Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ABSTRACT
Locomotor training on a treadmill is a therapeutic strategy used for several years in human para-
plegics in whom it was shown to improve functional recovery mainly after incomplete spinal cord
lesions. The precise mechanisms underlying its effects are not known. Experimental studies in adult
animals were chiefly performed after complete spinal transections. The objective of this experiment
was to assess the effects of early treadmill training on recovery of spontaneous walking capacity af-
ter a partial spinal cord lesion in adult rats. Following a compression-injury by a subdurally in-
flated microballoon, seven rats were trained daily on a treadmill with a body weight support sys-
tem, whereas six other animals were used as controls and only handled. Spontaneous walking ability
in an open field was compared weekly between both groups by two blinded observers, using the
Basso, Beattie and Bresnahan (BBB) locomotor rating scale. Mean BBB score during 12 weeks was
globally significantly greater in the treadmill-trained animals than in the control group, the bene-
fit of training appearing as early as the 2nd week. At week 7, locomotor recovery reached a plateau
in both animal groups, but remained superior in trained rats. Daily treadmill training started early
after a partial spinal cord lesion in adult rats, which accelerates recovery of locomotion and pro-
duces a long-term benefit. These findings in an animal model mimicking the closed spinal cord in-
jury occurring in most human paraplegics are useful for future studies of optimal locomotor train-
ing programs, their neurobiologic mechanisms, and their combination with other treatment
strategies.
Key words: BBB locomotor rating scale; locomotor recovery; spinal cord injury; treadmill training
Research Center for Cellular and Molecular Neurobiology, Neuroanatomy Laboratory, University of Liege, Liege, Belgium.
*These authors contributed equally to this work.
699
MULTON ET AL.
cord transection (Barbeau and Rossignol, 1987; de Leon vidually in a colony room under a normal 12:12 h
et al., 1998a; Edgerton et al., 1997; Lovely et al., 1986), light/dark cycle and temperature control at 22 6 2C with
which has supported the presence in the lower spinal cord food and water provided ad libitum. All experiments con-
of a central pattern generator (CPG) able to generate formed to the rules and regulations of the Belgian Na-
rhythmic motor activities in the absence of supraspinal tional Funds for Scientific Research concerning the use
descending inputs (Grillner, 1985; Grillner and Wallen, and care of laboratory animals and were approved by the
1985). How the CPG can shape its functional properties local ethics committee.
in response to the training is not clear, but it is thought
that reinforcement by sensory afferents of existing sen- Surgical Procedure
sorimotor pathways, rather than generation of new con-
nections, might be responsible for the beneficial effects Animals were anaesthetized by intraperitoneal (i.p.) in-
(de Leon et al., 1998a, 1999, 2001). jection of xylazine (10 mg/kg) and ketamine (75 mg/kg).
Clinical studies in human paraplegics indicate, how- The depth of anesthesia was adjusted for absence of
ever, that the efficiency of treadmill training depends corneal reflex. The back of the rat was shaved and dis-
largely on the severity of the lesion. Patients with com- infected. The eyes were protected from drying with arti-
plete spinal cord lesions never improve up to the stage ficial tears. The dorsal surface of the spinal cord was ex-
of being able to walk without the assistance of the weight- posed by a laminectomy at the T9 thoracic level. An
support system and consequently are not able to step on inflatable microballoon (model GV15; CathNet Science,
a static floor (Van de Crommert et al., 1998). The in- Paris, France) mounted on a catheter was introduced into
ability of patients with complete transections to achieve the subarachnoid space through a small hole in the dura
unassisted walking, unlike the fully spinalized cat, sug- mater and moved rostrally for two metameric levels. The
gests that the greater improvement observed in subjects balloon was rapidly inflated with 20 mL of sterile water
with incomplete lesions may not solely be attributable to and left in place for 5 min, after which it was deflated
spinal mechanisms, since generation of stepping is prob- and removed. We have shown previously that this vol-
ably more dependent on supraspinal and/or propriocep- ume-duration combination produces a necrotic lesion of
tive inputs in humans than in cat (Edgerton et al., 2001; the dorsal half of the spinal cord, including the corti-
Van de Crommert et al., 1998). Considering these clini- cospinal tracts and a partially reversible paraplegia (Mar-
cal and functional data and knowing that the ratio of in- tin et al., 1992). The surgical wound was closed in two
complete versus complete spinal cord lesions is becom- layers, and animals were allowed to awake in large cages.
ing increasing known in the population of paraplegics Their bladder was expressed once a day until spontaneous
(Tator et al., 1993), experimental studies using animals micturition was recovered. All rats received daily i.p. in-
with incomplete spinal cord injuries appear clinically and jection of antibiotics (2.7 mg/kg, Augmentin ; Smith
pathophysiologically relevant. However, such studies are Kline Beecham) during 15 days to prevent urinary tract
scarce and have provided contradictory results. Fouad et infection.
al. (2000) found no beneficial effect on free locomotor
activity after a very partial lesion of the cord, whereas Treadmill Training
Thota et al. (2001) reported on the opposite improved Three days before the spinal cord compression-injury
functional recovery after treadmill training in rats with was performed, all rats were handled and trained daily to
partial spinal cord lesions, although motor activity was walk on a customized treadmill. After the injury, seven
assessed on a treadmill, and not in an open field. The pur- rats were trained daily on a treadmill and seven others,
pose of this study was to use a previously developed used as controls, were taken out of their cages and only
model of a partial closed injury of the spinal cord in adult handled daily. Both procedures were started as soon as
rat (Martin et al., 1992) and to assess in this model the the animals reached a score of 1 on the BBB scale. The
effects on recovery of free walking capacity of daily lo- time to reach this score ranged from 2 to 4 days post-in-
comotor training on a treadmill performed as in human jury. Allocation to the treadmill-trained or untrained
studies with body weight support. group was made in a balanced way such as to obtain com-
parable post-injury delays to score 1 in both groups.
Taking into account published data (Edgerton et al.,
MATERIALS AND METHODS 1983; Fouad et al., 2000) as well as feasibility, the fol-
lowing treadmill training protocol was chosen: speed of
Animals 5.8 cm/sec; 30 min/day (three sessions of 10 min sepa-
The study was performed on a total of 13 adult female rated by 5-min pauses); 5 days/week for 12 weeks. For
Wistar rats (200250 g). The animals were housed indi- the training session, animals were placed in an adjusted
700
TREADMILL TRAINING EFFECT ON MOTOR RECOVERY
701
MULTON ET AL.
FIG. 1. Mean weekly BBB scores over the 12-week observation period in control non-trained and treadmill-trained rats after
a partial compression-injury of thoracic spinal cord at T67. *p , 0.05.
this spared tissue to the total area of white matter in a covery in human paraplegics (Dietz et al., 1994, 1995;
corresponding segment of normal spinal cord, percent- Dobkin et al., 1995; Wernig and Mller, 1992; Wernig
age areas of spared white matter were on average com- et al., 1995) and in experimental studies in cats (Barbeau
parable between treadmill-trained (12.17 6 2.20%) and and Rossignol, 1987; de Leon et al., 1998a; Lovely et al.,
untrained animals (11.42 6 3.08%; Fig. 3). 1986).
However, our study differs from previous ones on the
effects of treadmill training in experimental paraplegia
DISCUSSION by the type and severity of the spinal cord injury (SCI)
and the motor activities that were assessed. SCIs in the
Our data suggest that treadmill training initiated early cat model consist in total transection of the cord. The
after an incomplete closed spinal cord compression-in- spinal cord being isolated from the brain, the improve-
jury can improve locomotor recovery in adult rats. Com- ment in functional recovery has been interpreted on the
pared to non-trained animals, the benefit appears as soon basis of training-induced biochemical and structural
as the second week of training and is maximal at 4 weeks. changes in the lumbar central pattern generator (CPG; de
Between weeks 7 and 12 post-injury, motor performance Leon et al., 2001; Rossignol, 2000). By contrast, with the
as assessed by the BBB rating scale reaches a plateau, compression protocol used in our model, the lesion de-
during which the difference between the two animal stroys mainly the gray matter and dorsal tracts (Martin
groups remains stable. At the end of the 12-week obser- et al., 1992), which are involved in the fine control of
vation period, the gain in mean BBB score in treadmill- movements (Fouad et al., 2000; Metz et al., 1998), par-
trained rats, although consisting of only two points, is tially sparing the ventral and ventro-lateral tracts, which
functionally significant, as it indicates that they are able are more implied in the initiation of walking and coor-
to support their body weight, while non-trained rats are dination between fore- and hindlimbs (Brustein and
not. It is unlikely that the difference in motor outcome Rossignol, 1998; Gorska et al., 1996; Jordan, 1998). As
between untrained and treadmill-trained animals is due a first probable consequence of the incompleteness of the
to a less severe spinal cord injury in the latter. There was spinal lesions performed in our study, non-trained con-
indeed no difference in the amount of spared ventral trol animals were able to recover spontaneous locomotor
white matter between the two groups. Also, after the com- activity. Such partial restoration of voluntary stepping has
pression-lesion, treadmill-trained rats reached a BBB also been observed after incomplete lesions in cat
score of 1 slightly, though not significantly, later (mean: (Brustein and Rossignol, 1998; Rossignol et al, 1999).
3.5 days) than untrained animals (mean: 3 days). The rapid motor recovery over weeks might be attributed
The results presented here are in accordance with data to the partial sparing of descending pathways, sufficient
on beneficial effects of treadmill training on stepping re- to provide the necessary drive for the initiation of loco-
702
TREADMILL TRAINING EFFECT ON MOTOR RECOVERY
A B
C D
FIG. 2. Toluidine bluestained (A,B) and corresponding camera lucida drawings (C,D) of transverse semi-thin (1 mm) sections
at the epicenter of the lesion from a treadmill-trained (A,C) and an untrained control animal (B,D). Dark-shaded areas represent
spared white matter and are similar in both animals.
motion as well as some postural control. To reinforce this for instance, that hindlimb motor training (de Leon et al.,
hypothesis, in our model of spinal compression-injury 1999) is able to attenuate the increase of inhibitory trans-
with a subdural balloon, more severe lesions produced mitters that occurs in the caudal spinal cord after a
by inflating the balloon with 40 mL for 5 min were never complete injury (Robinson and Goldberger, 1986;
followed by any recovery of spontaneous walking move- Tillakaratne et al, 2000). Most studies which have ex-
ments in an open field (Martin et al., 1992 and unpub- amined this, came to the conclusion that the contribution
lished data). Another important consequence of an in- of muscle trophicity or reflex activity in the beneficial
complete spinal lesion is that it leaves open the possibility effects of locomotor training was negligible (de Leon et
that the significant improvement of locomotor recovery al., 2001; Edgerton et al., 2001; Van de Crommert et al.,
by treadmill training might not be solely due to plastic 1998).
changes in the caudal segment containing the CPG, but Another difference between previous studies and
also to the progressive reinforcement of partially spared ours pertains to the method used to evaluate motor re-
descending connections through sprouting and/or synap- covery. In cats, locomotor recovery is assessed by ex-
tic plasticity. In spinalized vertebrates, motor recovery amining induced stepping on a treadmill, as adult ani-
after such a training can indeed only be explained by mals have no spontaneous walking activity after
changes of caudal spinal networks. It has been shown, spinalization (Edgerton et al., 1983). In fact, in spinal-
703
MULTON ET AL.
704
TREADMILL TRAINING EFFECT ON MOTOR RECOVERY
705
MULTON ET AL.
of locomotor function after treadmill training of incomplete WERNIG, A., MLLER, S., NANASSY, A., et al. (1995).
spinal cord injured rats. Biomed. Sci. Instrum. 37, 6367. Laufband therapy based on rules of spinal locomotion is ef-
fective in spinal cord injured persons. Eur. J. Neurosci. 7,
TILLAKARATNE, N.J., MOURIA, M., ZIV, N.B., et al.
823829.
(2000). Increased expression of glutamate decarboxylase
(GAD(67)) in feline lumbar spinal cord after complete tho- Address reprint requests to:
racic spinal cord transection. J. Neurosci. Res. 60,
Jean Schoenen, M.D., Ph.D.
219230.
Research Center for Cellular and
VAN DE CROMMERT, H., MULDER, T., and DUYSENS, J. Molecular Neurobiology
(1998). Neural control of locomotion: sensory control of the Neuroanatomy Laboratory
central pattern generator and its relation to treadmill train- University of Liege
ing. Gait Posture 7, 251263. Rue de Pitteurs, 20 (L3)
WERNIG, A., and MLLER, S. (1992). Laufband locomotion 4020 Liege, Belgium
with body weight support improved walking in persons with
severe spinal cord injuries. Paraplegia 30, 229238. E-mail: jschoenen@ulg.ac.be
706