Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ABSTRACT
Several goodness of. fit (GOP) criteria have been
developed to assist the researcher in interpreting structural
equation models. However, the determination of GOF for structural
equation models is not as straightforward as that for other
statistical approaches in multivariate procedures. The four GOF
criteria used across the commonly used statistical packages are: (1)
chi square; (2) GOF; (3) adjusted GOF; and (4) root mean square
residual. Two other approaches are the Tucker-Lewis Index (1973) and
the Wormed Fit Index (1980). Other measures that provide model
comparisons are the formed chi-square, the parsimonious fit index,
and the Akaike Information criterion. A new measure of model fit, the
maximum internal correlation coefficient, is propose as a GOF
criterion in structural equation models. This approach offers another
test of model fit. Model testing is suggested for effectiveness and
functionality of the specified variable relationships. Two tables
summarize GOF criteria, and there is a 32-item list of references.
(SLD)
***********************************************************************
* Reproductions supplied by EDRS are the best that can be made *
Izs
INTRODUCTION
3
2
GOODNESS-OF-FIT CRITERIA
program).
most GOF criteria range in value from 0 (no fit) to 1 (perfect fit)
MODEL FIT
6
5
Chi-square (0)
The 24:2 test being non-significant indicates that the model fits the
statistic is: X.2 = (n-1) Fa; GLS X2 statistic is: X2 = (n-1) Fig's ;
F", = .5 tr
S ( I )2 ;
df = .5 (p+q) (p+q+1) - t
ULS estimates (Bollen, 1989, 276-277). The GFI index for ULS
estimates would be computed as:
7
tr 1(5 E)2))
GFI = 1 -
tr (S2)
The AGFI adjusts the GFI index for the degrees of freed= of a
model relative to the number of variables. The AGFI index is
computed as:
Where:
The RMR index uses the square root of the mean squared
differences between matrix elements in S and E. It is used to
compare the fit of two different models with the same data. The
)2 1/ 2
RMR = I (1/k) Z ( s" -
MODEL COMPARISON
9
Tucker-Lewis Index (TLI) and Normed Fit Lndex (NFI) (Bentler &
Bonett, 1980, 1982; Loehlin, 1987, 68). These GOF criteria
typically compare a proposed model to a null model. In the EQS
program, the null model is indicated by the Independence Model Chi-
square value. The null model could also be any model that
establishes a base for expecting other models to exceed.
(X2null df dfnuu) 1
(X2ntir11 x2 pre/pos*4)
NFI =
10
9
MODEL PARSIMONY
Parsimony refers to the number of estimated coefficients
required to achieve a specific level of fit. Basically, an "over
not fit the observed data and need improvement. The NC measure,
X2
X2 =
df
Muliak, & Brett, 1982). The PFI however takes into account the
11
10
,X2
AIC =
2
Muliak et al. (1989) evaluated the X2, NFIr GFIr AGFI, and AIC
2
11
RNFIl
Where:
F = X2 of full model
RP, = - / d - j
Where:
d, = degrees of freedom for structural equation model
13
12
as:
p (s) = ) / + )
14
13
Where:
p (*) = ( X ( + 24.1
Where:
SUMMARY
15
14
GOF criteria because the variables may not be on the same scale of
the sample data. What then is the solution to this dilemna? The
(test) the effect upon other variables in the model. Model testing
16
15
REFERENCES
17
16
11, 325-344.
Joe, G.W. and J.L. Mendoza (1989a). The internal correlation: Its
16
17
1,9
18
Williams, J.D. and R.J. Klimpel (1974). Path analysis and causal
models as regression techniques. Multiple Linear Rearessionj
Viewpoints, 5(3), 1-20.
20
19
Scientific
Software/ LISREL 7 Chi-square
Goodness-of-Fit Index
Adjusted Goodness-of-Fit Index
Root Mean Square Residual