.

( ). Check general interaction ratio.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.2.1 (6.2) ] - Class1 or Class2
N_Ed M_Edy M_Edz
-. Rmax1 = ------ + ------- + -------
N_Rd My_Rd Mz_Rd
= 0.233 < 1.000 ---> O.K.

( ). Check interaction ratio of bending and axial force member.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.2.9 (6.31 ~ 6.41) ] - Class1 or Class2
-. n = N_Ed / Npl_Rd = 0.082
-. a = MIN[ (Area-2b*tf)/Area, 0.5 ] = 0.269
-. Alpha = 2.000
-. Beta = MAX[ 5*n, 1.0 ] = 1.000

Modeling, Integrated Design & Analysis Software Print Date/Time : 09/20/2016 09:08
http://www.MidasUser.com
MIDAS/Civil V 8.5.5 - 30 / 94 -
MIDAS/Civil Steel Code Checking Result

PROJECT TITLE : Design of Shutter Box Culvert

Company HDEC Client Reclamation at Tuas Finger One


Author RJT File Name Shutter Box_option 2_sept5.acs

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MIDAS/Civil - Steel Code Checking[ Eurocode3-2:05 ] Version 8.5.5
==========================================================================================

-. N_Ed < 0.25*Npl_Rd = 112555.64 N.


-. N_Ed < 0.5*hw*tw*fy/Gamma_M0 = 50525.00 N.
Therefore, No allowance for the effect of axial force.
-. Mny_Rd = Mply_Rd = 17471075.00 N-mm.
-. Rmaxy = M_Edy / Mny_Rd = 0.120 < 1.000 ---> O.K.

-. N_Ed < hw*tw*fy/Gamma_M0 = 141470.00 N.


Therefore, No allowance for the effect of axial force.
-. Mnz_Rd = Mplz_Rd = 8351312.50 N-mm.
-. Rmaxz = M_Edz / Mnz_Rd = 0.031 < 1.000 ---> O.K.

[ | M_Edy |^(Alpha) | M_Edz |^(Beta) ]


-. Rmax2 = [ |--------| + |--------| ]
[ | Mny_Rd | | Mnz_Rd | ]
= 0.046 < 1.000 ---> O.K.

( ). Check interaction ratio of bending and axial compression member.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.3.1, 6.2.9.3 (6.61, 6.62), Annex A ]
-. N_Ed = -36895.21 N.
-. M_Edy = -2092663.31 N-mm.
-. M_Edz = 262193.97 N-mm.
-. kyy = 0.840
-. kyz = 0.556
-. kzy = 0.428
-. kzz = 0.971
-. Xiy = 1.000
-. Xiz = 1.000
-. XiLT = 1.000
-. N_Rk = A*fy = 450222.57 N.
-. My_Rk = Wply*fy = 17471075.00 N-mm.
-. Mz_Rk = Wplz*fy = 8351312.50 N-mm.
-. N_Ed*eNy = 0.0 (Not Slender)
-. N_Ed*eNZ = 0.0 (Not Slender)
N_Ed M_Edy + N_Ed*eNy M_Edz + N_Ed*eNz
-. Rmax_LT1 = ----------------- + kyy * ------------------- + kyz * ----------------
Xiy*N_Rk/Gamma_M1 XiLT*My_Rk/Gamma_M1 Mz_Rk/Gamma_M1
= 0.220 < 1.000 ---> O.K.
N_Ed M_Edy + N_Ed*eNy M_Edz + N_Ed*eNz
-. Rmax_LT2 = ----------------- + kzy * ------------------- + kzz * ----------------
Xiz*N_Rk/Gamma_M1 XiLT*My_Rk/Gamma_M1 Mz_Rk/Gamma_M1
= 0.180 < 1.000 ---> O.K.

-. Rmax = MAX[ MAX(Rmax1, Rmax2), MAX(Rmax_LT1, Rmax_LT2) ] = 0.233 < 1.000 --->
O.K.

Modeling, Integrated Design & Analysis Software Print Date/Time : 09/20/2016 09:08
http://www.MidasUser.com
MIDAS/Civil V 8.5.5 - 31 / 94 -
MIDAS/Civil Steel Code Checking Result

PROJECT TITLE : Design of Shutter Box Culvert

Company HDEC Client Reclamation at Tuas Finger One


Author RJT File Name Shutter Box_option 2_sept5.acs

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MIDAS/Civil - Steel Code Checking[ Eurocode3-2:05 ] Version 8.5.5
==========================================================================================

*. PROJECT :
*. MEMBER NO = 255, ELEMENT TYPE = Beam
*. LOADCOMB NO = 1, MATERIAL NO = 1, SECTION NO = 6
*. UNIT SYSTEM : N, mm

*. SECTION PROPERTIES : Designation = H 100x100x5/7


Shape = H - Section. (Built-up)
Depth = 100.000, Top F Width = 100.000, Bot.F Width = 100.000
Web Thick = 5.000, Top F Thick = 7.000, Bot.F Thick = 7.000

Area = 1.91584e+003, Avy = 1.40000e+003, Avz = 5.16000e+002


Ybar = 5.00000e+001, Zbar = 5.00000e+001, Qyb = 7.43450e+003, Qzb = 1.25000e+003
Wely = 6.88169e+004, Welz = 2.33958e+004, Wply = 7.43450e+004, Wplz = 3.55375e+004
Iyy = 3.44085e+006, Izz = 1.16979e+006, Iyz = 0.00000e+000
iy = 4.23792e+001, iz = 2.47101e+001
J = 2.67417e+004, Cwp = 2.52263e+009

*. DESIGN PARAMETERS FOR STRENGTH EVALUATION :


Ly = 4.50000e+002, Lz = 4.50000e+002, Lb = 4.50000e+002
Ky = 1.00000e+000, Kz = 1.00000e+000

*. MATERIAL PROPERTIES :
Fy = 2.35000e+002, Es = 2.10000e+005, MATERIAL NAME = S235

*. FORCES AND MOMENTS AT (I) POINT :


Axial Force Fxx =-1.97869e+004
Shear Forces Fyy =-1.37952e+002, Fzz =-2.40434e+004
Bending Moments My =-6.78870e+006, Mz =-8.64378e+004
End Moments Myi =-6.78870e+006, Myj = 4.03082e+006 (for Lb)
Myi =-6.78870e+006, Myj = 4.03082e+006 (for Ly)
Mzi =-8.64378e+004, Mzj =-2.43593e+004 (for Lz)

*. Sign conventions for stress and axial force.


- Stress : Compression positive.
- Axial force: Tension positive.

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CLASSIFY LEFT-TOP FLANGE OF SECTION (BTR).
======================================================================================

( ). Determine classification of tension outstand flanges.


-. Not Checking the Section Classification.

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CLASSIFY RIGHT-TOP FLANGE OF SECTION (BTR).
======================================================================================

( ). Determine classification of tension outstand flanges.


-. Not Checking the Section Classification.

Modeling, Integrated Design & Analysis Software Print Date/Time : 09/20/2016 09:08
http://www.MidasUser.com
MIDAS/Civil V 8.5.5 - 32 / 94 -
MIDAS/Civil Steel Code Checking Result

PROJECT TITLE : Design of Shutter Box Culvert

Company HDEC Client Reclamation at Tuas Finger One


Author RJT File Name Shutter Box_option 2_sept5.acs

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MIDAS/Civil - Steel Code Checking[ Eurocode3-2:05 ] Version 8.5.5
==========================================================================================

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CLASSIFY LEFT-BOTTOM FLANGE OF SECTION (BTR).
======================================================================================

( ). Determine classification of compression outstand flanges.


[ Eurocode3:05 Table 5.2 (Sheet 2 of 3), EN 1993-1-5 ]
-. e = SQRT( 235/fy ) = 1.00
-. b/t = BTR = 5.36
-. sigma1 = 104.074 MPa.
-. sigma2 = 102.250 MPa.
-. BTR < 9*e ( Class 1 : Plastic ).

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CLASSIFY RIGHT-BOTTOM FLANGE OF SECTION (BTR).
======================================================================================

( ). Determine classification of compression outstand flanges.


[ Eurocode3:05 Table 5.2 (Sheet 2 of 3), EN 1993-1-5 ]
-. e = SQRT( 235/fy ) = 1.00
-. b/t = BTR = 5.36
-. sigma1 = 101.033 MPa.
-. sigma2 = 99.209 MPa.
-. BTR < 9*e ( Class 1 : Plastic ).

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CLASSIFY WEB OF SECTION (HTR).
======================================================================================

( ). Determine classification of bending and compression Internal Parts.


[ Eurocode3:05 Table 5.2 (Sheet 1 of 3), EN 1993-1-5 ]
-. e = SQRT( 235/fy ) = 1.00
-. d/t = HTR = 13.20
-. sigma1 = 70.595 MPa.
-. sigma2 = -49.939 MPa.
-. Psi = [2*(Nsd/A)*(1/fy)]-1 = -0.912
-. Alpha = 0.628 > 0.5
-. HTR < 396*e/(13*Alpha-1) ( Class 1 : Plastic ).

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] APPLIED FACTORS.
======================================================================================

( ). Calculate equivalent uniform moment factors (Cmy,Cmz,CmLT).


[ Eurocode3:05 Annex A. Table A.1, A.2 ]
-. Cmy,0 = 0.665
-. Cmz,0 = 0.849
-. Cmy (Default or User Defined Value) = 0.850
-. Cmz (Default or User Defined Value) = 0.850
-. CmLT (Default or User Defined Value) = 1.000

Modeling, Integrated Design & Analysis Software Print Date/Time : 09/20/2016 09:08
http://www.MidasUser.com
MIDAS/Civil V 8.5.5 - 33 / 94 -
MIDAS/Civil Steel Code Checking Result

PROJECT TITLE : Design of Shutter Box Culvert

Company HDEC Client Reclamation at Tuas Finger One


Author RJT File Name Shutter Box_option 2_sept5.acs

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MIDAS/Civil - Steel Code Checking[ Eurocode3-2:05 ] Version 8.5.5
==========================================================================================

( ). Partial Factors (Gamma_Mi).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1 ]
-. Gamma_M0 = 1.00
-. Gamma_M1 = 1.10
-. Gamma_M2 = 1.25

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CHECK AXIAL RESISTANCE.
======================================================================================

( ). Check slenderness ratio of axial compression member (Kl/i).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.3.1 ]
-. Kl/i = 18.2 < 200.0 ---> O.K.

( ). Calculate axial compressive resistance (Nc_Rd).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1, 6.2.4 ]
-. Nc_Rd = fy * Area / Gamma_M0 = 450222.57 N.

( ). Check ratio of axial resistance (N_Ed/Nc_Rd).


N_Ed 19786.89
-. ----- = --------------- = 0.044 < 1.000 ---> O.K.
Nc_Rd 450222.57

( ). Calculate buckling resistance of compression member (Nb_Rdy, Nb_Rdz).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.3.1.1, 6.3.1.2 ]
-. Beta_A = Aeff / Area = 1.000
-. Lambda1 = Pi * SQRT(Es/fy) = 93.913
-. Lambda_by = {(Ky*Ly/iy)/Lambda1} * SQRT(Beta_A) = 0.113
-. Ncry = Pi^2*Es*Iyy / (Ky*Ly)^2 = 35217573.76 N.
-. Lambda_by < 0.2 or N_Ed/Ncry < 0.04 --> No need to check.

-. Lambda_bz = {(Kz*Lz/iz)/Lambda1} * SQRT(Beta_A) = 0.194


-. Ncrz = Pi^2*Es*Izz / (Kz*Lz)^2 = 11972948.68 N.
-. Lambda_bz < 0.2 or N_Ed/Ncrz < 0.04 --> No need to check.

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CHECK SHEAR RESISTANCE.
======================================================================================

( ). Calculate shear area.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.2.6, EN1993-1-5:04 5.1 NOTE 2 ]
-. eta = 1.2 (Fy < 460 MPa.)
-. Avy = 2*B*tf = 1400.0000 mm^2.
-. Avz = eta*hw*tw = 516.0000 mm^2.

( ). Calculate plastic shear resistance in local-y direction (Vpl_Rdy).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1, 6.2.6 ]
-. Vpl_Rdy = [ Avy*fy/SQRT(3) ] / Gamma_M0 = 189948.24 N.

Modeling, Integrated Design & Analysis Software Print Date/Time : 09/20/2016 09:08
http://www.MidasUser.com
MIDAS/Civil V 8.5.5 - 34 / 94 -
MIDAS/Civil Steel Code Checking Result

PROJECT TITLE : Design of Shutter Box Culvert

Company HDEC Client Reclamation at Tuas Finger One


Author RJT File Name Shutter Box_option 2_sept5.acs

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MIDAS/Civil - Steel Code Checking[ Eurocode3-2:05 ] Version 8.5.5
==========================================================================================

( ). Check ratio of shear resistance (V_Edy/Vpl_Rdy).


( LCB = 1, POS = I )
-. Applied shear force : V_Edy = 137.95 N.
V_Edy 137.95
-. ------- = --------------- =7.263e-004 < 1.000 ---> O.K.
Vpl_Rdy 189948.24

( ). Calculate plastic shear resistance in local-z direction (Vpl_Rdz).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1, 6.2.6 ]
-. Vpl_Rdz = [ Avz*fy/SQRT(3) ] / Gamma_M0 = 70009.49 N.

( ). Shear Buckling Check.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.2.6 ]
-. HTR < 72*e/Eta ---> No need to check!

( ). Check ratio of shear resistance (V_Edz/Vpl_Rdz).


( LCB = 1, POS = I )
-. Applied shear force : V_Edz = 24043.37 N.
V_Edz 24043.37
-. ------- = --------------- = 0.343 < 1.000 ---> O.K.
Vpl_Rdz 70009.49

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CHECK BENDING MOMENT RESISTANCE ABOUT MAJOR AXIS.
======================================================================================

( ). Calculate plastic resistance moment about major axis.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1, 6.2.5 ]
-. Wply = 74345.0000 mm^3.
-. Mc_Rdy = Wply * fy / Gamma_M0 = 17471075.00 N-mm.

( ). Check ratio of moment resistance (M_Edy/Mc_Rdy).


M_Edy 6788697.11
-. ------ = --------------- = 0.389 < 1.000 ---> O.K.
Mc_Rdy 17471075.00

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CHECK BENDING MOMENT RESISTANCE ABOUT MINOR AXIS.
======================================================================================

( ). Calculate plastic resistance moment about minor axis.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1, 6.2.5 ]
-. Wplz = 35537.5000 mm^3.
-. Mc_Rdz = Wplz * fy / Gamma_M0 = 8351312.50 N-mm.

( ). Check ratio of moment resistance (M_Edz/Mc_Rdz).


M_Edz 86437.78
-. ------ = --------------- = 0.010 < 1.000 ---> O.K.
Mc_Rdz 8351312.50

Modeling, Integrated Design & Analysis Software Print Date/Time : 09/20/2016 09:08
http://www.MidasUser.com
MIDAS/Civil V 8.5.5 - 35 / 94 -
MIDAS/Civil Steel Code Checking Result

PROJECT TITLE : Design of Shutter Box Culvert

Company HDEC Client Reclamation at Tuas Finger One


Author RJT File Name Shutter Box_option 2_sept5.acs

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MIDAS/Civil - Steel Code Checking[ Eurocode3-2:05 ] Version 8.5.5
==========================================================================================

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CHECK LATERAL-TORSIONAL BUCKLING RESISTANCE.
======================================================================================

( ). Calculate lateral-torsional buckling resistance (Mb_Rd).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1, 6.3.2 ]
-. Por = 0.300
-. Gs = Es / [ 2*(1+Por) ] = 80769.231 MPa.
-. Ncr = Pi^2*Es*Izz / Lu^2 = 11972948.68 N.
-. psi = -0.594
-. C1 = 2.788
-. Mcr = C1 * Ncr * SQRT [ (Cwp/Izz) + (Gs*Ixx)/Ncr ] = 1613445199.65 N-mm.

-. Lambda_LT_bar = SQRT [ Wply*fy / Mcr ] = 0.104


-. Lambda_LT_bar0 = 0.200

-. Lambda_LT_bar = 0.104 < Lambda_LT_bar0 = 0.200


-. M_Ed/Mcr = 0.004 < Lambda_LT_bar0^2 = 0.040
If Lambda_LT_bar < Lambda_LT_bar0 or M_Ed/Mcr < Lambda_LT_bar0^2,
No allowance for lateral-torsional buckling necessary.

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CHECK INTERACTION OF COMBINED RESISTANCE.
======================================================================================

( ). Calculate Major reduced design resistance of bending and shear.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.2.8 (6.30) ]
-. In case of V_Edz / Vpl_Rdz < 0.5
-. My_Rd = Mc_Rdy = 17471075.00 N-mm.

( ). Calculate Minor reduced design resistance of bending and shear.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.2.8 (6.30) ]
-. In case of V_Edy / Vpl_Rdy < 0.5
-. Mz_Rd = Mc_Rdz = 8351312.50 N-mm.

( ). Check general interaction ratio.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.2.1 (6.2) ] - Class1 or Class2
N_Ed M_Edy M_Edz
-. Rmax1 = ------ + ------- + -------
N_Rd My_Rd Mz_Rd
= 0.443 < 1.000 ---> O.K.

( ). Check interaction ratio of bending and axial force member.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.2.9 (6.31 ~ 6.41) ] - Class1 or Class2
-. n = N_Ed / Npl_Rd = 0.044
-. a = MIN[ (Area-2b*tf)/Area, 0.5 ] = 0.269
-. Alpha = 2.000
-. Beta = MAX[ 5*n, 1.0 ] = 1.000

Modeling, Integrated Design & Analysis Software Print Date/Time : 09/20/2016 09:08
http://www.MidasUser.com
MIDAS/Civil V 8.5.5 - 36 / 94 -
MIDAS/Civil Steel Code Checking Result

PROJECT TITLE : Design of Shutter Box Culvert

Company HDEC Client Reclamation at Tuas Finger One


Author RJT File Name Shutter Box_option 2_sept5.acs

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MIDAS/Civil - Steel Code Checking[ Eurocode3-2:05 ] Version 8.5.5
==========================================================================================

-. N_Ed < 0.25*Npl_Rd = 112555.64 N.


-. N_Ed < 0.5*hw*tw*fy/Gamma_M0 = 50525.00 N.
Therefore, No allowance for the effect of axial force.
-. Mny_Rd = Mply_Rd = 17471075.00 N-mm.
-. Rmaxy = M_Edy / Mny_Rd = 0.389 < 1.000 ---> O.K.

-. N_Ed < hw*tw*fy/Gamma_M0 = 141470.00 N.


Therefore, No allowance for the effect of axial force.
-. Mnz_Rd = Mplz_Rd = 8351312.50 N-mm.
-. Rmaxz = M_Edz / Mnz_Rd = 0.010 < 1.000 ---> O.K.

[ | M_Edy |^(Alpha) | M_Edz |^(Beta) ]


-. Rmax2 = [ |--------| + |--------| ]
[ | Mny_Rd | | Mnz_Rd | ]
= 0.161 < 1.000 ---> O.K.

( ). Check interaction ratio of bending and axial compression member.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.3.1, 6.2.9.3 (6.61, 6.62), Annex A ]
-. N_Ed = -19786.89 N.
-. M_Edy = -6788697.11 N-mm.
-. M_Edz = -86437.78 N-mm.
-. kyy = 0.845
-. kyz = 0.582
-. kzy = 0.431
-. kzz = 1.293
-. Xiy = 1.000
-. Xiz = 1.000
-. XiLT = 1.000
-. N_Rk = A*fy = 450222.57 N.
-. My_Rk = Wply*fy = 17471075.00 N-mm.
-. Mz_Rk = Wplz*fy = 8351312.50 N-mm.
-. N_Ed*eNy = 0.0 (Not Slender)
-. N_Ed*eNZ = 0.0 (Not Slender)
N_Ed M_Edy + N_Ed*eNy M_Edz + N_Ed*eNz
-. Rmax_LT1 = ----------------- + kyy * ------------------- + kyz * ----------------
Xiy*N_Rk/Gamma_M1 XiLT*My_Rk/Gamma_M1 Mz_Rk/Gamma_M1
= 0.416 < 1.000 ---> O.K.
N_Ed M_Edy + N_Ed*eNy M_Edz + N_Ed*eNz
-. Rmax_LT2 = ----------------- + kzy * ------------------- + kzz * ----------------
Xiz*N_Rk/Gamma_M1 XiLT*My_Rk/Gamma_M1 Mz_Rk/Gamma_M1
= 0.247 < 1.000 ---> O.K.

-. Rmax = MAX[ MAX(Rmax1, Rmax2), MAX(Rmax_LT1, Rmax_LT2) ] = 0.443 < 1.000 --->
O.K.

Modeling, Integrated Design & Analysis Software Print Date/Time : 09/20/2016 09:08
http://www.MidasUser.com
MIDAS/Civil V 8.5.5 - 37 / 94 -
MIDAS/Civil Steel Code Checking Result

PROJECT TITLE : Design of Shutter Box Culvert

Company HDEC Client Reclamation at Tuas Finger One


Author RJT File Name Shutter Box_option 2_sept5.acs

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MIDAS/Civil - Steel Code Checking[ Eurocode3-2:05 ] Version 8.5.5
==========================================================================================

*. PROJECT :
*. MEMBER NO = 775, ELEMENT TYPE = Beam
*. LOADCOMB NO = 1, MATERIAL NO = 1, SECTION NO = 7
*. UNIT SYSTEM : N, mm

*. SECTION PROPERTIES : Designation = H 100x100x5/7


Shape = H - Section. (Built-up)
Depth = 100.000, Top F Width = 100.000, Bot.F Width = 100.000
Web Thick = 5.000, Top F Thick = 7.000, Bot.F Thick = 7.000

Area = 1.91584e+003, Avy = 1.40000e+003, Avz = 5.16000e+002


Ybar = 5.00000e+001, Zbar = 5.00000e+001, Qyb = 7.43450e+003, Qzb = 1.25000e+003
Wely = 6.88169e+004, Welz = 2.33958e+004, Wply = 7.43450e+004, Wplz = 3.55375e+004
Iyy = 3.44085e+006, Izz = 1.16979e+006, Iyz = 0.00000e+000
iy = 4.23792e+001, iz = 2.47101e+001
J = 2.67417e+004, Cwp = 2.52263e+009

*. DESIGN PARAMETERS FOR STRENGTH EVALUATION :


Ly = 9.00000e+002, Lz = 9.00000e+002, Lb = 9.00000e+002
Ky = 1.00000e+000, Kz = 1.00000e+000

*. MATERIAL PROPERTIES :
Fy = 2.35000e+002, Es = 2.10000e+005, MATERIAL NAME = S235

*. FORCES AND MOMENTS AT (J) POINT :


Axial Force Fxx =-1.68279e+005
Shear Forces Fyy = 6.98906e+002, Fzz = 9.54106e+003
Bending Moments My =-5.90110e+006, Mz =-3.05609e+005
End Moments Myi = 1.49322e+006, Myj =-5.90110e+006 (for Lb)
Myi = 1.49322e+006, Myj =-5.90110e+006 (for Ly)
Mzi = 2.36044e+005, Mzj =-3.05609e+005 (for Lz)

*. Sign conventions for stress and axial force.


- Stress : Compression positive.
- Axial force: Tension positive.

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CLASSIFY LEFT-TOP FLANGE OF SECTION (BTR).
======================================================================================

( ). Determine classification of compression outstand flanges.


[ Eurocode3:05 Table 5.2 (Sheet 2 of 3), EN 1993-1-5 ]
-. e = SQRT( 235/fy ) = 1.00
-. b/t = BTR = 5.36
-. sigma1 = 17.061 MPa.
-. sigma2 = 10.611 MPa.
-. BTR < 9*e ( Class 1 : Plastic ).

Modeling, Integrated Design & Analysis Software Print Date/Time : 09/20/2016 09:08
http://www.MidasUser.com
MIDAS/Civil V 8.5.5 - 38 / 94 -
MIDAS/Civil Steel Code Checking Result

PROJECT TITLE : Design of Shutter Box Culvert

Company HDEC Client Reclamation at Tuas Finger One


Author RJT File Name Shutter Box_option 2_sept5.acs

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MIDAS/Civil - Steel Code Checking[ Eurocode3-2:05 ] Version 8.5.5
==========================================================================================

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CLASSIFY RIGHT-TOP FLANGE OF SECTION (BTR).
======================================================================================

( ). Determine classification of tension outstand flanges.


-. Not Checking the Section Classification.

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CLASSIFY LEFT-BOTTOM FLANGE OF SECTION (BTR).
======================================================================================

( ). Determine classification of compression outstand flanges.


[ Eurocode3:05 Table 5.2 (Sheet 2 of 3), EN 1993-1-5 ]
-. e = SQRT( 235/fy ) = 1.00
-. b/t = BTR = 5.36
-. sigma1 = 175.810 MPa.
-. sigma2 = 169.360 MPa.
-. BTR < 9*e ( Class 1 : Plastic ).

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CLASSIFY RIGHT-BOTTOM FLANGE OF SECTION (BTR).
======================================================================================

( ). Determine classification of compression outstand flanges.


[ Eurocode3:05 Table 5.2 (Sheet 2 of 3), EN 1993-1-5 ]
-. e = SQRT( 235/fy ) = 1.00
-. b/t = BTR = 5.36
-. sigma1 = 165.060 MPa.
-. sigma2 = 158.611 MPa.
-. BTR < 9*e ( Class 1 : Plastic ).

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CLASSIFY WEB OF SECTION (HTR).
======================================================================================

( ). Determine classification of compression Internal Parts.


[ Eurocode3:05 Table 5.2 (Sheet 1 of 3), EN 1993-1-5 ]
-. e = SQRT( 235/fy ) = 1.00
-. d/t = HTR = 13.20
-. sigma1 = 140.223 MPa.
-. sigma2 = 35.448 MPa.
-. HTR < 33*e ( Class 1 : Plastic ).

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] APPLIED FACTORS.
======================================================================================

( ). Calculate equivalent uniform moment factors (Cmy,Cmz,CmLT).


[ Eurocode3:05 Annex A. Table A.1, A.2 ]
-. Cmy,0 = 0.733
-. Cmz,0 = 0.605

Modeling, Integrated Design & Analysis Software Print Date/Time : 09/20/2016 09:08
http://www.MidasUser.com
MIDAS/Civil V 8.5.5 - 39 / 94 -
MIDAS/Civil Steel Code Checking Result

PROJECT TITLE : Design of Shutter Box Culvert

Company HDEC Client Reclamation at Tuas Finger One


Author RJT File Name Shutter Box_option 2_sept5.acs

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MIDAS/Civil - Steel Code Checking[ Eurocode3-2:05 ] Version 8.5.5
==========================================================================================

-. Cmy (Default or User Defined Value) = 0.850


-. Cmz (Default or User Defined Value) = 0.850
-. CmLT (Default or User Defined Value) = 1.000

( ). Partial Factors (Gamma_Mi).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1 ]
-. Gamma_M0 = 1.00
-. Gamma_M1 = 1.10
-. Gamma_M2 = 1.25

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CHECK AXIAL RESISTANCE.
======================================================================================

( ). Check slenderness ratio of axial compression member (Kl/i).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.3.1 ]
-. Kl/i = 36.4 < 200.0 ---> O.K.

( ). Calculate axial compressive resistance (Nc_Rd).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1, 6.2.4 ]
-. Nc_Rd = fy * Area / Gamma_M0 = 450222.57 N.

( ). Check ratio of axial resistance (N_Ed/Nc_Rd).


N_Ed 168279.00
-. ----- = --------------- = 0.374 < 1.000 ---> O.K.
Nc_Rd 450222.57

( ). Calculate buckling resistance of compression member (Nb_Rdy, Nb_Rdz).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.3.1.1, 6.3.1.2 ]
-. Beta_A = Aeff / Area = 1.000
-. Lambda1 = Pi * SQRT(Es/fy) = 93.913
-. Lambda_by = {(Ky*Ly/iy)/Lambda1} * SQRT(Beta_A) = 0.226
-. Ncry = Pi^2*Es*Iyy / (Ky*Ly)^2 = 8804393.44 N.
-. Lambda_by < 0.2 or N_Ed/Ncry < 0.04 --> No need to check.

-. Lambda_bz = {(Kz*Lz/iz)/Lambda1} * SQRT(Beta_A) = 0.388


-. Ncrz = Pi^2*Es*Izz / (Kz*Lz)^2 = 2993237.17 N.
-. Lambda_bz > 0.2 and N_Ed/Ncrz > 0.04 --> Need to check.
-. Alphaz = 0.490
-. Phiz = 0.5 * [ 1 + Alphaz*(Lambda_bz-0.2) + Lambda_bz^2 ] = 0.621
-. Xiz = MIN [ 1 / [Phiz + SQRT(Phiz^2 - Lambda_bz^2)], 1.0 ] = 0.904
-. Nb_Rdz = Xiz*Beta_A*Area*fy / Gamma_M1 = 369893.43 N.

( ). Check ratio of buckling resistance (N_Ed/Nb_Rd).


-. Nb_Rd = MIN[ Nb_Rdy, Nb_Rdz ] = 369893.43 N.
N_Ed 168279.00
-. ----- = --------------- = 0.455 < 1.000 ---> O.K.
Nb_Rd 369893.43

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CHECK SHEAR RESISTANCE.
======================================================================================

Modeling, Integrated Design & Analysis Software Print Date/Time : 09/20/2016 09:08
http://www.MidasUser.com
MIDAS/Civil V 8.5.5 - 40 / 94 -
MIDAS/Civil Steel Code Checking Result

PROJECT TITLE : Design of Shutter Box Culvert

Company HDEC Client Reclamation at Tuas Finger One


Author RJT File Name Shutter Box_option 2_sept5.acs

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MIDAS/Civil - Steel Code Checking[ Eurocode3-2:05 ] Version 8.5.5
==========================================================================================

( ). Calculate shear area.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.2.6, EN1993-1-5:04 5.1 NOTE 2 ]
-. eta = 1.2 (Fy < 460 MPa.)
-. Avy = 2*B*tf = 1400.0000 mm^2.
-. Avz = eta*hw*tw = 516.0000 mm^2.

( ). Calculate plastic shear resistance in local-y direction (Vpl_Rdy).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1, 6.2.6 ]
-. Vpl_Rdy = [ Avy*fy/SQRT(3) ] / Gamma_M0 = 189948.24 N.

( ). Check ratio of shear resistance (V_Edy/Vpl_Rdy).


( LCB = 1, POS = J )
-. Applied shear force : V_Edy = 698.91 N.
V_Edy 698.91
-. ------- = --------------- = 0.004 < 1.000 ---> O.K.
Vpl_Rdy 189948.24

( ). Calculate plastic shear resistance in local-z direction (Vpl_Rdz).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1, 6.2.6 ]
-. Vpl_Rdz = [ Avz*fy/SQRT(3) ] / Gamma_M0 = 70009.49 N.

( ). Shear Buckling Check.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.2.6 ]
-. HTR < 72*e/Eta ---> No need to check!

( ). Check ratio of shear resistance (V_Edz/Vpl_Rdz).


( LCB = 1, POS = J )
-. Applied shear force : V_Edz = 9541.06 N.
V_Edz 9541.06
-. ------- = --------------- = 0.136 < 1.000 ---> O.K.
Vpl_Rdz 70009.49

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CHECK BENDING MOMENT RESISTANCE ABOUT MAJOR AXIS.
======================================================================================

( ). Calculate plastic resistance moment about major axis.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1, 6.2.5 ]
-. Wply = 74345.0000 mm^3.
-. Mc_Rdy = Wply * fy / Gamma_M0 = 17471075.00 N-mm.

( ). Check ratio of moment resistance (M_Edy/Mc_Rdy).


M_Edy 5901103.73
-. ------ = --------------- = 0.338 < 1.000 ---> O.K.
Mc_Rdy 17471075.00

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CHECK BENDING MOMENT RESISTANCE ABOUT MINOR AXIS.
======================================================================================

Modeling, Integrated Design & Analysis Software Print Date/Time : 09/20/2016 09:08
http://www.MidasUser.com
MIDAS/Civil V 8.5.5 - 41 / 94 -
MIDAS/Civil Steel Code Checking Result

PROJECT TITLE : Design of Shutter Box Culvert

Company HDEC Client Reclamation at Tuas Finger One


Author RJT File Name Shutter Box_option 2_sept5.acs

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MIDAS/Civil - Steel Code Checking[ Eurocode3-2:05 ] Version 8.5.5
==========================================================================================

( ). Calculate plastic resistance moment about minor axis.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1, 6.2.5 ]
-. Wplz = 35537.5000 mm^3.
-. Mc_Rdz = Wplz * fy / Gamma_M0 = 8351312.50 N-mm.

( ). Check ratio of moment resistance (M_Edz/Mc_Rdz).


M_Edz 305608.55
-. ------ = --------------- = 0.037 < 1.000 ---> O.K.
Mc_Rdz 8351312.50

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CHECK LATERAL-TORSIONAL BUCKLING RESISTANCE.
======================================================================================

( ). Calculate lateral-torsional buckling resistance (Mb_Rd).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1, 6.3.2 ]
-. Por = 0.300
-. Gs = Es / [ 2*(1+Por) ] = 80769.231 MPa.
-. Ncr = Pi^2*Es*Izz / Lu^2 = 2993237.17 N.
-. psi = -0.253
-. C1 = 2.286
-. Mcr = C1 * Ncr * SQRT [ (Cwp/Izz) + (Gs*Ixx)/Ncr ] = 367109858.31 N-mm.

-. Lambda_LT_bar = SQRT [ Wply*fy / Mcr ] = 0.218


-. Lambda_LT_bar0 = 0.200

-. Lambda_LT_bar = 0.218 > Lambda_LT_bar0 = 0.200


-. M_Ed/Mcr = 0.016 < Lambda_LT_bar0^2 = 0.040
If Lambda_LT_bar < Lambda_LT_bar0 or M_Ed/Mcr < Lambda_LT_bar0^2,
No allowance for lateral-torsional buckling necessary.

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CHECK INTERACTION OF COMBINED RESISTANCE.
======================================================================================

( ). Calculate Major reduced design resistance of bending and shear.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.2.8 (6.30) ]
-. In case of V_Edz / Vpl_Rdz < 0.5
-. My_Rd = Mc_Rdy = 17471075.00 N-mm.

( ). Calculate Minor reduced design resistance of bending and shear.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.2.8 (6.30) ]
-. In case of V_Edy / Vpl_Rdy < 0.5
-. Mz_Rd = Mc_Rdz = 8351312.50 N-mm.

Modeling, Integrated Design & Analysis Software Print Date/Time : 09/20/2016 09:08
http://www.MidasUser.com
MIDAS/Civil V 8.5.5 - 42 / 94 -
MIDAS/Civil Steel Code Checking Result

PROJECT TITLE : Design of Shutter Box Culvert

Company HDEC Client Reclamation at Tuas Finger One


Author RJT File Name Shutter Box_option 2_sept5.acs

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MIDAS/Civil - Steel Code Checking[ Eurocode3-2:05 ] Version 8.5.5
==========================================================================================

( ). Check general interaction ratio.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.2.1 (6.2) ] - Class1 or Class2
N_Ed M_Edy M_Edz
-. Rmax1 = ------ + ------- + -------
N_Rd My_Rd Mz_Rd
= 0.748 < 1.000 ---> O.K.

( ). Check interaction ratio of bending and axial force member.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.2.9 (6.31 ~ 6.41) ] - Class1 or Class2
-. n = N_Ed / Npl_Rd = 0.374
-. a = MIN[ (Area-2b*tf)/Area, 0.5 ] = 0.269
-. Alpha = 2.000
-. Beta = MAX[ 5*n, 1.0 ] = 1.869

-. N_Ed > 0.25*Npl_Rd = 112555.64 N.


-. N_Ed > 0.5*hw*tw*fy/Gamma_M0 = 50525.00 N.
Therefore, Allowance for the effect of axial force.
-. Mny_Rd = MIN[ Mply_Rd*(1-n)/(1-0.5*a), Mply_Rd ] = 12643004.53 N-mm.
-. Rmaxy = M_Edy / Mny_Rd = 0.467 < 1.000 ---> O.K.

-. N_Ed > hw*tw*fy/Gamma_M0 = 141470.00 N.


Therefore, Allowance for the effect of axial force.

-. In case of n > a
-. Mnz_Rd = Mplz_Rd * [ 1 - ((n-a)/(1-a))^2 ] = 8180468.04 N-mm.
-. Rmaxz = M_Edz / Mnz_Rd = 0.037 < 1.000 ---> O.K.

[ | M_Edy |^(Alpha) | M_Edz |^(Beta) ]


-. Rmax2 = [ |--------| + |--------| ]
[ | Mny_Rd | | Mnz_Rd | ]
= 0.220 < 1.000 ---> O.K.

( ). Check interaction ratio of bending and axial compression member.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.3.1, 6.2.9.3 (6.61, 6.62), Annex A ]
-. N_Ed = -168279.00 N.
-. M_Edy = -5901103.73 N-mm.
-. M_Edz = -305608.55 N-mm.
-. kyy = 0.828
-. kyz = 0.480
-. kzy = 0.428
-. kzz = 1.360
-. Xiy = 1.000
-. Xiz = 0.904
-. XiLT = 1.000
-. N_Rk = A*fy = 450222.57 N.
-. My_Rk = Wply*fy = 17471075.00 N-mm.
-. Mz_Rk = Wplz*fy = 8351312.50 N-mm.
-. N_Ed*eNy = 0.0 (Not Slender)
-. N_Ed*eNZ = 0.0 (Not Slender)

Modeling, Integrated Design & Analysis Software Print Date/Time : 09/20/2016 09:08
http://www.MidasUser.com
MIDAS/Civil V 8.5.5 - 43 / 94 -
MIDAS/Civil Steel Code Checking Result

PROJECT TITLE : Design of Shutter Box Culvert

Company HDEC Client Reclamation at Tuas Finger One


Author RJT File Name Shutter Box_option 2_sept5.acs

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MIDAS/Civil - Steel Code Checking[ Eurocode3-2:05 ] Version 8.5.5
==========================================================================================

N_Ed M_Edy + N_Ed*eNy M_Edz + N_Ed*eNz


-. Rmax_LT1 = ----------------- + kyy * ------------------- + kyz * ----------------
Xiy*N_Rk/Gamma_M1 XiLT*My_Rk/Gamma_M1 Mz_Rk/Gamma_M1
= 0.738 < 1.000 ---> O.K.
N_Ed M_Edy + N_Ed*eNy M_Edz + N_Ed*eNz
-. Rmax_LT2 = ----------------- + kzy * ------------------- + kzz * ----------------
Xiz*N_Rk/Gamma_M1 XiLT*My_Rk/Gamma_M1 Mz_Rk/Gamma_M1
= 0.669 < 1.000 ---> O.K.

-. Rmax = MAX[ MAX(Rmax1, Rmax2), MAX(Rmax_LT1, Rmax_LT2) ] = 0.748 < 1.000 --->
O.K.

Modeling, Integrated Design & Analysis Software Print Date/Time : 09/20/2016 09:08
http://www.MidasUser.com
MIDAS/Civil V 8.5.5 - 44 / 94 -
MIDAS/Civil Steel Code Checking Result

PROJECT TITLE : Design of Shutter Box Culvert

Company HDEC Client Reclamation at Tuas Finger One


Author RJT File Name Shutter Box_option 2_sept5.acs

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MIDAS/Civil - Steel Code Checking[ Eurocode3-2:05 ] Version 8.5.5
==========================================================================================

*. PROJECT :
*. MEMBER NO = 401, ELEMENT TYPE = Beam
*. LOADCOMB NO = 1, MATERIAL NO = 1, SECTION NO = 8
*. UNIT SYSTEM : N, mm

*. SECTION PROPERTIES : Designation = H 100x100x5/7


Shape = H - Section. (Built-up)
Depth = 100.000, Top F Width = 100.000, Bot.F Width = 100.000
Web Thick = 5.000, Top F Thick = 7.000, Bot.F Thick = 7.000

Area = 1.91584e+003, Avy = 1.40000e+003, Avz = 5.16000e+002


Ybar = 5.00000e+001, Zbar = 5.00000e+001, Qyb = 7.43450e+003, Qzb = 1.25000e+003
Wely = 6.88169e+004, Welz = 2.33958e+004, Wply = 7.43450e+004, Wplz = 3.55375e+004
Iyy = 3.44085e+006, Izz = 1.16979e+006, Iyz = 0.00000e+000
iy = 4.23792e+001, iz = 2.47101e+001
J = 2.67417e+004, Cwp = 2.52263e+009

*. DESIGN PARAMETERS FOR STRENGTH EVALUATION :


Ly = 8.00000e+002, Lz = 8.00000e+002, Lb = 8.00000e+002
Ky = 1.00000e+000, Kz = 1.00000e+000

*. MATERIAL PROPERTIES :
Fy = 2.35000e+002, Es = 2.10000e+005, MATERIAL NAME = S235

*. FORCES AND MOMENTS AT (J) POINT :


Axial Force Fxx =-5.30613e+004
Shear Forces Fyy = 1.46268e+003, Fzz = 3.52328e+003
Bending Moments My =-1.86484e+006, Mz =-4.33664e+005
End Moments Myi = 8.90079e+005, Myj =-1.86484e+006 (for Lb)
Myi = 8.90079e+005, Myj =-1.86484e+006 (for Ly)
Mzi = 7.36482e+005, Mzj =-4.33664e+005 (for Lz)

*. Sign conventions for stress and axial force.


- Stress : Compression positive.
- Axial force: Tension positive.

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CLASSIFY LEFT-TOP FLANGE OF SECTION (BTR).
======================================================================================

( ). Determine classification of compression outstand flanges.


[ Eurocode3:05 Table 5.2 (Sheet 2 of 3), EN 1993-1-5 ]
-. e = SQRT( 235/fy ) = 1.00
-. b/t = BTR = 5.36
-. sigma1 = 14.816 MPa.
-. sigma2 = 5.663 MPa.
-. BTR < 9*e ( Class 1 : Plastic ).

Modeling, Integrated Design & Analysis Software Print Date/Time : 09/20/2016 09:08
http://www.MidasUser.com
MIDAS/Civil V 8.5.5 - 45 / 94 -
MIDAS/Civil Steel Code Checking Result

PROJECT TITLE : Design of Shutter Box Culvert

Company HDEC Client Reclamation at Tuas Finger One


Author RJT File Name Shutter Box_option 2_sept5.acs

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MIDAS/Civil - Steel Code Checking[ Eurocode3-2:05 ] Version 8.5.5
==========================================================================================

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CLASSIFY RIGHT-TOP FLANGE OF SECTION (BTR).
======================================================================================

( ). Determine classification of tension outstand flanges.


-. Not Checking the Section Classification.

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CLASSIFY LEFT-BOTTOM FLANGE OF SECTION (BTR).
======================================================================================

( ). Determine classification of compression outstand flanges.


[ Eurocode3:05 Table 5.2 (Sheet 2 of 3), EN 1993-1-5 ]
-. e = SQRT( 235/fy ) = 1.00
-. b/t = BTR = 5.36
-. sigma1 = 64.983 MPa.
-. sigma2 = 55.830 MPa.
-. BTR < 9*e ( Class 1 : Plastic ).

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CLASSIFY RIGHT-BOTTOM FLANGE OF SECTION (BTR).
======================================================================================

( ). Determine classification of compression outstand flanges.


[ Eurocode3:05 Table 5.2 (Sheet 2 of 3), EN 1993-1-5 ]
-. e = SQRT( 235/fy ) = 1.00
-. b/t = BTR = 5.36
-. sigma1 = 49.729 MPa.
-. sigma2 = 40.577 MPa.
-. BTR < 9*e ( Class 1 : Plastic ).

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CLASSIFY WEB OF SECTION (HTR).
======================================================================================

( ). Determine classification of compression Internal Parts.


[ Eurocode3:05 Table 5.2 (Sheet 1 of 3), EN 1993-1-5 ]
-. e = SQRT( 235/fy ) = 1.00
-. d/t = HTR = 13.20
-. sigma1 = 44.251 MPa.
-. sigma2 = 11.141 MPa.
-. HTR < 33*e ( Class 1 : Plastic ).

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] APPLIED FACTORS.
======================================================================================

( ). Calculate equivalent uniform moment factors (Cmy,Cmz,CmLT).


[ Eurocode3:05 Annex A. Table A.1, A.2 ]
-. Cmy,0 = 0.688
-. Cmz,0 = 0.662

Modeling, Integrated Design & Analysis Software Print Date/Time : 09/20/2016 09:08
http://www.MidasUser.com
MIDAS/Civil V 8.5.5 - 46 / 94 -
MIDAS/Civil Steel Code Checking Result

PROJECT TITLE : Design of Shutter Box Culvert

Company HDEC Client Reclamation at Tuas Finger One


Author RJT File Name Shutter Box_option 2_sept5.acs

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MIDAS/Civil - Steel Code Checking[ Eurocode3-2:05 ] Version 8.5.5
==========================================================================================

-. Cmy (Default or User Defined Value) = 1.000


-. Cmz (Default or User Defined Value) = 1.000
-. CmLT (Default or User Defined Value) = 1.000

( ). Partial Factors (Gamma_Mi).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1 ]
-. Gamma_M0 = 1.00
-. Gamma_M1 = 1.10
-. Gamma_M2 = 1.25

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CHECK AXIAL RESISTANCE.
======================================================================================

( ). Check slenderness ratio of axial compression member (Kl/i).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.3.1 ]
-. Kl/i = 32.4 < 200.0 ---> O.K.

( ). Calculate axial compressive resistance (Nc_Rd).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1, 6.2.4 ]
-. Nc_Rd = fy * Area / Gamma_M0 = 450222.57 N.

( ). Check ratio of axial resistance (N_Ed/Nc_Rd).


N_Ed 53061.27
-. ----- = --------------- = 0.118 < 1.000 ---> O.K.
Nc_Rd 450222.57

( ). Calculate buckling resistance of compression member (Nb_Rdy, Nb_Rdz).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.3.1.1, 6.3.1.2 ]
-. Beta_A = Aeff / Area = 1.000
-. Lambda1 = Pi * SQRT(Es/fy) = 93.913
-. Lambda_by = {(Ky*Ly/iy)/Lambda1} * SQRT(Beta_A) = 0.201
-. Ncry = Pi^2*Es*Iyy / (Ky*Ly)^2 = 11143060.45 N.
-. Lambda_by < 0.2 or N_Ed/Ncry < 0.04 --> No need to check.

-. Lambda_bz = {(Kz*Lz/iz)/Lambda1} * SQRT(Beta_A) = 0.345


-. Ncrz = Pi^2*Es*Izz / (Kz*Lz)^2 = 3788315.79 N.
-. Lambda_bz < 0.2 or N_Ed/Ncrz < 0.04 --> No need to check.

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CHECK SHEAR RESISTANCE.
======================================================================================

( ). Calculate shear area.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.2.6, EN1993-1-5:04 5.1 NOTE 2 ]
-. eta = 1.2 (Fy < 460 MPa.)
-. Avy = 2*B*tf = 1400.0000 mm^2.
-. Avz = eta*hw*tw = 516.0000 mm^2.

( ). Calculate plastic shear resistance in local-y direction (Vpl_Rdy).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1, 6.2.6 ]
-. Vpl_Rdy = [ Avy*fy/SQRT(3) ] / Gamma_M0 = 189948.24 N.

Modeling, Integrated Design & Analysis Software Print Date/Time : 09/20/2016 09:08
http://www.MidasUser.com
MIDAS/Civil V 8.5.5 - 47 / 94 -
MIDAS/Civil Steel Code Checking Result

PROJECT TITLE : Design of Shutter Box Culvert

Company HDEC Client Reclamation at Tuas Finger One


Author RJT File Name Shutter Box_option 2_sept5.acs

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MIDAS/Civil - Steel Code Checking[ Eurocode3-2:05 ] Version 8.5.5
==========================================================================================

( ). Check ratio of shear resistance (V_Edy/Vpl_Rdy).


( LCB = 1, POS = J )
-. Applied shear force : V_Edy = 1462.68 N.
V_Edy 1462.68
-. ------- = --------------- = 0.008 < 1.000 ---> O.K.
Vpl_Rdy 189948.24

( ). Calculate plastic shear resistance in local-z direction (Vpl_Rdz).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1, 6.2.6 ]
-. Vpl_Rdz = [ Avz*fy/SQRT(3) ] / Gamma_M0 = 70009.49 N.

( ). Shear Buckling Check.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.2.6 ]
-. HTR < 72*e/Eta ---> No need to check!

( ). Check ratio of shear resistance (V_Edz/Vpl_Rdz).


( LCB = 1, POS = J )
-. Applied shear force : V_Edz = 3523.28 N.
V_Edz 3523.28
-. ------- = --------------- = 0.050 < 1.000 ---> O.K.
Vpl_Rdz 70009.49

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CHECK BENDING MOMENT RESISTANCE ABOUT MAJOR AXIS.
======================================================================================

( ). Calculate plastic resistance moment about major axis.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1, 6.2.5 ]
-. Wply = 74345.0000 mm^3.
-. Mc_Rdy = Wply * fy / Gamma_M0 = 17471075.00 N-mm.

( ). Check ratio of moment resistance (M_Edy/Mc_Rdy).


M_Edy 1864836.56
-. ------ = --------------- = 0.107 < 1.000 ---> O.K.
Mc_Rdy 17471075.00

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CHECK BENDING MOMENT RESISTANCE ABOUT MINOR AXIS.
======================================================================================

( ). Calculate plastic resistance moment about minor axis.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1, 6.2.5 ]
-. Wplz = 35537.5000 mm^3.
-. Mc_Rdz = Wplz * fy / Gamma_M0 = 8351312.50 N-mm.

( ). Check ratio of moment resistance (M_Edz/Mc_Rdz).


M_Edz 433664.16
-. ------ = --------------- = 0.052 < 1.000 ---> O.K.
Mc_Rdz 8351312.50

Modeling, Integrated Design & Analysis Software Print Date/Time : 09/20/2016 09:08
http://www.MidasUser.com
MIDAS/Civil V 8.5.5 - 48 / 94 -
MIDAS/Civil Steel Code Checking Result

PROJECT TITLE : Design of Shutter Box Culvert

Company HDEC Client Reclamation at Tuas Finger One


Author RJT File Name Shutter Box_option 2_sept5.acs

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MIDAS/Civil - Steel Code Checking[ Eurocode3-2:05 ] Version 8.5.5
==========================================================================================

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CHECK LATERAL-TORSIONAL BUCKLING RESISTANCE.
======================================================================================

( ). Calculate lateral-torsional buckling resistance (Mb_Rd).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1, 6.3.2 ]
-. Por = 0.300
-. Gs = Es / [ 2*(1+Por) ] = 80769.231 MPa.
-. Ncr = Pi^2*Es*Izz / Lu^2 = 3788315.79 N.
-. psi = -0.477
-. C1 = 1.285
-. Mcr = C1 * Ncr * SQRT [ (Cwp/Izz) + (Gs*Ixx)/Ncr ] = 254192290.34 N-mm.

-. Lambda_LT_bar = SQRT [ Wply*fy / Mcr ] = 0.262


-. Lambda_LT_bar0 = 0.200

-. Lambda_LT_bar = 0.262 > Lambda_LT_bar0 = 0.200


-. M_Ed/Mcr = 0.007 < Lambda_LT_bar0^2 = 0.040
If Lambda_LT_bar < Lambda_LT_bar0 or M_Ed/Mcr < Lambda_LT_bar0^2,
No allowance for lateral-torsional buckling necessary.

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CHECK INTERACTION OF COMBINED RESISTANCE.
======================================================================================

( ). Calculate Major reduced design resistance of bending and shear.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.2.8 (6.30) ]
-. In case of V_Edz / Vpl_Rdz < 0.5
-. My_Rd = Mc_Rdy = 17471075.00 N-mm.

( ). Calculate Minor reduced design resistance of bending and shear.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.2.8 (6.30) ]
-. In case of V_Edy / Vpl_Rdy < 0.5
-. Mz_Rd = Mc_Rdz = 8351312.50 N-mm.

( ). Check general interaction ratio.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.2.1 (6.2) ] - Class1 or Class2
N_Ed M_Edy M_Edz
-. Rmax1 = ------ + ------- + -------
N_Rd My_Rd Mz_Rd
= 0.277 < 1.000 ---> O.K.

( ). Check interaction ratio of bending and axial force member.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.2.9 (6.31 ~ 6.41) ] - Class1 or Class2
-. n = N_Ed / Npl_Rd = 0.118
-. a = MIN[ (Area-2b*tf)/Area, 0.5 ] = 0.269
-. Alpha = 2.000
-. Beta = MAX[ 5*n, 1.0 ] = 1.000

Modeling, Integrated Design & Analysis Software Print Date/Time : 09/20/2016 09:08
http://www.MidasUser.com
MIDAS/Civil V 8.5.5 - 49 / 94 -
MIDAS/Civil Steel Code Checking Result

PROJECT TITLE : Design of Shutter Box Culvert

Company HDEC Client Reclamation at Tuas Finger One


Author RJT File Name Shutter Box_option 2_sept5.acs

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MIDAS/Civil - Steel Code Checking[ Eurocode3-2:05 ] Version 8.5.5
==========================================================================================

-. N_Ed < 0.25*Npl_Rd = 112555.64 N.


-. N_Ed > 0.5*hw*tw*fy/Gamma_M0 = 50525.00 N.
Therefore, Allowance for the effect of axial force.
-. Mny_Rd = MIN[ Mply_Rd*(1-n)/(1-0.5*a), Mply_Rd ] = 17471075.00 N-mm.
-. Rmaxy = M_Edy / Mny_Rd = 0.107 < 1.000 ---> O.K.

-. N_Ed < hw*tw*fy/Gamma_M0 = 141470.00 N.


Therefore, No allowance for the effect of axial force.
-. Mnz_Rd = Mplz_Rd = 8351312.50 N-mm.
-. Rmaxz = M_Edz / Mnz_Rd = 0.052 < 1.000 ---> O.K.

[ | M_Edy |^(Alpha) | M_Edz |^(Beta) ]


-. Rmax2 = [ |--------| + |--------| ]
[ | Mny_Rd | | Mnz_Rd | ]
= 0.063 < 1.000 ---> O.K.

( ). Check interaction ratio of bending and axial compression member.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.3.1, 6.2.9.3 (6.61, 6.62), Annex A ]
-. N_Ed = -53061.27 N.
-. M_Edy = -1864836.56 N-mm.
-. M_Edz = -433664.16 N-mm.
-. kyy = 0.991
-. kyz = 0.648
-. kzy = 0.508
-. kzz = 1.175
-. Xiy = 1.000
-. Xiz = 1.000
-. XiLT = 1.000
-. N_Rk = A*fy = 450222.57 N.
-. My_Rk = Wply*fy = 17471075.00 N-mm.
-. Mz_Rk = Wplz*fy = 8351312.50 N-mm.
-. N_Ed*eNy = 0.0 (Not Slender)
-. N_Ed*eNZ = 0.0 (Not Slender)
N_Ed M_Edy + N_Ed*eNy M_Edz + N_Ed*eNz
-. Rmax_LT1 = ----------------- + kyy * ------------------- + kyz * ----------------
Xiy*N_Rk/Gamma_M1 XiLT*My_Rk/Gamma_M1 Mz_Rk/Gamma_M1
= 0.283 < 1.000 ---> O.K.
N_Ed M_Edy + N_Ed*eNy M_Edz + N_Ed*eNz
-. Rmax_LT2 = ----------------- + kzy * ------------------- + kzz * ----------------
Xiz*N_Rk/Gamma_M1 XiLT*My_Rk/Gamma_M1 Mz_Rk/Gamma_M1
= 0.256 < 1.000 ---> O.K.

-. Rmax = MAX[ MAX(Rmax1, Rmax2), MAX(Rmax_LT1, Rmax_LT2) ] = 0.283 < 1.000 --->
O.K.

Modeling, Integrated Design & Analysis Software Print Date/Time : 09/20/2016 09:08
http://www.MidasUser.com
MIDAS/Civil V 8.5.5 - 50 / 94 -
MIDAS/Civil Steel Code Checking Result

PROJECT TITLE : Design of Shutter Box Culvert

Company HDEC Client Reclamation at Tuas Finger One


Author RJT File Name Shutter Box_option 2_sept5.acs

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MIDAS/Civil - Steel Code Checking[ Eurocode3-2:05 ] Version 8.5.5
==========================================================================================

*. PROJECT :
*. MEMBER NO = 851, ELEMENT TYPE = Beam
*. LOADCOMB NO = 1, MATERIAL NO = 1, SECTION NO = 9
*. UNIT SYSTEM : N, mm

*. SECTION PROPERTIES : Designation = H 250x250x12/19


Shape = H - Section. (Built-up)
Depth = 250.000, Top F Width = 250.000, Bot.F Width = 250.000
Web Thick = 12.000, Top F Thick = 19.000, Bot.F Thick = 19.000

Area = 1.22638e+004, Avy = 9.50000e+003, Avz = 3.05280e+003


Ybar = 1.25000e+002, Zbar = 1.25000e+002, Qyb = 5.13368e+004, Qzb = 7.81250e+003
Wely = 1.11083e+006, Welz = 3.96255e+005, Wply = 1.23208e+006, Wplz = 6.01382e+005
Iyy = 1.38854e+008, Izz = 4.95318e+007, Iyz = 0.00000e+000
iy = 1.06406e+002, iz = 6.35522e+001
J = 1.27622e+006, Cwp = 6.60064e+011

*. DESIGN PARAMETERS FOR STRENGTH EVALUATION :


Ly = 1.05000e+003, Lz = 1.05000e+003, Lb = 1.05000e+003
Ky = 1.00000e+000, Kz = 1.00000e+000

*. MATERIAL PROPERTIES :
Fy = 2.35000e+002, Es = 2.10000e+005, MATERIAL NAME = S235

*. FORCES AND MOMENTS AT (I) POINT :


Axial Force Fxx =-1.14366e+004
Shear Forces Fyy = 4.63853e+004, Fzz =-1.26352e+005
Bending Moments My =-1.30420e+008, Mz = 2.35929e+007
End Moments Myi =-1.30420e+008, Myj = 1.54684e+006 (for Lb)
Myi =-1.30420e+008, Myj = 1.54684e+006 (for Ly)
Mzi = 2.35929e+007, Mzj =-2.51116e+007 (for Lz)

*. Sign conventions for stress and axial force.


- Stress : Compression positive.
- Axial force: Tension positive.

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CLASSIFY LEFT-TOP FLANGE OF SECTION (BTR).
======================================================================================

( ). Determine classification of tension outstand flanges.


-. Not Checking the Section Classification.

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CLASSIFY RIGHT-TOP FLANGE OF SECTION (BTR).
======================================================================================

( ). Determine classification of tension outstand flanges.


-. Not Checking the Section Classification.

Modeling, Integrated Design & Analysis Software Print Date/Time : 09/20/2016 09:08
http://www.MidasUser.com
MIDAS/Civil V 8.5.5 - 51 / 94 -
MIDAS/Civil Steel Code Checking Result

PROJECT TITLE : Design of Shutter Box Culvert

Company HDEC Client Reclamation at Tuas Finger One


Author RJT File Name Shutter Box_option 2_sept5.acs

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MIDAS/Civil - Steel Code Checking[ Eurocode3-2:05 ] Version 8.5.5
==========================================================================================

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CLASSIFY LEFT-BOTTOM FLANGE OF SECTION (BTR).
======================================================================================

( ). Determine classification of compression outstand flanges.


[ Eurocode3:05 Table 5.2 (Sheet 2 of 3), EN 1993-1-5 ]
-. e = SQRT( 235/fy ) = 1.00
-. b/t = BTR = 5.42
-. sigma1 = 99.881 MPa.
-. sigma2 = 67.555 MPa.
-. BTR < 9*e ( Class 1 : Plastic ).

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CLASSIFY RIGHT-BOTTOM FLANGE OF SECTION (BTR).
======================================================================================

( ). Determine classification of compression outstand flanges.


[ Eurocode3:05 Table 5.2 (Sheet 2 of 3), EN 1993-1-5 ]
-. e = SQRT( 235/fy ) = 1.00
-. b/t = BTR = 5.42
-. sigma1 = 146.017 MPa.
-. sigma2 = 113.691 MPa.
-. BTR < 9*e ( Class 1 : Plastic ).

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CLASSIFY WEB OF SECTION (HTR).
======================================================================================

( ). Determine classification of bending and compression Internal Parts.


[ Eurocode3:05 Table 5.2 (Sheet 1 of 3), EN 1993-1-5 ]
-. e = SQRT( 235/fy ) = 1.00
-. d/t = HTR = 15.00
-. sigma1 = 77.147 MPa.
-. sigma2 = -75.282 MPa.
-. Psi = [2*(Nsd/A)*(1/fy)]-1 = -0.992
-. Alpha = 0.511 > 0.5
-. HTR < 396*e/(13*Alpha-1) ( Class 1 : Plastic ).

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] APPLIED FACTORS.
======================================================================================

( ). Calculate equivalent uniform moment factors (Cmy,Cmz,CmLT).


[ Eurocode3:05 Annex A. Table A.1, A.2 ]
-. Cmy,0 = 0.788
-. Cmz,0 = 0.593
-. Cmy (Default or User Defined Value) = 1.000
-. Cmz (Default or User Defined Value) = 1.000
-. CmLT (Default or User Defined Value) = 1.000

Modeling, Integrated Design & Analysis Software Print Date/Time : 09/20/2016 09:08
http://www.MidasUser.com
MIDAS/Civil V 8.5.5 - 52 / 94 -
MIDAS/Civil Steel Code Checking Result

PROJECT TITLE : Design of Shutter Box Culvert

Company HDEC Client Reclamation at Tuas Finger One


Author RJT File Name Shutter Box_option 2_sept5.acs

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MIDAS/Civil - Steel Code Checking[ Eurocode3-2:05 ] Version 8.5.5
==========================================================================================

( ). Partial Factors (Gamma_Mi).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1 ]
-. Gamma_M0 = 1.00
-. Gamma_M1 = 1.10
-. Gamma_M2 = 1.25

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CHECK AXIAL RESISTANCE.
======================================================================================

( ). Check slenderness ratio of axial compression member (Kl/i).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.3.1 ]
-. Kl/i = 16.5 < 200.0 ---> O.K.

( ). Calculate axial compressive resistance (Nc_Rd).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1, 6.2.4 ]
-. Nc_Rd = fy * Area / Gamma_M0 = 2881981.79 N.

( ). Check ratio of axial resistance (N_Ed/Nc_Rd).


N_Ed 11436.56
-. ----- = --------------- = 0.004 < 1.000 ---> O.K.
Nc_Rd 2881981.79

( ). Calculate buckling resistance of compression member (Nb_Rdy, Nb_Rdz).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.3.1.1, 6.3.1.2 ]
-. Beta_A = Aeff / Area = 1.000
-. Lambda1 = Pi * SQRT(Es/fy) = 93.913
-. Lambda_by = {(Ky*Ly/iy)/Lambda1} * SQRT(Beta_A) = 0.105
-. Ncry = Pi^2*Es*Iyy / (Ky*Ly)^2 = 261034480.26 N.
-. Lambda_by < 0.2 or N_Ed/Ncry < 0.04 --> No need to check.

-. Lambda_bz = {(Kz*Lz/iz)/Lambda1} * SQRT(Beta_A) = 0.176


-. Ncrz = Pi^2*Es*Izz / (Kz*Lz)^2 = 93116081.25 N.
-. Lambda_bz < 0.2 or N_Ed/Ncrz < 0.04 --> No need to check.

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CHECK SHEAR RESISTANCE.
======================================================================================

( ). Calculate shear area.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.2.6, EN1993-1-5:04 5.1 NOTE 2 ]
-. eta = 1.2 (Fy < 460 MPa.)
-. Avy = 2*B*tf = 9500.0000 mm^2.
-. Avz = eta*hw*tw = 3052.8000 mm^2.

( ). Calculate plastic shear resistance in local-y direction (Vpl_Rdy).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1, 6.2.6 ]
-. Vpl_Rdy = [ Avy*fy/SQRT(3) ] / Gamma_M0 = 1288934.48 N.

Modeling, Integrated Design & Analysis Software Print Date/Time : 09/20/2016 09:08
http://www.MidasUser.com
MIDAS/Civil V 8.5.5 - 53 / 94 -
MIDAS/Civil Steel Code Checking Result

PROJECT TITLE : Design of Shutter Box Culvert

Company HDEC Client Reclamation at Tuas Finger One


Author RJT File Name Shutter Box_option 2_sept5.acs

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MIDAS/Civil - Steel Code Checking[ Eurocode3-2:05 ] Version 8.5.5
==========================================================================================

( ). Check ratio of shear resistance (V_Edy/Vpl_Rdy).


( LCB = 1, POS = I )
-. Applied shear force : V_Edy = 46385.26 N.
V_Edy 46385.26
-. ------- = --------------- = 0.036 < 1.000 ---> O.K.
Vpl_Rdy 1288934.48

( ). Calculate plastic shear resistance in local-z direction (Vpl_Rdz).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1, 6.2.6 ]
-. Vpl_Rdz = [ Avz*fy/SQRT(3) ] / Gamma_M0 = 414195.70 N.

( ). Shear Buckling Check.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.2.6 ]
-. HTR < 72*e/Eta ---> No need to check!

( ). Check ratio of shear resistance (V_Edz/Vpl_Rdz).


( LCB = 1, POS = I )
-. Applied shear force : V_Edz = 126351.87 N.
V_Edz 126351.87
-. ------- = --------------- = 0.305 < 1.000 ---> O.K.
Vpl_Rdz 414195.70

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CHECK BENDING MOMENT RESISTANCE ABOUT MAJOR AXIS.
======================================================================================

( ). Calculate plastic resistance moment about major axis.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1, 6.2.5 ]
-. Wply = 1232082.0000 mm^3.
-. Mc_Rdy = Wply * fy / Gamma_M0 = 289539270.00 N-mm.

( ). Check ratio of moment resistance (M_Edy/Mc_Rdy).


M_Edy 130420064.26
-. ------ = --------------- = 0.450 < 1.000 ---> O.K.
Mc_Rdy 289539270.00

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CHECK BENDING MOMENT RESISTANCE ABOUT MINOR AXIS.
======================================================================================

( ). Calculate plastic resistance moment about minor axis.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1, 6.2.5 ]
-. Wplz = 601382.0000 mm^3.
-. Mc_Rdz = Wplz * fy / Gamma_M0 = 141324770.00 N-mm.

( ). Check ratio of moment resistance (M_Edz/Mc_Rdz).


M_Edz 23592871.93
-. ------ = --------------- = 0.167 < 1.000 ---> O.K.
Mc_Rdz 141324770.00

Modeling, Integrated Design & Analysis Software Print Date/Time : 09/20/2016 09:08
http://www.MidasUser.com
MIDAS/Civil V 8.5.5 - 54 / 94 -
MIDAS/Civil Steel Code Checking Result

PROJECT TITLE : Design of Shutter Box Culvert

Company HDEC Client Reclamation at Tuas Finger One


Author RJT File Name Shutter Box_option 2_sept5.acs

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MIDAS/Civil - Steel Code Checking[ Eurocode3-2:05 ] Version 8.5.5
==========================================================================================

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CHECK LATERAL-TORSIONAL BUCKLING RESISTANCE.
======================================================================================

( ). Calculate lateral-torsional buckling resistance (Mb_Rd).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1, 6.3.2 ]
-. Por = 0.300
-. Gs = Es / [ 2*(1+Por) ] = 80769.231 MPa.
-. Ncr = Pi^2*Es*Izz / Lu^2 = 93116081.25 N.
-. psi = -0.012
-. C1 = 1.285
-. Mcr = C1 * Ncr * SQRT [ (Cwp/Izz) + (Gs*Ixx)/Ncr ] =14374977828.21 N-mm.

-. Lambda_LT_bar = SQRT [ Wply*fy / Mcr ] = 0.142


-. Lambda_LT_bar0 = 0.200

-. Lambda_LT_bar = 0.142 < Lambda_LT_bar0 = 0.200


-. M_Ed/Mcr = 0.009 < Lambda_LT_bar0^2 = 0.040
If Lambda_LT_bar < Lambda_LT_bar0 or M_Ed/Mcr < Lambda_LT_bar0^2,
No allowance for lateral-torsional buckling necessary.

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CHECK INTERACTION OF COMBINED RESISTANCE.
======================================================================================

( ). Calculate Major reduced design resistance of bending and shear.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.2.8 (6.30) ]
-. In case of V_Edz / Vpl_Rdz < 0.5
-. My_Rd = Mc_Rdy = 289539270.00 N-mm.

( ). Calculate Minor reduced design resistance of bending and shear.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.2.8 (6.30) ]
-. In case of V_Edy / Vpl_Rdy < 0.5
-. Mz_Rd = Mc_Rdz = 141324770.00 N-mm.

( ). Check general interaction ratio.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.2.1 (6.2) ] - Class1 or Class2
N_Ed M_Edy M_Edz
-. Rmax1 = ------ + ------- + -------
N_Rd My_Rd Mz_Rd
= 0.621 < 1.000 ---> O.K.

( ). Check interaction ratio of bending and axial force member.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.2.9 (6.31 ~ 6.41) ] - Class1 or Class2
-. n = N_Ed / Npl_Rd = 0.004
-. a = MIN[ (Area-2b*tf)/Area, 0.5 ] = 0.225
-. Alpha = 2.000
-. Beta = MAX[ 5*n, 1.0 ] = 1.000

Modeling, Integrated Design & Analysis Software Print Date/Time : 09/20/2016 09:08
http://www.MidasUser.com
MIDAS/Civil V 8.5.5 - 55 / 94 -
MIDAS/Civil Steel Code Checking Result

PROJECT TITLE : Design of Shutter Box Culvert

Company HDEC Client Reclamation at Tuas Finger One


Author RJT File Name Shutter Box_option 2_sept5.acs

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MIDAS/Civil - Steel Code Checking[ Eurocode3-2:05 ] Version 8.5.5
==========================================================================================

-. N_Ed < 0.25*Npl_Rd = 720495.45 N.


-. N_Ed < 0.5*hw*tw*fy/Gamma_M0 = 298920.00 N.
Therefore, No allowance for the effect of axial force.
-. Mny_Rd = Mply_Rd = 289539270.00 N-mm.
-. Rmaxy = M_Edy / Mny_Rd = 0.450 < 1.000 ---> O.K.

-. N_Ed < hw*tw*fy/Gamma_M0 = 946580.00 N.


Therefore, No allowance for the effect of axial force.
-. Mnz_Rd = Mplz_Rd = 141324770.00 N-mm.
-. Rmaxz = M_Edz / Mnz_Rd = 0.167 < 1.000 ---> O.K.

[ | M_Edy |^(Alpha) | M_Edz |^(Beta) ]


-. Rmax2 = [ |--------| + |--------| ]
[ | Mny_Rd | | Mnz_Rd | ]
= 0.370 < 1.000 ---> O.K.

( ). Check interaction ratio of bending and axial compression member.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.3.1, 6.2.9.3 (6.61, 6.62), Annex A ]
-. N_Ed = -11436.56 N.
-. M_Edy = -130420064.26 N-mm.
-. M_Edz = 23592871.93 N-mm.
-. kyy = 0.999
-. kyz = 0.703
-. kzy = 0.529
-. kzz = 1.518
-. Xiy = 1.000
-. Xiz = 1.000
-. XiLT = 1.000
-. N_Rk = A*fy = 2881981.79 N.
-. My_Rk = Wply*fy = 289539270.00 N-mm.
-. Mz_Rk = Wplz*fy = 141324770.00 N-mm.
-. N_Ed*eNy = 0.0 (Not Slender)
-. N_Ed*eNZ = 0.0 (Not Slender)
N_Ed M_Edy + N_Ed*eNy M_Edz + N_Ed*eNz
-. Rmax_LT1 = ----------------- + kyy * ------------------- + kyz * ----------------
Xiy*N_Rk/Gamma_M1 XiLT*My_Rk/Gamma_M1 Mz_Rk/Gamma_M1
= 0.629 < 1.000 ---> O.K.
N_Ed M_Edy + N_Ed*eNy M_Edz + N_Ed*eNz
-. Rmax_LT2 = ----------------- + kzy * ------------------- + kzz * ----------------
Xiz*N_Rk/Gamma_M1 XiLT*My_Rk/Gamma_M1 Mz_Rk/Gamma_M1
= 0.545 < 1.000 ---> O.K.

-. Rmax = MAX[ MAX(Rmax1, Rmax2), MAX(Rmax_LT1, Rmax_LT2) ] = 0.629 < 1.000 --->
O.K.

Modeling, Integrated Design & Analysis Software Print Date/Time : 09/20/2016 09:08
http://www.MidasUser.com
MIDAS/Civil V 8.5.5 - 56 / 94 -
MIDAS/Civil Steel Code Checking Result

PROJECT TITLE : Design of Shutter Box Culvert

Company HDEC Client Reclamation at Tuas Finger One


Author RJT File Name Shutter Box_option 2_sept5.acs

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MIDAS/Civil - Steel Code Checking[ Eurocode3-2:05 ] Version 8.5.5
==========================================================================================

*. PROJECT :
*. MEMBER NO = 96, ELEMENT TYPE = Beam
*. LOADCOMB NO = 1, MATERIAL NO = 1, SECTION NO = 10
*. UNIT SYSTEM : N, mm

*. SECTION PROPERTIES : Designation = H 200x200x8/12


Shape = H - Section. (Rolled)
Depth = 200.000, Top F Width = 200.000, Bot.F Width = 200.000
Web Thick = 8.000, Top F Thick = 12.000, Bot.F Thick = 12.000

Area = 6.35300e+003, Avy = 4.94500e+003, Avz = 1.96100e+003


Ybar = 1.00000e+002, Zbar = 1.00000e+002, Qyb = 3.20720e+004, Qzb = 5.00000e+003
Wely = 4.72000e+005, Welz = 1.60000e+005, Wply = 5.26000e+005, Wplz = 2.44000e+005
Iyy = 4.72000e+007, Izz = 1.60000e+007, Iyz = 0.00000e+000
iy = 8.62000e+001, iz = 5.02000e+001
J = 2.60000e+005, Cwp = 1.41000e+011

*. DESIGN PARAMETERS FOR STRENGTH EVALUATION :


Ly = 3.44000e+002, Lz = 3.44000e+002, Lb = 3.44000e+002
Ky = 1.00000e+000, Kz = 1.00000e+000

*. MATERIAL PROPERTIES :
Fy = 2.35000e+002, Es = 2.10000e+005, MATERIAL NAME = S235

*. FORCES AND MOMENTS AT (I) POINT :


Axial Force Fxx =-7.74041e+004
Shear Forces Fyy =-3.87781e+001, Fzz = 3.41895e+004
Bending Moments My = 2.36501e+007, Mz =-9.83766e+004
End Moments Myi = 2.36501e+007, Myj = 1.18499e+007 (for Lb)
Myi = 2.36501e+007, Myj = 1.18499e+007 (for Ly)
Mzi =-9.83766e+004, Mzj =-8.50369e+004 (for Lz)

*. Sign conventions for stress and axial force.


- Stress : Compression positive.
- Axial force: Tension positive.

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CLASSIFY LEFT-TOP FLANGE OF SECTION (BTR).
======================================================================================

( ). Determine classification of compression outstand flanges.


[ Eurocode3:05 Table 5.2 (Sheet 2 of 3), EN 1993-1-5 ]
-. e = SQRT( 235/fy ) = 1.00
-. b/t = BTR = 6.92
-. sigma1 = 57.549 MPa.
-. sigma2 = 57.215 MPa.
-. BTR < 9*e ( Class 1 : Plastic ).

Modeling, Integrated Design & Analysis Software Print Date/Time : 09/20/2016 09:08
http://www.MidasUser.com
MIDAS/Civil V 8.5.5 - 57 / 94 -
MIDAS/Civil Steel Code Checking Result

PROJECT TITLE : Design of Shutter Box Culvert

Company HDEC Client Reclamation at Tuas Finger One


Author RJT File Name Shutter Box_option 2_sept5.acs

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MIDAS/Civil - Steel Code Checking[ Eurocode3-2:05 ] Version 8.5.5
==========================================================================================

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CLASSIFY RIGHT-TOP FLANGE OF SECTION (BTR).
======================================================================================

( ). Determine classification of compression outstand flanges.


[ Eurocode3:05 Table 5.2 (Sheet 2 of 3), EN 1993-1-5 ]
-. e = SQRT( 235/fy ) = 1.00
-. b/t = BTR = 6.92
-. sigma1 = 57.078 MPa.
-. sigma2 = 56.743 MPa.
-. BTR < 9*e ( Class 1 : Plastic ).

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CLASSIFY LEFT-BOTTOM FLANGE OF SECTION (BTR).
======================================================================================

( ). Determine classification of tension outstand flanges.


-. Not Checking the Section Classification.

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CLASSIFY RIGHT-BOTTOM FLANGE OF SECTION (BTR).
======================================================================================

( ). Determine classification of tension outstand flanges.


-. Not Checking the Section Classification.

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CLASSIFY WEB OF SECTION (HTR).
======================================================================================

( ). Determine classification of bending and compression Internal Parts.


[ Eurocode3:05 Table 5.2 (Sheet 1 of 3), EN 1993-1-5 ]
-. e = SQRT( 235/fy ) = 1.00
-. d/t = HTR = 18.75
-. sigma1 = 45.906 MPa.
-. sigma2 = -21.538 MPa.
-. Psi = [2*(Nsd/A)*(1/fy)]-1 = -0.896
-. Alpha = 0.637 > 0.5
-. HTR < 396*e/(13*Alpha-1) ( Class 1 : Plastic ).

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] APPLIED FACTORS.
======================================================================================

( ). Calculate equivalent uniform moment factors (Cmy,Cmz,CmLT).


[ Eurocode3:05 Annex A. Table A.1, A.2 ]
-. Cmy,0 = 0.895
-. Cmz,0 = 0.972
-. Cmy (Default or User Defined Value) = 1.000
-. Cmz (Default or User Defined Value) = 1.000
-. CmLT (Default or User Defined Value) = 1.000

Modeling, Integrated Design & Analysis Software Print Date/Time : 09/20/2016 09:08
http://www.MidasUser.com
MIDAS/Civil V 8.5.5 - 58 / 94 -
MIDAS/Civil Steel Code Checking Result

PROJECT TITLE : Design of Shutter Box Culvert

Company HDEC Client Reclamation at Tuas Finger One


Author RJT File Name Shutter Box_option 2_sept5.acs

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MIDAS/Civil - Steel Code Checking[ Eurocode3-2:05 ] Version 8.5.5
==========================================================================================

( ). Partial Factors (Gamma_Mi).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1 ]
-. Gamma_M0 = 1.00
-. Gamma_M1 = 1.10
-. Gamma_M2 = 1.25

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CHECK AXIAL RESISTANCE.
======================================================================================

( ). Check slenderness ratio of axial compression member (Kl/i).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.3.1 ]
-. Kl/i = 6.9 < 200.0 ---> O.K.

( ). Calculate axial compressive resistance (Nc_Rd).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1, 6.2.4 ]
-. Nc_Rd = fy * Area / Gamma_M0 = 1492955.00 N.

( ). Check ratio of axial resistance (N_Ed/Nc_Rd).


N_Ed 77404.14
-. ----- = --------------- = 0.052 < 1.000 ---> O.K.
Nc_Rd 1492955.00

( ). Calculate buckling resistance of compression member (Nb_Rdy, Nb_Rdz).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.3.1.1, 6.3.1.2 ]
-. Beta_A = Aeff / Area = 1.000
-. Lambda1 = Pi * SQRT(Es/fy) = 93.913
-. Lambda_by = {(Ky*Ly/iy)/Lambda1} * SQRT(Beta_A) = 0.042
-. Ncry = Pi^2*Es*Iyy / (Ky*Ly)^2 = 826692796.98 N.
-. Lambda_by < 0.2 or N_Ed/Ncry < 0.04 --> No need to check.

-. Lambda_bz = {(Kz*Lz/iz)/Lambda1} * SQRT(Beta_A) = 0.073


-. Ncrz = Pi^2*Es*Izz / (Kz*Lz)^2 = 280234846.43 N.
-. Lambda_bz < 0.2 or N_Ed/Ncrz < 0.04 --> No need to check.

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CHECK SHEAR RESISTANCE.
======================================================================================

( ). Calculate shear area.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.2.6, EN1993-1-5:04 5.1 NOTE 2 ]
-. eta = 1.2 (Fy < 460 MPa.)
-. r = 13.0000 mm.
-. Avy = Area - hw*tw = 4945.0000 mm^2.
-. Avz1 = eta*hw*tw = 1689.6000 mm^2.
-. Avz2 = Area - 2*B*tf + (tw + 2*r)*tf = 1961.0000 mm^2.
-. Avz = MAX[ Avz1, Avz2 ] = 1961.0000 mm^2.

( ). Calculate plastic shear resistance in local-y direction (Vpl_Rdy).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1, 6.2.6 ]
-. Vpl_Rdy = [ Avy*fy/SQRT(3) ] / Gamma_M0 = 670924.31 N.

Modeling, Integrated Design & Analysis Software Print Date/Time : 09/20/2016 09:08
http://www.MidasUser.com
MIDAS/Civil V 8.5.5 - 59 / 94 -
MIDAS/Civil Steel Code Checking Result

PROJECT TITLE : Design of Shutter Box Culvert

Company HDEC Client Reclamation at Tuas Finger One


Author RJT File Name Shutter Box_option 2_sept5.acs

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MIDAS/Civil - Steel Code Checking[ Eurocode3-2:05 ] Version 8.5.5
==========================================================================================

( ). Check ratio of shear resistance (V_Edy/Vpl_Rdy).


( LCB = 2, POS = J )
-. Applied shear force : V_Edy = 40.84 N.
V_Edy 40.84
-. ------- = --------------- =6.087e-005 < 1.000 ---> O.K.
Vpl_Rdy 670924.31

( ). Calculate plastic shear resistance in local-z direction (Vpl_Rdz).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1, 6.2.6 ]
-. Vpl_Rdz = [ Avz*fy/SQRT(3) ] / Gamma_M0 = 266063.21 N.

( ). Shear Buckling Check.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.2.6 ]
-. HTR < 72*e/Eta ---> No need to check!

( ). Check ratio of shear resistance (V_Edz/Vpl_Rdz).


( LCB = 1, POS = J )
-. Applied shear force : V_Edz = 34416.66 N.
V_Edz 34416.66
-. ------- = --------------- = 0.129 < 1.000 ---> O.K.
Vpl_Rdz 266063.21

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CHECK BENDING MOMENT RESISTANCE ABOUT MAJOR AXIS.
======================================================================================

( ). Calculate plastic resistance moment about major axis.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1, 6.2.5 ]
-. Wply = 526000.0000 mm^3.
-. Mc_Rdy = Wply * fy / Gamma_M0 = 123610000.00 N-mm.

( ). Check ratio of moment resistance (M_Edy/Mc_Rdy).


M_Edy 23650140.03
-. ------ = --------------- = 0.191 < 1.000 ---> O.K.
Mc_Rdy 123610000.00

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CHECK BENDING MOMENT RESISTANCE ABOUT MINOR AXIS.
======================================================================================

( ). Calculate plastic resistance moment about minor axis.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1, 6.2.5 ]
-. Wplz = 244000.0000 mm^3.
-. Mc_Rdz = Wplz * fy / Gamma_M0 = 57340000.00 N-mm.

( ). Check ratio of moment resistance (M_Edz/Mc_Rdz).


M_Edz 98376.58
-. ------ = --------------- = 0.002 < 1.000 ---> O.K.
Mc_Rdz 57340000.00

Modeling, Integrated Design & Analysis Software Print Date/Time : 09/20/2016 09:08
http://www.MidasUser.com
MIDAS/Civil V 8.5.5 - 60 / 94 -
MIDAS/Civil Steel Code Checking Result

PROJECT TITLE : Design of Shutter Box Culvert

Company HDEC Client Reclamation at Tuas Finger One


Author RJT File Name Shutter Box_option 2_sept5.acs

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MIDAS/Civil - Steel Code Checking[ Eurocode3-2:05 ] Version 8.5.5
==========================================================================================

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CHECK LATERAL-TORSIONAL BUCKLING RESISTANCE.
======================================================================================

( ). Calculate lateral-torsional buckling resistance (Mb_Rd).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1, 6.3.2 ]
-. Por = 0.300
-. Gs = Es / [ 2*(1+Por) ] = 80769.231 MPa.
-. Ncr = Pi^2*Es*Izz / Lu^2 = 280234846.43 N.
-. psi = 0.501
-. C1 = 1.285
-. Mcr = C1 * Ncr * SQRT [ (Cwp/Izz) + (Gs*Ixx)/Ncr ] =33947948642.90 N-mm.

-. Lambda_LT_bar = SQRT [ Wply*fy / Mcr ] = 0.060


-. Lambda_LT_bar0 = 0.200

-. Lambda_LT_bar = 0.060 < Lambda_LT_bar0 = 0.200


-. M_Ed/Mcr = 6.967e-004 < Lambda_LT_bar0^2 = 0.040
If Lambda_LT_bar < Lambda_LT_bar0 or M_Ed/Mcr < Lambda_LT_bar0^2,
No allowance for lateral-torsional buckling necessary.

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CHECK INTERACTION OF COMBINED RESISTANCE.
======================================================================================

( ). Calculate Major reduced design resistance of bending and shear.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.2.8 (6.30) ]
-. In case of V_Edz / Vpl_Rdz < 0.5
-. My_Rd = Mc_Rdy = 123610000.00 N-mm.

( ). Calculate Minor reduced design resistance of bending and shear.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.2.8 (6.30) ]
-. In case of V_Edy / Vpl_Rdy < 0.5
-. Mz_Rd = Mc_Rdz = 57340000.00 N-mm.

( ). Check general interaction ratio.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.2.1 (6.2) ] - Class1 or Class2
N_Ed M_Edy M_Edz
-. Rmax1 = ------ + ------- + -------
N_Rd My_Rd Mz_Rd
= 0.245 < 1.000 ---> O.K.

( ). Check interaction ratio of bending and axial force member.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.2.9 (6.31 ~ 6.41) ] - Class1 or Class2
-. n = N_Ed / Npl_Rd = 0.052
-. a = MIN[ (Area-2b*tf)/Area, 0.5 ] = 0.244
-. Alpha = 2.000
-. Beta = MAX[ 5*n, 1.0 ] = 1.000

Modeling, Integrated Design & Analysis Software Print Date/Time : 09/20/2016 09:08
http://www.MidasUser.com
MIDAS/Civil V 8.5.5 - 61 / 94 -
MIDAS/Civil Steel Code Checking Result

PROJECT TITLE : Design of Shutter Box Culvert

Company HDEC Client Reclamation at Tuas Finger One


Author RJT File Name Shutter Box_option 2_sept5.acs

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MIDAS/Civil - Steel Code Checking[ Eurocode3-2:05 ] Version 8.5.5
==========================================================================================

-. N_Ed < 0.25*Npl_Rd = 373238.75 N.


-. N_Ed < 0.5*hw*tw*fy/Gamma_M0 = 165440.00 N.
Therefore, No allowance for the effect of axial force.
-. Mny_Rd = Mply_Rd = 123610000.00 N-mm.
-. Rmaxy = M_Edy / Mny_Rd = 0.191 < 1.000 ---> O.K.

-. N_Ed < hw*tw*fy/Gamma_M0 = 496320.00 N.


Therefore, No allowance for the effect of axial force.
-. Mnz_Rd = Mplz_Rd = 57340000.00 N-mm.
-. Rmaxz = M_Edz / Mnz_Rd = 0.002 < 1.000 ---> O.K.

[ | M_Edy |^(Alpha) | M_Edz |^(Beta) ]


-. Rmax2 = [ |--------| + |--------| ]
[ | Mny_Rd | | Mnz_Rd | ]
= 0.038 < 1.000 ---> O.K.

( ). Check interaction ratio of bending and axial compression member.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.3.1, 6.2.9.3 (6.61, 6.62), Annex A ]
-. N_Ed = -77404.14 N.
-. M_Edy = 23650140.03 N-mm.
-. M_Edz = -98376.58 N-mm.
-. kyy = 0.988
-. kyz = 0.659
-. kzy = 0.511
-. kzz = 1.060
-. Xiy = 1.000
-. Xiz = 1.000
-. XiLT = 1.000
-. N_Rk = A*fy = 1492955.00 N.
-. My_Rk = Wply*fy = 123610000.00 N-mm.
-. Mz_Rk = Wplz*fy = 57340000.00 N-mm.
-. N_Ed*eNy = 0.0 (Not Slender)
-. N_Ed*eNZ = 0.0 (Not Slender)
N_Ed M_Edy + N_Ed*eNy M_Edz + N_Ed*eNz
-. Rmax_LT1 = ----------------- + kyy * ------------------- + kyz * ----------------
Xiy*N_Rk/Gamma_M1 XiLT*My_Rk/Gamma_M1 Mz_Rk/Gamma_M1
= 0.266 < 1.000 ---> O.K.
N_Ed M_Edy + N_Ed*eNy M_Edz + N_Ed*eNz
-. Rmax_LT2 = ----------------- + kzy * ------------------- + kzz * ----------------
Xiz*N_Rk/Gamma_M1 XiLT*My_Rk/Gamma_M1 Mz_Rk/Gamma_M1
= 0.167 < 1.000 ---> O.K.

-. Rmax = MAX[ MAX(Rmax1, Rmax2), MAX(Rmax_LT1, Rmax_LT2) ] = 0.266 < 1.000 --->
O.K.

Modeling, Integrated Design & Analysis Software Print Date/Time : 09/20/2016 09:08
http://www.MidasUser.com
MIDAS/Civil V 8.5.5 - 62 / 94 -
MIDAS/Civil Steel Code Checking Result

PROJECT TITLE : Design of Shutter Box Culvert

Company HDEC Client Reclamation at Tuas Finger One


Author RJT File Name Shutter Box_option 2_sept5.acs

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MIDAS/Civil - Steel Code Checking[ Eurocode3-2:05 ] Version 8.5.5
==========================================================================================

*. PROJECT :
*. MEMBER NO = 803, ELEMENT TYPE = Beam
*. LOADCOMB NO = 1, MATERIAL NO = 1, SECTION NO = 11
*. UNIT SYSTEM : N, mm

*. SECTION PROPERTIES : Designation = H 250x250x9/14


Shape = H - Section. (Rolled)
Depth = 250.000, Top F Width = 250.000, Bot.F Width = 250.000
Web Thick = 9.000, Top F Thick = 14.000, Bot.F Thick = 14.000

Area = 9.21800e+003, Avy = 7.22000e+003, Avz = 2.79200e+003


Ybar = 1.25000e+002, Zbar = 1.25000e+002, Qyb = 5.20494e+004, Qzb = 7.81250e+003
Wely = 8.67000e+005, Welz = 2.92000e+005, Wply = 9.61000e+005, Wplz = 4.44000e+005
Iyy = 1.08000e+008, Izz = 3.65000e+007, Iyz = 0.00000e+000
iy = 1.08000e+002, iz = 6.29000e+001
J = 5.11000e+005, Cwp = 5.08000e+011

*. DESIGN PARAMETERS FOR STRENGTH EVALUATION :


Ly = 4.50000e+002, Lz = 4.50000e+002, Lb = 4.50000e+002
Ky = 1.00000e+000, Kz = 1.00000e+000

*. MATERIAL PROPERTIES :
Fy = 2.35000e+002, Es = 2.10000e+005, MATERIAL NAME = S235

*. FORCES AND MOMENTS AT (J) POINT :


Axial Force Fxx =-6.95987e+005
Shear Forces Fyy =-5.31939e+004, Fzz = 1.09887e+005
Bending Moments My =-1.00700e+008, Mz = 1.83050e+007
End Moments Myi =-5.12510e+007, Myj =-1.00700e+008 (for Lb)
Myi =-5.12510e+007, Myj =-1.00700e+008 (for Ly)
Mzi =-5.63224e+006, Mzj = 1.83050e+007 (for Lz)

*. Sign conventions for stress and axial force.


- Stress : Compression positive.
- Axial force: Tension positive.

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CLASSIFY LEFT-TOP FLANGE OF SECTION (BTR).
======================================================================================

( ). Determine classification of tension outstand flanges.


-. Not Checking the Section Classification.

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CLASSIFY RIGHT-TOP FLANGE OF SECTION (BTR).
======================================================================================

Modeling, Integrated Design & Analysis Software Print Date/Time : 09/20/2016 09:08
http://www.MidasUser.com
MIDAS/Civil V 8.5.5 - 63 / 94 -
MIDAS/Civil Steel Code Checking Result

PROJECT TITLE : Design of Shutter Box Culvert

Company HDEC Client Reclamation at Tuas Finger One


Author RJT File Name Shutter Box_option 2_sept5.acs

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MIDAS/Civil - Steel Code Checking[ Eurocode3-2:05 ] Version 8.5.5
==========================================================================================

( ). Determine classification of bending and compression outstand flanges.


[ Eurocode3:05 Table 5.2 (Sheet 2 of 3), EN 1993-1-5 ]
-. e = SQRT( 235/fy ) = 1.00
-. b/t = BTR = 7.46
-. sigma1 = 11.944 MPa.
-. sigma2 = -22.523 MPa.
-. Psi = sigma2 / sigma1 = -1.886
-. Alpha = 1.000
-. BTR < 9*e/Alpha ( Class 1 : Plastic ).

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CLASSIFY LEFT-BOTTOM FLANGE OF SECTION (BTR).
======================================================================================

( ). Determine classification of compression outstand flanges.


[ Eurocode3:05 Table 5.2 (Sheet 2 of 3), EN 1993-1-5 ]
-. e = SQRT( 235/fy ) = 1.00
-. b/t = BTR = 7.46
-. sigma1 = 173.529 MPa.
-. sigma2 = 139.062 MPa.
-. BTR < 9*e ( Class 1 : Plastic ).

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CLASSIFY RIGHT-BOTTOM FLANGE OF SECTION (BTR).
======================================================================================

( ). Determine classification of compression outstand flanges.


[ Eurocode3:05 Table 5.2 (Sheet 2 of 3), EN 1993-1-5 ]
-. e = SQRT( 235/fy ) = 1.00
-. b/t = BTR = 7.46
-. sigma1 = 221.517 MPa.
-. sigma2 = 187.051 MPa.
-. BTR < 9*e ( Class 1 : Plastic ).

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CLASSIFY WEB OF SECTION (HTR).
======================================================================================

( ). Determine classification of bending and compression Internal Parts.


[ Eurocode3:05 Table 5.2 (Sheet 1 of 3), EN 1993-1-5 ]
-. e = SQRT( 235/fy ) = 1.00
-. d/t = HTR = 21.11
-. sigma1 = 155.141 MPa.
-. sigma2 = -4.135 MPa.
-. Psi = [2*(Nsd/A)*(1/fy)]-1 = -0.357
-. Alpha = 1.000 > 0.5
-. HTR < 396*e/(13*Alpha-1) ( Class 1 : Plastic ).

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] APPLIED FACTORS.
======================================================================================

Modeling, Integrated Design & Analysis Software Print Date/Time : 09/20/2016 09:08
http://www.MidasUser.com
MIDAS/Civil V 8.5.5 - 64 / 94 -
MIDAS/Civil Steel Code Checking Result

PROJECT TITLE : Design of Shutter Box Culvert

Company HDEC Client Reclamation at Tuas Finger One


Author RJT File Name Shutter Box_option 2_sept5.acs

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MIDAS/Civil - Steel Code Checking[ Eurocode3-2:05 ] Version 8.5.5
==========================================================================================

( ). Calculate equivalent uniform moment factors (Cmy,Cmz,CmLT).


[ Eurocode3:05 Annex A. Table A.1, A.2 ]
-. Cmy,0 = 0.897
-. Cmz,0 = 0.725
-. Cmy (Default or User Defined Value) = 0.850
-. Cmz (Default or User Defined Value) = 0.850
-. CmLT (Default or User Defined Value) = 1.000

( ). Partial Factors (Gamma_Mi).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1 ]
-. Gamma_M0 = 1.00
-. Gamma_M1 = 1.10
-. Gamma_M2 = 1.25

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CHECK AXIAL RESISTANCE.
======================================================================================

( ). Check slenderness ratio of axial compression member (Kl/i).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.3.1 ]
-. Kl/i = 7.2 < 200.0 ---> O.K.

( ). Calculate axial compressive resistance (Nc_Rd).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1, 6.2.4 ]
-. Nc_Rd = fy * Area / Gamma_M0 = 2166230.00 N.

( ). Check ratio of axial resistance (N_Ed/Nc_Rd).


N_Ed 695987.10
-. ----- = --------------- = 0.321 < 1.000 ---> O.K.
Nc_Rd 2166230.00

( ). Calculate buckling resistance of compression member (Nb_Rdy, Nb_Rdz).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.3.1.1, 6.3.1.2 ]
-. Beta_A = Aeff / Area = 1.000
-. Lambda1 = Pi * SQRT(Es/fy) = 93.913
-. Lambda_by = {(Ky*Ly/iy)/Lambda1} * SQRT(Beta_A) = 0.044
-. Ncry = Pi^2*Es*Iyy / (Ky*Ly)^2 = 1105395692.92 N.
-. Lambda_by < 0.2 or N_Ed/Ncry < 0.04 --> No need to check.

-. Lambda_bz = {(Kz*Lz/iz)/Lambda1} * SQRT(Beta_A) = 0.076


-. Ncrz = Pi^2*Es*Izz / (Kz*Lz)^2 = 373582803.63 N.
-. Lambda_bz < 0.2 or N_Ed/Ncrz < 0.04 --> No need to check.

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CHECK SHEAR RESISTANCE.
======================================================================================

( ). Calculate shear area.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.2.6, EN1993-1-5:04 5.1 NOTE 2 ]

Modeling, Integrated Design & Analysis Software Print Date/Time : 09/20/2016 09:08
http://www.MidasUser.com
MIDAS/Civil V 8.5.5 - 65 / 94 -
MIDAS/Civil Steel Code Checking Result

PROJECT TITLE : Design of Shutter Box Culvert

Company HDEC Client Reclamation at Tuas Finger One


Author RJT File Name Shutter Box_option 2_sept5.acs

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MIDAS/Civil - Steel Code Checking[ Eurocode3-2:05 ] Version 8.5.5
==========================================================================================

-. eta = 1.2 (Fy < 460 MPa.)


-. r = 16.0000 mm.
-. Avy = Area - hw*tw = 7220.0000 mm^2.
-. Avz1 = eta*hw*tw = 2397.6000 mm^2.
-. Avz2 = Area - 2*B*tf + (tw + 2*r)*tf = 2792.0000 mm^2.
-. Avz = MAX[ Avz1, Avz2 ] = 2792.0000 mm^2.

( ). Calculate plastic shear resistance in local-y direction (Vpl_Rdy).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1, 6.2.6 ]
-. Vpl_Rdy = [ Avy*fy/SQRT(3) ] / Gamma_M0 = 979590.20 N.

( ). Check ratio of shear resistance (V_Edy/Vpl_Rdy).


( LCB = 1, POS = J )
-. Applied shear force : V_Edy = 53193.90 N.
V_Edy 53193.90
-. ------- = --------------- = 0.054 < 1.000 ---> O.K.
Vpl_Rdy 979590.20

( ). Calculate plastic shear resistance in local-z direction (Vpl_Rdz).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1, 6.2.6 ]
-. Vpl_Rdz = [ Avz*fy/SQRT(3) ] / Gamma_M0 = 378811.06 N.

( ). Shear Buckling Check.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.2.6 ]
-. HTR < 72*e/Eta ---> No need to check!

( ). Check ratio of shear resistance (V_Edz/Vpl_Rdz).


( LCB = 1, POS = J )
-. Applied shear force : V_Edz = 109887.14 N.
V_Edz 109887.14
-. ------- = --------------- = 0.290 < 1.000 ---> O.K.
Vpl_Rdz 378811.06

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CHECK BENDING MOMENT RESISTANCE ABOUT MAJOR AXIS.
======================================================================================

( ). Calculate plastic resistance moment about major axis.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1, 6.2.5 ]
-. Wply = 961000.0000 mm^3.
-. Mc_Rdy = Wply * fy / Gamma_M0 = 225835000.00 N-mm.

( ). Check ratio of moment resistance (M_Edy/Mc_Rdy).


M_Edy 100700219.61
-. ------ = --------------- = 0.446 < 1.000 ---> O.K.
Mc_Rdy 225835000.00

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CHECK BENDING MOMENT RESISTANCE ABOUT MINOR AXIS.
======================================================================================

Modeling, Integrated Design & Analysis Software Print Date/Time : 09/20/2016 09:08
http://www.MidasUser.com
MIDAS/Civil V 8.5.5 - 66 / 94 -
MIDAS/Civil Steel Code Checking Result

PROJECT TITLE : Design of Shutter Box Culvert

Company HDEC Client Reclamation at Tuas Finger One


Author RJT File Name Shutter Box_option 2_sept5.acs

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MIDAS/Civil - Steel Code Checking[ Eurocode3-2:05 ] Version 8.5.5
==========================================================================================

( ). Calculate plastic resistance moment about minor axis.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1, 6.2.5 ]
-. Wplz = 444000.0000 mm^3.
-. Mc_Rdz = Wplz * fy / Gamma_M0 = 104340000.00 N-mm.

( ). Check ratio of moment resistance (M_Edz/Mc_Rdz).


M_Edz 18305018.99
-. ------ = --------------- = 0.175 < 1.000 ---> O.K.
Mc_Rdz 104340000.00

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CHECK LATERAL-TORSIONAL BUCKLING RESISTANCE.
======================================================================================

( ). Calculate lateral-torsional buckling resistance (Mb_Rd).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1, 6.3.2 ]
-. Por = 0.300
-. Gs = Es / [ 2*(1+Por) ] = 80769.231 MPa.
-. Ncr = Pi^2*Es*Izz / Lu^2 = 373582803.63 N.
-. psi = 0.509
-. C1 = 1.316
-. Mcr = C1 * Ncr * SQRT [ (Cwp/Izz) + (Gs*Ixx)/Ncr ] =58251323718.96 N-mm.

-. Lambda_LT_bar = SQRT [ Wply*fy / Mcr ] = 0.062


-. Lambda_LT_bar0 = 0.200

-. Lambda_LT_bar = 0.062 < Lambda_LT_bar0 = 0.200


-. M_Ed/Mcr = 0.002 < Lambda_LT_bar0^2 = 0.040
If Lambda_LT_bar < Lambda_LT_bar0 or M_Ed/Mcr < Lambda_LT_bar0^2,
No allowance for lateral-torsional buckling necessary.

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CHECK INTERACTION OF COMBINED RESISTANCE.
======================================================================================

( ). Calculate Major reduced design resistance of bending and shear.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.2.8 (6.30) ]
-. In case of V_Edz / Vpl_Rdz < 0.5
-. My_Rd = Mc_Rdy = 225835000.00 N-mm.

( ). Calculate Minor reduced design resistance of bending and shear.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.2.8 (6.30) ]
-. In case of V_Edy / Vpl_Rdy < 0.5
-. Mz_Rd = Mc_Rdz = 104340000.00 N-mm.

Modeling, Integrated Design & Analysis Software Print Date/Time : 09/20/2016 09:08
http://www.MidasUser.com
MIDAS/Civil V 8.5.5 - 67 / 94 -
MIDAS/Civil Steel Code Checking Result

PROJECT TITLE : Design of Shutter Box Culvert

Company HDEC Client Reclamation at Tuas Finger One


Author RJT File Name Shutter Box_option 2_sept5.acs

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MIDAS/Civil - Steel Code Checking[ Eurocode3-2:05 ] Version 8.5.5
==========================================================================================

( ). Check general interaction ratio.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.2.1 (6.2) ] - Class1 or Class2
N_Ed M_Edy M_Edz
-. Rmax1 = ------ + ------- + -------
N_Rd My_Rd Mz_Rd
= 0.943 < 1.000 ---> O.K.

( ). Check interaction ratio of bending and axial force member.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.2.9 (6.31 ~ 6.41) ] - Class1 or Class2
-. n = N_Ed / Npl_Rd = 0.321
-. a = MIN[ (Area-2b*tf)/Area, 0.5 ] = 0.241
-. Alpha = 2.000
-. Beta = MAX[ 5*n, 1.0 ] = 1.606

-. N_Ed > 0.25*Npl_Rd = 541557.50 N.


-. N_Ed > 0.5*hw*tw*fy/Gamma_M0 = 234765.00 N.
Therefore, Allowance for the effect of axial force.
-. Mny_Rd = MIN[ Mply_Rd*(1-n)/(1-0.5*a), Mply_Rd ] = 174238922.90 N-mm.
-. Rmaxy = M_Edy / Mny_Rd = 0.578 < 1.000 ---> O.K.

-. N_Ed < hw*tw*fy/Gamma_M0 = 730380.00 N.


Therefore, No allowance for the effect of axial force.
-. Mnz_Rd = Mplz_Rd = 104340000.00 N-mm.
-. Rmaxz = M_Edz / Mnz_Rd = 0.175 < 1.000 ---> O.K.

[ | M_Edy |^(Alpha) | M_Edz |^(Beta) ]


-. Rmax2 = [ |--------| + |--------| ]
[ | Mny_Rd | | Mnz_Rd | ]
= 0.395 < 1.000 ---> O.K.

( ). Check interaction ratio of bending and axial compression member.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.3.1, 6.2.9.3 (6.61, 6.62), Annex A ]
-. N_Ed = -695987.10 N.
-. M_Edy = -100700219.61 N-mm.
-. M_Edz = 18305018.99 N-mm.
-. kyy = 0.792
-. kyz = 0.440
-. kzy = 0.414
-. kzz = 0.831
-. Xiy = 1.000
-. Xiz = 1.000
-. XiLT = 1.000
-. N_Rk = A*fy = 2166230.00 N.
-. My_Rk = Wply*fy = 225835000.00 N-mm.
-. Mz_Rk = Wplz*fy = 104340000.00 N-mm.
-. N_Ed*eNy = 0.0 (Not Slender)
-. N_Ed*eNZ = 0.0 (Not Slender)
N_Ed M_Edy + N_Ed*eNy M_Edz + N_Ed*eNz
-. Rmax_LT1 = ----------------- + kyy * ------------------- + kyz * ----------------
Xiy*N_Rk/Gamma_M1 XiLT*My_Rk/Gamma_M1 Mz_Rk/Gamma_M1
= 0.827 < 1.000 ---> O.K.
N_Ed M_Edy + N_Ed*eNy M_Edz + N_Ed*eNz
-. Rmax_LT2 = ----------------- + kzy * ------------------- + kzz * ----------------
Xiz*N_Rk/Gamma_M1 XiLT*My_Rk/Gamma_M1 Mz_Rk/Gamma_M1
= 0.717 < 1.000 ---> O.K.

Modeling, Integrated Design & Analysis Software Print Date/Time : 09/20/2016 09:08
http://www.MidasUser.com
MIDAS/Civil V 8.5.5 - 68 / 94 -
MIDAS/Civil Steel Code Checking Result

PROJECT TITLE : Design of Shutter Box Culvert

Company HDEC Client Reclamation at Tuas Finger One


Author RJT File Name Shutter Box_option 2_sept5.acs

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MIDAS/Civil - Steel Code Checking[ Eurocode3-2:05 ] Version 8.5.5
==========================================================================================

-. Rmax = MAX[ MAX(Rmax1, Rmax2), MAX(Rmax_LT1, Rmax_LT2) ] = 0.943 < 1.000 --->
O.K.

Modeling, Integrated Design & Analysis Software Print Date/Time : 09/20/2016 09:08
http://www.MidasUser.com
MIDAS/Civil V 8.5.5 - 69 / 94 -
MIDAS/Civil Steel Code Checking Result

PROJECT TITLE : Design of Shutter Box Culvert

Company HDEC Client Reclamation at Tuas Finger One


Author RJT File Name Shutter Box_option 2_sept5.acs

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MIDAS/Civil - Steel Code Checking[ Eurocode3-2:05 ] Version 8.5.5
==========================================================================================

*. PROJECT :
*. MEMBER NO = 770, ELEMENT TYPE = Beam
*. LOADCOMB NO = 1, MATERIAL NO = 1, SECTION NO = 12
*. UNIT SYSTEM : N, mm

*. SECTION PROPERTIES : Designation = H 100x100x5/7


Shape = H - Section. (Built-up)
Depth = 100.000, Top F Width = 100.000, Bot.F Width = 100.000
Web Thick = 5.000, Top F Thick = 7.000, Bot.F Thick = 7.000

Area = 1.91584e+003, Avy = 1.40000e+003, Avz = 5.16000e+002


Ybar = 5.00000e+001, Zbar = 5.00000e+001, Qyb = 7.43450e+003, Qzb = 1.25000e+003
Wely = 6.88169e+004, Welz = 2.33958e+004, Wply = 7.43450e+004, Wplz = 3.55375e+004
Iyy = 3.44085e+006, Izz = 1.16979e+006, Iyz = 0.00000e+000
iy = 4.23792e+001, iz = 2.47101e+001
J = 2.67417e+004, Cwp = 2.52263e+009

*. DESIGN PARAMETERS FOR STRENGTH EVALUATION :


Ly = 5.25000e+002, Lz = 5.25000e+002, Lb = 5.25000e+002
Ky = 1.00000e+000, Kz = 1.00000e+000

*. MATERIAL PROPERTIES :
Fy = 2.35000e+002, Es = 2.10000e+005, MATERIAL NAME = S235

*. FORCES AND MOMENTS AT (J) POINT :


Axial Force Fxx =-3.84075e+004
Shear Forces Fyy = 2.62488e+003, Fzz = 1.43743e+004
Bending Moments My =-5.76885e+006, Mz =-1.37056e+006
End Moments Myi = 1.77767e+006, Myj =-5.76885e+006 (for Lb)
Myi = 1.77767e+006, Myj =-5.76885e+006 (for Ly)
Mzi = 3.49420e+004, Mzj =-1.37056e+006 (for Lz)

*. Sign conventions for stress and axial force.


- Stress : Compression positive.
- Axial force: Tension positive.

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CLASSIFY LEFT-TOP FLANGE OF SECTION (BTR).
======================================================================================

( ). Determine classification of tension outstand flanges.


-. Not Checking the Section Classification.

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CLASSIFY RIGHT-TOP FLANGE OF SECTION (BTR).
======================================================================================

( ). Determine classification of tension outstand flanges.


-. Not Checking the Section Classification.

Modeling, Integrated Design & Analysis Software Print Date/Time : 09/20/2016 09:08
http://www.MidasUser.com
MIDAS/Civil V 8.5.5 - 70 / 94 -
MIDAS/Civil Steel Code Checking Result

PROJECT TITLE : Design of Shutter Box Culvert

Company HDEC Client Reclamation at Tuas Finger One


Author RJT File Name Shutter Box_option 2_sept5.acs

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MIDAS/Civil - Steel Code Checking[ Eurocode3-2:05 ] Version 8.5.5
==========================================================================================

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CLASSIFY LEFT-BOTTOM FLANGE OF SECTION (BTR).
======================================================================================

( ). Determine classification of compression outstand flanges.


[ Eurocode3:05 Table 5.2 (Sheet 2 of 3), EN 1993-1-5 ]
-. e = SQRT( 235/fy ) = 1.00
-. b/t = BTR = 5.36
-. sigma1 = 136.210 MPa.
-. sigma2 = 107.285 MPa.
-. BTR < 9*e ( Class 1 : Plastic ).

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CLASSIFY RIGHT-BOTTOM FLANGE OF SECTION (BTR).
======================================================================================

( ). Determine classification of compression outstand flanges.


[ Eurocode3:05 Table 5.2 (Sheet 2 of 3), EN 1993-1-5 ]
-. e = SQRT( 235/fy ) = 1.00
-. b/t = BTR = 5.36
-. sigma1 = 88.001 MPa.
-. sigma2 = 59.077 MPa.
-. BTR < 9*e ( Class 1 : Plastic ).

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CLASSIFY WEB OF SECTION (HTR).
======================================================================================

( ). Determine classification of bending and compression Internal Parts.


[ Eurocode3:05 Table 5.2 (Sheet 1 of 3), EN 1993-1-5 ]
-. e = SQRT( 235/fy ) = 1.00
-. d/t = HTR = 13.20
-. sigma1 = 71.261 MPa.
-. sigma2 = -31.166 MPa.
-. Psi = [2*(Nsd/A)*(1/fy)]-1 = -0.829
-. Alpha = 0.748 > 0.5
-. HTR < 396*e/(13*Alpha-1) ( Class 1 : Plastic ).

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] APPLIED FACTORS.
======================================================================================

( ). Calculate equivalent uniform moment factors (Cmy,Cmz,CmLT).


[ Eurocode3:05 Annex A. Table A.1, A.2 ]
-. Cmy,0 = 0.725
-. Cmz,0 = 0.784
-. Cmy (Default or User Defined Value) = 1.000
-. Cmz (Default or User Defined Value) = 1.000
-. CmLT (Default or User Defined Value) = 1.000

Modeling, Integrated Design & Analysis Software Print Date/Time : 09/20/2016 09:08
http://www.MidasUser.com
MIDAS/Civil V 8.5.5 - 71 / 94 -
MIDAS/Civil Steel Code Checking Result

PROJECT TITLE : Design of Shutter Box Culvert

Company HDEC Client Reclamation at Tuas Finger One


Author RJT File Name Shutter Box_option 2_sept5.acs

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MIDAS/Civil - Steel Code Checking[ Eurocode3-2:05 ] Version 8.5.5
==========================================================================================

( ). Partial Factors (Gamma_Mi).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1 ]
-. Gamma_M0 = 1.00
-. Gamma_M1 = 1.10
-. Gamma_M2 = 1.25

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CHECK AXIAL RESISTANCE.
======================================================================================

( ). Check slenderness ratio of axial compression member (Kl/i).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.3.1 ]
-. Kl/i = 21.2 < 200.0 ---> O.K.

( ). Calculate axial compressive resistance (Nc_Rd).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1, 6.2.4 ]
-. Nc_Rd = fy * Area / Gamma_M0 = 450222.57 N.

( ). Check ratio of axial resistance (N_Ed/Nc_Rd).


N_Ed 38407.54
-. ----- = --------------- = 0.085 < 1.000 ---> O.K.
Nc_Rd 450222.57

( ). Calculate buckling resistance of compression member (Nb_Rdy, Nb_Rdz).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.3.1.1, 6.3.1.2 ]
-. Beta_A = Aeff / Area = 1.000
-. Lambda1 = Pi * SQRT(Es/fy) = 93.913
-. Lambda_by = {(Ky*Ly/iy)/Lambda1} * SQRT(Beta_A) = 0.132
-. Ncry = Pi^2*Es*Iyy / (Ky*Ly)^2 = 25874135.82 N.
-. Lambda_by < 0.2 or N_Ed/Ncry < 0.04 --> No need to check.

-. Lambda_bz = {(Kz*Lz/iz)/Lambda1} * SQRT(Beta_A) = 0.226


-. Ncrz = Pi^2*Es*Izz / (Kz*Lz)^2 = 8796452.09 N.
-. Lambda_bz < 0.2 or N_Ed/Ncrz < 0.04 --> No need to check.

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CHECK SHEAR RESISTANCE.
======================================================================================

( ). Calculate shear area.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.2.6, EN1993-1-5:04 5.1 NOTE 2 ]
-. eta = 1.2 (Fy < 460 MPa.)
-. Avy = 2*B*tf = 1400.0000 mm^2.
-. Avz = eta*hw*tw = 516.0000 mm^2.

( ). Calculate plastic shear resistance in local-y direction (Vpl_Rdy).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1, 6.2.6 ]
-. Vpl_Rdy = [ Avy*fy/SQRT(3) ] / Gamma_M0 = 189948.24 N.

Modeling, Integrated Design & Analysis Software Print Date/Time : 09/20/2016 09:08
http://www.MidasUser.com
MIDAS/Civil V 8.5.5 - 72 / 94 -
MIDAS/Civil Steel Code Checking Result

PROJECT TITLE : Design of Shutter Box Culvert

Company HDEC Client Reclamation at Tuas Finger One


Author RJT File Name Shutter Box_option 2_sept5.acs

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MIDAS/Civil - Steel Code Checking[ Eurocode3-2:05 ] Version 8.5.5
==========================================================================================

( ). Check ratio of shear resistance (V_Edy/Vpl_Rdy).


( LCB = 1, POS = I )
-. Applied shear force : V_Edy = 2729.41 N.
V_Edy 2729.41
-. ------- = --------------- = 0.014 < 1.000 ---> O.K.
Vpl_Rdy 189948.24

( ). Calculate plastic shear resistance in local-z direction (Vpl_Rdz).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1, 6.2.6 ]
-. Vpl_Rdz = [ Avz*fy/SQRT(3) ] / Gamma_M0 = 70009.49 N.

( ). Shear Buckling Check.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.2.6 ]
-. HTR < 72*e/Eta ---> No need to check!

( ). Check ratio of shear resistance (V_Edz/Vpl_Rdz).


( LCB = 1, POS = J )
-. Applied shear force : V_Edz = 14374.34 N.
V_Edz 14374.34
-. ------- = --------------- = 0.205 < 1.000 ---> O.K.
Vpl_Rdz 70009.49

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CHECK BENDING MOMENT RESISTANCE ABOUT MAJOR AXIS.
======================================================================================

( ). Calculate plastic resistance moment about major axis.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1, 6.2.5 ]
-. Wply = 74345.0000 mm^3.
-. Mc_Rdy = Wply * fy / Gamma_M0 = 17471075.00 N-mm.

( ). Check ratio of moment resistance (M_Edy/Mc_Rdy).


M_Edy 5768854.41
-. ------ = --------------- = 0.330 < 1.000 ---> O.K.
Mc_Rdy 17471075.00

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CHECK BENDING MOMENT RESISTANCE ABOUT MINOR AXIS.
======================================================================================

( ). Calculate plastic resistance moment about minor axis.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1, 6.2.5 ]
-. Wplz = 35537.5000 mm^3.
-. Mc_Rdz = Wplz * fy / Gamma_M0 = 8351312.50 N-mm.

( ). Check ratio of moment resistance (M_Edz/Mc_Rdz).


M_Edz 1370559.39
-. ------ = --------------- = 0.164 < 1.000 ---> O.K.
Mc_Rdz 8351312.50

Modeling, Integrated Design & Analysis Software Print Date/Time : 09/20/2016 09:08
http://www.MidasUser.com
MIDAS/Civil V 8.5.5 - 73 / 94 -
MIDAS/Civil Steel Code Checking Result

PROJECT TITLE : Design of Shutter Box Culvert

Company HDEC Client Reclamation at Tuas Finger One


Author RJT File Name Shutter Box_option 2_sept5.acs

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MIDAS/Civil - Steel Code Checking[ Eurocode3-2:05 ] Version 8.5.5
==========================================================================================

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CHECK LATERAL-TORSIONAL BUCKLING RESISTANCE.
======================================================================================

( ). Calculate lateral-torsional buckling resistance (Mb_Rd).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1, 6.3.2 ]
-. Por = 0.300
-. Gs = Es / [ 2*(1+Por) ] = 80769.231 MPa.
-. Ncr = Pi^2*Es*Izz / Lu^2 = 8796452.09 N.
-. psi = -0.308
-. C1 = 1.285
-. Mcr = C1 * Ncr * SQRT [ (Cwp/Izz) + (Gs*Ixx)/Ncr ] = 553986630.22 N-mm.

-. Lambda_LT_bar = SQRT [ Wply*fy / Mcr ] = 0.178


-. Lambda_LT_bar0 = 0.200

-. Lambda_LT_bar = 0.178 < Lambda_LT_bar0 = 0.200


-. M_Ed/Mcr = 0.010 < Lambda_LT_bar0^2 = 0.040
If Lambda_LT_bar < Lambda_LT_bar0 or M_Ed/Mcr < Lambda_LT_bar0^2,
No allowance for lateral-torsional buckling necessary.

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CHECK INTERACTION OF COMBINED RESISTANCE.
======================================================================================

( ). Calculate Major reduced design resistance of bending and shear.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.2.8 (6.30) ]
-. In case of V_Edz / Vpl_Rdz < 0.5
-. My_Rd = Mc_Rdy = 17471075.00 N-mm.

( ). Calculate Minor reduced design resistance of bending and shear.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.2.8 (6.30) ]
-. In case of V_Edy / Vpl_Rdy < 0.5
-. Mz_Rd = Mc_Rdz = 8351312.50 N-mm.

( ). Check general interaction ratio.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.2.1 (6.2) ] - Class1 or Class2
N_Ed M_Edy M_Edz
-. Rmax1 = ------ + ------- + -------
N_Rd My_Rd Mz_Rd
= 0.580 < 1.000 ---> O.K.

( ). Check interaction ratio of bending and axial force member.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.2.9 (6.31 ~ 6.41) ] - Class1 or Class2
-. n = N_Ed / Npl_Rd = 0.085
-. a = MIN[ (Area-2b*tf)/Area, 0.5 ] = 0.269
-. Alpha = 2.000
-. Beta = MAX[ 5*n, 1.0 ] = 1.000

Modeling, Integrated Design & Analysis Software Print Date/Time : 09/20/2016 09:08
http://www.MidasUser.com
MIDAS/Civil V 8.5.5 - 74 / 94 -
MIDAS/Civil Steel Code Checking Result

PROJECT TITLE : Design of Shutter Box Culvert

Company HDEC Client Reclamation at Tuas Finger One


Author RJT File Name Shutter Box_option 2_sept5.acs

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MIDAS/Civil - Steel Code Checking[ Eurocode3-2:05 ] Version 8.5.5
==========================================================================================

-. N_Ed < 0.25*Npl_Rd = 112555.64 N.


-. N_Ed < 0.5*hw*tw*fy/Gamma_M0 = 50525.00 N.
Therefore, No allowance for the effect of axial force.
-. Mny_Rd = Mply_Rd = 17471075.00 N-mm.
-. Rmaxy = M_Edy / Mny_Rd = 0.330 < 1.000 ---> O.K.

-. N_Ed < hw*tw*fy/Gamma_M0 = 141470.00 N.


Therefore, No allowance for the effect of axial force.
-. Mnz_Rd = Mplz_Rd = 8351312.50 N-mm.
-. Rmaxz = M_Edz / Mnz_Rd = 0.164 < 1.000 ---> O.K.

[ | M_Edy |^(Alpha) | M_Edz |^(Beta) ]


-. Rmax2 = [ |--------| + |--------| ]
[ | Mny_Rd | | Mnz_Rd | ]
= 0.273 < 1.000 ---> O.K.

( ). Check interaction ratio of bending and axial compression member.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.3.1, 6.2.9.3 (6.61, 6.62), Annex A ]
-. N_Ed = -38407.54 N.
-. M_Edy = -5768854.41 N-mm.
-. M_Edz = -1370559.39 N-mm.
-. kyy = 0.990
-. kyz = 0.660
-. kzy = 0.513
-. kzz = 1.526
-. Xiy = 1.000
-. Xiz = 1.000
-. XiLT = 1.000
-. N_Rk = A*fy = 450222.57 N.
-. My_Rk = Wply*fy = 17471075.00 N-mm.
-. Mz_Rk = Wplz*fy = 8351312.50 N-mm.
-. N_Ed*eNy = 0.0 (Not Slender)
-. N_Ed*eNZ = 0.0 (Not Slender)
N_Ed M_Edy + N_Ed*eNy M_Edz + N_Ed*eNz
-. Rmax_LT1 = ----------------- + kyy * ------------------- + kyz * ----------------
Xiy*N_Rk/Gamma_M1 XiLT*My_Rk/Gamma_M1 Mz_Rk/Gamma_M1
= 0.572 < 1.000 ---> O.K.
N_Ed M_Edy + N_Ed*eNy M_Edz + N_Ed*eNz
-. Rmax_LT2 = ----------------- + kzy * ------------------- + kzz * ----------------
Xiz*N_Rk/Gamma_M1 XiLT*My_Rk/Gamma_M1 Mz_Rk/Gamma_M1
= 0.556 < 1.000 ---> O.K.

-. Rmax = MAX[ MAX(Rmax1, Rmax2), MAX(Rmax_LT1, Rmax_LT2) ] = 0.580 < 1.000 --->
O.K.

Modeling, Integrated Design & Analysis Software Print Date/Time : 09/20/2016 09:08
http://www.MidasUser.com
MIDAS/Civil V 8.5.5 - 75 / 94 -
MIDAS/Civil Steel Code Checking Result

PROJECT TITLE : Design of Shutter Box Culvert

Company HDEC Client Reclamation at Tuas Finger One


Author RJT File Name Shutter Box_option 2_sept5.acs

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MIDAS/Civil - Steel Code Checking[ Eurocode3-2:05 ] Version 8.5.5
==========================================================================================

*. PROJECT :
*. MEMBER NO = 37, ELEMENT TYPE = Beam
*. LOADCOMB NO = 1, MATERIAL NO = 1, SECTION NO = 13
*. UNIT SYSTEM : N, mm

*. SECTION PROPERTIES : Designation = H 100x100x5/7


Shape = H - Section. (Built-up)
Depth = 100.000, Top F Width = 100.000, Bot.F Width = 100.000
Web Thick = 5.000, Top F Thick = 7.000, Bot.F Thick = 7.000

Area = 1.91584e+003, Avy = 1.40000e+003, Avz = 5.16000e+002


Ybar = 5.00000e+001, Zbar = 5.00000e+001, Qyb = 7.43450e+003, Qzb = 1.25000e+003
Wely = 6.88169e+004, Welz = 2.33958e+004, Wply = 7.43450e+004, Wplz = 3.55375e+004
Iyy = 3.44085e+006, Izz = 1.16979e+006, Iyz = 0.00000e+000
iy = 4.23792e+001, iz = 2.47101e+001
J = 2.67417e+004, Cwp = 2.52263e+009

*. DESIGN PARAMETERS FOR STRENGTH EVALUATION :


Ly = 4.00000e+002, Lz = 4.00000e+002, Lb = 4.00000e+002
Ky = 1.00000e+000, Kz = 1.00000e+000

*. MATERIAL PROPERTIES :
Fy = 2.35000e+002, Es = 2.10000e+005, MATERIAL NAME = S235

*. FORCES AND MOMENTS AT (J) POINT :


Axial Force Fxx =-1.25675e+004
Shear Forces Fyy =-9.92240e+003, Fzz = 1.15452e+004
Bending Moments My =-2.86657e+006, Mz = 2.35673e+006
End Moments Myi = 1.73560e+006, Myj =-2.86657e+006 (for Lb)
Myi = 1.73560e+006, Myj =-2.86657e+006 (for Ly)
Mzi =-1.61223e+006, Mzj = 2.35673e+006 (for Lz)

*. Sign conventions for stress and axial force.


- Stress : Compression positive.
- Axial force: Tension positive.

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CLASSIFY LEFT-TOP FLANGE OF SECTION (BTR).
======================================================================================

( ). Determine classification of tension outstand flanges.


-. Not Checking the Section Classification.

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CLASSIFY RIGHT-TOP FLANGE OF SECTION (BTR).
======================================================================================

Modeling, Integrated Design & Analysis Software Print Date/Time : 09/20/2016 09:08
http://www.MidasUser.com
MIDAS/Civil V 8.5.5 - 76 / 94 -
MIDAS/Civil Steel Code Checking Result

PROJECT TITLE : Design of Shutter Box Culvert

Company HDEC Client Reclamation at Tuas Finger One


Author RJT File Name Shutter Box_option 2_sept5.acs

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MIDAS/Civil - Steel Code Checking[ Eurocode3-2:05 ] Version 8.5.5
==========================================================================================

( ). Determine classification of bending and compression outstand flanges.


[ Eurocode3:05 Table 5.2 (Sheet 2 of 3), EN 1993-1-5 ]
-. e = SQRT( 235/fy ) = 1.00
-. b/t = BTR = 5.36
-. sigma1 = 34.319 MPa.
-. sigma2 = -15.419 MPa.
-. Psi = sigma2 / sigma1 = -0.449
-. Alpha = 1.000
-. BTR < 9*e/Alpha ( Class 1 : Plastic ).

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CLASSIFY LEFT-BOTTOM FLANGE OF SECTION (BTR).
======================================================================================

( ). Determine classification of tension outstand flanges.


-. Not Checking the Section Classification.

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CLASSIFY RIGHT-BOTTOM FLANGE OF SECTION (BTR).
======================================================================================

( ). Determine classification of compression outstand flanges.


[ Eurocode3:05 Table 5.2 (Sheet 2 of 3), EN 1993-1-5 ]
-. e = SQRT( 235/fy ) = 1.00
-. b/t = BTR = 5.36
-. sigma1 = 111.434 MPa.
-. sigma2 = 61.697 MPa.
-. BTR < 9*e ( Class 1 : Plastic ).

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CLASSIFY WEB OF SECTION (HTR).
======================================================================================

( ). Determine classification of bending and compression Internal Parts.


[ Eurocode3:05 Table 5.2 (Sheet 1 of 3), EN 1993-1-5 ]
-. e = SQRT( 235/fy ) = 1.00
-. d/t = HTR = 13.20
-. sigma1 = 32.008 MPa.
-. sigma2 = -18.888 MPa.
-. Psi = [2*(Nsd/A)*(1/fy)]-1 = -0.944
-. Alpha = 0.581 > 0.5
-. HTR < 396*e/(13*Alpha-1) ( Class 1 : Plastic ).

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] APPLIED FACTORS.
======================================================================================

( ). Calculate equivalent uniform moment factors (Cmy,Cmz,CmLT).


[ Eurocode3:05 Annex A. Table A.1, A.2 ]
-. Cmy,0 = 0.663
-. Cmz,0 = 0.646

Modeling, Integrated Design & Analysis Software Print Date/Time : 09/20/2016 09:08
http://www.MidasUser.com
MIDAS/Civil V 8.5.5 - 77 / 94 -
MIDAS/Civil Steel Code Checking Result

PROJECT TITLE : Design of Shutter Box Culvert

Company HDEC Client Reclamation at Tuas Finger One


Author RJT File Name Shutter Box_option 2_sept5.acs

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MIDAS/Civil - Steel Code Checking[ Eurocode3-2:05 ] Version 8.5.5
==========================================================================================

-. Cmy (Default or User Defined Value) = 1.000


-. Cmz (Default or User Defined Value) = 1.000
-. CmLT (Default or User Defined Value) = 1.000

( ). Partial Factors (Gamma_Mi).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1 ]
-. Gamma_M0 = 1.00
-. Gamma_M1 = 1.10
-. Gamma_M2 = 1.25

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CHECK AXIAL RESISTANCE.
======================================================================================

( ). Check slenderness ratio of axial compression member (Kl/i).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.3.1 ]
-. Kl/i = 16.2 < 200.0 ---> O.K.

( ). Calculate axial compressive resistance (Nc_Rd).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1, 6.2.4 ]
-. Nc_Rd = fy * Area / Gamma_M0 = 450222.57 N.

( ). Check ratio of axial resistance (N_Ed/Nc_Rd).


N_Ed 12567.52
-. ----- = --------------- = 0.028 < 1.000 ---> O.K.
Nc_Rd 450222.57

( ). Calculate buckling resistance of compression member (Nb_Rdy, Nb_Rdz).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.3.1.1, 6.3.1.2 ]
-. Beta_A = Aeff / Area = 1.000
-. Lambda1 = Pi * SQRT(Es/fy) = 93.913
-. Lambda_by = {(Ky*Ly/iy)/Lambda1} * SQRT(Beta_A) = 0.101
-. Ncry = Pi^2*Es*Iyy / (Ky*Ly)^2 = 44572241.79 N.
-. Lambda_by < 0.2 or N_Ed/Ncry < 0.04 --> No need to check.

-. Lambda_bz = {(Kz*Lz/iz)/Lambda1} * SQRT(Beta_A) = 0.172


-. Ncrz = Pi^2*Es*Izz / (Kz*Lz)^2 = 15153263.17 N.
-. Lambda_bz < 0.2 or N_Ed/Ncrz < 0.04 --> No need to check.

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CHECK SHEAR RESISTANCE.
======================================================================================

( ). Calculate shear area.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.2.6, EN1993-1-5:04 5.1 NOTE 2 ]
-. eta = 1.2 (Fy < 460 MPa.)
-. Avy = 2*B*tf = 1400.0000 mm^2.
-. Avz = eta*hw*tw = 516.0000 mm^2.

( ). Calculate plastic shear resistance in local-y direction (Vpl_Rdy).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1, 6.2.6 ]
-. Vpl_Rdy = [ Avy*fy/SQRT(3) ] / Gamma_M0 = 189948.24 N.

Modeling, Integrated Design & Analysis Software Print Date/Time : 09/20/2016 09:08
http://www.MidasUser.com
MIDAS/Civil V 8.5.5 - 78 / 94 -
MIDAS/Civil Steel Code Checking Result

PROJECT TITLE : Design of Shutter Box Culvert

Company HDEC Client Reclamation at Tuas Finger One


Author RJT File Name Shutter Box_option 2_sept5.acs

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MIDAS/Civil - Steel Code Checking[ Eurocode3-2:05 ] Version 8.5.5
==========================================================================================

( ). Check ratio of shear resistance (V_Edy/Vpl_Rdy).


( LCB = 1, POS = J )
-. Applied shear force : V_Edy = 9922.40 N.
V_Edy 9922.40
-. ------- = --------------- = 0.052 < 1.000 ---> O.K.
Vpl_Rdy 189948.24

( ). Calculate plastic shear resistance in local-z direction (Vpl_Rdz).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1, 6.2.6 ]
-. Vpl_Rdz = [ Avz*fy/SQRT(3) ] / Gamma_M0 = 70009.49 N.

( ). Shear Buckling Check.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.2.6 ]
-. HTR < 72*e/Eta ---> No need to check!

( ). Check ratio of shear resistance (V_Edz/Vpl_Rdz).


( LCB = 1, POS = J )
-. Applied shear force : V_Edz = 11545.24 N.
V_Edz 11545.24
-. ------- = --------------- = 0.165 < 1.000 ---> O.K.
Vpl_Rdz 70009.49

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CHECK BENDING MOMENT RESISTANCE ABOUT MAJOR AXIS.
======================================================================================

( ). Calculate plastic resistance moment about major axis.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1, 6.2.5 ]
-. Wply = 74345.0000 mm^3.
-. Mc_Rdy = Wply * fy / Gamma_M0 = 17471075.00 N-mm.

( ). Check ratio of moment resistance (M_Edy/Mc_Rdy).


M_Edy 2866570.69
-. ------ = --------------- = 0.164 < 1.000 ---> O.K.
Mc_Rdy 17471075.00

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CHECK BENDING MOMENT RESISTANCE ABOUT MINOR AXIS.
======================================================================================

( ). Calculate plastic resistance moment about minor axis.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1, 6.2.5 ]
-. Wplz = 35537.5000 mm^3.
-. Mc_Rdz = Wplz * fy / Gamma_M0 = 8351312.50 N-mm.

( ). Check ratio of moment resistance (M_Edz/Mc_Rdz).


M_Edz 2356731.39
-. ------ = --------------- = 0.282 < 1.000 ---> O.K.
Mc_Rdz 8351312.50

Modeling, Integrated Design & Analysis Software Print Date/Time : 09/20/2016 09:08
http://www.MidasUser.com
MIDAS/Civil V 8.5.5 - 79 / 94 -
MIDAS/Civil Steel Code Checking Result

PROJECT TITLE : Design of Shutter Box Culvert

Company HDEC Client Reclamation at Tuas Finger One


Author RJT File Name Shutter Box_option 2_sept5.acs

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MIDAS/Civil - Steel Code Checking[ Eurocode3-2:05 ] Version 8.5.5
==========================================================================================

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CHECK LATERAL-TORSIONAL BUCKLING RESISTANCE.
======================================================================================

( ). Calculate lateral-torsional buckling resistance (Mb_Rd).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1, 6.3.2 ]
-. Por = 0.300
-. Gs = Es / [ 2*(1+Por) ] = 80769.231 MPa.
-. Ncr = Pi^2*Es*Izz / Lu^2 = 15153263.17 N.
-. psi = -0.605
-. C1 = 1.285
-. Mcr = C1 * Ncr * SQRT [ (Cwp/Izz) + (Gs*Ixx)/Ncr ] = 933642205.96 N-mm.

-. Lambda_LT_bar = SQRT [ Wply*fy / Mcr ] = 0.137


-. Lambda_LT_bar0 = 0.200

-. Lambda_LT_bar = 0.137 < Lambda_LT_bar0 = 0.200


-. M_Ed/Mcr = 0.003 < Lambda_LT_bar0^2 = 0.040
If Lambda_LT_bar < Lambda_LT_bar0 or M_Ed/Mcr < Lambda_LT_bar0^2,
No allowance for lateral-torsional buckling necessary.

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CHECK INTERACTION OF COMBINED RESISTANCE.
======================================================================================

( ). Calculate Major reduced design resistance of bending and shear.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.2.8 (6.30) ]
-. In case of V_Edz / Vpl_Rdz < 0.5
-. My_Rd = Mc_Rdy = 17471075.00 N-mm.

( ). Calculate Minor reduced design resistance of bending and shear.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.2.8 (6.30) ]
-. In case of V_Edy / Vpl_Rdy < 0.5
-. Mz_Rd = Mc_Rdz = 8351312.50 N-mm.

( ). Check general interaction ratio.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.2.1 (6.2) ] - Class1 or Class2
N_Ed M_Edy M_Edz
-. Rmax1 = ------ + ------- + -------
N_Rd My_Rd Mz_Rd
= 0.474 < 1.000 ---> O.K.

( ). Check interaction ratio of bending and axial force member.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.2.9 (6.31 ~ 6.41) ] - Class1 or Class2
-. n = N_Ed / Npl_Rd = 0.028
-. a = MIN[ (Area-2b*tf)/Area, 0.5 ] = 0.269
-. Alpha = 2.000
-. Beta = MAX[ 5*n, 1.0 ] = 1.000

Modeling, Integrated Design & Analysis Software Print Date/Time : 09/20/2016 09:08
http://www.MidasUser.com
MIDAS/Civil V 8.5.5 - 80 / 94 -
MIDAS/Civil Steel Code Checking Result

PROJECT TITLE : Design of Shutter Box Culvert

Company HDEC Client Reclamation at Tuas Finger One


Author RJT File Name Shutter Box_option 2_sept5.acs

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MIDAS/Civil - Steel Code Checking[ Eurocode3-2:05 ] Version 8.5.5
==========================================================================================

-. N_Ed < 0.25*Npl_Rd = 112555.64 N.


-. N_Ed < 0.5*hw*tw*fy/Gamma_M0 = 50525.00 N.
Therefore, No allowance for the effect of axial force.
-. Mny_Rd = Mply_Rd = 17471075.00 N-mm.
-. Rmaxy = M_Edy / Mny_Rd = 0.164 < 1.000 ---> O.K.

-. N_Ed < hw*tw*fy/Gamma_M0 = 141470.00 N.


Therefore, No allowance for the effect of axial force.
-. Mnz_Rd = Mplz_Rd = 8351312.50 N-mm.
-. Rmaxz = M_Edz / Mnz_Rd = 0.282 < 1.000 ---> O.K.

[ | M_Edy |^(Alpha) | M_Edz |^(Beta) ]


-. Rmax2 = [ |--------| + |--------| ]
[ | Mny_Rd | | Mnz_Rd | ]
= 0.309 < 1.000 ---> O.K.

( ). Check interaction ratio of bending and axial compression member.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.3.1, 6.2.9.3 (6.61, 6.62), Annex A ]
-. N_Ed = -12567.52 N.
-. M_Edy = -2866570.69 N-mm.
-. M_Edz = 2356731.39 N-mm.
-. kyy = 0.996
-. kyz = 0.690
-. kzy = 0.513
-. kzz = 1.228
-. Xiy = 1.000
-. Xiz = 1.000
-. XiLT = 1.000
-. N_Rk = A*fy = 450222.57 N.
-. My_Rk = Wply*fy = 17471075.00 N-mm.
-. Mz_Rk = Wplz*fy = 8351312.50 N-mm.
-. N_Ed*eNy = 0.0 (Not Slender)
-. N_Ed*eNZ = 0.0 (Not Slender)
N_Ed M_Edy + N_Ed*eNy M_Edz + N_Ed*eNz
-. Rmax_LT1 = ----------------- + kyy * ------------------- + kyz * ----------------
Xiy*N_Rk/Gamma_M1 XiLT*My_Rk/Gamma_M1 Mz_Rk/Gamma_M1
= 0.425 < 1.000 ---> O.K.
N_Ed M_Edy + N_Ed*eNy M_Edz + N_Ed*eNz
-. Rmax_LT2 = ----------------- + kzy * ------------------- + kzz * ----------------
Xiz*N_Rk/Gamma_M1 XiLT*My_Rk/Gamma_M1 Mz_Rk/Gamma_M1
= 0.505 < 1.000 ---> O.K.

-. Rmax = MAX[ MAX(Rmax1, Rmax2), MAX(Rmax_LT1, Rmax_LT2) ] = 0.505 < 1.000 --->
O.K.

Modeling, Integrated Design & Analysis Software Print Date/Time : 09/20/2016 09:08
http://www.MidasUser.com
MIDAS/Civil V 8.5.5 - 81 / 94 -
MIDAS/Civil Steel Code Checking Result

PROJECT TITLE : Design of Shutter Box Culvert

Company HDEC Client Reclamation at Tuas Finger One


Author RJT File Name Shutter Box_option 2_sept5.acs

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MIDAS/Civil - Steel Code Checking[ Eurocode3-2:05 ] Version 8.5.5
==========================================================================================

*. PROJECT :
*. MEMBER NO = 802, ELEMENT TYPE = Beam
*. LOADCOMB NO = 1, MATERIAL NO = 1, SECTION NO = 14
*. UNIT SYSTEM : N, mm

*. SECTION PROPERTIES : Designation = H 250x250x9/14


Shape = H - Section. (Rolled)
Depth = 250.000, Top F Width = 250.000, Bot.F Width = 250.000
Web Thick = 9.000, Top F Thick = 14.000, Bot.F Thick = 14.000

Area = 9.21800e+003, Avy = 7.22000e+003, Avz = 2.79200e+003


Ybar = 1.25000e+002, Zbar = 1.25000e+002, Qyb = 5.20494e+004, Qzb = 7.81250e+003
Wely = 8.67000e+005, Welz = 2.92000e+005, Wply = 9.61000e+005, Wplz = 4.44000e+005
Iyy = 1.08000e+008, Izz = 3.65000e+007, Iyz = 0.00000e+000
iy = 1.08000e+002, iz = 6.29000e+001
J = 5.11000e+005, Cwp = 5.08000e+011

*. DESIGN PARAMETERS FOR STRENGTH EVALUATION :


Ly = 4.50000e+002, Lz = 4.50000e+002, Lb = 4.50000e+002
Ky = 1.00000e+000, Kz = 1.00000e+000

*. MATERIAL PROPERTIES :
Fy = 2.35000e+002, Es = 2.10000e+005, MATERIAL NAME = S235

*. FORCES AND MOMENTS AT (J) POINT :


Axial Force Fxx =-6.97401e+005
Shear Forces Fyy =-5.32586e+004, Fzz =-1.10016e+005
Bending Moments My = 1.00548e+008, Mz = 1.83154e+007
End Moments Myi = 5.10408e+007, Myj = 1.00548e+008 (for Lb)
Myi = 5.10408e+007, Myj = 1.00548e+008 (for Ly)
Mzi =-5.65100e+006, Mzj = 1.83154e+007 (for Lz)

*. Sign conventions for stress and axial force.


- Stress : Compression positive.
- Axial force: Tension positive.

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CLASSIFY LEFT-TOP FLANGE OF SECTION (BTR).
======================================================================================

( ). Determine classification of compression outstand flanges.


[ Eurocode3:05 Table 5.2 (Sheet 2 of 3), EN 1993-1-5 ]
-. e = SQRT( 235/fy ) = 1.00
-. b/t = BTR = 7.46
-. sigma1 = 173.520 MPa.
-. sigma2 = 139.034 MPa.
-. BTR < 9*e ( Class 1 : Plastic ).

Modeling, Integrated Design & Analysis Software Print Date/Time : 09/20/2016 09:08
http://www.MidasUser.com
MIDAS/Civil V 8.5.5 - 82 / 94 -
MIDAS/Civil Steel Code Checking Result

PROJECT TITLE : Design of Shutter Box Culvert

Company HDEC Client Reclamation at Tuas Finger One


Author RJT File Name Shutter Box_option 2_sept5.acs

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MIDAS/Civil - Steel Code Checking[ Eurocode3-2:05 ] Version 8.5.5
==========================================================================================

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CLASSIFY RIGHT-TOP FLANGE OF SECTION (BTR).
======================================================================================

( ). Determine classification of compression outstand flanges.


[ Eurocode3:05 Table 5.2 (Sheet 2 of 3), EN 1993-1-5 ]
-. e = SQRT( 235/fy ) = 1.00
-. b/t = BTR = 7.46
-. sigma1 = 221.536 MPa.
-. sigma2 = 187.050 MPa.
-. BTR < 9*e ( Class 1 : Plastic ).

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CLASSIFY LEFT-BOTTOM FLANGE OF SECTION (BTR).
======================================================================================

( ). Determine classification of tension outstand flanges.


-. Not Checking the Section Classification.

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CLASSIFY RIGHT-BOTTOM FLANGE OF SECTION (BTR).
======================================================================================

( ). Determine classification of bending and compression outstand flanges.


[ Eurocode3:05 Table 5.2 (Sheet 2 of 3), EN 1993-1-5 ]
-. e = SQRT( 235/fy ) = 1.00
-. b/t = BTR = 7.46
-. sigma1 = 12.279 MPa.
-. sigma2 = -22.207 MPa.
-. Psi = sigma2 / sigma1 = -1.809
-. Alpha = 1.000
-. BTR < 9*e/Alpha ( Class 1 : Plastic ).

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CLASSIFY WEB OF SECTION (HTR).
======================================================================================

( ). Determine classification of bending and compression Internal Parts.


[ Eurocode3:05 Table 5.2 (Sheet 1 of 3), EN 1993-1-5 ]
-. e = SQRT( 235/fy ) = 1.00
-. d/t = HTR = 21.11
-. sigma1 = 155.174 MPa.
-. sigma2 = -3.861 MPa.
-. Psi = [2*(Nsd/A)*(1/fy)]-1 = -0.356
-. Alpha = 1.000 > 0.5
-. HTR < 396*e/(13*Alpha-1) ( Class 1 : Plastic ).

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] APPLIED FACTORS.
======================================================================================

Modeling, Integrated Design & Analysis Software Print Date/Time : 09/20/2016 09:08
http://www.MidasUser.com
MIDAS/Civil V 8.5.5 - 83 / 94 -
MIDAS/Civil Steel Code Checking Result

PROJECT TITLE : Design of Shutter Box Culvert

Company HDEC Client Reclamation at Tuas Finger One


Author RJT File Name Shutter Box_option 2_sept5.acs

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MIDAS/Civil - Steel Code Checking[ Eurocode3-2:05 ] Version 8.5.5
==========================================================================================

( ). Calculate equivalent uniform moment factors (Cmy,Cmz,CmLT).


[ Eurocode3:05 Annex A. Table A.1, A.2 ]
-. Cmy,0 = 0.897
-. Cmz,0 = 0.725
-. Cmy (Default or User Defined Value) = 0.850
-. Cmz (Default or User Defined Value) = 0.850
-. CmLT (Default or User Defined Value) = 1.000

( ). Partial Factors (Gamma_Mi).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1 ]
-. Gamma_M0 = 1.00
-. Gamma_M1 = 1.10
-. Gamma_M2 = 1.25

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CHECK AXIAL RESISTANCE.
======================================================================================

( ). Check slenderness ratio of axial compression member (Kl/i).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.3.1 ]
-. Kl/i = 7.2 < 200.0 ---> O.K.

( ). Calculate axial compressive resistance (Nc_Rd).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1, 6.2.4 ]
-. Nc_Rd = fy * Area / Gamma_M0 = 2166230.00 N.

( ). Check ratio of axial resistance (N_Ed/Nc_Rd).


N_Ed 697401.23
-. ----- = --------------- = 0.322 < 1.000 ---> O.K.
Nc_Rd 2166230.00

( ). Calculate buckling resistance of compression member (Nb_Rdy, Nb_Rdz).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.3.1.1, 6.3.1.2 ]
-. Beta_A = Aeff / Area = 1.000
-. Lambda1 = Pi * SQRT(Es/fy) = 93.913
-. Lambda_by = {(Ky*Ly/iy)/Lambda1} * SQRT(Beta_A) = 0.044
-. Ncry = Pi^2*Es*Iyy / (Ky*Ly)^2 = 1105395692.92 N.
-. Lambda_by < 0.2 or N_Ed/Ncry < 0.04 --> No need to check.

-. Lambda_bz = {(Kz*Lz/iz)/Lambda1} * SQRT(Beta_A) = 0.076


-. Ncrz = Pi^2*Es*Izz / (Kz*Lz)^2 = 373582803.63 N.
-. Lambda_bz < 0.2 or N_Ed/Ncrz < 0.04 --> No need to check.

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CHECK SHEAR RESISTANCE.
======================================================================================

( ). Calculate shear area.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.2.6, EN1993-1-5:04 5.1 NOTE 2 ]

Modeling, Integrated Design & Analysis Software Print Date/Time : 09/20/2016 09:08
http://www.MidasUser.com
MIDAS/Civil V 8.5.5 - 84 / 94 -
MIDAS/Civil Steel Code Checking Result

PROJECT TITLE : Design of Shutter Box Culvert

Company HDEC Client Reclamation at Tuas Finger One


Author RJT File Name Shutter Box_option 2_sept5.acs

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MIDAS/Civil - Steel Code Checking[ Eurocode3-2:05 ] Version 8.5.5
==========================================================================================

-. eta = 1.2 (Fy < 460 MPa.)


-. r = 16.0000 mm.
-. Avy = Area - hw*tw = 7220.0000 mm^2.
-. Avz1 = eta*hw*tw = 2397.6000 mm^2.
-. Avz2 = Area - 2*B*tf + (tw + 2*r)*tf = 2792.0000 mm^2.
-. Avz = MAX[ Avz1, Avz2 ] = 2792.0000 mm^2.

( ). Calculate plastic shear resistance in local-y direction (Vpl_Rdy).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1, 6.2.6 ]
-. Vpl_Rdy = [ Avy*fy/SQRT(3) ] / Gamma_M0 = 979590.20 N.

( ). Check ratio of shear resistance (V_Edy/Vpl_Rdy).


( LCB = 1, POS = J )
-. Applied shear force : V_Edy = 53258.56 N.
V_Edy 53258.56
-. ------- = --------------- = 0.054 < 1.000 ---> O.K.
Vpl_Rdy 979590.20

( ). Calculate plastic shear resistance in local-z direction (Vpl_Rdz).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1, 6.2.6 ]
-. Vpl_Rdz = [ Avz*fy/SQRT(3) ] / Gamma_M0 = 378811.06 N.

( ). Shear Buckling Check.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.2.6 ]
-. HTR < 72*e/Eta ---> No need to check!

( ). Check ratio of shear resistance (V_Edz/Vpl_Rdz).


( LCB = 1, POS = J )
-. Applied shear force : V_Edz = 110015.85 N.
V_Edz 110015.85
-. ------- = --------------- = 0.290 < 1.000 ---> O.K.
Vpl_Rdz 378811.06

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CHECK BENDING MOMENT RESISTANCE ABOUT MAJOR AXIS.
======================================================================================

( ). Calculate plastic resistance moment about major axis.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1, 6.2.5 ]
-. Wply = 961000.0000 mm^3.
-. Mc_Rdy = Wply * fy / Gamma_M0 = 225835000.00 N-mm.

( ). Check ratio of moment resistance (M_Edy/Mc_Rdy).


M_Edy 100547907.61
-. ------ = --------------- = 0.445 < 1.000 ---> O.K.
Mc_Rdy 225835000.00

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CHECK BENDING MOMENT RESISTANCE ABOUT MINOR AXIS.
======================================================================================

Modeling, Integrated Design & Analysis Software Print Date/Time : 09/20/2016 09:08
http://www.MidasUser.com
MIDAS/Civil V 8.5.5 - 85 / 94 -
MIDAS/Civil Steel Code Checking Result

PROJECT TITLE : Design of Shutter Box Culvert

Company HDEC Client Reclamation at Tuas Finger One


Author RJT File Name Shutter Box_option 2_sept5.acs

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MIDAS/Civil - Steel Code Checking[ Eurocode3-2:05 ] Version 8.5.5
==========================================================================================

( ). Calculate plastic resistance moment about minor axis.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1, 6.2.5 ]
-. Wplz = 444000.0000 mm^3.
-. Mc_Rdz = Wplz * fy / Gamma_M0 = 104340000.00 N-mm.

( ). Check ratio of moment resistance (M_Edz/Mc_Rdz).


M_Edz 18315354.53
-. ------ = --------------- = 0.176 < 1.000 ---> O.K.
Mc_Rdz 104340000.00

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CHECK LATERAL-TORSIONAL BUCKLING RESISTANCE.
======================================================================================

( ). Calculate lateral-torsional buckling resistance (Mb_Rd).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1, 6.3.2 ]
-. Por = 0.300
-. Gs = Es / [ 2*(1+Por) ] = 80769.231 MPa.
-. Ncr = Pi^2*Es*Izz / Lu^2 = 373582803.63 N.
-. psi = 0.508
-. C1 = 1.317
-. Mcr = C1 * Ncr * SQRT [ (Cwp/Izz) + (Gs*Ixx)/Ncr ] =58293841260.83 N-mm.

-. Lambda_LT_bar = SQRT [ Wply*fy / Mcr ] = 0.062


-. Lambda_LT_bar0 = 0.200

-. Lambda_LT_bar = 0.062 < Lambda_LT_bar0 = 0.200


-. M_Ed/Mcr = 0.002 < Lambda_LT_bar0^2 = 0.040
If Lambda_LT_bar < Lambda_LT_bar0 or M_Ed/Mcr < Lambda_LT_bar0^2,
No allowance for lateral-torsional buckling necessary.

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CHECK INTERACTION OF COMBINED RESISTANCE.
======================================================================================

( ). Calculate Major reduced design resistance of bending and shear.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.2.8 (6.30) ]
-. In case of V_Edz / Vpl_Rdz < 0.5
-. My_Rd = Mc_Rdy = 225835000.00 N-mm.

( ). Calculate Minor reduced design resistance of bending and shear.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.2.8 (6.30) ]
-. In case of V_Edy / Vpl_Rdy < 0.5
-. Mz_Rd = Mc_Rdz = 104340000.00 N-mm.

Modeling, Integrated Design & Analysis Software Print Date/Time : 09/20/2016 09:08
http://www.MidasUser.com
MIDAS/Civil V 8.5.5 - 86 / 94 -
MIDAS/Civil Steel Code Checking Result

PROJECT TITLE : Design of Shutter Box Culvert

Company HDEC Client Reclamation at Tuas Finger One


Author RJT File Name Shutter Box_option 2_sept5.acs

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MIDAS/Civil - Steel Code Checking[ Eurocode3-2:05 ] Version 8.5.5
==========================================================================================

( ). Check general interaction ratio.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.2.1 (6.2) ] - Class1 or Class2
N_Ed M_Edy M_Edz
-. Rmax1 = ------ + ------- + -------
N_Rd My_Rd Mz_Rd
= 0.943 < 1.000 ---> O.K.

( ). Check interaction ratio of bending and axial force member.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.2.9 (6.31 ~ 6.41) ] - Class1 or Class2
-. n = N_Ed / Npl_Rd = 0.322
-. a = MIN[ (Area-2b*tf)/Area, 0.5 ] = 0.241
-. Alpha = 2.000
-. Beta = MAX[ 5*n, 1.0 ] = 1.610

-. N_Ed > 0.25*Npl_Rd = 541557.50 N.


-. N_Ed > 0.5*hw*tw*fy/Gamma_M0 = 234765.00 N.
Therefore, Allowance for the effect of axial force.
-. Mny_Rd = MIN[ Mply_Rd*(1-n)/(1-0.5*a), Mply_Rd ] = 174071333.69 N-mm.
-. Rmaxy = M_Edy / Mny_Rd = 0.578 < 1.000 ---> O.K.

-. N_Ed < hw*tw*fy/Gamma_M0 = 730380.00 N.


Therefore, No allowance for the effect of axial force.
-. Mnz_Rd = Mplz_Rd = 104340000.00 N-mm.
-. Rmaxz = M_Edz / Mnz_Rd = 0.176 < 1.000 ---> O.K.

[ | M_Edy |^(Alpha) | M_Edz |^(Beta) ]


-. Rmax2 = [ |--------| + |--------| ]
[ | Mny_Rd | | Mnz_Rd | ]
= 0.394 < 1.000 ---> O.K.

( ). Check interaction ratio of bending and axial compression member.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.3.1, 6.2.9.3 (6.61, 6.62), Annex A ]
-. N_Ed = -697401.23 N.
-. M_Edy = 100547907.61 N-mm.
-. M_Edz = 18315354.53 N-mm.
-. kyy = 0.792
-. kyz = 0.440
-. kzy = 0.414
-. kzz = 0.830
-. Xiy = 1.000
-. Xiz = 1.000
-. XiLT = 1.000
-. N_Rk = A*fy = 2166230.00 N.
-. My_Rk = Wply*fy = 225835000.00 N-mm.
-. Mz_Rk = Wplz*fy = 104340000.00 N-mm.
-. N_Ed*eNy = 0.0 (Not Slender)
-. N_Ed*eNZ = 0.0 (Not Slender)
N_Ed M_Edy + N_Ed*eNy M_Edz + N_Ed*eNz
-. Rmax_LT1 = ----------------- + kyy * ------------------- + kyz * ----------------
Xiy*N_Rk/Gamma_M1 XiLT*My_Rk/Gamma_M1 Mz_Rk/Gamma_M1
= 0.827 < 1.000 ---> O.K.
N_Ed M_Edy + N_Ed*eNy M_Edz + N_Ed*eNz
-. Rmax_LT2 = ----------------- + kzy * ------------------- + kzz * ----------------
Xiz*N_Rk/Gamma_M1 XiLT*My_Rk/Gamma_M1 Mz_Rk/Gamma_M1
= 0.717 < 1.000 ---> O.K.

Modeling, Integrated Design & Analysis Software Print Date/Time : 09/20/2016 09:08
http://www.MidasUser.com
MIDAS/Civil V 8.5.5 - 87 / 94 -
MIDAS/Civil Steel Code Checking Result

PROJECT TITLE : Design of Shutter Box Culvert

Company HDEC Client Reclamation at Tuas Finger One


Author RJT File Name Shutter Box_option 2_sept5.acs

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MIDAS/Civil - Steel Code Checking[ Eurocode3-2:05 ] Version 8.5.5
==========================================================================================

-. Rmax = MAX[ MAX(Rmax1, Rmax2), MAX(Rmax_LT1, Rmax_LT2) ] = 0.943 < 1.000 --->
O.K.

Modeling, Integrated Design & Analysis Software Print Date/Time : 09/20/2016 09:08
http://www.MidasUser.com
MIDAS/Civil V 8.5.5 - 88 / 94 -
MIDAS/Civil Steel Code Checking Result

PROJECT TITLE : Design of Shutter Box Culvert

Company HDEC Client Reclamation at Tuas Finger One


Author RJT File Name Shutter Box_option 2_sept5.acs

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MIDAS/Civil - Steel Code Checking[ Eurocode3-2:05 ] Version 8.5.5
==========================================================================================

*. PROJECT :
*. MEMBER NO = 1013, ELEMENT TYPE = Beam
*. LOADCOMB NO = 1, MATERIAL NO = 1, SECTION NO = 15
*. UNIT SYSTEM : N, mm

*. SECTION PROPERTIES : Designation = H 100x100x5/7


Shape = H - Section. (Built-up)
Depth = 100.000, Top F Width = 100.000, Bot.F Width = 100.000
Web Thick = 5.000, Top F Thick = 7.000, Bot.F Thick = 7.000

Area = 1.91584e+003, Avy = 1.40000e+003, Avz = 5.16000e+002


Ybar = 5.00000e+001, Zbar = 5.00000e+001, Qyb = 7.43450e+003, Qzb = 1.25000e+003
Wely = 6.88169e+004, Welz = 2.33958e+004, Wply = 7.43450e+004, Wplz = 3.55375e+004
Iyy = 3.44085e+006, Izz = 1.16979e+006, Iyz = 0.00000e+000
iy = 4.23792e+001, iz = 2.47101e+001
J = 2.67417e+004, Cwp = 2.52263e+009

*. DESIGN PARAMETERS FOR STRENGTH EVALUATION :


Ly = 7.30000e+002, Lz = 7.30000e+002, Lb = 7.30000e+002
Ky = 1.00000e+000, Kz = 1.00000e+000

*. MATERIAL PROPERTIES :
Fy = 2.35000e+002, Es = 2.10000e+005, MATERIAL NAME = S235

*. FORCES AND MOMENTS AT (I) POINT :


Axial Force Fxx =-1.63682e+005
Shear Forces Fyy = 3.71593e+003, Fzz = 6.46738e+003
Bending Moments My = 3.99390e+006, Mz = 1.87746e+006
End Moments Myi = 3.99390e+006, Myj =-7.80339e+005 (for Lb)
Myi = 3.99390e+006, Myj =-7.80339e+005 (for Ly)
Mzi = 1.87746e+006, Mzj =-8.35171e+005 (for Lz)

*. Sign conventions for stress and axial force.


- Stress : Compression positive.
- Axial force: Tension positive.

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CLASSIFY LEFT-TOP FLANGE OF SECTION (BTR).
======================================================================================

( ). Determine classification of compression outstand flanges.


[ Eurocode3:05 Table 5.2 (Sheet 2 of 3), EN 1993-1-5 ]
-. e = SQRT( 235/fy ) = 1.00
-. b/t = BTR = 5.36
-. sigma1 = 125.950 MPa.
-. sigma2 = 86.327 MPa.
-. BTR < 9*e ( Class 1 : Plastic ).

Modeling, Integrated Design & Analysis Software Print Date/Time : 09/20/2016 09:08
http://www.MidasUser.com
MIDAS/Civil V 8.5.5 - 89 / 94 -
MIDAS/Civil Steel Code Checking Result

PROJECT TITLE : Design of Shutter Box Culvert

Company HDEC Client Reclamation at Tuas Finger One


Author RJT File Name Shutter Box_option 2_sept5.acs

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MIDAS/Civil - Steel Code Checking[ Eurocode3-2:05 ] Version 8.5.5
==========================================================================================

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CLASSIFY RIGHT-TOP FLANGE OF SECTION (BTR).
======================================================================================

( ). Determine classification of compression outstand flanges.


[ Eurocode3:05 Table 5.2 (Sheet 2 of 3), EN 1993-1-5 ]
-. e = SQRT( 235/fy ) = 1.00
-. b/t = BTR = 5.36
-. sigma1 = 191.988 MPa.
-. sigma2 = 152.365 MPa.
-. BTR < 9*e ( Class 1 : Plastic ).

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CLASSIFY LEFT-BOTTOM FLANGE OF SECTION (BTR).
======================================================================================

( ). Determine classification of tension outstand flanges.


-. Not Checking the Section Classification.

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CLASSIFY RIGHT-BOTTOM FLANGE OF SECTION (BTR).
======================================================================================

( ). Determine classification of compression outstand flanges.


[ Eurocode3:05 Table 5.2 (Sheet 2 of 3), EN 1993-1-5 ]
-. e = SQRT( 235/fy ) = 1.00
-. b/t = BTR = 5.36
-. sigma1 = 84.546 MPa.
-. sigma2 = 44.923 MPa.
-. BTR < 9*e ( Class 1 : Plastic ).

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CLASSIFY WEB OF SECTION (HTR).
======================================================================================

( ). Determine classification of compression Internal Parts.


[ Eurocode3:05 Table 5.2 (Sheet 1 of 3), EN 1993-1-5 ]
-. e = SQRT( 235/fy ) = 1.00
-. d/t = HTR = 13.20
-. sigma1 = 120.892 MPa.
-. sigma2 = 49.980 MPa.
-. HTR < 33*e ( Class 1 : Plastic ).

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] APPLIED FACTORS.
======================================================================================

( ). Calculate equivalent uniform moment factors (Cmy,Cmz,CmLT).


[ Eurocode3:05 Annex A. Table A.1, A.2 ]
-. Cmy,0 = 0.747
-. Cmz,0 = 0.687

Modeling, Integrated Design & Analysis Software Print Date/Time : 09/20/2016 09:08
http://www.MidasUser.com
MIDAS/Civil V 8.5.5 - 90 / 94 -
MIDAS/Civil Steel Code Checking Result

PROJECT TITLE : Design of Shutter Box Culvert

Company HDEC Client Reclamation at Tuas Finger One


Author RJT File Name Shutter Box_option 2_sept5.acs

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MIDAS/Civil - Steel Code Checking[ Eurocode3-2:05 ] Version 8.5.5
==========================================================================================

-. Cmy (Default or User Defined Value) = 1.000


-. Cmz (Default or User Defined Value) = 1.000
-. CmLT (Default or User Defined Value) = 1.000

( ). Partial Factors (Gamma_Mi).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1 ]
-. Gamma_M0 = 1.00
-. Gamma_M1 = 1.10
-. Gamma_M2 = 1.25

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CHECK AXIAL RESISTANCE.
======================================================================================

( ). Check slenderness ratio of axial compression member (Kl/i).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.3.1 ]
-. Kl/i = 29.5 < 200.0 ---> O.K.

( ). Calculate axial compressive resistance (Nc_Rd).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1, 6.2.4 ]
-. Nc_Rd = fy * Area / Gamma_M0 = 450222.57 N.

( ). Check ratio of axial resistance (N_Ed/Nc_Rd).


N_Ed 163682.32
-. ----- = --------------- = 0.364 < 1.000 ---> O.K.
Nc_Rd 450222.57

( ). Calculate buckling resistance of compression member (Nb_Rdy, Nb_Rdz).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.3.1.1, 6.3.1.2 ]
-. Beta_A = Aeff / Area = 1.000
-. Lambda1 = Pi * SQRT(Es/fy) = 93.913
-. Lambda_by = {(Ky*Ly/iy)/Lambda1} * SQRT(Beta_A) = 0.183
-. Ncry = Pi^2*Es*Iyy / (Ky*Ly)^2 = 13382545.85 N.
-. Lambda_by < 0.2 or N_Ed/Ncry < 0.04 --> No need to check.

-. Lambda_bz = {(Kz*Lz/iz)/Lambda1} * SQRT(Beta_A) = 0.315


-. Ncrz = Pi^2*Es*Izz / (Kz*Lz)^2 = 4549675.56 N.
-. Lambda_bz < 0.2 or N_Ed/Ncrz < 0.04 --> No need to check.

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CHECK SHEAR RESISTANCE.
======================================================================================

( ). Calculate shear area.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.2.6, EN1993-1-5:04 5.1 NOTE 2 ]
-. eta = 1.2 (Fy < 460 MPa.)
-. Avy = 2*B*tf = 1400.0000 mm^2.
-. Avz = eta*hw*tw = 516.0000 mm^2.

( ). Calculate plastic shear resistance in local-y direction (Vpl_Rdy).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1, 6.2.6 ]
-. Vpl_Rdy = [ Avy*fy/SQRT(3) ] / Gamma_M0 = 189948.24 N.

Modeling, Integrated Design & Analysis Software Print Date/Time : 09/20/2016 09:08
http://www.MidasUser.com
MIDAS/Civil V 8.5.5 - 91 / 94 -
MIDAS/Civil Steel Code Checking Result

PROJECT TITLE : Design of Shutter Box Culvert

Company HDEC Client Reclamation at Tuas Finger One


Author RJT File Name Shutter Box_option 2_sept5.acs

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MIDAS/Civil - Steel Code Checking[ Eurocode3-2:05 ] Version 8.5.5
==========================================================================================

( ). Check ratio of shear resistance (V_Edy/Vpl_Rdy).


( LCB = 1, POS = I )
-. Applied shear force : V_Edy = 3715.93 N.
V_Edy 3715.93
-. ------- = --------------- = 0.020 < 1.000 ---> O.K.
Vpl_Rdy 189948.24

( ). Calculate plastic shear resistance in local-z direction (Vpl_Rdz).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1, 6.2.6 ]
-. Vpl_Rdz = [ Avz*fy/SQRT(3) ] / Gamma_M0 = 70009.49 N.

( ). Shear Buckling Check.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.2.6 ]
-. HTR < 72*e/Eta ---> No need to check!

( ). Check ratio of shear resistance (V_Edz/Vpl_Rdz).


( LCB = 1, POS = J )
-. Applied shear force : V_Edz = 6612.72 N.
V_Edz 6612.72
-. ------- = --------------- = 0.094 < 1.000 ---> O.K.
Vpl_Rdz 70009.49

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CHECK BENDING MOMENT RESISTANCE ABOUT MAJOR AXIS.
======================================================================================

( ). Calculate plastic resistance moment about major axis.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1, 6.2.5 ]
-. Wply = 74345.0000 mm^3.
-. Mc_Rdy = Wply * fy / Gamma_M0 = 17471075.00 N-mm.

( ). Check ratio of moment resistance (M_Edy/Mc_Rdy).


M_Edy 3993895.21
-. ------ = --------------- = 0.229 < 1.000 ---> O.K.
Mc_Rdy 17471075.00

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CHECK BENDING MOMENT RESISTANCE ABOUT MINOR AXIS.
======================================================================================

( ). Calculate plastic resistance moment about minor axis.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1, 6.2.5 ]
-. Wplz = 35537.5000 mm^3.
-. Mc_Rdz = Wplz * fy / Gamma_M0 = 8351312.50 N-mm.

( ). Check ratio of moment resistance (M_Edz/Mc_Rdz).


M_Edz 1877458.33
-. ------ = --------------- = 0.225 < 1.000 ---> O.K.
Mc_Rdz 8351312.50

Modeling, Integrated Design & Analysis Software Print Date/Time : 09/20/2016 09:08
http://www.MidasUser.com
MIDAS/Civil V 8.5.5 - 92 / 94 -
MIDAS/Civil Steel Code Checking Result

PROJECT TITLE : Design of Shutter Box Culvert

Company HDEC Client Reclamation at Tuas Finger One


Author RJT File Name Shutter Box_option 2_sept5.acs

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MIDAS/Civil - Steel Code Checking[ Eurocode3-2:05 ] Version 8.5.5
==========================================================================================

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CHECK LATERAL-TORSIONAL BUCKLING RESISTANCE.
======================================================================================

( ). Calculate lateral-torsional buckling resistance (Mb_Rd).


[ Eurocode3:05 6.1, 6.3.2 ]
-. Por = 0.300
-. Gs = Es / [ 2*(1+Por) ] = 80769.231 MPa.
-. Ncr = Pi^2*Es*Izz / Lu^2 = 4549675.56 N.
-. psi = -0.195
-. C1 = 1.285
-. Mcr = C1 * Ncr * SQRT [ (Cwp/Izz) + (Gs*Ixx)/Ncr ] = 299890034.05 N-mm.

-. Lambda_LT_bar = SQRT [ Wply*fy / Mcr ] = 0.241


-. Lambda_LT_bar0 = 0.200

-. Lambda_LT_bar = 0.241 > Lambda_LT_bar0 = 0.200


-. M_Ed/Mcr = 0.013 < Lambda_LT_bar0^2 = 0.040
If Lambda_LT_bar < Lambda_LT_bar0 or M_Ed/Mcr < Lambda_LT_bar0^2,
No allowance for lateral-torsional buckling necessary.

======================================================================================
[[[*]]] CHECK INTERACTION OF COMBINED RESISTANCE.
======================================================================================

( ). Calculate Major reduced design resistance of bending and shear.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.2.8 (6.30) ]
-. In case of V_Edz / Vpl_Rdz < 0.5
-. My_Rd = Mc_Rdy = 17471075.00 N-mm.

( ). Calculate Minor reduced design resistance of bending and shear.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.2.8 (6.30) ]
-. In case of V_Edy / Vpl_Rdy < 0.5
-. Mz_Rd = Mc_Rdz = 8351312.50 N-mm.

( ). Check general interaction ratio.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.2.1 (6.2) ] - Class1 or Class2
N_Ed M_Edy M_Edz
-. Rmax1 = ------ + ------- + -------
N_Rd My_Rd Mz_Rd
= 0.817 < 1.000 ---> O.K.

( ). Check interaction ratio of bending and axial force member.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.2.9 (6.31 ~ 6.41) ] - Class1 or Class2
-. n = N_Ed / Npl_Rd = 0.364
-. a = MIN[ (Area-2b*tf)/Area, 0.5 ] = 0.269
-. Alpha = 2.000
-. Beta = MAX[ 5*n, 1.0 ] = 1.818

Modeling, Integrated Design & Analysis Software Print Date/Time : 09/20/2016 09:08
http://www.MidasUser.com
MIDAS/Civil V 8.5.5 - 93 / 94 -
MIDAS/Civil Steel Code Checking Result

PROJECT TITLE : Design of Shutter Box Culvert

Company HDEC Client Reclamation at Tuas Finger One


Author RJT File Name Shutter Box_option 2_sept5.acs

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MIDAS/Civil - Steel Code Checking[ Eurocode3-2:05 ] Version 8.5.5
==========================================================================================

-. N_Ed > 0.25*Npl_Rd = 112555.64 N.


-. N_Ed > 0.5*hw*tw*fy/Gamma_M0 = 50525.00 N.
Therefore, Allowance for the effect of axial force.
-. Mny_Rd = MIN[ Mply_Rd*(1-n)/(1-0.5*a), Mply_Rd ] = 12849130.66 N-mm.
-. Rmaxy = M_Edy / Mny_Rd = 0.311 < 1.000 ---> O.K.

-. N_Ed > hw*tw*fy/Gamma_M0 = 141470.00 N.


Therefore, Allowance for the effect of axial force.

-. In case of n > a
-. Mnz_Rd = Mplz_Rd * [ 1 - ((n-a)/(1-a))^2 ] = 8212215.53 N-mm.
-. Rmaxz = M_Edz / Mnz_Rd = 0.229 < 1.000 ---> O.K.

[ | M_Edy |^(Alpha) | M_Edz |^(Beta) ]


-. Rmax2 = [ |--------| + |--------| ]
[ | Mny_Rd | | Mnz_Rd | ]
= 0.165 < 1.000 ---> O.K.

( ). Check interaction ratio of bending and axial compression member.


[ Eurocode3:05 6.3.1, 6.2.9.3 (6.61, 6.62), Annex A ]
-. N_Ed = -163682.32 N.
-. M_Edy = 3993895.21 N-mm.
-. M_Edz = 1877458.33 N-mm.
-. kyy = 0.969
-. kyz = 0.545
-. kzy = 0.509
-. kzz = 1.248
-. Xiy = 1.000
-. Xiz = 1.000
-. XiLT = 1.000
-. N_Rk = A*fy = 450222.57 N.
-. My_Rk = Wply*fy = 17471075.00 N-mm.
-. Mz_Rk = Wplz*fy = 8351312.50 N-mm.
-. N_Ed*eNy = 0.0 (Not Slender)
-. N_Ed*eNZ = 0.0 (Not Slender)
N_Ed M_Edy + N_Ed*eNy M_Edz + N_Ed*eNz
-. Rmax_LT1 = ----------------- + kyy * ------------------- + kyz * ----------------
Xiy*N_Rk/Gamma_M1 XiLT*My_Rk/Gamma_M1 Mz_Rk/Gamma_M1
= 0.778 < 1.000 ---> O.K.
N_Ed M_Edy + N_Ed*eNy M_Edz + N_Ed*eNz
-. Rmax_LT2 = ----------------- + kzy * ------------------- + kzz * ----------------
Xiz*N_Rk/Gamma_M1 XiLT*My_Rk/Gamma_M1 Mz_Rk/Gamma_M1
= 0.836 < 1.000 ---> O.K.

-. Rmax = MAX[ MAX(Rmax1, Rmax2), MAX(Rmax_LT1, Rmax_LT2) ] = 0.836 < 1.000 --->
O.K.

Modeling, Integrated Design & Analysis Software Print Date/Time : 09/20/2016 09:08
http://www.MidasUser.com
MIDAS/Civil V 8.5.5 - 94 / 94 -

You might also like